9 ms·
Lost "Doctor Who" episodes found but owner is reluctant to hand them to BBC
- walterbell 3y agoPreservers of cultural memory should be rewarded. Canada spent years digitizing classic TV and published the shows on a Youtube channel, then suddenly deleted all the content without notice to archivers, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35716982 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35716982. In the absence of social contracts for preservation, we are left with defensive archiving.
- petermcneeley 3y agoWhy preserve what you wish not to remember.
- patmorgan23 3y agoBecause someone else might want to remember
- hughesjj 3y agoAnd that someone else may be future me
- dylan604 3y ago[flagged]
- david-gpu 3y agoResearchers.
- Exoristos 3y agoPeople watch older content all the time.
- kubiton 3y agoMl training for example. "Generate cartoon in style of"
- dylan604 3y agoyou're definitely not winning me over with this
- Loughla 3y agoI don't know why, but my knee-jerk reaction is that this is the worst use of the material. Why is that? Anyone else with that opinion able to put into words the reason? Because I'm not really sure why I think that, but I do.
- kubiton 3y agoNo clue what your problem is with it. Old material always has some use an we do live in a timeless time now. Reusing the lid and getting inspired by it is part of humans creativity
- lm28469 3y agoI've downloaded shows created before both my parents were even born, and some others not as old but still older than me. I don't think it's the norm but I doubt it's that uncommon
- terminous 3y ago> who is going to watch all of this older content? Historians, archivists, and everyone who is interested in having access to the past.
- 2muchcoffeeman 3y agoThe current state of affairs is a real shame. The guys behind the Curiosity Show bought all the episodes and are uploading them to youtube. Great science show for kids. I've never seen a better kids science show.
- adventured 3y ago> which is funny, as who is going to watch all of this older content? younger generations do not watch older content. That's pretty obviously false. People watch old episodes of, to name two easy examples, Johnny Carson or the Letterman Show. Whether that's to see a comedian (eg Rodney Dangerfield) or a band perform on Letterman, and so on. People love to watch old episodes of SNL, and we know that by the enormous view counts. They love to watch old music videos from before their time. People were funny in the past, too. Bands were great in the past, too.
- justinclift 3y agoThere are probably some people (other than historians) into that stuff. For a parallel example, the earliest records of anime stretch back to winter 1917 (!), though no-one has recordings of those any more: https://anidb.net/anime/season/1917/winter/?do=calendar&h=1 https://anidb.net/anime/season/1917/winter/?do=calendar&h=1 Some of the slightly newer anime (summer 1917!) used to be on YouTube but the account seems to have been deleted. Unsure if by YouTube or by the account holder: * https://anidb.net/anime/5862 https://anidb.net/anime/5862 * https://anidb.net/forum/thread/10412#c461218 https://anidb.net/forum/thread/10412#c461218 * https://youtu.be/AnxMNq2QbvA https://youtu.be/AnxMNq2QbvA This account on YouTube seems to have a bunch of anime from around that period, along with some modern stuff too: https://www.youtube.com/@ccm1112/videos https://www.youtube.com/@ccm1112/videos
- 2C64 3y agoThey watch it themselves (and sometimes make reaction videos to it). They watch it with their parents. They watch it as part of a class. They study history and watch it. There are so many ways in which this statement is demonstrably false.
- doublepg23 3y ago> younger generations do not watch older content This is completely false.
- ethbr1 3y agoTwo gems (among many)... Periscope Films (on YouTube): https://m.youtube.com/@PeriscopeFilm/playlists https://m.youtube.com/@PeriscopeFilm/playlists Digitized 40-60s era reels. It still amazes me how effectively they presented complex topics then. E.g. mechanical naval gunnery computers: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=gwf5mAlI7Ug https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=gwf5mAlI7Ug And this on-the-ground movie on the Columbia student occupation in 1968: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=BUcYLuGiL_s https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=BUcYLuGiL_s
- dghlsakjg 3y agoI was literally just searching for an episode of The Fifth Estate from 1988 a week ago. A current events/documentary show is never going to get remade. There's plenty of reasons that people watch old shows. Even on streaming services, the biggest shows seem to be older stuff like The Office, Seinfeld, Friends, etc. Seinfeld will never get remade, and Friends and the Office might, but will not in any way reflect the original. Going to youtube its pretty clear that there is plenty of demand for old shows: Secrets of War, an obscure 90s era cable documentary show has millions of views across the episodes they uploaded.
