16 ms·
Adding crushed rock to farmland pulls carbon out of the air
- 3seashells 3y agoWouldn't it make more sense to sponge rock without crushing it? Basically drill air pipes into it, then fracture the material with rapid cooling and heating +water.
- redavni 3y ago[flagged]
- sunday_serif 3y agoA good idea is a good idea, regardless of where it comes from.
- vosper 3y agoThis study is about whether the rock weathering we’ve seen posted here before (crushed olivine etc) works in dry climates like California. The answer appears to be “yes, but more slowly” > The study found the plots with crushed rock stored 0.15 tons of carbon dioxide per hectare (2.47 acres) during the study compared to plots without crushed rock. Though researchers expect different weathering rates in different environments, if this amount of carbon was removed across all California cropland, it would be equivalent to taking 350,000 cars off the road every year.
- jeffbee 3y agoTaking only 3% of California's cars off the road seems way easier.
- philipkglass 3y agoIt is, but consider the future. We need net negative emissions to stabilize the climate because we didn't decarbonize early/fast enough to achieve this goal with emissions cuts alone. The vast majority of climate progress must come from energy system decarbonization, but active carbon dioxide removal approaches like this one will be necessary to draw down the excess atmospheric CO2 accumulated so far. "IPCC Report: Carbon Removal is Now Required to Meet Climate Mitigation Targets" https://www.carbon-direct.com/insights/ipcc-report-carbon-removal-is-now-required-to-meet-climate-mitigation-targets https://www.carbon-direct.com/insights/ipcc-report-carbon-re... Also see this IPCC fact sheet about carbon dioxide removal, which includes enhanced rock weathering (the technique under discussion here): https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg3/downloads/outreach/IPCC_AR6_WGIII_Factsheet_CDR.pdf https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg3/downloads/outreach/IPCC_A...
- bluGill 3y agoWithout human actives the earth is slightly net negative. We need to be more net negative than that in the short term to fix some problems (ice melt), but we don't need that forever.
- vlovich123 3y ago> Without human actives the earth is slightly net negative Source? AFAIK greenhouse warming has the capacity to be a runaway effect. It's not immediately obvious that if you remove all current human carbon emissions, that temperatures would level off & start declining vs continue increasing because of the feedback loop.
- philipkglass 3y agoThe Earth slowly depletes excess atmospheric CO2 due to the geological carbon cycle of silicate weathering. This is the slow, natural counterpart of the accelerated silicate weathering discussed above. It is too slow to reverse global warming on human time scales, but it means that if anthropogenic emissions ceased Earth would reach its peak temperature in less than a thousand years (ice melting and other reactions to this change would go on for several thousands of years) and gradually decline back to the pre-industrial atmospheric CO2 and climate within about 100,000 years. My source for this recollection is David Archer's 2009 book The Long Thaw: How Humans Are Changing the Next 100,000 Years of Earth's Climate.
- unlikelymordant 3y agoHumans are currently on track for around 4 degrees of warming by 2100 assuming we hit all our current emission reduction targets (i.e. reaching net zero when governments have said they would). So removals are quite necessary.
- hedora 3y agoThey don't say how much rock they added to each field, but note that the 0.15 tons of CO2 they remove is only 300 lbs. A gallon of gasoline emits 20 lbs of CO2 when burnt. So, if they use more than 15 gallons of gasoline to mine, crush, transport and spread the rock over 2.47 acres, then this process emits more CO2 than it captures. I think they'd need to use electric high-tonnage dump trucks and electric tractors to make this process actually capture carbon. Electric tractors are stating to become available, but I don't know of any high-tonnage electric truck manufacturers.
- freeone3000 3y agoDepends on how high “high tonnage” is. Kennworth is offering a 680hp full-electric with a 3 hour range. Volvo offers an electric VNR with identical performance to its standard VNR. Freightliner sells the eCascadia, matching its regular Cascadia.
- hedora 3y agoThose are semi-trucks. You'd need to attach a compatible dump trailer to them. (Those might exist, but I don't think I've ever seen one).
- peteradio 3y agoThey exist, its how animal manures are applied to fields. Likely this would be shipped via trains long distance and last mile with semi.
