3 ms·
I think it is still fair to point out that it is a thought experiment on how to extract as much value in the form of taxes. It makes sense only if you see taxe
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
I think it is still fair to point out that it is a thought experiment on how to extract as much value in the form of taxes.
It makes sense only if you see taxes as a positive good, ignore the concept of ownership, and are pretty loose with the human suffering implications.
- anonymoushn 3y agoMaybe it makes sense if you've seen the human suffering implications of prop 13
- s1artibartfast 3y agoWhich are what exactly? The state has been setting record surpluses. Housing is very expensive, but that's due to a failure to build. Higher property taxes doesn't reduce the cost of ownership or make housing more affordable. This is like saying we should rise the tax rate on food because people are starving in the street
- clarifyingN 3y ago[flagged]
- kadoban 3y agoYou could consider being more humble and polite, especially if you're going to be wrong. (Note that they said _state_, your numbers are national).
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Housing is very expensive, but that's due to a failure to build. The low maximum property tax rate and systematic failure to tax full value created by Prop 13 is a reason for the failure to build. (Now, actually, I think residential property tax is a horribly regressive tax, and its better to fund government by progressive income taxes, but there needs to be a funding allocation formula that gives local government more of an incentive for development; California has adopted some limits on discretion and consequences for not meeting targets as a stick, but that's not enough to encourage good positive planning.)
- s1artibartfast 3y ago>The low maximum property tax rate and systematic failure to tax full value created by Prop 13 is a reason for the failure to build. Only by indirect argument. IF homeowners were taxed more, they would be more sensitive to housing costs in general, and perhaps more inclined to expanding the housing stock. Given that the government is funded, this would simply be a punitive tax incentive to motivate policy. I don't particularly buy the lack of local government incentive. New development is already taxed at substantially higher rates relative to older stock due to prop 13. If expanding the tax base were a major driver of policy, then we would expect to be building already.
- imtringued 3y agoPeople don't block commercial construction because it raises property values. They block residential construction because it lowers their property values. You get an imbalance of jobs to housing and then people complain about expensive housing.
- lokar 3y agoOne issue with prop 13 has been a major shift in (property) tax burden from large commercial to residential owners. Also, a big shift in overall revenue from property tax to income tax. This is less stable source and tends to benefit the investor class over W2 earners.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI tend to agree that companies that never die should not have the same protections that homeowners or small businesses do. My point was rather that props through 13 isn't what's driving the cost of housing up in California. In fact it does the opposite. If Prop 13 were removed, taxes for new home buyers would go down, enabling even higher costs.
- jfim 3y agoProp 13 is one factor that's driving the cost of housing up in California. Vacant lots are taxed based on their purchase price, so there's no real reason to develop them when the land value keeps on rising while the taxes don't. Commercial zoned buildings aren't affected by prop 13, which leads to more revenue for the cities, hence them preferring commercial development to housing. All that prop 13 does is favor people who bought real estate decades ago, at the detriment of everyone else.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI am extremely skeptical that the few vacant lots are enough to counterbalance what would essentially be a massive tax break for every new homebuyer.
- jfim 3y agoI'm in favor of everyone paying taxes fairly to get high quality city services, instead of having people with large increases in property value getting an unfair tax subsidy.
- thinkharderdev 3y agoThe original thought experiment is not really about extracting maximum tax revenue (the overall level of taxation is pretty orthogonal to how you assess and collect taxes) but more in the spirit of how to promote more efficient allocation of resources in economic terms. Think of it as a Pigouvian tax on inefficiency.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI think that this is both an incorrect and amoral way of thinking about externalities. Externality costs Must be real incurred costs, not just hypothetical opportunity costs. Otherwise they are useless for economic analysis and lead to repugnant conclusions IF you drop trash on your neighbor's lawn, that is an externality. If you refuse to mow their lawn, that is not an externality, no matter how much they have to pay someone else. Efficiency is not an inherent good, and Pigouvian taxes on inefficiency are a huge moral hazard. Is it inefficient for a doctor to play with their children instead of work? Who are the decision makers?
- thinkharderdev 3y agoThe comments here have been very focused on the case of implementing some system like this for housing (which to be fair was the example the book used), but as I said in the original comment, I actually don't think this is a workable or desirable system for property taxes on owner-occupied housing for roughly the reasons that you dislike it. Someone's home is not just some financial asset and economic efficiency is not the only important consideration in society. I brought it up specifically in this context (and article about patent litigation) because I think it is potentially a good idea in some domains (like patent law) where the overriding consideration should legitimately be economic efficiency. I think it is entirely reasonable to design our intellectual property rights around the idea that the person or firm that can derive the most economic value from any piece of IP is the most desirable owner of that IP.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThat's fair. I agree that intellectual property does not have the same foundational justifications as physical property. IP justifications ARE generally based on economic efficiency rationales, and typically cut contrary to physical property rights (e.g. Why cant I produce a copy for sale with material I own, in a factory I own) I was mostly picking at how you invoked externalities, which is a major pet peeve of mine. I feel that between sloppy economics and utilitarianism, the concept of externalities is invoked anytime anyone doesnt get what they want.
- AmericanChopper 3y ago> I think it is still fair to point out that it is a thought experiment on how to extract as much value in the form of taxes. I think you’re saying the quiet part out loud. But you’re certainly right that there are many people interested in maximum tax and minimum property rights.
- ryandrake 3y agoThat's one (pessimistic) way to look at it. Another way to look at it is it's a thought experiment on how to solve the disconnect between a property owner's asset value for the purpose of sale vs. its value for the purpose of taxes. If you're against the very concept of taxes, then obviously nothing is going to make you happy, and the discussion is pointless. Today, we have this illogical situation where you can sell your property for $X but when the taxman comes, it's all "oh, but my property is only worth $Y!" It doesn't make sense.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoWhy do you think the disconnect is illogical and needs to be solved? Do you know that isn't how it actually works? The taxman tracks the real real appraised value too. When you pay taxes, there is a disconnect between your total income and adjusted income. Is that similarly illogical?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- freejazz 3y ago> and are pretty loose with the human suffering implications Which is pretty on-point for Posner, who thought that a free market would solve the problem of racism and segregation.