11 ms·
New Study Says Maybe Helicopter Parenting Is Making Kids Depressed
- callalex 3y agoMaybe the earth/environment collapsing around them while nobody does anything to fix it is also depressing.
- klyrs 3y agoWhy not both? Adults are no less depressed/anxious about being powerless to fix the environment, but they do have power over their children...
- timeon 3y agoHelicopter parenting forces kids to live in car-in-between nodes.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Lammy 3y agoOr at least all the constant doomsaying about it
- MrRolleyes 3y ago[flagged]
- skrebbel 3y agoNobody? All the solar stats are up and the right, IEA expects fossil fuel consumption will soon plateau, solar panel prices keep going down faster than experts predict, seas are getting flooded with windmill parks etc etc.
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y agoI don't see why you're getting downvoted. There is an ocean of difference between "we're on track to fix things" and "nobody's doing anything at all", yes, but it does nobody any good to pretend we haven't even gotten on the boat yet. They'll just reach the assumption that it's 100% hopeless.
- skrebbel 3y agoThanks. I was rather confused as well so I just assumed that it’s people who are so attached to their doomsday conviction they actively block good news.
- ben_w 3y agoI've also been surprised by witnessing a bit of that here recently. I guess the names "last generation" and "extinction rebellion" are sincere.
- skrebbel 3y agoFwiw I see the extinction rebellion groups as a beacon of hope (even if they’re way more pessimistic than I am). I live in NL and as far as I can see their work is actually beginning to move the needle. You don’t go sit on a highway and block all traffic with 200 people for a month straight if you believe it’s all futile anyway.
- ben_w 3y agoGood point. I was focussing a bit too much on the "extinction" and not on the "rebellion" part.
- southerntofu 3y agoNo, we haven't gotten on the boat. Who cares how dirty energy is when so much of it is wasted? Who cares if electricity comes from solar or wind, if you're still adding PFAS to any furniture and other dirty chemicals in all food supply chains. Industrial lobbies (aka "green capitalism") are trying to frame the debate as a question of clean energies, but for decades scientists have known and studied that consuming less, and more durable products is the only way out of this global crisis. Another example, industrial organic agriculture (yes that's a thing) is still very damaging to the environment in many ways (eg. contributing to desertification of soils), while permaculture/agroforestry is good for everyone but less profitable. So i replied to the original comment in good faith, but such arguments are usually pushed by industrialists who explicitly profit from destroying the environment and silencing the narratives of actual scientists and environmentalists. Capitalism is what destroyed everything (see also scientists naming this geological era "capitalocene"), and nothing it can produce it can fix the inherent death-bringing at its core.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoMy belief as well. "Hey kids. You're inheriting a cluster fuck. There's hate, and war, and gloom & doom around every corner. But look, we give you...The Kardashians!!! And never forget, here's a never ending list of things you need to worry about...Don't go outside, it's dangerous. Eat this shite fake food and they worry about your heakth...and so on..." But it's social media to blame??? That disconnect would be funny if it wasn't so sad.
- bregma 3y agoMaybe. Growing up in the 1960s we all expected to die in the imminent nuclear holocaust. That was a relatively good thing because if we didn't most people were expected to perish from mass starvation by the year 2000 due to the global population bomb. But yeah, kids today have it hard because their future looks bleak.
- persponsibility 3y agoI got excited when I saw something about helicopters. There are hardly ever any articles about helicopters on HN. I have a commercial helicopter license and almost 900 hours of combined helicopter and airplane flight time. If any extra rich people in the bay area or Sacramento want to buy a heli I will be your personal pilot available 24/7. Helis can go almost anywhere. I love to fly but it is hard to fly them unless you have a lot of money. You can get a used Robinson R-44 4 seater for about $500k. Maintenance and insurance are expensive but no insurance is required if you pay cash. Let me know.
- Aloha 3y agoI love your enthusiasm no matter how not directly on topic it may be ;-)
- fakedang 3y ago> I love to fly but it is hard to fly them unless you have a lot of money. I have a comfortable amount of money, and I have been certified to fly some small airplanes, including one turbojet model, yet helicopters still elude me - it's just so much harder. Much respect to you sir.
- kreeben 3y agoI have an uncomfortable amount of money, so uncomfortable it makes flying in a helicopter a pipe dream. Guess I'll have to drive my kid to football practice in a plain ol' car. I know, car's are very 1999.
- jraby3 3y agoThis makes sense. You give kids confidence by letting them get through difficult situations on their own. If the parent fixes every issue, kids never develop confidence. They feel incapable of solving their own problems. That’s a recipe for depression.
