12 ms·
Why does sleep become more elusive as we age?
- mg 3y agoMaybe because of less physical activity? Since 2020 I have manually tracked 35093 data points about my life [1]. And the one parameter that correlates most with my sleep time is how many steps I took during the day. The median number of steps I take during a day is about 9500. When I look at the sleep time of the following night, on average I slept an additional 9 minutes after a day with 9500 steps or more compared to a day with less than 9500 steps. The gap increases to 16 minutes when I look at nights where I walked over 12000 steps in the previous day. To see if that is just correlation or if there is causation at play, I also started to decide to take an additional walk or not by coin flip. So far, I did that 31 times. 16 times the coin decided to take a walk, 21 times it decided not to. On average, I slept 13 minutes longer after the coin decided that I take an additional walk. 31 is a very small N of course. I hope to have a larger sample by the end of next year. 1: https://www.gibney.org/a_syntax_for_self-tracking https://www.gibney.org/a_syntax_for_self-tracking
- contingencies 3y agoMakes sense. Also, while overfed idle wealthy people faceplant in CPAP machines, older people in traditional cultures with healthy physical activity and consumption levels continue to live long regardless. For example, the Hunza. Experimental results suggest this is because of both their activity levels and a reduced caloric intake of a low protein, plant based diet high in complex carbohydrates. But what would a continuous culture of longevity know?
- twelve40 3y agoI've never heard of the Hunza and kind of suspected that these "older people in traditional cultures" sounds too good to be true, and sure enough: > A widely repeated claim of remarkable longevity of the Hunza people has been refuted as a longevity myth, citing a life expectancy of 53 years for men and 52 for women, although with a high standard deviation.
- xcv123 3y agoThat statistic could be skewed by a high childhood mortality rate.
- contingencies 3y agoLike all modern claims, there's probably a kernel of truth. The "standard deviation" probably masks it. As with the whole world, one doesn't doubt the current population has succumbed to modernity. Similar health can be observed in physically active people with conservative consumption levels globally.
- twelve40 3y agoI'm not really sure what "succumbed to modernity" means in this context. World life expectancy went from 46 years in 1950 to 72.63 in 2020 to 73.16 in 2023. Is that the right metric to look at? If it is, succumbing to modernity doesn't sound too terrible.
- wkat4242 3y agoIsn't that figure from 1950 also impacted by the fact they just had a major war killing millions of young people prematurely? After all this calculation is done over a longer term than 1 year as far as I know.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoWorth noting that the only source for that excerpt from Wikipedia, for the life expectancy, is some NYT article written by a journalist in 1996 which is now paywalled.
- toolz 3y ago> older people in traditional cultures with healthy physical activity and consumption levels continue to live long regardless I agree with the point on physical activity, but the implication that traditional cultures have as long or longer lifespans is easily dismissed as inaccurate.
- coldtea 3y agoCan it, if we exclude child mortality (and effects of war, resource stealing, etc)? All so-called "blue zones" are in traditional cultures (food and general lifestyle wise).
- toolz 3y agoWhy would we exclude child mortality? It isn't clear to me that isn't an indirect product of culture any more that any other longevity indicator. Blue zones seems somewhat ambiguous but if I'm understanding correctly, they are small areas of people who live more traditionally surrounded by mostly modern people? Seems like by definition those zones are made up of cherry picked people and it's unclear to me that those aren't just outliers.
- Rewrap3643 3y agoSleep apnea is not exclusively a lifestyle disorder. I have it with a BMI of under 21.
- locallost 3y agoPhysical activity definitely makes a difference, but in my experience it will never cause me to sleep like my kids. That ship has sailed. I was very active last year, and had many days of 30k steps, sometimes although rarely 40k steps and I can't say I ever experienced falling a sleep and sleeping 8h rock solid. Maybe once. edit: just checked, I did a 120km bike ride this year and the next night I slept for around 6h.
- bad_username 3y ago> I did a 120km bike ride this year and the next night I slept for around 6h. Intensive or prolonged exercise (especially close to bedtime) can actually interfere with sleep. I never sleep very well the night after 10k runs or 60km+ rides. There is a sweet spot (for sleep quality) between zero exercise and too much exercise.
