9 ms·
I cancelled my Replit subscription
- echelon 3y agoWhat's the draw of Replit? What does it give you that Codespaces doesn't?
- gardenhedge 3y agoWhat's the draw of either of them? I just code locally. What am I missing?
- rockwotj 3y agoYou’re not missing anything. The draw of these is a one click opinioned setup (containerized for codespaces). It does save a lot of time, but as someone who enjoys tweaking neovim config I don’t feel the draw. That being said, I did setup a codespace for a one click to try a new feature product and that was very cool.
- n2d4 3y agoIf you also enjoy tweaking VSCode configs, you can sync it with your GitHub account and all your configs will apply to Codespaces as well
- n2d4 3y agoIf you work on several projects in different environments and languages, and need to check out new ones quickly, it saves a lot of time if you don't have to set up an environment locally (especially if you don't even have the necessary platform or hardware).
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoI work in embedded, but we just pushed out VSCode Dev Containers (docker images that natively run a vscode server that your client attaches to) and it has been the greatest thing ever. Clone the repo, open in container, complete toolchain with all the extensions and settings you’ll need. I absolutely love it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- YetAnotherNick 3y agoThe only thing I could think of is automatic syncing between devices. I have tried various options for this on PC, but this simple looking problem is far from solved.
- esafak 3y agoI use replit for coding interviews -- pair coding -- so I am interested in the "code" more than the "space". Can you use Codespaces for that?
- danvoell 3y agoI recently started paying for it. The simplicity from taking code from chatGPT to testing in realtime in the cloud, to deploying to production is amazing. Granted I am a hack developer but its created a new world for me. I'm done trying to create local development environments, I've wasted too much time in that regard. Edit: If I figured out a production app that had legs, I would move it away to save on costs. It's more of a test space for me.
- arcanemachiner 3y ago> I'm done trying to create local development environments I went the other way. I suppose it depends on the nature of the project, but I can spin up a new environment in a couple of minutes. Maybe a couple more if I need to configure a Docker container.
- api 3y agoReplit is one of those dystopian things that I hope fails. Let’s move programming entirely into an environment where you don’t own your data, can’t duplicate or fully understand the runtime, are subject to total surveillance and the harvesting of your data for AI training and other monetization, and must pay rent forever with the constant threat of a rug pull. Great idea. The thing I find most dystopian about it is that it’s aimed at beginners in a lot of ways. So you could have a generation raised up that doesn’t understand the idea of general purpose compute under their own control at all. Basically it’s the last nail in the coffin of personal computing.
- samsartor 3y agoAt my old university one of the intro classes moved all their students to Replit. Which might have been fine in isolation, but I think it created a year of students who struggled endlessly to use gcc, Makefiles, debuggers, or local tooling in general. Starting your CS journey with the local command line seems to put you into the perfect headspace right off the bat, even if it is a little slower to get going.
- ethbr1 3y agoIMHO, the ugliest part of local environments is the OS, and fighting with interactions. But VMs can abstract away most of this, especially in a learning environment where performance isn't a primary goal. Then you can have a known-good set of instructions that doesn't have to include messing with whatever Apple/Microsoft/Ubuntu changed recently.
- mattmcknight 3y agoDocker was getting us pretty close to this until the M1 Macs came out and our Intel CPU presumptions blew up.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 3y ago
- _sword 3y agoIn an open market with alternatives I can’t really sympathize with points of view such as “I don’t like that pricing went up so my vendor can be profitable.” If you like a product and want it to be available long term, you would want it to be a self sustaining business, not a cash bonfire.
- paxys 3y agoEspecially considering there isn't a high barrier to entry in the space and there are a hundred alternatives, with more popping up every day. If a polished, fully-featured service charging like $10/mo is too much then it's really your expectations that are the problem.
- pantsforbirds 3y agoIf you don't want the AI features it would make sense to be unhappy with the pricing changes.
- okdood64 3y agoThat's fine. > so my vendor can be profitable But this is a ridiculous notion.
