7 ms·
Goldman Sachs reportedly said Apple Card savings account was a mistake
- hprotagonist 3y agotough noogies, give me that sweet 4.15% APY.
- akashshah87 3y ago>> as all cardholders get their bills on the same date, giving customer service reps a huge peak in workload. A real world manifestation of the thundering herd problem
- reneherse 3y agoSounds like a great use case for AI-based customer service
- datavirtue 3y agoThe UI and the repayment scheme for that cards' promotions and servicing is ridiculously confusing. I ended up in arrears due to Goldmans shitty servicing methods and had no idea how until I contacted customer service. I had been making larger than required payments and could not fathom why my card was being disabled. These guys should have brought people in who know what they are doing. Instead it looks like they clumsily let Apple dictate some requirements and were not able to guide product development properly due to their own inexperience. Blind leading the blind. I have familiarity with another payment product Apple launched with another shaky partner. The problems there were mostly technical though, since the company had vast servicing experience and could competently guide that part of product development. Apple really should create a consumer Fintech division that can do implementation. They might be steering clear of that due to the GE case study. They don't need to be or own a bank but their presence and size would likely be an outsized portion of the business in most banks that would take them on as a partner. Setting up a bank and running a consumer facing product (Fintech) are two different projects altogether. Two different modules, if you will. I also witnessed MasterCard falter when entering a consumer market they had not played in before. Very ugly. I think Apple keeps approaching perceived industry leaders and keeps getting bad advice. A better choice might be to recruit talent from smaller Fintechs where the people are intimate with the real world challenges and turn them loose.
- paulmd 3y ago> I also witnessed MasterCard falter when entering a consumer market they had not played in before. Very ugly. not sure if this is what you're thinking of, but it's been crazy to think of all the payment-processor systems the CC networks have launched that have tried and failed to compete with paypal. I swear every 3-4 years we have some new thing from mastercard or visa, they do a bunch of promos at newegg/etc where you can get $10/$20 off if you sign up for an account/etc, and then after the promo funding dries up they just wither away to dust. I swear this has happened at least 3-4 times now.
- tiltowait 3y agoI'm not sure what's confusing about the Apple Card's payment screen? It's a dial with clear markings for how much interest you'll pay at various points, and it strongly encourages paying off the balance so you'll pay zero interest. The UI is, IMO, the best part of the service. It's lightyears beyond every other card I've used.
- M5x7wI3CmbEem10 3y agowhy not a supply-chain related phenomenon such as cyclical demand?
- gjsman-1000 3y agoHilarious. "We're Goldman Sachs, we can totally out-negotiate Apple when it comes to finances."
- trident5000 3y agoThis has nothing to do with the situation.
- paulmd 3y agoApple is always "the hot girl in the relationship". They are giving you the opportunity to be a supplier to apple, with massive volume, and they expect cut-throat pricing, a high level of QC (no chinese factory fuck-fuck games with "impromptu cost reduction"), and absolute supply-chain reliability. It is just like Walmart and Costco, they are big enough that they can dictate the terms of the relationship, and they do so aggressively. And just like walmart, in the long term this can mean that you have a single monopsony buyer who dominates your business and can ratchet you down even more over time. goldman didn't realize what they were getting into here, they figured they could put one over on Tim Apple and no, the fruit company always comes out on top. on top of that, apple really also kinda has a track record of using their market power to go to bat for consumers (app review/permissioning being one example, also user-privacy on MDM'd apple devices in the quasi-workplace being a focus, etc). And in this case they set up a bunch of terms that tend to reduce the fee stream that CC providers normally extract, pay the rewards daily, etc. Apple undoubtedly knew exactly what they were negotiating for etc, and goldman didn't realize how much those things were going to cost them (in lost fees). So yeah, goldman thought they were the big man on campus and apple took them to the cleaners.
- trident5000 3y agoThe issue as stated in the article that I'm pretty sure nobody actually read, is that consumer finance is a logistical nightmare they wernt prepared for. It had nothing to do with Apple.
- dclaw 3y agoThis is hilarious, but I am genuinely concerned about Goldman Sachs dropping Apple and the cc and savings account ending up with a shittier bank.
- next_xibalba 3y agoApple could just start their own bank. Apple’s wealth, power, and brand allure should alleviate some of your concerns. They will find a willing partner who will uphold their offering.
