11 ms·
A third of chocolate products are high in heavy metals
- BaculumMeumEst 3y agolike the article says, the takeaway isn't to panic, but just to consider dark chocolate a food you don't overindulge in. obviously you want to avoid contaminants, but some degree of exposure is part of life, and it's the dose that makes the poison.
- davzie 3y agoI know I'm spending too long on HN when I start panicking about every day normal things to consume or do incase it poisons me, causes cancer, gives me alzheimer's or something else that makes top page posts. The health-nut side of HN is what lets it down and makes it a depressing place to hang out in.
- Pigalowda 3y agoJust eat a balanced diet and exercise. Don’t smoke, drink, or do drugs (if you do then do them sparingly). Everything else won’t move the needle and should be mostly ignored - someone is selling you something or gaining a click. Luckily for the American health care industry people ignore that advice and do their very level best to oppose it at every turn.
- davzie 3y agoWell a big green tick for me on all those points. Thanks for being a voice of reason!
- Dylan16807 3y ago> Just eat a balanced diet and exercise. I've never seen a particularly good definition for "balanced diet", and many communities that are super healthy have diets that don't look balanced at all.
- BaculumMeumEst 3y agothe problem is these submissions are incentivized to scare the shit out of you, but not to be honest about “how worried you should be about it”. this heavily applies to MSM stories as well. once i understood that, i got more aggressive about hiding this kind of content, or taking it with a huge grain of salt.
- Blackthorn 3y agoThere is no safe level of lead exposure, though.
- jksflkjl3jk3 3y agoHow are you defining a "safe level"? Everyone in the world has been exposed to some amount of lead and most live out relatively long and healthy lives.
- rgrieselhuber 3y agoComments like these are always so annoying to be honest. It takes the responsibility off the food manufacturers to do really simple things like, let’s not put toxic chemicals in food, and instead writes the whole thing down with flimsy statements like “well you’re already poisoned to some degree, should be fine though.”
- smegger001 3y agoBut its not entirely wrong there is some natural background level of expected exposure for things like lead, arsenic, mercury, etc as they are naturally occurring part of our environment. wanting to know what the floor is when talking about exposure to these toxins helps you understand the scale of exposure.
- rgrieselhuber 3y agoIn what environment should we be expected to naturally encounter lead, arsenic, and mercury?
- jksflkjl3jk3 3y agoJust about anywhere in the world that's not a sterilized room.
- 3y ago
- Obscurity4340 3y agoIts kind of ironic that dark chocolate is more a rich person's thing on a practical level and that the shittier the chocolate (in the sense of real chocolate content which is heavily used as a proxy for quality), the safer it might be
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoNot the first time. White bread was originally a rich person's food compared to whole grain. It cost more to produce white flour. Now we promote whole grain and charge more for it.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoLol, I feel that way about anything "white" in terms of breads and such except like if its with italian food
- e40 3y agoNote there is a good site for checking your chocolate: https://www.asyousow.org/environmental-health/toxic-enforcement/toxic-chocolate#chocolate-tables https://www.asyousow.org/environmental-health/toxic-enforcem... It's nice that Consumer Reports made OP free for non-subscribers.
- SllX 3y agoThanks! The results were what I expected and depressing, but at least now I know.
- crazygringo 3y agoWhat were you expecting? I personally can't see any kind of pattern anywhere at all, except dark chocolate is (logically) higher. Also, one-time testing isn't going to reveal much. Since different manufacturers are constantly getting different batches of beans from different farms, wouldn't the heavy metal content in any chocolate bar be essentially random? E.g. Cadbury's might be low in April, high in May, and then medium in June.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoMakes you wonder if there's any way to "synthesize" whatever it is that makes cacao make cacao or something to the effect of the way various opioids and flavors are already synthesized en masse, although obviously in the opioid case we're probably not gonna get around having to grow poppies forever.