- Msw242 3y agoNo it's not. You do want your vendors to make money working with you. That way they are incentivized to help.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoGoogle makes money from me, and is thoroughly enshittified. The goal of business is state-backed monopoly and extraction, which is not always aligned with or predicated on user value. I generally find superior value from sources that are less singularly profit motivated such as worker-owned organizations or public goods providers
- pbhjpbhj 3y ago
- cantSpellSober 3y agoFrom the linked article: > Lisp is the language that comes most natural to me, I'm most productive with, and gives me joy and not just fun Can you elaborate on why please? It feels relevant to this article.
- pamoroso 3y agoI'm the author of the linked post. I'm not sure what you're specifically interested in as coming natural, being productive, and giving joy are largely subjective reasons for preferring a language. For example, I can say in Lisp it's easier for me to start writing and evolving programs which in turn allows me to produce more code than in other languages. As for the joy, it comes in part from the instant gratification of a low friction environment where you can evaluate -- and see running -- anything from an individual atom to a full program.
- cantSpellSober 3y agoThanks, sorry I wasn't more specific, I'm learning it and was just interested in your thoughts.
- canadianfella 3y ago[dead]
- imachine1980_ 3y agoNot the author, for me lisp is the only langues I can write in pen and paper, and I can think the code as simple a different mathematical notation, real lisp is little different than that but you can check the code and retry the part that works different than you expected, make me work in different level of abstraction than opp programming.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pyb 3y ago[flagged]
- 63 3y agoGiven the author's sentiment at the end of the article I'd say that's unlikely, but even if it was that's kind of irrelevant to the point at hand.
- pamoroso 3y agoI'm no ChatGPT :-) I'm the author of the linked post and I didn't use ChatGPT or other tools, not even a spell checker. But I'm not a native English speaker and my writing may come across quite differently.
- theusus 3y agoIt can’t run a simple C# code either. Shared resources I have remain at 100% all the time.
- odyssey7 3y agoIt sounds like the author is disappointed by Python and prefers Lisp, which isn’t as supported. I would suggest trying JavaScript. Its functional programming support is much better than Python’s, and it is widely supported.
- corethree 3y agoPythons functional programming support is quite good. Better than JavaScript imo. JavaScript doesn't support list comprehensions. Additionally python with a type checker supports sum types AND exhaustive pattern matching similar to haskell and rust. Typescript does not support this as far as I know. Outside of types the differences between the two languages are just sugar. Lisp on the other hand is something truly different.
- globular-toast 3y agoList comprehensions aren't very functional. A functional language would use higher-level functions like map and filter which JS absolutely has. One thing I always miss in languages like Python and JS is the identity function. I don't how people are writing all this functional code without it.
- rebeccaskinner 3y agoI don't really see how list comprehensions aren't functional- it's just a different notation for dealing with maps, filters, and cartesian products. Python borrowed list comprehensions from Haskell in the first place.
- pama 3y ago(not GP and I agree with you, and wanted to add some additional thoughts that may help others.) The comprehensions are great and have a functional flavor, sure. But when you hit the corner cases in Python you feel that the addition they provide to Python are not taking the language close to Haskell. Lambda functions within the Python comprehensions have limited power, reductions don’t work as nicely with comprehensions as map or filter; more generally, when you compose comprehensions things feel messy without the ability to pipe previous results to a next function, so you are using lots of intermediates and have to think of useful names which is hard. The end result can be good and closer to pseudo code, which is fantastic. However Python does not satisfy the need of many people used to lisp and often takes much longer to get right in those complex corner cases where Haskell or lisp would make validation and testing much easier.
- jacknews 3y agoIMHO replit is great for spinning up a dev configuration and doing some prototyping. It's also really good for teaching, and for sharing live-coded snipets and so on. I have no idea about using it for actual production coding, and deploying from a repl, as I haven't tried it because it it looks far less suitable than a traditional development workflow. But it seems like they've received some 'investment' that may be pushing them towards being an actual production tool. IMHO, this will cause them to lose their hobby, hacker, and education patrons, and still not win with serious professional, commercial ones.
