23 ms·
Suspects can refuse to provide phone passcodes to police, court rules
- walterbell 3y agoAvoid phones which flash plaintext password characters onscreen during typing, visible to any nearby video camera for record/replay.
- willsoon 3y agoWell, I am not in the USA, but I think that in the whole of the West you cannot incriminate yourself. But thank you, Your Honour.
- tasn 3y agoUnfortunately that's not the case. In the UK you can be forced to decrypt data and provide passwords. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law#United_Kingdom https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law#United_Ki...
- smcin 3y agoWhat, "the West" meaning everything from Bulgaria to Canada to Estonia? That's way overly broad claim. This ruling isn't even for all of the US, currently only at the Utah state Supreme Court level, it hasn't gone to the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals or Supreme Court. This is not necessarily the last word on the topic, not even just for the US. Another of many factors is whether the person was being detained or merely questioned, whether they had been formally notified of their right to remain silent, etc.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- atoav 3y agoAnd this is why one shouldn't use biometrics.
- wolverine876 3y ago> one shouldn't use biometrics. How else do you protect against the exploit of security cameras, anywhere you unlock your phone, recording your passcode?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoReminder to iPhone users that five fast presses of the side button will pop up the emergency calling page; it will also lock your phone in a way that requires your passcode to unlock even if you use biometrics.
- hanniabu 3y agoIf you spam the button and press it more than 5 times, does it still work?
- davely 3y agoJust tried it and it appears so (on an iPhone 14, at least).
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoYes; spam away.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kingnothing 3y agoAlso power + volume down
- qingcharles 3y agoFrom personal experience, this does not work if a cop puts a loaded gun to your head. You will not want to move.
- unstatusthequo 3y agoAnd so law enforcement just uses GreyKey[1] and problem solved for them. [1] https://www.magnetforensics.com/products/magnet-graykey/ https://www.magnetforensics.com/products/magnet-graykey/
- sparker72678 3y agoIs it still the case that this product attempts to brute-force unlock the phone?
- ssl232 3y agoHow does that work? Reading between the lines it sounds like it is device dependent, so at least obscure Android phone users might be safe...?
- forgotpwd16 3y agoWas going do the same question. And was more curious in the >When time is critical or access is restricted, selectively extract specific data you need to kick-start your investigation part. With full-device encryption, was expecting it would've been all or nothing.
- yencabulator 3y agoFor what it's worth, Android no longer supports full-device encryption, it encrypts filesystem subtrees. For a single-user phone, there's not much of a difference; your "user files" key is obtained from the hardware secret store when you type your PIN.
- yencabulator 3y agoI would assume security exploits, mostly targeting old unpatched versions, with some undisclosed 0days in the more expensive products. And against a modern Pixel/iPhone I would also expect the answer to how does it work to be "not so well". Consider the percentage of the population that uses a potato phone from 2018, consider the likelihood of them being the criminal in question, and the product starts working a lot better. Remember how FBI failed to decrypt the iPhone of some domestic terrorists: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple%E2%80%93FBI_encryption_dispute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple%E2%80%93FBI_encryption_d... Also remember that lower-end Android hardware uses a different, cheaper, algorithm: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adiantum_(cipher) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adiantum_(cipher)
- ejb999 3y agoI can't even understand why this was even still up for debate - 5th amendment allows you to not incriminate yourself - being forced to give up your passcode is no different then being forced to give up any secrets you might have. Not sure why this hasn't been slapped down a long, long time ago.
- genocidicbunny 3y agoFrom my reading about this case, is this not down partially to the specific language the court was looking at? That is, the warrants were compelling someone to produce the password, which is a form of testimony, but that a lot of times the warrant instead compels the device to be unlocked, which does not require testimony?
- ethanbond 3y agoI mean... police can force you to open your door, your safe, or virtually any other container of secrets. The 5th Amendment doesn't give you broad protection to hide things from police when they have a warrant. A phone is unique thing not because it contains so many secrets, but because you have to give testimony (as opposed to property, like a key) in order to open it, and it's impossible to open by bashing the door down or cutting it open. It's a technological coincidence, not a legal/philosophical doctrine, that makes phones secure against compulsion by law enforcement.
