18 ms·
Children of married parents do better, but America is moving the other way
- Retric 3y agoIs it that marriage itself is beneficial or that people capable of maintaining a relationship make better parents? Divorce is significantly more common for bipolar, paranoid, and schizophrenic people for example. So I think we need to look at widows or something to control for those kinds of issues.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoObligatory note that it’s unethical to do a real control experiment at society wide levels, so we will never untangle causation/correlation.
- COGlory 3y agoI was wondering about that, too. The data are very clear: if you grow up with married parents, you will do better. But, should everyone be rushing off to get married, or is marriage selective for people who will do better? Or is it partly selective, and also partly forcing yourself to work through a marriage makes you a better person?
- hfuyf65 3y agoIts effects may be more visible, because in previous iterations society condemned children out of wedlock so data on it was not as reliable. Naturally, potential solutions would result in rather unwelcome dystopias that could be encapsulates in a phrase 'oi you got loicense for those kids?'
- rawgabbit 3y agoIt is a bit of all the above. People select marriage partners who are trust worthy, stable, and not constantly looking for excitement. These same people, when they find a suitable spouse, are more likely to tough it out when things get unpleasant in the belief their spouse is fundamentally a good person. In marriage just like at work, you don’t judge someone by one event. People may have a bad day. Or they are sick and not themselves. Instead you should judge their actions over a long period of time. If someone has always been there for you, appreciated you and delivered what they promised, and for some reason hurt you today; you are more likely to give them the benefit of the doubt.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- parsimo2010 3y agoPossibly some of the poor outcomes are due to married people being more likely to be able to sustain a stable relationship. There are a lot of factors confounded with marriage, and it doesn’t seem like the author controlled for them (this is an article about a book and not a peer reviewed study). She explicitly mentioned that married couples are more likely to have a better household income and that single moms are less likely to have support from outside family members. So I suspect that outcomes might be better for a single parent with the income and family support the same as a married couple, but that situation is rare. Similarly, if you forced two people to get married and have kids when they didn’t want to, those kids probably aren’t going to get the same benefit of growing up in a married household.
- pixl97 3y agoI wonder how much more we can add to this with Divorce being more common now, but adding Family sizes decreasing over time. Families moving farther away and not able to support each other as readily. Fewer friends with kids reducing the number of potential helpers with ones kids in time crunched/emergency situations.
- rafaelmn 3y agoIt's literally in the first paragraph : >In the book, released last month, Kearney points out a rather obvious fact: Children raised by two parents have a much higher chance of success than those raised by one. Yet she goes even further to argue that whether parents are married or not impacts their children's success.
- chomp 3y agoFrom the article: > In the U.S., she says, unmarried adults who decide to live together do it for a much shorter duration than in Europe. Children in many of these households are more likely to experience two or three parental partnerships by age 15. Its a stability thing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- andyjohnson0 3y ago> In the U.S., she says, unmarried adults who decide to live together do it for a much shorter duration than in Europe. Are there any theories about why this might be? The article doesn't seem to follow this up.
- hdjjhhvvhga 3y agoYeah, I'm also curious. Another commenter in this thread blames individualism and inability to cope with minor incompatibilities but I wonder if it's really true.
- andyjohnson0 3y agoThose seem too universal to affect the US more than Europe.
- laurencerowe 3y agoI suspect this is a result of the tax system in the US which is structured in a way that strongly incentivises parents into marriage. Europe generally taxes incomes individually and offers parental leave to help when one of the parents is out of the workforce with a baby. In the US there's just the pooling of tax allowances. For dual income households in very high cost of living areas though you need to balance the benefits of pooling tax allowances while only one of you is working with the reduction in mortgage interest tax deduction (which has the same maximum for both a married couple or unmarried single filers.)
- jkhdigital 3y agoFunny you mention that. I have four siblings, raised together in a (mostly) traditional family, and all five of us have children now. The only one who is not married is my schizophrenic sister. However, my late aunt was schizophrenic and stayed married for her entire adult life, so who knows.
- konschubert 3y agoOn a slightly related note, why is it that one gets lynched on twitter nowadays any time one brings up that "correlation doesn't imply causation"?
- mikrl 3y agoAre you sure there is a causative relation between bringing it up and getting eviscerated? Perhaps a third process correlates them.
- konschubert 3y agoI am sure, because people literally say: 'I will ban anyone who says "correlation doesn't imply causation"'
- pram 3y agoBecause it has become a lazy thought terminating cliche since people say it and then contribute nothing else of value.
- konschubert 3y agoBut what if the thoughts were dumb?
- konschubert 3y agoIt's also lazy and pointless to have a discussion based on 0 evidence.
- gemstones 3y agoBecause it’s on you to show what about the correlation makes causation unlikely, and most people don’t take that step. We all know correlation isn’t causation, that’s trite and obvious. Why wouldn’t the correlation between married parents and better child outcomes be causative?
