13 ms·
OpenAI's misalignment and Microsoft's gain
- floor_ 3y agoShengjia Zhao's deleted tweet: https://i.imgur.com/yrpXvt9.png https://i.imgur.com/yrpXvt9.png
- mandmandam 3y ago[flagged]
- hutzlibu 3y ago"The Anthropocene Extinction." Currently I see no downward trend in human population.
- bdsa 3y agoIt's not humans going extinct
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoYet!
- whelp_24 3y agoHe didn't make it up, https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction . The extinction (so far) is of other species not humans.
- hutzlibu 3y agoI see, thanks for clearing that up.
- reqo 3y agoThe author is simply stating the facts, not putting the blame on anyone! It has historically been extremly hard to motivate people with anything other than money, at least at a coporate level. Even ideals such as religion where money and power are not the focus have been eventually used as a mean to gain money and power!
- manyoso 3y agoThis makes it seem like all altruistic non-profit endeavors have never worked which is obviously not the case.
- jprete 3y agoI think most people don’t see it that way. Most people, once their basic physical needs are met, will look for social goods - belonging, relationships, prestige, and sex. Some people are unusually motivated by new experiences and knowledge as well. The need for belonging is historically way more powerful than the need for money. Belonging can get someone to put themselves in harm’s way for the group at large. Money doesn’t do that unless the employee is either desperate or confident of their personal survival.
- Applejinx 3y agoMoney IS power. As youtuber Beau puts it, 'power coupons'. It's a fatal mistake to look at the human species, a fiercely competitive killer ape that cooperates on nearly a eusocial level, and acknowledge only the competitive side. It's even worse to look at this killer ape's killer side and conclude that THAT is all intelligence is, or ever will be. You've only got half the facts. Do better. AGI will have to do better or we'll be creating paperclip maximizers where the paperclips are 'tyranny', on purpose, because we thought we had to.
- Herring 3y agoYeah that sentiment in the article reflects a common mistake in America regarding capitalism. Many countries, from Western Europe to Japan and New Zealand, already outperform the U.S. in key metrics like average lifespans, social mobility, and rankings of "happiest countries to live in" (where the U.S. often ranks around 15th).
- zone411 3y agoThe pre-open market doesn't see it as a big win for MSFT. The stock is still lower than it was at Friday's open.
- alexb_ 3y agoIf Mr. Market was perfectly rational and correct, profit would cease to exist.
- panragon 3y agoThat's not true, Capital would still accumulate returns higher than the cost of inventory plus wages, the return would just be the same 'everywhere', and you'd have a perfect market alpha for all stocks, whether it be 1, 2, 5, or 10%. Even perfectly rational markets do not establish socialism overnight. Now maybe you could argue under a Marxist lens that exploitation would be more 'visible', causing socialism to arrive out of social rebellion faster, but that's really besides the point. What would cease to exist would simply be speculation and arbitrage. Since all prices are perfect, you simply wouldn't be able to make more (or even less, for that matter) money than the return on capital everyone gets by buying and selling shares quickly.
- latency-guy2 3y agoWhy? That is a gigantic statement to make to provide no backing for.
- HarHarVeryFunny 3y agoIt doesn't seem like it is a big win for MSFT. Hard to argue that MSFT is now in a better position than they were before this happened. Best case scenario for MSFT probably would have been to negotiate Altman et al back to OpenAI with some governance changes to boost stability. Keep the OpenAI GPT-N momentum going that they have harnessed for themselves. MSFT have managed to neutralize (for now) the threat of Altman et al creating a competitor, but this has come at the cost of souring their relationship with OpenAI who they will continue to be dependent on for AI for next couple of years. Big question here is what happens to OpenAI - can they keep the momentum going, and how do they deal with their sugar-daddy & compute-provider MSFT now also being a competitor? How much of the team will leave, and can they recover from that ?
- dboreham 3y agoUnusually well written and apparently well informed article.
- macintux 3y agoBen Thompson has been a keen observer of the tech industry for quite some time. I recommend browsing the archives, or HN’s history of submissions. https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=stratechery.com https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=stratechery.com
- nimish 3y agoIf the openai board can't get humans to align, what hope do they have of "aligning" ml models?
