14 ms·
Why The US Can Beat China: The Facts About SpaceX Costs
- hef19898 15y agoFollowing the discussion on the SpaceX infrastructure, I did some didding on their homepage and stumbled over this article. Seriously, being in this industry, that's more than just impressive. And you should really ask yourself what you do wrong...
- evoxed 15y ago> The Falcon 9 launch vehicle was developed from a blank sheet to first launch in four and half years for just over $300 million. The Falcon 9 is an EELV class vehicle that generates roughly one million pounds of thrust (four times the maximum thrust of a Boeing 747) and carries more payload to orbit than a Delta IV Medium. > The Dragon spacecraft was developed from a blank sheet to the first demonstration flight in just over four years for about $300 million. Last year, SpaceX became the first private company, in partnership with NASA, to successfully orbit and recover a spacecraft. The spacecraft and the Falcon 9 rocket that carried it were designed, manufactured and launched by American workers for an American company. The Falcon 9/Dragon system, with the addition of a launch escape system, seats and upgraded life support, can carry seven astronauts to orbit, more than double the capacity of the Russian Soyuz, but at less than a third of the price per seat. Well now, look at these gems! If you still need a reason to get into this company, just read the first sentence of either quote.
- skore 15y agoWell, that may be true, but when you hire a ton of NASA scientists, I would assume they can fill out those blank sheets rather quickly...
- objclxt 15y agoSure, but the same is equally true the tech industry: bright developers make smart products.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoAnd yet, how is it that NASA, or even Boeing or Lockheed-Martin, can't manage to fill out those blank sheets rather quickly, let alone cheaply?
- skore 15y agoI would suppose it's a combination of corporate politics being very different, more goal driven than in government agencies and the simple fact that SpaceX simply has a lot more giants on whose shoulders they can stand. Why they are that much more effective at it remains to be seen. I would guess it's being smart with the shoulders you pick to stand on and a good bit of PR.
- rst 15y agoSome of those statements are ... forward-looking. In particular, Dragon isn't man-rated yet, and that will require a lot of further engineering. Most notably, SpaceX has committed to a launch abort system for getting a crewed Dragon away from a failing booster; they've got a concept for this, and design work is underway, but it's not tested as of now, and I think some of the work is probably contingent on getting NASA funding to finish up. So, Dragon can't carry astronauts yet.
- Roboprog 15y agoCool. The Falcon 9 is most of the thrust of a Saturn 1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn_I#S-I_stage http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn_I#S-I_stage
- MatthewPhillips 15y ago> font-size: 11px; Why?
- ForrestN 15y agoSeriously! This must be the worst website I've encountered in a long time. Despite the inspiring content in the article, I leave with a mixed experience. Just goes to show how much design matters.
- jkeel 15y agoYou're comment made me smile. Only because I clicked the link, saw the page and thought, "who designed this?". My next thought was, "well, most of the space related sites look like this, so maybe it fits well with what that community expects".
- joering2 15y agoGoogle Chrome: Ctr +, Ctr +, Ctr + Honestly, the same thing I had to do with Hacker News. Font is damn too small, for me at least.
- yesbabyyes 15y agoI view webpages at 120% by default. I used to love small fonts, now I don't know what I was thinking and instead prefer the browser default of 16px.
- sp332 15y agoIn Chrome: Settings, Under the Hood, Customize Fonts. Set the "Minimum font size" to something comfortable. Firefox: Options, Content, click the Advanced tab under "Colors and Fonts". Choose a minimum font size that's comfortable.
- ordinary 15y agoI didn't even realize I was squinting at the tiny letters until I read this comment. Thanks for pointing it out, future me's eyes are grateful.
- 15y ago
- PaulHoule 15y agoIt's astonishing to see this much transparency into launch costs. Governments have long held this information close to their chests. NASA, in particular, has never published accounting on what the Space Shuttle really costs, since this information would help a competitor (Russians, Chinese, etc.) build a similar vehicle with better economics.
