10 ms·
13 States join the IRS direct-file test after tax prep firms dropped the ball
- kvdveer 3y agoAs a citizen of a country where tax is handled entirely by the government, schemes where for-profit corporations are part of the tax collection infrastructure seems absurd. As absurd as for-profit courts or for-profit election polling stations. The article mentions that the tax software maker opposes the government doing this, but doesn't mention public opinion. What does the average American think about this?
- jsaintmything 3y agoDepending on how straight forward the IRS makes it, considering they already know what most people owe and yet still force us to jump through hoops, then I’d be willing to give it a go instead of paying a company to help me with my taxes or using one of the various “free” websites that usually just try to sell you something else.
- psunavy03 3y agoPart of the problem is that both parties have ended up making our tax code so convoluted as sops to their own special interest groups. Group A needs a tax break for this! Group B for that! And so if you have a bog-standard boring return, fine, but if your financial situation ends up in certain buckets such as renting out property, getting RSUs, etc., then sometimes it's cheaper to hire an accountant than leave money on the table not understanding your deductions. And then people in less-complicated situations get intimidated and think they need tax-prep software. Or they're lazy like me and use TurboTax so they can click through everything in an hour and be done with it.
- mnky9800n 3y agoThe tax code is complicated simply because wealthy people do not want to pay their fair share.
- samus 3y agoDepends on your definition of wealthy I guess. There are many tax exemptions that also affect less affluent people. There are simplified filing schemes, but one would leave a lot of money on the table using those.
- rayiner 3y agoHave you ever done your taxes? For individuals, it’s easier if you have a high income because many of the deductions and credits phase out and are capped by AGI. Dependent care FSA versus dependent care credits, student loan interest deductions, etc. Most of the questions the software asks you aren’t “Warren buffet” deductions.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIf you have high w-2 cash income. Once you get into equity or business income, it starts getting convoluted again.
- ghaff 3y agoOnce you get beyond W2 income, things get complex in a hurry. I don't think I have especially complicated income sources and deductions and I still end up with a half-inch sheaf of forms from my accountant every year. It's not actually a lot of work for me personally. I just need to make sure I've kept track of all the paperwork drifting in or downloaded and I have to write a fairly substantial check to my accountant.
- yonaguska 3y agoActual wealthy is living off investment income, not a W2. These are the people the complications are built for.
- rayiner 3y agoBut those complications don’t affect the average tax filer, which was OP’s theory.
- pid-1 3y agoMost countries have complicated tax codes. That's not a good reason for tax filling to be hard, unless the tax agency itself doesn't know how much a person should be paying.
- karmajunkie 3y agoi procrastinated on getting my tax paperwork together this year until an unbelievably late date. so i was kind of surprised to get a call from my tax guy on oct 16 letting me know my return was ready —they had just requested my transcripts from the irs, which had all my income from 2022 listed. so it would seem that a) for at least the nominal taxpayer, it’s entirely possible that the government has your information already; and b) unless i get back into consulting or otherwise complicate my income, my tax guy just set himself up to request those transcripts every year!
- knubie 3y ago> What does the average American think about this? That all depends on the government's execution. If they can deliver a system that is more convenient to use, cheaper (no, government services are not "free") and provides better results, then I'm all for it.
- AlexandrB 3y agoI'm pretty sure in this case it could be actually free since the government already collects and verifies all the required information.
- sokoloff 3y agoFree at point of use, but cannot possibly be free overall. If it would be free overall, it would take no time to develop or support and would already be rolled out.
- bell-cot 3y ago> What does the average American think about this? Like most problems, the average American has (for political purposes) ~zero mental engagement with this. Vs. those for-profit corporations (and a variety of other interest groups) are intensely engaged. And it's all-too-frequently reported that any politician who wants to be (re-)elected to America's Congress needs to be intensely engaged with wooing interest group support and campaign fundraising.
- vonwoodson 3y agoHere here! And, that is honestly the best. It’s why we have a republic and not a “pure democracy”. Nobody likes taxes, but other than having to interface with the system once a year… who cares? I can pay H&R Block $X or pay $Y more in taxes. Whoopie!
- bell-cot 3y ago/s, perhaps? Summed across the whole economy, the total $X being paid to America's "Tax-Industrial Complex" is vastly more than the total $Y that it'd cost to have an efficient government-run system.