- catchnear4321 3y agopeople in alignment with each other is agreement. a language model in alignment is control. the model does not need to be aligned with the desires of people. just person. it could be people, but getting alignment with people is…
- manyoso 3y agoLOL This is more of the Altman based media blitz to drive this in his favor. This is nothing short of an unmitigated DISASTER for Microsoft and they well know it.
- flappyeagle 3y agoYou keep saying this. Why?
- edgyquant 3y agoNot them but it’s not a good look to spend 10B in a bet for zero control. Also to spend months building up to an acquisition (there’s no way that wasn’t what Sam was trying for) only for it to result in the firing of the CEO who was trying to sell his company to you. This looks terrible, and all of these “Sam is the real winner” posts are cope
- flappyeagle 3y agoThe majority of that money is in the form of Azure credit. It all pretty much hinges on how much talent you think Microsoft can obtain. I’m going to make a bet that Microsoft poaches between 30 and 70% of open AI key employees. If they spent $10 billion to achieve this outcome, securing the loyalty of the two founders and attracting double digit percentage of the employees, then they will have conservatively gotten a 5 to 10x return overnight Edit: I was too conservative, it's looking like 90%
- maxdoop 3y agoIs there anything that would persuade you this isn’t some sneaky media frenzy orchestrated by Altman?
- vouaobrasil 3y agoIt may be OpenAI's loss and Microsoft's gain, but any support that AI gets is a tragedy for humanity. Everything is good in moderation, and with AI we are taking our efficiency past that good point. AI not only takes jobs away from creatives such as illustrators and can be used for identity theft, it also is removing the reliance that people have on each other. Society is held together because people need each other. People meet each other through needing each other, and this is what makes local communities strong. AI takes that away so that the only entities we need are big tech like Microsoft, Google, and other soulless organizations. It is a descent into feudalism, where everyone will pay big tech for basic living necessities (first option, later a necessity, like the smartphone). If a man or woman wants to live independently of big tech, it will be harder and harder now, and we are losing are sense of what it means to be human through the immoral actions of these companies.
- kumarvvr 3y agoYup. The world we are headed into, accelerated by huge leaps in technology like AI, will be a sorry, pathetic, unforgiving world, that amplifies suffering and nullifies humanity. Is that image of a child being assaulted by terrorists real or fake? To the victims, its real, to political powers it fake, to mega corporations, its money.
- ChatGTP 3y agoI can't believe I'm playing devil's advocate here because I'm generally a skeptical / pessimistic person, but what? The world we are headed into, accelerated by huge leaps in technology like AI, will be a sorry, pathetic, unforgiving world, that amplifies suffering and nullifies humanity. Is that what has happened so far in your life? Technology has messed it up for you ?
- vouaobrasil 3y agoI think technology has messed up a lot of lives. Sure, we've got good healthcare and resources in the first-world, but smaller communities are eroding to the global force of technology. Don't bully people into not expressing critical thought by emphasizing that they have their basic physical needs met. We should be critical of society, even if on the surface it seems pretty good. We also have more advanced psychological needs such as the need to depend on others, and that is what is at stake here.
- shmatt 3y agoI can’t believe people are cheerleading this move * Tigris is DOA - If because it would piss off the MSFT board but mostly because the SEC would arrest Sam assuming he’s an officer at MSFT. He could maybe be a passive investor, but that’s it * People really think many Open Ai employees will give up their equity to get whatever mediocre stock grant their level at Microsoft has? And 1% raises, no bonus some years, and the board forced headcount reductions? * Sam has even less power with the board, and the board in a 3 trillion dollar corporation would be even more risk averse than the OpenAI one * there was a ton of fan fiction yesterday online about Satya forcing a move on the board. This was never really a thing. He made one of the worst investments in the history of SV in terms of keeping power to make sure your money is used correctly. $10B for 0 votes or any power to change votes
- asimovfan 3y agoMicrosoft can offer more if it wishes, no?
- blibble 3y agobut they can't offer the whole "we are doing this for the benefit of humanity" lark will researchers that were lured into OpenAI under this pretense jump ship to explictly work on extending microsoft's tendrils into more of people's lives? (essentially the opposite of "benefit humanity") no doubt some will
- vikramkr 3y agoI don't think Microsoft cares about that crowd, since now without capital they can't really do anything anyway. The rest of the crowd that wants to make bank? Might be more appealing
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> without capital they can't really do anything Not a bad moment for a rich patron to swoop in and capitalise the non-profit. If only there were a billionaire with a grudge against Altman and historic link to the organisation…
- dpflan 3y agoIt really depends what actually happens, on paper OpenAI business leadership is now at MSFT. Research leadership seems to be at OpenAI. What does OpenAI need to pursue its goal? One may argue that hiring developed under ex-OpenAI leadership was to facilitate the productization of the models. Does someone know the actual engineering/product/research makeup of the OpenAI that can provide substance?