- SllX 3y agoUnfortunately (or fortunately? But I’m guessing this affects them to given the description of how this happens) I don’t see any brands I actually eat on this list, save for Lindt, but we’re talking one of those chocoballs two or three times a year.
- denton-scratch 3y ago> Kids and pregnant people should consume dark chocolate sparingly I've never met kids that like dark chocolate. Pregnant "people" (IME they're usually women) famously have appetites for all kinds of interesting foods.
- BaculumMeumEst 3y agoyou can just say pregnant women
- jcutrell 3y agoI don’t think HN is the place for arguing gender politics. Pregnant people is as or more accurate than pregnant women.
- GamerUncle 3y agoThere is simply no place to discuss whether there is anything beside pregnant women, giving the space to this antiscientifical vocab in science is not a matter of discussion don't let the loonies run the asylum simple as
- elzbardico 3y ago[flagged]
- MrOwen 3y agoNitpick: you probably mean pregnant females. Man/woman is sociological, male/female is biological.
- bigstrat2003 3y agoIt may well not be the place, but the GP isn't the one who opened that door.
- actuallyalys 3y agoIn a comment section where people are (rightfully) arguing the interpretation of microgram differences and the merits of different visualization schemes, I think we can be nuanced here as well and use language that reflects the fact that transgender men and nonbinary people also get pregnant, even though most pregnant people are indeed women.
- AdamN 3y agoMeta point here but Consumer Reports is doing really solid work for the consumer and is a nonprofit that needs donations - please consider subscribing/supporting.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoI really hate that Facebook has turned this sentence into something that used to have nothing to do with them that you did not intend and that is absent from your sentence in spirit but for the letter- like connotation they have legally purchased forever now.
- trgn 3y agowhoa! Consumer Reports is a non-profit. TIL.
- okokwhatever 3y agoGoal 2030: be the healthiest in the cemetery
- omginternets 3y agoThere’s a joke I like a lot (fair warning: it is a stupid one). An elderly husband and wife die in their sleep on the same night. They both appear before the pearly gates, where St. John takes them on a tour of the heavens, ending with the banquet hall. The table is overflowing with all sorts of delicious foods—sweets, beautiful cuts of meat, cakes, cocktails, etc. This puts the husband in a foul mood, which further degrades into full-on sulking when he sees the liquor cabinet and the humidor. Eventually, his wife says to him “okay, dear, out with it. What did I do wrong this time?” The husband glares back at her and mutters under his breath, “you and your damn bran-muffins… we could have been here years ago.”
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- prmoustache 3y agoThat's what we get when we pretend recycling stuff while all we do is sending the bad stuff to the very same countries that are tasked to grow our food.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoSerious question: say burning garbage had no detrimental impact, it would be the best solution right? We know that's not the case (don't we?) so how do we move through that particular "solution-tree" to get to the right practical solution/implementation? Not sure if what I'm saying is cogent but I feel like there's an ideological game of hide and seek not being played or someone is "it" and simply leaving the rest of the players to hide but they lobbied against a rule that allowed for unoffical games of hide and seek and insisted they are only ever "it" and the rest of the players can't gather and create their own non-sanctioned game that disincludes the current player and that the current instance can never actually end to allow for a new game.
- kleton 3y agoJapan incinerates essentially all of their trash, and it's not a polluted hellscape.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoSo why aren't we doing that? Like what's the rub? And it better not be BigRecycling or imma lose my mind right now (you know what I mean) :/
- kleton 3y agoLong ago, they tried burning trash in other countries and it was just basically an open burn pit, so incineration is a political no-go. Even though now it's possible to attain essentially complete oxidation and no nox/sox/ash in flue gas.
