6 ms·
Psychologists say they can't meet the growing demand for mental health care
- ThalesX 3y agoI have three personal data points that I want to put out here for the world: 1 - I am passionate about philosophy and human psychology. I have yet found a psychologist with whom I can talk to about the various topics I am interested in. The younger ones are just shells of knowledge in the fields to the point where I am shocked they got degrees. I had a great relationship with an older therapist but unfortunately she retired. 2 - A relative is a certified psychotherapist. The amount of misinformation she subscribes to only reinforces my views that most are not to be trusted. Zero interest in debunking failed classical 'experiments'. Judgemental character, prescription instead of understanding etc. 3 - I've seen psychologists ruin a close to me person's life by validating all their strange fantasies. With these data points, I no longer trust this profession and would rather appeal to a priest if I ever feel the need to feel myself heard.
- staticman2 3y agoFor #3- I wonder if your friend was looking for a psychologist that would validate their fantasies? There are some psychologists that believe in supernatural ideas like hypnosis enabling recovery of memories from past lives-- but you are extremely unlikely to run into them unless you specifically look for one.
- ThalesX 3y agoFrom what I understood of the situation, it was less esoteric and more of a your perspective is what matters, there's no such thing as objective reality. This lead to some extreme life changes in a very short period of time and after that it was spending a lot of money on therapy for validation of whatever extreme life choices happened to be next in the pipeline.
- jstarfish 3y ago> your perspective is what matters This is everything that is wrong with this institution in a nutshell. If one is--literally--mentally unwell (ill), their perspective is flawed by definition. The industry has found that humoring flawed perspectives drives repeat business, like me selling a drowning man a glass of water. You can't say I'm not helping him, but I am deliberately not giving him the help he needs.
- dmreedy 3y agoConsider for a moment a world in which not every mind is as self-possessed and self-assured as yours. Consider further a world in which there are many minds for whom sensitivity to being wrong is such a high priority, as you seem to want it to be, that they may try and avoid formulating stances or taking positions at all. Lest they be wrong. Sometimes it can be helpful to have someone explain to you how you have to have some confidence in your own capacity for intuition, your own ability make decisions, in order to make anything happen. I certainly won't argue that there are probably a lot of ineffective practitioners out there, but to me that speaks to the difficulty of the task, of tuning between insecurity and confidence and arrogance. It doesn't suggest to me the task, or the institution that is still in its earliest years of trying to formally study it, is fundamentally flawed.
- jstarfish 3y ago> Consider further a world in which there are many minds for whom sensitivity to being wrong is such a high priority, as you seem to want it to be, that they may try and avoid formulating stances or taking positions at all. Lest they be wrong. [...] Sometimes it can be helpful to have someone explain to you how you have to have some confidence in your own capacity for intuition, your own ability make decisions, in order to make anything happen. We all live in that world. These hypothetical individuals sound like people in desperate need of direction, not self-reflection. People don't go to therapists because everything's great and they're thinking clearly; therapists have a naturally-exploitable customer base. Left to their own devices, these wayward souls tend to end up radicalized in some way. Your suggested approach sounds an awful lot like the outcome of grooming-- "I didn't tell you to do that. You wanted to do it." Make anyone spend enough time miring in their own confused thoughts and they'll start to normalize and rationalize whatever it is. No wonder we have so many gender-confused kids running around; they're exposed to the topic constantly. If that's what therapy amounts to, we can call off the labor shortage, because any accomplished child molester has the qualifications to do this job...I'm sure they need the work. For some reason, doctors have little problem proscribing direct advice to ailing patients-- "you're dying because you won't stop eating cheesecake and smoking meth." Why are therapists so resistant to telling clients they're unlikable assholes and they need to fix their shit? Why the "need" for florid introspection that distracts from obvious problems, unless it's an intelligence-gathering exercise, looking for something else to blame or ideate? No other professional service works like this except fortune-tellers and the church (through confessionals) and their track record is about as effective. My mechanic doesn't wax poetic about thermodynamics, ask about the journeys I've been on with the vehicle and blame the engineers when my car doesn't start. > It doesn't suggest to me the task, or the institution