15 ms·
How to learn chess as an adult (2021)
- isyuricunha 3y agooh, nice!
- locallost 3y agoOn a side note, it's a good demonstration that knowledge beats intelligence. Being smart just gives you a higher ceiling, but most people can get pretty good at almost anything if they work hard enough. The question is of course why would you do it, and do you have the motivation.
- ckuehne 3y agoThis conclusion does not follow from the article.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eviks 3y agoMost people are intelligent, that's why they can get good, but being smart not only has a big effect on the ceiling, but also on the speed to get to the same level, which in turn affects motivation, so you can't judge it to be an inferior factor But this isn't a good illustration anyway since it's a very constrained artificial example of a game based on pattern matching
- locallost 3y agoI see examples of that pretty much everywhere. People that regularly do and practice something get to be better than the vast majority of people, so talent and intelligence end up playing a lesser role. This is true for physical skills and also mental. The author said he ended up in the 95th percentile -- I doubt this is achievable for all people, but "high" yes (whatever the interpretation of high is).
- petercooper 3y agoFor most cases, I agree. I think almost anyone with the time and determination can get to 95th percentile or up in a non-physical pursuit. Intelligence becomes a key determinant if you want to break the top 0.1%. Most people of average intelligence could become a top 5% programmer if they wanted to, but getting 2 minute solutions on Advent of Code? Almost certainly not. (I pick AOC because I've been looking into the folks who hit the leaderboards and they all seem to give off high IQ vibes so far.)
- gwnywg 3y agoWhen I was a kid I heard proffessional player opinion that people who play more games get better results, he stated chess is game of numbers. I'm probably not on that level as no matter how many games I played there is rating level I cannot beat, it's glass ceiling for me.
- IdPreferNotTo 3y ago[flagged]
- gnicholas 3y agoInteresting to see a shoutout to Gwern for his writeup on spaced repetition.
- kqr 3y agoI'm curious: which part of that is interesting? Aside from Piotr Wozniak's writing, Gwern is the common coordination point for these techniques.
- gnicholas 3y agoOh, just interesting to see a reference to Gwern, whom I'm only familiar with through postings on HN, in a blog post that's on HN.
- tasuki 3y agoThis is also on HN. Same bubble, not much of a coincidence?
- gnicholas 3y agoI wouldn't have been surprised to see him referenced in a comment. I was surprised to see it in a blog post that ended up here, where the blogger didn't reference HN in any way — it was all about chess (which is not one of the more common things discussed on HN).
- cwillu 3y ago(2021)
- glouwbug 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rtpg 3y agoand here I was happy to get up to 1000 in Chess.com after 2 years (only to then just hover around forever). Knowledge is power etc etc but at one point nothing replaces studying. I've found that anything under 15 minute clocks just feels like brain poison to me, though. Your brain goes completely into pattern matching mode and lose out on the actual interesting tactical analysis you can do when you're taking a bit more time. I have been queueing up daily games instead and it's nice. Games take a month to resolve but if you just continuously add to the queue that's good. EDIT: > I learned a bunch of openings with White for 6 months or so, also via Chessable. Amazingly I won more games with Black, where I had learned nothing, than with White. I got frustrated with this, and switched my openings entirely. It had literally no impact on my rating, and I continued to improve. I felt this so much recently. I got kind of obsessed with the Evans gambit, and would still lose to people who would play into the gambit and let me go down the lines I knew well. I'd just flummox later on. The game below a certain point is really just "don't blunder as much as the opponent"
- thomasz 3y agoHave you tried mixing up games with daily moves with rapid and blitz? Mixing “do it right” with “do it fast” training is more effective than doing only one of both.
- rtpg 3y agoOne thing a friend of mine mentioned about studying, is that you can get in a weird cycle where you end up reinforcing answering incorrectly to a thing over and over. I think that blitz reinforces my bad habits of approximate pattern matching and ultimately makes me play worse in my other games. If I want to "do it fast" I can just open my dailies and play them fast! But this is a me problem, I routinely play board games etc too quickly, and lose because of it. I do not need help with "do it fast".
- ycombinete 3y agoSounds good to me! Ratings are a treadmill. As you get better so do your opponents. You'll always have a ~50% winrate. I'd rather have a stable rating over time, at a level I can maintain comfortably, than have to expend ever increasing levels of energy to maintain a higher level; and probably end up having less fun. (maybe it's more like treading water. You can get more of your body out of the water, but each inch requires exponentially more effort to maintain) That said, I started doing a lot of puzzles a while ago, as well as doing the basic mating pattern practice on Lichess. My rating jumped up a few hundred rating points. Turns out that I was missing a bunch of the basics. Now I hover around average on the server for Blitz (~1500), and slightly above for Rapid (~1700) and that's awesome.
