8 ms·
Ensō: write now, edit later
- dewey 3y agoIf you are using iA Writer, it also has this feature: https://ia.net/writer/support/editor/focus-mode https://ia.net/writer/support/editor/focus-mode
- kstrauser 3y agoClose: Writer still lets you edit text in that mode. Ensō looks like typewriter mode, and is also append-only. Writer doesn't have that bit.
- dewey 3y agoTrue, good point. I feel like the main point is that you are not able to "edit" your text in the sense that you re-structure paragraphs, moving bits around, not about not being able to correct a typo.
- kstrauser 3y agoI think you're right. For me, the fading is enough to greatly reduce that temptation. I could just turn off focus mode, but there's a big "out of sight, out of mind" component, too. It would be kinda cool to have a way to disable backward cursor movement, or a "enable focus mode until I restart the app" option as another barrier to "I just want to make this one quick change...". Huh. Wonder if I could emulate the cursor stuff with Keyboard Maestro by making it swallow those keypresses?
- rpastuszak 3y agoYup, that's one of the reasons I built Ensō instead of using iA Writer.
- 101008 3y agoI really like it. As a writer of novels, this is useful for those moments when I have too many doubts about how it should look. One minor feedback: deleting should be forbidden - it's a way to edit the text. So it should be like a writing machine + the fade out effect.
- surprisetalk 3y agoSo few novelists on HN! Where can I read your stuff?
- 101008 3y agoI'd prefer to try to not associate my user with some personal data. But thanks for the interest!
- rpastuszak 3y agoHehe, I considered that in my first prototypes. I avoid any kind of customisation like fire when it comes to Ensō, but perhaps I should change my approach after all... My main source of inspiration was writing by hand, and then typing.
- 101008 3y agoWriting by hand definitely does not allow to delete! :-)
- loloquwowndueo 3y agoThere’re these things called erasers…
- gilcot 3y ago…or correction fluid (like Tipp-Ex)
- 3y ago
- beepbooptheory 3y agoLove the idea. Also, a fun elisp project to try and figure out.
- kstrauser 3y agoThat's clever, and I see the appeal. The UI looks an awful lot like iA Writer in typewriter mode. That's a compliment. But it does seem like a feature that iA could add, calling it "write-only" mode or such, and then you could have that nice experience with all the other awesomeness that Writer brings. Still, unless/until they do, I totally get why someone would want to use this. Nice job!
- CharlesW 3y agoHorses for courses, but the fading gimmick would not work for me at all. However, this is conceptually interesting. It might be fun to speak the first draft of my next piece and transcribe the result with Whisper.
- rpastuszak 3y agoI experimenting with sth similar actually. One small additional requirement: although I studied linguistics and took a year-long course in English phonology, speech-to-text still struggles with my accent. The approach I'm playing with atm is inspired by some advice from Simon Willis, here on HN: record audio → transcribe using whisper → clean up and format using a GPT prompt So far the results have been pretty good: the original meaning is preserved but the text is much easier to read (and the missing/"misheard" words are often corrected). What I'm experimenting at the moment: - picking the right model size, tweaking the prompts - better UX (e.g. immediate visual feedback)
- Semiapies 3y agoI think the fading, if I paused to think about anything, would make me lose track of what I'd already written.
- ksynwa 3y agoI found this obscure emacs package last week that seems related: https://github.com/KeyWeeUsr/typewriter-roll-mode https://github.com/KeyWeeUsr/typewriter-roll-mode (I'm not related to this package in any way. Don't use it either.)
- livrem 3y ago50 lines of elisp. I tried it just now, and it seems like what it does is that every time I press space it scrolls the buffer so that I am at the top and only see the current line I am editing. Does not look as nice as that fading out editor, but maybe it is functional enough. It would be more like that other editor if it would show at least one or two previous lines of text.
- oritron 3y agoThat's easy enough to adjust if you'd like, redefine typewriter-roll--scroll-up to call (recenter-top-bottom 2) instead of 0.