- Karrot_Kream 3y agoThese vehicles would need to be charged on fully renewables or non emitting sources (like hydro) to offset this. Even if Natgas or Gas plants are much more efficient than engines, the calculation still needs to account for amortized emissions.
- freeone3000 3y agoYes? Obviously yes? Idk why everyone is assuming we’re going to keep dragging our feet on something that, at this point, is merely a matter of buying a few batteries and setting up a few more solar panels. Provinces have done it; heck, entire countries have done it. Switch to renewables already.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI think this is cool from an academic perspective, but I have a very difficult time believing the energy needed to crush rock, and distribute it over fields, makes this a net benefit.
- DennisP 3y agoThat depends on the energy source, and how much is available. If for example we convert to 100% wind/solar/battery, we'll end up with a large oversupply of zero-carbon electricity in the summer.
- brianbreslin 3y agoThis may be a dumb question, but if we're collecting volcanic rock, could we not tap into geothermal energy from the volcano to get cheap energy?
- rogerkirkness 3y agoThe argument is basically that we will need extra energy to go towards carbon capture one way or the other. Energy in, carbon reduced. This may or may not be a feasible way to do that.
- pacaro 3y agoIt seems reasonable to assume that many places where there is easily accessible volcanic rock are also places where geothermal is possible, but the connection between rocks like basalt and volcanoes can be more temporally distant that you may be thinking. If I go to a beach in the US Pacific North West, I can pick up basalt rocks/boulders/pebbles, but they last were in contact with an active volcano millions of years ago (approx 12mya is the usual number given locally, if memory serves)
- aziaziazi 3y agoThat is only true if we also convert to 100% w/s/b the w/s/b material sourcing, fabrication, distribution…
- 3y ago
- jeron 3y agoCan anyone speak to whether this helps or hurts the fertility of the soil?
- Sparkyte 3y agoNot too sure, but some plants greatly benefit from rock in soil.
- UncleOxidant 3y agoIt should help replenish certain minerals in the soil.
- tastyfreeze 3y agoThe sand and rocks in the soil is where phosphorus and trace minerals come from. Ideal soil has a combination of living carbon, dead carbon, and minerals. The fungi and bacteria breakdown the minerals along with weathering and make it available to plants. All the living carbon builds itself from the dead carbon. The dead carbon came from dead plants that pulled the carbon from the air with photosynthesis.
- brianbreslin 3y agovolcanic soil is often considered very fertile for agricultural purposes. [1] [1] https://www.bgs.ac.uk/discovering-geology/earth-hazards/volcanoes/living-with-volcanoes/#:~:text=Volcanic%20deposits%20are%20enriched%20in,in%20years%20following%20an%20eruption https://www.bgs.ac.uk/discovering-geology/earth-hazards/volc....
- marcosdumay 3y agoDepends on the soil. But it helps often enough that there is no lack of places.
- thsksbd 3y agoThey're dumping alkalinity into the soil. What could go wrong?
- mcpackieh 3y agoIf it were a good idea from the perspective of farmers, then farmers would already be paying to do it themselves. This isn't the case though, so you will have to pay farmers to do it. Why does it even have to be on farmland in the first place? If it's such a great idea with no environmental downsides, then dump the crushed rock onto other land instead. Then you can dump more of it without being limited by whatever is optimal for farm yields.
- jlhawn 3y ago> Previous studies have estimated this “enhanced” rock weathering could store 215 billion tons of carbon dioxide over the next 75 years if spread across croplands globally. This is an average rate of 2.8 Billion tons of CO2 per year. We currently emit over 35 Billion tons of CO2 every year so this could potentially offset about 8% of global emissions. Obviously not enough to get us to net zero but that is very significant in my opinion. I'm not certain how the economics of this solution would work. Is it easy to source, produce, and distribute this crushed volcanic rock? Would farmers get carbon credits for doing so? Or direct subsidies paid for by taxes on net-positive CO2 generating industries (which ironically is a lot of Ag itself)?
- xjidjccudux 3y ago[dead]
- reaperman 3y agoAnd how much would it affect agriculture? Do the plants thrive if you do this every year?