- sandreas 3y agoOne of the best "beginner chess" videos I have ever seen was made by one of the persons, I would have least expected making a good tutorial video, because she is hardly ever too serious in her other videos: Andrea Botez It's only 10 mins, stuffed with good information and explained very beginner friendly: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aavP_NnrXS8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aavP_NnrXS8
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Capablanca's famous adage "I see only one move ahead, but always the best move" turns out to be true I know there is a tendency to frame human intelligence in terms of the age’s breakthrough technology. But man if that isn’t reminiscent of token prediction.
- pella 3y agoMy practice: watching https://www.youtube.com/@agadmator https://www.youtube.com/@agadmator chanel.
- mathematicaster 3y agoYeah, I, too, practice my bball skills watching Curry's highlights ;) Jokes aside, it's a fun channel. Makes me feel like I know what's going on in those games.
- DeathArrow 3y agoIs there a well known strategy game where AI doesn't have better chances to win than a human? Is there possibly, math wise, that such games exist? I kind of dislike not having a chance when playing against bots.
- yreg 3y agoCivilization V? Warcraft 3? But any answer will be such only because no one tried hard enough to make a supreme AI.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- huytersd 3y agoI would say any game that includes a lot of uncertainty, subjectivity and random chance would mean that an AI would not usually have an edge over a human. Maybe games like diplomacy, magic the gathering, pandemic, Gloomhaven, maybe poker (?), backgammon (?) etc. On a sidenote, I think it’s interesting that we’re a point where it’s starting to get hard to come up with games that humans can beat AI at.
- kdwikzncba 3y agoI would like to hear your reasoning as to why you think that a human is especially good at dealing with uncertainty. My experience is the opposite.
- washmyelbows 3y ago"Only about 10% of players ever gain more than 100 points, and only about 1% of players gain more than 200 rating points given years." This seems like a wild claim. On chess.com I've gone from 500 to ~1050 in a handful of months without any real study, just some light YouTube watching. 500->800 felt like all it took was learning a few openings and not blundering pieces. 800-1050 felt like it came mostly from getting familiar with the common patterns from those openings that led to advantages/disadvantages. Most of my learning here came from reviewing my own games and trying to understand why my mistakes were mistakes. I don't understand how people learn from slamming blitz/bullet games. The time constraints are too rushed to really think about what makes a move good or bad. I assumed it was a young person's thing, but the author said he plays these quick formats too.
- kqr 3y agoThe author says specifically blitz/bullet is suboptimal for learning, for precisely the reasons you mention. The author plays these types of games to kill boredom.
- vasco 3y agoI love quick games, 3min blitz being my favorite and I suck at chess. It makes it almost a different game to me. I stopped playing for years because my memory of chess was slow boring waiting. Blitz is just full on, all the time.
- chongli 3y agoIf you follow the link to the data analysis [1] you’ll see that the argument is based on higher rated players. Low rated players have much higher variance in their rating and can improve by quite a lot, just by learning to stop blundering. That’s basically the situation you’re in. Getting to 2000 rating is going to be quite a mountain to climb for you, unless you’re very young. [1] https://github.com/jcw024/lichess_database_ETL/blob/main/README.md https://github.com/jcw024/lichess_database_ETL/blob/main/REA...
- zelphirkalt 3y agoAnd not to forget to avoid disappointment: An online 2000 is maybe an offline 1800 or so. Online ratings are in general higher than what people actually have offline.
- baal80spam 3y ago> Like most people, late last year I watched the Queen's Gambit. That's a... bold statement.
- ta8903 3y agoNot the only bold statement in the article. >But I'm a smart guy (hi white male privilege) It's amusing to see someone go mask off and call non-whites low IQ like that.
- LargeTomato 3y agoI don't think that's what they meant.
- qingdao99 3y agoWhat did they mean? Can't figure it out.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoEducated. Access to good schools.
- dabeeeenster 3y agoWhat has that got to do with being good at chess?
- stavros 3y agoThe concept of privilege is that you have time/energy/resources to do things like play chess instead of looking for work. I'm not sure if you're questioning the concept of privilege (which is fine) or saying that it specifically doesn't have anything to do with chess.
- faeriechangling 3y ago
- alberto_ol 3y agoI briefly scanned the article. I am not that impressed by the result. I thought that an average smart person and particularly someone with a scientific background could reach that resalt in one or two months. My experience. I played chess when I was between 13 and 16, at that time I was a good player but not a child prodigy, let's say one of the best players in my school. I have no idea of my ELO then, there was no internet in the early '80s. I have not played for roughly 40 years. I few years ago I started playing on lichess and my ELO is now around 1700 (with a peak of 1900). I don't know if chess.com and lichess have different ratings.
- zpeti 3y agoLichess ratings are higher generally, although they even out with chess.com the higher you get. 1400 on lichess is more like 1200 on chess.com, but 1900 is probably 1900. Based on your post though, you definitely seem like you are very smart or have a natural affinity for chess. 1900 is extremely high, especially in a few months or even years. Normally people gain around 300 ELO points per year if they are learning and practicing actively.