- woliveirajr 3y ago> Two years later, and the commitment to “openly share our plans and capabilities along the way” was gone; three years after that and the goal of “advanc[ing] digital intelligence” was replaced by “build[ing] general-purpose artificial intelligence”. Be no evil, for example. Billions and billions were made when that phrase was erased.
- padolsey 3y agoI'm a bit confused. Does MSFT have a perpetual license to the original OpenAI LLC's IP *or* the capped company OpenAI "Global" LLC that was specifically created for MSFT's stake? Because, if the latter, it seems like the new/abandoned/forsaken OpenAI could just fork any new IP back into its original non-microsoft-stained LLC and not be mere tools of Microsoft moving forward.
- manyoso 3y agoUndoubtedly they have a perpet on what they released so far: chatgpt4. Not so for new innovations or tech.
- padolsey 3y agoSo when the author states that "Microsoft just acquired OpenAI for $0" they mean, effectively, only a fixed-time snapshot of code that is likely old news in about 18 months by the time other models have caught up. Microsoft still needs to execute like mad to make this work out for them. Right now the entire thing seems to rest on the hope that enough talent bleeds out of OpenAI to make this worthwhile. They'll probably get that. But it's still a delicate game. I most wonder what breakthrough Ilya has been alluding to recently [1] and whether it'll be available under MSFT's license. [1] https://youtu.be/Ft0gTO2K85A?si=YaawmLi8zKrFxwue&t=2303 https://youtu.be/Ft0gTO2K85A?si=YaawmLi8zKrFxwue&t=2303
- bamboozled 3y agoPlenty of them can go to Google, Anthropic, Apple, Tesla, Amazon or any other attractive company to work for. By attractive I mean they'd be compensated well enough to have a nice life there. There's not a lot to suggest everyone will jut join M$ by default.
- Terretta 3y agoIf you have: - intellectual property as of today - the servers that run it - the people that wrote it - the executive leadership that executed the play so far and know the roadmap ahead What else do you need?
- m_ke 3y agoJust a tip for OpenAI employees that plan on leaving: this is probably one of the best opportunities you’ll ever get to start your own thing. If you’re joining a new startup make sure you’re a founder and have a good chunk of the equity. For the next few months there will be a line of investors waiting at your door to give you money at a wild valuation, take it and do what you always wanted and know that if it doesn’t work out there will be plenty of large companies ready to acquire you for much more than they’d ever be willing to pay you.
- lewisjoe 3y agoTLDR: Open AI structured its organization such that there's no boss. And even if there is one, it's not about the money. Reality hits Open AI: There is always a boss and it's always about money.
- bigEnotation 3y agoI feel like I’m missing something about this chatGPT craze… to me the product is chatGPT, and it’s mostly fleshed out (would like to see the ability to upload an image, as part of a conversation), I don’t see the appeal for paying 100x more for every new iteration for a marginal reduction in misinformation. To me the target user of chatGPT needs to have some level of expertise in the domain their asking a question, as based on how gpt works, chatGPT will eventually produce an output with misinformation, therefore someone familiar with the subject matter would have a higher chance at catching the nuance in a response and be able to continue their conversation.
- maxdoop 3y agoYou are 100% missing something. You don’t see the current value nor potential of what these LLMs are capable of. They are as “dumb” as they will ever be right now. To act like it’s just a chat bot is the silliest take.
- lysecret 3y agoReally absolutely fascinating to see this unfold. I believe more and more the most realistic explanation is the next GPT will be mind-blowing.
- toth 3y agoThe analysis in the article is mostly very good, but I object to this observation `The biggest loss of all, though, is a necessary one: the myth that anything but a for-profit corporation is the right way to organize a company.` I don't see how anything that happened this weekend leads to this conclusion. Yes, it seems likely that the board's actions will result in an OpenAI with much smaller revenue and consumer traction. But the whole reason for setting up OpenAI as a non-profit was precisely ensuring that those were not the overriding goals of the company. The only conclusion that seems warranted is that "the myth that anything but a for-profit corporation is the right way to organize a for-profit company.", but that is pretty obvious.