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Aurornis 3y agoIt’s interesting to see the charts with a binary threshold where green is good and red is bad: https://www.asyousow.org/environmental-health/toxic-enforcement/toxic-chocolate#chocolate-tables https://www.asyousow.org/environmental-health/toxic-enforcem... The threshold is based on heavy metals per serving. I suppose it makes sense that dark chocolate would be flagged more frequently because it has a higher concentration of cacao per serving. It also means that for some of these products, eating half as much dark chocolate would give the same dose as someone eating twice as much milk chocolate. Good reminder to consider the absolute dose rather than binary thresholds.
- crazygringo 3y agoYeah, I don't like the binary threshold at all. 3.8 is green, while 4.3 is red? That hardly makes a difference to your health. Meanwhile, both 0.2 and 3.8 are green, while 4.3 and 19.2 are red? It doesn't distinguish at all that one is 4x or 20x worse or better than another. A color interpolation would be far more informative for health.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoHow much chocolate do you think the heaviest "chocoholics" consume? Demographically (in terms of money and in reference to the consumer), who do you think is most likely to be "vulnerable" to this reality? What's the extent of the harm possible or does it compound indefinitely like bioaccumulation or whatever?
- irrational 3y agoMy wife consumes a lot of chocolate. She would subsist solely on chocolate if that was possible. I have no idea how much she actually consumes, but I’m never surprised to find empty chocolate chip bags in the garbage.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoIf you love your wife, show her this article. I have no remaining commentary on the matter otherwise
- crazygringo 3y agoSerious question: what is the actual story or solution here? Are food manufacturers breaking California law or not? And given that it's the cacao beans themselves with lead and cadmium (not factory contamination or something), is the solution to test every batch from each farm individually, and then just throw half the beans into the garbage? Or shut down half the cacao farms worldwide because of tainted soil? Or is this pretty much in line with food safety levels generally, there's nothing to be worried about, and California guidelines are overly strict? I just find it unfortunate that the article presents all the facts but basically zero analysis or context.
- adrian_b 3y agoThis problem is not specific to cocoa. The seeds of many plants concentrate lead and cadmium whenever they are found in their environment, so with most seeds and nuts there is always a risk of high lead or cadmium content. In most countries there are legal limits for the lead and cadmium content of seeds and nuts, but the limits are much more lenient than for other products, because there are few sources of seeds and nuts that are not affected, so setting low limits would eliminate most products from the market. So the only recommendation is like for fish, which should not constitute a too large part of the food due to the risk of high mercury content, also most seeds and nuts should not be a too large part of the food, due to the risk of high lead and cadmium content. The pollution caused by human stupidity has converted some of the healthiest foods into health risks.
- aksss 3y agoIn second to last paragraph, you mean that for these reasons of contamination, fish and chocolate should not constitute too large a part of one’s diet, correct? Just trying to clarify.
- adrian_b 3y agoYes. Consuming them from time to time should not be a problem, but eating a chocolate (or fish) every day presents the risk of excessive intake of contaminants. Unfortunately, most of us cannot afford to make a chemical analysis of every food we buy, to determine whether it is safe or not for consumption, so it is better to be cautious. Even the legal limits for the lead and cadmium content of cocoa and of most seeds and nuts are rather high also based on the reasoning that on average they should be only a minor part of the daily intake.
- thrdbndndn 3y agoSo cocoa got heavy metals from soil, makes sense. But why does it have significant more concentration than other crops?
