6 ms·
i guess they'll just have to use lalr(1) more seriously, i wonder if something like this is a cause of the obesity pandemic: an unrecognized widespread immune
by kragen 3y ago
i guess they'll just have to use lalr(1)
more seriously, i wonder if something like this is a cause of the obesity pandemic: an unrecognized widespread immune response to a novel food additive provoking continuous low-level inflammation
though probably not peg itself; e1521 is not in that many foods, not like xanthan gum or nanoparticles of titanium dioxide
- sjducb 3y agoOr the widespread allergies
- due-rr 3y agoHere’s an interesting Twitter thread with various explanations for the obesity pandemic [1]. [1] https://twitter.com/mold_time/status/1412827749828513800?s=20 https://twitter.com/mold_time/status/1412827749828513800?s=2...
- 4death4 3y agoJust speaking from personal experience, I’m fat because I eat cake and ice cream every day and walk 6,000 steps on a good day. I don’t really see a mystery here tbh.
- thrwwyunpopular 3y agoThe prevalence of sugar in modern diets along with how ludicrously industrialized food has become, particularly in America, is likely still the main cause for obesity rates. People point out all these other secondary factors but we should really focus on the 80%, the big ticket item. It's damn near impossible to find nutritiously acceptable breakfast, lunch and dinner choices near the office in big cities in America. From the American perspective, the choices are all fine because that's all people know. But relative to what you can find in Europe or even Latin America, the alternatives are downright appalling. "Food manufacturing" should be a banned term.
- flextheruler 3y agoWhat city do you live in? There is a huge array of healthy low calorie options near me all the way to pure vegetarian/vegan places. There is a ridiculously strong correlation between sedentariness and obesity. We our more sedentary than ever before and then remote work/school increased it again. I believe a person struggling with weight is basically determined in their childhood. Only in childhood will the body build new fat cells and the number of fat cells determines hormonal production of leptin and others which trigger hunger cues for the rest of life. Basically a fat child will permanently be hungrier for the rest of their life due to increased numbers of fat cells. If you’re a skinny and active kid you will permanently have an easier time to keep weight off. And before you blame food again sedentariness has increased among children immensely as well.
- kragen 3y agoyet most fat adults were not fat children, though in another 30 years that will no longer be true; childhood obesity was rare until this millennium
- aksss 3y agoFat parents often have fat children. There’s a strong correlation.
- kragen 3y agoyes, that is true, and we know several reasons for it, but it is irrelevant both to the narrow issue of whether fat cells produced in childhood derange your caloric intake regulatory homeostasis thereafter, and to the broader issue of why there's an obesity pandemic
- flextheruler 3y agoIt certainly was rarer but this was a known phenomenon occurring at least back in the 1960s Off the top of my head I know there’s a speech of JFKs where he advocates for child health saying quote “there’s nothing more unfortunate than fat chubby children”
- kragen 3y agoand there are many people like you! yet a century ago you could have eaten cake every day if you wanted, though not ice cream, and in many places, many people already had office jobs to which they could take the subway. why did your counterparts in new york not have an obesity epidemic? somehow they didn't want to eat cake instead of food, and they felt restless if they had so little activity clearly diet and exercise are the proximate causes of obesity, but what has so deranged our diet and exercise?
- monknomo 3y agoheck, a hundred years ago you could just drive to work. Car ownership was exploding in the '20s, and people did not balloon up immediately
- swatcoder 3y agoSure, but something has made far more people make choices like yours than ever used to. We don't yet know what that is. We probably should. Our individual choices are ours to make, but they don't happen in a vacuum. Cultural signals, environmental factors, biological processes, uncritically reinforced habits, etc all shape what choices we're inclined towards and what choices look implausible or untenable. There's been a shocking shift in weight management and general wellness over the last hundred years, that seems to creep into every country that assimilates with " modern" culture, and it's prudent that we collectively understand why, because we probably should do something about it on that same collective scale.
- themaninthedark 3y agoHow have the labor trends shifted in the last 50, 100 years? Labor intensive jobs(also calorie intensive) are down. Even the jobs that remain have more of the physical demands taken out i.e. using an airgun to frame up a house instead of a hammer.
- vjk800 3y ago> Sure, but something has made far more people make choices like yours than ever used to. Not a big mystery there. Food used to be expensive and cakes only available in special occasions. Now I can get a cake delivered to my home within half an hour without getting up from my chair and it costs me about 15 minutes worth of paid work.