that is still in its earliest years of trying to formally study it, is fundamentally flawed. My point remains: perceptions are subjective, are easily manipulated, and are frequently wrong. Eyewitness testimony is incorrect 50-fucking-percent of the time. This institution has already had scandals involving "discovery" of false memories and other manipulations of both its own personnel and the public. I've even had one insist I was molested despite no such attestations on my part (and it not being true). Psychiatrists have vouched for the perceived rehabilitation of rapists and murderers up for parole, who then immediately proceeded to rape and kill again within hours of release. There are other peculiarities too, like insistence that hypersexuality is exclusively an artifact of abuse (and not at all precocious/excessive access to pornography), while sex addiction is not recognized at all in the DSM-V-- yet they'll offer to treat you for something they say doesn't exist. They like to tout the idea of all this domestic and sexual abuse going on based on what patients report, but it's not like they conduct any actual investigation-- they'll believe anything you tell them at face value (it's how Sybil got away with it for so long). On that note, they've managed to legitimize what we used to call demonic possession as multiple/disassociative personality disorder. Here's an open challenge: prove it. So far, the highest-profile cases they've put forth have all been frauds, and it's so easy to act out the symptoms of that there are entire subreddits and hashtags dedicated to overprivileged children LARPing it. Why it's even still in the book, I cannot fathom. It is junk science. They have some neat ideas about behavioral classification and CBT is as useful for humans as it is for dogs, but that's about it.
- I_Am_Nous 3y agoThis is a field where the patient has to trust the psychologist implicitly for it to "work properly" and unfortunately there are a lot of ways that trust can be abused, maliciously or otherwise. Regarding point #3, I have no doubt that this happens and would probably fall on the accidental abuse spectrum, where the psychologist thought they were helping free the person when it really just made them more chained inside their own lusts.
- talldatethrow 3y agoEverytime I hear of a couple having serious issues and considering therapy, I always recommend they talk to a priest instead. Ive been doing this for almost 10 years. Basically all that rejected the idea broke up, divorced, or are are still more miserable than ever. The one couple I know that talked to several priests in the end, is happier than ever. Small sample size but it makes sense to me. Priests study people and have experience bonding people. Therapists seem to have experience separating people.
- hotpotamus 3y agoAny particular denomination?
- mschuster91 3y agoIMHO, those of Lutheran Protestant belief - at least here in Germany the Lutherans are just about the most welcoming people you can get. Catholic ones push far too much anti-contraceptive, anti-LGBT, "marriage is sacrosanct" and other questionable stuff, and Evangelical/Amish/Pentecostal/Mormons tend to be even more nuts than the Catholics (we have everything but the Amish here as well).
- talldatethrow 3y agoWhat is "questionable" about what Catholics push. I'm a western degenerate basically, but even I understand why they say what they say. For example, while I might enjoy casual sex, I get that if I followed what's best for me, I really would abstain from having sex outside of marriage. And even in marriage, sex would hold more meaning and be even more bonding if there was a chance of a child being born. If that means I'd have a lot less sex, so be it, I still think that would be best. I could explain lgbt issues also from their angle, but that would just upset HN. What you call questionable, is just as questionable from their side towards your views. What do you think is more questionable.. waiting til you find someone very important to you, who promises to join you for life, before you have sex... Or a sorority girl having sex with two dudes at the same time at 19 yrs old because one made her laugh a lot and his roommate is really good looking. (I was the funny one in this story 20 years ago)
- JoeyJoJoJr 3y agoI’ve gotten the impression that a new crop of psychologists has appeared in the last 10-15 years that almost encourages damaged people to go online, discover labels like “narcissist”, then categorise the people that have hurt them. The psychologist might not say it, but they will nod agreeably when you “come to the realisation” that one or both or your parents are “narcissists”. Whether or not that is actually true, there is a massive incentive for the psychologist’s business for you to blame your parents.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lepus 3y agoFor-profit diploma mills are taking full advantage of the situation, but unfortunately the education and training they provide is lackluster in comparison to the demands of the job, adding to the burnout rate.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 3y ago> the demands of the job And it seems like this would be exacerbated by there being fewer doctors to pick up the slack.