- globular-toast 3y agoDoes it do anything a Docker image can't do?
- hipadev23 3y agoI stopped using replit when they got rid of their REPLs and replaced everything with this strange in-browser IDE thing.
- ydlr 3y agoThere is no VC funding for companies that offer simple, well-designed products at a reasonable price.
- curiousgal 3y agoI stopped using it when the CEO bullied an intern and threatened him with a lawsuit over a hobbyist project.
- esafak 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27424195 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27424195
- vlz 3y ago> Finally, like other development tool vendors, Replit is doubling down on AI coding features which affect the cost of paid plans. But I'm not interested in this as the whole point of my hobby programming is to write all the code myself and learn from the experience. I sometimes wish companies had „dumb“ plans where I could just pay less for the main product instead of the bolted on intelligence.
- totallywrong 3y agoThe next 5 years are going to be hell. Expect AI pushed into everything but the kitchen sink. With the accompanying price raises whether you want the "feature" or not.
- ravivyas 3y agoon a lighter note.. you meant "Expect AI pushed into everything and the kitchen sink" right? :)
- totallywrong 3y agoYou see that a lot, but the actual idiom is with but, look it up.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wycy 3y agoThe idiom is with “but,” but I think the joke is it’s going to be so pervasive that it’ll definitely be included in sinks too. There are already smart sinks so it’s pretty much inevitable.
- youcantcook 3y ago[flagged]
- 3y ago
- lovasoa 3y agoI use replit to give people a quick way to play with my open source projects online without installing anything on their computers (https://replit.com/@pimaj62145/SQLPage https://replit.com/@pimaj62145/SQLPage). But I have always been on the free plan. Their paid plans are indeed very expensive for what they offer.
- diamondfist25 3y agoI had a rat terrier growing up. It's born to go after rodent we thought. But it went after our pillows, stuffed animals, and shoes
- brianjking 3y agoI was paying for the $20 plan for quite some time and switched to the $7/month Hacker plan a month or two ago as it had everything I needed. Disappointed to see my only option is to pay nothing or $20. Overall, still love Replit, just unsure if I'll continue paying myself. Not because it's bad, but because I don't' necessarily need it.
- Sharlin 3y agoRather ironic that a service named REPLit doesn't support Lisp well…
- lispm 3y agoThey named their company after one of the core features of Lisp (where it was also discovered ~ 1960) and then they don't support it...
- mark_l_watson 3y agoI tried Replit for a]small Common Lisp and Clojure projects. It was OK, but I decided that I liked having a remote VPS with both languages and EMacs properly setup. My use case was being able to write code on my iPadPro while traveling or sitting in my living room. I don’t do that anymore, BTW.
- paulsutter 3y agoThere’s a good reason to provide AI even in the lowest plan, which means they need to charge a higher price: They’re focusing on AI capabilities at the core of the product, because they believe that’s the future of software development. It’s admirable that they can make such clear decisions rather than waffle in an attempt to make everyone happy Focus = Speed. Focus means saying no to the good to focus on the great
- pamoroso 3y agoI'm the author of the shared post and I blogged about the reactions to it, thanks all for the feedback: https://journal.paoloamoroso.com/reactions-to-my-post-on-cancelling-the-replit-subscription https://journal.paoloamoroso.com/reactions-to-my-post-on-can...