- cubefox 3y agoCake and ice cream did exist 50 years ago, and I doubt it was any healthier back then. Anyway, nobody doubts that excessive calorie intake causes obesity. The question is whether some chemicals in food cause an increased desire for excessive calorie intake, e.g. via confusing our hormone system. Most thin people aren't just thin because they eat less, they are thin because they don't have a disposition for binge eating. They just aren't as hungry.
- autoexec 3y ago> Cake and ice cream did exist 50 years ago, and I doubt it was any healthier back then. Cake and Ice cream 50 years were ago were likely healthier and would have been healthier still going farther back. They'd have likely used fewer ingredients, less sugar (and less HFCS), and contained fewer microplastics/PFAS. Much of the ice cream sold in stores today can't even legally call themselves ice cream! They're "Frozen dessert products"
- Turing_Machine 3y ago> i guess they'll just have to use lalr(1) I see what you did there. :-) I myself was momentarily confused when I saw "PEG".
- jhugo 3y agoHow would that explain the massive difference in obesity rates between countries?
- tomjakubowski 3y agohow does continuous low-level inflammation cause obesity?
- kragen 3y agoit's a very interesting question https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflammation#Interleukins_and_obesity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflammation#Interleukins_and_... is probably a good place to start reading
- idiotsecant 3y agoI think the primary cause of the obesity epidemic is the widespread availability of cheap calorie dense food and a few hundred million years of evolution devoted to making biological machines designed to consume as much calorie dense food as they could find.
- kragen 3y agoolive oil has been widely available for the last 7000 years, butter for ten thousand years, but the obesity pandemic is only 50 years old
- schnitzelstoat 3y agoBut they were relatively expensive and scarce. And no-one is getting fat by drinking litres of olive oil or eating tubs of butter. It's a combination of more high-calorie convenience foods and a more sedentary lifestyle than even just 50 years ago.
- kragen 3y agothe fact that no-one is getting fat by drinking litres of olive oil would seem to conclusively disprove your hypothesis as previously stated the cost of edible oil has not been a bar to access to calorie-dense foods for at least centuries if not millennia clearly the proximate cause of obesity is eating more and metabolizing less (both by way of lower exercise and lower basal metabolism). but why are people doing that? did they lose the gene for willpower in a single generation? that seems implausible it seems to closely follow industrially-mass-produced foods, but the relevant feature of those foods is clearly not that they are more convenient or higher in calorie density than a can of crisco or an amphora of olive oil; they aren't
- nullindividual 3y agoOlive oil is a natural laxative. If you're gaining weight on olive oil, I'd be impressed, beyond how one would keep it down due to taste and texture. People aren't gaining weight on olive oil because people aren't consuming it in mass quantities required to gain weight, if one could even do so after having your intestines coated by oil. But many are consuming highly processed foods which is shown to lead to less optimal health outcomes. > clearly Clearly a post on HN doesn't make for a scientific study!
- xeckr 3y agoIt doesn't look like obesity is infectious, so calling it a pandemic doesn't seem appropriate. The cure is eating less and exercising more. Many have done it.
- kragen 3y agothere is substantial, but not convincing, evidence that much current obesity is due to an infectious etiology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infectobesity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infectobesity the cure you suggest fails on 95% of obese people, though like many pseudoscientific quack cures, it does appear to work at first, and actually does work in a few cases the implied etiology doesn't hold up to the most casual critical thinking: resting and eating have been part of every human life since long before there were humans, but the obesity pandemic is only 50 years old. this is like attributing deaths from dengue to "bleeding" and recommending that people bleed less
- Enginerrrd 3y agoDiet and exercise absolutely does work. It's just that when you frame the intervention as TELLING people to eat less and exercise more, it is very ineffective. So from a physician's standpoint, it's not a great approach.
- kragen 3y agoit's almost as ineffective when undertaken on your own initiative; that's where the 95% number comes from diet and exercise is clearly the proximate cause of obesity, but the question is what drives diet and exercise, and what changed so suddenly?
- Pigalowda 3y agoEducation and socioeconomic status correlate with lower obesity rates, healthy diet, and exercise. The “sudden” change is easy to see in the supermarket. Most people don’t shop at Whole Foods, Sprouts, or Central market. Go to Walmart and admire all of the densely caloric colorful boxed foods. Did you know young people actually use door dash/uber to get their fast food? It’s wild. So not even expending a few calories to get it but also wasting a bunch of cash.