- GMoromisato 3y agoI'm slightly confused because the chart shows a sharp decrease in suicides between 1994 and 2007 and then a gradual increase. But neither theory (bad social media or helicopter parents) explains the curve. Did helicopter parenting get better between 1994 and 2007 and then get worse? Why did suicides increase between 1968 and 1994 and then start decreasing? AITA for expecting a theory to explain the observed curve?
- readthenotes1 3y agoThat sudden drop in 2000 smells like redefinition so that the data before and after aren't measuring the same thing.
- throwbadubadu 3y agoHelicopter parenting was not (a very widespread?) thing til the age of smartphones (not meaning any causation), which started 2006, realistically for the masses 2010, or was it? Only learned or heard this term 2015-2020ish..
- vasco 3y agoYou did not hear about it till 10-15 years after it got mainstream then: https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=Helicopter+parent&year_start=1975&year_end=2019&corpus=en-2019 https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=Helicopter+par...
- throwbadubadu 3y agoThanks for the reference - indeed no. But it is also totally not my focus/interest, so how I meant it actually there was that when that term reached me, it must have already been much spread and likely something 5-10 years after its creation ;)
- jl6 3y agoThere is probably no single factor that totally explains the trend, but rather a multitude of contributing factors that will be extremely difficult to disentangle. Most of the world’s big headline problems are similar - most have no single smoking-gun root cause, but a whole bunch of factors that come together and interact in complex ways. We seek simple narratives, but that’s just not the way the world at large works. Accordingly, I think “social media causes depression” and “social media doesn’t cause depression” could be equally bogus takes.
- mcpackieh 3y agoLack of agency causing depression? Makes perfect sense to me. Helicopter parenting, particularly of teenagers, is like locking an animal into a cage.
- gnicholas 3y agoInteresting that the study author attributes the decline in teen suicides from 1990 to 2005 to technology. [1] In particular, he says that adults considered children (especially boys, who make up the large majority of teen suicides) to be knowledgeable about computers, which gave the kids agency. 1: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/freedom-to-learn/202309/why-did-teen-suicides-decline-sharply-from-1990-to-2005 https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/freedom-to-learn/202...
- bombcar 3y agoThe Internet also allowed you to find like minded people to talk with. That alone could be a huge factor.
- pollux01 3y agoI am a victim of this and was depressed until, I took control of my life. The worst part is, all of your life decision are taken by the parents and you feel at odds at your own emotions when you grow up to become an adult. Now a days, any words that my parent utter, even if the advice is a good one, I never take them seriously. Lost trust on both the parents.
- synecdoche 3y agoThis makes sense. Kids need agency and make their own mistakes. And parents to guide them not too far off course on the road to adulthood and a well functioning being in society.
- matt89 3y agoI feel very similarly having grown up with a very overprotective and overly attached mother. I'm constantly struggling with emotions and have a lot of self doubt and don't feel like Im in control of my life. Been slowly regaining this control and trying to improve myself via therapy. Unfortunately right now I don't value my parents very much and Im resentful towards my mother. Perhaps that will change in future, perhaps not.
- helij 3y agoPeople are not perfect. I know it's hard now but I urge you not to resent your mother. If she was otherwise kind then she was just overprotective and overly attached because she loves you.
- whstl 3y agoI'm on the same boat. To me the worst part is that their behavior hasn't really changed as I became an adult, and in fact the have gotten worse. I'm not affected anymore due to stronger and more mature boundaries, but my siblings still are. And damn if it those boundaries are not isolating as hell. Another very isolating factor is societal response to having a less than ideal relationship with ones parents. Some people really change their opinion on you after knowing you're not close with your folks.
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y agoThe great irony of helicopter parenting is it doesn't accomplish all that much. After you cover the First World basics (adequate nutrition, no violence in the home etc) you just don't have that much control over who your kids will eventually grow up to be, no matter how much test prep or whatever you throw at them. See also: https://www.npr.org/2011/04/22/135612560/selfish-reasons-for-parents-to-enjoy-having-kids https://www.npr.org/2011/04/22/135612560/selfish-reasons-for...
