9 ms·
Apple might have to pay that €13B EU tax bill after all
- frank_bb 3y ago[dead]
- ryaneager 3y ago[flagged]
- jstummbillig 3y agoDo you want to elaborate?
- tejinderss 3y agoThese sweetheart taxation deals should stop in Ireland and other tax havens. It benefits none; although on paper it looks that Ireland is doing too well, the reality is not that rosy for its residents.
- qaq 3y agoApple employees a ton of people in Ireland same as pretty much all top tier tech companies. Outside of crazy real estate prices Ireland is actually doing pretty well.
- isaacremuant 3y agoEmploying lots of foreigners who pay insane rent prices and are taxed heavily doesn't really benefit anyone else other than home owners who already were fleecing people due to the lack of construction. Ireland is doing well as a country in GDP terms (ignoring debt) but the people in the mid and lower tiers don't necessarily do well at all. It's increasingly classist and it has bad and inefficient healthcare, lack of police, excessive bureocracy and lack of political change due to an entrenched political class. Ireland, it's only doing well for some and only in the surface. Corrupt to an unbelievable degree if you actually see it up close, and not through layers of numbers and "process".
- turbo_fart 3y agoIreland is doing well directly because of extremely clever biz Dev Irish people who made Ireland top tech and biotech centre in the entire world.
- nikhilsimha 3y ago/s in the end? (genuine question)
- andrepd 3y agoI'm pretty sure. They're poking fun at people who see the billions in tax dodge BEPS schemes included in Ireland GDP and think it has any bearing in reality.
- skyyler 3y agothe point is that this is only benefiting those that already have money A bunch of foreigners showing up to pay more than you can for rent is not a good thing.
- qaq 3y agoIreland has pretty good education system while there are certainly immigrants a large % of positions is actually occupied by people born in Ireland.
- qaq 3y agoI lived in Ireland for 4 years can't say I share your sentiment
- isaacremuant 3y agoGreat arguments. I'm convinced.
- qaq 3y ago
- ndsipa_pomu 3y agoI agree - it's a race to the bottom if different countries compete to provide global corporations the lowest tax bill.
- foooorsyth 3y agoThat’s exactly how it should be. Without nation to nation competition, taxes would be even more outrageous than they already are. The institution that monopolizes violence in order to tax should be at the very least threatened by the risk of losing its constituents to other nations/regions that offer a better deal.
- hef19898 3y agoYou missed the memonof a global minimum corporate tax, thatbia being implemented rihht now, didn't you? It seems the majoroty of people, and governments, have not too much interest to exist in a world of unlimited capitalism only benefiting the largest corporations and richest of people.
- kyrra 3y agoRepublicans in the US are not on bored. They are threatening retaliation if EU countries move forward with it. https://www.wsj.com/articles/house-lawmakers-europe-global-corporate-tax-janet-yellen-jason-smith-49e0d910 https://www.wsj.com/articles/house-lawmakers-europe-global-c...
- hef19898 3y agoAnd what exactly can tje GOP do? Unless they win the White House, in which case I guess even NATO membership of the US woupd be on the table, right? Just remind me, how well did tue last GOP trade war with China go?
- justinzollars 3y agoSimply one election away, from any sovereign country on earth, from disappearing.
- psychlops 3y agoSomeone is benefitting or it wouldn't happen.
- pornel 3y agoIt's a problem like the prisoner dilemma. It's beneficial to the country that "deflects" and gives a discount, but makes everyone worse off than if all countries held line on a higher tax rate. (disclaimer: I mean it from a direct perspective of maximizing tax income. In this comment I'm not getting into the deeper economics/politics/philosophy of whether higher or lower taxes are better overall).
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoIt obviously benefits Apple shareholders.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- closewith 3y agoThe reality in Ireland is still that Ireland is a wealthy, stable, safe, educated liberal democracy, which is not at all what it was when I was young. Although suffering from the same housing-, cost-of-living-, refugee-, and public-service-crises as most other Western nations, its path has been extremely successful and beneficial to its citizens. I think you might just be too young and too insulated to see how successful the policies have been.
- tejinderss 3y ago> how successful the policies have been. I don't know how these “successful” policies are sustainable if they are not playing level field with the rest of EU.
- closewith 3y agoWell, they are not sustainable, but Ireland no longer relies on them, so it's a moot point. The policies enabled the rapid development over a 25 year period and as the country became richer and the progress became self-sustaining, the arrangements were discontinued. For example, the "Double Irish" arrangement, which is the subject of this case, was only in use up to 2014 (and was modelled on and often paired with the "Dutch Sandwich" BEPS arrangement, so you should note that Ireland wasn't the only EU country playing these games). It was this case that closed the Double Irish arrangement and while "Green Jersey"/CAIA partially took it's place, the legitimate tax take was already more than sustainable. Now that Ireland has agreed to a global minimum corporate tax (CT) rate, it's likely that the CT take in Ireland will fall over time, but the inflated CT take of recent years has been treated as a windfall and not current income.