- evoxed 15y agoOn that note, this might be the perfect opportunity for some never-before-herad-of Russian billionaire to make their mark as well by providing similar services to the rest of Europe that may be underserved if SpaceX really takes off in the US. (Apparently when I don't sleep I think in puns, so apologies for that.)
- guard-of-terra 15y agoIf this SpaceX thing takes off, of course other space agencies, including RKA, will be forced to make transparent and comparable offerings in order to stay relevant (or get out from the launch "business"). Competition is actually a good thing sometimes.
- tjic 15y ago> On that note, this might be the perfect opportunity for some never-before-herad-of Russian billionaire to make their mark as well by providing similar services to the rest of Europe that may be underserved if SpaceX really takes off in the US. You haven't learned your lesson from the last 20 years. There are no more "European markets for space launch" and "American markets for space launch" than there are "European markets for database products". People compete globally. The only reason that someone in China or France wouldn't prefer the use the best quality / lowest cost supplier is if their local government gets involved and distorts the marketplace via either taxation or regulation.
- mcguire 15y ago...or if our government gets involved and distorts the marketplace. Which is entirely possible.
- randall 15y agoMost YC hackers: "I'm fixing x because x is broken. They're slow, costly, inefficient, and aren't taking advantage of modern technology." Elon Musk is doing a YC startup (in spirit) on the most grand scale possible.
- piotrSikora 15y agoHow is that YC-specific?
- lutorm 15y agoYou are affirming the consequent. It was never stated that this was a property of only YC.
- stcredzero 15y ago"Affirming the Consequent" should be the name of a Culture GSV. (Or maybe an ROU?)
- Dylan16807 15y agoHonestly I'd say randall is the one doing that. YC hackers are like Z. SpaceX is like Z. Therefore SpaceX is YC hackers (in spirit). piotrSikora isn't literally asking why such a thing is a property of only YC hackers. He's asking why randall is using property Z to label things as 'YC hacker'. I don't think your jumping on his imperfect wording is very helpful.
- ewolfe 15y agoI had no clue they were profitable. With "over $3 billion in revenues" and "total company expenditures ... were less than $800 million" that is quite the ROI.
- hyperbovine 15y agoClassic example of economic profit. They figured out how to do something at a fraction of the cost, and get to print money until the market catches up and prices fall.
- piotrSikora 15y agoKeep in mind that those $3bn are mostly "future" revenues that will be generated over the next 5 years (http://www.spacex.com/launch_manifest.php http://www.spacex.com/launch_manifest.php).
- simonh 15y agoAlso that was $800 Million through 2010, we are now 2 years on and counting.
- angersock 15y agoWonderful quote from the article: "(This concept may be foreign to some traditional government space contractors that seem to believe that cost overruns should be the responsibility of the taxpayer.)"
- skore 15y agoReally? That sounds rather obvious and a bit too cheeky to me. To twist it the other way around: If cost run over in a government project, who else could you hold responsible? Sure, it's not a great thing that this happens, but it seems like a douche point to make when the government simply has no other choice. Edit: Sorry, misread 'government contractors' as 'government agencies'. I was under the impression that he is talking about NASA.
- excuse-me 15y agoEven with commercial contracts a lot of government (and especially military) was done on cost+. However much we spent on a development the customer (taxpayer) would pay "+" an agreed margin.
- maxerickson 15y agoThe quote is in direct reference to a contract that NASA (the government...) has with SpaceX. So apparently it is possible for the government to agree to contracts that do not leave the taxpayer holding the bag for overruns.
- fr0sty 15y ago>who else could you hold responsible? The contractor who underbid. If Roger's submits a bid for $1m to deliver 50k widgets he shouldn't be able to come back after the fact and demand $4m to complete the project because he underestimated his costs.
- natep 15y agoYou gave a very simple example. Lets say the contract is to build widgets that frobulate. What if nobody has ever made widgets that frobulate? What if frobulating is poorly defined in the process, and what it means to frobulate changes over the course of the project? What if the government later decides they want widgets that barbulate in addition/instead? The contractor has to swallow all the extra costs, because they were foolish enough to sign a vague/wrong contract? I'm not asking this to suggest a particular answer, just wondering where this strategy takes us.
