15 ms·
Google's plan to stop Apple from getting serious about search
- SheinhardtWigCo 3y agoGee, I wonder how the NYT got its hands on internal documents that reinforce Google’s public narrative, just days before they’re due to set out their defense in court. :)
- dang 3y agoRelated ongoing thread: Google paid $26.3B in 2021 to be the default search engine - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38041335 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38041335 - Oct 2023 (104 comments)
- fennecbutt 3y agoGoogle needs better execs. They should have seen this coming from a mile away and diversified themselves. How the fuck some execs + CEO ever thought "we have to pay our competitors to use our service as the main one" was a good idea and didn't see it as a "the world is ending time to do things differently" warning sign for the company, ugh.
- who-shot-jr 3y agohttps://archive.ph/vZwNu https://archive.ph/vZwNu
- m4jor 3y agoSo weird. I see a "Welcome to nginx!" page when I hit archive.ph.
- cj 3y agoarchive.ph doesn’t allow people using Cloudflare DNS to access their site.
- daveguy 3y agoI've heard this before. Do you know why?
- acatton 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Archive.today&oldid=1181524346#Cloudflare_DNS_availability https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Archive.today&old...
- cj 3y agoHm, Wikipedia says it’s resolved. For me, archive.ph always shows an insolvable captcha (the page reloads after submitting the captcha in a never ending loop).
- jrochkind1 3y agoIt's come up on HN a bunch, including recently. I'm not sure how to find the threads. It is weird and confusing, and has to do with the fact, if i remember right, that the Archive.today maintainer is mad that Cloudflare won't forward end-user IP addresses with DNS queries. This seems mysterious, but one other comment pointed out the maintainer saying that this prevents the maintainer from assigning traffic to servers the way they want, which is an odd way having to do with legal systems and national boundaries and maybe trying to send the user to a CDN endpoint _not_ in their own nation for some reason? If I'm remembering right. The whole thing is weird and I can't explain it, and is very under-documented, the archive.today maintainer apparently doesn't really like talking about it or explaining it? But basically archive.today intentionally deny-lists anyone using cloudflare DNS in a way that results in very mysterious behaivor where you don't know you are denylisted, including infinite captchas. I have had the same issue with Google 8.8.8.8 DNS and archive.today btw.
- vanchor3 3y agoI've also found they do very suspicious things in those captcha pages as well, such as sending random requests to unrelated websites (feels like a DDoS at that point). I've been avoiding archive.today links ever since.
- chrismsimpson 3y agoHaving not used Android in basically forever, how tightly is search integrated with the OS/interface? If spotlight can be designated a search engine can Android be as well? Google can’t talk out of both sides of its mouth here and be taken seriously: “we can’t allow someone else to have a monopoly in search because that’s our shtick”.
- Denvercoder9 3y ago> how tightly is search integrated with the OS/interface? Basically not at all.
- EwanToo 3y agoIn some system apps it's deeply embedded, others not at all. e.g. The Google phone dialler which is pre-installed on a lot of phones can bring up the phone number for nearby places without them being in your contacts.
- bt4u 3y agoGenerally not very tightly but of course with Android, there are many different OEMs and they all try to do their own things to stand out
- fidotron 3y agoIt changed over time, and now the answer is not much. The early idea was very much like spotlight where each app would be able to respond to search queries itself without needing any remote connection. (The Android infra for this inter app functionality like this is criminally wasted). Google suffered from what now afflicts Microsoft where you alter the product away from what is good for the user towards strategic interests of the company, so the Android search bar widget becomes a Google search bar widget. Android is a truly lost opportunity - things like it should be possible to launch an Activity on another device, access content providers from another device and so on, all mediated by the OS.
- mschuster91 3y ago> things like it should be possible to launch an Activity on another device, access content providers from another device and so on, all mediated by the OS Actually, that does exist, at least for smartwatches. I fail to see the use case for other devices beyond sending links between Chrome on the device and on a laptop.
- toni 3y agoThe article says that in 2021, Google paid Apple around $18 billion to keep Google’s search engine as default in iPhones. What if Apple would put all that money back into developing its own search engine?! That would be beating Google with its own money!
- TradingPlaces 3y agoThat is from the recent Bernstein estimate. Justice Department says only $4-$7b
- toni 3y agoThat is indeed far less. Hopefully Apple has still put some of that money into rivaling Google search.
- dewey 3y ago> What if Apple would put all that money back into developing its own search engine?! They have 50B cash on hand, I don't think the money would be the limiting factor if they wanted to do it or think they are in a position where they could do it.
- jasode 3y ago>They have 50B cash on hand, I don't think the money would be the limiting factor if they wanted to do Just to provide some ballpark numbers... Supposedly, Microsoft spent $100 billion on Bing and the CEO Nadella said the most common search query on Bing is "Google". https://www.google.com/search?q=microsoft+spent+%24100+billion+on+bing+-openai https://www.google.com/search?q=microsoft+spent+%24100+billi... It's safe to assume Apple executives look at Bing and estimate the costs and potential ROI when considering their own plans for an in-house search engine.