- konschubert 3y ago
- mdorazio 3y agoSome bad answers (and non-answers) to your question here. There are many studies on this with various conclusions worth reading, example set [1]. At a high level, US marriages (and potentially non-US long-term partnerships) bring stability, additional economic support, an additional role model (completely missing for boys growing up in a single mother household), additional attention & emotional support at home, and the ability to split parenting tasks as the need arises (ex. dad goes to a school event because mom needs to work late, or vice versa). Also important to note is that parental attention has a large impact on academic outcomes of kids [2], so in single parent households where the parent doesn't have the time to provide sufficient attention, the kids suffer at school compared to their two-parent peers. [1] https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C44&q=two+parent+households+child+development https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C44&q=two... [2] https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00131911.2013.780009 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00131911.2013.78...
- xattt 3y agoWhy not both? All people, kids and adults, have a finite level of emotional and mental energy that they have to “dispense” in everyday life. If you are a couple that’s dealing with marital strife, this is emotional overhead that gets diverted to dealing with that instead of your kids. Same goes for kids. A child that’s struggling to comprehend why parents decided to leave each other will be using that emotional energy to process it instead of focusing on personal growth. This is not taking into account the divorce process is costly, with money diverted to lawyers, instead of being pooled and applied to improve family life. Also, persons who divorce early in a relationship may not have taken the time to understand compatibility with each other, may be emotionally immature and impulsive. The lack of insight might be something that perpetuates into other aspects of their life. There are, obviously, relationship patterns where it takes a long time for one partner to realize the other one has gradually become more and more abusive and controlling, either because they have low self-confidence or self-esteem. This somewhat tracks the concept of emotional maturity, but this is difficult to talk about as this form of framing puts the blame onto the abused partner.
- pixl97 3y ago>This is not taking into account the divorce process is costly, When parties choose not to fight, it's not near as costly. This said there is a new set of costs incurred in creating and managing two households in most cases.
- danielschonfeld 3y agoThis question is answered in the interview. She is saying that a household with a stable long lasting relationship is what’s driving these better outcomes. She’s also saying that in America marriage (unfortunately) seems to be the only way to keep people together for a long while (long enough for a child to not experience a parade of parents by the time they are 15 according to the article). In my personal opinion. I think what she’s stumbled on is yet again proof of Americans hyper individuality rearing its ugly face. The Europeans can stay together longer without the marriage piece of paper because 1) Selfishness derived from hyper individuality doesn’t drive people to nope out of relationships at the first sign of minuscule problems or one side not getting their way 2) Since over there not everything is an economical benefit proposal people value the relationship with different metrics than our countrymen and women do.
- seec 3y agoWhy do you assume Europeans do any better at this? Do you have comparable statistics? From my own experience, it is extremely unlikely that it is any different once you accounted for all variables. One reason Europeans might stay together longer together is for the tax benefits and other government subventions they would not get if they were single. In fact, except for single mothers who get everything with very litte conditions but terrible outcomes. The reality does not have much to do with a special government, religion, or whatever convoluted explanation you want to find. The answer is right there in plain sight; expect you cannot really say it because of strong enforcement of the public discourse. If that was not clear, I am saying that women are the variable that is messing everything up, and as a recipient of this reality I think anyone who believe otherwise is either a fool or politically motivated for some reason.
- Retric 3y agoAgain, both parents in a stable long lasting relationship are capable of a stable long lasting relationship. Americans being bad at this doesn’t mean long term relationships are the sole difference, though they likely do provide some benefits it’s not the total difference in populations. "I don't know exactly what it is about marriage, but it is a very practical matter," says Kearney, chafing at all the criticism. "If you just look in the data, marriage is what delivers kids a stable, long-term, two-parent household in this country." The data is clear, however understanding the root causes is important because it impacts what approaches are most useful. If the relationships themselves are important the having a high school class in maintaining healthy relationship could be useful. If it’s the broader issues then we need to address those issues.
- WillAdams 3y agoI think that's it in a nutshell. Divorce is also more common for selfish and self-centered people, and I would argue that those traits do not make for good parents. (which is not to say that a good person should remain married to such a spouse --- arguably the only thing worse than a good divorce is a bad marriage) Ages ago, I worked at a school for boys, and one could pretty much map negative trats of the parents to corresponding unsocial behaviours on the part of the child.
- ryandrake 3y ago> Ages ago, I worked at a school for boys, and one could pretty much map negative trats of the parents to corresponding unsocial behaviours on the part of the child. My parents were both teachers, and it was a very commonly held belief among teachers that you could predict a kid's academic outcome reasonably well by simply learning about their parent(s) behaviors and home life. Kids' academic achievement has little to do with the quality of schools, quality of teachers, wealth or poverty of the area, but has everything to do with the positive and negative traits of their parents.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI strongly agree with this, but it is an inconvenient truth because everyone wants to search out good policy in the domain space to improve outcomes. That is unfortunately extremely challenging, as you can't fix broken parents. You end up having to design systems to clean up the mess after kids turn into adults, because there are limited mechanisms to encourage better behavior from suboptimal parents. (did a sustained stint as a volunteer guardian ad litem [1] and occasionally provide advice to others performing the work) [1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/guardian_ad_litem https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/guardian_ad_litem
- marcosdumay 3y ago> but it is an inconvenient truth because everyone wants to search out good policy in the domain space to improve outcomes Just because something defines 90% of the result, it doesn't mean you must just give-up and not work on that remaining 10%. The same applies to the luck vs. hard work problem people keep missing the point about.
