9 ms·
You Win or You Learn
- kevmarsden 3y agoI'm surprised that memo leaked. Automattic is very open with employees and trusts them not to share internal information. While I worked there (2013-2018) I don't remember any news leaking.
- photomatt 3y agoEven when we do leak, it's thoughtful. You can tell whoever did it cropped out a bunch of stuff, including the text that would have tripped the Texts acquisition that wasn't announced at the time. I still don't love it, but at least it speaks to our hiring process finding people with high integrity.
- burkaman 3y agoAlso mentioned in this thread: Tumblr's ActivityPub integration (discussed here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33716429 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33716429) was apparently announced without any plan and then immediately cancelled once they started thinking about how to implement it. - https://mastodon.social/@_jv_/110692236418053393 https://mastodon.social/@_jv_/110692236418053393
- grftloplthrow 3y agolol
- altairprime 3y agoGlad to hear they dodged that bullet. Thanks for pointing this out.
- thejohnconway 3y agoWho dodged which bullet? This is all just lose-lose as far as I can make out.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoThough with the new context that a few months after that tweet, the whole of Tumblr has been put on life support, it seems there may have been business considerations he wasn't privy too.
- ggambetta 3y agoAnyone knows when will Threads be available in the EU? :(
- troupo 3y agoWhen Meta figures out a way to screw users without running afoul of Digital Markets Act. See what this act is about: https://ia.net/topics/unraveling-the-digital-markets-act https://ia.net/topics/unraveling-the-digital-markets-act
- ronsor 3y agoNo American media company wants to touch the EU now.
- Hamuko 3y agoWow, Facebook and Instagram finally pulled out of the EU?
- CamperBob2 3y agoNo, but thanks to a devil's brew of knee-jerk moral panic and regulatory capture, nobody else can afford to enter your market. You're stuck with the incumbents. Sorry, but you can't say you weren't warned. We're seeing the same thing happen with AI now.
- Hamuko 3y agoBluesky is an incumbent? Because that's where I am mostly now.
- CamperBob2 3y agoEnjoy it while it lasts.
- rchaud 3y agoMoral panic and regulatory capture? You must be talking about the Congressional hearings about Tiktok in the US. They haven't needed to do that in the EU, but then again they don't have a Facebook to protect.
- qingcharles 3y agoDamn it. I love Tumblr, but it is really hard to sell advertising against the content on there, I'm guessing. I wonder if it will get sold again? I wish it hadn't been cleansed. Reddit just ploughed through all the objections to their adult content and came out the other side unharmed. Tumblr could have done the same.
- Kye 3y agoI always expected them to roll its functionality and community into WordPress.com and essentially turn it into a frontend. There's a lot of redundancy. They already have a whole service dedicated to making and maintaining custom WordPress installs, so that would be the obvious place to go.
- Night_Thastus 3y agoThat's not quite accurate about Reddit. It only made it through by purging dozens to hundreds of the more controversial NSFW subreddits. Most were justified, but they definitely bent to advertisers and PR like anyone else.
- thedaly 3y agoThey also stopped allowing NSFW content to appear on the front page of r/all.
- ClearAndPresent 3y agohttps://archive.is/WNfDg https://archive.is/WNfDg
- thejohnconway 3y agoIt’s not clear to me what this means. Freezing feature development? Rolling the backend into the rest of Automattic? Or the end of Tumblr?
- I_Am_Nous 3y agoSounds like they are moving it from an actively developed project to one where they just babysit the existing users knowing they aren't making infinite money off them like they hoped. No new features, new features are for closers.
- araes 3y agoAnd move to the next project where we hope to make infinite money with no work. Crypto had a great exemplary quote a while ago from poop face bros: "Obviously the crypto market did not live up to its lofty ambitions, so we're leaving."
- wmf 3y agoAutomattic has never been a get-rich-quick scheme.
- thejohnconway 3y agoThe only new feature I wanted for Tumblr was ActivityPub, that was nixed a while ago. Bad show.