- anonuser123456 3y agoLong bouts of cardio nearly always interfere with my sleep. But I don’t think that’s abnormal; the body should be raising cortisol in response to energy demands. Try weight training in the morning. I’m someone that doesn’t usually nap… but after starting weight training I find myself needing a nap in the afternoon, and it is much easier to fall asleep.
- InSteady 3y agoMy anecdotal experience agrees with this. Long/intense cardio doesn't improve my sleep but weight training seems to. Occasionally I have to struggle to stay awake to keep my schedule, which is marvelous compared to struggling to fall asleep!
- locallost 3y agoI do early morning weight training two to three times a week. When I get a good workout I noticed the sleepiness in the afternoon too, but I still do not sleep like my kids. To be clear, I don't have insomnia or a very difficult sleep, but the article is in general about sleeping less as you age. Leading a healthy lifestyle will definitely help get a better sleep, but now being around 40 years old, I just don't sleep like when I was a child, teenager or even in my late twenties. I don't need an alarm anymore for instance, I'll just wake up at 6am 6:30 no matter what I do.
- beardyw 3y agoYes, I find I sleep better after some proper exercise during the day. But when I was working I worked from home every work day, with only a tour round the block at lunchtime. I did much less exercise but slept like a baby. Not so now.
- anonporridge 3y agoSleep quality would be a better metric than duration. HRV is generally the metric used. You can measure that with a cheap chest monitor, or get a fitness watch that tracks it continuously throughout the day and night. Good HRV levels are highly correlated to activity level, so your base hypothesis still makes sense.
- mg 3y agoGood point. Is there a standardized way to measure sleep quality? Or are the numbers one measures only compareable as long as one uses the same device? I would be interested in suggestions which watches measure the HRV / Sleep quality reliably and display the data on screen. Or let me get it from a Linux laptop. I hate having to install an app to get the info off the watch.
- anonporridge 3y agoMy understanding is that different devices measure HRV with different techniques, so they're not necessarily comparable. I've heard Apple Watch is especially bad at measuring HRV, while Garmin and Whoop are good. One performance and health coach I follow recommends the Polar H10 chest strap to take a measurement every morning. https://twitter.com/Alan_Couzens/status/1723334537235607989 https://twitter.com/Alan_Couzens/status/1723334537235607989 https://twitter.com/Alan_Couzens/status/1473672665541984259 https://twitter.com/Alan_Couzens/status/1473672665541984259 There's also not an absolute number or threshold that's good or bad. Generally higher is better, but what really matters are the fluctuations from a personalized baseline.
- mg 3y agoIs "take a measurement every morning" about sleep quality or about something else? Is it even possible to sleep with the H10 strap?
- nradov 3y agoTaking a measurement at the same time every morning helps to establish a consistent baseline so that you can detect changes from day to day. But the latest generation of smart watches can track HRV continuously throughout the day, so if you have one of those then taking specific measurements is less useful.
- travisjungroth 3y agoWhat’s the full sleep data, or at least the variance? 31 may be large enough. And if it’s not, getting more by the end of the year may not make a big difference. Power only increases at the square root of the sample size.
- mg 3y agoEnd of next year. So in theory I could 10x the number of data points. But its one of the more annoying experiments to let a coin decide if you have to take another walk :) So I'm not sure how often I will do that. I'm pretty convinced already that walking more is a good thing. I'm in a hurry right now, but I will probably write a full blog post about the steps-sleep relationship with p values and everything some time next year.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoMy sleep pattern changed when I had a kid and remained that way. I always needed 7 hours of sleep to feel good and productive, but after the baby, I've found myself being equally productive with 5-5.5hrs of sleep.
- seper8 3y agoNah, you have just gotten used to being lower functioning. Like an alcoholic who still thinks he can drive equally well after 5 beers. At least, almost all of the existing science points into this direction. You aren't sleeping less because you need less. You have lost the ability to stay asleep for a healthy amount of time.