- ravenstine 3y agoExactly. The best you can do is provide your children what they need to allow them to become who they are, and maybe some guard rails to discourage them from the not so great parts of themselves until they can adequately self-reflect. Otherwise, the idea that parents can "mould" their children without also damaging them in some way seems unproven. Case in point, I know someone who grew up with a helicopter parent who kept said person and their siblings effectively sheltered from adulthood well into their 20s. Despite all experiencing more or less the same childhood with a parent imposing the same values, each of the siblings ended up having very different personalities and attitudes towards life. They get along fairly well, but each is very different from one another, and none of them identify with the aformentioned parent. Although this person is more safety-paranoid than is average, which seems to be one of the few things to have been moulded by the parent. How positive! There are many possible reasons for helicopter parenting, but I think one widespread cultural cause is the post Great Depression idea that failures in adulthood are borderline unrecoverable. When I was a young person not so long ago, a message we got from our authority figures was that, if we fail for whatever reason, it will have disastrous consequences; fail a classes or don't go to college and you'll be unsuccessful while your peers who did exactly what they were told will be showered with riches, safety, and happiness. This erroneous attitude is meant to keep young people in line and, though it doesn't always work, many young people internalize it, and their own parenting skills are influenced as a result. Simultaneously, American society in the last century and half, and especially in the last two decades, has done far more to de-adultize young people than any society prior to it. So-called "adolescents" and even later teens, whom would have been considered adults until recent history, face a substantial amount of oppression from every level of society that more than ever are failing to launch at 18 or even after college. The more this happens, the less confidence that older adults have in the competence of young people, creating a cycle of more and more shielding. Young people in America today are barely trusted with anything, which is ironic given that, in many parts of the world, they would be trusted with tasks like herding large animals and operating heavy machinery. Outside of a rural farm life, many young people are essentially treated as mentally challenged; they can't open a bank account without a parent having control over it, have their privacy routinely violated by their parents (not every parent does this, but it's extremely common), don't have control over their private property, can only work "safe" jobs for a limited number of hours, can't move away from their parents without begging a judge for emancipation, can't consent to their own medical treatment, can't vote, are subject to curfew laws, must go to public school, and so forth. Garbage in, garbage out, anyone? The view that children and even young people in their late teens need so much protection is a cycle that feeds itself, and there's scant evidence that such levels of protection are necessary. At worst, alienating young people from the adult world can be damaging and cause delays in becoming fully functional as an autonomous individual.
- jtrn 3y agoJust my personal experience working as a psychologist with kids: The kids who were overly protected had about the same amount of problems as the kids from seriously neglected homes. So when I want to make my case for NOT overprotecting kids, I say: "If you really want to damage your kid: Protect them from all adversity." I do think that the whole "suicide is increasing" trope is seldom put in context. Of course, it's a serious issue. But the number is relatively stubbornly just hanging around 5-15 per 100k for all nations for hundreds of years. So when people say stuff like "suicide among teenagers is skyrocketing," I roll my eyes, because I know they think THEY know the cause of the supposed epidemic of suicide. The absolute risk of suicide has been almost strangely stable across culture and time (as a population rate). By contrast, it is so good to see that death by drowning and car accidents have plummeted over the last 50 years. Here is a link to some interesting graphs on cause-of-death: https://www.nejm.org/doi/10.1056/NEJMsr1804754 https://www.nejm.org/doi/10.1056/NEJMsr1804754 On a side now, I love the nerd tangent in this thread about actual helicopters :P
- Aeolun 3y agoI had to read this twice, because it seemed like you said that overprotective, and neglective parents have the same outcomes, but I think you are mostly trying to say that parents which are neither overprotective nor neglective have a lower rate of issues right?
- orwin 3y agoThat's my reading (in case GP doesn't respond).
- logicchains 3y ago>overprotective, and neglective parents have the same outcomes I think that is what they were saying; I've seen the stat elsewhere, that extremely spoiling children produces just as bad outcomes on average as neglecting them.
- meiraleal 3y agoOP said same amount of problems not the same problems or same outcome. As in, sheltered kids will fail as much, becoming alcoholics, criminals, depressed and frustrated with not accomplishing things their parents made easier for them.
- NotGMan 3y agoThe effect of heli parenting is the same as when you have a boss that is an idiot and you hate him because you realize he is incomptent but he doesn't see it: you intuitively realize that something is very wrong but you may have credit so you are locked into the job. With a kid it's much worse: you can quit from a job even if you have credit (risky), but as a kid you can NEVER "quit" from your parents: it's being stuck in a perpetual situation with a shitty boss who gives you no freedom and micromanages you.
- david-gpu 3y agoThe title blames "helicopter parenting" while the actual study blames the lack of independent mobility: > Considerable research, mostly in Europe, has focused on children’s independent mobility (CIM), defined as children’s freedom to travel in their neighborhood or city without adult accompaniment Isn't that lack of independent mobility largely caused by car-centric urban planning? Children and teens can't safely roam the streets on foot or by bike because of the awful amount of car traffic everywhere. Urban sprawl is the direct cause of car dangerous and noisy car traffic everywhere, as well as the reason why interesting places are often too far apart to walk between them. I'm currently trying to find a place to live where my kids can become more independent and it's surprisingly difficult to find places like that in Canada. Suburbia may have little traffic, but they are also devoid of "third places" where teens can be teens.