- em-bee 3y agoDivorce is significantly more common for bipolar, paranoid, and schizophrenic people for example is that really a significant factor? i'd think that the number of people suffering from mental issues is a minority, and even if in their group are more divorces, those should only be a fraction of the total number of divorces.
- Retric 3y agoYes, because either parent could have menial issues. Especially when you include things like gambling addiction which are also linked to divorce. ~2.8% of the population has bipolar disorder. The odds that one partner at the start of a relationship is bipolar should be ~5.6%. 1% of the population is schizophrenic so ~2% of the population. We aren’t quite up to 7.6% of relationships just from those 2 groups because there’s overlap but it does stack. Granted I haven’t done the research to pin down exact numbers but higher rates of divorce operates in both directions. So stable couples are healthier than average and divorced couples are worse than average.
- jamespo 3y agoMaybe nonstable are less likely to have relationships / kids
- somehnguy 3y agoMaybe, but over my 30 years every piece of anecdotal evidence I’ve seen *and* the movie Idiocracy says the exact opposite.
- Retric 3y agoSure, which is why you want actual real research. Still something like 16-25% of the overall population has some form of diagnosable mental illness, couples have 2 people, and divorced are more likely to have various conditions. So the effect size would need to be huge for this not to be relevant.
- lazide 3y agoMore like the exact opposite, at least recently.
- _8j50 3y agoParents being formally committed to one another.
- ACow_Adonis 3y agoI know Australia would provide a psuedo-natural experiment, because of the family laws effectively making de-facto relationships legally more or less equivalent of actual marriage.
- diogenescynic 3y agoMarried people vs divorced probably have the same distribution of mental illness. I think it has to due more with two incomes, two parents attention/time/insights/wisdom to benefit from. Maybe mom is good at math and dad is good at writing or history. It seems like more is better when it comes to raising a kid--hence the phrase 'it takes a village'. I bet if you did a study that also counted how many other extended family members are involved in the kid's life that would also show the same correlation.
- janalsncm 3y agoThere’s also the financial benefits of having two adults sharing responsibility under one roof. Switching every weekend doesn’t scale.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tenebrisalietum 3y ago"Their book suggests that many women don't marry the father of their child not because they reject the concept of marriage, but because they do not see him as a reliable source of economic security or stability." Marriage is not a magical thing that fixes economic problems, even if you want to keep turning the clock back and make certain acts outside of marriage illegal. The only thing that fixes economic problems is money. "Kearney says she wants to grab the attention of both conservatives who say they care about children's well-being and progressives reluctant to talk about family structures, because the link between single parenting, inequality and mobility in America is too strong to deny." Marriage is not a magical thing that creates good family structures, and parents can be deadbeat parents even within a marriage. It might give people motivation to stick around, but families that "stick together for the children" can have A) abuse, and B) the same sort of economic problems as unmarried if one or both parents aren't working. What does enable good family structures is support, provided by extended family or other things.
- hdjjhhvvhga 3y agoI would like to hear from people who downvote you their reasons. In discussions such as these where nuances matter a lot, a downvote (or upvote) is meaningless.
- ryanklee 3y agoDowbvotes could very well be because GP is putting words in the paper's mouth. And not very good words either.
- COGlory 3y ago>Marriage is not a magical thing that creates good family structures, and parents can be deadbeat parents even within a marriage. It might give people motivation to stick around, but families that "stick together for the children" can have A) abuse, and B) the same sort of economic problems as unmarried if one or both parents aren't working. What does enable good family structures is support, provided by extended family or other things. We're talking about on average though. Those things might happen, but only in a very small number of cases, and on average forcing a marriage to "work" might still be better.
- bloopernova 3y agoAmerica is moving the other way because all the wealth and power has been sucked up by the 0.1% and a large majority are too tired, stressed, and poor. Everything stems from this. Too much wealth tied up in the health insurance scam to switch to single payer, so people stay bound to their employment, and they can't afford time off or visits to the doctor because nothing is completely covered anymore. Too much wealth available to politicians and getting elected requires massive funding, so already rich folk are the vast majority of elected officials now. Which means they're completely out of touch of what a poor person's life consists of nowadays.
- christophilus 3y agoI’m not sure everything stems from this. Marriage was not just for the wealthy and nobles in the Middle Ages, or in the 1800s or in subsaharan Africa, etc. If it’s a matter of relative wealth disparity, there have been plenty of eras (probably the majority of recorded human history) in which the kings and nobles had a similar wealth gap to their poorest married subjects as we see today between the 1% and the 99%. I’m not defending wealth disparity; simply suggesting there’s likely another cause for the marriage-rate collapse.
