5 ms·
Japan automakers play catch-up in EV race
- mdgrech23 3y agoNothing is what it seems in this industry. If we had a free market system here in the US GM would of went out of business in 08 and the streets would be filled with cheap BYD imports from China. We have major domestic protectionism in place b/c in times of war the auto industry can and has been used to produce the machines of war. EVs produced in the US by domestic automakers are heavily subsidized
- elzbardico 3y agoFree Trade is something that powerful nations impose on less powerful nations. Anything else is just ideological bullshit. EDIT: I understand that free trade theoretically could be a win-win game. But the real world is a lot more complicated, and is a historical fact that developed nations always have and continue to push for less powerful nations to open their markets while abusing of protectionist practices themselves.
- rwmj 3y agoHow do you account for Singapore?
- dontlaugh 3y agoSingapore has significant central planning as part of its economy and also does some protectionism. It's also an important US proxy in the region. Not unlike South Korea in both respects.
- elzbardico 3y agoSingapore economy is a result of foreign investment aided by very generous tax benefits and a repressive regime that ensured for a long time a low paid and compliant work-force. Being also basically a city-state without natural resources, Singapore was always trade-oriented and as a commercial hub of course it is in an extraordinary position to engage in free-trade. But believing that the same recipe could be applied for Argentina, South-Africa or Brasil takes a lot more faith But what is funny about the Singapore example always abused on those conversations is that it begs the question of why people always cite a more or less tiny Asian city-state as the most prominent case of the success of free-trade instead of bigger economies like the US, China, Japan, South Korea or the UE. And the reason for that is that all those nations have always engaged and still engage on protectionist practices while expecting less developed markets to open their borders. Subsides, Non-Tax Barriers, Direct government investments, taxes and fees, you name it, they did and they do it.
- csomar 3y agoSingapore is a tiny city-state and its model can't scale for large nations.
- scythe 3y agoSingapore overlooks the strait of Malacca, the key gateway by sea between India and China. It has been a strategic trading port for centuries. The cost of shipping goods there is correspondingly low — ships go there anyway. Consequently, it has always had a culture and economy that was prepared to take advantage of our high-trade global economy. Being the Switzerland of Asia doesn't hurt either. Panama is the logical point of comparison — its governance has been consistently atrocious (cf. Noriega), but it nonetheless remains among the front of the pack in Latin America economically.
- esotericimpl 3y ago[dead]
- Barrin92 3y agoThen why does the Jones act exist and why is the US curtailing chip exports to China, and why does Mercosur want a trade deal with Europe? No, free trade is mutually beneficial and the natural state of things, protection exists for two reasons. Pursuit of military interests (blockades) or satisfying domestic rent seekers. (e.g. the shipping industry, farmers etc.)
- jryle70 3y agoThat's a very narrow minded view. China is number one counterpoint. Without free trade, and very favorable terms that Western countries offered, China wouldn't become the superpower it is today. The tension between US and China today has more to do with geopolitics than protectionism. Read the following (from 1984) to understand how Deng Xiao Peng saw the roles of Special Economic Zone in the revival of China's economy: https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/deng-xiaoping/1984/21.htm https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/deng-xiaoping/198...
- azinman2 3y agoI’m not sure if you’re trying to say this is good or bad. Seems good to me.
- droopyEyelids 3y agoIt's too complex of a system to label the whole "good" or "bad". There are a many involved parties and they're affected by it in multiple ways. I think you're trying to say the consumer harm of increased prices of EVs is outweighed by the benefits to industry etc?
- azinman2 3y agoThe entire revolt against globalism shows that just lowering price isn’t enough when you no longer have a job, or the job you have pays you very little. It’s not smart for a country to let all of their industrial engine be replaced just because it’s cheaper. It’s more expensive in the long run.
- konstmonst 3y agoThe problem is that an industry can be used as leverage by China to hurt the economy. See Putin and Gazprom, Tawianese Chips and so on. Globalization is good, because it makes production of consumer goods more cost effective. But cost alone is not worth much if the supply is not reliable and can be leveraged by a potential opponent.
- csomar 3y agoIt's good if the local market catches up in the next 3-4 years. It's catastrophic if they do not, however.
- metabagel 3y agoGM was bailed out to save the jobs. And it’s got nothing to do with the “free market”. The “free market” is between GM and their customers.
