10 ms·
Drunk grizzlies keep getting hit by trains in Montana
- jb1991 3y agoAs a drunk grizzly myself, I resent the implication that life has somehow taken us down the wrong track.
- foggedb0nk 3y agoI wonder where all the grain comes from? Is this grain that spills out of grain cars on the trains or?
- Tao3300 3y agoAveraging 1.5 bears a year since 1980. Is that a lot?
- tomjakubowski 3y agoThe state grizzly population is about 2,100. Seems like a lot, compared to per capita human-train deaths
- steve_adams_86 3y agoLooks like that would be over 780 people hit by trains per year at that rate. I’m guessing that’s a couple orders of magnitude higher, haha. These bears have a problem on their hands.
- tomalbrc 3y agoTurns out humans get hit by trains much more often than you would think
- tomjakubowski 3y agoOn the order of 1000 train fatalities per year in the United States the Montana grizzly bear rate is >200x the American person rate!
- tomjakubowski 3y ago780 people hit per year in Montana's population yeah? At national population (1.5/2100/*3.5e6) the Montana train-bear fatality rate would correspond to a rate of 214k people hit per year.
- steve_adams_86 3y agoHa, yeah. I should have specified I was basing that off of Montana human and grizzly populations.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hellotheretoday 3y agoI worked in a place that had several apple trees in the parking lot that led to a similar issue. The apples would ferment then drunk squirrels would chase people around sometimes. It was pretty funny unless it happened to you
- e40 3y agoConfirms my belief that squirrels are assholes. We have some that urinate on our deck. They also pick and take a single bite out of our tomatoes and lemons, spoiling an entire harvest just before we pick it.
- sonofhans 3y agoOMG yes. I feed crows on my balcony, giving them a few dozen peanuts every day. I mind less that the squirrels steal them and much more that they fucking pee on the deck railing every time. I’ve taken to leaving a window open and shooting them with a water pistol; that blows their minds.
- b112 3y agoThey're probably marking their territory against other squirrels, and who wouldn't, with those wondrous peanuts. (Not that I blame you for squinting them, I am only providing reason why, perhaps)
- bluedino 3y agoCheck your states nuisance animal laws, you may be able to switch from a water pistol to a pellet gun or bow.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoSounds like they may not want to.
- nickpeterson 3y ago
- lettergram 3y agoThis article has no real facts in it… How often do train cars carrying fermented grain come through? How many bears are actually hit in this manner? (there is just someone saying this is what happens, but no autopsy or anything) I can’t imagine fermented grain leaks are all that common. I’ve been next to a lot of rail road tracks and never seen leaks. Imagine if you had a leak and it remained for 1000 or 2000 miles. This story doesn’t make sense Seems more reasonable a bear doesn’t know what a train is, has gone def or is asleep and just gets hit.
- sitharus 3y agoI don't think the railcars are carrying fermented grain, they carry grain which spills and ferments... However getting grain to ferment is somewhat tricky compared to fruit, you need the right amount of water at the right time to get it to malt and then ferment so I'm surprised there's enough of it. Just surprising, not doubting it happens. I assume the spills are from hoppers with worn out chutes, because I would not expect open hoppers for grain transport.
- mattigames 3y agoThey don't need to know what a train is to run from one, they are taller and louder than them so instincts will immediately kick in telling them to run.
- HankB99 3y agoIn evolutionary terms I don't think that there was anything that represented a danger to grizzly bears (save adult males killing cubs) so they may not have evolved behavior patterns to run from big loud things.
- usrusr 3y agoI think it's safe to assume that those instincts habe been dialed in long before the current state of relative danger fell into place. Fear of wiry bipeds that aren't actually that big but might carry sparkling stuff would be a far more specific, younger and thus variable fear. But then on the other hand train speed is dangerously difficult to assess even for us humans who in theory know full well what a train is. I believe that this is because much of the perception of movement is in terms of "size-units over time", which is why a fly at walking speed appears fast whereas big ship at 25 knots appears almost stationary unless you are too close for your own good.
- labrador 3y agoGrain hoppers are typically covered, so why are they running uncovered grain cars on this run?
- dmix 3y agoMoney falls out of armoured bank trucks all over highways when it’s supposed to be secured in the back sometimes. Stuff happens. Humans etc
- Swizec 3y ago> Money falls out of armoured bank trucks all over highways when it’s supposed to be secured in the back sometimes I had a few classmates back in high school whose uncles could get you cheap Nike, Adidas, Calvin Klein etc that fell out of trucks. Happens all the time. Stuff sometimes just gets lost on the way.
- msrenee 3y agoI'm pretty sure saying goods "fell off the truck" is just a euphemism for them being stolen. That's why they're sold cheap.