- lupusreal 3y agoMost content, new or old, is slop not worth watching. And since there are more content from the past than in the present, that means most content worth watching will be from the past. Do you limit yourself to reading books released in 2023, or do you give any book a chance regardless of age? Most of the greatest books ever written were not first published this year!
- matheusmoreira 3y agoWe do enjoy old stuff. And it still deserves to be preserved even if nobody did. It does not matter if not a single person on this earth watches that content, human beings toiled to create it and therefore it does not deserve to be lost to the mists of time.
- CuriouslyC 3y agoYounger people will watch it when it gets spoofed and meme'd. Tiktok is massively overrun with people watching things and reacting to them, I'm sure a genre of MST3k style reaction videos to cheesy old content would do well there.
- DonHopkins 3y agoTell that to the all the young people at Mrs. Roper Romp Drag Queen Parties. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/22/arts/television/mrs-roper-romp-threes-company.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/22/arts/television/mrs-roper...
- bacchusracine 3y agoHow about a link people can actually read? https://archive.li/69gz9 https://archive.li/69gz9
- hotnfresh 3y agoEternal cloudflare captcha loop. I’ve never actually seen one of these in the wild. I hit the “I’m not a robot” checkbox, half second later the page reloads with the same checkbox.
- DonHopkins 3y agoYou have to check "I'm not a Roper"! ;) PS: Thank you bacchusracine! Twillingate was a bit brighter with these Mrs. Roper wannabes for a pub crawl, complete with muumuus: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wWCx3_GVu84 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wWCx3_GVu84
- Dylan16807 3y ago> younger generations do not watch older content Care to quantify that? It's not 0%. Even 1% of view time thrown at older content is a lot of hours. Americans watch something like 1.5 billion hours of video per day when we combine TV and internet. If we look at the broadcast channels in the US, and estimate they put out 20 hours of shows on the average day, then a historic archive 70 years deep would have half a million hours of video. If one tenth of one percent of view time went to old broadcast shows in particular, then that's 3x the archive size daily and 1000x the archive size yearly. And all the standard definition content combined would be well under a petabyte.
- hotnfresh 3y agoMy kids like the silent movies I’ve shown them enough that sometimes they ask to watch another, unprompted. And I gladly watch talkies with them, too, it’s not like this is one of those “they only suffer it to spend time with dad” things. I wasn’t born when those came out, either. My parents weren’t born when those played in theaters, for that matter. For many, neither were my grandparents. I watch TV shows from before I was born, pretty often.
- kelnos 3y agoI very well might. My parents watched Doctor Who religiously in their 20s/30s, and I watched some of it in syndication with them when I was a kid. I never got into the 21st century version of it, though. But being able to watch the old stuff would be a connection back to my parents that I would love to have.
- zilti 3y agoStop caring about that ignorant crowd.
- benj111 3y agoSo you've never watched an old film? Listened to music from before you were born? Read a book from before you were born? There was more than enough of this stuff when I was young, but instead of watching police academy 26 I watched something actually good.
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y agoYou have no idea how many movies I've watched that are ~100 years old.
- unicornmama 3y agoBecause you don't create the future by destroying the past.
- terminous 3y agoMaybe you don't value history, but many people do. The point isn't entertainment, or the kind of entertainment you're imagining. Of course this won't compete on the streaming market. The point is that it is a time capsule of an age we've already forgotten.
- petermcneeley 3y agoI think most people also concluded that this was statement of my personal position. It certainly is not.