- exabrial 3y agoIt's pretty easy: allow prices to rise a bit and people will enter the field. I think existing ones wouldn't mind a raise considering some of the stuff they have to deal with
- trevoristall 3y agoit's already prohibitively expensive for most people since most insurance doesn't cover it. Doesn't really seem like a solution. Edit: in the US. Can't speak for other nations.
- nradov 3y agoDue to the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act of 2008, most insurance does cover it. Depending on the patient's particular conditions there may be limits on the type of care and number of sessions. In many areas there are also practical access problems due to a shortage of network providers who are currently accepting new patients. https://www.psychiatry.org/psychiatrists/advocacy/federal-affairs/health-insurance-coverage-access-to-care/mental-health-parity https://www.psychiatry.org/psychiatrists/advocacy/federal-af...
- taurath 3y agoThere’s a shortage of network providers because the network tends to pay peanuts, they mandate the usage of only a few treatment methods that may not be effective for the client, and make actually getting reimbursed a massive administrative headache (think many hours a week writing billing appeals instead of seeing clients). Medicaid is even worse and pays bottom of the barrel. The restrictions and complications that come with insurance repayment have lead a huge amount of providers to not bill the medical system, for simple personal economic reasons - they can’t afford to feed and house themselves if they have to deal with the lower rates and overhead of dealing with insurance.
- plagiarist 3y agoIf it is covered, can people afford to pay their deductibles and coinsurance every year if they take advantage? Or is it more like "covered?"
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoI wonder how much of the therapeutic benefit from psychologists is actually just having an empathetic listener as you “rubber ducky” debug yourself. Along the same lines, I wonder if the reliance on psychologists is a symptom or our increasing isolation. Whereas in the past, people would have gone to a priest, rabbi, older relative, family friend, they now go to a psychologist.
- Etheryte 3y agoFor most cases the answer is pretty much none of it. Expecting someone with depression to just rubber duck themselves out of it is like hoping for a car crash survivor to perform surgery on themselves. Sure, there are some fringe cases where it might occur, but by and large this simply doesn't happen.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoSomebody with deep depression should probably be seeing a psychiatrist (medical doctor) and receive medical therapy instead of seeing a psychologist.
- blueridge 3y agoI know this is an unpopular opinion but I think psychology as a profession is a scam. I wish more people would read 19th century literature. It is wonderful therapy and offers endless examples of how to confront the difficulties of the human experience.
- _aavaa_ 3y agoI’ll echo what’s I’ve heard argued before, and I find convincing. Lack psychologists is not the cause of an increase in mental health problems any more than lack of doctors are the cause for an increase in broken bones. Focusing on training more of them is to focus on the easy to medicate symptoms rather than the complex and varied root causes.
- Spivak 3y agoLack of psychologists is the cause of increasing untreated medical health problems in the exact way a lack of doctors leads to an increase in untreated illness. And given how many older adults have untreated mental health issues and just lived with them the work won't be wasted on a fly-by-night increase.
- _aavaa_ 3y agoI completely agree with you. My point was that the discussion is often framed such that lack of psychologists is causing a mental health crisis. Their shortage may be making it worse since people cannot be treater after they have issues, but it isn't causing the issue in the first place.
- hackeraccount 3y agoIf you paid "broken bone fixing doctors" more money would you get an increase in broken bones? I tend to think you would - though it'd probably come in the form of a definition change of just what a broken bone is.