- dewey 3y agoAlso they don't have to spend it all at once, they have been crawling the web for a long time already and are not starting from scratch. So far it's just more in the background and integrated into the OS (Siri etc.) https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2023-10-01/could-apple-replace-google-with-own-search-engine-it-s-possible-but-unlikely-ln7gywed#xj4y7vzkg https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2023-10-01/could-...
- matthewfelgate 3y agoSurprise, New York Times article that says nothing at all. Might as well have been a one line "I hate Google". Who's afraid of AI when you have drivel like this written by "journalists".
- robg 3y agoImpressed that Apple pockets $18 Billion and still mostly protects privacy with reasonable UX choices. Nothing is perfect, but denying Google more data about me is one reason I’ll always stick with iOS over Android and why I’ll ditch my Fitbit when it forces a Google account in 2025.
- vik0 3y agoIf you think Apple cares more about you and your privacy than Google, I have a bridge to sell you. Sure, it probably does deny Google some data, but you really think Apple doesn't collect data for itself? It's the world's most valuable company, its iOS is not open source, and by extension we can't verify that it doesn't do shady stuff with our data - and given that it's a pretty big megacorp, experience says to be cautious, to say the least.
- PlutoIsAPlanet 3y agoApple isn't a data selling company. Google is.
- _aavaa_ 3y agoGoogle does not sell your data. They’re valuable because their hoard the data for themselves and charge advertisers but doesn’t give them the data.
- xnx 3y agoGoogle sells your attention, not your data.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Apple isn't a data selling company. Google is. Microsoft also wasn't a data selling company, but that didn't stop them pivoting into one when they realized that Google was making more money from Windows users than they were. At some point in the future Apple's growth will plateau, Tim Cook will retire, another CEO will be appointed, while shareholders will always demand more growth, so guess where that growth will come from. Companies always change with time, they never stay the same, otherwise Woz would still be working there. Which is why I trust no big company in the world and why you shouldn't either, no matter how shiny their products are.
- davars 3y agoIt boggles my mind that Apple’s market position allows it to pocket $18 billion a year in pure rent for this real estate on its platform and the company paying is the one that gets an antitrust suit.
- isodev 3y agoGoogle is the offender because they control both the search and the browser market. Imagine having to pay $18 billion and still coming on top. Folks hooked to Chrome seem to forget that whatever they do online is used to refine their ad profile and generate even more ad money for Google and you can't opt out.
- csallen 3y agoWe don't forget. We just don't care. I am in no way upset that Google is refining my ad profile and making money. Many billions of other people are also not upset by that.
- rgbrgb 3y agoI have a hard time believing that many billions of people know about adtech surveillance in any way.
- stronglikedan 3y agoOf course they were being hyperbolic with the use of the word "billions". The point still stands though. The vast majority of people using Google's services do know about adtech surveillance, and just don't care.
- riscy 3y agoDo you have a source for that claim? I think laypeople know google serves them custom ads, but don’t understand how or the extent to which adtech is tracking and profiling them to select those ads. In fact, because it’s a common trope to say “they must have been listening to our conversation” when served an eerily specific ad, I’d wager people do not know about adtech at all.
- AlbertCory 3y ago> Google is expected to begin a three-week presentation of its defense in the lawsuit’s monthslong trial on Thursday. Implicit here is that prosecution's case has rested. How about all those bombshells that dominated the news for months and months? /s /s There IS a case to be made, but I don't think they made it. Expect the verdict to be a mild slap on the wrist and a (empty) promise from Google to sin no more.
- nmilo 3y ago> Google quietly planned to put a lid on Apple’s search ambitions. The company looked for ways to undercut Spotlight by producing its own version for iPhones and to persuade more iPhone users to use Google’s Chrome web browser instead of Apple’s Safari browser, according to internal Google documents reviewed by The New York Times. So their top secret plan is to.. make a competing product? AKA what all companies always do with their competition?
- simonw 3y agoThe next sentence is more interesting: > At the same time, Google studied how to pry open Apple’s control of the iPhone by leveraging a new European law intended to help small companies compete with Big Tech.
- datavirtue 3y agoGroan...late stage tech
- goalonetwo 3y agoquarterly reminder that regulation is usually favoring the existing big players in the market. (see what is currently going on with AI regulation)
- trompetenaccoun 3y agoOr banking regulation for centuries.
- supriyo-biswas 3y agoEuropeans like to cry blasphemy whenever this is mentioned, but the article above is great evidence of it, one which I have to save for later discussions.