- coenhyde 15y agoIf SpaceX can put the costs to launch a satellite into orbit on their website, then you'd think that enterprise software companies would be able to price their software ...... By the way SpaceX is my favourite company of all time. Elon Musk is living my 6 year old self's dream (actually my dream is still pretty similar, just haven't got their yet ;p )
- goatforce5 15y agoCan I get a 30 day free trial of one of their launch vehicles?
- StavrosK 15y agoYes, but you have to arrange for a call and watch a short spaceinar.
- stcredzero 15y agoI may have to name a villain in a video game "Spacinar."
- driverdan 15y agoThat was one of the first things I thought about too. Transparency helps everyone. If a space company can do it so can your SaaS company.
- protomyth 15y agoHeck, at this point I'd accept a particular enterprise software company shipping a one click update program instead of 10 pages of instructions and 720,621 lines of PL/SQL that I need to run against the Oracle database. // that is the exact line count from "wc -l" - I am not joking
- zschallz 15y agoBut then we couldn't charge you for training and consulting.
- alanbyrne 15y ago> "The total company expenditures since being founded in 2002 through the 2010 fiscal year were less than $800 million which includes all the development costs for the Falcon 1, Falcon 9 and Dragon." Wow. Facebook could have started an entire space program for less money than they spent on Instagram.
- rytis 15y agoSad, isn't it? Just shows where the priorities are these days...
- nickik 15y agoThe priorities where always the same, its all about ROI. It always has been.
- lolcraft 15y agoAnd they would've had bigger profits and a solid business model, as well!
- huggyface 15y agoThat really is a goosebump-inducing reframing of many recent valuations.
- dude_abides 15y agoThat reminds me of this classic tweet: Your mobile phone has more computing power than all of NASA in 1969. NASA launched a man to the moon. We launch a bird into pigs. Instagram or omgpop or space travel, its all about priorities.
- harrylove 15y agoThe status update, for reference: https://twitter.com/#!/svenningsen/status/144111724923076608 https://twitter.com/#!/svenningsen/status/144111724923076608
- nirvana 15y ago
- excuse-me 15y agoThere's nothing new in this - it has been done before. Want to build a Mach3 aircraft in the days when most people thought jets were pretty clever? Want to do it in <2years using materials that had never been used in a plane before - and do it on budget. And repeat the success with half a a dozen other projects. And it's described in a book that everyone in technology (or management) should read http://www.amazon.com/Skunk-Works-Personal-Memoir-Lockheed/dp/0316743003 http://www.amazon.com/Skunk-Works-Personal-Memoir-Lockheed/d...
- excuse-me 15y agore: the downvote. This wasn't an attack on space-X it was a celebration of them having continued the tradition of the frankly astonishing work that skunk works started. ps. it is a very good book
- spenrose 15y agoThe real cost of space flight is energy, specifically: 1) The huge amount of energy required to lift mass out of Earth's gravity well. 2) The vexing practical expense of obtaining that energy in useful form (e.g. rocket fuel) for launch. Rocketry's future will always be limited by those daunting constraints.
- api 15y agoFuel is at present an insignificant cost of launching a rocket. Of course, you could also say that the rocket itself has far more embodied energy than it carries in fuel.
- excuse-me 15y ago>Fuel is at present an insignificant cost of launching a rocket Fuel is almost ALL the cost of launching a rocket. If you can arrange for me to pick up fuel every vertical mile on the way up - I can get to orbit very cheaply!
- JabavuAdams 15y agoYeah, except for the rocket thingy.
- excuse-me 15y agoIf you don't need to achieve escape velocity in the thick lower atmosphere and accelerate all those 100,000lbs of fuel to 10km/s the rocket becomes pretty trivial
- JabavuAdams 15y agoI was replying to this: "Fuel is almost ALL the cost of launching a rocket." Also, how did your hardware get out of the thick lower atmosphere? Someone paid the cost of lofting that mass. Not much about rockets is trivial, except in theory. Practical issues: * heat dissipation: your fuel / oxidizer combo probably burns hotter than the nozzle material can tolerate. This needs to be tested (not for on orbit, for the first time) * fuel supply -- it's non-trivial to design tankage and feed systems that can supply fuel and oxidizer at the rate needed, in vacuum * propellant storage -- non-trivial unless you go for the really nasty "storable" propellants Pretty much every piece of the problem is non-trivial.