- tejinderss 3y ago> Ireland no longer relies on them If Ireland has closed all the loopholes then why do the phantom exports (US subsidiary buying IPs) account for 38% of total exports of this year? > Now that Ireland has agreed to a global minimum corporate tax (CT) rate. Provided that they dont find another loophole. Edit: Someone asked for baseline, the phantom exports were 6 billion in 2012, they are 134 billion this year. https://www.businesspost.ie/news/irish-phantom-exports-surge-to-e134-billion/ https://www.businesspost.ie/news/irish-phantom-exports-surge...
- tekla 3y ago[flagged]
- hef19898 3y agoI don't think nations follow a sports team fan culture when it comes to the question of whether or not a certain company paid enough taxes.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y agoTo be fair 13B sounds like a tax avoidance scheme that didn't work out
- tekla 3y ago> Then, as we said, in 2018, the commission had a change of heart, felt rules had been broken, and wanted that €13 billion in tax from Apple. > Fast-forward to 2020, and the General Court of the European Union decided Apple didn't actually need to pay the tax due to the arrangement the iPhone maker had in Ireland seemingly being above board. It was ok, then not ok, then ok again. The powers that be are going to keep trying until they want the ruling they want.
- todd-davies 3y agoWhat's the cause of all the flip flopping between Apple having to pay the bill or not? I think the main problem that this area of law is fundamentally uncertain and hard to apply. Legal mistakes get made, and judgements get appealed until people figure out what the law actually says. A secondary issue is that judges in appeals courts are generalists, not tax or state aid experts. Despite this, they get landed with the hardest cases - situations that haven't been seen before which throw up new legal issues - and need to figure out what to do. Most of the time they get it right. Some of the time, they mis-interpret the law and get it wrong. That's why we have the appeals process. So where are we up to in terms of this case, and how many more flip-flops we can expect? This article is citing an advisory opinion of one of the EU's Advocate Generals (themselves, very senior judges). These advisory opinions are issued prior to the CJEU (the highest court) making a final ruling. They are there to guide the CJEU so that the final ruling is as good as possible. Although this specific case should be finalised after the CJEU makes its ruling, I'm sure the case law will continue to evolve in the future as multinational companies push the boundaries of the EU's tax and state aid regimes.
- izacus 3y ago> What's the cause of all the flip flopping between Apple having to pay the bill or not? I think the main problem that this area of law is fundamentally uncertain and hard to apply. Legal mistakes get made, and judgements get appealed until people figure out what the law actually says. Or you know, Apple is trying really hard to not pay the tax they should and are stalling the process by throwing lawyers at it, because they want to continue their shell company scheme of reselling IP rights to avoid taxes in locales where they sell their hardware and make profit. Is this the first time you're seeing a megacorp try their hardest not to pay their due?
- todd-davies 3y agoFor sure they are throwing lawyers at it. It's 13bn after all. But the underlying reason for the appeal is the same; the law is not yet clear as to what should happen.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoMore discussion a few days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38205155 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38205155
- findthewords 3y agoRegressive (opposite of progressive) taxation for corporations seems to be one of the root causes of the "teracorps'" ostensibly anti-competitive habitus (and unchecked growth). Just my observation.
- tick_tock_tick 3y agoCorporate taxes in general are just a regressive tax on the population.
- hackernewds 3y agothere is not much wrong with unchecked growth. Apple has added a ton of value to society
- CuriouslyC 3y agoApple's market cap has increased almost 4000% since the release of the iphone. What have the contributed to society since then, nicer iphones? A watch that's mostly a clunky status symbol for affluent techies? Hyper-expensive VR goggles used by nobody? It doesn't seem like allowing that unchecked growth has really paid off in terms of benefit to society. I think taxes that greatly reduced that growth would have paid for countless hospitals, scholarships, aid to the poor, etc.
- Apocryphon 3y agoThey financed Scorsese’s new picture
- Invictus0 3y agoWhen the iPhone was released, Apple had sold 0 iPhones. Since then, Apple has sold over 1.5 billion iPhones. Your position is that Apple produces no value for society?
- CuriouslyC 3y agoIf apple stopped existing shortly after android phones became available, everyone would just be using android phones now and the tears would be long in the past.