- DonHopkins 3y agoOh, just trolling then?
- benj111 3y agoI believe it's called 'playing devils advocate' or in this case sarcasm. Unfortunately sarcasm doesn't come across very well on the internet.
- chagen 3y agoDid you not intend for people to conclude this to be your personal position? Because there are ways to communicate that more clearly.
- phs318u 3y agoBecause you (making the decision) do not speak for the generations that will follow. In making that decision you are (arrogantly) assuming that you know the minds of all those that will follow and that they will agree with your assessment that "there's nothing to see here". Perhaps you meant in the sense of a deliberate memory hole (in the Orwellian sense), in other words eliminating that which you don't want others to discover.
- darkclouds 3y ago[dead]
- maximus-decimus 3y agoThere's a Quebec kid tv show "Une grenade avec ca" I really liked when I was a teenager and at some point one of the main actors got prosecuted for possession of child pornography, so they pulled out all the episodes he played in... which is basically every single episode I ever watched. I understand their decision to not air those, but it still feels like a part of my childhood got erased and I wish I could get a copy of those episodes.
- coolspot 3y agohttps://archive.org/details/une-grenade-avec-ca-s-05-e-22-pattes-de-grenouilles-vfq-720p https://archive.org/details/une-grenade-avec-ca-s-05-e-22-pa...
- maximus-decimus 3y agoWow, thanks!
- 462436347 3y ago> These collectors were seen as criminals, but now we can see they are really saviours. An amnesty would stop them being frightened of prosecution,” he said. The UK is unusual in that it has no statute of limitations for most crimes besides "summary offenses" (equivalent to US misdemeanors): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limitation_periods_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limitation_periods_in_the_Unit...
- gonzo41 3y agoHe should give the tapes to the British museum out of spite. They BBC will never get the back and the British Museum doesn't care what crimes were committed as long as their collection grows.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoIs that unusual among all the countries of the world? Or is the US unusual for having a statute of limitations?
- vkou 3y ago
- astrange 3y ago[flagged]
- Philpax 3y agoWhat are you on about
- astrange 3y ago[flagged]
- ClassyJacket 3y agoAnd so your solution is to scrap public healthcare and make the problem far, far worse. Fucking genius. If something isn't 100% literally perfect in all possible scenarios, we shouldn't do it at all. I suppose you're in favour of removing airbags from cars and putting lead back in paint, too?
- astrange 3y agoNo, public healthcare systems are good because they have monopsony power. (That is, they keep costs down by increasing the supply of doctors… or just paying them less.) They are just not so good that being sick doesn't make your life worse. Also, they have the problem that if you elect people who want to ruin it they can ruin it. Don't want an anti-abortion government owning all the abortion clinics. Same problem with public housing - it's bad if you're a minority the government is racist against. Most systems aren't designed like the NHS anymore than they're designed like the US though. Japan's is good for instance.
- ClassyJacket 3y ago[flagged]
- stevage 3y agoSeems like an article that would have been vastly improved if they had simply put the question about an amnesty directly to the BBC and printed their response.
- iudqnolq 3y agoThey did. The BBC carefully avoided saying anything meaningful. > The BBC said it was ready to talk to anyone with lost episodes. “We welcome members of the public contacting us regarding programmes they believe are lost archive recordings, and are happy to work with them to restore lost or missing programmes to the BBC archives,” it said.
- jstarfish 3y ago> They did. The BBC carefully avoided saying anything meaningful. I think it can be interpreted a little more charitably than that: > We welcome members of the public contacting us regarding programmes they believe are lost archive recordings They're literally feeding lines to potential respondents, to help them avoid implicating themselves in theft. You didn't take reels from the studio, you found "lost recordings" they were looking for. > and are happy to work with them to restore lost or missing programmes to the BBC archives They're doing it again here. It's not "returning shit you stole," it's "restoring lost or missing programmes." Return it as lost and stick to your story. FWIW, here in the US "we will work with you" is the exact same verbiage we use in calls to recover lost equipment we actually need but retain discretion in litigation over. We don't commit to promises of amnesty because sometimes it turns out you've been dumping brand-new equipment off the loading dock and selling it on eBay for years, and that's not worth looking past just for the return of one item. But if you happen to have the one thing we're looking for and weren't misappropriating millions of dollars in assets in addition to the lost item, we just want it back and won't ask questions.