- macintux 3y agoThanks! I was inspired by a different thread to disable the backspace key by adding this to the mode file: (defvar typewriter-roll-mode-hook nil) (defvar typewriter-roll-mode-map (let ((map (make-keymap))) (define-key map (kbd "<backspace>") 'ignore) map) "Keymap for typewriter-roll minor mode")
- pier25 3y agoI've always noticed when writing by hand I could get into the zone more easily but always thought it was because of the lack of speed compared to typing. I had never considered maybe the huge effort required to edit was another factor that kept my mind focused in the present.
- zogrodea 3y agoIt might also partially be that the activity and movements of writing by hand put you in the zone better than using a keyboard. When you have a pen/pencil in hand, your body may feel "it's prose/whatever writing time" rather than when you have a keyboard in hand, when the multitude of activities (browsing HN for example or texting on IRC or whatever) dilutes a similar mental association between tool and activity.
- Analemma_ 3y ago> All of your changes are saved locally. Ensō works perfectly fine even without internet connection. I know this is a sign of the times and so I'm not blaming the author, but Christ, what a depressing development that this is enough of a feature to be one of the headline hero paragraphs on the landing page.
- nine_k 3y agoDeveloping for the web client and having centralized control over both code and data on your server is just so much easier for the developer. Not necessarily the best client experience, but the difference in development and support cost is huge. Thus any local-first software is more rare, if it has to also include an online component. It's just harder.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rpastuszak 3y agoAuthor here: 0) Ensō's on the top page of HN? what the hell! 1) it's fun to use Ensō in the middle of the woods with no internet access (done that), but 2) the main reason I build web apps this way is that following offline-first (generally) results in a better user experience, especially for people without access to optic fibre or 5G[*]. And with Ensō this was trivial to implement. 3) the second reason I do that: often it's much easier to write offline first apps. 10 years ago we already had tools like pouchdb to do so much heavy lifting for us. [*] Ironically, having lived in Shoreditch for 7 years helped me develop this mindset, as every single flat I rented there turned out to be the one without fibre. In one of them the windows even acted as a Faraday cage, so no luck with 4G!
- Analemma_ 3y agoYeah, I want to be totally clear that this wasn't a dig at you - Ensō looks really cool and I'm glad to see a web application embrace offline-first development. This was more just generic griping at how the web has become the only real cross-platform application development environment, regardless of how well it's actually fit for that purpose. But that has nothing to do with you - keep rocking with this :)
- yu3zhou4 3y agoNice tool Rafał!
- maxisaurus 3y agoMade me think of Excalidraw when I saw it - cool stuff! Will try my 750 words on it.
- g-b-r 3y agoed was right all along?
- kstrauser 3y agoOr cat.
- nico 3y agoReminds me a lot of Omm writer, really nice peaceful writing experience, designed to keep you focused on just writing
- dheera 3y agoSeems like it would be a good tool for coding interviews that want to mimic the whiteboard-coding experience without a physical whiteboard. /s
- norir 3y agoVery nice. In my experience writing both prose and code, rewrites are usually better than edits. Strangely, this tool reminds me a bit of how Fossil does not have rebase. The history is useful for context, but it shouldn't be edited.
- johnwheeler 3y agoThis kind of stream of consciousness is how I do a lot of my GPT work. I have double command key tap to start dictation, and then I launch into these stream of consciousness dialogues with uhms, ohhs, and uhhs etc. GPT is able to then summarize that for me, filter out the garbage, and we can iterate from there.
- inciampati 3y agoI do this for five to ten minute stretches to draft pages of prose. Also filtering through ChatGPT to clean it up and reformat it into any shape I'd like.
- kaba0 3y agoI really don’t want to bash it as the web version is free, and I absolutely agree that authors should be able to get money in exchange for their work, but still… not sure if the Mac version does anything more, but if not, making it paid when it is a program most people can reproduce in at tops 100 lines in any framework of their choice rubs me a bit in the wrong way.