- zwieback 3y agoThe researchers conclude that while cocoa bean shells may be one source of lead, most contamination occurs during shipping or processing of the beans and in manufacturing. Further research on those stages of the process will help to isolate the source. source: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1281312/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1281312/
- waveBidder 3y agoit doesn't really: >The FDA estimated dietary exposure of children to Cd and Pb from 2014 to 2016 based on Cd and Pb concentration data from the FDA Total Diet Study and food consumption data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey and determined that dietary Cd and Pb from all sweets (i.e., candy, gelatin, jelly, sugar, and syrup), including chocolate, comprises 1.2 and 3.5% of total dietary intake, respectively. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32293881/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32293881/ https://sci-hub.se/10.1021/acs.jafc.9b08295 https://sci-hub.se/10.1021/acs.jafc.9b08295
- perihelions 3y agoFrom the linked report: - "Excessive nib Cd levels occur due to several main factors: 1) Theobroma cacao is a natural Cd accumulating plant species compared to others grown on the same soils; 2) topsoil Cd increases from deposition of litter and harvest debris on the soil surface; 3) Because cocoa roots remain in the topsoil, tillage to incorporate soil amendments harms the trees; 4) Most cocoa soils in South America and the Caribbean (LAC) are strongly acidic with pH as low as 4.5, so low that soil Cd is highly phytoavailable; 5) Some cocoa soils were historically Cd contaminated by mining wastes (minor part of land in cocoa production); and 6) some cocoa soils are naturally Cd enriched from parent rocks (e.g., marine shale) which makes these have high Cd:Zn ratios and thus have very high Cd phytoavailability. In these soils, beans can reach 10 mg Cd/kg rather than the 0.8 mg Cd/kg limit usually enforced on bean imports in the EU. One location in Colombia has 27 mg Cd/kg topsoil, 100-fold background levels. Other areas with high Cd:Zn problem soils growing cocoa were identified in at least Ecuador, Honduras, Peru and Trinidad & Tobago." - "Cocoa plants absorb Cd into roots on a ZIP-family Zn transporter, not on the NRAMP5 transporter used by rice. Zn2+ in soil solution strongly inhibits Cd2+ uptake; thus higher Zn2+ in soil can reduce Cd in cocoa beans. The Cd:Zn ratio in the soil solution strongly affects Cd accumulation in cocoa trees and beans. Unfortunately, surface applied ZnSO4 does not rapidly leach into the rooting zone soil, and foliar Zn sprays are ineffective in reducing Cd in beans. Surface applied ZnEDTA as a Zn fertilizer could leach Zn into the rooting depth soil. But ZnEDTA costs much more than ZnSO4."
- tedchs 3y ago> Chocolate [...] Is a popular treat eaten by children and adults and not an essential part of a someone’s diet Well that's just, like, your opinion, man.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mikercampbell 3y agoThat sounds like the voice of someone who is trying to ruin chocolate for me by making me think heavy metals every time I get a break of that KitKat bar
- 11235813213455 3y agoCacao can be part of the diet, it's healthy, like Carob (a good substitute) Chocolate is a processed product, enriched in sugar, not beneficial in the long term
- notfed 3y agoOkay, but, heavy metals are from the Cacao.
- delfinom 3y agommmm flavor.
- benatkin 3y agoThey have a Feastables product! By MrBeast. Missed opportunity to include the flavor that I had last night: https://feastables.com/products/deez-nutz-chocolate https://feastables.com/products/deez-nutz-chocolate (purchased at 7-Eleven) BTW there's a trademark lawsuit, in which I'm rooting for MrBeast: https://www.businessinsider.com/dees-nuts-sues-mr-beast-feastables-for-deez-nuts-chocolate-2023-9 https://www.businessinsider.com/dees-nuts-sues-mr-beast-feas... Extrapolating, but I don't think it's the worst, if lead is worse than cadmium. Their milk chocolate one is lower in lead than the one from Hershey's. It reminds me of arsenic in rice. The founder of Braintree is on a longevity quest and he has a list of what makes healthy chocolate, and suggests a brand. I might start ordering my chocolate. https://protocol.bryanjohnson.co/Blueprint-At-A-Glance https://protocol.bryanjohnson.co/Blueprint-At-A-Glance
- Modified3019 3y agoOn the topic of rice and arsenic, a method of parboiling can greatly reduce the amount, useful if one eats a lot of rice: https://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-say-this-rice-cooking-hack-removes-arsenic-but-keeps-the-nutrients https://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-say-this-rice-cookin...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- queuebert 3y agoOn the plus side, these tainted chocolate bars provide better X-ray shielding.