- anonylizard 3y agoIt means that those 'organisations' can never scale, and therefore make the titanic impacts on society they hoped to have. No investors will touch these non-profits with a 10 foot pole now. An unaccountable board that can lead the majority of the company and investors to revolt is radioactive for investors. It proves that the shares=votes, standard corporate structure is the only way to organize mega scale organizations. OpenAI will keep its goals, but it'll simply accomplish nothing. It'll probably devolve into some niche lab with no resources or GPUs to do anything significant.
- BryantD 3y agoWould you say Wikipedia has had a significant impact on society?
- mschuster91 3y agoOf course it has. Wikipedia is the first (and only) truly global source of knowledge, to a depth no other encyclopedia has ever covered before - and with an unmatched capability to react to current events.
- hgomersall 3y agoRight! The Wikimedia Foundation is dead in the water, and everyone except Jimmy knows it. If only it could raise hundreds of millions in capital from investors then they could actually start delivering value and get significant market share.
- mymusewww 3y agoPeople are thinking this guy is rich. He’s a pawn like anyone else without a billion dollars. This means nothing for tech.
- superultra 3y agoAnyone here that has worked with a non-profit can recognize the scenario of boards operating untethered by the sometimes more relatable profit motive. I think what remains to be seen is who is on the right side of history. The real loser here is probably ethical AI. I know this won’t be a popular opinion around here, but it’s clear to me that with computing and AI, we may be in an echo of the Industrial Revolution where the profit motive of the 19th century led to deep human injustices like child labor and unsafe and inhumane working conditions. Except of course that AI could have even more impact - both positive and negative, in the same way socmed has.
- Nasrudith 3y agoIf you think child labor or unsafe and inhumane working conditions started with the industrial revolution your history teachers have deeply failed you. Those existed long before industrialization. Hell, for most of history education was child labor!
- superultra 3y agoI was a history teacher! And you are absolutely correct that of course child labor existed prior to the industrial revolution. But the industrial revolution introduced systematicized, institutionalized child labor and unsafe working conditions at a sense of exponential scale and density. Which is why it's illegal now, which we would all agree is a good thing, whether it happened before or not.
- artisin 3y agoIt does lend credence to an emerging landscape trend that suggests large companies, not disruptive startups, will dominate AI development due to high costs and infrastructure needs.
- photochemsyn 3y agoI really see no reason that LLMs can't go the way of operating systems when it comes to the success of the open-source approach vs. the proprietary closed-source approach. The argument over for-profit vs. non-profit is largely meaningless, as anyone who is paying attention knows that 'non-profits' just use different methods to distribute the revenue than for-profits do, using various smoke-and-mirrors approaches to retain their legal status. Arguably a non-profit might put more revenue back into R & D and less into kickbacks to VC investors but that's not always the case. Additionally, given all the concerns about "AI safety" open-source seems like the better approach, as this is a much better framework for exposing biases, whether intentional or accidental. There are many successful models for financing the open-source approach, as Linux has shown.
- akamaka 3y agoThis article is missing the point that, for decades, Microsoft has been trying and failing to hire the best AI researchers. They might succeed at commercializing the current generation of LLMs, but the revolutionary breakthroughs will still happen elsewhere, in an organization that is built for researchers.
- Eumenes 3y agoGiven Microsoft is an apparatus of the US federal government and globalization in general, I suspect TPTB are pretty content with this outcome.
- asb 3y ago> Here’s the reality of the matter, though: whether or not you agree with the Sutskever/Shear tribe, the board’s charter and responsibility is not to make money. This is not a for-profit corporation with a fiduciary duty to its shareholders; [...] to the extent the board believes that Altman and his tribe were not “build[ing] general-purpose artificial intelligence that benefits humanity” it is empowered to fire him; they do, and so they did. I would quibble with this slightly. They do have a right to fire, but they're doing a poor job of working in the not-for-profit's interests if they do so in a way that collapses the value of their biggest asset (the for-profit), especially when other options are potentially available. e.g. a negotiated exit, providing proper warning to their investors etc etc.