- wave 15y agoActual goal of Elon Musk is to send someone to Mars, but since seems far reaching goal for most people and since they might call him crazy, he is sticking with near space for now. Do not be surprise when he starts talking about Mars.
- nickpinkston 15y agoHe already does - check out his recent Daily Show interview: http://www.thedailyshow.com/full-episodes/tue-april-10-2012-elon-musk http://www.thedailyshow.com/full-episodes/tue-april-10-2012-...
- ballooney 15y agoHe talks about Mars quite publicly already and various of SPaceX's corporate videos contain CGI dragon capsules landing on mars. Also he's not 'sticking with near space for now' to avoid being called crazy as you imply, he's sticking to near-space now because you have to get that capability working and reliable so you can build on it for going further afield. It's not a smoke screen, it's all quite consistent with a road-map to mars.
- wolf550e 15y agoNo, he uses launching to LEO to make money to pay for a mission to Mars.
- kamaal 15y agosince they might call him crazy Trust me, success in these kind of projects is impossible unless you are crazy. In fact you have to be crazy to work on anything which others think is impossible.
- andys627 15y agoMan I wish this could be replicated in train construction - Florida is exploring this. One downside however, is you get what the private developer wants - so they're ending up with a train station at Orlando airport instead of downtown Orlando where it should be. Government is uniquely incentivised to do that right because they gain from increasing property values near where the train will go. Unfortunately local developers won't be so nice as to pony up more for that kind of thing even though they will reap disproportionate rewards. Another example - here in Reno, we're trying to build Bus Rapid Transit through a main corridor that is undergoing a pretty great revitalization. People in NV are especially not cool with traditional way for raising taxes for this kind of project (a la 1 cent sales tax just for BRT/streetcar). It begs to ask, if the developers nearby are going to gain so much, why aren't they building it themselves? Too many groups that won't take risk... I mean probably 1,000 people who own buildings there will benefit disproportionately... you are never going to get them together to pony up for a streetcar. But the proof is there... look at Portland for a US example... also Seattle and SF and San Diego. Its just easier to get the government to do it. They should put a local surcharge on property values. Its only fair. However, they will f- this project up I'm sure... just like NASA spent a kabillion extra dollars just to build certain parts in certain senator's home states... and my other local train is going to have a snack bar so the Sonoma County housewives that will never ride the train can get a snack; instead of more seats and bike space.
- btilly 15y agoIf you want to understand why it is hard to get many people who will benefit to pony up, read The Logic of Collective Action. Basically the problem is that it is a public good. If the good is provided, everyone benefits, not just the ones who paid. So unless your payment is going to make the difference between it happening or not happening, you don't want to pay. And even if someone gets you to pay, you'll be incentivized to pay as little as you can get away with.
- andys627 15y agoI'm not trying to understand it. I'm saying its not going to happen. Government is the only one that can do it, and they might even be able to do it equitably (in theory). The government should tax them because they are benefiting disproportionately more than the rest of the population. Yes, it is a public good. The public benefits. But if I own condos full of college students and they decide to build a train station for the train that goes to the college in front of it, I'm going to benefit more. And its not that many people - its property owners within a few blocks. We could figure something equitable out.
- noomerikal 15y agoOn a side note, could you pony up for a designer? I felt like I was perusing a README file for StarCraft.
- retube 15y agoI am surprised that a leavy-lifting rocket capable of achieving orbit only develops 4 times the thrust of a 747.
- mcguire 15y agoA Delta IV Medium's payload capacity is roughly 10,000lbs (to a geosynchronous transfer orbit). A 747's original design payload is more than 10x that. (Wikipedia claims a 747-8F's payload is about 150 tons.)
- mburshteyn 15y agoThis is why SpaceX is my favorite company.
- hashfold 15y agomine too.
