12 ms·
Why Isn't Landfill Mining More Popular?
- ysofunny 3y ago[flagged]
- izzydata 3y agoSome day once we strip the entire planet of its accessible natural resources and turn it into trash the landfills will be the only place left to scrounge for rare materials.
- incrudible 3y agoIf mining landfills was profitable, recycling would be profitable even before that.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoI thought recycling was sometimes profitable? At least for metals
- hinkley 3y agoThe rule of thumb used to be you could save about a kilowatt hour of electricity making a soda can from recycled aluminum versus mining and refining. I don’t know where things sit today Aluminum was ridiculously expensive before the electrolysis method and municipal electricity.
- incrudible 3y agoSometimes, yes. It depends on many factors, but generally speaking if it is profitable to recycle, it would be unlikely to end up in a landfill in the first place.
- olyjohn 3y agoI took a truckload of scrap steel and aluminum to the scrap yard and got a pretty good chunk of money for it. Used metals are definitely worth something. All old cars are cushed and paid for by the ton. You can even take old wire and piping to the scrap yards for money. That's why abandoned houses will get ripped apart for copper pipes and wiring.
- graphe 3y agoGood, our descendants will recycle!
- grotorea 3y agoWill this happen before asteroid mining?
- SpaceNoodled 3y agoDepends how much cheaper it is.
- lainga 3y agoReading through the several answers, it seems like the TL;DR is 1. Maybe there is toxic material IDK who wants to touch that instead of some rock 2. The industry actors who would do it only regard landfills as shiny metal reserves, and don't want/can't get the other materials one might extract from it, raising cost floor
- lazide 3y agoBecause it’s a lot more complicated and expensive than mining native minerals right now, because you have to deal With all the other random things mixed in.
- gosub100 3y agoI've wondered why they haven't implemented a compromise between recycling and tossing, which would just be segregating certain materials for later sale or recycling. If they put all the plastic bottles in one section of landfill, all the glass, etc it would be a bet toward there someday being a change in technology, materials science, or market prices that might make it worth mining. It would also be cheaper because the same trucks could pick it up (some cities have this, put your recyclables in a blue bag and throw them in the regular trash). One of the asinine things about recycling (to me) is that they have another has guzzling truck. There should be better accounting done on recycling so we can eliminate feel-good practices and only do things that actually help the environment. Sorting trash (at the landfill) would be a great step forward for this.
- SoftTalker 3y agoYou should visit the average landfill to get a firsthand impression of the sheer volume of trash that arrives every day. Sorting at that point would require a huge investment in infrastructure and technology on-site. Individuals sorting their own trash at the other end of the stream is quite easy and costs only a few minutes of their time. It's like diverting the flow of a tributary stream vs. diverting the Mississippi River.
- robocat 3y ago> costs only a few minutes of their time. You are so casual about throwing away an irreplaceable resource. Like many conversations about the environment and taxation, many people seem happy to talk all day about how others can afford to pay and about how others should pay. Personally, I worry about how costly those defuse costs are overall. How often do we save uneconomic resources by wasting aggregate large amounts of resources. The tradeoffs seem to be rarely counted. Only one side of the ledger is looked at. In context Switzerland decided that all garbage is incinerated. Perhaps we should presume that Switzerland has done this because it is the most enviromentally friendly and least wasteful measure.
- gosub100 3y agoBig City: "Hey WM, we appreciate the valuable service you provide us just like you appreciate the monopoly on business we grant you. Trouble is, your industry doesn't seem to innovate at the same pace as other industries. Starting next year, we are going to levy taxes and fees on your business model. You can avoid paying these fees if you invest in technology to meet the following requirements: lower miles driven by your fleet, segregate 95% of plastic bottles, glass bottles, and food cans (they still go to the landfill, just in a particular place). Don't want to change? Fine, we'll bust your monopoly and you can compete with firms that will innovate."
- bradley13 3y agoSome years ago, Switzerland completely stopped using landfills. All garbage is incinerated. The resulting slag is then processed to reclaim nearly all metals as well as some other important elements. Of course, the burning creates CO2. However, you don't have to mine and refine metal ores, and the incinerators also generate electricity and district heating. So the ecological balance is actually pretty good. As a final bonus, you don't have literal square miles of landfills that occupy land and eventually will leak lovely chemicals into groundwater. The slag is far less problematic, and there is a lot less of it to deal with.
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoThe US has way too much space for incineration to become more cost-effective than just dumping it in a giant hole in the ground.
- ponector 3y agoCould be true for small cities. But try to find an empty space suitable for landfill near NYC.
- saalweachter 3y agoUp until 2001, it was inside NYC.
- mbiondi 3y agoAnd now they ship it down south to states who are happy to take it.
- eesmith 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobro_4000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobro_4000 > The Mobro 4000 was a barge owned by MOBRO Marine, Inc. made infamous in 1987 for hauling the same load of trash along the east coast of North America from New York City to Belize and back until a way was found to dispose of the garbage. ... > In 1987, the City of New York found that it had reached its landfill capacity. The city agreed to ship its garbage to Morehead City, North Carolina, where there were plans to convert it into methane.