- btbuildem 3y agoInteresting and insightful read - definitely seems like someone has been paying attention throughout. I can't get past this snippet: > they ultimately had no leverage because they weren’t a for-profit company with the capital to be truly independent. Maybe I don't understand non-profits, but.. they're allowed to amass a war chest for expansion and to pay for dependencies, right? They're not compelled by charter to have no capital like some sort of a corporate equivalent of a monk -- it's just OpenAI that did not have enough capital to grant them better negotiating terms. How is that different from any other startup that gives up ownership of its IP in exchange for investment?
- pgsandstrom 3y agoThis article read to me like someone tryint to shoehorn "non-profits sucks" into an otherwise interesting narrative.
- magarnicle 3y agoIn this case, I think it's "non-profits suck" for business analysts. How can you predict what those do-gooders will get up to if they sometimes refuse to make the numbers get bigger?
- asimovfan 3y agoI think this mainly means they dont pay out dividends to shareholders
- amadeuspagel 3y agoIt's different from other startups, because other startups can promise potentially infinite returns in exchange for investments, while Open AI had capped returns.
- btbuildem 3y agoThat sounds like the very likely most notable difference.
- dalbasal 3y agoWell written. Well done. Early hn vibes. A lot more in here, that actually helps to understand what's going on with openai, and what might happen next in the space. I think the last paragraph is a key point/question. "Ultimately, though, one could make the argument that not much has changed at all: it has been apparent for a while that AI was, at least in the short to medium-term, a sustaining innovation, not a disruptive one, which is to say it would primarily benefit and be deployed by the biggest companies. The costs are so high that it’s hard for anyone else to get the money... ..This, in the end, was Nadella’s insight: the key to winning if you are big is not to invent like a startup, but to leverage your size to acquire or fast-follow them." Use models like innovative disruption with caution. Look to their assumptions. How this plays out is not going to follow the pattern of web 2.0 or Kodak digitization. The road to AGI is one thing. The road to 1 billion market caps.. not necessarily that same thing. The road to victory, or definition of victory, are very vague still.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pklhr 3y agoDrama continues. I think he might regret publishing this a wee bit early :)
- neilv 3y ago> This is, quite obviously, a phenomenal outcome for Microsoft. I don't know whether that's true, nor do I know went on, but it seems interesting to consider... If OpenAI were government, and the history involved awarding a contract, or administering regulations, we have the concept of a revolving door.
- kbknapp 3y agoSeems the author is expecting OAI to continue merrily along its way working towards AGI (albeit at a stated slower pace) while MSFT is able to take Altman et al and circle the wagons on what already exists (GPT4) squeezing it for all its worth. While that's entirely possible, there are other outcomes not nearly as positive that would put MSFT at a disadvantage. It's like saying MSFT's AI hedge is built on what appears like sand; maybe it's stable, maybe it's not.
- edgyquant 3y agoDon’t think they can just outright steal GPT4 and they definitely won’t be taking the world class data set with them
- timetraveller26 3y agoThe biggest problem of Artificial Intelligence are the humans running it
- SilverBirch 3y agoI can't imagine what it will be like to work at OpenAI over the next few months. A massive load of talent has just left, the primary source of investment has just taken exactly what you do and brought it in house. Even if you wanted to stay at OpenAI how can you reasonably believe that MS will continue providing the compute and investment necessary for you to retain leadership? It just seems impossible. It may be that in the medium term this move means OpenAI is going to back to more research focus, because I just don't see how the MS partnership strategy makes any sense as a long term strategy now.
- chasd00 3y ago“ Finally, late Sunday night, Satya Nadella announced via tweet that Altman and Brockman, “together with colleagues”, would be joining Microsoft” Called it, EEE is complete. This is old Microsoft magic. I hope younger people starting their careers are taking note. All that money gates is giving away to buy his way into heaven came from the same tactics.
- ajryan 3y agoEmbrace, Enhance, Extinguish for those unfamiliar.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoExtend is the middle E.
- boringg 3y agoAll the shade going the board (legit) - that said Altman and Brockman just lost so much of their independence its unbelievable - sad state of affairs that its being described as a win for them (or a good salvage). Also - everyone is pinning the board for all the problems ... everybody's hands are dirty here that it even got to this point. What a mess.
- PoignardAzur 3y ago... What? How is this in any way related to EEE? The OpenAI board did this to themselves.
- debacle 3y agoWe can't know that - this may have been orchestrated.
- simiones 3y agoBy someone on the board, with the approval and participation of the rest of the board. So, the board did it to themselves. Or do you think MS fabricated evidence to falsely convince the board Sam Altman was lying to them?
