7 ms·
Can we deter tech monopolies through reformed open source software development?
- baybal2 3y ago[dead]
- xkekjrktllss 3y agoNo.
- reportgunner 3y agoBetteridge's law strikes again.
- tycho-newman 3y agoNo. Why do we spend all this time avoiding the truth? We have antitrust laws to dismantle monopolies. This is because monopolies can be dismantled by two things: 1. The coercive power of the state. 2. A sudden realization among those who run and benefit from the monopoly that selfless love for their fellow human beings is enough reason to stop predatory rent-seeking. In other words, only love or power. We spend a lot of time not talking about the two main forces that guide human life. Not reason. Not reformed open source software development. Love and power. I often suspect this reluctance to involve the coercive power of the state comes from a libertarian streak in the tech world. But I am a weird anarchist kind of guy so maybe I am mistaken on this.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SpicyLemonZest 3y agoAs the article touches on, we spend the time because people want to address companies like Facebook, which are not obviously monopolies in the normal legal sense. They don't overcharge users, they have strong competitors, etc. But they're still a huge tech company with outsized influence on both society and software development industry.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoI’d argue they are a monopoly in the traditonal sense too. They control the whole stack like standard oil. They probably do overcharge their actual users/customers (the advertisers, not you, the product they sell access to). The more you read about places like standard oil the more they reflect these modern companies.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> This is because monopolies can be dismantled by two things: > 1. The coercive power of the state. > 2. A sudden realization among those who run and benefit from the monopoly that selfless love for their fellow human beings is enough reason to stop predatory rent-seeking. You're missing the third option: Someone else finds a way to break their lock on the market. In many cases this happens indirectly. If you had a monopoly on local media before the internet, you don't have one after the internet. But that doesn't mean you can't do it with a purpose. In many cases this requires an act of altruism. To break the monopoly, somebody has to spend non-trivial resources to reproduce the ability to do something that currently only the monopolist can, without hope of turning a profit from it. People can do this if they choose to. And the work required to do it can be distributed throughout a community.
- lumb63 3y agoIt’s humorous to me that we discuss “monopolies” over what are ultimately very discretionary sectors. Compare to the trusts of the 20th century, which were monopolizing oil or steel for example. These are (or were) the commodities required to power commerce via shipping and transportation. A single entity having pricing power over such essential commodities threatens the robustness of the world economy. Today we complain about the monopolistic power of, e.g. Google, who does not actually have a monopoly on search (there are many other providers), and the ability to search the entire internet isn’t really that necessary, or Apple’s mobile marketplace, where they again do not have a monopoly (people choose to develop for Apple devices, and part of choosing to sell something somewhere is agreeing to the market’s terms - as has been the case for all of time), and this is mostly to power manipulative microtransactions for kids on games. These are entirely different ballparks.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe thing you're missing is the "you're not the customer, you're the product." The customer is the app developer or the advertiser -- the startup Apple is extracting 30% from, or the small business which just wants to get its name out but Google systematically excludes small websites from organic search results and requires you to pay a huge chunk of your revenue to be seen. If your prospective customers have iPhones, you need Apple's permission or you're out of business. If your prospective customers use Google search, you pay them for advertising or you're invisible. You don't get to choose which phone or search engine they use, and they rarely if ever use more than one -- unlike retail stores where it's common for the same customer to shop at dozens of different stores. If Walmart won't carry your products in their stores, you can sell them through Target and Amazon and a zillion other retailers. The same customers can get it from another store. If Apple won't carry your app, those customers have no other viable means to get it from you. This isn't just "manipulative microtransactions for kids on games" -- it's the reason you can't use cryptocurrency or any competing payment network for in-app purchases. Are payments not an important industry for which we care about competition? Apple basically murdered Tumblr by giving them an impossible choice between banning adult content (causing them to lose too much of their user base) or being banned from iPhones (causing them to lose too much of their user base). Regardless of how you feel about adult content, they have the power to do this over anything. Should they be able to destroy your social network or force you to censor if they don't like your politics? How does this not matter?