- V-2 3y ago> 1400 on lichess is more like 1200 on chess.com, but 1900 is probably 1900. Not in my experience. I'm rated 1900+ on lichess and 1600+ on chess.com. That's after playing a significant number of games (nearly 500 on chess.com, thousands on lichess). The way I feel about it, a 1900 player on lichess is an intermediate beginner (like myself), whereas 1900 on chess.com already represents a decent club player level. For reference, "in real life" (Elo rating / FIDE) I'm rated below 1300 in classical chess, and about 1400 in rapid - although I've played only one rapid tournament, and I don't have a blitz rating at all, which makes comparisons a bit tricky. For what it's worth though, as far as I can tell, these proportions are about typical.
- thope 3y agoyes, they use different rating systems (Glicko 1 and 2), see https://lichess.org/page/rating-systems https://lichess.org/page/rating-systems
- lovegrenoble 3y agoNever watched the Queen's Gambit )
- sph 3y agoGreat article. I got into chess recently, and I can only recommend the "Learn chess with Dr. Wolf" app. https://apps.apple.com/us/app/learn-chess-with-dr-wolf/id1353041020 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/learn-chess-with-dr-wolf/id135... It's got a beautiful UI, and it's a conversational chess tutor that goes over the basics, tactics, advanced strategy and with whom you can play and will point out mistakes and blunders for later review. Perhaps it is too basic for anybody that has a few hundred games of chess under their belt but if you know nothing about the game, it is a great way to get into it. As the author say, low level chess is about learning patterns and short-term strategy (what should I do the opening, how to checkmate with a rook, etc.) and this app teaches exactly that, in a gradual way. Not affiliated, just a happy and now paying user.
- 867-5309 3y agohttps://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.chess.chesscoach https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.chess.ches...
- 4lun 3y agoAh this is great, just spent 30 mins playing this on the London underground as it works offline too
- sph 3y agoYeah it's great when you have a few minutes to spare. I do a little lesson and a quick game to practice it in my lunch break.
- mptest 3y agoCan anyone recommend a similar app/site for learning go? That one feels so hard to learn, but it is so fun. the games really feel like a conversation
- IggleSniggle 3y agoGo is so wonderful as a social game. I took its philosophy on "teaching-games" (ie, every game is approached as an opportunity to learn/teach more than as a competition, and handicap structures are built-in to skill difference), and have applied them to chess as I start playing with my 7 yo son. We both really enjoy playing the game at our absolute best when I start the game less one rook, knight, bishop, and two pawns. I'm not a great chess player though. Anyway, more to your question, finding a way to play Go in person is such a game-changer, literally.
- ShoneRL 3y agoA bit of an unhinged, unpopular opinion take: Chess is a very overrated game that's overglorified to the limit and it's an unhealthy addiction for a lot of people and I think modern media needs to stop flaunting Chess as something of a high-horse type of thing. To put simply, I believe Chess is good as something of a brain exercise for when you're younger or if you are a parent and want to develop your child's logical thinking and that's it, no more and no less. So what happens if you take Chess further? People don't know when to stop and I've seen with my eyes this happen because there was this kid at Chess tournaments who was a much better player than I am, however the kid just lived Chess, there was nothing else to the kid, he was socially very unintelligent & awkward, didn't really do much anything else since his parents shoved him to Chess when he was 6 and made it a daily routine thing for him to focus on Chess and his school studies. Gradually, Chess took over his entire identity and he's now a titled player and from people who see him on an everyday basis, they all still don't say much about this now-adult other than that he's still just focused on Chess. The general sentiment of everyone who knows this kid is just pity because it's just a very one-dimensional life. He achieved success but it sacrificed a lot of his childhood, and for what? Chess players, even titled ones don't really make a lot of money from tournaments and if you want to be good at it and play at tournaments, you have to dedicate basically all your time to it and have good discipline to keep at it, day after day. There's the coach hustle but that also requires you to be at least above average and also I haven't met a coach who's not just living Chess so it's about the same, you still get sucked into this lifestyle. Chess at a higher level is pretty draw-ish and ultimately a memorization contest. Most strong players will not slip up if given a slight advantage and they will be able to convert this slight advantage into at least a draw. Strong players already have a good grasp on tactical motifs and can spot opportunities easily but that's where Chess theory comes into play. There's many openings and every opening has variations, which have optimal moves and then of course inaccurate moves and blunders. Just Sicilian theory is enough for someone to spend years of their life memorizing moves and building a repertoire. Ultimately, Chess doesn't get more fun the stronger you get and that's counter-intuitive because people want to get better. I played Chess for a few years both casually and professionally, I won some tropheys and have some medals to show for it. I beat titled players (2300+ rated) but I quit all of it to focus on software engineering because Chess got boring. For me, Chess got to a point where further improvement depended on memorizing opening theory, middlegame theory and endgame theory. Just memorize and nothing more. I refused to do that so I often drawn/lost games in situations where I played less than ideal moves and my opponent knew the theory to punish my very slight inaccuracy. What I liked in Chess was the calculation, so something like Fischer Chess (Chess960) was fun but did you know people actually made theory even for that? So games got more and more boring, in casual games I would purposefully play bad moves to throw my opponent off their theory and to get into unknown territory in terms of tactics. I'd do that just to try to make the game fun again, but obviously I was burned out and there was no coming back from it. In my country I am friends with a lot of Chess people. I saw a lot of things, like titled players throwing games for .. $10-$20. They spent about 20-30 years of their life to get good at Chess and now they have to throw games for money. Do I want to be that guy? How does it feel to study and play something for 30-40 years then just have to throw games for $20? Probably awful. Also, general health-wise, most Chess players I know are sedentary, playing Chess isn't really healthy as you are sat in a chair for hours on end. It's very competitive, which can lead to stress and stress just leads to burnout often. To end this post, I want to say that I luckily didn't keep on this path. In my opinion, life needs variety and so I have done much more and I am happier than the years I spent on Chess. Studied hard, got a job as a software engineer, went on many vacations, enjoyed food & drinks everywhere, had friends/love come and go, played many games, read books and watched movies and I just lived a more fulfilling life than my past Chess lifestyle because it's frankly, a stark contrast between the two. TLDR: Trying to logically explain my distaste for Chess in modern times.