- I_Am_Nous 3y agoTheir entire argument appears to be "We aren't making more money than all-time peak revenue and usage stats are lower than peak too so we aren't wasting money on it any longer." Maybe if they had realistic goals that weren't just "try to make more money than ever before" they could have kept going at least somewhat...
- notaustinpowers 3y ago
- Kye 3y agoA more accessible non-Threads version: https://xoxo.zone/@andybaio/111380745108104518 https://xoxo.zone/@andybaio/111380745108104518
- amadeuspagel 3y agoRemember when people talked about Tumblr replacing Twitter as Elon Musk took over? Remember their pathetic bluecheck stunt? What's wrong with this organization? How did they fail to capitalize on such a massive opportunity?
- JohnMakin 3y agotwitter still allows porn accounts
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoTwitter is being replaced the way Craigslist was replaced, gradually and by many options instead of one. There won't be a single new sudden Twitter replacement. That's a good thing, I use a bigger variety of sources than I did before quitting Twitter. I don't rely so much on any one.
- thejohnconway 3y agoTumblr fundamentally doesn't work the way Twitter does (imagine if Twitter was all screenshot retweet chains!), and so it's a poor replacement. I find it hard to use – I get lost in the reblogs – and I've used it for well over a decade now.
- beckingz 3y agoTumblr has better checkmarks.
- photomatt 3y agoIt's really hard to get people to switch one at a time, you have to bring over whole networks for it to work. It has to be a community switching together. Threads has been successful because they can promote it so much from Instagram.
- ulizzle 3y agoOr you lose, as Tumblr is figuring out.
- hypertexthero 3y agoUsability-wise, the thing that keeps me from using any Fb things, Threads.net included, is they break the bloody Back button!
- perfect-blue 3y agoGoing to a Microsoft support forum page will do this as well. At least in my experiences
- poilcn 3y agoYoutube web version for desktop has the same problem if I get what you mean right.
- echelon 3y agoChange of subject - any thoughts on the difference between user-friendly URLs? Root paths route to usernames: - https://twitter.com/username https://twitter.com/username - https://github.com/username https://github.com/username - https://www.instagram.com/username https://www.instagram.com/username Sigil-scoped paths for usernames (these also use www-prefix): - https://www.threads.net/@username https://www.threads.net/@username - https://www.youtube.com/@username https://www.youtube.com/@username Path-scoped usernames: - https://www.reddit.com/user/username https://www.reddit.com/user/username - https://www.reddit.com/u/username https://www.reddit.com/u/username (redirect) - https://bsky.app/profile/username.bsky.social https://bsky.app/profile/username.bsky.social There's obviously an engineering cost to having usernames at the root, but does that make sharing easier? Which would you use if you were starting a new app? Is the first option strictly better for growth? Are the technical caveats not worth it?
- echelon 3y agoWhy the heck did this get downvoted to -4? It was an earnest question. I'm trying to figure it out for my own startup. Perhaps a tangent too far?
- RamblingCTO 3y ago
- MatthiasPortzel 3y agoFrom a live-stream from the Tumblr staff convention this year, their CEO: > Yeah, so right now, we're burning. Which means spending more than we make. About 30 million per year more than we make. > So, that's a lot. We can't do that forever and so that's why we're really trying to figure out things that y'all would value. Whether that's merch or upgrades or badges or gifts or Blaze or other things. Every little bit helps, so please if you really enjoy Tumblr and want it to stay a thriving service buy things, and ask your friends to buy things. Tumblr’s monetization strategy since the Automattic acquisition has been “throw stuff at the wall and see what sticks.” Which is kind of your only option when the Tumblr user-base is actively hostile towards monetization attempts. Tumblr tried a “Tumblr Post Plus” Patreon-like subscription thing, and the creator that they enrolled in the test got so much hate they cancelled it before it fully launched. I could list the monetization strategies they’ve tried but there are too many. Merch, tipping, promoting your own posts, cosmetic check marks after your username, crabs, promoting other people’s posts, lore behind the merch store, a “Luffy” tab on the top of the page (in between “Following” and “For You”) (I think was a Netflix promo). At one point they were running ads for Tumblr on Tumblr. I should make a post describing them all.