- radlad 3y agoI don't understand this comment. If it's that easy to reproduce (and I don't necessarily disagree), go ahead and do it, and users can use that instead. Or, if it's not worth your time, consider paying the person who took the time to build it.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoCue the famous HN post saying dropbox could be replaced by ftp.
- kaba0 3y agoIt’s literally a textfield with a fade-off effect on top. But your take is also correct in most cases, I just felt that this one hits a particularly strange balance here.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tene80i 3y agoMost people? You mean most programmers, presumably?
- Hamcha 3y agoReminds me of http://al.chemy.org http://al.chemy.org A dead (sigh) drawing app with no layers and no undo and tons of wacky brushes. The main idea is that you can doodle and let the "happy little accidents" drive you into something that you can use as inspiration for a piece (think of it like ink blots)
- SeriousM 3y agoI would't call it dead, rather done. It's good that it doesn't get more features.
- rpastuszak 3y agoI love this, thank you for sharing.
- st3ve445678 3y agoIf you want a dead simple writing app, I think this is a better option for mac users: simpletext.app Costs 9 bucks for a lifetime license.
- dewey 3y agoBetter option: Apple's Notes.app which comes included, you can also make a note full screen and it looks almost the same. On top of being iCloud synced to all your devices for free.
- addaon 3y agoUnfortunately, Notes is incredibly slow. Even with just a few hundred pages of text in a note, and no images or complex formatting, it stutters on text input on an iPhone 15 and, while not stuttering in input, is jerky and slow to scroll on an M1 MacBook Pro. That means that there’s management overhead — going back and editing notes to split them up — to keep it usable, which is almost exactly contrary to the point of this article’s type of writing-and-writing-alone tool.
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoI like this idea, I do this all the time. Not sure I need an app though, I'll just turn off the monitor.
- dewey 3y agoI would be very worried that there's some random action stealing the focus of the writing app and me just typing letters into the void.
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoThe hotkey to return to my window manager is pretty hard to hit by accident. As for the writing app, it's just a python script looping over lines read from stdin and writing them to disk. Not many opportunities to do anything else.
- akho 3y agoWhy not just cat?
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoBecause I am a dummy. This is even better: cat - > prose.txt Thanks for the idea.
- rpastuszak 3y agoHeh, for that exact reason I'm using it with my screen dimmed as much as possible and even considered adding a night[*] (black to red) mode for OLED screens (I write at night, I'm a vampire). One of the use-cases I found when I was researching Ensō: there was a blogger who'd split writing into two steps: 1. writing with their screen dimmed as much as possible 2. editing the next day Also, perhaps a pure-black screen with a simple indicator of the number of characters/words written would work here? You'd still know that the editor is recording your changes. Seems like a nice idea for a little app/toy. [*]examples, inspiration: https://untested.sonnet.io/Obsidian+for+Vampires https://untested.sonnet.io/Obsidian+for+Vampires (apologies for messy notes, this project is separate from my main site)
- abcd_f 3y agoLooks pretty close to what iA Writer has been doing since its inception over a decade ago. Back then it was a very unique approach. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IA_Writer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IA_Writer
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- reidjs 3y agoBig fan of this app because it lets you write plaintext (.md or .txt) on your iphone
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- marban 3y agoThere are at least a dozen Mac apps that have been doing this for decades. Why the upvotes?
- bonif 3y agoAs a non-writer, I don't know those apps, I saw this on HN, tried it for 30 secs, and loved it. I'll never be a customer btw.
- maebert 3y agoOr, if you prefer to write with sweaty palms and the gun of permanent literary destruction against your head, there’s the Most Dangerous Writing App of course. https://maebert.github.io/themostdangerouswritingapp https://maebert.github.io/themostdangerouswritingapp
- hnreport 3y agoHow long before it actually saves?