- bcrosby95 3y agoJust to add onto this with an anecdote, I experienced this phenomena for a smaller amount of sleep: 1-3 hours per night. But I had other physical effects such as a persistent headache - it was obvious it was bad for me. It took a lot of effort to reset my body to obtain a more healthy amount of sleep. I think I went about a month with 1-3 hours per night. The initial cause was "sleep regression in twins", but that was only for 2 weeks. The next 2 weeks was how long it took me to get my body to sleep more than a couple hours per night.
- tstrimple 3y agoWhile this is likely true, there are differences in the amount of time folks need to sleep in order to recover. There is a gene that is found to be associated with these short sleepers as well. Activating the gene in mice demonstrates a similar reduction in natural sleep cycles with no apparent impact on health. https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/gene-identified-people-who-need-little-sleep https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/gene-id...
- wharvle 3y agoNb to observers considering having kids but worried about this, unless you’re badly space-constrained it’s pretty easy to keep sleep for both adults north of 6.5hrs a night, and to have catch-up nights for both on the weekend (9+ hours). Plus the period in which night feedings are necessary, rather than habit, is only 2.5-3 months anyway. It’s mostly a fairly simple scheduling problem, plus having one adult sleeping somewhere they can’t hear the baby during each “shift” (loud fans help). Not having to jump instantly on the crying baby also lets you slooowwwly stretch your response times longer, which is a nice smooth way work toward the glorious 1-feeding-per-night and finally no-night-feedings period (babies wake up and cry even when not hungry—past the earliest weeks, immediate feeding may not be necessary, and if you can wait a minute they may go back to sleep, because they weren’t hungry, they’d just woken up and briefly freaked out—if you keep pouncing every time as soon as they make a noise, it trains them to stay awake rather than going back to sleep, and you’ll have a bad time for, potentially, much longer) All bets off if you have a kid who’s ill, but for most babies, it’s entirely achievable.
- squidbeak 3y agoFancy, but I'm much more inclined to believe the causes are simpler. Steadily increasing aches and pains, worry about mortality, worry about younger relatives, multiplication of regrets, or this side of retirement, the sheer stress of modern life, which seems to wear more heavily when there's less time to bounce back, substance abuse maybe.
- mongol 3y agoYeah, the burdens of adulthood, a more complex life with more responsibilities, and so on
- iJohnDoe 3y agoGood summary. Oh, to be young again and when you can fall asleep without a busy mind keeping you awake.
- ideamotor 3y agoJeez, at what age was this true for you? Before puberty, surely. I think folks are mythologizing their past a tad bit here.
- jwells89 3y agoCan’t speak for others, by my teenage years were pretty worry-free. That may not have been the norm though because I spent most of my free time on my computer, pouring many hours into Photoshop, WoW, and tinkering with code rather than worrying about classmate drama or getting into trouble. Back then, I was practically always dead asleep within minutes of my head hitting the pillow and a snooze was always within easy reach no matter when I tried (wasn’t uncommon to have a 1-2 hour nap after coming home from school). Flash forward 16 years to today and getting to sleep isn’t too much of a problem but it’s much more common to have trouble with getting my head stopped long enough to drift off, especially nights when I don’t make a point of doing almost nothing for 2-3 hours prior to wind down.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoPerhaps but I think like the rest of the body the brain experiences dysfunction as well, which almost certainly impacts sleep as a fundamental function of the brain.
- seviu 3y agoFunnily enough when I was much younger I developed amnesia. It was devastating in many levels. Lost friendships, it impacted my long term memory, my concentration. I could go several nights without sleep no matter what I did. My mind would wander, I would worry about things, it was a nightmare. Eventually I had to relearn how to fall asleep. I am now much older and I won’t say my sleep is perfect, but I can easily fall asleep within minutes. I had to rewire myself to empty my mind of every external real life related thought. What works for me is to build an imaginary world and dive into it. Eventually that world disappears and I fall asleep. I know there are other techniques but this works for me.
- asdfologist 3y agoAmnesia? Or did you mean insomnia?