- swagempire 3y agoDidn't Tumblr do a whole "alienate your user base" thing like Reddit did recently? They got rid of all the racey hot content and basically made it super boring no? This always seems like a really bad idea.
- citruscomputing 3y agoThey did, but that was a while ago. Things are still pretty bad -- if your blog gets flagged for racy content, you lose the ability to have a custom avatar, for example. (Even more, and you get banned.) They've also had quite transphobic moderation policies (really strange considering their userbase!) -- normal, non-sexual photos of trans people are "nsfw" now, which'll get your account flagged or banned. They've been making the app actively worse, redesigned the website to look like twitter, and attempted to cram "Tumblr live" down everyone's throats (only having a "hide for one week" button). Generally doing things nobody asked for, nobody wants, and continuing to break existing functionality while not listening to their users. This is an own-goal.
- internet2000 3y agoTurns out social networks are hard to get right.
- rchaud 3y agoMore like, it's hard to turn social networks into advertiser casinos. As long as the servers stay up, I doubt Tumblr users care.
- KingOfCoders 3y agoI alwyas thought I did learn more from winning than from losing for future success.
- jacooper 3y agoWow, threads on the front page, is this the first time that organically happened (ie. Not the launch announcement)
- MissTake 3y agoSign of the times. Another classic name from the earlier days on the intertubes may be about to vanish.
- autokad 3y agoI guess I feel old because tumbler feels like one of the 'newer' sites, as it came out about 2007 - when the great migration to facebook started. to me, 'early days' means 1995-2005
- 0xDEAFBEAD 3y agoI miss the days of AIM and "Skype Me". Simpler, more innocent times.
- autokad 3y agoour AIM away message was the equivalent to a facebook wall back then
- gumby 3y agoA side point, but: the title holds another important lesson. It’s a well known truism that smart people learn from their failures. But most people also don’t bother to learn from their successes, thus have trouble repeating them.
- troupe 3y agoInteresting to see this was posted on Threads instead of Tumblr which might kind of show the root of some of their problems. Does $30 Million a year spend rate seem typical for their size? I'm assuming a large part of that is the salaries for 139 people.
- resolutebat 3y agoIf you're leaking confidential corporate info, you probably don't want to post the leaks on the same company's platform.
- taway1231563 3y ago[dead]
- mortallywounded 3y agoTumblr, a service mainly used by teenage girls is unmonetizable? You don't say...
- edmundsauto 3y agoHow do you know it’s mostly teenage girls? Also, teenage girls buy a lot of stuff as well as heavily influence what teenage boys buy/like… I know it’s cool to bags on teenage girl tastes but in reality it’s not very accurate. The youth demographic is one of the most important for many consumer businesses.
- languagehacker 3y agoAutomattic's product catalogue kind of comes across as an elephant graveyard of formerly important services well past their prime, so this doesn't seem terribly surprising.
- supportengineer 3y agoOpenText is another one like that.
- forgetfulness 3y agoIt was like a somewhat more positive counterpart to 4chan, it was full of madness, toxicity and vice, and also a space for creativity like few others. It was also one of the walled gardens, even if it always felt more open than the rest, but the web continues to weaken as content creation and delivery continues to be consolidated in the exploitative platforms of Meta, TikTok, and now to a smaller degree, X, with their recommendation algorithms fine tuned to make you an addict to parasocial relationships and negative emotions.
- eastbound 3y ago[flagged]
- AlexandrB 3y agoHave you been on Instagram lately?
- ben_w 3y agoMy IG feed is 80% WeRateDogs, most of the rest is silly-positive stuff. I've not ever seen erotica on there, barely even seen any ribaldry. It has learned my tastes well. I don't know how much variation there is in other people's feeds, of course, but that you think IG is a good example implies your feed is showing you very different things to mine.