- mukaiji 15y agoYou are a random billionaire (i.e. not Mark Zuckerberg) with a billion dollars. You could: A. Buy Instagram. B. Build SpaceX from scratch. Most of them would probably buy instagram. :(
- awj 15y agoWell ... yeah. I have a bit of experience buying things, but know nothing about creating and running companies that design and build rockets. I'd probably buy Instagram too since the rocket thing would die in my ineptitude.
- mukaiji 15y agowhat about Jeff Bezos (ok, he's EE [yay, EE!]), or Richard Brandson (or it's really Rutan's brainchild)? OK, Virgin Galatic is child-play next to SpaceX, but it still demonstrate that billionaires can invest in AA.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoTo be fair, it's not so simple. Elon Musk is an exceptional individual, he has a degree in Physics and he taught himself engineering and "rocket science". Not everyone is capable of replicating what he has done, regardless of the money involved. The average case of a billionaire dumping money into aerospace ends up with the billionaire having less billions and nothing much of consequence occurring in aerospace.
- ck2 15y agoI wonder how many decades until you can buy an earth-orbit ride giftcard at walmart.
- wtvanhest 15y agoIt will more likely be Amazon.
- workhorse 15y agoElon for president?
- cridal 15y agoNope... Born in South Africa...
- gaius 15y agoRemind me which continent Obama was born on?
- oijaf888 15y agoWhatever you consider Hawaii part of...why?
- gaius 15y agoIf a Kenyan can become POTUS, why not a Saffrican?
- ef4 15y agoBecause the actual law as written excludes someone not born in America from becoming president. Obama was born in Hawaii, so he passes. Musk was born in South Africa, so he doesn't. It would take a constitutional amendment to change the law. Highly unlikely.
- hashfold 15y agou r racist. a capable person will take country higher. be positive!
- ef4 15y agoYou're missing the point. It's actually written into the American Constitution that the president must be born in America. I don't think the above comment had anything to do with his capabilities. Merely the practical difficulty in becoming president. (It would require a constitutional amendment.)
- cridal 15y agoIs this guy the Richard Branson of XXI century? Barely in his 40s and: Paypal Tesla SpaceX You've got to be in owe...
- chrismealy 15y agoFor the first time in more than three decades, America last year began taking back international market-share in commercial satellite launch. This remarkable turn-around was sparked by a small investment NASA made in SpaceX in 2006 as part of the Commercial Orbital Transportation Services (COTS) program. A unique public-private partnership, COTS has proven that under the right conditions, a properly incentivized contractor — even an all-American one — can develop extremely complex systems on rapid timelines and a fixed-price basis, significantly beating historical industry-standard costs.
- drewblaisdell 15y agoIs it fair to say that NASA would likely require many times the amount of funding for the same result as SpaceX? I ask because as someone who was previously unfamiliar with the amount of funding SpaceX had to work with, $800 million sounds like an incredibly small amount of money to do (what looks like) more than NASA does with its ~$18 billion budget.
- cowkingdeluxe 15y agoGood point, and that $800 million was prorated over 4 years whereas NASA gets $18 billion annually.
- mitchty 15y agoNASA also has fair amount more research going on unrelated to "build rockets" as well so direct numerical comparison isn't exactly valid.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- damoncali 15y agoNASA does a lot more than launch people in capsules. It's not fair to compare spaceX to all of NASA. SpaceX has no Hubble, no ISS, no Mars antything, etc, etc. They seem to be doing well, but let's compare apples to apples.
- jacoblyles 15y agoKeep in mind that is $800 million over 8 years. So the Space X budget is about 0.6% of NASA's.
- JeffBlauser 15y agoNot that there couldn't be inefficiencies at nasa, but they have many other programs going on which account for its budget.
- tlogan 15y agoI hope that young entrepreneur will follow more steps of Elon Musk and instead of pursuing fast money start pursuing big dreams. Actually I think that is already happening...
- gsmaverick 15y agoExcept you can't start a space company without a lot of your own money much like Musk did. You need the big capital first to launch a company that requires hundreds of millions in capital.
