5 ms·
That was the pinnacle. Now we're too busy with wealth extraction and making a couple of dudes ever richer.
by jacquesm 3y ago
That was the pinnacle. Now we're too busy with wealth extraction and making a couple of dudes ever richer.
- brandly 3y agoEh, the future of space travel and exploration is very bright.
- jacquesm 3y agoI'm not so sure about that. Humanity is turning ever more inward and education is getting worse and worse with the peak somewhere in the 1950's. If we have a bright future in space travel none of the countries with launch capability today look like they will be the ones driving it.
- manicennui 3y agoThere are many, many unmanned missions happening now making amazing discoveries. Cassini was nothing short of mind blowing. I'm somewhat sympathetic to your claims, and I wish more people were intellectually curious, but there are very likely more people in absolute numbers performing scientific research now than ever.
- jacquesm 3y agoI'll believe it when I see it. For now the Voyagers are the only thing out there that are expanding our envelope of influence, everything else is just data and will eventually evaporate. Think about it from a non-solar system perspective. Nothing we've done since Voyager has had any effect outside of our solar system and if we don't change our attitude it is quite likely that nothing ever will. Everything else we've done will long term only be a little bit of radiation, some of it structured but so far below the noise floor it will be unrecoverable.
- yreg 3y agoThat's a strangely high bar. As if Voyager had some nonnegligible effect outside of the Solar system.
- jacquesm 3y agoIf something like Voyager would arrive from outside our Solar system it would be the event of the millenium.
- kadoban 3y agoThere's every possibility that neither Voyager will ever arrive anywhere ever again. If they do, it's going to be after our galaxy collides with another, and the place they arrive at may not even exist yet. https://www.space.com/predicting-voyager-golden-records-distant-future https://www.space.com/predicting-voyager-golden-records-dist...
- lIl-IIIl 3y agoWhile the Milky Way galaxy is on course to collide with Andromeda galaxy in 4.5 billion years, that will not make Voyager's arrival anywhere more likely, since the stars are far enough apart that they will not be affected. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andromeda%E2%80%93Milky_Way_collision https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andromeda%E2%80%93Milky_Way_...
- kadoban 3y agoMy understanding is that it just makes it less predictable once that happens. We don't know exactly where all those stars are, and it gets chaotic once they start interacting. It probably is a _bit_ more likely as well, you suddenly have ~2x the stars near you and some of them are moving much faster relative to you, it's just not a sure thing by any means.
- yreg 3y agoWell so would be picking up radio signals like the ones we emit. And while the probability that someone will be able to pick these signals up is low, it is still almost infinitely greater than that of someone finding one of the Voyagers out there.
- fsmv 3y agoIt's not the countries anymore. The future is starship.
- dotnet00 3y agoI don't see where you're getting this from? It's so blatant that things are only improving, the US is running so many high profile missions, SpaceX alone has launched almost 100 times this year, Starship testing is proceeding well, we're reasonably on track for a long term human presence on the Moon, we're gradually preparing for Mars, China is managing to maintain its own space station, India is closing in on its own crewed spaceflight capability, South Korea achieved orbit last year and so on. The only people saying that the countries with launch capability right now will not be the ones driving space travel are those who have (ironically) paid zero attention to the developments in progress.
- jacquesm 3y agoWhat I'm getting this from? Reading the news for the last 40 years or so. Watching the new generation and their education levels. Seeing how science is now 'the enemy' rather than the future. > SpaceX alone has launched almost 100 times this year, Starship testing is proceeding well, we're reasonably on track for a long term human presence on the Moon, we're gradually preparing for Mars, China is managing to maintain its own space station, India is closing in on its own crewed spaceflight capability, South Korea achieved orbit last year and so on. Yes, we had all that and then some. Somewhere between the 60's and the 80's we took a detour and since then we've been losing momentum ever faster. I'm not one of the believers in Elon Musk, his Mars Colony is just a way to get people to do what he wants them to do. China has so many internal issues that I highly doubt they will be able to sustain any long term efforts and India may well be the future, though it would have to deal with a lot of internal problems as well if it is to happen. South Korea 'achieved orbit' on a SpaceX rocket, not by their own power. You can label all of this as progress and in terms of volume launched into space it is impressive, but it doesn't move the needle in terms of actual progress towards anything much larger. It's like the software people with 30 times one year of experience, we're getting really good at redoing the years between 1939 and 1969. But we haven't progressed to 1990 even once. 1977: peak humanity.
- kortilla 3y ago[flagged]
- akokanka 3y agoChina Will. Their education is mint. Current US education model is too soft and weak. Perfect for war meatballs not enough for space travel.