- rented_mule 3y agoI'm not who you're responding to, so I don't know what they intended. But sleep issues can certainly lead to memory issues. So, maybe both? When I was in my mid 30s, I suddenly had extreme memory issues. For example, at dinner time, I had no memory of what I ate for lunch or even if I had lunch at all. I could remember people that I knew, but I could not remember if I talked with them earlier in the day. It was all very scary. After various neurological tests showed nothing unusual, my doctor thought we should look into sleep issues. It turned out I suffer from something called Delayed Sleep Phase Syndrome - whereas the average person has a natural bedtime that is ~24 hours after they last went to sleep, mine was significantly longer than 24 hours. My doctor concluded that this was the source of my memory issues. That confused me a bit, as I experienced trouble sleeping my entire life prior to this diagnosis. She explained that the consequences of inadequate sleep worsen as we age. It was inconvenient for work and social things, but I was able to start living longer days (i.e., don't go to bed until I'm sleepy). Within a week, the recall issues I'd had were a memory (see what I did there?). I was also able to fall asleep much more quickly than I had before, and sleep duration didn't have the wild swings I'd experienced all my life.
- mock-possum 3y ago
- Projectiboga 3y agoBody produced Melatonin levels go down throughout adulthood.
- cracrecry 3y agoDoes it? I firmly believe that most problems people have with sleep also depend on modern "way of living", that is highly Artificial. For example, lots of people have Apnea, and Apnea is highly correlated with being obese, and being obese is normal in the Western world, but it was not 100 years ago. So it is not about being older but about being overweight, something that depends on eating healthy and exercising, that most people do not do. Another important factor is artificial lighting, again a 100 years old thing, people that have used candles know how dim they are, and people using screens in the bedroom until late, specially social media. Social Media is addictive, but you don't need to use it, people can stop using it, but they just don't want to. Also living in the city is noisy, expensive and stressful. Most people are worried about lots of things, and that makes them sleep badly.
- letmevoteplease 3y agoAlso alarm clocks, caffeine, unnatural sleep schedules. This site[1] has lots of good information, with this basic (unfortunately impossible for many) recommendation: "There is only one formula for healthy and refreshing sleep: Go to sleep only when you are very tired. Not earlier. Not later. Wake up naturally without an alarm clock." [1] https://supermemo.guru/wiki/Science_of_sleep https://supermemo.guru/wiki/Science_of_sleep
- EA-3167 3y agoUnfortunately for me that would entail staying up until 3AM and waking up at 11AM. That might work for me, but it doesn't work for my professional or social life.
- hermanradtke 3y agoIt is worse. The sleep formula article says free sleep often involves 24 hour sleep sessions, which is practically impossible for most people.
- sen 3y agoYeah I had a period before I had kids and when I worked for myself where I could sleep whenever I wanted. I’d get tired around 3-4am, go to sleep about 5am, wake up around 12-1pm, and felt great every day. The most energy, motivation, and general good moods I’ve had in my life. Then kids + career = 10pm-5am sleep schedule and pretty much feel tired (struggling-to-function tired) 24/7.
- hindsightbias 3y agoThis may be obvious to most, but if you can’t sleep and your mind is empty, you probably have something bio going on. If you can’t sleep and you have ten things you’re worrying about then it’s probably more psychological and you might have to get that sorted before expecting night bliss. Have been amazed the number of people who complain about sleep and have all sorts of drama going on. People have this sense that the act of laying down and closing your eyes = sleep mode.
- jeremiahbuckley 3y agoI believed this strategy when I was a kid to think about a problem before you go to sleep and while you sleep your brain will figure it out for you. You’ll wake up with the problem solved. I believed it just like I believed countless other unverified truths. I think it caused me a lot of sleep problems over the years because I’d be mentally grinding away in the dark, trying to prep my brain for all the wonderful problem solving it was going to do, and… ending up never going to sleep because I had worries, ideas, things to do. I now work hard on meditation-style “make your mind blank” effort at sleep time. Any worry I have, it can be handled tomorrow. (But I have to in good faith have a plan to address it in the morning.) This has made it much easier to fall asleep.
- charlie0 3y ago"Sleep architeture"...where can I find the Dream engineers?