- taurath 3y agoThere’s a few big factors here - one is the amount that insurance will cover is extremely low - experienced psychologists won’t make more than $130 a session on most insurance, regardless of speciality or niche expertise. Medicaid is worse - the reimbursement rate is like $70-80 a session (not enough to cover CoL and expenses), AND if you want to bill Medicaid they make you jump through a huge amount of hoops and force you to take on more Medicaid clients. This makes for a situation where those most in need of therapy or counseling are only afforded providers who either work practically for charity, or only the most recent graduates with very little experience - that’s if they can find someone in their area, which is next to impossible given almost no therapist can afford to charge rates so low. Another problem is the insistence from insurers on only the most “evidence-based” treatment modalities. Everyone taking insurance has to play a dance with them to somehow shoehorn in the use of these or else get denied payment for months. As a result diagnoses and treatment methods that get put into the system are only those approved by the insurer - resulting in a dance that leaves a ton of actually useful individual treatments from being recognized. If it doesn’t bill, it can’t be mentioned, even if it’s working. This can also lead to pretty bad outcomes for clients. The medical model of treatment is preferred by insurance because it’s the cheapest and quickest to tamp down symptoms but rarely gets to the root cause, especially in the most traumatized populations. Take a homeless person and put them in treatment - they’re probably neurodivergent, traumatized, high ACE score. Making surface symptoms like substance use go into remission doesn’t treat the underlying cause of the substance use. Lastly, psychologists and therapists can’t make up for the lack of integrated community, sense of belonging and social purpose, and relational support networks that are failing all across society. We are an individualistic society that downplays the value of relational ties, which is part of the reason there is such a need for individual therapy in the first place. Relational trauma, lack of community resources, lack of time to spend with others, lack of social cohesion overall all contribute to a mental health crisis that is intricately tied with the excesses and stunted values of our socioeconomic system. It is an intentional feature, not a bug that people are suffering with little to no recourse. More money will help, more education and spreading of concepts and ideas will help, but as a society there is a massive amount of work to undertake to slow the engine that produces the social pollution that ends with mass depression, anxiety and worse. It is long overdue.
- 3y ago
- legitster 3y agoMy friend who is studying to be a counselor put it to me this way: counsellors are usually ethically bound against giving strong interventions! If you go to a counsellor and say "I'm feeling upset because my wife is yelling at me for cheating on her but I really want to keep cheating on her", an average counsellor can't say "well stop cheating on her, you numbskull" even if they know that's the best answer. Professional ethics dictates that they be neutral. So all they can really do is sit there and ask you questions about your feelings. The things that increase people's mental well-being are well researched and often obvious: lose weight, find a church, get a girlfriend, make more money, call your mom, join the Army. Things that a professional counsellor could never tell you to do! Not to say therapy is not a good idea for lots of people! But the modern need for therapy is not coming from some place of deep and widespread trauma. If anything, the opposite - we all live very comfortable lives full of emotional bed rest and mental junk food.
- Gud 3y agoUhm, why would they be ethically bound to not tell me this? If I am going to a third party to adjust my behavior, I don’t want someone who is just going to validate my feelings. I want actionable advice.
- legitster 3y agoBecause no insurance company is going to pay for someone to tell you that you'd probably be happier if you had more kids. Lol. So the entire industry has adopted a professional ethics code that is extremely edited. > If I am going to a third party to adjust my behavior, I don’t want someone who is just going to validate my feelings. I want actionable advice. I'm with you, but if you polled the average person looking for a therapist we are almost certainly in the minority.
- SuperNinKenDo 3y agoWell, imagine a world where counsellors could use their position with a constant roster of vulnerable people to, for instance, tell them to go to church. It's definitely potentially problematic. So psychologists have in some way developed an idea that their role is to facillitate people's mental well-being within whichever lifestyle they lead. This can be very effective for some things. For instance CBT can help you rewire your brain to work more the way you want. If you come to a counselor and say "I have anxiety with public speaking and want to get rid of it" then they have some tools that can help. But on more fundamental issues like "I live in a sick society", these tools can help you get through your day, maybe, but the actual remedy is more fundamental. This is why people need serious Liberal Arts and Humanities, but we as a society scoff at that more and more. Wonder if that has anything to do with our abject misery, hmmm.
- aantix 3y agoI developed a GPT-based virtual therapist, for myself. It utilizes the new GPTs functionality. It's meant to help with processing and coming to peace with past events. https://chat.openai.com/g/g-i283Q1fZr-bringing-peace-to-troubled-emotions https://chat.openai.com/g/g-i283Q1fZr-bringing-peace-to-trou... I wonder if AI will eventually fill this gap?
- xnx 3y agoThere are certainly at least a dozen ChatGPT wrappers/prompts/GPTs attempting to fill this gap, right? I'm not being totally cynically, I think a well-tuned AI therapist could play a role.