- anonymousab 3y ago> police can force you to open your door, your safe, or virtually any other container of secrets. Is it different from compelling someone to enter a text password to unlock a vault? What if it's self-destructive otherwise? What happens if the password itself - or act of unlocking - is something self-incriminating (in form, in contents, or otherwise)?
- ssl232 3y ago> What happens if the password itself - or act of unlocking - is something self-incriminating (in form, in contents, or otherwise)? Reminds me of Ian Watkins: https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2013/11/26/lostprophets-singer-ian-w-0_n_4344523.html https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2013/11/26/lostprophets-sin....
- mike_ivanov 3y agoWhich might imply that providing passcodes is no longer "necessary" to survey the content.
- croes 3y agoFaceid isn't protected and the passkeys get unlocked by Faceid
- lesuorac 3y agoMy god have we come a long way if its even a debate if you have to reveal your password. Back in the day your personal belongings couldn't be used to incriminate you [1] since the bill of rights prohibits self-incrimination. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere_evidence_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere_evidence_rule
- croes 3y agoNowadays it doesn't really matter when people replace passcode by biometrics and passkeys. These aren't protected.
- Ridj48dhsnsh 3y agoWon't your device holding the passkey still take passcodes to unlock itself?
- lxgr 3y agoiPhones and many Android phones default to biometrics for both screen unlock and passkey usage these days.
- hypothesis 3y ago> the government was becoming dissatisfied with the obstruction of criminal investigations that strict adherence to the rule engendered Also > The Court recognized that while the rejection of the mere evidence rule may "enlarge the area of permissible searches," the protections of the 4th Amendment, like the reasonableness and warrant requirements, would sufficiently safeguard the right to privacy. So SCOTUS think that government would be satisfied with Bill of Rights. What if government thinks it is just too frustrating to follow laws?
- abfan1127 3y agowhat do you mean, "what if?"? Its already there. There's plenty of examples. For instance, the FBI is involved in background checks for gun purchases in the US. They are legally required to destroy any results of said check. They have not (to my knowledge) ever passed an audit.
- terminous 3y ago*In the state of Utah
- snickerbockers 3y agoHas there ever been a court case related to encrypted data or secret codes without a computer being involved? If the cops get a warrant to tap a phone line and they hear me speaking with an associate using some sort of coded language (as spies and criminals often do on TV) can i be compelled to explain to them what all the little codewords actually mean?
- pc86 3y agoYou can't be compelled but especially with spoken language it's going to be very easy for LE to decrypt it on their own by just correlating the coded language with whatever actions were taken later.
- lelanthran 3y agoBut that's just the point. In the past, pre-computer days, if the cops couldn't break your encryption you were not compelled to tell them how and that was their problem. Now you are compelled. I feel that that should not have changed.
- yttribium 3y agoThey will admit testimony by some cop to explain that "based on my training and experience, I believe 'going to the pool' to be code for 'soliciting a murder'"
- wombatpm 3y agoBut what if translate everything to LinearB or Klingon pig-Latin and then encrypt. Am I required to provide a Rosetta Stone to investigators?
- anon84873628 3y agoIANAL but I don't think you're required to provide anything to "investigators". Certainly not before consulting your lawyer. However I believe the court could eventually order you to produce the Rosetta Stone, after various proceedings. At that point you have to decide whether you want to comply with the order or not, and not doing so would likely have negative consequences like being held in contempt.
- csdvrx 3y agoWe are lucky to have constitutional rights! In many countries, they have laws saying suspects can't refuse to give passcodes (or if they do, they'll be jailed) I think such laws are dangerous, as they could be used for a particularly evil type of attack: throw an encrypted cellphone in someone bag, then have them arrested for whatever wrong reason. When they can't provide the passcode, they are automatically guilty!