- petesergeant 3y ago> start their own bank My understanding is that it's much easier to buy one than start one
- adocomplete 3y agoGS Market Cap is only $100b. Do it Apple.
- flenserboy 3y agoOnly if they make sure none of the GS execs get their claws into Apple management. Best to cut them all loose immediately.
- bombcar 3y agoApple could buy Goldman Sachs with cash-on-hand and some stock. I'm sure they can find a smaller bank for cheap-as-free.
- FredPret 3y agoI looked into this - Apple actually only has $62B in equity in their business - $332B in assets and $270B in liabilities. [valustox.com/AAPL] GS is worth $100B and has $116B in equity. [valustox.com/GS] Of course, Apple has a market cap of 2.8T and could buy GS 28 times over using shares, but that involves diluting shareholders to fund this new venture. On the other hand, that might be a great new revenue driver for Apple since everyone already has a phone - I bet they could be a bigger, better bank than the big banks. Even JP Morgan, the biggest US bank, has a market cap of $435B [valustox.com/JPM].
- karaterobot 3y agoKnowing that it's costing Goldman billions of dollars is a really strong selling point for the Apple savings account. Apple should consider just putting that in an ad.
- garba_dlm 3y agobut it also means that Apple is the new Goldman similarly to google turning into "internet microsoft" and microsoft turned into ibm.....
- paxys 3y agoKnowing that the account will be handed off to another unknown party once Goldman ends the contract is definitely not a selling point.
- renewiltord 3y agoIt’s a bank account, not a home. You can switch in maybe 30 mins of work if you want to go to a different mainstream bank and 1 hr of work split over two days if you have an esoteric bank. Switched my wife off this two weeks ago into our shared HYSA.
- dewey 3y agoMaybe it works differently where you are from, but here (EU) there's usually a bunch of companies taking money out of your account via SEPA or transferring money to your account (salary). This is usually rent, power, water companies etc. so it's not that quick to switch as you'll have to update your bank credentials everywhere. Depending on how much you use the account that might be a lot of work and it's not "30 minutes of work".
- jwells89 3y agoIn the US most things are best paid with a credit card except for the biggest costs because it’s considered a liability to spread bank account info around too much (banks generally aren’t too helpful when a breach occurs, whereas credit card companies will happily wipe away fraudulent charges), plus you’re missing out on points. The only thing I had to change over when switching checking and savings to a different bank was which checking account my mortgage payments were getting pulled from.
- adocomplete 3y agoThey weren't happy with the Apple credit card either, yet still went ahead with the savings account. Seems self-inflicted.
- xyst 3y agoSo the more I use the Apple Card, pay it off in full. The more GS is in the hole? Also an additional fu if I deposit more money into the savings account since they have to invest that money to guarantee the interest rate. Lol I love it. The savings account is offering 4.15% right now. Might move $10K into account just as a small fu to the GS executives.
- xyzelement 3y agoIn my experience, giving a company more business (not to mention, straight up cash!) is seldom an FU :) The above article is kinda slim on why this is bad for GS but the sense that I got from clicking one link down is that the concrete thing is their 'platform' business has not recouped its investment. As in, they paid a bunch of people, paid for a bunch of integrations, etc and aren't generating sufficient offsetting revenue. Given how cards and accounts work, I suspect the incremental margin on a given CUSTOMER is positive. So yes, I think they would be happy to get the merchant fees off of your increased Credit Card spending and to enjoy the spread between your 4.15% and whatever they invest in which presumably pays more.
- datavirtue 3y agoHopefully it's invested in some type of insurance company, and in that case the spread is likely 1%. I would think the investment would have to be a guaranteed return.
- xyzelement 3y agoNot sure why that's "hopefully" - if you like getting the rate GS pays you, you want it to be sustainable for them and therefore for you. In practice - I forget the details - but it works in the other direction. The bank sets the rate it pays YOU based on a combination of what it can make elsewhere and how badly they want to get your money to fund that investment. Unless GS is somehow forced by their deal with Apple to pay out more than they can make (I see no evidence of that in the article) you'd expect this is how they operate.
- 3y ago
- schnable 3y agoWhere do the losses come from? Paying interest? Why can't GS learn to bank?