- reidjs 3y agoyou set the session lenght before you start in the tooltip
- brickers 3y agoI made something similar at https://drivl.app https://drivl.app. I should have known someone else had already done it
- code_with_kv 3y agoReally neat app! Raises the stakes for writers. I'm inspired now to write something like this but with a "redemption" feature where your lost words can be recovered by consistently completing multiple sessions over time.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- submain 3y agoHere's a naive bash implementation of this, just for fun: while true; do clear tail -n 5 /tmp/notes read line echo "$line" >> /tmp/notes done
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SeriousM 3y agoIs there a plugin for obsidian?
- rpastuszak 3y agoThere are two experiments AFAIK: one done by Steph Ango (Obsidian CEO) and another one by me. I didn't publish mine because I thought no one would like it, but I'm happy to do it if more people express interest. https://x.com/rafalpast/status/1693961256879726684?s=20 https://x.com/rafalpast/status/1693961256879726684?s=20 PS I use Ensō with Obsidian for my morning notes: https://untested.sonnet.io/Stream+of+Consciousness+Morning+Notes https://untested.sonnet.io/Stream+of+Consciousness+Morning+N...
- SeriousM 3y agoI would try it if you like! Drop me a mail at enos.luxurious788@aleeas.com (real mail alias)
- adaboese 3y agoI am building a writing tool and this serves as an inspiration. So beautiful!
- sea6ear 3y agoI've played around with a similar idea with a less attractive UI, using Vim or Emacs. With sufficient adjustments, you can reduce the GUI versions of Vim or Emacs to a single line of text. That way you can just write, but can't see what you've written one it's left that line, until you expand the window to see the full document. It gives a good sense of flow, although I find that if I'm just forcing myself to write and push forward, it's easy to get into a situation where I'm just pushing text, and not really enforcing any kind of structure on my thoughts. It's useful to get me into a mode where I'm thinking about new stuff, but I have to be ok with producing a lot of noise that I have to sift back though. Eventually that sifting starts to wear me out. If 90% percent of everything I write is crap, sorting back through to find the 10% that's good and useful, is more effort than I can make myself keep doing on a regular basis.
- drekipus 3y agoI also made a nvim plugin but from a different angle. I set up a "write only" mode, so you can't use backspace or get out of insert mode, you just gotta keep writing forward (also disable <c-w> ) To get out of it, you tap escape 15 times in a row. (to avoid my habitual ESC :wa) Note': I like the plugin but I don't know if it's helpful. My writing career has been exceptionally short for the moment
- gilcot 3y agoWith vim, one can go from single setting[1] to something more complex[2] or use one of the available plugins (e.g. typewriter-vim[3] or vim-goyo[4] or vim-focus[5] or Lite-DFM[6] or zen-mode[7] etc.) [1] https://superuser.com/a/368275 https://superuser.com/a/368275 [2] https://vitalyparnas.com/guides/vim-typewriter-mode/ https://vitalyparnas.com/guides/vim-typewriter-mode/ [3] https://github.com/logico/typewriter-vim https://github.com/logico/typewriter-vim [4] https://github.com/junegunn/goyo.vim https://github.com/junegunn/goyo.vim [5] https://github.com/merlinrebrovic/focus.vim https://github.com/merlinrebrovic/focus.vim [6] https://github.com/bilalq/lite-dfm https://github.com/bilalq/lite-dfm [7] https://github.com/folke/zen-mode.nvim https://github.com/folke/zen-mode.nvim
- pama 3y agoI recommend Olivetti for focused writing with Emacs. It is a simple mode but somehow it takes me back to days of writing on a typewriter. Occasionally I add a focus mode to fade out the other sentences or paragraphs. Maybe I’ve just conditioned myself because I typically only use these modes for documents that require flow over a long period of time. Emacs is excellent for the editing part of course, as is vi; plain text navigation and editing are their core values. And being in Emacs with my 100 active buffers, it super easy to combine disparate ideas, though that can mess with the flow.