- philipkglass 3y agoAdding ground silicates can significantly increase agricultural productivity on various kinds of land. Here's one review article about the subject: "Remineralizing soils? The agricultural usage of silicate rock powders: A review" https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S004896972106054X https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S004896972... IIRC the soils that benefit the most include: - Soils depleted in micronutrients - Acidic soil - Silica depleted soil (significant for rice farming and other silica-sensitive crops) Most of the world's acidic and depleted soils that could benefit the most are in warm tropical regions with heavy rainfall. That's also where fresh mineral applications would weather most rapidly to draw down CO2. Unfortunately, it may also be harder (logistically and culturally) to encourage silicate applications on those soils than on the temperate climate soils of North America. After a certain point adding more silicates doesn't help increase soil productivity. The one thing that I haven't found any reporting on is where the "too much" point is reached for soil amendment with crushed silicates. I have seen that yields stop increasing with ever-increasing addition of ground rock. I haven't seen a point where they go down. I would guess that there's some point where yields actually start dropping, and that would mark the upper limit for agricultural soil amendments. Up to the point where yields keep increasing, you could expect farmers to spread crushed silicates on their fields for their own benefit, depending on the cost. In the high-application case where yields flatten out but carbon sequestration continues to increase, you'd need to pay subsidies to get higher application rates. You'd also need to pay subsidies in the lower-application-rate cases if yields increase but not enough to justify the expense on a yield basis.
- denton-scratch 3y agoSo I guess you end up with finely-divided carbonate. I didn't notice any mention of how long it takes powdered basalt to weather down. Is that over a year?
- vonwolfhausen 3y agoCan be <5 years if it is super fine (~25um) or >20 years if it is coarse (minus 3/8" fines).
- kisamoto 3y agoTo reach maximum sequestration rate I thought it was much longer than that (~95% within 30 years at 3um). Where did you get your numbers from (curious, always looking for more sources)?
- denton-scratch 3y agoI seem to be wrong about the result of basalt-weathering being carbonates. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basalt#Weathering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basalt#Weathering It seems that basalt consists mainly of metal oxides, predominantly Fe, Ca, Mg and Al. How does carbonic acid from rain get bound into basalt, without dissolving in the next rainstorm? (My knowledge of chemistry is restricted to "A" level, what Americans would call High School; and I've forgotten it all, because it was 40 years ago). The article says that basalts weather down into clays, which aren't carbonates.
- danieloj 3y agoThere are interesting positive/negative (it hasn’t been researched enough yet) side effects on the effects this has in raising the pH of the ocean, potentially reversing ocean acidification
- RayanSord 3y ago[flagged]
- willtemperley 3y agoThis has been known for a while: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2448-9 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2448-9
- londons_explore 3y agoCrushed anything in air or water can be bad for the environment though. In air, it is effectively PM2.5/PM10 pollution. In water, I bet it gets into fishes gills just like it gets into our lungs.
- kisamoto 3y agoThe crushed rocks in this case mineralize into stable silicates which can be beneficial as they flow down rivers into the sea. As they are alkaline they can combat ocean acidity and the minerals help crustaceans harden their shells.
- londons_explore 3y agoAre those super finely crushed stable silicates those same ones which cause silicosis?
- kisamoto 3y agoGood question, more research needed (on my side and perhaps in general related to this specific case).
- the_sleaze9 3y agoI'm reading this a single-use carbon sequestration solution, is that not correct? As in - you pay the carbon to crush it, ship it and spread it. Then it captures carbon exactly once, and then what do you do with it?
- tux2bsd 3y ago[dead]
- anonymous344 3y agohow about u just dont cut all the trees because of greed??
- kisamoto 3y agoNot enough for what we need. Even if we covered all the possible area we could with trees we couldn't capture enough CO₂. And that ignores the fact that climate change increases the chances of wildfires.
- avodonosov 3y agoWhat is the risk to get silicosis caused by that rock dust? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silicosis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silicosis
- vonwolfhausen 3y agoDust is never good, but olivine specifically was introduced as a foundry sand specifically because it doesn't cause silicosis (vs quartz).
