6 ms·
YouTube's ad blocker crackdown escalates, aggravating users
- itsmemattchung 3y agoBeen experiencing intermittent frustration. Just last week, with uBlock origin installed, YouTube was preventing streaming almost every video I attempted to play. This week, have not received the ad blocker notification.
- ge96 3y agoubo's been on point, I had to refresh stuff first few days but yeah haven't seen it in a few
- jjbinx007 3y agoDoesn't seem to nag or block if you use Youtube if you're not logged in, but then you have to cope with the horrendous videos that get recommended.
- dwater 3y agoThe recommendations I found yesterday when I first got the 3 video warning were to turn off all other adblockers (I also use the Enhancer for YouTube extension which has it's own adblocker that I disabled), go to the uBlock Origin settings and enable the Adguard - Other Annoyances and Adguard - Popup Overlays blocks, purge all caches, and then click Update Now to update the blocklists. It's worked for the time being.
- ravenstine 3y agoInterestingly, I've yet to run into this issue. Since I've bought plenty of videos from YouTube, maybe they're letting me off the hook?
- nimbius 3y agoeasy fix for me, just block cookies from Youtube. on a more on-topic thought, this is a no-win situation for content providers. active reform of the advertisement model in Youtube is long overdue as twelve ads per video and a boilerplate ad from a content sponsor in the actual content is utterly unsustainable. people are motivated to stop adblock at google by a paycheck. this motivation pales in comparison to the white-hot rage most users experience at the current situation, combined with the open source model of most adblock projects. at best, the current effort from Meta is like pouring gasoline on a bonfire. People will join these projects even if its just to provide rapid debug data.
- slowmovintarget 3y agoGoogle is going much further than that, though. Google's Web Environment Integrity spec intends to give website providers control over what executes on your machine. You'd better believe this includes a way to ensure an adblocker isn't present.
- beej71 3y agoRemember, everyone: when you pay for Premium or watch ads, you're supporting the company that wants to do this to the web. Just say no.
- bananapub 3y agoI mean ads suck, but YouTube, unlike most of the web, is very happy to take your money in exchange for not showing you ads, so it seems entirely fair.
- hypeatei 3y agoI've never bought YT premium but from what other users have said, they still show ads anyway.
- LegitShady 3y agonegative. No youtube ads when using premium.
- wnevets 3y agoI've never seen an ad from YouTube with premium. Creators inserting ads into their own videos are outside of YouTubes control
- hypeatei 3y agoAh okay. Maybe there is confusion between their YT Music premium and the "video" premium. Some also seem to be saying that sponsored content is what they're referring to.
- Modified3019 3y ago“Sponsorblock” is a crowdsourced tool that helps take care of creator ads: https://sponsor.ajay.app/ https://sponsor.ajay.app/ Yt-dlp can also make use of it.
- wnevets 3y agoI just avoid any creator that is spamming their videos with sponsors. For example I have zero problem with how Gamers Nexus does their sponsor bits and it's just not worth trying to block them.
- 3y ago
- iandanforth 3y agoI got hit by this pretty hard and have since moved a lot of my viewing to https://freetubeapp.io/ https://freetubeapp.io/ (An AGPL desktop viewer for YouTube content)
- stbtrax 3y agoyou have a public profile with your real name, employer, and research interests and you're posting about workarounds to not pay a small subscription fee?
- 65 3y agoAnd? Who cares?
- fyrn_ 3y ago$14 a month _is_ pretty expensive, especially for some users were used to getting for free for many years. Also, this is _hacker_ news, have we really reqched the point where even something as benign as a link to an alternative youtube frontend is to risque?
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoYou mean hacking isn't synonymous with corporate bootlicking and supporting the hobbyist-turned-professional monetized locking down of cyberspace by advertisers?
- mozman 3y agoI watch a lot of youtube, never once got any warnings or pop ups. I have seen video bitrates drop, having to manually select the high bw option
- jdeaton 3y agoThis enforcement has helped me a lot reduce habitual youtube use in moments of boredom. Now when I hit the playback block, it gives me a moment of pause to remember that that watching youtube isn't something I really want to be spending my time doing anyways, so I just close the tab.
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoInshallah. Wallahi. When YouTube forces ads, I'll quit and get my life right. :copium: (Or VPN in from South Africa until it also rolls out over there.)