- yencabulator 3y agoAt that point, it'd be easier to throw some cocaine or an unregistered firearm in their bag, and that'd be a simpler argument in court.
- csdvrx 3y ago> At that point, it'd be easier to throw some cocaine or an unregistered firearm These can be illegal depending on the country in question. Cellphones are very frequent, and not illegal (except maybe in North Korea?)
- yencabulator 3y agoI read "have them arrested" as implying the dirty actor is the state/cops. For a dirty cop, drugs & weapons should be easy enough to access.
- csdvrx 3y agoI understand your point now, but the horrible thing is such laws turn normal objects into dangerous object: it increase the risks as "less dirty than usual" bad actors can cause the same potential amount of damage!
- CamperBob2 3y agoIt's not luck; we had to fight for those rights. The fight did not end, and never will.
- 3y ago
- egberts1 3y agoUse a passphrase of something like "I stole a government-owned pen." Then you can argue that the passphrase (unlike a PIN, face ID) may incriminate me of a crime and that Fourth Amendment prevents me from doing so. Same thing with voice-based passphrase. Of course, I am not a lawyer.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tacocataco 3y ago"Whats the password? I cannot recall."
- u32480932048 3y agoChanging all my passwords to "I don't recall."
- egberts1 3y agoAnd the prosecutor may try to entice you with a limited concise immunity deal to excuse you of "whatever crime" that passphrase would accuse you of, of which you would say "is that not a fishing trip?" And refuse that deal. IANAL.
- qingcharles 3y agoNote: the verdict only applies to those in Utah. Other US states have other rulings. Wait until there is a US Supreme Court ruling that affects the entire nation. Right now: do not use biometrics (can be legally forced); do not use numeric passcodes. Use alphanumeric password.
- sjfjsjdjwvwvc 3y agoWhy not numeric?
- croes 3y agoToo few possibilities?
- spiderice 3y agoHow is a 6 digit pass code too few possibilities when the phone locks you out after like 5 missed attempts? It seems unrealistic to expect people to type their alphanumeric password every time they want to unlock their phone.
- nijave 3y agoIf these are implemented in software it'd be possible to brute force offline and bypass the timeout
- Gigachad 3y agoI watched a video where they had the iphone cracked open and slightly modified in a way that would allow them to reset the storage to brute force quickly without timeouts.
- lxgr 3y agoThat shouldn’t be (at least easily) possible on newer iPhones anymore. The counters are now in rollback-protected dedicated memory; the lockout is implemented in the secure enclave.
- pphysch 3y agoIf LEO have a search warrant and find a locked safe in your house (that may include private data or evidence of crime), are they allowed to crack it or order you to open it? Why would a computer device be any different?
- sgjohnson 3y agoThey are allowed to crack it. They can’t order you to open it. Same goes for a computer device. Go ahead, crack it.
- hyperliner 3y ago[dead]
- croes 3y agoAnd know imagine you use passkeys secured by Faceid or other biometric procedures.
- olliej 3y agoas opposed to a password manager? Passkeys solve _many_ problems and the weaknesses all degrade to "password manager".
- croes 3y agoPasskeys take the passwords out of the user's hand. That's good for some users but bad for all, especially at the moment with missing migration possibilities between iOS and Android. Like all the rest of the computer stuff, it stops being yours and becomes theirs and you are only allowed to use it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- entriesfull 3y agoBull crap. I personally was on probation as a juvenile for a petty offense. One day the PO asks my parents to take me to talk with her to see how I'm doing. She then asked me for a facebook password and I refused. After which she put me in a court house cell for 8 hours and made me miss an entire day of school. I eventually gave this psychopath my password because I had nothing incriminating and I hadn't eaten all day. Nice to know USA is literally Nazi Germany but better at hiding their dirty secrets.
- wolverine876 3y agoThanks for sharing that. What a valuable perspective; most people on HN are talking with no experience. How old were you? (The last line usually wouldn't be ok on HN, but I can imagine your anger.)