- soneca 3y agoI am amateur (but wannabe professional) fiction writer. When I see this type of tool I realize that I have a conceptual misalignment with some (most?) writers in regarding to focus, editing, flow. For me, editing is part of the flow. I like to edit things as they go through my head, as part of my state of flow, not as a separate chore from which I have to “protect” my draft writing from. I think of it as an analogy from sculpting. The first draft writing is getting the amorphous block into a rough shape of, e.g., a hand. Then, editing is the fine work to make the bones, skin wrinkles and veins of the hand to make it perfect. In this analogy, the editing is the hardest, most focus demanding, most detail-oriented work that requires no distractions. But just offering my perspective here. A good thing about having more software developers in the world is the diversity of tools available for diverse people. So I am happy that this exists.
- drekipus 3y agoI think it's the same analogy, the tool is supposed to separate it so that you can get the rough shape in before you try to perfect the hand, (then realise it's facing the wrong way.)
- mat_epice 3y agoI'm with you, although any writing I do is technical. I find that immediately micro-editing the fragment/sentence/paragraph I just wrote is easier than coming back as a separate step. Maybe it's because my first cut is so bad!
- powersnail 3y agoIt’s less about flow but more about a practical problem faced by some writers: Some writers have the trouble stopping themselves from constant editing of the words they’ve just write, to the extent that significantly impact their ability to produce an actual draft. Lots of the editing are useless anyway, since when you are really editing the draft later, most likely you are going to throw away many pages and paragraphs of work, so all the time spent on micro-editing are wasted. The biggest contrast between sculpting and writing is that sculpting is non-revocable. You can negotiate over a single paragraph for hours, rewriting and rewriting and rewriting. There is no redo button for chiseling.
- lucharo 3y agoThis is what I wrote trying out the product, seems really focused haha: So today I'm thinking about potatoes warm potatoes, the kind that you eat with cheese or other saucy stuff really why not talk about potatoes today, does this go to the end of the line, oh yeah it does, and it goes to the new line, there's a counter at the bottom, displaying a number, it's word count I think, yeah I'm pretty sure 65 66 definitely cool, I like it!
- ryanianian 3y agoSounds like the start of productive therapy.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoI've been writing like this into text files for over a decade now. It feels like therapy, alright, but I wouldn't claim it's productive.
- powera 3y agoI accomplish something similar by typing with my eyes closed (or simply looking away from the screen). And, despite the "you can't edit" marketing, you can use the backspace key for typos. (which is good)
- kazinator 3y agoNeko! Write, now edit later: $ cat > file You can't edit anything. So you have to think.
- wholesomepotato 3y agoWow, how much do I pay to run it on MacOS?
- kazinator 3y agoFor most, the answer would be, "quite a lot". However, I happen to have a VirtualBox VM of an bootleg copy of an old MacOS version (32 bit x86).
- joemi 3y agoThe desire/need for focused writing apps has always baffled me, but then again I'm probably not the target audience for such an app. I do some technical writing and some non-technical blogging, and have never felt impeded by just writing in vim or textedit (or anything else that accepts text input). I'd love to better understand how such apps help people with their writing. I guess I'm kind of skeptical that they actually do help (compared to simply fullscreening any app that you can write in), but since there are so many apps designed for this I accept that they must be helpful to some people. I'd love to hear from people for whom they have helped. (I'm not trying to start a discussion about uselessness. I'd like to hear about _usefulness_. I truly want to understand it better.)
- oDot 3y agoI have built https://FileMonger.app https://FileMonger.app (which keeps a diffable undo history of a file) exactly after becoming skeptical as you are. After a bit of research I've figured that main need for this kind of focus is fear of the document changing too much, to the point where the current idea for an edit will no longer relevant. Apps such as OP try to solve it by hiding the problem, while with FileMonger the writer gets a guarantee that they can revert to any save at any time, if document indeed changes too much (it usually doesn't). If you've mentioned vim and technical writing you're probably writing plain text files and are knowledgeable enough to use manual version control like git when necessary, which is why this baffles you.
- Avshalom 3y agoSome people are just compulsive about some stuff. It's not always a thing you're (or they're) going to understand.