- fdgjgbdfhgb 3y agoSadly this article is misleading - John Franklin has issued a statement saying that he was misquoted [1] and there is actually an amnesty when handing over missing episodes. [1] https://twitter.com/drwhopodcasters/status/1723388160866943358?s=20 https://twitter.com/drwhopodcasters/status/17233881608669433...
- chasil 3y agoI didn't know anything about this; it's quite interesting. ...the infamous arrest of comedian Bob Monkhouse in 1978 has not been forgotten, Franklin suspects: “Monkhouse was a private collector and was accused of pirating videos. He even had some of his archive seized. Sadly people still believe they could have their films confiscated.” https://www.pressreader.com/uk/daily-mail/20180824/282703342950268 https://www.pressreader.com/uk/daily-mail/20180824/282703342...
- j-bos 3y agoI mean, if you were in that situation would you trust the legal system not to turn on you?
- rwmj 3y agoWeirdly the BBC later made a TV programme about his archive (https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00x9b7w https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00x9b7w) and I don't recall them mentioning that he was arrested.
- jccalhoun 3y agoAs others have said this article is poorly written with the person interviewed saying he was misquoted so nothing in it can be taken as true. However, there have been very strong rumors for years that 2-3 episodes known to be in the hands of collectors (I believe it was said in a recorded interview with the Radio Free Skaro podcast by someone involved in Classic Who bluray releases) While some people may be worried about legal implications I suspect that most just would rather keep it. If they really wanted to return it they could hand it off to someone who would be an intermediary. So the real danger is that once they die, whoever inherits their collection may not care about it and junk the whole thing.
- djmips 3y agoThat makes more sense to me knowing how this happens in the arcade preservation community. Some people really get off on having 'the only copy' of something.
- krustyburger 3y ago>>As others have said this article is poorly written with the person interviewed saying he was misquoted so nothing in it can be taken as true. I’m not finding this claim being made elsewhere in the comments here. Do you have a link?
- defrost 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38245171 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38245171
- jccalhoun 3y agoListening to the latest episode of Radio Free Skaro they confirm that the rumors were stated on their show and read a quote from the person interviewed for this article who says they were just repeating what they heard of Radio Free Skaro!
- ummonk 3y agoCan’t they just announce an amnesty but make it contingent on turning in any illicitly obtained footage to the BBC?
- dramm 3y agoI'd be more interesting in digging up the corpses of incompetent BBC management from back in the day and prosecuting them than any threat to somebody who has archival content--they ought to be well financially rewarded for protecting that content.
- walterbell 3y agoFrom Sept 2021 to Aug 2022, "old shows" were watched as much as Apple TV+, https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/business/business-news/filmrise-danny-fisher-interview-streaming-1235316039 https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/business/business-news/fil... > the Fishers scooped up rights to low-cost, syndicated staples like Forensic Files and Unsolved Mysteries and library titles with strong cult followings, from The Dick Van Dyke Show to The Greatest American Hero and 21 Jump Street.. FilmRise is now the largest independent provider of content to ad-supported streaming platforms.. in the U.S. top 10, with 21.68 billion cumulative minutes streamed .. just behind Apple TV+, with a cumulative 21.7 billion minutes streamed.
- Aerroon 3y agoJust another example of copyright law being garbage.