- jmyeet 3y agoLast year the Biden administration and the 50-50 Senate managed to get through the Inflation Reduction Act ("IRA"). One aspect taht wasn't talked about a lot was the 15% minimumn corporate tax [1]. The US likes these alternatigve minimum taxes when it collectively throws its hands up int he air and says it's too complicated. Now this faced some opposition but on the messaging front it was hard to argue gainst it because you simply say (as people did) "the corporate tax rate is 21%, why does it matter that there's a minimum of 15%?" Of course, we all know the answer: companies will be paying less than 15% tax or they wouldn't care. Now this is all still too low but it's something. Personally what I think we need is to go after profit shifting. Interestingly, "transfer pricing", which is basically the exact same thing, is illegal, but profit shifting isn't (because reasons). What is it? Acme Inc produces widgets in China for $100 including shipping and sells them in the US for $200. That's a taxable profit of $100. So instead Acme Inc sets up a subsidiary in Ireland. That subsidiary buys them for $100 and sells them to the US subsidiary for $195. That's now $5 taxable profit in the US and $95 low to no tax profit in Ireland. So how do we go after it? Simple. Revenue apportionment. If you, as a multinational, make 35% (for example) of your revenue in the US then 35% of your conglomerate's profit gets taxed in the US. Google and Meta do this too. Ad contracts in the UK are booked in Ireland. The UK subsidiary makes nothing. Ireland makes all the profits. The other aspect to this which is idiotic is IP transfer [1]. Say you're Google and you invent a search engine. Well, you value that IP at $X and transfer it to an Irish subsidiary. You then pay royalties to yourself to use that IP. There are rules around what you can do here but it's an essential part of Big Tech companies shifting profits to tax havens. [1]: mhttps://www.williamfry.com/knowledge/ireland-as-the-jurisdiction-of-choice-for-intellectual-property-rights/ https://www.williamfry.com/knowledge/ireland-as-the-jurisdic... [1]: https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-clarifies-rules-for-new-corporate-alternative-minimum-tax https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-clarifies-rules-for-new-cor...
- TrapLord_Rhodo 3y agoWhen i worked in a manufacturing Tech company we were all told to purchase capital equipment through the netherlands subsidiary. I never understood it, because the equipment never "went" to the netherlands, but the netherlands entity would buy equipment for the US based entity from a US based company. I think the real solution here would be to tax based on bills of landing. If you buy things for your american locations, then they should be taxed based on American tax law.
- jokoon 3y agoI love this sort of news
- bandyaboot 3y agoIt takes a special level of clownish incompetence to make Apple seem like the sympathetic character in the context of taxes.
- paulddraper 3y agoThis is taxes. Sympathy is irrelevant.
- wavemode 3y agoAm I reading the story correctly? Apple was given government permission to structure their business a certain way so they would not owe certain taxes, and now the government has changed its mind and wants to rule that they owe more than a decade in back taxes? I'm all for mega corporations paying fines for breaking the law, but this seems like overreach. A government shouldn't punish someone for doing something that that they only did because the government said they could.
- thegiogi 3y agoThat was my initial reaction. Then i thought about what would happen if it was an individual in a similar situation, say you are the subject of an error in your favour from a bank. I don’t know but it is not obvious.
- anonymousDan 3y agoClose, but there's slightly more to it that. In this case the government that gave Apple permission was Ireland, but the issue is whether by doing so the Irish government is in violation of an EU treaty that EU countries can't offer subsidies to companies selectively (typically to avoid them subsidising companies from their own country at the expense of companies from other EU countries). The tricky bit is that control over taxation is not included in any EU treaty (i.e. it remains a national competence and countries are free to set their own taxation policy, which is perfectly reasonable). This case hinges on the question as to whether the tax break given to Apple was also available to other companies (which would be fine), or whether they were given some kind of special treatment. The reason Ireland is fighting the case is that in the long term they (and many other EU countries) do not want to cede any power to the EU regarding tax policy, either directly as part of a new EU taxation treaty or via the backdoor through court cases such as this.
- anyoneamous 3y agoI would think for companies default should be: - Pay the tax we think you owe, or go directly to jail - if you can prove later that you overpaid, we will give you a rebate on taxes over the next N years - if the government is consistently getting your tax estimate wrong (in your view), then perhaps your tax-avoidance games aren't such a good idea after all
- xtracto 3y agoI'd conform with the 1st one. CEOs should be personally liable for a company's crimes. After all they are getting billions of dollars in bonuses.
- meepmorp 3y ago> Pay the tax we think you owe, or go directly to jail Did Apple not pay the taxes they owed? I ask because my reading of the article is that Apple did in fact pay all the taxes owed to Ireland, and the issue is actually about an EU internal disagreement over corporate subsidies and how they relate to tax policy. In other words, none of that has anything to do with the topic at hand.
- elzbardico 3y agoWell, a little of stock buy-backs. We common mortals can't escape our taxes, I don't understand why corporate behemoths should be allowed to do that.
- fabifabulous 3y agoGood. I like Apple and their products. I understand that publicly traded companies act solely for the benefit of their shareholders and their own profits in general. But man, are those big companies fu*** when it comes to tax avoidance. This comes at a cost for all societies which would benefit from a more just tax system. As a middle class earner I got the feeling that I‘m double-paying for those companies: for their products and for their tax deals.