- worik 3y ago> regulation is usually favoring the existing big players Yes. But it is not a law of nature. And no regulation is very bad for consumers It is a balance, and there are trade offs
- xrjskflgcp 3y ago[dead]
- Terretta 3y agoGoogle studied how to pry open Apple’s control of the iPhone by leveraging a new European law intended to help small companies compete with Big Tech. Last fall, Google executives met to discuss how to reduce the company’s reliance on Apple’s Safari browser and how best to use a new law in Europe to undermine the iPhone maker... Google, which the law will force to allow more competition in search, explored ways to lobby E.U. regulators to crack open Apple’s tightly controlled software ecosystem so Google could siphon users from Safari and Spotlight... Curious about HN's stance on carrying Google's water in these skirmishes advocating a forced dismantling of Apple's vertical integration consumers continue to deliberately choose, in service of enabling the deepening of Google's moat in collecting and profiling their (your) behavioral data exhaust in a way consumers don't understand. Stepping back... I believe engineering should pay the hard price to make user use easy, and privacy easy. I believe the hard work for achieving that ease makes users happy and engineers wealthy. Apple should be allowed to benefit from the sweat they invested and sell a mobile console appliance, while others should be allowed to make build-your-own mobile compute. Put another way, there's room for an iPad Pro 13 and a Frame.work Laptop 13. None of these should be forced to break their model to accommodate one of the others'.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoI have no problem with "carrying Google's water" in this case. They have as much right to computing freedom as we do. They should totally get to enjoy that freedom on Apple devices. As should we. This is completely independent from Google's surveillance capitalism problem. We should deal with that separately by turning personal information into massive liability. Society should make it so it costs them literal truckloads of money to know even a single bit of information about any human being. They should be scrambling to forget all about us the second we're done transacting with them. > sell a mobile console appliance Nope. I personally don't believe such things should be allowed to exist at all. Computers should always be real computers at all times. This "appliance" nonsense is everything that is wrong with computing today. Infinite potential, wasted.
- dontlaugh 3y agoCompanies have no rights. Only people do.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/18/business/google-antitrust-pandu-nayak.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/18/business/google-antitrust... Google's defense in this case is absurd. If bigger isn't better then let's shrink Google and see what happens. Let's share the index as public data (which it is) and see what others, less "briliant", can do with it. Let the best ingenuity and effort win. But the court may in fact be persuaded by Google's showmanship.
- jldugger 3y ago> Let's share the index as public data Common crawl[1] data has been in AWS for over a decade. [1]: https://commoncrawl.org https://commoncrawl.org
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoRegarding CommonCrawl How many websites block CCBot How many block GoogleBot https://www.google.com/search?q=inurl:robots.txt+CCBot&num=100&filter=0 https://www.google.com/search?q=inurl:robots.txt+CCBot&num=1...
- emi2k01 3y agoWow, it seems most websites that block it, block it because they data is used for training AI
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoBut CCBot has been a very common robots.txt entry for a long time, long before OpenAI of GPTBot existed, long before site operators were even aware CC was being used to train AI. This claim can be verified. Archive.org has good collection of robots.txt files. CC itself has collections of robots.txt files. If CCBot has been in most robots.txt files since 2008, it would be difficult to argue the reason has been to stop usage of crawls for training AI.
- choppaface 3y agoTheir defense is especially absurd given blatantly anti-competitive remarks like from one of their VPs: "Chrome exists to serve Google search" (And note Google lawyers fought hard to get exhibits like that permanently withheld from public view). https://twitter.com/jason_kint/status/1717679983617810523 https://twitter.com/jason_kint/status/1717679983617810523
- neonate 3y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20231026173416/https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/26/technology/google-apple-search-spotlight.html https://web.archive.org/web/20231026173416/https://www.nytim...
- nologic01 3y ago> Regulations intended to help smaller companies enter the marketplace “very frequently can also be used by incumbents to gain advantage over their rivals” But how much do we care if %x of users switch from coke to pepsi? If regulations help produce genuine alternatives that would a watershed moment as the current actors have users pretty much locked.
- oldbbsnickname 3y agoTL;DR: Google doesn't have to do a damn thing. Apple won't enter search or social networking because Erik Neuenschwander would poke holes in its privacy and Tim Cook would ask how it would add value. And there's no point in competing in hard-fought, expensive, entrenched categories without a mission and differentiation. And Spotlight isn't a search engine in the web sense or in the monetizing other things sense. It's an OS-based indexing engine to find local and some web and app content. Windows has one, Linux does, and so on. If anything, I would first bet Microsoft monetizes placement of "rich content" whereas Apple would be unlikely to do so. (Retail Windows looks to me like Yahoo or AOL of the 90's, but as a Teams, OneDrive, and Office365 advertising engine.)
- dhosek 3y ago[flagged]
- yalogin 3y agoMore of these stories come out, it is apparent that Google focused more on protecting their existing business rather than innovating to come up with the next thing after search.
- Kbelicius 3y agoThis is a story about Apple being more focused on their existing business rather than innovating and Google using these new regulations to try to force them to compete on a level playing field. How did you get it the other way around?
- retrocryptid 3y agoMaybe Google should build a search engine.
- thatgerhard 3y agomaybe google should stop being lazy and fix their existing services.. at this point google search and youtube feels abandoned