- refurb 3y agoIf you're on probation you lose certain rights as a condition of your release.
- zlg_codes 3y ago[dead]
- shoulderfake 3y ago[dead]
- LoganDark 3y agoCould police ever compel me to provide the passcode or even an unlocked device if I have a dissociative disorder that can't even guarantee my own knowledge of the passcode? It's entirely possible for me to lose access to it without being able to help myself and it'd be a real shame if they thought I was lying then. Fun thought experiment, though.
- autoexec 3y agoYou don't even need a disorder for that. Anyone could forget a passcode. They can't prove that you remember it, or that you have any idea what it is, but what they can do is lock you in a jail cell anyway. If your lucky you might get out after only several years https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/02/man-who-refused-to-decrypt-hard-drives-is-free-after-four-years-in-jail/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/02/man-who-refused-...
- LoganDark 3y agoSure I don't need the disorder to forget things, but the disorder makes it more likely to happen.
- autoexec 3y agoI'd argue that people are far more likely to forget a password/passcode than to have dissociative personality disorder and then have only one personality be aware of the password and then also be cured of the disorder/personality or otherwise be unable to ever manifest that personality to allow for questioning by police. I think in that case it'd probably be treated more or less the same. Jailed for months/years for contempt of court, either locked up in a cell or a hospital with court ordered mental health treatment depending on if the judge believes the person actually has the disorder or not.
- LoganDark 3y agoAn estimated 1% or so of the population is suspected to have DID, and memory gaps don't exclusively work like "some identity knows the password but it's not me". I can totally forget things without someone else in the system still knowing them. Nobody really has to hold the memory for it to become inaccessible.
- buryat 3y agoreality is more like https://xkcd.com/538/ https://xkcd.com/538/
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sampli 3y agoIn the UK you have to hand your password over on command
- jmprspret 3y agoSame in a number of Australian states. You can face up to 10yrs jail time if you don't give it up iirc
- hutzlibu 3y agoIsn't that a violation of the right to silence? "Australia has no constitutional protection for the right to silence,[4] but it is broadly recognized by State and Federal Crimes Acts and Codes and is regarded by the courts as an important common law right and a part of the privilege against self-incrimination" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_silence_in_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_silence_in_Australia
- jay-barronville 3y agoI’m an American, so this doesn’t apply to me, but the idea that someone could be forced, by their government, to self-incriminate is absurd to me.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoI’m an American. Americans are forced by their government to self-incriminate all the time and are sitting in jail for it. Here's a computer to explain it to you: https://chat.openai.com/share/532f399a-80d4-4973-9508-67f0f092808b https://chat.openai.com/share/532f399a-80d4-4973-9508-67f0f0... And the references used. I even checked them myself: https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca4/21-4442/21-4442-2023-11-21.html https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca4/21... https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca4/22-4593/22-4593-2023-10-12.html https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca4/22... This one in particular is great because apparently the 5th amendment doesn't apply if you're not an English speaker and don't understand the extreme subtleties of the law, such that you can be compelled to incriminate “To qualify for the Fifth Amendment privilege, a communication must be testimonial, incriminating, and compelled.” The Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination thus only protects a defendant from being compelled to provide “testimonial” evidence, meaning that the communication “must itself, explicitly or implicitly, relate a factual assertion or disclose information.” Indeed, the Supreme Court has explicitly distinguished between “the use of compulsion to extort communications from a defendant” and merely “compelling a person to engage in conduct that may be incriminating,” such as providing samples of one’s voice, handwriting, or physical appearance, all of which are constitutionally permissible." Note, these are only the ones that were appealed. Land of the free baby
- ckdarby 3y agoI always wonder what happens if you unlock with a code that switched profiles and encrypted the other profile.