- spacemadness 3y agoThis seems like satanic panic style paranoia. Dropping a hot take like that, especially with “literally” thrown in, needs a bit more content to mean anything. To start, I don’t know how any site “makes people addicted to porn.” Why? Because it has porn? So what?
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Tumblr literally made people addict to porn. “Porn addiction” seems largely to be an evangelical Christian shame mechanism more than (and possibly instead of) an actual phenomenon.
- notaustinpowers 3y agoAs an early Tumblr user, godspeed. You were fun while you lasted.
- escapedmoose 3y agoTumblr is the only social media site that truly hooks me for hours at a time anymore. So while I’d be sad to see it go and take all its lovely fan communities down… I would get a lot of my time back.
- DanielleMolloy 3y agoIs there any alternative for having a gallery of text&photo posts without forced login and exploitative social media distractions? (except for self-hosting) When I looked for this 11 years ago, tumblr was the only platform ticking these boxes. I just wanted to share a link to photos of what we are up to with family and friends without asking them to register at another platform, and only tumblr allowed that and did not look as if it would close shop within two years. Looked again recently and it still seems to be the only platform filling that overall „niche“. Also it has a clean and good user interface, and is customizable to the point of changing the HTML. I hope they can save or otherwise sustain it. Other social media attempts to constantly distract and emotionalize me to keep me hooked. Looking at a good art or photography Tumblr feels like relief now honestly.
- sp332 3y agohttps://cohost.org/ https://cohost.org/ ? Edit for a bit of info: There is no discovery mechanism built-in and no "algorithm". The way to find more posts on a topic is to use hashtags. Everything is reverse-chronological. If someone wants their post to have broader engagement, they will post with "#The Cohost Global Feed" or some broad topic. You can go browse if you want to, but the site isn't going to push anything on you (besides following the site admins lol). Cohost doesn't have full-text search built-in, but Google actually has it covered. https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=is%20piss%20a%20vegetable https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=is%20piss%20a%20vegeta...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- yallpendantools 3y agoCool find! I'm trying to post a content-focused side project in as many grassroots platforms as I can. My main site is already in Neocities, for example. I think I could work with this too! That said, I wish they featured some random pages or categories from their homepage. I'd like to see what communities already exist around the topic of my project.
- 3y ago
- michaelt 3y ago> losing $30M a year > 139 employees working on product and marketing $216,000 loss per employee per year? Ouch.
- armchairhacker 3y agoIt seems like social medias, from a financial perspective, are more commonly bad than good. Out of all the mainstream social medias I know, these ones seem to be losing money (or at least aren't generating "enough" profit): - Twitter: halved in value in 1 year - Tumblr - Reddit: stated it wasn't doing well when it increased the API price - YouTube: seems to not be doing well because it's trying to push adds and increasing YouTube premium - Threads: I doubt this is generating profit, because I see multiple posts about how this "failed" and this is the first threads post I've seen posted somewhere else. Maybe I'm wrong though - Mastodon & rest of the Fediverse: not very mainstream, but funding seems to be a common issue among communities, and this is with the relatively small userbase - Stack Overflow and Quora: they've both done layoffs recently, and I've heard they're also faring poorly, but I don't have much information - Bluesky, the audio-only one I forgot it's name: these certainly aren't making money The ones which are doing well: - Facebook: seemingly generating a lot of revenue because of ads and data collection - Instagram: same as Facebook - TikTok: probably because China pays well do to all of the information they get - Discord: I haven't heard anything about them losing money, and they don't really push ads. Maybe because a lot of people pay for Discord nitro, or people pay for the servers? - Slack & Teams: I also haven't heard anything, but I doubt they are losing money because companies pay for these - Tinder: not really a social media but they're probably making money from people who pay a lot for premium - Hacker News: Because it's cheap to run being text-only and brings publicity to YCombinator and their companies, I'm sure this is considered a financially good investment. But even then, it doesn't generate any revenue on its own And ones I don't know: - Twitch: seemed to have issues with money but idk, they have a lot of deals and sponsorships - LinkedIn Of course starting a small social media is always a bad investment, because it's very hard to get popular. But it looks like even the popular social medias are burning through cash reserves.