- kibwen 3y ago> Kearney says she's not advocating that children live in a household filled with marital tension or where parents are unhappy or mistreating each other. Then what is the proposed solution? Pointing out the problem is the easy part. But if you want more people to be married, and if they're currently choosing not to get married, then you need to either force them to get married against their will (institutionalized shotgun marriages) or incentivize them to get married by offering benefits to married couples. The former produces miserable, abusive marriages and traumatized children. And as for the latter, as a country we're already utterly incapable of allocating funding for the aid of childrearing--where's the guaranteed maternity/paternity leave? where's the socialized childcare?--so pardon me if I don't quite see that solution as politically feasible.
- mhb 3y agoA good first step would be to first remove economic disincentives such as tax penalties and reductions in benefits.
- hfuyf65 3y agoOr.. remove benefits.
- wesselbindt 3y ago[flagged]
- pierat 3y ago> Then what is the proposed solution? Pointing out the problem is the easy part. This is not a position paper. This paper is a finding of fact. Demanding that they must advocate something is an anathema to proper science. And, saying that "pointing out the problem is the easy part" indicates to me you're not in the sciences. It's laughable, even.
- em-bee 3y agosolving problems is just as important as finding them. the parent comment may be unfair for dismissing the finding of a problem as the easy part, but they are absolutely right in asking how do we solve this. so let's be more constructive and explore possible solutions to this problem as well, and not just argue about the problem itself. i do agree that the political landscape in the US makes addressing this problem difficult. the only option i see is to develop grassroots support for this issue by changing peoples opinions on the need to support parenting and having children.
- digbyw12 3y ago[flagged]
- hdjjhhvvhga 3y agoDo you mean the children of Black parents? If that's really the case, I see no problem of cancellation here as it would further accentuate the point of systematic disadvantages of people of color.
- DonaldTruck 3y ago[flagged]
- hdjjhhvvhga 3y ago> Few have the combination of intellectual integrity and social obliviousness to publicly ignore that these socioeconomic factors likely have common causes among them, including lower intelligence, poorer impulse control, tendency towards violence and aggression, lower empathy, etc. OK, assuming for a moment these are true. What solutions do you offer? Because if this is the conclusion, i.e. the fault is inherent to the Black people, you basically block any (reasonable) solution. Whereas if you focus on relevant external factors, there is always a way out.
- black6 3y agoAll those are symptoms of chronic vitamin D deficiency. High melanin content associated with adaptation to the higher year-round insolation at lower latitudes also inhibits the natural production of vitamin D in the body. Living at higher latitudes, wearing more clothing due to the weather (further limiting sun exposure), and a modern lifestyle largely spent indoors all exacerbate the underlying problem.
- DonaldTruck 3y agoI'm not offering any solutions. I don't accept that it's my duty to fix their problems any more than it is an Eskimo's to fix mine. We've done more than enough. We've put them ahead of ourselves financially, socially, even legally. We've thrown ourselves into a spiral of self-loathing and despair because of their problems. Incalculable sums of money, time, and other resources have been burned by well-meaning Whites all around the world trying to elevate those of darker complexion. It's all been futile. And so the problem that I see, from my unashamedly White perspective, is that we are suffering for their failures. The solution I offer to that problem is simple: stop. At this point, only the most anti-White prick could possibly find a way to blame us for giving up.
- hfuyf65 3y agoAnecdote incoming. Usual disclaimers apply. I genuinely am not sure what true numbers are. Couple#1 They are married for a good while with three kids. He is a cop in Chicago; she has semi-random kid watching gigs. While it did not happen, they did openly discuss strategic divorce to ease their financial situation. Couple#2 She works corpo job. He works a cash only contracting job. They are married in every sense, but legally. Two kids. She would not marry for fear of losing existing benefits. ### There are some benefits to being married, but the 'benefits of kids while not married' outweigh those. And you can't argue against those cuz then you are taking food away from the hungry.
- em-bee 3y agowhat are those benefits you speak of? and why are they structured in such a way that it benefits those not legally married? in austria/germany at least what matters is household income. if you live together you get supported together. being married has no disadvantage.
- hfuyf65 3y agoSome of what I am about to say is state specific ( in my case IL ), so take this into consideration. Income is a consideration for any help. Married couple will have higher documented income, while unmarried cohabiting couple won't. In other words, single parent ( on paper ) will claim a child and with lower income have a better chance of being in the low enough income bracket. I have zero idea how common that situation is though, but I know someone who structures their life around snap benefits ( or whatever they are called now ) and its kinda ridiculous, because her monthly benedit is on par with our family's grocery budget. I struggled not to report it as fraud ( the person in question is not poor; they are using - abusing?- the system ).