- TacticalCoder 3y agoThat'd be some form of "plausible deniability" (although the term has a lot of different meanings depending on the context). I know it exists for certain cryptocurrencies hardware wallets: they can be setup (but are not required to) so that one PIN unlocks the real wallet and another PIN unlocks a decoy wallet, which only has some coins. P.S: people are probably going to point out the $5 wrench attack though
- fastball 3y agoIsn't that the benefit of such a scheme? You ask for my password, I say no, you hit me with a $5 wrench, I say no. You keep hitting me, I input the decoy password and you think that is all the crypto (or content or whatever) I have. $5 wrench attack works on known unknowns, but not well on unknown unknowns.
- ljm 3y agoIf your adversary is the US intelligence machine then you’re already presumed to be guilty and a fail safe on your phone will achieve nothing. People were sent to Guantanamo bay for much less.
- tomcam 3y agoYou’re so cynical. And by cynical, I mean absolutely right.
- plorg 3y agoIf they threaten to beat you with a $5 wrench and you refuse and refuse and refuse and eventually cave and unlock the wallet with $10 of Bitcoin they're going to hit you with a wrench because you wouldn't resist so hard over so little and you're obviously trying to be clever.
- wolverine876 3y agoIf you feed a bunch of a target's personal info into an LLM, would it guess their password more quickly than a human? What about an LLM trained specifically for the task? It could be the end of non-random passwords.
- BriggyDwiggs42 3y agoDoubt it, they arent magic
- bryan0 3y agoAm I missing something or is the headline (and most of the HN commentary) missing the point of this ruling? The ruling is not about whether you have the right to refuse to give your passcode (of course you have that right). Rather the ruling is about whether your refusal to give your passcode can be used against you at trial as incriminating evidence (?!) > A court of appeals reversed the conviction, agreeing "with Valdez that he had a right under the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution to refuse to provide his passcode, and that the State violated that right when it used his refusal against him at trial." The Utah Supreme Court affirmed the court of appeals ruling. This seems like a much more subtle question.
- SuperNinKenDo 3y agoIn terms of the Fifth Amendment, it would seem that those issues are identical. Your right to silence means that your refusal to answer a question, provide interviews, etc, can't be brought up as evidence of your guilt.
- bryan0 3y agoYeah thinking about it more I think this makes sense. It seems like it could be brought up in court though? Just not used as “evidence” again you?
- Terr_ 3y agoIANAL, but I imagine that would ideally go something like this: Prosecution: "Mr. Defendant, when the police asked you to unlock your phone, what did you tell them?" Defense: "Objection, prejudicial and irrelevant. Fifth-Amendment." Judge: "Objection sustained--move on to the next question."
- jonstewart 3y agoYes, but from TFA it sounds like the prosecution did this in closing arguments, when they’re not talking to a witness. Objections are typically not made by opposing sides in closing arguments (though possible). IANAL and don’t know precisely under which circumstances the judge should intervene in closing arguments. But implying that pleading the fifth is evidence of guilt is kinda “Prodecutorial No-Nos 101” and it’s not surprising it was overturned on appeal. What’s more surprising is that the prosecution then went to the state Supreme Court.
- cynicalsecurity 3y agoNever store anything incriminating on your phone. How hard can it be. Your phone is never your friend. A compact Linux device without any biometrics, telemetry, public clouds and corporate spying software is probably what you could be looking for.
- madeofpalk 3y agoHow do i know if it's incriminating or not?
- nagonago 3y agoUnfortunately the encrypted phone market is a total mess. The Darknet Diaries podcast has a good episode about this. https://darknetdiaries.com/episode/105/ https://darknetdiaries.com/episode/105/
- rendaw 3y agoAre you arguing against the ruling? Is this not a good move away from what you've described?