- nvm0n2 3y agoIt says a lot about the state of the BBC that they produce so little sci-fi that this is actually considered news. Look at Netflix, for whom sci-fi/fantasy is the most popular genre of show and as a consequence they invest heavily into it. The BBC seems to be staffed by an incredibly narrow and stifling cultural homogeneity in which period dramas that appeal to middle aged women are good, but sci-fi shows that appeal to young men aren't even on the radar. Dr Who is notable primarily because it's one of the only recognizable sci-fi shows they ever made, and it's targeted at kids. The others are mostly comedies like Red Dwarf or Hitchhiker's Guide and they're all from decades ago. One day the BBC is going to lose the license fee and discover it doesn't even know what types of shows are popular, let alone how to make them.
- krapp 3y agoThis isn't news because the BBC produces so little sci-fi, it's news because of the popularity and hstorical legacy of Doctor Who specifically. No one (except maybe lost media nerds) would care if this were about Blake's Seven or something.
- OJFord 3y agoIt's got nothing to do with it being sci-fi, (except that maybe it makes it more likely to end up here) it's because it's popular & has lost episodes. Dad's Army would make the news for it (but maybe not Hacker News, sure) too.
- gushie 3y agoSo do these collectors have the ability to play back these recordings? If so, could they at least make some recording (even if pointing a camera while playing back would be better than nothing) to send to the BBC. Otherwise if they have no means to play it back, I fail to understand why they'd not want the opportunity to watch their collection!
- h2odragon 3y agoFYI, archive.org has a bunch of whats been available: https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s01 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s01 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s02 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s02 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s03_v2 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s03_v2 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s04 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s04 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s05 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s05 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s06 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s06 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s07 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s07 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s08 https://archive.org/details/doctorwho_s08
- jakderrida 3y agoHoly crap! How long has this been available? Every time I read up on it, finding it was like the thing of legends.
- edent 3y agoThose aren't lost episodes. They are available on DVD and iPlayer.
- jakderrida 3y agoOh, now I got it. Thank you so much for clarifying.
- trashface 3y agoThanks for this, didn't know these were out there. I started watching as a kid when Jon Pertwee was the doctor and haven't seen most of these.
- rbanffy 3y agoThe easiest solution would be to send them anonymously to a third party abroad, who'd then proceed to digitise the tapes, returning the originals to the collectors, and hand the resulting files to the BBC. Setting up a trustable network of anonymous relays crossing jurisdictions for physical goods is the hard part, and tends to attract the wrong kind of attention to the ones involved.
- egorfine 3y agoI'm such a third party, could do it. I could't care less about restoring BBC history if BBC themselves don't care enough to lay down a legal way for this to happen without my help.
- thatguy0900 3y agoThis is how it feels to me. Dump them on a pirate site, no reason to give them to the BBC if they have no interest in trying to get them
- rbanffy 3y agoAre we sure the copyright belongs to BBC and not the royal family?
- krustyburger 3y agoExcuse my ignorance, but why exactly would the copyright belong to the royal family?
- rbanffy 3y agoI don't know much either. I don't think the BBC is a government department though, but it's kind of messy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crown_copyright https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crown_copyright
- drewcoo 3y ago
- wilg 3y agoWhy is the BBC being weird about it?
- rodent_rodeo 3y agoIn the article: The collectors involved are ex-employees and so are terrified. The rule was that you didn’t take anything, even if it had been thrown out. But if you loved film and knew it would be important one day, what did you do? So what we need now is an amnesty,” he said.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Mindwipe 3y agoThere have been a lot of attempts to extort money out of the BBC by people falsely claiming that they have lost episodes over the years, they may simply not believe these claims are as credible as the article suggests.
- gwern 3y agoThat doesn't make any sense. OP is about reports that BBC refuses to make any legal promises and talk only vaguely about cooperating with owners, when it would be so easy for them to simply publicly promise to not prosecute material stole before, say, 1990. Obviously, granting 'an amnesty for stolen episodes' is even easier for fake episodes which were never stolen in the first place... The credibility of the claims is irrelevant.
- justrealist 3y agoThe BBC does not have any discretion over who is prosecuted for a crime though. They can give their opinion but it's up to the police. So a public promise doesn't actually hold any weight.
- 3y ago