- ChatGTP 3y agoAdding yet another dimension to the challenge is the transformational nature of the EV business, which may ultimately be driven less by hardware than software. I'd argue the opposite. I wouldn't buy a software filled "smart EV". I'd love a dumb as hell, electric "kei van" that's 4WD. No Japanese automaker produces them however, it's absolutely ridiculous considering how popular the form factor and "dumb" kei car is.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoYou are not the target market. Get a second hand Leaf or Bolt or similar golf cart EV. https://electrek.co/2023/05/25/tesla-model-y-is-now-the-worlds-best-selling-car-first-ev-to-do-so/ https://electrek.co/2023/05/25/tesla-model-y-is-now-the-worl... ("Tesla Model Y is now the world’s best-selling car, first EV to do so") https://insideevs.com/news/698351/used-ev-prices-drop-sales-take-longer/ https://insideevs.com/news/698351/used-ev-prices-drop-sales-... ("Polestar 2, Ford F-150 Lightning, and Kia EV6 are among the slowest-selling used EVs.")
- ChatGTP 3y ago[flagged]
- dv_dt 3y agoHow are those non-tesla models selling used? I don’t think any of them are even three years old. It seems like a skewed comparison.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoStudy/methodology: https://www.iseecars.com/hybrid-and-electric-car-prices-study https://www.iseecars.com/hybrid-and-electric-car-prices-stud... (disclaimer: I am trying to pick up used undervalued Teslas for folks in my circle who are in need of a vehicle, hence my ear to the ground on this topic)
- dv_dt 3y ago
- rtpg 3y agoIt is kind of sad to see Japanese EVs barely take off. After seeing all the weird and busted stuff about Teslas (on top of the "luxury price for fake luxury interior" stuff)... all I really want for an EV is a Yaris but with a battery. I just want normal door handles and a satnav with buttons, and Japanese makers seem to be among the last holdouts.
- jhallenworld 3y agoChevy Bolt? https://cleantechnica.com/2023/05/06/my-first-ev-part-iv-2023-bolt-euv-or-2020-tesla-model-3/ https://cleantechnica.com/2023/05/06/my-first-ev-part-iv-202...
- ngngngng 3y agoSpeaking as someone that's owned Chevy's and Tesla's recently, if you're concerned about Tesla's quality, I would steer clear of Chevy.
- sofixa 3y agoRenault Zoe or Dacia Spring sounds right up your alley.
- bestouff 3y agoI've got a Zoe. It's fantastic - simple, efficient, that thing just works.
- joezydeco 3y agoIt's sad, but it's not a surprise. I'm a huge Mazda fan and their first attempt at a BEV was pretty shitty. And consumers figured it out really quickly. https://electrek.co/2023/07/29/mazda-kills-off-mx-30-ev-in-us-again-after-selling-just-66-cars/ https://electrek.co/2023/07/29/mazda-kills-off-mx-30-ev-in-u... And the CEO is just clueless. https://insideevs.com/news/698183/mazda-ceo-says-evs-not-taking-off-in-us-except-teslas/ https://insideevs.com/news/698183/mazda-ceo-says-evs-not-tak... I just want normal door handles and a satnav with buttons My mantra through this whole thing is "I don't want an electric car, I just want a car that's electric". I found what I was looking for in the XC40 Recharge, but I realize that's still a really expensive car for this market. I'm with you on a Yaris BEV.
- DrNosferatu 3y agoCompletely counterintuitive VW is so high on that list.
- hef19898 3y agoVW, the brand, has some very serious issues, not all of those are related to EVs as they started much earlier. VW, as in VAG the enterprise, is doing quite well with brands like Skoda, Porsche and Audi.
- csunbird 3y agoID series, especially ID4, are a success. They are definitely good cars, except for the entertainment system, which you can replace with CarPlay.
- jhallenworld 3y agoJohn Cadogan on VW... https://youtu.be/u1UfDOLk8ic?t=2103 https://youtu.be/u1UfDOLk8ic?t=2103 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hn0U55n7Vwg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hn0U55n7Vwg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjToFe1oAAI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjToFe1oAAI He's anti-EV, but the main point is pretty good: cars from different companies are all pretty much the same, so the next thing you should look at is the company itself- will they help you after the sale? Are they a good corporate citizen? Oh, one more: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2018/jan/29/vw-condemned-for-testing-diesel-fumes-on-humans-and-monkeys https://www.theguardian.com/business/2018/jan/29/vw-condemne...
- jillesvangurp 3y agoDieselgate basically. They got a rude awakening around that time and accelerated plans to take EVs to market because they realized that their diesel strategy was dead in the water. So, they now have EV production capacity on multiple continents and battery supply secured. Their first generation platform has been a bit rough but they are selling cars built on it in volume now directly and through companies like Seat. The probably do so at a loss or with low margins. Which is something they have in common with other struggling manufacturers.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThey've still got time given their reputation. In 2024 it's borderline OK not to have an EV business. EV's are 10% of the American market, 25% of the European market and >50% of the Chinese market. The Chinese market is probably lost anyway due to the insane local competition, so concentrating in 2024 on the larger share of the market outside of China is reasonable. Let's say that the flipover point is 2027. And let's say it's 2027 and you're looking to buy an EV. You narrow down your choice to a 3rd generation Tesla, a second generation Ford or VW and a first generation Toyota or Honda. Reliability is the deciding factor. What do you choose? Lots of people are going to choose a Japanese brand despite any drawbacks getting a "bleeding edge" model entail. By not ramping up EV production gradually they're setting themselves hard production and logistics problems. All new production processes have teething problems, and they're a lot easier to solve when production is in the 5 figures rather than when it is in the 7 figures, but if anybody can solve hard production and logistics problems it's probably Toyota.