- jmbwell 3y agoNothing has to be on your phone for a cop to demand its contents. At which point, if they want to find something incriminating, rest assured they will. “Nothing to fear if you’re not doing anything wrong” is a fallacy that serves only the cops
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SCAQTony 3y agoIt seems so evident that the 5th is in play. I wonder if this is a test case to take advantage of a particularly conservative Supreme Court.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wmidwestranger 3y agoI'd go so far as to say they never needed permission to refuse, so thanks for confirming the traditional position that coercion is not a valid means of confession.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoOrin Kerr noted, commenting on this case, that it's restricted to the question of whether suspects can be compelled to divulge their passwords, even though the more common legal question is whether suspects can be compelled to unlock their phone.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- alliao 3y agoChinese netizens posed this question the other day, about how their police never seem to run into the US police issues unable to gain access; especially to iPhones. Many conspiracy theory surfaced from back door to rooted iCloud servers in China. Till a supposedly policemen chimed in and said they'd just browse through the millions upon millions of security footage to see the perp unlocking their phone with passcode.
- walterbell 3y agoApple iPhone needs opt-out of flashing the plaintext passcode characters onscreen during device unlock. If users need to verify the entered characters, use the “show password” eye icon. Avoid the attack surface of flashing inverted characters visible to nearby surveillance and phone cameras. > they'd just browse through the millions upon millions of security footage to see the perp unlocking their phone with passcode s/browse/facial recognition search/
- DeathArrow 3y agoI am imagining an authentication system that doesn't just ask you for a password but beside making sure it's you who made the request, also makes sure that you request the access on your free will without being forced. A primituve one would be requiring a main password to authenticate every 12 hours. If the main password is not used until that period passes. A second password that you don't memorize can be used to unlock but it is stored in a place that only you can access and only if you are totally free.
- notfed 3y agoSo every 12 hours you'd have to go find your non-memorized password? Sounds incredibly inconvenient. Anyway, a tyrant is simply going to hold and gun to your head and tell you to go get that second password.
- doctor_phil 3y agoI think you read parent-comment wrong. My interpretation: unlock your phone normally at least every 12h. Only if you fail to do that, then the phone locks harder and you need to unlock with the non-memorizable password. Imagine the PIN/PUK system on SIM cards but with a timed lock-out as well. I agree that it sounds inconvenient though. I'm not that familiar with the US law system, but wouldn't a written down password be worse? With a memorized password it's at least possible to claim you have forgotten. Some encryption schemes allow two keys for unlocking, but they would show different content depending on the key. I think I remember trying that on TrueCrypt many years ago.
- DeathArrow 3y agoI would imagine the second password being in a safe in a Swiss bank. It's not practical at all, but there should be possible to build systems that authenticate you only if you are free and doing that on your free will without any compulsion.
- Ikatza 3y agoI sleep longer than 12h most days.
- gorgoiler 3y agoI read the article as well as the (imho much better) blog post on reason.com*, and it still feels tenuous to hope that this would be decided definitively by the Supreme Court. In the original case the prosecution argued that the defendant’s lack of cooperation in unlocking their phone was evidence of guilt. Wouldn’t a Supreme Court ruling therefore be about whether or not a prosecutor may assert such a thing as evidence? That feels quite different from the original act of (and rights around) refusal to unlock the phone. It’s as if the prosecution said “he had a gun, so he must be guilty!”, and hoping that the case will go to the Supreme Court to decide on the legality of the second amendment. * https://reason.com/volokh/2023/12/14/is-compelled-decryption-heading-to-the-supreme-court/ https://reason.com/volokh/2023/12/14/is-compelled-decryption...
- pstuart 3y agoSeems to me a very clear 4th Amendment issue. If there's reasonable suspicion that's one thing but a fishing expedition should not be allowed.
- tamimio 3y agoDoes it only to phones?! If so, it is probably because they are already compromised and backdoored, unless it applies to all other mediums and electronics. On the other hand, I remember I read border controls can operate within certain distance from the border inside the country, and as far as I know, they can ask you to provide the codes.
- TomK32 3y agoFor the US it's 100 miles and 2/3 of the US population live in this zone. https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/border-zone https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/border-zone
- callalex 3y ago(This is because airports count as borders for BS reasons)
- kelnos 3y agoAnd you can refuse, and they can't compel you to comply. They can take your phone and do their best to break into it or image its internal storage, but they have no right to detain you based on a refusal to unlock your phone. If you are not a US citizen, however, and you are trying to enter the country, they can use your refusal as a basis for denying you entry. Which is garbage, but... yeah.