- ghaff 3y agoI expect most of the people who spend substantial amounts of time/money on doing taxes in the US would spend substantial time/money on taxes in most other countries too--unless it's a country where a lot of people basically evade paying taxes at all.
- vonwoodson 3y ago“Tax-Industrial Conplex”?! If you had something to say, it’s now lost behind your rhetoric. "Eisenhower's farewell address to the nation" does not commute to H&R Block. This is a foolish misquote that absolutely reeks of an appeal to (false) authority. I also disagree that a new government tax program would be more efficient than the established market-rate tax preparation businesses. Let alone vastly more efficient. Magical thinking doesn’t help anyone solve anything.
- vonwoodson 3y agoIt’s very much a “who cares?” Issue. It’d be cool… but: taxes are still super easy to file for 90% of people. You’ve literally always been able to file your taxes by paper and not have to pay anyone anything to do so. It does not have to be a digital system and the government should not chase technical solutions unless it genuinely benefits its operation and legal requirement. If people want easy taxes then they can hire someone. That seems to be the market solution to most problems.
- mulmen 3y agoPaper forms are also a technology. Why should we use paper forms but not electronic forms? Presumably the IRS has embraced electronic computer technology internally and no longer does business only on paper.
- ryaneager 3y agoOr for-profit hospitals…
- mnky9800n 3y agoIn the 8 years since I lived in the United States my income taxes in other countries have been almost unbelievably easy. Typically I look at the calculated amount provided by a government website, compare it to what I think it should be if there is done discrepancy, upload some receipts or whatever for deductions, then click submit. It is beyond me why the experience should be any how different in the United States. And don't tell me, oh but there's 50 States which makes it complicated. I've lived in 5 countries in those years, four of which I had to pay taxes and every one was this easy.
- sdenton4 3y ago"And tax politics make strange bedfellows. Fighting alongside H&R Block and Intuit are anti-tax activist groups like Grover Norquist’s Americans for Tax Reform. H&R Block and Intuit love taxes—that’s how they make their money. Grover Norquist wants to cut taxes wherever possible. But on this issue, their interests are aligned. H&R Block and Intuit want to make it difficult for you to file on your own. The anti-tax activists think that if taxpaying is too easy, voters will be less likely to resist the federal government’s growth. Both want to make it as painful as possible for you to do your taxes yourself." https://www.politico.com/agenda/story/2018/07/18/tax-filing-congress-irs-000683/ https://www.politico.com/agenda/story/2018/07/18/tax-filing-...
- broken-kebab 3y agoUS taxes were pretty cumbersome before Intuit et al. Intuit wouldn't appear if not that. So your quote may partially explain resistance to change, but not causes.
- Retric 3y agoTaxes weren’t particularly difficult if like most people you were overpaying before this software showed up. The complexity was originally a way to effectively have different rules for people with accountants than regular citizens thus allowing politicians to shift the tax burden without making the carveouts obvious. Now days we just blatantly tax people living off investments less, etc. Thus defeating the original purpose of that complexity.
- andyjohnson0 3y agoNon-USian here. How does federal income tax work for people with a normal, regular job? If someone just works full time in a shop or on a factory line, do they get yearly tax demand that they have to check and/or calculate themself?
- ImPleadThe5th 3y agoWhen you get a new job, you fill out some forms that tells the government how much money to withhold from your paycheck based on your expected earnings, deductions, etc. Later, at the end of the year, you file your return of what you actually made, what your actual deductions were, etc. And then the government will either pay you if you paid too much or they will ask you to pay if you did not pay enough.
- andyjohnson0 3y agoThanks. Presumably such a person wouldn't need tax-return software? The system here in the UK is similar, except that "regular workers" don't file a tax return. Work-related deductions/additions (e.g. private health plans) are reported by the employer and are automatically accounted for. Non-work stuff like capital gains on personal property sales are mostly dealt with as part of the transaction.
- yurishimo 3y agoThe user you're replying to simplified the process some. There is no government website that will tell you exactly what you owe. You always are doing the math yourself and then hoping that you did the math correctly. Even for a refund, it's up to you to tell the government that you overpaid. The reason you might have heard a lot of fuss around hiring more IRS agents, is that the only way to validate these numbers if to be audited (broadly speaking). There might be some automated checks for very obvious things but much of the process is self-reported. The software is largely there to help people with the math and accounting for all of the deductions that the average person may be eligible for (mortgage interest being the largest and most common).