- avodonosov 3y agoThe article also mentions metabasalt
- pfdietz 3y agoOlivine is a kind of silicate where the silicon atoms are in isolated tetrahedra (with four oxygen atoms), rather than linked into large chains, sheets, or 3d lattices. This makes it weather more quickly (for CO2 absorption), but I suspect also makes it dissolve more quickly in the body.
- RecycledEle 3y agoI thought humans spent thousands of years removing rock from dirt to create framland. Are they trying to reverse that? Certainly destroying the farmland and letting people starve would result in decreased carbon dioxide emissions.
- PeterisP 3y agoIt depends on the soil pH, where it's needed, crushed olivine is already used to increase crop yields (see e.g. https://modernfarmer.com/2023/09/enhanced-rock-weathering/ https://modernfarmer.com/2023/09/enhanced-rock-weathering/ ) where it's close enough / cheap enough. Bringing it everywhere where it could be useful, though, is unlikely to happen without subsidies to cover the transport costs, but the need for carbon capture might support that.
- robomartin 3y agoTypical "Assume a cow is a uniform sphere of milk one meter in diameter" proposal. > "adding crushed VOLCANIC ROCK to cropland" ... "by crushing the rock into a FINE DUST" Emphasis mine. So... - Mine massive far-away lava fields - Generate massive amounts of CO2 through this process - Cause serious environmental damage - Transport what you mined - Generate massive amounts of CO2 through transportation - Crush it into a fine dust - Generate massive amounts of CO2 through this process - Transport massive quantities again - Generate massive amounts of CO2 again - Likely need for massive amounts of chemicals as part of all of the above - Use a high carbon footprint process to distribute the dust - Use a high carbon footprint process to bury the dust to the required depth - Hope and pray for enough rain - Hope and pray you don't destroy the fields for agricultural use Right. And that's not even a full accounting of what the process at scale would look like. It is far more likely to add massive amounts of CO2 to the atmosphere than the opposite. Not to mention potential ecological damage across every region the project might touch, from mining to deployment. We are not going to surface real solutions until we are willing to be honest about the full and real accounting behind proposals. Most so-called solutions barely pass basic high school science and economics tests. That's where we are. Still. I mean, we are still talking about stuff like huge fan-powered filters? Have we gone mad? All we are doing is wasting time and money looking at false supernatural solutions to a planetary scale problem that requires real solutions. > if this amount of carbon was removed across all California cropland, it would be equivalent to taking 350,000 cars off the road every year. OK. Then forget volcanic dust and focus on the infrastructure and power generation required to enable a million electric cars per year. If this volcanic powder nonsense is good for 350K cars per year, well, doing THREE TIMES BETTER with electric cars is a realistic objective that isn't in fantasy-land at all and does not create the potentially horrific ecological danger of mining and spreading volcanic dust. One is realistic and attainable. The other is, at best, a dangerous fantasy.
- djtriptych 3y agoI can imagine a geothermal-based extraction process to mine + a wind/solar transportation method. This works fine even if it takes 100x longer to transport. Can be fully robotic piloting for instance. Bottom line I'm not sure it MUST be a C02-generating process once bootstrapped. Also no reason we can't focus on both electric cars and this soil method.
- twic 3y agoThe two-step plan to fix more carbon into soil: 1. Rocks 2. Ants! https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/ants-may-boost-co2-absorption-enough-to-slow-global-warming/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/ants-may-boost-co...
- skymast 3y ago[dead]
- JoshTko 3y ago1. Tax companies for their portion of CO2 generation. Let costs trickle down to customers. 2. Split tax collected evenly to each citizen/perm resident via monthly check. 3. Let market figure out Co2 reduction solutions. 4. Create whistleblower process to keep carbon sequestration companies in check.
- ericjmorey 3y agoThat industries fight hardest against this approach tells me that it's probably the most effective and efficient approach.
- Willish42 3y ago#2 seems like a ludicrous misalignment / conflict of interest. Why would I as a taxpayer/voter want CO2 emissions to decrease if I'm essentially getting a monthly bonus for their existence?