- jebarker 3y ago> What gives me pause is that the goal is not an IPO, retiring to a yacht, and giving money to causes that do a better job of soothing the guilt of being fabulously rich than actually making the world a better place. Ouch. Is that really the ideal vision of founding a SV startup?
- nemo44x 3y agoThe best part of Satya’s tweet is that he opens it with “we’re committed to our partnership with OpenAI” and then mentions that he’s hiring Sam and Greg and “colleagues”. Nearly spat my tea out laughing at that one. Well played.
- burntalmonds 3y agoI don't think MS expects this to really happen. It's negotiation, designed to make OAI's board come to their senses and reinstate Altman.
- lightedman 3y agoI wonder if MS is aware of the allegations against Sam Altman, which were put forth by his sister, of sexual, financial, and other abuse.
- leoc 3y ago> The biggest loss of all, though, is a necessary one: the myth that anything but a for-profit corporation is the right way to organize a company. Hmmmh? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Bosch_Stiftung https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Bosch_Stiftung https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tata_Sons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tata_Sons If anything it seems like the more likely lesson is that Altman manoeuvred OpenAI into a situation which was incompatible with its non-profit objectives.
- xxpor 3y agoThe Bosche example doesn't really match: >Although the charity is funded by owning the vast majority of shares, it has no voting rights and is involved in health and social causes unrelated to Bosch's business There's also the example of Ikea's ownership structure, but that's just a giant tax dodge.
- leoc 3y ago> The Bosch example doesn't really match Yes, I think you're right there.
- airstrike 3y agoI'd retitle this as "OpenAI's blunder and Microsoft's excellent damage control" I don't think Microsoft is necessarily in a better position than it was on Thursday. If we're tallying up points: + More control over the full AI stack + Effectively they will own what was once OpenAI, but is now really OpenAI 2.0 - OpenAI 2.0 is probably a worse business than OpenAI 1.0, which was, prior to the coup, a well-oiled machine + Control over OpenAI 2.0 operations, which can lead to better execution in the long term - Higher wage costs - Business disruption at OpenAI, delaying projects - Potential OpenAI departures to competitors like Google, Meta, Anthropic, Amazon, Apple (?) - Risk that OpenAI 1.0 (what's left of it) either sells to any of those competitors - Risk that OpenAI 1.0 actually goes open source and releases GPT-4 weights
- oakashes 3y agoSeems like a pretty good list, but I think a lot depends on how much you weight each item and how many of the negatives were already "priced in" to the status quo ante when Microsoft was strategically linked to OpenAI without any formal control.
- codeisawesome 3y agoGPT-4 weights, the RLHF s/w & logs, data sources … if all of that were truly open, it would be incredible.
- fbdab103 3y ago>Risk that OpenAI 1.0 (what's left of it) either sells to any of those competitors Who else is positioned that they could possibly do anything with it commercially? Even Microsoft is supposedly renting GPUs from Oracle (deals with the devil!) to keep up with demand. Amazon is the only other company with the potential computational power + business acumen to strike, but they already have their own ventures. Google could, but not sure they would willingly take the reputation hit to use a non-Google model.
- fomine3 3y agoOpenAI 1.0 to become Netscape? It's great if it happen.
- firexcy 3y agoI can never understand Stratechery's obsession with overquoting, and it just becomes more unhinged over the years. Every weekly post comes down to something like: hey, have you heard of the latest tech news X, as I wrote long before (super long quotes), and as I read somewhere else (super long quotes), (some piggybacked observations).
- amadeuspagel 3y agoA thought experiment to illustrate the incoherence of OpenAI's structure. Imagine a company called ProfitAI, a company without any limits on profit and returns, and thus able to raise much more money then OpenAI and using that money to license the base models from OpenAI. Microsoft played the role of ProfitAI here. The non-profit structure only served to ensure that someone else would make the profits.
- rekuber 3y agoThe real loser in this chaos is Microsoft. Remember skype? Microsoft had to buy it twice to gain usable access to IP.
- charles_f 3y ago> you can make the case that Microsoft just acquired OpenAI for $0. You would first have to make the case that those $11B that gave them the perpetual access to IP are worth $0. Probably not the market cap of OpenAI, but also not 0.