- adolph 3y agoWhy would they be sold cheaply because they are stolen? If the item is the same, then why wouldn’t the price be nearly the same?
- transcriptase 3y agoA discount moves the stolen items out of your possession much faster, reducing risk of being caught with them and need for storage.
- zztop44 3y agoIf the price were nearly the same, why would anyone choose to deal with criminals and expose themselves to some level of legal risk when they could get the same product (with a warranty) in a store?
- JCharante 3y agoCould they try putting a very very strong and focused spotlight on the front of the train? The light would be visible through their eyelids and wake them up.
- mattigames 3y agoAnd they could stick a couple of yoga balls on the front of the train so the bears have a higher chance of survival.
- daoboy 3y agoI understand that moose are responsible for quite a few train derailments, too. I presume they are sober, though.
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoRIP Tycho Brahe's moose.
- zoky 3y agoMoose don’t give a fuck. A moose would derail a train just ‘cause.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoSource? I would have figured that a moose didn't have enough mass.
- cwmma 3y agoMoose are way bigger then you think.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoI know how big a moose is. I've been uncomfortably close to them more than once. But I also know how big a train is, and I still don't see it. I know that in terms of mass, a train is to a car as a car is to an empty beer can. A car can derail a train, but won't very often. A moose might weigh as much as a small car, but has less stiff metal in the frame. It still might derail a train... but not very often.
- giardini 3y agoBear and moose have plenty of fat et al. The derailment isn't a simple metal-on-metal action, it's a metal-on-moose-on-metal interaction. The moose is skin-protein-fat-bone-fat-protein-skin. Do the math.
- v3ss0n 3y agoSo , cocaine bear isn't far fetched
- tjpnz 3y agoIt's based on a true story.
- dreamcompiler 3y agoBears are weird. Cocaine bear actually happened, although it was a very small black bear and it died of an overdose before it could hurt anybody [0]. I've had bears in my yard fairly often. They used to come at night and tear up my porch trying to get to the bird feeders. We finally wised up and stopped feeding the birds. One time a bear tore up my windshield wipers because I made the mistake of leaving a candy bar in my truck overnight. Bears are weird, but you learn their weirdnesses when you live in the country. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cocaine_Bear_(bear) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cocaine_Bear_(bear)
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 3y agoMany years ago at Lake Shasta, a couple a few spots down the campground from us had the canopy on their truck destroyed when a bear tried to get the cooler they had stored in there. Unfortunately for them, they were also sleeping back there. They weren't hurt, just badly shaken, and from listening to the woman, I have a feeling she never camped again.
- TACD 3y ago> According to the bear's owners, the Cocaine Bear has the authority to officiate legally binding weddings in the mall where it is kept due to Kentucky's marriage laws. This claim is only partly true; the bear does not have the authority to solemnize weddings, but the state of Kentucky cannot invalidate marriages performed by unqualified persons if the parties believe that the person marrying them has the authority to do so. As such, it is a belief in the Cocaine Bear's authority that allows it to officiate legally binding weddings in Kentucky. *Wiping away a tear* God bless America.
- fblp 3y agoVarious states have pretty strict (including criminal laws) re littering and securing loads on vehicles. Montana does not. Linked are some examples that mostly apply to vehicles on highways but some apply to trains. Montana doesn't seem to have rules for trains, and even for trucks carrying agricultural produce and fertilizer seem to be exempt from littering laws. There are also environmental protection laws that may apply. So this seems like an issue that could be prevented by introducing littering laws / secure loads that apply in other states. https://www.pulltarps.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/WhitePaper-TarpingLaws-1.pdf https://www.pulltarps.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/WhitePa...
- gosub100 3y agoThe railroad owns the property on which they operate their trains. I don't think that spilling grain on your own property constitutes littering.
- malfist 3y agoI don't believe they do. The article mentions the trains are running through national parks.
- gosub100 3y agoThat's called an easement. I'd rather talk about what it effectively means, rather than the semantics of the word "own".
- PH95VuimJjqBqy 3y agois it an easement or do they own the land? It's not clear to me which is correct although I WOULD expect it to be an easement. I wonder if it's both depending on where it's at.
- dboreham 3y agoThese trains come from other states and are going to other states so I doubt MT regulations are the root cause.
- dclowd9901 3y agoSorry, but why is this on the front page? 63 deaths in 43 years. Im actually surprised only that many have been hit. I love curiosities as much as the next person, but I’m getting the sense someone’s trying to make a mountain out of a molehill here.
- Dalewyn 3y agoJournalist: "Look, just bear with me. I need to pump out another piece about global war-- I mean climate ch-- I mean extreme weath-- uhh, the environment."