- raphaelj 3y agoI had the same thoughts a few years ago. The winner will not be the first one to the market, but the one at the right time with the best car on the market.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoActually neither. The best car is the one that you can actually buy. That requires manufacturing, logistics and supplies. The likes of Toyota have barely begun the process of getting organized there. Even if they had an amazing EV product (which so far they don't), they'd struggle to sell a lot of them because they simply don't have factories, battery supplies, etc. in place that they would need for that. And at the scale they operate anything that doesn't sell in the millions of units is not worth doing. Getting from zero to there will take them quite a bit of time and money. Which is why the winners in this market so far are Chinese and Korean manufacturers. And Tesla. Unlike other manufacturers they have manufacturing dialed in and a robust supply line with batteries and other things they need. Their main challenges are keeping up with demand and keeping cost low while growing manufacturing capacity. The pace at which this market is growing means that it is getting harder for the likes of Toyota to break into this market. The few EVs they have on the market are actually not made by them and also a bit underwhelming. For example the bZ4X is actually a BYD car with a Toyota logo. That might be their future: leave the manufacturing to specialized companies and simply milk the brand. They seem to still insist they'll have their own drive trains and supposedly amazing batteries. But so far there's little sign of them building factories for those. Maybe that will work for them.
- jeffbee 3y agoWeird since Yamaha pioneered the electric bicycle more than 30 years back.
- jrsj 3y agoHybrid sales are way up, that’s where the growth is going to be the next couple of years. The strategy that everyone was calling Toyota insane or even evil for is starting to make a lot more sense looking at market trends.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- epolanski 3y agoI think they are doing the right thing by waiting out. They will reap a series of huge benefits: - powertrain and battery technologies will get cheaper and more reliable - they will do much more money for the foreseeable future by focusing on a very cost efficient market they already do well in - they minimize the investments by having to experiment less I think that many companies like Mercedes and Ford and Volkswagen FOMOed into a premature EV transition blinded by the growth and margins and Tesla. They are now finding out that EV demand isn't as high as they thought and that even Tesla's growth and margins is collapsing (and obviously will never recover with more competition coming).
- user568439 3y agoIn the other hand it’s not that simple to catch up. Tesla has a huge advantage in costs at the moment and the non-chinese don’t seem to be able to compete. Supply chain contracts of batteries and new raw materials, software, efficient electric engines, aerodynamics, battery management, software, charging stations, vehicle platform design, cheaper manufacturing, trained workers, experienced engineers… There are a lot of elements and some will fall because they waited too much. VW for example is having huge delays due to software and also prices (even though in China they have no problem selling the IDs for half price than in Europe…)
- epolanski 3y ago> In the other hand it’s not that simple to catch up. Chinese market clearly shows that it is possible. Japanese companies already have EVs btw they are simply not making them at scale nor as their primary focus.
- matthewfelgate 3y agoWill the entire car market transition to electric vehicles? There's a possibility that this shift might result in a scenario where only premium cars are electric, while a proportion remain petrol-powered.
- dalyons 3y agoThat shouldn’t be stable long term though, evs will be fundamentally cheaper to manufacture
- tsudounym 3y agoI don't know why Nissan isn't aggressively exporting the Sakura and Note e-power, the Note especially has a gas engine fallback that powers the battery (not the drivetrain) which should remove range anxiety
- sharts 3y agoCatch-up to what? EVs are still a bad idea for the majority of the world. They are not cleaner (until at least about 100K miles), cheaper, faster to refuel, or have the same range. That’s not counting the lack of meaningful global infrastructure to support them. Maybe things will change by 2050 or so. For now, EVs are the biggest grift of our time.
- methou 3y agothe problem with EV in Japan is that electricity is quite expensive (30~40 Yen/kwh) to the typical salaryman who earns around 300,000 Yen a month pretax/pension. It could be an easy 5 - 10% of their allocatable income. To make it worse, the capacity of Japanese power grid isn’t very well. Although people are adapting EV cars and e-bikes in Japan, the price parity per charge isn’t that much comparing to gas. I think what made it popular today is that gas price is skyrocketing (140->180/L within a year), so people started seeking alternatives.