- user_7832 3y agoI wonder if HN gets paid by companies recruiting, they might even manage to make a small profit if so. I think the "high density" of users is in favor of HN doing well - low server requirements and an average high median income per user (if HN ever need crowdfunding, that is.)
- 3y ago
- mewse-hn 3y agoI think Tumblr is going to end up in business textbooks as a classic example of corporations seizing a community and strangling the life out of it
- x0x0 3y agoI think it's rather a cautionary tale of never growing income to meet your expenses. They never made a business; just a vc then yahoo then verizon then automattic-owned charity.
- WJW 3y agoIt's really fascinating how long some of these things can carry on. One of my contracting clients has been going for over ten years (!!!) without ever making a profit and even now with the waves lapping at their feet they're still angling for the next big investment tranche.
- rchaud 3y agoIt's a case study footnote, a citation that proves that the social media economy could only bear 2-3 commercially successful participants. Everything else is just prospectors digging for oil and never striking it.
- durable_queue 3y agoMindGeek should buy Tumblr and allow adult content again. Tumblr's success was that it was an adult space that wasn't strictly pornography. It was a "cool sex" to PornHub's "hot sex".
- parker_mountain 3y agoUnfortunately, it's not that simple. Tumblr allowing adult content would probably get it removed from app stores. Only a few major apps get away with it, and when they're gone, they're gone.
- Bud 3y agoTumblr did fine before app stores ever existed, and could do perfectly well without them now as well. Web is enough.
- radlad 3y agoBefore app stores existed, smartphones weren't used the way they are today. Consumer habits have shifted... you'd be missing out on a HUGE part of the market.
- h0l0cube 3y agoMissing out on a huge part of the market is comfortable territory for Tumblr
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Bud 3y agoThat simply doesn't matter. Tumblr just needs to succeed in ANY slice of the market it can find. A small slice would do nicely. The best bet would be the slice it originally appealed to, with its original kinds of content, in the original medium it was in.
- 10g1k 3y ago( win || ( learn || wallow in self pity ) )
- Kye 3y agoFrom Mr. Automattic himself: https://www.tumblr.com/photomatt/733544011556618240/theres-obviously-a-lot-of-talk-about-tumblr-being https://www.tumblr.com/photomatt/733544011556618240/theres-o... Key part: >> "I'm advocating for this change because I think it has a good chance at success. I don't do anything hoping to fail. There are lots of examples of products with hundreds of millions more MAUs and smaller teams than Tumblr currently has, and there are amazing examples like OpenAI and Telegram running circles around much bigger players with small teams. That's what we hope to replicate." So it sounds like he hasn't given up on Tumblr.
- rrdharan 3y agoHe's also commenting on other threads in this post.
- photomatt 3y agoI answered a ton of questions about this, on my Tumblr using the Asks feature: https://www.tumblr.com/photomatt https://www.tumblr.com/photomatt
- hoistbypetard 3y agoI didn't scroll very far down before the site demanded that I log in and wouldn't let me continue reading. Why do you do that, and is it possible you could see your way clear to not do that?
- etchalon 3y agoI wonder what amount of a service like Tumblr's server expenses are strictly related to storing and serving historical content, and what value it really brings to the business. What would a service like Tumblr look like if things just got deleted after 90 days, or a year? What would your server costs look like then? How much traffic do ancient posts actually garner, in aggregate? Could you monetize permanence (only pro users data is kept for longer than a year)?
- doubtfuluser 3y agoOT: it seems as if Meta‘s play with Threads is working out?
- mvkel 3y agophotomatt is like a benevolent DHH
- konschubert 3y agoI wish I was allowed to use Threads.
- david164 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bitsoda 3y ago> […] we’re going to give everyone an opportunity to have a “top three” ranked list of what other things around Automattic they would be interested in working on. Admittedly cynical take, but please don’t let anybody mess up Pocket Casts. That app is near perfection and has been criminally underrated for far too long.