- thisisabhii 3y agobut why?
- onemoresoop 3y agoNo. Maybe there's a path to do this through unions though?
- Apocryphon 3y ago(Dutch)
- Philpax 3y agoWhat's the relevance of this?
- BanTheBastards 3y agoNo. Proper "reform" entails reorganizing our economy. We will all die before this happens.
- loup-vaillant 3y agoSome would rather die trying to make it happen.
- leashless 3y agoI recently discussed whether Stallman’s “Four Freedoms” apply to corporations. If not, that would change things.
- bdw5204 3y agoThey do apply to corporations. Allowing commercial use is part of the definition of both "open source" and "free software" so a non-commercial license is incompatible with the GPL Without Stallman releasing an official Non-Commercial GPL (NCGPL) and allowing GPL'd software to be upgraded to it like it can be upgraded to AGPL, there's no way to merge non-commercial licensed code into GPL code without relicensing even if the non-commercial code is otherwise using a standard FOSS license.
- kube-system 3y agoThis article sounds like the author started with a conclusion and worked their way back to a premise. Monopolistic powers are a business and economics problem, it has nothing to do with the building blocks used to build their products. >For example, if Uber’s driver rating could be exported to other similar ride-hailing services, it would have the effect of reducing the lock-in effect of Uber platform. People are not using Uber because they don't have a rating on newcomer apps. They're using it because Uber has a large number riders and drivers in many locations, and people are aware of it. > Mandate the use of open standards and open source competitor: All solutions must have open source alternatives before being implemented. For example, the Bavarian government switched the government operating system to Linux in 2018 to avoid being subject to Microsoft’s monopoly on software. While the project was not entirely successful They discovered that there's a difference between "software" and "a software implementation". A myopic view of software as just code that you can throw over a fence is missing the entire reason that Windows was and is dominant on desktop. Deploying, integrating, maintaining, and operating software across an organization is labor intensive. Microsoft doesn't "compete with Linux", they compete with Red Hat or Canonical.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> People are not using Uber because they don't have a rating on newcomer apps. They're using it because Uber has a large number riders and drivers in many locations, and people are aware of it. I think the general point is that you want to move the network effect outside the control of a single entity. So for example, like email rather than like Facebook. You relegate the service into something narrower, like payment processing, which then becomes fungible. You find the driver you want in a decentralized system and then pay them using Uber or Paypal or CashApp or Mastercard or physical cash or whatever you like. > Deploying, integrating, maintaining, and operating software across an organization is labor intensive. Microsoft doesn't "compete with Linux", they compete with Red Hat or Canonical. That depends on your scale, but there are different ways to go about it. If you're small, just compiling something from github is a reasonable thing to do. You're not deploying it to a thousand workstations or trying to centrally manage anything. What do you need with Active Directory? If you're large, you have a well-staffed IT department and possibly even your own software developers who can handle deployment issues in-house. Google has its own in-house Linux distribution in addition to ChromeOS. The target market for Windows and Red Hat and Canonical is medium-sized entities with enough money to pay someone else to solve their problems but not enough to bring that expertise in house. But many corporations and governments are large enough that they'd be better off doing what Google does, and open source communities can operate at the same scale. Medium sized companies that actually have a dedicated IT department could very well be better off to make a minor contribution to a community effort, and use it themselves, than lock themselves into one of these enterprise vendors. That would require more organization than is currently present, but not necessarily more than is humanly possible.
- taeric 3y agoIf you rephrase this as fighting consolidation through open source software, I think it is rather clear that you cannot. Consolidation will always have benefits at the small. That there is a straw that breaks that camel's back is not an argument against carrying more straw. I am personally of the mind that we need to somehow shift the care not from personal future but to collective future. I don't have any thoughts on how to actually do that, though. It is very hard to convince people that are legitimately working hard for their personal well being that they should also give thoughts to those that come next.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> It is very hard to convince people that are legitimately working hard for their personal well being that they should also give thoughts to those that come next. What have you tried?