- 3y ago
- BrandoElFollito 3y agoWe have in France pre-filled taxes, you go to the tax site, click next a few times and you are done. Takes 30 seconds for 90% of the population. Usually people do not even check what they click if they have a standard job. Is the system in the US much more complicated to require software purchases? I get it that it is not prefilled, but is there a lot to actually input in the system?
- tuwtuwtuwtuw 3y agoSame here in Sweden. You can also just send a text message to confirm all is good as is.
- BrandoElFollito 3y agoStarting from this year I think that in France if you do not react then it is assumed that you completed your taxes as described in the tax sites. The rationale is that for the vast, vast, vast majority of people there is nothing to do so it does not make much sense to bother them at all. A lot of things changed when we finally moved to have taxes automatically deduced form the salary (before that you had to pay separately three times a year, and later you could make it a monthly payment). This means in practical terms zero contact wth your taxes when you are in the general situation.
- flandish 3y agoYes. We have to wait for forms to be mailed, or emailed, or avail. Download them or enter them in the tax website. Even though the fed already knows. Forms are things like: main employment, side jobs over 600, bank interest, car/house loan and tax payments, stocks, and other things. The forms are often not ready until late feb to mid march. Mid april is the filing deadline. Mind you - the gov already has copies of ALL the forms. They just want you to f it up.
- BrandoElFollito 3y agoAh OK. In our case the various sources of income have to provide the information to the tax authority, and this is summarized in the prefilled web form (that you approve by clicking submit). Now, it is your responsibility to make sure that all of the sources are indeed there but for normal people it is the salary only. It happened to me once that one source was missing and I was not happy at all (but said source provided me pronto with what to put where in the form). Overall I would say that our tax system is complicated (as all trax systems) but made really simple for average people. Also we do not have any companies such as yours that would provide software to make your taxes. If you want some help you can either contact a specialized finance person (this usually costs 200€ and is useful only if your case is really complicated) or you have free help areas at town halls (mairies). Or clear directions from the providers. But as I said, it is for a select population, not for the everyday Joe who just clicks three times. There was even national ads on the radio about that.
- somewhereoutth 3y agoDoes 'direct file' mean you won't have to post (by registered mail) your physical tax form to the IRS? That would be the biggest win surely (although huge loss for USPS)
- ss1996 3y agoJust curious, why are you still sending physical tax forms? Have you been filing 1040NR? Those were recently digitalized, while the standard 1040 has been digital since a while.
- creer 3y agoThe issue is not the mere form 1040. Many taxpayers have to provide several to many other forms. But besides that, the reason for printing and mailing is that the IRS seems to have focused on either tax prep software company interfaces to the IRS (the tax prep software submits), or fill out - esign - encrypt/hash/protect - submit in their own web-based workflows. In the cases they provide for, there is essentially no provision for adjusting the form to your needs or attaching statements (notes in your own format). And attached statements are very often required. In particular the IRS refuses to let us upload a PDF or other images of filled out forms. Or email them. Such a submission could then take the exact same path as the forms they receive by mail - doesn't seem too hard - but no, we can't do that. Some departments at IRS/Treasury insist on a fax interface. As the main alternative to mailing paper. At least in this case I can use a (not exactly safe) PDF to fax gateway to get on with my life.
- karmajunkie 3y agothat’s not a thing for most people —registered mail is not necessary, even when physical forms ARE submitted, and the “Direct” part means directly with the IRS (no middleman). But the Direct File program is electronic so the answer to your question is yes.
- coldpie 3y agoYou haven't had to do this for years & years. The IRS provides an online form for all the paperwork. Type all your stuff in and hit Submit, for free. AFAIK it should work for pretty much all tax situations, all the forms are in there. https://www.irs.gov/e-file-providers/free-file-fillable-forms https://www.irs.gov/e-file-providers/free-file-fillable-form...
- jmclnx 3y agoI think I will pass this trial for now. I knew a high-level programmer who worked at the IRS and he was very good. But the bureaucracy was overwhelming. Given enough time then sure, but now, no thank you. But if the IRS wants to use my returns as a test case, I say go for it.