- whywhywhywhy 3y agoThe day uBlock "Purge All Caches" "Update Rules Now" stops working is the day I just start using something else.
- exabrial 3y agoI'm sort of excited about this. There are great subscription streaming service like Nebula that content producers have been advocating for. Google management is going to boost sales over there as people exit YouTube and we can finally break it's monopoly hold.
- drcongo 3y agoI'm with you. YouTube is a clown car of user-hostile design and clickbait. I'd never heard of Nebula so just had a quick look, design looks OK but the horrendous thumbnails of people pulling stupid faces and debasing themselves for clicks is sadly almost as bad as YouTube. I'm resigned to the fact that dignity is an anachronism in 2023.
- mvdtnz 3y agoI bought a Nebula subscription to support Grady Hillhouse and have been deeply disappointed in it. Virtually everything I have found there can also be found free on YouTube (including Grady's own Practical Construction series, something he didn't make clear when promoting Nebula for the series). And it's full of the same clickbait crap like "7 dumbest animals in the world" and that fucking face YouTubers all make for their thumbnails. The app is also dog slow.
- Euphorbium 3y agoI was hyped when it came out, paid for a subscription for a year and it was unusable. Did not improve in the year, so I just cancelled. Somehow the quality looked worse than the worst 180p. Not 1080p, 180p.
- leereeves 3y agoI can't say what was wrong for you, but Nebula doesn't have that problem for me.
- kup0 3y agoI subscribed to Nebula and honestly there hasn't been any content there that has ever kept me coming back. Been subscribed for a year and all the content I want is still only on YouTube. They're going to have to screw over creators bad enough for creators to move elsewhere before there's any remotely significant change in critical mass
- haunter 3y agoWish they would offer Google One and YT Premium together tho
- iAMkenough 3y agoI'm holding out for Alphabet Plus
- taylodl 3y agoI want a YouTube TV, YouTube Red, and YouTube Music bundle. Bundle and save! Ive held off on YouTube Red because I have YouTube TV and I'm kinda pissed they don't have a bundle.
- xnx 3y agoI pay for YouTube, but will be very annoyed if YouTube starts targeting SponsorBlock or limiting speed controls.
- altvali 3y agoI caved in and bought Premium (currently in the free trial month). It greatly enhanced the experience on my phone as well, plus I do most of my learning on youtube, so given how valuable it is for me, I don't mind paying.
- hotnfresh 3y agoReally gotta finally get around to archiving everything on Youtube that I care about this weekend, before it implodes completely. ... yt-dlp does still work for now, right? Or have I waited too long?
- Darmody 3y agoI don't know about everybody else but if I can't use an adblocker on Youtube I'll look for content somewhere else. The platform is not vital to me. Most of what I watch is because I'm procrastinating or curious about something. I can live without it. I already watch enough ads when I watch some Youtube on my TV. This is like when game companies thought that killing piracy would increase their sales.
- bananapub 3y ago> This is like when game companies thought that killing piracy would increase their sales. how is it like that at all? YouTube says: hey guys, it costs a bunch of money to host exabytes of video and a video CDN, so we either need to show ads or charge you the price of two pints a month. what secret third option would you like them to offer?
- Darmody 3y agoIt's like that because if I had pay to watch Youtube I wouldn't. I'd watch what I want on other platforms even if I had to pay. Google is already making a lot of money from me and it doesn't stop there. They spy on me. They process every bit of data they can find of me even if I don't want to and I don't see a cent.
- throwing_away 3y agoFor your TV needs: https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube I think YouTube doesn't realize the size of the beast they're provoking if they intentionally break downloaders, adblockers, and alternate clients. If this is a cat and mouse game of technical prowess between hackers and Google engineers to consume content without ads, Google will either lose or use the government to do violence on open source developers. If that game begins in earnest, then people will fear for the long term existence of YouTube, and it will become self-fulfilling as people mirror content on other sites until the cat-and-mouse game becomes pointless -- investing ever more money into ever smaller returns. New video sites will gain massive number of users and over-inflate in value if there's a YouTube exodus and the process can begin anew.
- jahabrewer 3y agoCan't wait to hear why Google should host unfathomable gobs of video for free in perpetuity.
- RamblingCTO 3y agoI only have ublock origin and sponsorblock and nothing changed. I would appreciate a bit of help with the habit of watching too much youtube though! I'm also very happy to see youtube implode, hopefully it does and spawns something new. Remember reddit? Whatever happened to that ...