- taeric 3y agoFair question, I think? But I am not exactly in a position to really try anything. What do you have in mind?
- robertlagrant 3y agoSorry - I wasn't clear. I mean what have you tried that leads you to know this: > It is very hard to convince people that are legitimately working hard for their personal well being that they should also give thoughts to those that come next
- eYrKEC2 3y agoWe're all stuck in the quagmire of Oracle databases, licenses, and lawsuits, because no open source alternatives exist. What a shame that open source hasn't deterred any monopolies and can't possibly do so in the future.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoNo you can’t American/Worldwide capitalism incentivizes monopolist behavior There are no currently coherent checks on this because of regulatory capture. There exist no socialist governing bodies that have power at the same scale as capitalist ones. (Note: please no “might make right” rejoinders) The us government has set precedent over the last ~40 years which has intentionally, and structurally enshrined the capital class as legally distinct and more protected in practice
- atleastoptimal 3y agoThe biggest disadvantage of open source is the lack of organization. Blender solved this. Solve organization and open source wins.
- narag 3y agoCan you ellaborate? What exactly did Blender to solve organization challenges? A relevant link will suffice and be greatly appreciated :-)
- pwdisswordfishc 3y agoh1 { font-family: 'Maven Pro', cursive; font-size: 38px; color: #000; line-height: 1; } I have Google Fonts blocked, so I see the headings on the page displayed using the generic cursive font which ends up being… Comic Sans. Which certainly gives this article a unique kind of gravitas. A pretty strange choice anyway, given that Maven Pro doesn’t even seem to be a cursive font at all.
- Skunkleton 3y agoI feel like you could make a strong argument that open source actually aids tech monopolies. Consider some business that needs <foo> to work. They can use OSS, buy, or build. If they buy, they share their profits with some other company, and they have to do that for the duration of their use of <foo>. If they build <foo> as proprietary software then they are stuck with keeping expertise in that software. If <foo> is instead OSS, then they can either directly use that component, or make some initial investment in that component, and then use it with minimal further overheads. If you are building, then it better be your core competence. If you buy, then as you become larger and more successful, buying will be more and more expensive. Its hard to make your suppliers exclusive, and competition will be somewhat maintained. The Linux Kernel is a great example. There used to be a ton of kernels to choose from maintained and developed by small businesses, but over time Linux was chosen as a good free option. Companies would then put relatively minor investments into customizing or maintaining Linux, avoiding needing a proprietary kernel. After 20 or so years of this, there is almost no money to be made as a small operating systems vendor.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoIf they are the primary maintainer of <foo> then that's no different than building it in house and it becomes "open source" in the way that Android is, where they throw the code over the wall once a in a while but don't develop it in public. This only helps them in the sense that it prevents a competing ecosystem, by making the one they control free-as-in-beer. But that is something they do, not something you do. Whether or not you produce some other free software yourself isn't going to change it. If they're using some common community-developed free software, that's good, because they contribute to it without controlling it, and then anyone else can use it too and it's one less component of the stack that someone else has to build or buy in order to compete with them.
- naasking 3y agoI'm not sure how that drives monopolies though. All you've explained is how it lowers the barriers to market, but it does so for all companies, competitors included.
- jlarocco 3y agoI feel modern "open source" is kind of a parody of the original intentions and it completely misses the forest for the trees. Wikipedia says the goals of the GPL are "the four freedoms to run, study, share, and modify the software." It's a pyrrhic victory in today's world where the building blocks are open source, but the full stack is not, and the software is running on corporate servers where users have no control over it. Companies have simply commoditized and devalued the software and started hoarding the far more valuable user data instead.
- ponty_rick 3y agoYes, large corps have weaponized open source.