- kaycebasques 3y ago> The biggest loss of all, though, is a necessary one: the myth that anything but a for-profit corporation is the right way to organize a company. This is a big picture idea that we should examine more closely. Right now, in the heat of the chaotic collapse, it's easy to conclude that for-proft corp structure is the only way to go. But I think we should take a "proof is in the pudding" approach and remember all the amazing things that OpenAI accomplished under it's non-conventional org structure. Maybe that non-conventional org structure was a key ingredient in OpenAI's success? Sure, we now know that "long-term stability" does not seem to be a quality of this org structure, but nonetheless it seemed to have lots of other desirable qualities.
- typon 3y agoWhy does it have to be all or nothing? Why not non-profit in the start when you need to attract scientists and engineers who are in it for the challenge, and then change to for profit when you need to attract product managers and people who will scale the company and make it sustainable.
- leetharris 3y agoIt's so weird that people think a bunch of personnel moving to MS is a win for MS. They can't just magically recreate what OpenAI has done. The data sets, the tooling, the models, the everything around it. It will take so long for MS to catch up even if they had 100% of their people working on it tomorrow. The rest of the market is going to benefit more than MS.
- tedivm 3y agoTheir contract with OpenAI gives them unlimited access to the data sets, the tooling (which is all on Azure and was built out with the help of Azure engineers), the models and their weights, and basically everything around it.
- RadixDLT 3y agoOpenAI's co-founder Ilya Sutskever and more than 500 other employees have threatened to quit the embattled company after its board dramatically fired CEO Sam Altman. In an open letter to the company's board, which voted to oust Altman on Friday, the group said it is obvious 'that you are incapable of overseeing OpenAI'. Sutskever is a member of the board and backed the decision to fire Altman, before tweeting his 'regret' on Monday and adding his name to the letter. Employees who signed the letter said that if the board does not step down, they 'may choose to resign' en masse and join 'the newly announced Microsoft subsidiary run by Sam Altman'.
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago> Sutskever is a member of the board and backed the decision to fire Altman, before tweeting his 'regret' on Monday and adding his name to the letter. Employees who signed the letter said that if the board does not step down, This reads like a disingenuous strategy to get rid of the other three members (one half) of the board. A real coup, not a fake one. I know nothing about any of these people, but it seems possible Sutskever convinced the board to make a decision that he knew would have an outcome that would end in them being fiduciarily obliged to resign so that he, Altman, and Brockman could come back as the entirety of the board. And if the hiring by MS is involved, then MS would then control the board of the non-profit.
- ayakang31415 3y agoOpenAI was non-profit to begin with. Their shenanigans to tip-toeing the line between charity and commercialization were, as it seems, doomed to fail.
- Futurebot 3y ago"The biggest loss of all, though, is a necessary one: the myth that anything but a for-profit corporation is the right way to organize a company." Alternatively, we could have these companies turned into research organizations run by the government and funded by taxes they way most research (e.g. pharmaceuticals) should be. There's more than one way to get good research done, and having it public removes many strange incentives and conflicts of interest.
- xxpor 3y agoCompare OpenAI's funding to the national labs. Sandia and Los Alamos both receive about $4.5 billion per fiscal year. OpenAI is likely spending an order of magnitude more than that.
- asadotzler 3y agoReally? OAI spending 45 billion dollars a year with fewer than 1,000 employees? Seems unlikely.
- specificcndtion 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38350637 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38350637 : "None of these companies appease China; they refuse to provide service under those conditions and/or they are IP range blocked. Microsoft does service China with Bing, for example. You should not sell OpenAI's to China or to Microsoft, [or to China or Russia through Microsoft] Especially after a DDOS by Sue Don and a change in billing. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_websites_blocked_in_mainland_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_websites_blocked_in_ma...
- ecshafer 3y agoSo? What does it matter if China is blocked?
- cleandreams 3y agoI worked for a startup acquired by Microsoft and suffice to say, MS is a culture killer. Our open dynamism and free discussion withered under a blanket of MS management. I don't think it's possible that the cultures of OpenAI and MS can be made compatible. MS is dreary. Highly effective at productizing, yes. But the culture that propels deep innovation -- that is not going to last.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoWas that under Nadella, though? Things have changed quite a bit, as I understand it.
- cleandreams 3y agoYes, Nadella.
- JetSpiegel 3y agoYes, Microsoft is the new trillion dollar corporation with a human face.