- totetsu 3y agoPresumably if there is an option that is more C02 efficient, it would have less tax so could be cheaper. If you spend your monthly bonus on the cheaper option it’s still a net positive
- JoshTko 3y agoIf 1-4 is implemented, gas would become a lot more expensive. Companies will switch to EV fleets, gas demand would drop, oil companies would not lobby politicians for drilling permits as new drilling would have bad ROI. Voters will to a lesser extent do what companies are doing and purchase lower carbon impact products. The hypothetical voter you speak of would only benefit if they purchase lower carbon impact products and pocket the savings from the check. However the act of purchasing the lower carbon impact product today has far more impact than a vote for a politician carbon intensive policy in the future. The incentives are aligned in that even this weird hypothetical voter will drive the adoption of lower carbon impact products long term.
- 3y ago
- jacobgorm 3y agoRelated idea, but for oceans https://www.vesta.earth/ https://www.vesta.earth/
- huytersd 3y agoSo ruin farmland with crushed rock? Why would you even study such things?
- jamescrowley 3y agoIt can actually have benefits to the soil as a fertiliser - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10011191/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10011191/
- huytersd 3y agoAnything bigger than a pebble is going to ruin harvesters and planters.
- lucb1e 3y agoThe person you're replying to posted a link which mentions in the "materials and methods" section that the particles in the study were all smaller than 2mm (and 99.6% smaller than 1mm). To compare with your pebble, which wikipedia says is > A pebble is a clast of rock with a particle size of 4-64 mm
- ksenzee 3y agoThey’re using rock crushed to ~100 microns.
- lucb1e 3y agoIf you open the article and click the only link in the first paragraph, leading to the source, it will tell you in the introduction > Crushed metabasalt and olivine soil amendments were used to investigate changes in soil pore water alkalinity as a proxy for bicarbonate production. The metabasalt (median grain size: 102 ± 22 μm) was selected because of its benign elemental composition and modest weathering potential (the parent volcanics includes felsic facies, yielding an overall silica content in the intermediate-to-felsic range). The olivine (median grain size: 83 ± 12 μm), in contrast, was chosen for its potential to weather rapidly TL;DR scan for the digits in that quote. This stuff is measured in micrometers. > Why would you even study such things? Because if everyone were willing to read sources and get to understandings, we would probably not have climate problems in the first place
- CrzyLngPwd 3y agoAs a land owner all I can think of is; I wonder what the unforseen outcomes of this might be? Will it turn my soil acidic? Will it kill off bacteria? Will reduce drainage or will my soil suddenly be unable to hold water? Will it harm the nematodes, will it create a nutrient imbalance that is only corrected by some monsanto/bayer patented soil amendment?
- AndreSobolewski 3y agoThese are the same questions I raised in an earlier comment. They are pertinent.
- earth2jason 3y agoPeculiar as to why this is pitched at farmers. Maybe there could be a question of ulterior motives.
- AndreSobolewski 3y agoEnhanced Weathering, as the practice is called, has merit and is being investigated by a dozen startups. The idea of spreading Olivine (a magnesium iron silicate) or Brucite (magnesium hydroxide) or Wollastonite (calcium inosilicate) has been floated around for a while. There are three aspects relating to its feasible application - as distinct from theoretical considerations. 1. Is the process feasible? The slow reaction rate seems to be a significant obstacle. Additionally, these minerals are rarely pure and may vary significantly in quality from source to source, leading to a QA/QC problem. 2. Can the process be scaled-up? Contrary to earlier comments, there is no wide availability of these minerals, not at the scale needed to make an impact. Moreover, the material-handling side of the issue is not well addressed. It isn't a simple question of drawing a distribution network on a diagram: it's working out the economics of the mass mining, transport, distribution and application of these materials. People are working on this, but I have not yet heard a compelling solution. 3. Are there undesirable side reactions? This is what farmers will worry about. It'll be good if these amendments increase soil fertility, but that has to be demonstrated. Do these amendments alter the physical structure of soils or reduce their capacity to retain water, especially after carbon is absorbed? Do they form concretions over time that would make soils less permeable? Does the exposure to plant exudates release contaminants in soil? I was involve in a project at a Canadian diamond mine in which the host rock - Kimberlite - absorbed CO2. This caused a decrease in its alkaline pH and allowed small quantities of sulphides to oxidize and release contaminants. Clearly, this is the kind of undesirable outcome that must be avoided. Lots more to say, but perhaps some EW experts will chime in.