- aquafox 3y agoIIRC, the explanation of Matthew Walker, a well respected sleep researcher and author, (https://www.amazon.com/Why-We-Sleep-Unlocking-Dreams/dp/1501144316 https://www.amazon.com/Why-We-Sleep-Unlocking-Dreams/dp/1501...) involves melatonin. It's a sleep timer: Melatonin levels peek in the middle of the day and are lowest around midnight. "Around" is the important part. As we get older, melatonines gets is earlier and earlier, say 1am for a juvenile but 8pm for a retiree. But the retiree doesn't got to sleep at 8pm because of social activities, watching a movie or a late night sports game. By the time he goes to bed, it's already too late and at 4am, melatonin levels are so high that he cannot sleep anymore, despite being tired.
- ashirviskas 3y agoI've read that Matthew Walker isn't a good source on sleep, as he tends to just make up some claims or bend the data to support whatever point he wants to make [1]. [1] - https://guzey.com/books/why-we-sleep/ https://guzey.com/books/why-we-sleep/ EDIT: >Melatonin levels peek in the middle of the day and are lowest around midnight. Isn't that the opposite of how melatonin works?
- strken 3y agoBased on https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/07/10/melatonin-much-more-than-you-wanted-to-know/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/07/10/melatonin-much-more-th..., as well as every chart of melatonin I can find, it doesn't seem to peak during the day. It seems to rise before bedtime and peak in the early hours of sleep. According to the blog post, the treatment for some sleep disorders is to take a dose of melatonin during the day, which moves your natural melatonin production earlier for unclear reasons. Maybe there's confusion between when you take the melatonin and when melatonin is naturally highest?
- naruhodo 3y agoYeah, it was my understanding that melatonin is secreted under low-light conditions according to one's circadian rhythm. > A substantial number of studies have shown that, within this rhythmic profile, the onset of melatonin secretion under dim light conditions (the dim light melatonin onset or DLMO) is the single most accurate marker for assessing the circadian pacemaker. Additionally, melatonin onset has been used clinically to evaluate problems related to the onset or offset of sleep. DLMO is useful for determining whether an individual is entrained (synchronized) to a 24-h light/dark (LD) cycle or is in a free-running state. DLMO is also useful for assessing phase delays or advances of rhythms in entrained individuals. Additionally, it has become an important tool for psychiatric diagnosis, its use being recommended for phase typing in patients suffering from sleep and mood disorders. More recently, DLMO has also been used to assess the chronobiological features of seasonal affective disorder (SAD). DLMO marker is also useful for identifying optimal application times for therapies such as bright light or exogenous melatonin treatment. [1] [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16884842/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16884842/
- fooker 3y agoThis is anecdotal, but whenever I have managed to keep my phone in a different room, I get pure uninterrupted sleep.
- beebeepka 3y agoSince I almost never sleep for more than 5-6 hours, in my early 20s I wanted the cycle to be more like 32 hours, or at least 28. Now, 20 years later, I think 32 would be too much but 28 is still looking attractive to me, especially with an afternoon nap just after lunch.
- crawfordcomeaux 3y agoBetting it has a lot to do with carrying on with denying the collective impact of our daily choices & is a recent (past 5k years) development
- faeriechangling 3y agoI’ve slept better as I age because there isn’t a government enforced mandate to force me to wake me up early in the morning and go into a room with my same age peers. Not being in poverty helps as well. I found children were set up to fail so spectacularly when it comes to sleep that I wonder why it would become more elusive with age.
- esperent 3y ago> a government enforced mandate to force me to wake me up early in the morning and go into a room with my same age peers When someone jumps into a discussion and reframes a well known concept in a way that's intended to make people angry so that they can further a point of view that is orthogonal (x) to the current discussion, I always wonder, why? Has life taught you that this is a useful way to further a discussion? Do people respond well to it? Or do you just like strong reactions to what you say and you have found that stating things in a way designed to elicit anger is a good way to get those? (x) This article is about sleep patterns in adults over 60 versus younger adults, not sleep deprivation in children and teens who are forced to get up early for school. Your point is not totally unrelated, it's worth discussing, and it's also orthogonal to the actual discussion here. So again, why did you feel the need to jump in and try to make people angry about it?