- dumbaccount123 3y ago[dead]
- mgaunard 3y agoI like casual chess; as soon as it gets into blitz and studying openings and patterns I tend to lose interest, that sounds like work, not fun. It's like studying the meta instead of actually playing.
- kqr 3y agoI have the exact same opinion, and this is what drove me to play go. I can't really explain it, but go feels more suitable to casual games.
- thomasfromcdnjs 3y agoI love playing Scrabble (with people I know), still competitive, but try to play words you know and share the meanings after the game so it's fun and you learn. (Scrabble champions just memorize the spelling not the meaning) (They probably also know a lot of the meanings but my point still stands)
- prometheus76 3y agoQat
- bnralt 3y agoThis is how I feel as well. I did a little studying, but it not only felt like a treadmill, I actually felt like I was using less of my critical thinking skills the more I studied. Stuff like memorizing openings, memorizing the best move a chess engine would give you for certain situations, stuff like grandmasters memorizing entire games - this all seemed to be pretty common. I didn't see the point in putting in work only to enjoy the game less. Of course, plenty of people enjoy a much more memorization heavy game. But it feels like ruining the fun part of the game to me.
- NickC25 3y agoI'm 1700-1800ish lichess (Crazyhouse and King of the Hill). I agree with this, but with one caveat. I memorize a few openings just because games can get crazy sharp pretty quickly, and there are a few patterns or move orders in the opening to memorize just so you aren't mated quickly. I don't memorize games several moves deep, just 3-4 maybe 5 depending on the opening, which especially in Crazyhouse as there are only probably 3-4 good openins.
- kzrdude 3y agoI don't like losing, I want to always win. That's why I don't play. I've been thinking recently that I should play anyway so that I could grow out of this condition. Any tips for that?
- twixfel 3y agoI am the same, I'm so terrible at chess that it's just not enjoyable for me, and I don't have time to learn it properly, so I just don't play even though I find the game interesting and a bit addictive.
- grzaks 3y agoYeah. You have to realize that in chess there are two players and one of them is going to lose. Sometimes it's you, sometimes it's your opponent. To progress in chess you need to win more games than you lose. 50.5% win rate is enough in the long term. My suggestion based on my own emotions with chess is that you should start playing quick games like 3+2 or something. The time and emotional "investment" in those games is low enough that you might not care when you lose. Just start another game and try again. Losing classical game that you were playing for 2 weeks is a different beast.
- JR1427 3y agoI was the same. I can't easily describe what changed, but now I don't play to win or lose, I just decided to play for the sake of playing. If you lose a game, just stop playing for a bit, and don't give in to the feeling of wanting to play another to prove you can win. This will only result in frustration. If you lose, make yourself think "That was a fun game. I learned X, and will try and do Y next time."
- stavros 3y agoI'm the same, but I haven't managed to grow out of it. I just get frustrated and keep playing in anger until I win, which sucks for my social life. Oddly, the only sport where I'm chill about losing is tennis, where I think "nice, they played really well". Everywhere else, including chess, it's "how could you do this to me". The only time I managed to be chill in chess was after I'd taken MDMA, and then when I'd lose I'd think "they played better, they deserve it". It went away after a few days, though, never to be repeated (presumably without more MDMA).
- INTPenis 3y agoMy dad was a master chess player in my country when I was growing up so I know all the moves but I never had the interest to go further than that. So what I really need to study are the famous openings and the responses to various openings. Seems like a memory game. Computer games were always more fun.
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 3y agoThis is why I've been avoiding chess. Anything that feels too memory intensive just doesn't seem fun to me. It's not creative strategy it's just rote memorization. Same goes for Rubik's cubes.