- unlikelymordant 3y agoThis whole 'undesireable side reactions' thing is completely overblown for basalts. The effects to soil of volcanic ash from eruptions is quite well studied, not to mention crushed basalt is a recognised fertiliser in organic and biodynamic farming, and there have been places spreading it each year for the last 40 years (purely as a fertliser). You cant use rocks with significant sulphides or other heavy metals though, that has to be tested before spreading. Basalt is quite wide spread.
- pfdietz 3y agoMy concern would be nickel pollution.
- luxuryballs 3y agoWhy are we even thinking of doing this? I am more than a little concerned that it may not be wise to assume the answer to biome engineering is even more biome engineering…
- m0llusk 3y agoBefore we blew past 400 ppm carbon in the atmosphere this might have made sense. Now it would probably be more accurate to phrase the implicit proposal as asserting the answer to rampant biome disruption may include some cautious biome engineering.
- natch 3y agoAre they claiming that microbes and other life forms don't just harvest the carbon (directly or indirectly) putting it right back into the air?
- matznerd 3y agoThe CO2 storage is inorganic as bicarbonate dissolved in seawater and is considered permanent (60,000-100,000+ years). This process occurs as rocks weather and release magnesium or calcium cations. The "enhanced rock weathering" (ERW) process is all about speeding up the rate of release of these cations. Taking them out of a closed mountain not in the tropics and grinding them up, increasing their reactive surface area, speeds up the weathering process by many millions of years or more. See: The role of soils in the regulation of ocean acidification - https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rstb.2020.0174 https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rstb.202...
- natch 3y agoInteresting. I don’t know enough to judge the veracity of this, but it will lead me to learn more, so thanks. And geology is fascinating, so that’s another reason to learn more.
- garrickvanburen 3y agoHow do we get it distributed across suburban backyards?
- orthecreedence 3y agoSimple: https://cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/archetype/Q7XYKG5UTZCLXH6INZOPTM6ET4.jpg https://cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/archet...
- pfdietz 3y agoIt could be sold as a magnesium and iron supplement, to make lawns greener when those elements are in short supply.
- fuzztester 3y agoGabe Brown: treating the farm as an ecosystem https://youtu.be/uUmIdq0D6-A?si=RnMka7Nnx0yZ3Tqm https://youtu.be/uUmIdq0D6-A?si=RnMka7Nnx0yZ3Tqm
- fsckboy 3y agoin New England (and other places I assume), rocks are light enough to float. There are many rocks under the surface of the soil, and over time they work their way upward and pop out of the ground. Every spring when the fields are being tilled for planting, these rocks get in the way and they need to be removed (for the convenience of the farmer and his plow). Today's New England forests are all 2nd or 3rd growth; the land was previously completely cleared for farmland, before the farmland of the Great Plains opened up and was found more efficient for scale farming (and not least because the human population there was smaller). If you walk through the New England woods today, you will periodically/frequently come across old "abandoned" stone walls among the trees. Farmers built these stone walls to mark their property from the stones that were handy because they were removed from their nearby fields, where these stones had "floated" to the surface. The reason these stones are under the surface is because the grinding and bulldozing of glaciation, and then the subsequent outwashing of ice-melt carrying stones and sediment. All of that (from memory, apologies for any mistakes) to ask: won't adding crushed rocks to farmland result in a lot of those rocks popping back out of the ground? Will plowing just keep them turned under, but even so, wouldn't the population of rocks keep increasing?