- csydas 3y agoI would largely agree with this viewpoint having grown up in the US in a medium sized city. Everything was a few miles away, public transit was present but not reliable (missing a bus meant waiting 40+ minutes for the next one), no bike lanes or paths except for one outside of the city, etc. as a child bikes were our only option to meet friends but this meant biking in traffic or on sidewalks, neither pleasant or convenient. While i survived fine, it was in spite of the childhood, not because of it. I still don’t want to bike in a city unless they have well defined and protected bike lanes; too many close calls, not so close calls that ended up in disaster, bike theft, etc. After moving to Europe and seeing how mobile kids are without cars even, i wish i had that growing up, as just seems so much nicer to be able to meet friends and do things without needing a car or having to survive biking in traffic. I’m glad i had internet very early to make hanging out with friends easier and keeping up with what’s going on way easier. instead of having to do a bunch of phone calls or go visit and make plans, we could just do IRC or AIM or Skype chats and it’s much like it is nowadays for planning and joining/declining meetups. I do wonder what my teens years would have looked like if we had the same public transport options as most EU cities do.
- filoleg 3y ago> After moving to Europe and seeing how mobile kids are without cars even, i wish i had that growing up, as just seems so much nicer to be able to meet friends and do things without needing a car or having to survive biking in traffic. Same, but in regards to moving to NYC recently. Seeing just random groups of kids who look no older than middle schoolers riding on subway along with everyone else and just going about their day and visiting places on weekends makes me feel happy for them. Just knowing that people are able to have that kind of experiences I only could dream of having as a child. Makes me feel hopeful, knowing that at least some of the kids in get to grow up like this. I am very confident that helicopter parenting was the biggest hindrance when it came time for me to get out into the real world. The level of preparedness that those kids growing up in NYC will have is a great advantage. Quite a few of my friends who grew up in NYC (and other places with similar cultures around public transport usage; ofc almost all of those other ones were outside of the US) definitely have that “just built different” feel to them. And that feel mostly extends to things like going to places, trying new things, independence/drive, etc., which all feel like extensions of those experiences I described above. Not trying to say “NYC-grown people are special, and people from the rest of the US is all the same and lame,” that’s entirely false. Lots of different parts of the US with people who grew up there having their own unique culture and “built different” feel (SoCal, south-east, north-east, PNW, Texas, etc.). But in terms of that independence and just being able to go places and do things on your own from a very early age (way before you can get a driver’s permit/license in any US state), it absolutely feels like it gives people something that is very difficult to replicate otherwise.
- nemo44x 3y agoPeople helicopter parent children because they have so few children today. This intensifies risk adversity and the default behavior is to over protect and smother their kid since it gives a sense of control. When people had more kids they could look after each other, and although a tragedy if you lost one you still had others left. Additionally when you have many kids it’s not possible to helicopter them.
- Dowwie 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37902599 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37902599
- Maarten88 3y agoIt's annoying how the article shows that independent activity/movement of children has declined drastically in the US and UK over the past 30 years while suicides have risen and how this contrasts to Finland where young children are much more independent. But then it somehow fails to compare the trends in teen suicides between those geographies and does not prove the point.
- chongli 3y agoI would have thought this would be obvious but I don’t see a single mention of it. The reason for helicopter parenting and a lack of independent mobile kids is the disappearance of stay at home moms. When I was a kid in the early 90’s we moved to a new neighbourhood with hundreds of families and kids my age. There were stay at home moms all over the place so everyone collectively felt safe letting kids roam during the day, especially in the afternoon when they got out of school until supper time and all day during the summer break. What changed since then? The cost of housing shot through the roof! Now it’s extremely difficult to afford a house on a single income so stay at home moms are much rarer. This has also led to loneliness and depression for moms staying home with very young children and I believe a big part of that is due to a lack of other moms around to socialize with. So when the kids start school these moms rush back into the workforce and feel much better getting to socialize with other adults. But all of this leads to neighbourhoods having a very different character during the day. With basically no friendly eyes around, the place seems much more dangerous and scary. Of course it also does not help that traffic has gone way up. My neighbourhood also has the (common) issue that there is more than one entrance/exit to main roads so there is a lot of through-traffic and people tend to drive way over the residential speed limits when they’re just passing through. This could be fixed by designing subdivisions as trees rooted at a main road, making through traffic impossible, but you can’t really retrofit a neighbourhood like that.
- mharig 3y agoDon't forget the abominable nanny states. I.e. all nation states I know. The overkill of laws and bureaucracy, that affects directly and indirectly parents and kids, must be destroyed. Normal childhood is an evolving exploration of the environment, with growing age more and more independent and (self-)educated. If you steal that from the kids, you steal their whole childhood. And as one cannot grow up without this progress, you steal their adulthood, too.
- dunkmaster 3y agoParadox: Japanese children have high independent mobility: young kids can be seen walking to school, taking subway and buses. Yet Japan is known for high suicide rate.