- gniv 3y agoAnd so do dried herbs and spices. I wonder how the levels compare. https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/your-herbs-and-spices-might-contain-arsenic-cadmium-and-lead-a6246621494/ https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/your-herb...
- MrOwen 3y agoGreat point to bring up! I learned of this a while ago and saught out sellers who said they tested their products for contaminants like that and found only 2! Hopefully this is not against guidelines to list but the sellers are Starwest Botanicals and Mountain Rose Herbs. Starwest seems to be a little more strict/upfront about testing than mountain rose but products from either should be significantly safer than what you find in the grocery store (which I now avoid like the plague).
- irrational 3y agoJust in time for Halloween when kids will be consuming massive amounts of chocolate.
- bell-cot 3y agoFortunately, there's precious little actual chocolate in most modern Halloween candy. Now if the heavy metals were in corn syrup and palm oil...
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoHershey and Nestle are addressing the problem by slowly replacing chocolate with brown-dyed wax so that no one realizes that there is no longer any actual chocolate in the products. Cadmium intake is down 15%, and profits are up 42%. That's win/win. Correction: It's a brown "waxlike substance". Paraffin was too costly.
- beef234 3y agoSo... Tootsie rolls?
- wes-k 3y agoThey've been user testing this product for decades!
- antimimetics 3y agoThis is interesting
- hbarka 3y agoThe author of the article does not seem to be able to make a good distinction between cacao and cocoa. For instance, they wrote “cocoa plant” but there’s no such. There’s a cacao tree and it grows pods (similar in size and shape to a small American football) and these pods contain beans surrounded by pulp. These pods are cut from the cacao tree, the mushy pulp is allowed to ferment and dry over a period of many days, and then the beans from desiccated pod are what ultimately get transformed into powder and then we get what is referred to as the cocoa butter—-from cacao tree to cocoa butter. Finally, it’s a complex process of churning the cocoa butter with the addition of milk and lecithin to get the tasty end product chocolate. In most cases it is mostly milk chocolate and lecithin with a smaller percent of cocoa butter. The native origins of Cacao trees are in the Amazon region (Brazil, Colombia, Peru) but have a rich history of being transplanted to other regions around the world since colonial times, largely for commercialization. In present day, the top growers of cacao trees are in Africa. 70% of the world’s cocoa come from Cameroon, Nigeria, Ivory Coast, and Ghana. The CR article fails to make the connection as to where in the lifecycle the heavy metals are introduced.
- ses1984 3y agoI’m pretty sure the heavy metals are introduced from the soils in certain regions, maybe most regions, where cacao is grown. I think you may have applied a little unnecessary pedantry. In many languages there is only one word used to describe the tree and the finished product, and that’s most of the time enough to figure out what people are talking about in context.
- hbarka 3y agoAmong nutritionists and cooks, there is a big distinction. There’s cacao powder and there’s cocoa powder. There’s also a big difference between cocoa versus chocolate, which is really milk chocolate. The real question is which soils contain the pollutants. Is there a statistical significance among cacao trees grown in the Amazon region versus African region, for example, and why.
- ses1984 3y ago
- RobotToaster 3y agoAt least it isn't death metal.
- account-5 3y agoIs this a world thing or a US thing?
- autoexec 3y agoThis ought to make Halloween a little creepier. Everything we've got for the Candy Bowl this year has chocolate in it. The FDA hasn't just dropped the ball here, they've set it down and kicked it away from them. They seem dead set against regulating the food industry to protect consumers (aka doing their job). Food companies could produce chocolate safely, but they don't want to because it would eat into their profits. They're fine with poisoning us to make a little more money, but if they weren't allowed to sell chocolate at all unless it conformed to a federal limit they'd do it because selling chocolate would still be massively profitable. We really need to put pressure on the FDA to do their job and set federal limits for the amount of heavy metals allowable in our foods. Our food supply seems to be getting less and less safe all the time. Why are we letting these FDA employees live off of our tax dollars if they refuse to work for us?
