3 ms·
And this is why fully autonomous flight control systems won't be certified for airliners in our lifetimes. While autonomous systems are capable of taking off, n
by nradov 3y ago
And this is why fully autonomous flight control systems won't be certified for airliners in our lifetimes. While autonomous systems are capable of taking off, navigating to a destination, and landing they are largely incapable of handling major emergencies. It's impossible for engineers to foresee every possible failure mode and program for it.
- cesarb 3y ago> It's impossible for engineers to foresee every possible failure mode and program for it. Playing devil's advocate: you don't have to. It just has to be better than a pair of experienced airplane pilots working together. Which is still very hard, and there's still a good chance we won't see it in our lifetimes, but at least it's not impossible.
- lovemenot 3y agoAlso, let's not completely discount remote pilots
- nradov 3y agoLet's completely discount remote pilots. There is no technology on the horizon which would solve the network latency or sensor fidelity problems that prevent remote piloting from being adequate for handling in-flight emergencies.
- lovemenot 3y agoI don't claim to be knowledgeable. It's just a hypothetical question. Surely, it depends on the nature of the emergency. As I understand it, in this Qantas example, the pilots did not need to fly the plane with real-time responses, just to make good decisions. Let's not completely discount remote pilots, while recognising they are not a universal panacea.
- mkl 3y agoThey needed to make a lot of real-time responses when coming in to land, as they had a very narrow window of viable speeds and limited control.
- lovemenot 3y agoThat seems to be correct. A partial mitigation of these issues could be high bandwidth / low latency networks just in take-off / landing corridors?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- MBCook 3y agoThere are plenty of times the thing that happens and the bits that save the plane are in remote areas of up high. They may still need help at landing, or by then it could be relatively normal. But if you can’t provide that level of help everywhere (including over oceans) the design of the system is choosing to lose planes in a trade off for needing fewer human pilots.
- foobazgt 3y agoThere are probably hundreds of ways a plane could fail that would require constant low latency supervision by a pilot. For example, in this specific circumstance, the pilots had to manually maintain speed within a narrow range of 3-4 knots with a bunch of blown control surfaces. Let's do completely discount remote pilots, please.
- rgmerk 3y agoIt’s worth pointing out that there are also plenty of airliner crashes that are attributed to pilot error.
- kergonath 3y agoPlenty compared to the set of airliner crashes, which is very small. There are also a lot of near misses that don’t turn into crashes precisely because of pilots being good at their jobs. For AI to replace pilots, you don’t need to prove that sometimes humans fuck up. You need to demonstrate that AI would fuck up less often and in a more acceptable way. This requires looking at the big picture, not only bad cases.
- rgmerk 3y agoFair points. But I reckon single pilot operation with emergency autoland will happen. The tech already exists for general aviation.
- nradov 3y agoMaybe for cargo. But there's zero chance that single pilot operation will be allowed for airliners. The workload for managing emergencies is too high for a single pilot, even with extensive automation.
- Dylan16807 3y agoYou don't think extensive automation could cut the workload in half?
- nradov 3y agoNot for major emergencies. It's impossible to build automation if you can't anticipate all of the possible failure modes.