- lucb1e 3y ago> these rocks get in the way and they need to be removed [...] you will periodically/frequently come across old "abandoned" stone walls [made] from the stones that were handy because they were removed from their nearby fields You didn't mention what size these rocks/stones are (to my non-native ears, a rock is at least several centimetres), but if you can build walls from them, I take it they're not sand-sized. If you click the link in the first paragraph of the article, leading to the source, it mentions in the introduction > Crushed metabasalt and olivine soil amendments were used to investigate changes in soil pore water alkalinity as a proxy for bicarbonate production. The metabasalt (median grain size: 102 ± 22 μm) was selected because of its benign elemental composition and modest weathering potential (the parent volcanics includes felsic facies, yielding an overall silica content in the intermediate-to-felsic range). The olivine (median grain size: 83 ± 12 μm), in contrast, was chosen for its potential to weather rapidly TL;DR the remains of the crushed rock they tested is measured in micrometers
- coding123 3y agoIn other news the Mining industry rushes to produce 3000 trillion tons of crushed rock, causing 1b cubic tons of rock dust over the world.
- slowhand09 3y ago"crushed rock stored 0.15 tons of carbon dioxide per hectare (2.47 acres)". (.15 * 2000lb)/2.47 = 300lb/2.47 = ~121.5lbs/acre of carbon uptake. After applying 41tons/acre of olivine. How is this feasible? You ship railroad cars of volcanic rock dust, spread it on a field, and watch it take up a sandbag size amount of carbon per acre. Is it continuous or a onetime thing?
- trhway 3y ago>The study found the plots with crushed rock stored 0.15 tons of carbon dioxide per hectare (2.47 acres) during the study compared to plots without crushed rock. According to the article it took several months of winter. Say, even though there is less rain in the summer, it is 0.3 tons per hectare per year. To put into perspective - trees sequester more than 6 tons of carbon dioxide per hectare per year.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- ruiisnwn 3y ago[flagged]
- orthecreedence 3y agoCrushed rock is communism...? Someone should have told Lenin.
- oldbbsnickname 3y agoIn Soviet Russia, Gulag break you into rocks.
- hownottowrite 3y agoThere’s so much more to soil conservation. Our reliance on manmade chemicals over good stewardship of the land has resulted in so many problems. Highly recommend looking into Louis Bromfield. A very accessible book: The Planter of Modern Life: How an Ohio Farm Boy Conquered Literary Paris, Fed the Lost Generation, and Sowed the Seeds of the Organic Food Movement
- vonwolfhausen 3y agoI've been enjoying this thread. I have a company that does this (Eion). We are recruiting for a data engineer role to implement the algorithms for quantifying carbon removal, if these questions are interesting to you. Touches on nearly every aspect in this thread.
- SteveGreaseBoss 3y agoCrushing rock is very energy intensive, transporting rock to farms is energy intensive. Placing rock in the soil is energy intensive. Its hard to see how this passes the B/S test.
- oldbbsnickname 3y agoYep. It's easy to skip the TCO analysis to make it seem like it's "helping" in the context of a study trying to sell another study. The Bill Gates-associated method of spraying fine lye in a hyperboloid tower seems the most effective, perhaps at a slightly higher pressure of 2-3 atm to both increase the temperature and reactivity. The lye would be produced in a closed carbon cycle process using renewable energy sources.
- m3kw9 3y agoFor any one that need to squeeze out that extra carbon credits
- 8bitsrule 3y agoWe're addicted to stuff that runs on fossil fuels. Keep running into ideas about how to offset that. We need to wake and stop. If there hasn't already been enough climate Narcan sprayed to wake us up by now, we'll keep dreaming until we can't. Then we will stop.
- MrDresden 3y ago> 215 billion tons of carbon dioxide over the next 75 years if spread across croplands globally. But for how long does the rock 'function' before needing to be replaced? I'm doubtful that it would work at the same rate over just a few years, let alone 75. With the need for massive mining, transportation and application of the rock at regular intervals I wonder if it would erode what ever gains this gives us.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AndreSobolewski 3y agoThis article is directly relevant to this question: https://carbonherald.com/silicate-to-undertake-first-ever-enhanced-weathering-trial-in-the-u-s/ https://carbonherald.com/silicate-to-undertake-first-ever-en... "Climate tech startup Silicate is set to start the first-ever enhanced weathering trial in the United States. The trial will involve applying 500 metric tons of milled returned concrete to 50 hectares of farmland in Buckingham, Illinois. According to company estimates, this project has the potential to remove as much as 100 tons of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere annually."
- spandextwins 3y agoJust plant trees.
- gomijacogeo 3y agoWondering about pH and leaching mercury...