- simple10 3y agoI just tested uBlock Origin and didn't see any warnings (or ads) on youtube.com on Chrome. I was not logged in. Do only logged in users get the popup warnings? Or maybe uBlock Origin isn't effected yet? It seems fair game to me that YouTube would block ad blockers. Video hosting is relatively expensive and creators rely on the ad income. Am I missing something from the argument as to why people are aggravated?
- rowls66 3y agoAnother sign that the gold rush phase of the web is over. It is no longer enough for companies to just increase their active user base and be rewarded with a rising share price. Google gets paid for showing users adds, so if users aren’t looking at the adds, there is no reason to incur the cost of showing them content, and if they stop using the service, so be it. It’s been 25 years, but it’s nice to see that fundamental economic principles still hold even on the internet. I expect that we will be seeing much more of this in the near future.
- hereme888 3y agoI don't see any ads or warnings. Maybe my combination of Brave + custom NextDNS + uBlock + Enhancer for YouTube + DF YouTube will keep working for the forseeable future. I also use Brave on my Android and wife's iPhone, which has the option to block YT ads. And I use NewPipe on my Android. Just in case anyone wants to copy my setup, because it works well.
- bananapub 3y agoit really is fascinating to read the comments on posts like this and find out just how many people are massive cheapskates who have spent ages constructing elaborate ethical systems to justify not paying ~two pints a month to get the thing they say they want.
- slowmovintarget 3y ago> ...users aren't allowed to "modify" the service or "circumvent, disable, fraudulently engage with, or otherwise interfere with any part of the Service (or attempt to do any of these things), including security-related features or features that (a) prevent or restrict the copying or other use of Content or (b) limit the use of the Service or Content." Sorry Google, but how my computer operates is not part of your Service.
- correlator 3y agoI can just close the popup and play the video. Does that not work for anyone else?
- danaris 3y agoThere are multiple versions of it—some that are just a "hey, please turn off your adblo—oh, you're closing the popup, okay :'(" and others that are a full blockage that you can't get past without turning off adblock.
- kup0 3y agoWhile I'm a full-on ad-blocker user and will almost never disable an ad-blocker to use or support any website, I also think it's fine if a service wants to block my access for using one. I pay for YT Premium because right now it's worth it- it and Twitch (I use Turbo) are both essentially my only video entertainment (instead of paying far more for cable or something- I don't watch regular TV shows or movies anyway). I would rather a service cease to exist, require a subscription, than view ads. My attention is not for sale to the lowest bidder. Yes, I understand that some of what survives on the web today is because it has been ad supported- and that it's one way we have democratized / made content available to the masses, including those that can't afford to pay- I just think we'd find another way if ads went away and it's sad that advertising ever was allowed to have the foothold it has today and become the industry it is. Its very existence is repugnant.
- xnx 3y agoThere's currently a bug(?) where YouTube videos displayed as modal/overlays from Google search results will show ads even if you are a YouTube Premium subscriber.
- joak 3y agoHey why everyone thinks it's legitimate to pay for content? So if you are poor, access to content should be denied to you? Most of the people on the internet are poor accessing youtube with $40 smartphones. They cannot pay premium, why send them ads? What's the point? Make them waste their precious time and bandwidth?
- water-data-dude 3y agoHere’s my 2 cents that no one asked for: youtube has been the default video hosting service for a LONG TIME. It’s free to host videos, free to watch videos - it’s what people automatically think of when they think about watching longer videos online. As a consequence of it’s “default-ness”, there’s a lot of content that isn’t available anywhere else. Sometimes I can’t find a specific lecture, hardware installation video, or - yes - that funny video a friend sent me anywhere else. And it sucks, because I don’t want the tendrils from Google’s evil empire squirming into me like nematodes, but if I want to access that specific piece of content I need to take a big slurp from the cursed chalice. A big part of me hopes that this ends with more people putting their content somewhere else. Will “somewhere else” be any better? I have no idea. Would a video hosting diaspora even be desirable? Also no idea - it might be a terrible idea that ends with a lot of content being lost forever when a service goes belly up. I just feel like there’s got to be a better way.
- shashashasha___ 3y agoI just wrote a userscript to remove their timer dialog. Their recommendations are pretty bad and are not worth the subscription.