- em-bee 3y agoMarried couple will have higher documented income, while unmarried cohabiting couple won't that seems to be the problem then. i think generally, hiding the income of a divorced partner is difficult so making your first scenario less likely in many places. and the other case would also require one partner to maintain credible evidence that they actually live apart and do not support each other. where i come from this is not easy to do. if you live in an area where this is possible then that's a disappointing state of local legislation. either way i doubt there is a large number of people doing this. at least i hope not. and it may as well be considered fraud. i wouldn't bother reporting it though, because it is not going to improve your own life.
- BaculumMeumEst 3y ago"Kearney says she wants to grab the attention of both conservatives who say they care about children's well-being and progressives reluctant to talk about family structures, because the link between single parenting, inequality and mobility in America is too strong to deny." She doesn't need to grab the attention of conservatives because her findings already support their pre-existing beliefs, like it says earlier in the article. I get the feeling she felt like she needed to phrase this very delicately.
- tetromino_ 3y agoI suspect her findings that the gender of the married parents is irrelevant, the thing that matters is whether or not they are married is the part that conservatives are unwilling to accept.
- BaculumMeumEst 3y agothat is a good point
- kibwen 3y ago> She doesn't need to grab the attention of conservatives because her findings already support their pre-existing beliefs Not quite, because the other solution to the problem is giving people access to sexual education and birth control so that they can decide to have children only after they find someone they're willing to marry, which are so famously contrary to conservative beliefs that they've based 40 years of political campaigning around their opposition.
- sneed_chucker 3y agoThe system of marriage in the United States was built around social and economic assumptions that largely don't hold anymore.
- DangitBobby 3y agoMaybe it will be rebuilt around the belief that it's a better environment for child rearing.
- hotpotamus 3y agoOr perhaps people will decide that childrearing is too much effort in addition to all the other pressures put upon them and birthrates will continue to fall. Perhaps South Korea and Japan are examples.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CodeNest 3y ago[flagged]
- lapcat 3y agoIt appears that marriage and money are inextricably bound. After all, Melissa Kearney is an economist. And of course the success of children is related to the wealth and education of their parents. The article mentions money many times: > Kearney notes that families headed by a single mother are five times more likely to live in poverty than families headed by a married couple. > Most single mothers start from behind; they're less likely to have a college education or a high income. Single motherhood is a lot less prevalent in higher-educated women. > Data also shows that many single mothers don't have help from any other adult, like a grandparent or other family member. That means it's mom who both supports the family financially and serves as the primary caregiver. > many women don't marry the father of their child not because they reject the concept of marriage, but because they do not see him as a reliable source of economic security or stability. This doesn't look like a "moral" problem (family values, yadda yadda). It looks more like a monetary problem.
- jkhdigital 3y agoAs with nearly all of social science, we can’t really run the controlled experiments necessary to determine if this is a causal relationship. Just because it looks like a “monetary problem” does not mean that throwing money at it will fix anything.
- lapcat 3y ago> Just because it looks like a “monetary problem” does not mean that throwing money at it will fix anything. There's a grain of truth and a grain of falsity to this statement. It's true that indiscriminately "throwing" money doesn't necessarily fix monetary problems. On the other hand, it seems unlikely that the problem can be solved without addressing the economic conditions that seem to have created it. Certainly, lecturing people about "family values", which has been happening for many decades, hasn't fixed anything.
- bsder 3y agoAs people have pointed out, contrasting widowers is a good control group.
- 3y ago
- jkhdigital 3y agoThe article really doesn’t answer that clickbait headline, but it seems analogous to “Why Jews earn so many PhDs”. It’s mostly culture, which is a tangled and recursive process that can’t be deconstructed into some government funded social programs.
- jqpabc123 3y agoProof that we need more "family values"; more religious conservatism? This is what a lot of people seem to believe --- people who've never bothered to look at the actual evidence --- or who refuse to accept it once they see. A detailed county by county survey of the entire country shows that the most religious and conservative parts of the country have higher divorces rates by far. Getting married in the Bible Belt and giving money to the church seems to *create* a lot of one parent families. https://sites.utexas.edu/contemporaryfamilies/2014/01/16/impact-of-conservative-protestantism-on-regional-divorce-rates/ https://sites.utexas.edu/contemporaryfamilies/2014/01/16/imp...
- em-bee 3y agowe do need more family values, but religious conservatism is not that. we also need equality between women and men, and that is where conservatism gets in the way. i suspect that lack of equality is what's driving most divorces in those conservative areas because women no longer allow themselves to be treated as being lesser than men, so they stand up for themselves and the conservative men can't handle that.
- em-bee 3y agoit appears that some people disagree with my comment. but i do not understand why. am i misunderstanding what conservatism is? or do people disagree with the idea of equality between men and women? or with the idea that valuing family more would be better?