- anon373839 3y agoIt’s a difficult problem to solve. There is a very sleazy revolving door between regulators and regulated industries. Industries will essentially send people to work as regulators and represent the industries’ interests while in their government posts. These people then return to industry to command much higher salaries. In this way, government service is a stepping stone to a better private sector job. But it would be hard to shut this down because regulatory bodies need industry insiders working for them. You don’t want the agencies to be composed of people who couldn’t hack it in the private sector. This is one of the reasons I am skeptical when people reflexively suggest more government regulation as the solution to all problems.
- smolder 3y ago> But it would be hard to shut this down because regulatory bodies need industry insiders working for them. You don’t want the agencies to be composed of people who couldn’t hack it in the private sector. I think this problem (the need for industry players in regulatory bodies) is overstated by many. In particular, you don't need them in leadership roles, they can just consult. We could also write a law to close the door on their return to an industry after working as a regulator, but we don't. My conclusion is that the corrupt practices continue mainly because the corrupt people want them to.
- 01100011 3y agoAs someone who regularly consumes large amounts of dark chocolate and has for decades, is there anything I can do to reduce the accumulated heavy metals, short of injecting chelating agents(assuming that would even work)? And I'm not suggesting chelation therapy, just mentioning it because I have heard it is the usual treatment for acute metal poisoning.
- Solvency 3y agoLiterally by donating blood. That's the most effective way to gradually clear heavy metals. But they're also stored in your fat tissue. When you burn fat you temporarily leak those metals back into your bloodstream.
- 01100011 3y agoI can only find references to blood donation lowering PFAS levels, not heavy metals, but it does make some sense.
- downrightmike 3y agohttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6523211/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6523211/
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- perihelions 3y agoFor convenience, here's the primary source at the end of the chain of links (at depth=5): "Expert Investigation Related to Cocoa and Chocolate Products: Final Report" https://static1.squarespace.com/static/59a706d4f5e2319b70240ef9/t/62fd592790137e31288a1698/1660770607858/asyousow_chocolatefullreport_fin_20220817.pdf https://static1.squarespace.com/static/59a706d4f5e2319b70240... (pdf, 381pp)
- eh_why_not 3y agoThe file is from March 2022, and the article October 2023. Curious why it would take 1.5 years to go from investigation to report.
- goodmachine 3y agoMmm... cadmium
- timbit42 3y agoIs that why it's called Cadbury?
- demondemidi 3y agoSimilar problems with protein powder: https://www.consumerreports.org/dietary-supplements/heavy-metals-in-protein-supplements/ https://www.consumerreports.org/dietary-supplements/heavy-me...
- GalaxyNova 3y agohow fucked are we?
- dang 3y agoRelated. Others? Do I need to avoid dark chocolate now? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35216973 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35216973 - March 2023 (62 comments) Hershey sued over chocolate containing heavy metals - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34179115 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34179115 - Dec 2022 (9 comments) Lead and Cadmium Could Be in Your Dark Chocolate - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34016384 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34016384 - Dec 2022 (11 comments) Research reveals ways lead and cadmium in chocolate may be reduced - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34014515 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34014515 - Dec 2022 (82 comments) Consumer Group’s Test Finds Lead, Cadmium in Some Chocolate Treats - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11359270 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11359270 - March 2016 (1 comment)
- Solvency 3y agoI love how Hu Chocolate is one of the worst offenders while Whole Foods and Erewhorn peddle it as the healthiest chocolate.
- rendaw 3y agoThey identify ones that are over the limit and ones that are under, but even the ones that are under aren't significantly under - it's not like a 100x reduction. Sam's choice has 99% cadmium - only 1% below the limit. They point out that no level of cadmium is safe... so how can they say it's okay to eat Sam's Choice chocolate? Maybe they need to describe their limit choice better. It seems like they might have tested everything then chosen their limit so that half the products were okay.