- aendruk 3y agoThe issue of perverse behavior of self-preserving economic entities is interesting and touches upon broader concerns. > BNSF have been stalling doing anything for some years believing that the grizzly is going to be delisted (from endangered species status)
- myrmidon 3y agoI agree that this is not very front page relevant, but its still a lot of animals dying-- since the local bear population is <2000, 1.5 fatalities per year are quite significant! Compare to just ~700 human railway fatalities in the US (population: >300M)-- if railways were similarly lethal for us, the would be over 200000 deaths per year.
- CapsAdmin 3y agoMakes me wonder what a train can do other than to try and slow down and honk to make animals step aside and not run along the track. I would assume spraying water have been tried?
- gnicholas 3y agoYou'd have to be spraying the water pretty hard/fast for it to give the bear enough warning to get out of the way. I'd think that could injure the bear (though I suppose that's better than hitting it?).
- Symbiote 3y agoYou could read the final paragraphs of the article, which has some suggestions.
- lostlogin 3y agoYeah, but they would inconvenience the rail company. It needs to be cost neutral and effortless.
- dottedmag 3y agoIsn't it nice that the article has a summary with all the facts upfront for a change?
- black_puppydog 3y agoI "love" how the title makes it seem like it's the grizzlies' fault. As if they're the actors here.
- isametry 3y agoThe grizzlies are mentioned in passive voice, which by definition makes a subject acted on (rather than the acting one) in a sentence. While I see what you’re getting at from a human reader standpoint, in reality the reason for this phrasing (instead of the grammatically equivalent “Trains keep hitting drunk grizzlies”) is that starting with “Drunk grizzlies” just makes for an unmistakably better headline.
- black_puppydog 3y agoRight, the cause for the outcome might be (also messed-up) media industry incentives, but the outcome is still that the more accurate "we keep getting grizzlies drunk then running them over" stance gets replaced by something that reads more like it's their fault.
- isametry 3y agoThe messed up incentives of… Seeking as much attention as possible, which is as old as media itself and arguably the very purpose of its existence. Yeah, I guess you’re right. But then again, I’m afraid there’s bigger evils to fight in this world. Plus in this particular case, apart from the feelings it might generate in more engaged readers such as you, I don’t think the title has further real-life implications. People conscious enough to actually have an impact on the matter (e.g. those to potentially reach out to organizations, or appeal to railroad companies directly to secure their cargo better) will surely read the article and realize the bears are 100% the victims. Whereas the people who will think “haha, stoopid wasted bears” and move on, wouldn’t have actively done anything about the situation to begin with. They might still share the article though, which in turn increases its reach and improves its chance of finding someone who cares. If there’s a fallacy here please call me out, but at this moment I don’t think the “sensationalized” element in this title is a bad thing. At worst it’s neutral, apart from earning Cowboy State Daily some (un)deserved bucks.
- Aardwolf 3y agoIf it's that easy for things to ferment, makes me wonder if drunkenness existed (in animals) before humanity
- jahnu 3y agoDefinitely. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/article/151121-animals-science-drunk-insects-mammals-drinking https://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/article/151121-an... https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2022/04/220401141345.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2022/04/220401141345.h...
- jccalhoun 3y agoHow much grain is spilled? It seems that given the size of the bears that it would have to be a whole lot to actually get the bears drunk.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoI think animals get drunk much easier than humans because we have an adaptation that allows us to process alcohol.
- MichaelMoser123 3y agoFor Humans this adaptation is very localized, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ALDH2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ALDH2 Lots of people have less of that ALDH2 gene, so a much smaller dose will be enough to get them drunk.
- anon23432343 3y agoCowboy news? HN has become a second reddit...
- jadbox 3y agoLet's be honest, hn has always been populated with cowboys... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cowboy_coding https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cowboy_coding
- anon23432343 3y agoYou mean Coding Ninjas? Coding Rockstars? Coding Superstars? Coding <WORD OF THE YEAR TO DESCRIBE THE WORST DEV YOU KNOW>?
- LinuxBender 3y agoThe article could be worded differently and submitted to Nature to make it more HN friendly but I figured people might find the content something curious to discuss either way and perhaps give a small taste of the Mountain West to keep things interesting.
- Apocryphon 3y agobottom of the guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- paulcole 3y ago> Since 1980, 63 grizzlies have been hit by trains and killed along a section of railroad near Glacier National Park They could at least try to hide the fact that the headline is misleading rather than putting it directly below it…
- generic92034 3y agoAre the proportions in the first large image of the article off? Somehow the bear looks too small to me, compared to the rails.
- dboreham 3y agoPerhaps it was on the Great Western track when it was broad gauge?
- DrThunder 3y ago[dead]