- AnimalMuppet 3y ago> Arizona, California, Massachusetts and New York have decided to work with the IRS to integrate their state taxes into the Direct File pilot for filing season 2024. Taxpayers in nine other states without an income tax – Alaska, Florida, New Hampshire, Nevada, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington and Wyoming -- may also be eligible to participate in the pilot. Washington has also chosen to join the integration effort for the state's application of the Working Families Tax Credit. All states were invited to join the pilot, but not all states were in a position to join the pilot at this time. Since the article didn't bother to list the states, as far as I could see... From https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-advances-innovative-direct-file-project-for-2024-tax-season-free-irs-run-pilot-option-projected-to-be-available-for-eligible-taxpayers-in-13-states https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-advances-innovative-direct-..., which is linked by the article.
- gumby 3y agoI love the quote from the Intuit VP, which complained that it would end up “costing billions of dollars in taxpayer money.” The current system costs billions of dollars in taxpayer money, it’s just that today those dollars flow to Intuit. The IRS one should end up costing less overall, even at govt contracting rates.
- toomuchtodo 3y ago“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.” ― Upton Sinclair
- jancsika 3y agoGoing further-- if the company depends on it, then the man already understands it.
- gumby 3y agoIn this case I’m pretty sure it’s simply his job to say such things and who knows what he actually believes. But sure, it’s likely that he would vote against a candidate who supported the IRS’s program.
- fwungy 3y agoThis is the most important quote for the modern era.
- wredue 3y agoThe IRS taking this on this way has incentive to automate and make taxes as easy as possible. Intuits incentive is to keep taxes complicated and as manual as possible. Therefore, the most likely outcome is that the IRS taking this on will most assuredly result in saving tax payer money.
- fwungy 3y agoSimple, relatively high, taxes for the plebs and a complex, exploitable tax code for the rich. There's no need for wagies with low net worths to go through the full process.
- clubm8 3y ago[flagged]
- spandextwins 3y agoA value added tax on goods would be good, then we wouldn't have to file taxes at all. Or just get rid of federal income taxes all together like they did around 100 years ago.
- yohannparis 3y agoConsumption is not the only way to levy taxes.
- MrRadar 3y agoLow income individuals spend a far greater share of their income on goods that would be subject to VAT than high-income individuals. Eliminating income tax would shift the burden of paying for government even more to the people who can least afford it. Ideally, taxation should be a mechanism that redistributes wealth within society to be more equitable which ultimately benefits everyone, even the wealthy, by increasing overall economic growth. Income tax is a very good mechanism to achieve that goal (though definitely not perfect) and I agree with Thomas Piketty that we should add a small wealth tax on the very wealthiest individuals.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 3y agoPrevious: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37920633 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37920633
- Ographer 3y agoThe TurboTax CEO called this direct file test, "a solution and search of a problem." That is pretty ironic because TurboTax is working to prolong the problem in order to profit from their own solution.
- username3 3y agoTax prep firms should market themselves as software to audit automated IRS tax calculations.
- INTPenis 3y agoThis federal government thing is really confusing to me as a european. Like the federal government can come to California and shutdown a cannabis dispensary, but they can't make you use an easier way to file your taxes.
- dudul 3y agoEven in Europe, countries have several levels of administration/government. Cities, regions, districts, whatever. The national government is not all powerful.
- ac29 3y agoRe: the cannabis situation - the closest European analogy would be Amsterdam or Christiania. Cannabis sales are not legal in those countries, but some sales are tolerated in specific areas. California isnt too much different - it is illegal in the United States to sell cannabis, but the federal government mostly tolerates it in states that permit sales.
- INTPenis 3y agoYeah christiania is great and all but incidentally I've been going to christiania for almost as long as we've been able to file our taxes online with a button. (20 years)
- shinjitsu 3y agoNow if only they could do something like this for states. Some of the high pop high tax states are far worse to file for than the feds.
- trident5000 3y agoJust have a sales tax and an inheritance tax and forget collecting taxes from millions of people every year.
- instagib 3y agoAccording to the IRS, these are the states joining the pilot: States with state income tax: Arizona, California, Massachusetts, and New York States without state income tax: Alaska, Florida, New Hampshire, Nevada, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington, and Wyoming