- fisttrain 3y ago[flagged]
- em-bee 3y agook, fair enough. would it help to elaborate on the points? let me try: by more family values i mean: value family more. that implies better financial support and less taxes for having children, parental leave, counseling and other measures that help parents stay together. but also raising the image of being a parent in society in general. religious conservatism refers to older family values where the woman submits to man among other things as is mentioned in other comments in this subthread. equality between men and women means equal value and station. a lot has improved in that area, but it's not quite there yet. we also need to learn to respect each other equally, especially in a relationship. equal value and station doesn't just mean equal rights or equal pay for the same work, but also equal importance of their contribution, their wishes and their needs, regardless of who is doing what in a family. the last claim that religions conservatism drives divorces, again is supported by other comments
- dcre 3y agoThis article is far too generous to the argument. Matt Bruenig’s analysis will likely appeal to some here. https://mattbruenig.com/2023/09/20/doing-the-marriage-thing-again/ https://mattbruenig.com/2023/09/20/doing-the-marriage-thing-... https://mattbruenig.com/2023/09/30/response-to-douthat-on-two-parent-families/ https://mattbruenig.com/2023/09/30/response-to-douthat-on-tw...
- lordgrenville 3y agoA substacker I follow claimed that Kearney's thesis ignores a confounder, that unhappily married couples are more likely both to split up and to have kids with worse outcomes. The fairer comparison would be between unhappily married two-parent homes, and single-parent homes. Haven't read the book so can't say if this is true. https://afeteworsethandeath.substack.com/p/recent-pieces-bad-social-science https://afeteworsethandeath.substack.com/p/recent-pieces-bad...
- Boatfaceing 3y ago[dead]
- otteromkram 3y ago[flagged]
- denton-scratch 3y agoMarriage is a legal construct; it can provide a level of security (and fairness) that isn't otherwise accessible. But as the laws change, the benefits change too. I think men marry in the hope of binding their partner; fat chance. Marriage gives the partner a claim on a big chunk of the man's assets, so it incentivizes women to divorce their husbands. The great majority of divorces are initiated by the wife. I'm not sure why women marry; I'm not a woman, but maybe the reason is the same. Marriage is an outdated custom. People should learn how to live together without submitting to these ancient legal customs. Source: I'm twice married, and twice divorced; both partnerships lasted 15+ years. I'll never marry again.
- ghusto 3y agoIt's mad, no? When I ask people point blank why they're getting married, they just stare at me. Obviously part of that is because I'm being autistically rude in asking such a questions, but I haven't heard any compelling answers either.
- saiya-jin 3y agoWell if you ask such an autistic question (given that I am responding to a adult person and not some small kid who doesn't have a clue about actual life), don't expect much, it clearly signalizes that you are either taking a piss or are so immature there is no point even discussing it. Its a bit like asking why do you like color blue, mature adults don't ask that and for kids you can say anything or nothing, same result. But I'll bite - if you decide to settle down with a partner you match with very well on tons of actually important stuff, including how your future together could look like while lacking any significant (yet known) drawbacks, and you want to raise kid(s) together, then the question is why not. Without the kids part, less reasons but why not. The inexperienced people (in my case immature kids/teens, I've answered similar but better formed question couple of times already) think its just a paper signed, and contractual obligations stemming from it. Far from it, at least for us. It changed our relationship, for the better, made it stronger and not only due to longer cancellation procedure. Do I have some peer-reviewed study for that? Of course not, just my personal 2 cents.
- ghusto 3y ago> Kearney's argument that children who grow up in unmarried households are fighting the odds has progressives miffed and accusing Kearney of stigmatizing single mothers I find this attitude applies to everything people don't want to hear. Anything that requires real change, effort, and difficulty seems to be met with anger and attack. It's so much easier to follow the accepted easy road of ignorance. > "I'm not prioritizing one. I'm just recognizing the data and the evidence and the reality." Good luck with that. People don't want data and evidence, they want to give their kids iPads at age 1 so they themselves can "have it all", they want to leave relationships the moment they realise compromise means not getting everything you want, they want to down pills to combat symptoms instead of working on where those symptoms are coming from.
- pixl97 3y agoThe issue I have with your take on this is one of, most likely, reverse causality. I may be making a bad guess, but if I had to I feel I would get the "If these women would just stay married like a traditional relationship demands, then all these problems go away" answer from you. Now, I'll also make an assumption that you are also going to have a hard time admitting that this is a multi-generational problem caused by male lead institutions treating women like second class citizens where they have massively unequal power. Add in a little equality and you can no longer treat your partner like an optionless slave.
- kbelder 3y agoImagining the ridiculous responses you would like your opponent to make does give you an opportunity to win arguments in your mind. I don't imagine that kind of intellectual self-pleasuring is really convincing many other people, though.
- pixl97 3y agoBecause of the nature of the issues that are occuring anyone over 30 typically isn't getting convinced. The people that are getting convinced are the younger generations of whoms general fertility rate is falling off a cliff.
- futureamish 3y agoSo we're not going to ask for the addresses of the people that created these circumstances because we really should.
- RecycledEle 3y agoSingle parents raising kids should be charged with child abuse. Get married before you engage in reproductive or recreational pseduo-reproductive activities. If your spouse does, find another widow(er) in the same spot and marry them for the kids. It's not that hard. People knew this 4,000 years ago.