- xtracto 3y agoI feel you are seeing it wrong. You are feeling anger where it wasn't meant to be. The way I read these types of comments is trying to reframe typical human actions in an "impartial " light. Everybody knows kids should go yk school, if someone dared to say otherwise people would jump to "cancel" them because "think of the children". So trying to put the argument in a different light to avoid the knee-jerk reactions helps drive conversation. I hate that English is not my first language, so my argument here surely reads somewhat funky.
- ozymandium 3y agoI greatly appreciate when people reframe old ideas in a new light. It's not only helpful to the conversation, but an effective way to communicate with people who have entrenched ideas and need help getting out of a rut. Perhaps the discomfort you're feeling is from being challenged.
- nunez 3y agoGET A SLEEP STUDY DONE! I waited way too long to do mine and learned so much afterwards. In my case, while I don't have apnea (many MANY people do, and not just fat people!), I learned that I have a deviated septum that causes airflow problems primarily during sleep, especially in our dusty ass house. (I have since installed air purifiers.) My daily sleep quality improved considerably after using breathe right strips, Flonase and melatonin, all at the direction of my ENT. I still have episodes of maintenance insomnia (waking up at night), but they've gone way down. I also didn't know that taking melatonin 1.5-3hr before bed and Flonase 30m before falling asleep can greatly help induce sleep quickly. Melatonin is also non-habit-forming and is produced naturally by the body, so taking SMALL amounts of it daily is completely fine. (small = 1.5-3mg) There's other stuff that can affect sleep quality for sure (staying in bed when you can't fall back asleep; inconsistent sleep/wake times; doing things other than sleeping or aggressive snuggling), but getting a sleep study done and ruling out physical reasons is so, so, so important. GET A SLEEP STUDY DONE! (Also, if you're struggling with insomnia, look into CBT-I. It's hard work, but your sleep will improve demonstrably if you stick to the program. But not before getting your sleep study done!)
- garciasn 3y agoI asked my doctor if I should have a sleep study done because I snore. She said, “I can tell you right now that it’ll say you have sleep apnea; that’s all they ever say.” Yes, I found a new doctor but with so many people being diagnosed with it, I do sometimes wonder.
- zachkatz 3y agoI feel like maybe one of the causes of apparently such widespread sleep apnea is how most people, as far as I gather, sleep with their windows closed. This is deeply unnatural—we evolved to sleep more or less outside, or at least in a shelter with a steady airflow—so of COURSE sleeping in an unventilated box with stale, stagnant air is going to result in not getting enough air while sleeping. A CPAP machine is basically doing the same thing. This is pure speculation, so I’m curious if anyone else has any perspective on this.
- anonzzzies 3y agoNever slept better getting older; I used to do 3-5 hour nights in my 20s because of stress for my company, sold the company and had no worries anymore so slept 8-9 hours/day. Opened another company but with far less worries (if it fails it’s sad but far from the existential stress the first company was) so now into my 50s I lay down, pass out and wake exactly 8 hours later. Usually remembering at least a few dreams. I remember my granddad having the complete reverse; he slept well when younger (during WOII, which I would think is an actual existential threat vs monetary one) and when he was 50, he would take heavy sleeping pills and then even only get 4 hours or so.
- pallas_athena 3y agoThings that empirically work for me to sleep better: Mandatory: - separate duvets for me & my partner, so we don't wake each other up by turning - no screentime for ~1 hr before falling asleep - going to bed and read a book for that ~1 hr. When I get sleepy I sleep - bedroom as dark as possible - physical activity of any kind Less important: - no caffeine in the ~8 hrs before falling asleep - glass of warm milk before going to bed
- positr0n 3y agoHow does dark room, reading in bed, and sleeping when you are tired go together with a partner? Does the first person to get tired sleep with the room lit enough for the other to keep reading?
- MattSayar 3y agoThis only works if you're reading on a backlit device like a phone or ebook reader
- rowanG077 3y agoI have never noticed that sleep gets more elusive as I get older. In fact it seems the opposite. As a teen and young adult it was not uncommon for me to toss and turn for hours before I could sleep. Something I almost never have now.
- Madmallard 3y agoWalking around in the sun for a couple hours every day has made it impossible for me to stay up at night
- throw4847285 3y agoWhy does sleep become more elusive as we age? Probably because we're all dying.