- INTPenis 3y agoYeah I'll play the shit out of a Civilization game. That's like "3D chess" in a way because every unit has their own moves, you're restricted by the hexagonal board, you have to know which unit to use in which context.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- stephen_g 3y agoI’ve always felt the same way - perhaps it’s because I get to work on interesting and hard problems at work so when I get home I’d rather veg out. I’d much rather swim for an hour than do something mentally taxing and memory intensive. If I did something more manual I think I would perhaps crave that kind of outlet so I can kind of see the appeal. At least playing good chess does involve some improvisation and creativity. Cubing on the other hand has not appealed to me at all since I learnt it was mostly just memorising some patterns and executing them. It just feels like a trick - it is impressive the speed some people can do it but I’ve never really been impressed by people being able to solve them. Perhaps those are unpopular opinions though!
- FergusArgyll 3y agoI don't find chess memory intensive, I almost never directly commit opening variations to memory. I play around with them, often against myself, until I get a feel for what works, what's speculative and what's bad. Preparing for a tourney or a big game is different obv. but usually you just play enough that openings and their values become a part of you
- grzaks 3y agoMy biggest frustration with chess online is the huge number of cheaters on platforms like chess.com and lichess. It really takes the whole fun away. I never really understood WHY people are cheating in online chess games. There is no fame, no money in it. This is puzzling for me. My frustration is that chess.com and lichess are extremely week at finding and banning cheaters. Sometimes is sooo obvious, when for example somebody blunders a piece in first few moves and from this moment starts playing just perfect moves.
- gwnywg 3y agochess.com puts some effort in detecting cheaters. When I was active user I was receiving messages stating that such and such game was lost to cheater and my rating is updated to reflect that. Cheater detection sounds like very interesting problem
- V-2 3y agoCheating detection can only be achieved statistically (it's kind of like proving a random number generator isn't random). It makes it easy to achieve great accuracy in the long run, but hard to be accurate in the short run, because you don't want false alarms. So 99.9% of cheaters may get banned after a few games, but since they keep on coming up (it's not hard to simply register another account, after all), the frustration they're causing is always going to be there.
- Ma8ee 3y agoSome kind of shadow banning would be suitable. Let them play bots, or just other cheaters.
- V-2 3y agoGood idea, apparently this is - or at least was - already being done on lichess, albeit not without some controversies (of the sort that's fairly typical whenever shadow banning enters the picture).
- 3y ago
- thisisauserid 3y agoI learned about the Woodpecker Method from HN, bought it through the Forward Chess app so I could plough (plow?) through it on my phone. You won't feel like you're getting better with this method but you will start to sense opportunities consistently (and then recognize them specifically). Yes, you still need to then go learn a couple openings.
- aronhegedus 3y ago>get started and keep going. My personal opinion is that this is the most important. There's so many things you can focus on, sometimes we forget that we need to just spend more time actively focusing on chess to get better. I think actively focusing makes a huge difference. Playing a 2+1 while watching netflix is completely different than 5+3, fully committing. Lastly, I think if you find the part of chess you like most then lean into that! I love endgames, so I spend 75% of my time studying those. I might not be the best off for it (~1675 Lichess), but I like it, so there :) My workplace has a chess league which is really cool and useful to keep wanting to practice.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoFun to see GM Axel Smith mentioned, I used to be his student as a teenager, when he was still an IM. Great teacher and just a wonderful person overall. I can vouch for his methods, even if I was a teenager when I practiced them. This is a great article on how to improve chess as a beginner, from the perspective of a former beginner. Basic recognition of patterns is the bedrock of tactical calculation. And focusing on problems that can be solved quickly is a good strategy for building it. I do want to champion the cause of harder problems though, because there is more to calculation than pattern recognition. And this will become more and more important above the very impressive 1500 the author managed to reach. Calculation is a conscious mental process that needs training in its own right. It involves the ability to visualise board states, remember where you are in the game tree, enumerate candidate/forcing moves and threats, heuristics like the method of elimination. None of these can be trained purely through these simpler problems, only through slowly taking your time applying all these techniques. This is why blitz rarely leads to an improvement in your base ability. The only way to build out your ability beyond what you can immediately recognise is to really struggle with positions you can't solve in 8 seconds, or even 8 minutes. This happens naturally if you play longer time controls(and actually spend your time). It's also tremendously helpful to join your local chess club and work through some problems with a stronger player to guide you. That's also a lot more fun to most people. Learning chess doesn't have to be just a lot of rote exercise. You can also read books on positional chess, pawn structures, endgames, and openings. No, they don't decide games as much as tactical mistakes but they certainly influence games profoundly whether the players are aware of them or not. And a more "holistic" approach can be more motivating.
- kqr 3y agoThe way I've heard it described for go is that beginners improve fastest by focusing on problems that require them to calculate 1–3 plies out of their comfort zone. These build strongly on pattern recognition (those are the comfortable bits) but also include some game tree walking (at least in go, 1–3 plies make up a pretty heavy game tree for a beginner.) The idea is that calculation practise is great, but it also takes a lot of time. In the time it takes a beginner to solve one very deep calculation problem, they could have finished 40 pattern recognition problems and that would probably be more beneficial. So calculation and pattern recognition has to be balanced, and a few plies out of the comfort zone strikes that balance.