- alex_lav 3y ago> If you are not a US citizen, however, and you are trying to enter the country, they can use your refusal as a basis for denying you entry. Which is garbage, but... yeah. Why is refusing to comply resulting in denying entry garbage?
- halJordan 3y agoYou can just read the article and you wouldn't need to make up a reason for why, the article tells you why.
- eastof 3y agoIANAL but what's stopping the "that's not my phone and I don't know the passcode" defense?
- vasco 3y ago"Officer, these drugs / gun in my pocket aren't mine!!" Not sharing the password should be obviously protected, but saying the phone isn't yours when in your person is harder to try and get away with.
- andylynch 3y agoI was a juror on a trial where this was tried. The prosecution showed logs from the mobile phone companies’ towers showing where it have been seen, including overnights, and calls from it to the guys friends. Also didn’t help him that it was on a loan application in his name. This helped convict them of aggravated burglary. (Incidentally, one of the others failed to provide his passcode but we found it implausible that he could have forgotten it, unlike the USA in England this is absolutely something you can be done for here and he was. I don’t want to get in to the pros/ cons of this law but the basic idea is that its seen as a key, albeit intangible, to a locked container which investigators can require you to open)
- notfed 3y agoStandard responses in order of increasing tyranny: 1. "I promise to tell you if you bring me snacks" 2. "Thanks. My password is a-n-i-d-i-o-t-t-y-p-e-d-t-h-i-s-6-9" 3. "Ok, ok, it's f-o-o-l-m-e-t-w-i-c-e-4-2-0" 4. "no." 5. "I refuse to answer any questions without a lawyer present" 6. "I don't remember the password" 7. "I tried to learned Android development and I think I accidentally wiped the device"
- chmod600 3y agoIf I were SCOTUS, here's how I would settle this question: The accused can't be compelled to produce a password, and the prosecution can't use the defendant's silence as an argument against them. BUT the police can explain in court that they were unable to search and/or seize what's listed on the warrant due to an unknown password and unbreakable encryption. In other words, they can't say "Joe wouldn't give us his phone password and that means he's guilty". But they can say "we were unable to search his phone or collect these documents listed on the warrant due to unbreakable phone security". There's not a huge difference between those two statements when it comes to the jury. They'll understand that evidence is missing, and that the defendant can probably produce it but won't. Maybe civil libertarians won't like that, but I think that's misplaced: there is a warrant, remember, it's not just a random search. And the defendant can always produce it if it's exculpatory.
- halJordan 3y agoThat merely adds a layer of indirection rather than solving anything. It is still using the person's silence against them and saying "there is proof behind that door." If there is proof it needs to be produced. If the State can always go "well there's encrypted data and inside the encrypted data is the reason to imprison this guy." You dont need the evidence, you just need to know its not visible. Why ever even seek the decryption order if you automatically get the negative implication for free? Its never been the defendants job to prove their innocence. Remember that's where we start. A defendant is innocent. An innocent person does not need to unlock anything, they're innocent.
- chmod600 3y agoAre we supposed to tell the prosecutor that they can't ask the police witnesses questions about how their legal, warranted search went? Or that the police can't answer?
- egberts1 3y agoProblem with Apple iPhone authentication scheme is their reductive logic of eliminating one of three basic authentications by using OR logic, instead of AND logic. In short, they are still single-factor authentication. https://www.pearsonitcertification.com/articles/article.aspx?p=1718488 https://www.pearsonitcertification.com/articles/article.aspx...
- mhbrsjsw 3y agoIn South Korea, a prosecutor under investigation for personal corruption once refused to hand over a password. The prosecutor was appointed to the position of Minister of Justice and is also a candidate for the next presidential election.
- butlike 3y agoYeah but can they refuse the detective holding the phone up to your face for FaceID?