- tlogan 15y agoI'm sorry I was not 100% clear. With term "entrepreneur" I mean to include only people who already made it and prove to society they are entrepreneurs - i.e., they already sold the first company and have $$ and name. So my point is that instead raising money to build path.com, color.com, or some other stupid web 2.0, young entrepreneurs should follow Musk steps.
- gvb 15y agoElon Musk started with fast money (PayPal) and is now using that to pursue big dreams. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk
- tlogan 15y agoI'm sorry I was not 100% clear. With term "entrepreneur" I mean to include only people who already made it and prove to society they are entrepreneurs - i.e., they already sold the first company and have $$ and name. So my point is that instead raising money to build path.com, color.com, or some other stupid web 2.0, young entrepreneurs should follow Musk steps.
- developer9 15y agoThe reason China can't beat us is that they don't yet have the resources. If anything, this post will just make them want to beat us faster. But, hats off to SpaceX! We need more space entrepreneurs to produce technological innovation and rid us of government cruft.
- DanI-S 15y ago> This is a clear case of American innovation trumping lower overseas labor rates. As much as I admire Elon Musk, this is a short-sighted, exceptionalist dogma. It may apply in some cases - for the time being - but do people really think that non-Americans are incapable of innovation? SpaceX have had a headstart, since NASA and their gigantic budget have decided to take advantage of free enterprise. It's only a matter of time before Asian and European governments begin to do the same.
- gaius 15y agoYou've not met many European governments, have you? In England Elon'd still be waiting planning permission from his local council to build a launch site...
- excuse-me 15y agoIt's also the right time politically Sea Launch was an even more innovative entrepreneurial commercial launcher. However the USA first stopped it docking in US ports to receive a payload because it was a foreign missile system and then stopped payloads being loaded in a foreign port because that would be exporting sensitive technology. I'm guessing that Lockheed Martin and Boeing have less political clout in Texas today than they did in California 10 years ago
- hef19898 15y agoNot counting for the political discussion after some ethical experts told publicly it's dangerous and wont work. He would have been trapped in PR nightmare and have burned at least his intial 100M$ just on lobbing to find a launch site. Sometimes I love th US! (No irony in it)
- jacoblyles 15y agoIn France, a Presidential candidate who advocates a 100% income tax on incomes over $300,000 is polling at 16% of the vote. Europe doesn't like Elon Musks. It's inequal :(
- ph0rque 15y agoSeeing how Elon Musk did not start out as American, I believe all his pro-USA rhetoric in this speech is designed to sway or convince some government people, just not sure to what end.
- pgroves 15y agoThis is how a CEO gets engineers to want to work for his company.
- MPSimmons 15y agoBy working on impossibly cool goals for the betterment of humanity? Yes.
- rorrr 15y agoI hope Elon Musk gets all the "man of the year" awards. The man is brilliant, and there's so much resistance to what he's doing, it's insane.
- beernutz 15y agoWow, and that post from Elon is over a year OLD! Wonder where things lie currently?
- brainless 15y agoThis is disruption in true sense. Hope others follow the footsteps.
- rrrazdan 15y agohttp://www.astronautix.com/lvs/gslv.htm http://www.astronautix.com/lvs/gslv.htm India's comparable GSLV has a programme cost of 800 million dollars and a launch cost of around 90 million dollars. Given the relatively less development costs in India. I'd have to say very impressive SpaceX.
- rdl 15y agoThis is a good reason to the sarbanes oxley. If SpaceX had IPO'd already, more end cheaper capital might have helped, and buying spacex stock would the best thing I can do personally for space for a while.
- olalonde 15y ago> China has the fastest growing economy in the world. But the American free enterprise system, which allows anyone with a better mouse-trap to compete, is what will ensure that the United States remains the world’s greatest superpower of innovation. China is also moving pretty fast towards a free enterprise system while the United States is moving in the opposite direction at approximately the same speed. Well at least, having lived both in America and China, that's my impression.
- jeffool 15y agoIs it dumb of me to ask "so why isn't NASA working on terraforming bodies yet?" It seems inevitable, and like we may as well start spitballing now. Send a few rooms that attach to the surface and dig in, practice in there remotely.