- iLoveOncall 3y agoI think the most important thing about learning chess is to not play blitz or bullet games until you are already at a high-enough level (1500+). Learning comes with analysis and deduction, both of which are pretty much impossible in a sub 10 minutes game for a beginner.
- kdamica 3y agoThis is a less interactive site than those mentioned in the article, but i found www.chesstactics.org incredibly helpful when i was starting out. I eventually realized that i enjoy chess puzzles much more than playing actual games of chess due to the lower time commitment and lower stress. I do puzzles every day but almost never play a full game.
- thrwyexecbrain 3y agoDespite absolutely loving chess as a child, I never studied it professionally, and I did not even play a single game after primary school. A couple of years ago I stumbled upon a chess video recommendation here on Hacker News. It was the 27th entry of ChessNetwork's Beginner to Chess Master series and it rekindled my love for the game. I have been playing chess casually ever since. I cannot recommend ChessNetwork's videos enough: I found them to be insightful, well-made, and very respectful of both the game and the audience.
- codetrotter 3y agoI preferred the original title: > How To Learn Chess As An Adult (or, how I went from 300 to 1500 ELO in 9 months) Because it showed that the person writing this “how to learn” was speaking from personal experience. There are too many articles online that say how to learn something, but the author may never have actually tried it themselves and are instead writing based on other sources. Or worse yet, now in 2023 they may have asked ChatGPT how to learn something and just copy-pasted what it said. Changing the title to just: > How to learn chess as an adult Is a mistake IMO, and makes it easier to skip past this article.
- ZiiS 3y agoFor anyone less then 1,000 it is trivial to gain 100 points. Most could do it by playing games but anyone wanting to learn just needs to read some advice, study an opening and practice. 1400 > 1500 is much more impressive then 300>1200.
- mellosouls 3y ago(2021) Some previous discussions on similar articles fwiw: Learning chess at 40 (2016) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31433914 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31433914 (69 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20154285 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20154285 (82 comments) On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Years (2020,338 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25108800 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25108800 How to get good at chess fast (2013, 65 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10695748 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10695748
- scotty79 3y agoWhen I first encountered chess as a kid I thought it was a game about thinking because that's how we played it. I was good at it. Then in high school I've met a kid that wiped the floor with me because he actually was taught how to play chess. I played with him few times until I won once just because he was lulled by a streak of wins. That was enough for me so I stopped bothering him with myself. Later in some other context I played checkers with him which I used played (and loose terribly) with my grandma as a few years old child. It turned out that I'm wiping the floor with him in checkers. He didn't even won once. Then I formed a overgeneralized opinion that games are not using any universal matter of thinking. Any thinking you do for the purposes of games is narrowly tailored to the game itself. Being good at one means you are still terrible at others. I generalized this opinion even more, into all domains of human activity. So now when highly educated geologist claims something about climate or zoologist claims something about vaccines I know that they are beginner level wrong.
- Ma8ee 3y agoMy favourite example of that is retired physics professors who assume economics must be easy compared to physics and write opinion pieces about how the country should be run (and make first year economics student errors).
- gcanyon 3y agoChessable Pro is $12 per month, or $75 per year: https://www.chessable.com/pro/ https://www.chessable.com/pro/
- johngossman 3y agoGood article. A lot of the comments here give bad advice though, which isn’t surprising because they show a lot of common misperceptions about chess. Jeremy Silman has written a couple of books about what is actually important. Quickly, what worked for me when I started playing on chess.com at age 40 after not playing for over twenty years. My rating at age 17 was 1450. Restarted at 1200, and barely progressed at first. If your rating is different you may need different things. Again, Silman is good on this. What worked: 1) eat. I would start playing in the morning, do okay, then lose a bunch. Finally, realized my blood sugar level was a major contributor to my elo 2) study tactics. Chess Tempo is great. Lots of good tactics books. Especially study spotting threats 3) Study basics of positions: best places to post rooks, bishops, control of center. But tactics more important. 4) don’t spend much time on openings. Learn the basics of a few common ones. Games will quickly diverge from openings. Because GM games so often depend on openings, amateurs (like me) tend to overpivot on this. 5) After playing, load your game into a chess engine and analyze what went wrong (if you played perfect, analyze what your opponent did wrong). Until about 2000, whomever makes the fewest mistakes usually wins.
- xrd 3y agoHow do you load your games into a chess engine? Where do you play that allows you to export games? And then are you loading into another site or using a local application on your laptop as the "chess engine?"
- johngossman 3y agoThey all have ways of saving a PGN file. I have Fritz and now I usually use playchess.com which automatically stores your games and has an easy way to launch analysis.