- dberst 3y agoI'm not a professional writer, but as someone with severe ADHD I have battled frequently with my own version of "writer's block". When I'm stuck in this way sometimes small things can make a tremendous difference (positive or negative) in my productivity. I guess what it comes down to is distractibility. This app seems focused on reducing the distraction of perfectionism: the thoughts of possible improvements to the structure of the current paragraph or feelings that a sentence could've come out better. For me, and I expect for some writers, this type of second guessing may take up a significant amount of the time I've allocated to sit down and write. Especially if there's a lot of external pressure for my work to be of a certain quality, correctness, or completeness. So while I don't personally use a tool like this, I can see how reducing distractions could raise productivity. And if it I were my livelihood, then even a 20-30% raise in productivity could be well worth installing and learning to use a dedicated piece of software.
- blueagle 3y agoThis by far one of my favorite pieces of software ever. It's perfect for journaling and just doing a complete brain dump of thoughts. I frequently am surprised by the word count when I download the text file after the end of one of my writing binges. Thank you for your work on this rpastuszak!
- noduerme 3y agoThis is a neat idea. But I accomplish the same thing with a pen and paper. Once I start to write there's no time to go back and read or edit until later. Additionally, pen and paper forces me to consider each word more carefully, because my writing speed is always slower than my thinking.
- drewzero1 3y agoTiming is good for sharing this now, with NaNoWriMo right around the corner. I have heard a similar approach advocated to get through a first draft of an entire novel in a month: just write it all down, never backspace, and save the editing for December!
- easeout 3y agoI value this method; my strategy is to turn my display brightness down to nothing while drafting. If I think I mistyped something, I just type a line break and go again.
- p4bl0 3y agoAt some point I realized that it took me a lot less time to write gigantic Twitter threads than a blog post half that size. Of course my own expectations of quality are quite higher for a post on my blog than for a Twitter thread that will be buried by time. But apart from that the big difference was my inability to edit tweets already sent. Now for a few years it's been different since it is possible to prepare multiple tweets at a time, but it's still not as a single big box with text you can freely and easily edit, but the format (the requirement to cut the text in small pieces) still plays a role in the process I think. I was toying with the idea of making an text editor that would work in the same way, append-only by limited size chunks, just for proficiency purpose, but never had time. This project seems to be in the same vein. Thanks for sharing!
- Balooga 3y ago"If I Had More Time, I Would Have Written a Shorter Letter" -- https://quoteinvestigator.com/2012/04/28/shorter-letter/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2012/04/28/shorter-letter/
- p4bl0 3y agoI know that quote. The thing is, I don't have more time, and a lot of blog post are just never written because of that.
- FPGAhacker 3y agoWhen I used to do nanowrimo, I would turn off my screen to stop my various means of self sabotage. Worked well enough that I could meet my writing goals.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago(2021)? Author's Show HN: from then https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26448887 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26448887
- zubairq 3y agoI really like this idea. I think I'll try Enso, as often I think of editing too much while writing, and it definitely breaks my state of flow
- 2easy 3y agoSooo… like a notebook?
- forgotmypw17 3y agoGreat design! I enjoyed writing my thoughts, and I like that I can save it to a file right away. This makes it immediately compatible with all textfile-based systems.
- MrRolleyes 3y ago[dead]
- koutsie 3y agofor a split second i thought someone had made psv stuff in 2023
- bkeating 3y agoRead “Enso” and my mind immediately called up Humanized, Inc. Enso (a modeless command launcher—entirely different from what we’re talking about here( was such a great tool. https://www.reddit.com/r/answers/s/dkKyKqYI8S https://www.reddit.com/r/answers/s/dkKyKqYI8S
- sillywalk 3y agoReminds me of the (dead) RoughDraft mac app by 43 Folders(?). There is also FocusWriter - opensource and multi-platform. https://gottcode.org/focuswriter/ https://gottcode.org/focuswriter/