- thoughtpalette 3y agoWhat an archaic way of thought. I can only hope you're not being serious.
- RecycledEle 3y agoHelping our children grow up to be successful adults is not archaic.
- thoughtpalette 3y agoPlenty of children raised by a single parent are successful.
- RecycledEle 3y agohttps://www.heritage.org/crime-and-justice/report/the-real-root-causes-violent-crime-the-breakdown-marriage-family-and https://www.heritage.org/crime-and-justice/report/the-real-r...
- giantrobot 3y agoHoly fucking shit. This is the Poe's Lawiest Poeslaw I've seen in a while.
- dragonwriter 3y agoThis is something of a useless article as a discussion point, since it discusses the conclusions the book argues for and the controversy, but not much of the actual argument, particularly its factual basis (assuming there is one) beyond post hoc ergo propter hoc. Its worth noting that this issue has been discussed for a long time, and while the article acts as if the promotion of marriage in the face of trends the other way on a “think about the children” basis was a novel suggestion of the author, this is not at all the case; it’s been suggested for decades, been the basis of vast amounts of unsuccessful, even at the “step one” of actually influencing the marriage trend, public policy at the state and federal level (the latter as far back as the 1996 Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act). And there has been lots of analysis suggesting that marriage, per se, is not driving most of the difference, but things like income and parenting style are [0], and that those correlate with propensity to marry (but are not themselves driven by marriage), so promoting marriage is likely barking up the wrong tree. [0] e.g., https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-marriage-effect-money-or-parenting/ https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-marriage-effect-money...
- foogazi 3y agoIs there any survivorship bias in looking at children of married couples? Whatever causes a non-marriage outcome for households didn’t happen to them: addiction, unemployment, disease, violence, etc Bad things didn’t happen = success The challenge for society is resiliency in avoiding bad outcomes in the face of bad situations
- stainablesteel 3y ago> Where are the dads? > One of the biggest issues is that women seem to be giving up on men, particularly those without college degrees this is about what i would expect from npr it has nothing to do with welfare starting in the 1960s where you can visibly see a breakup in families by incentivizing divorce, its.... college
- kleiba 3y agoIn contrast to your argument though, Europe has comparatively higher welfare across the board, but the US has the world's highest rate of children living in single-parent households.
- ls612 3y agoIn America single parents get more access to welfare programs than married ones so they are specifically incentivizing divorce. It isn’t a function of the welfare state level in general it’s this disparate incentive.
- rcxdude 3y agoIf that were the case wouldn't ypu see the correlation between long-term stability of the household and marriage to weaken? Since couples would be getting divorced but still living together if they were just doing it for the benefits.
- uoaei 3y agoIs this just a lazy version of the "welfare queen" argument? By all metrics it's cheaper to be married. Better tax benefits, lower housing and insurance costs when you bundle, etc.
- mvncleaninst 3y ago> By all metrics it's cheaper to be married. Better tax benefits, lower housing and insurance costs when you bundle, etc. yeah maybe if you do prenup it is
- jgalt212 3y agoThe Great Society incentivized single parent households, but you know these people were actually trying to help...
- Hgelo 3y agoEducation education and education. Good one of course. It's not hard. Really
- mvncleaninst 3y agoThese types of articles are doing the opposite of what they're trying to do. How exactly is framing marriage in purely economic terms supposed to encourage marriage? How is reducing people down to an income stream, a college diploma, genitalia, etc going to encourage marriage? Take this for example: > not because they reject the concept of marriage, but because they do not see him as a reliable source of economic security or stability. It's really disgusting what they're doing here. They don't talk about whether you love the other person, or whether you complement each other... no, they talk about economics. They talk about "what's good for me and my bank account" The tone of this article: it reads like it was written by a sociopath. You ask the author "why do people get married" and hear this stupid shit about economics and "benefits to society", nothing about love or trust or any of the actual reasons. People can't just get along for some reason, economics has to insert itself into everything and liquidate whatever trust and spontaneity it can find
- userinanother 3y agoBecause initial burst of love only lasts so long. After that it’s friendship, economics, co dependence and the other things that keep families working tougher as one unit
- bobbylarrybobby 3y agoInitial bursts by definition only last so long, but is it really so crazy to think that love might persist indefinitely?
- userinanother 3y agoYes, initial love and later love might be the same word but they mean different things. It’s a deficiency in our language and terminology
- caeril 3y ago[flagged]
- 3y ago
- rayiner 3y agoWe should do more social studies research into US subcultures that have significantly different marriage norms than the mainstream US. Mormons and Asians both have strong taboos against divorce, and also have strong rates of upward mobility (i.e. much higher odds of kids from low income households ending up as high earning adults). There is some research supporting the link, but not nearly enough: https://www.brookings.edu/articles/how-marriage-and-divorce-impact-economic-opportunity/ https://www.brookings.edu/articles/how-marriage-and-divorce-... (“A child born to a never-married mother in the bottom fifth of family income is 3 times more likely to stay in the bottom fifth than a child born to a continuously married mother with equally low income.”). It’s possible that it’s not marriage per se. Both Mormons and Asians socialize children into “do what you’re obliged to do, not what you want to do.” Marriage is one aspect of that—you get married, and you stay married, and what you “want” doesn’t really matter. But it might be that mentality that also drives upward mobility rather than marriage per se.