- I_complete_me 3y ago> How do you load your games into a chess engine? > Where do you play that allows you to export games? > And then are you loading into another site or using a local application on your laptop as the "chess engine?" I assume that you are a beginner and the following is quite simplified but I believe will assist you in getting started. Most sites allow you to save your games as PGN (Portable Game Notation). On lichess, for example, you can go into your profile page an click on the download button to Export Games. This will save your games in PGN format. You need to download install a chess engine onto your computer / device. On a laptop or desktop it is relatively simplest to first install chess software with a Graphical User Interface - google that term - I will mention just one - no affiliation - just that it's relatively simple. Arena is a free graphical user interface for chess that helps you analyze and play games, plus test chess engines. After you run Arena chess you can import the games you exported in PGN format. There are very strong open source / free chess engines (eg Stockfish) and other chess software with or without commercial chess engines. Just remember these three things: - The format that chess games are saved in is PGN with a .pgn extension - There is chess software that replays these PGN with no chess engine and that's fine to review a game digitally - There are umpteen chess-engines that will analyze your games / moves - some free, some commercial
- crashbunny 3y agoI've been playing on lichess for about 10-15 years, started playing when I was over 30. I probably average one 5+0 game a day. I don't play in tournaments. Usually one game for a break and then get back to work. My philosophy is skill level and rating doesn't affect enjoyment. Whether I'm rated 700 or 2700, once my rating stabilizes, I win as many games as I lose. I have the capacity to improve a little with a lot of work, but, eventually my rating will stabilize and once again I'll have equal wins to loses.
- Ma8ee 3y agoBut the games might have more depth, and be more interesting, the more skilled you are.
- yodsanklai 3y agoWhat does it even mean to learn chess? I suppose any adult can learn the rule in a few hours and start to have fun from there. Then is there a specific rating after which you can claim that you have learned chess? or will you get more fun once you reach a given level? it seems to be a very elusive target.
- johngossman 3y agoWhat does it mean to learn piano? A foreign language? Programming? Tennis? As you get better, you make fewer mistakes and it is (usually) less of a struggle to perform well. You’re right in the sense that you’re never (as a human) going to master it like you can tic-tac-toe or rubik’s cube. But that sort of mastery isn’t fun either.
- yodsanklai 3y agoI guess a proficient piano player wouldn't say "I'm learning piano", even though they're still trying to improve. In the case of chess, you can learn the game very quickly. So I'm wondering at what stage a chess player consider they can play, and that they're now trying to improve rather than just learn.
- lucasjames9 3y ago[dead]
- cyrialize 3y agoThe way I got into chess was by doing a couple of lessons using the Chess.com app. Once I learned the basic opening principles, a basic opening for white (Italian) and black (Two Knights), and the phases of the game - the game opened up much more for me. Just knowing to do E4/E5, take center, mobilizing pieces, trying to move pieces once in the opening, etc. improved my game so much. I was making so many bad moves without knowing these and having a terrible time. Knowing all this didn't help me win at all, but it made my experience much better.
- e40 3y agoWhat got me was how much chess.com spammed me after signing up. I used a throwaway email address specific to them, so I know it's them. I unsubscribed but they continue to spam me.
- EduardoBautista 3y agoWhat exactly are they spamming? I haven't noticed anything.
- e40 3y agohttps://postimg.cc/yWFXJp7W https://postimg.cc/yWFXJp7W I unsubscribed immediately after getting the first. And I deleted some without marking them spam, so I got about double.
- EduardoBautista 3y agoI don't see how using a throwaway email was the giveaway that it was Chess.com sending those emails, the emails are clearly from Chess.com. The comment I replied to made it sound as though they sold your data to a third party for marketing purposes or had a data breach.
- e40 3y agoYou're right, I was unclear. Yes, it's all from them and it annoyed me they kept coming after I unsubscribed.
- weregiraffe 3y agoWhy to learn chess as an adult?
- 29athrowaway 3y agoWhat works with most mind sports: Play few long games where you think your moves carefully, then review your games. Understand the key moves that defined the outcome of the game. Review your games when you win, review your games when you lose. Watch professional games, do problems, etc.
- blastro 3y agoI was introduced to chess in adulthood by a friend who taught chess in schools. His advice: play 2000 games without worrying about game play or outcome. Worked great for me.
- mratsim 3y agoWe have the same advice in go. But it's lose your first 50 games as fast as possible. https://senseis.xmp.net/?LoseYourFirst50GamesAsQuicklyAsPossible https://senseis.xmp.net/?LoseYourFirst50GamesAsQuicklyAsPoss...
- blastro 3y agoHey now that I'm reading this, that's exactly the way my friend phrased it as well. Best wishes.