- ddxv 3y agoI like imagining that some of our large ore deposits are infact ancient garbage heaps from tens of millions of years ago.
- lorax 3y agoThe remains of dinosaur cities.
- konfusinomicon 3y agothe ancient ones were meticulous in their sorting, in some cases
- nobodyandproud 3y agoHah! I enjoy imagining that much of our oil was pumped into the ground long ago, to prevent run-away global warming.
- analog31 3y agoMy knee jerk reaction is that I wouldn't trust a mining operation to clean up after itself. While I'm sure that landfills could be cleaner, whatever level of cleanliness they achieve is based on the assumption that the sites won't be disturbed.
- cranky908canuck 3y agoMy notion was, conventional mining often doesn't bother to clean up after itself (eg., orphan wells), whereas landfill mining will likely be held to a higher standard.
- jrmg 3y agoOne of the protagonists of Kim Stanley Robinson’s ‘Mars’ trilogy (starting in ‘Blue Mars’ onwards IIRC) is a billionaire who made his billions by starting ‘dumpmines’, a landfill mining company.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> starting in ‘Blue Mars’ Starting with Red Mars. Blue Mars is last in the trilogy.
- jrmg 3y agoI think the character was not in the first book. Maybe he appears in Green Mars? It’s been so long since it read them.
- mwattsun 3y agoThere's probably millions of tons of unused copper wire formerly used for telephone land lines nailed to poles unused. I wonder when we're going to start taking that down instead of despoiling natural wonders like the proposed Pebble Mine in Alaska https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pebble_Mine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pebble_Mine
- dave333 3y agoEven the power poles can be recycled: https://illumination.duke-energy.com/articles/how-duke-energy-finds-new-life-for-old-power-poles#:~:text=Treated%20wood%20that's%20still%20in,with%20little%20transportation%20and%20processing https://illumination.duke-energy.com/articles/how-duke-energ.... and some can be left with perhaps a top platform added as nest sites.
- progne 3y agoI've heard that the biggest barrier to reuse is the expense of purifying the inputs of the various recycling processes. A few stray baked beans can gum up the works. If so the economics would be greatly changed by a robot running AI software that can just sort and wash trash the way we're supposed to at home.
- feoren 3y agoI've never before heard anyone ever suggest that we're "supposed to" be sorting and washing our trash at home. What an unbelievably wasteful and pointless notion.
- progne 3y agoSee for example the Seattle "tips to recycle right" * Empty, Clean, and Dry * When in Doubt, Find Out * Keep Bags Out The page goes into detail on each. This isn't unusual in my experience. https://www.seattle.gov/utilities/your-services/collection-and-disposal/recycling/recycle-right https://www.seattle.gov/utilities/your-services/collection-a... Here's an online tool to help people identify the various kinds of recyclables and direct them correctly. It isn't easy and I doubt few Seattle residents know all of these. https://www.seattle.gov/utilities/your-services/collection-and-disposal/where-does-it-go#/a-z https://www.seattle.gov/utilities/your-services/collection-a... If everyone started sorting and cleaning according to these rules the fraction of usable recyclables would increase a lot.
- tmountain 3y agoHow does this align with NPRs fairly recent report that recycling probably isn't even worth it? https://www.npr.org/2021/04/21/987111675/video-is-recycling-worth-it-anymore-people-on-the-front-lines-say-maybe-not https://www.npr.org/2021/04/21/987111675/video-is-recycling-... How many hours have we (as a species) wasted sorting and meticulously managing our waste when the vast majority of it never gets recycled anyway? I'm asking the question as someone who cares deeply about the environment. I just think recycling is a fake solution invented by the plastic industry to alleviate the consumer guilt that comes with purchasing single-use plastics. If you don't like a bunch of waste in your landfills, buy fewer single-use products. The vast majority of what goes into the bin never gets recycled anyway.
- sneed_chucker 3y ago"Trash economy. The abundance of trash. What are we gonna do with it? Are we gonna put it on an island? Are we gonna make it somebody else’s problem? Or are we going to take the initiative, and take this problem by the horns? Trash economy. You use cubes of trash as money. Everybody becomes rich, it’s a gold rush."
- sovietmudkipz 3y agoSounds like a 2070 paradigm shift.
- akoboldfrying 3y agodabs finger tastes Needs more blockchain
- iandanforth 3y agoI'd love to see 'mining' defined more broadly here. Sure metals are a great target but every useful and valuable material known to man exists in landfills. A "full cycle" or "total recovery" mindset would be far more exciting. Treat everything as potentially valuable and you get better economics. I'd love to join a company who had this as their mission. Sure, start with metal recovery but continually build out new recovery processes until you can "ingest" everything and turn it into something useful.
- theendisney2 3y agoThere is or was a British inventor who build an odd contraption with 2 vibrating plates with grinded garbage flowing between them suspended in ferrofluid. Along the track the paeticles sort themselves by density. Innitially a silly idea as ferrofluid is expensive but he wanted to see how well it worked and possibly try better fluids. It turned out to produce much more ferrofluid than was consumed. The story ends with: no one was interested enough to spend money on it.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- FounderBurr 3y agoThis site is an unusable mess