- varun_ch 3y agoOne thing I really liked about Replit is being able to spin up a public website really quickly and just 'code in production'. It's really great for one off projects/demos, I think they've removed that from the free plan now though. I built my own self-hosted Replit 'clone' for replicating that specific use case but under my control. I mapped a wildcard subdomain to my server and wrote a web IDE and backend using Docker's REST API and Openresty to spin up quick projects that are publicly accessible. It works really well for me, I haven't open sourced it because I don't know if anyone else would want it though. https://youtu.be/nITIMrND0Z0 https://youtu.be/nITIMrND0Z0
- djbusby 3y agoBefore dropping code you could do a series of blog posts on how all the pieces fit together. Those could generate some signal, to know of the next steps are worth it. I don't need that specific use case but I do love seeing the tricks folk do with Docker. Maybe all you have to share is a readme and compose yaml?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- samsquire 3y agoI was on the Hacker plan ($8 a month) but now I've been upgraded to the Core plan ($20 a month) and I pay annually but I'm guessing it won't change until renewal unless I've been grandfathered. It is definitely a big jump in cost. I use replit for my experimental projects when I just need a quick place to write some code to see how to do something. I use the git integration with GitHub which is really helpful. I wouldn't want to set up Nix myself, but I appreciate that the "replit.nix" is easy to add packages that are necessary.
- brianjking 3y agoYeah, I'm having this same problem too. I was paying $20, then switched to the $7 Hacker plan, now have been upgraded again to $20/month Replit Core. I am torn on what I'll do as I do see value in Replit and really like their product, but not sure I need it at $20/month.
- smoldesu 3y ago> I wouldn't want to set up Nix myself Why not? Even the official installer is pretty straightforward, the biggest bottleneck that comes to mind is setting your flakes up with the right template. Even then... I don't think I spend more than 15 minutes a month editing or fixing my flakes. It feels more like a superpowered makefile than a roadblock; I recommend learning the ins-and-outs even if you intend to stick with hosted environments.
- samsquire 3y agoI do like makefiles. I am not at the point I have a mental model of what Nix really is that I have with git. I understand it has something to do with derivations where each package is a collection of files at a given version and the data and state is immutable. Which reminds me of Git. It's also a programming language for expressions which evaluate to a hierarchy of files on disk. pkgs.git, pkgs.vim I find the tooling, command line utilities aren't immediately understandable to me. I just rely on that Replit have implemented the Nix integration so that when you change "replit.nix" it just updates the environment :-) I really ought to give an immutable desktop a go at some point such as Silverblue .
- yawboakye 3y agoi canceled my replit plan maybe a year and half ago. for similar-ish reasons. i loved the initial product (and evangelized of my own free will), not so much later iterations. making good use of replit now required some learning. considering that replit wasn’t a tool in any of my critical paths i didn’t feel the need to make the investment. i miss it though because i used to collaborate with my partner’s sister on her c++ code for her astrophysics work, and it was a huge learning opportunity for me. looking at the current trajectory of github, it looks like it may be a good replacement for replit v1, soon.
- ericjmorey 3y agoI'm not sure what required learning with the new version. It seems like it requires less prior knowledge to do more.
- dehrmann 3y ago> The other change is my shift of focus back to Lisp, the programming language I love most and know best. Part of this is that Replit is for people who want to get things done, but are intimidated by JetBrains's IDEs. Lisp is a language nerd's language. So really, you're not the target customer. > chromeOS lifestyle Maybe I'm out-of-touch, but I assumed Lisp hackers would be on something beefier. Yes, it's a "linux" laptop, but it'll be an uphill battle. I expected either a Linux Thinkpad or Framework, maybe Mac OS on a Macbook. I actually looked into ChromeOS for my grandma. She basically just browses the web, uses gmail, and plays Freecell, but the app situation made Freecell a non-starter.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- implements 3y ago> but I assumed Lisp hackers would be on something beefier. He’s using an “Intel CORE i7 ASUS Chromebox 3 with 16 GB RAM and 256 GB storage”. https://journal.paoloamoroso.com/why-i-use-a-chromebox https://journal.paoloamoroso.com/why-i-use-a-chromebox Previously discussed here, oddly enough: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32743576 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32743576
- dehrmann 3y agoInteresting quote from him: > realized I was living in Chrome anyway For average users, this fine, but for software development, I'd find it too limiting. I completely empathize with the hassle of maintaining a linux desktop. I use Windows for this reason. Servers are another story.