- Misha_Bilous 3y ago>Especially at lower levels, chess is a game of short term patterns, not long term strategy. That’s actually wrong. Short-term patterns will improve your chess short-term but you’ll hit the plateau pretty fast. They don’t teach you to play better at chess. It’s like copypasting some code from the Internet without fully understanding how it works. In chess, it’s absolutely necessary to have a long-term plan: especially at lower levels, your ultimate goal should be attacking the king most of the time. Use the engine smartly. Because it will tell you what move is objectively the best. It won’t tell you what move is best at your level. At different levels the best moves are different. It’s important to train tactics but not with puzzles. Puzzles model situations that are out of context. It’s like training your swimming movements without hitting the water. It may be not harmful, but not particularly useful. Instead, you should get “puzzles” in your live games within the context, seeing the bigger picture. Of course, you should play games. How can you expect to get better at playing chess without actually playing chess? Moreover, playing games and getting feedback on them should be the bulk of your training. Learning happens by trial and error. Without dissecting this article any further, there is a battle-tested approach on how to get better at chess at any level and age: - Be a kid. Don't overthink it. It's just a game after all. Feel it. - Play as many games as possible. You can quickly get enough volume with bullet and blitz. - Get feedback. You're able to give yourself decent feedback most of the time. Quickly analyze your games yourself or check them with someone, who can tell you what mistakes you have made at your level. Only afterward compare your thoughts to engine suggestions. Pay attention to the moves that drop the evaluation by more than (1, 2, 3, 4) points, depending on your level. Of course, these are not hard and fast rules. But this is a solid foundation for the success. P.S. My FIDE rating is 2423.
- pelasaco 3y ago> That’s actually wrong. Short-term patterns will improve your chess short-term but you’ll hit the plateau pretty fast What you wrote, is exactly in-line with what the OT said: "Especially at lower levels, chess is a game of short term patterns, not long term strategy." You are beginner, you need some opening, some little patterns to move out from the beginner level, and then you reach a new plateau, but you understand the basic, you have your "first stripe white belt" game and from there you should search for sure a way to move to the next plateau.
- gmiller123456 3y agoI had been playing regularly for the past 30 years or so. After I watched "The Queen's Gambit", my rating went up about 100-200 points on Lichess. I was hovering in the 1800-1900 range, and shortly after watching it, I broke 2000 for the first time. While the series did inspire me to study a little more, I'm pretty sure the result was due to an influx of weaker players who also watched the series, rather than my playing ability. But I still jokingly tell people it made my rating go up.
- leesec 3y agoI just started playing after watching ChessNetwork channel on youtube a few years ago. I played a little as a kid but was about 1000 at bullet when I started as an adult. I've grinded my way up to 2220~ with no study or training at all. My point is: just go play for fun, you don't have to study or become a master at some opening.
- SadWebDeveloper 3y agoLearned chess while young... elo around 1200~1500, pickup the game at 2023 because everyone has been talking about chess, maybe related to the netflix series but since i don't have netflix account and couldn't care to watch about a young-love drama series with chess around it, it wasn't the main motive. Anyway opened a chesscom account, i got completly destroyed by online people, elo 100 according to chesscom, move to bots could beat 1200 up to 1500 elo eaisly... decided to give a try to online matches again destroyed but then started to find the pattern... chesscom free account give me "three fair matches" that i could win to engage me in the platform, then it pairs me with either bots, 3-second chess engine cheaters or chess streamers playing with smurfs accounts, these pattern repeat almost every time sometimes is three, other times is four even five, if i play three games on 1 day the next day i would have another "three fair matches" and so on... so whats my point? Unless you are paying good money for the subcription you are pretty much "meat canon" for others, the same applies to lichess... if you play 3 games a day for at least 2 years months you could get the 1200 elo, if you pay-to-win or pay the premium you would likely reach that 1000 elo more eaisly because is convenient for them to no match you against known cheaters on the platform...
- bongodongobob 3y agoWas that your FIDE Elo or are you just guessing? It sounds like you just need to practice. You're going to need to provide much more evidence if you think the two biggest chess platforms in existence are impossible and cheating you. Yes there are some bots, yes some people cheat, but what you're implying is just plainly false.
- SadWebDeveloper 3y agoThats what my chess teacher used to put me in their local chess club tournaments, in order to get a FIDE Elo, i would have need to go (on that time 1995~1999) to official tournaments and that was expensive for a rural area... M not saying m on the level of masters but definitely not a newbie... either way i don't need proof just go to chesscom, open a new free account and start grinding... you are gonna see fast the pattern on how the platform gets you engaged but you need to look careful, it entices you with free wins before going hard on you, having three to five games a day was the eureka moment to get good ratings... either go slow or pay premium to get an edge on the game and preferred match making.
- daniel-cussen 3y ago[dead]
- mvkel 3y agoAs someone who has been playing a few times a week for a year and stuck at 350 ELO, this was written for me.
- veucast 3y agoI just use chess.com I started in 4 months ago. But to be fair, I still think having a real person teach you is better.
- tatrajim 3y agoReally fascinating article. Any similar advice for an adult xiangqi leaner? I recently decided to delve into East Asian forms of chess and chose xiangqi to begin. I have some limited written Chinese, if needed for the best sites and texts.
- nilslindemann 3y agoRelated: https://archive.org/details/chessmasteratanyage https://archive.org/details/chessmasteratanyage
- chupapimunyenyo 3y agoI stopped reading after "white male privilege". Political submission, highly controversial