- amelius 3y agoFOSS developers should probably slap a license on it that says it's free unless you are a company that has a revenue greater than $X million dollars. This is still fair to everyone since for the company the price of using the software would be peanuts. And now at least these companies are paying for the development and maintenance.
- an_ko 3y agoWhat stops Amazon from establishing a separate company called Totally Not Amazon, which employs 1 person, and hosts your software for the rest of Amazon, and has revenue much less than 1M$ so they can use it for free? If they need more capacity than 1M would plausibly buy them from themselves, just establish however many more identical companies are necessary, none of which exceed 1M$.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoProbably language that suggests if amazon would like to do that they would need to split the entire company into a million pieces to each be under the revenue limit. In practice though amazon engineers would reverse engineer any tool they cant legally use and need.
- cenobyte 3y agoNo.
- none_to_remain 3y agoNo thanks.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- zeruch 3y agoNot really. At this stage the weaponization/enshittification of FOSS by abstracting its original goals, and making it about the equivalent of leverage for larger firms to use for cheap labor/R&D will only likely change if people only use reciprocal licenses with clauses for SaaS firms to straighten up (e.g. AGPL v3) AND legally enforce them in the courts.
- jayloofah 3y agoUnions & regulation
- fyokdrigd 3y agoA: yes, since gpl v3, but nobody cares.
- ilaksh 3y agoI think the key is data interoperability and open protocols. Ideally peer-based but I know federation is much more popular and that can work also. But it's not just the fact that they leverage open software to build their closed systems, it's the large networks and marketplaces they have. The only way to compete with that is through decentralized systems. Which (despite the connotation of the name), are the best approaches for creating large scale, open, holistic networks. Moving to decentralized protocols also means it is harder to dominate with one piece of software. Ideally the protocols are in some kind of protocol registry so they can evolve freely. But on some level I believe that some entity like a government needs to mandate this. Although I know there are many people who are philosophically against governments or practically against them due to their track record of being generally awful. But at some level you may have to force people to cooperate in some basic technical way in order to avoid the technopolies.
- kazinator 3y agoClosed stuff can always be built on open formats and protocols. E.g. TCP/IP is open; that doesn't make the Internet and Web open. Open formats and protocols can serve as monopoly-enabling catalysts.
- drewcoo 3y ago> Closed stuff can always be built on open formats and protocols. Could copyleft protocols be a thing?
- 3y ago
- throwawaaarrgh 3y agoUh, lol, no. Software development has nothing to do with business plans. Don't like monopolies? That's economic policy, not software. You can't code your way out of politics. But mandating legislation of open source is a great way to kill it if that's your goal.
- p0w3n3d 3y agoSadly no. Nowadays monopolies are built on open standards (Linux) with law-making-machete in left hand and patent-axe in right. Everything is open unles wideVine/trusted computing/other vendor lock or another smelly thing that makes you unable to use your own computer and requires you to marry a big tech corp. Meanwhile LibreOffice and other opensource software is staying in the same place as it was 10 years ago, because too open licenses do not require companies to push changes to the public or make them choose a proprietary solution instead
- p0w3n3d 3y agoGiving example of Amazon: their vendor lock-in does not allow to reuse most of AWS code and requires companies to take a "happily-everafter" marriage with their tech, that's why clients, when trying to disable vendor lock-in, spend a lot of money to create facades that would allow to use different cloud providers, but usually they fail (anecdotal evidence only)
- gtsop 3y agoOpen source is rotting the ground benieth propriatary software companies. Those who have understood this fact have shifted their strategy. Every piece of software can and will eventually be open sourced. It is only a matter or time. The silly argument saying open source lags behind, by comparing specific pieces of software, does nkt hold. There are pieces of open source software that are miles ahead of propriatary counterparts and which dont stand a chance in catching up. The productive force of millions of developers piecing togetger gazillions of open source pieces of software is (and will become even more) unmatched by single company entities. Companies will not be able to hire the hords of people that are/will be working on some open source piece of software for free.