- curiousfiddler 3y agoBoth Mormons and Asians socialize children into “do what you’re obliged to do, not what you want to do.” Wow, that's incredibly reductive. Asia has approx 4.7 billion people!
- huytersd 3y agoHonestly, this thing holds true for most of them.
- DarknessFalls 3y agoHe said "US Mormons and Asians".
- squigz 3y agoTechnically, no, he didn't; note the period before Mormons
- tomjakubowski 3y ago
- cinntaile 3y agoInteresting that they're moving the other way. My impression has always been that there is a sort of social taboo on not getting married in the US when you have kids. Nice to see that finally changing.
- Racing0461 3y ago> Where are the dads? there we go. blaming men right off the bat.
- cvccvroomvroom 3y agoThe joke was there were so many single working people my age that the only people having kids were either the very poor or those making >$400k/yr. There's no way to meet anyone, so there's no point to think about it. Live life without worrying about it.
- ergl 3y agoAs someone from Europe, I can't understand the inability of mainstream US culture and media to disentangle marriage from long term stable relationships. Take this paragraph from the article: > More women are deciding to have children and also remain single. Almost half of all babies born in the U.S. were born to unmarried women in 2019, a dramatic increase since 1960, when only 5% of births were to unmarried mothers. And it's not because of divorce; today's unpartnered mothers are also more likely to have never been married. They go from "single" to "unmarried" back to "unpartnered" without batting an eye. The statistics they cite are about marriage yet they are generalized to all single women. It doesn't make sense. At least the author of the book is aware of this: > In the U.S., she says, unmarried adults who decide to live together do it for a much shorter duration than in Europe. [...] "If you just look in the data, marriage is what delivers kids a stable, long-term, two-parent household in this country." In my opinion looking into what's driving that difference between couples in the US and Europe would be worth a discussion on its own.
- inglor_cz 3y ago"In my opinion looking into what's driving that difference between couples in the US and Europe would be worth a discussion on its own." The problem is especially acute in the underclass, and American underclass differs a lot from European underclass. For example, a lot of the Western European poor are Muslims (in countries that keep the relevant statistics, Muslim immigrants and their descendants tend to score below average on income and educational outcomes), who are nevertheless socially very conservative and don't tend to have kids out of wedlock. Having kids out of wedlock is much more typical among secular Europeans, including highly educated ones. In the US, the trend leaders when it comes to having kids out of wedlock are the poorest parts of the population, mostly blacks, where "unmarried" and "unpartnered" tend to go hand-in-hand.
- cthalupa 3y agoI'm not really seeing any argument in the article that this is causation vs. correlation. I know there have been studies done on this, but even anecdotally, from the people I am aware of via Facebook, friends of friends, etc., the ones that are married or even just stable in their careers and life in general are all childless minus a few, whereas the ones that have had more turbulent lives have much higher rates of having children. My reading of the situation is that if you are born into a disadvantaged household, you are going to struggle to get ahead because of how the system works. I don't think marriage is going to suddenly solve that or make a significant impact - the people I know where the father isn't in the picture, their situation wouldn't be any better if he was, and for some, the situation would be worse. I suppose the book might do more to prove out a causal link but the reasoning in the article doesn't inspire enough confidence for me to chance investing the time reading it.
- RiOuseR 3y ago[dead]
- rcxdude 3y agoIt might be interesting to consider others who are involved in child-rearing as well. If the main predictor is having two parents stavly present, as opposed to marriage, it may be worth considering other ways in which this is accomplished. For example, by friends or family. I've considered becoming a parent and one thing that strongly factors in whether it would work is whether I would be able to have that kind of support network beyond my partner, as raising a kid even as two people seems like a lot of stress: but 4 people dividing the work of 4 kids is seems much easier. Traditionally family would be around to fulfill this kind of role, but both I and my partner live far from our relatives, so we would need to lean on our friends instead, and given how hard it is to make friends as an adult these days, let alone ones close enough to help with childcare, it seems that's an option which is available to few. Perhaps fixing that problem would also help with this one.
- sjducb 3y agoLeaning on friends to raise kids doesn’t really work. They’ll help out in an emergency, but they won’t babysit two days a week for free. The real work is done by blood relatives, aunts, uncles and grandparents or paid help. Mutual babysitting clubs are a form of paid help. I babysit for you and you babysit for me
- jiscariot 3y agoThe most disingenuous use of stats I see regularly published, are those bemoaning wealth inequality between ethnic and racial groups that don't control for family makeup. There is a 30+% difference between some groups on one vs. two parent households, but I guess that doesn't fit the right narrative an would presume people have some agency in their circumstances.