- nonethewiser 3y agoJust a reminder that the department of education did not exist until 1980. Disagree on the trajectory of space travel though.
- sharma-arjun 3y agoThis is only true in the western world. Globally, education has been trending upwards, at least until the pandemic. What is happening is a noticeable decline in the levels of trust in education and science. Generally, in the rich world, education used to be assumed to be a necessarily good allocation of resources, and whether you accessed it or not was largely a function of your wealth. Now, in some pockets of the world, this is no longer true. I also think that space travel will only see a revival in public interest if it provides viable economic value or becomes a renewed front for competing nationalism, neither of which appear to be extremely likely in the short term. Up to that point, I think it'll continue to be a playground for billionaires.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoFor who but the gilded?
- dotnet00 3y agoYou could've said the same for air travel in the early days.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoWell, we don’t have great figures on this but there are some estimates that only 20% of the human population has ever flown on an airplane. That seems like it’s a pretty heavily “gilded only” type of thing especially if you look at percentage distributions of flight frequency and by class.
- tobyjsullivan 3y agoWhere are you setting the bar for something to be commonly accessible? Only about 60% of the world’s population has reliable access to clean drinking water. 18% of people own a car. Compared to those numbers, 20% of people flying seems downright common - especially considering many people likely never fly simply because they have nowhere worth going (relative to cost).
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoYeah, it’s unconscionable that that such a small percentage of the population have access to clean, drinking water, given its triviality and creating So yes 100% of the population having clean water seems like the low bar As to flying, it’s probably good there aren’t more flyers
- BizarreByte 3y agoThere remains a fairly good chance that Voyager will be the last surviving thing in the universe made by humans. It may not be our pinnacle, but it might be our legacy.
- basementcat 3y agoPioneer 10, 11, New Horizons and some upper stages would like to have a word. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_artificial_objects_leaving_the_Solar_System https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_artificial_objects_l...
- dclowd9901 3y agoWhere do you find your optimism? Looks to be turning into yet another cynical cash grab to me.
- nonethewiser 3y agoEven if your cynical doom porn is true you’re wrong because both of those people, 1 in particular, are pushing space exploration forward.
- iAMkenough 3y agoI think you’re both right. They’re cornering a market with little competition because of the high cost barrier, with the hopes of personally owning/controlling space travel and any future colonization of other planets. I believe their primary motivation is monopolization and money, even if the science community experiences a benefit.
- mlrtime 3y agoI disagree, I think it's the opposite. Men have lofty dreams, they're also realists. How can you realistically get a man on Mars? Use all their talents to work with a government? Or use it to create enough capital to do it yourself (And piss off some people at the same time for fun)?
- phatfish 3y agoIt's just the whims of the rich and powerful, sometimes we are lucky and their mood aligns with needs of society as a whole. Sometimes the only way to for a billionaire to differentiate themselves from your run-of-the-mill middle-eastern oil billionaire is a vanity project to Mars.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoWhy do you even want to put a human on mars? What would you have them do that you can’t do with a probe or robot?. Its extremely risky to put people in space with our present technology. Even if nothing goes “wrong” they are dealing with microgravity and radiation. We aren’t adapted for it at all.
- fasterik 3y agoThere are a few reasons. You could say that putting humans on Mars has intrinsic value. In other words, "because it's cool". The other main argument for putting humans on Mars is that the grand projects of humanity push our technology forward. Putting humans on Mars requires solving a larger class of problems than sending probes does. The first space race accelerated the development of rocketry, integrated circuits, computers, satellite communications, and materials science. There's reason to believe that sending humans to Mars will cause similar advances in our capabilities, possibly in novel ways that we can't anticipate. A third argument is existential risk. If something catastrophic happens on Earth, there is some probability that having independent colonies on other planets would prevent extinction of the species. This is definitely true in the long term if we truly master the technology of surviving and thriving in space, but it's less realistic in the near term. That said, I don't think Musk and others working on this problem are taking the challenges of creating a colony on Mars seriously. We know very little about the long-term effects on the human body, reproductive cycle, and psychology. If they're serious about this, one of their top priorities should be funding research to create isolated self-sustaining human colonies closer to Earth as a proof of concept. If we can't survive for decades at the bottom of the ocean or on the moon, we probably can't survive for decades on Mars. We would also need high confidence that generations of humans born on Mars wouldn't accumulate severe genetic damage and birth defects. This is a whole research program in itself that we're nowhere close to solving.
- vt85 3y ago[dead]