- bombcar 3y agoGS is not a consumer bank, and they're trying to play as a consumer bank, and they didn't just buy a consumer bank. You don't know what you don't know until you try, and they got burned. I'm sure that they always have done "consumer bank-like stuff" but it's more like a favor to their big customers than an actual business, kind of like when a business that doesn't offer delivery will still drive stuff over to the owner's house. And someone sold someone the bill of goods that Apple customers are "so perfect" and "high value" that the customer service will be absolutely minimal ...
- tiltowait 3y agoArticle from February, but things probably haven't changed much: https://9to5mac.com/2023/02/16/apple-card-future-goldmans-sachs-losses/ https://9to5mac.com/2023/02/16/apple-card-future-goldmans-sa...
- anon1199022 3y agoBeating investment bankers in their own game must feel amazing :) Maybe board should lower the teams that made the decision. How hard it can be create a model and calculate. Apple is better at Finance than GS.
- xyzelement 3y agoWho is "beating" someone here? In adult reality, Apple are likely "concerned" rather than "feel amazing" if this isn't sustainable for their strategic partner. If your wife is miserable, you'd be dumb to think "I am better at marriage than she is" because eventually it's going to end. Also. Businesses make bets. GS made a bet on consumer finance and on this deal in particular. You hope that every bet will work out, you know some won't and that's fine as long as you have more wins than losses. GS seems fine holistically so seems like they are taking a calculated amount of risk.
- anon1199022 3y agoAre we talking about GS that has direct access to money printer and cheaper credit so they have certain revenue and profit no matter what? In the other hand, Apple creates hardware and software with real world risk. Supply chain risk etc. They are not like they can just manipulate markets to make billions for their staff. That game.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIf your premise were true, then why would their net income ever decrease? https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/GS/goldman-sachs/net-income https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/GS/goldman-sachs/n... I would bet Apple's profits are far more resilient than Goldman's.
- anon1199022 3y agoNet income can be volatile, just like the stock market? They can never go out of business with direct money printer support. They have very minimal risk compared to even lower banks. That privilege applies to very few at top. Whether people realize it or not. After Lehman, things changed. Apple makes their profit with actually creating products and innovation. GS no. read here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systemically_important_financial_institution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systemically_important_financi...
- naillo 3y agoGreat bit of streisand effect advertising to look into getting an Apple Card savings account. Too bad it's not available in europe.
- traviswingo 3y agoInteresting. The APY on savings accounts is only 4.15%. The spread between that and short term T bills is over 1%. My main HYSA is paying me 5.30% APY currently, and they aren’t complaining. A 1-1.5% spread on customer cash should be celebrated by GS…
- iends 3y agoIs there another “too big to fail” bank offering similar rates for savings accounts? Most high yield savings accounts are regional banks.
- queuebert 3y agoAlly and Interactive Brokers both offer those rates, and they are in the $5-9 billion market cap range. Not sure if they qualify as too big to fail.
- johng 3y agoWealthfront has high percentages right now.
- iends 3y agoWealthfront is not a bank, they use a bunch of small banks: https://www.wealthfront.com/cash-account-participant-banks https://www.wealthfront.com/cash-account-participant-banks
- prh8 3y agoAmex is at 4.3 now
- lotsofpulp 3y agoBoA offers 5.02% via their "Preferred Deposit" offering: https://olui2.fs.ml.com/Publish/Content/application/pdf/GWMOL/ICCRateSheet.pdf https://olui2.fs.ml.com/Publish/Content/application/pdf/GWMO... But you have to start with $100k. (You can decrease that to as low as $1 anytime after though).
- gonehome 3y agoThe Apple Card is a great credit card for people that aren't optimizing points for travel (most regular people). The software is solid and Apple prevents them from reselling your data to third parties. The cash back is super easy to use and visible (and the extra percentage on Apple purchases is a nice bonus). I have some cards I use for perks (Amex Plat/Gold, United Club, used to have Chase Sapphire Reserve) but I used the Apple Card as my sole card for a while and I kind of miss the simplicity of it. With Amex I feel like I'm fighting against an Army of Amex employees trying to make it as hard as possible for me to use the card's perks where as with Apple I feel like they're genuinely trying to make the software usable for me, the incentives are more aligned. Every time I have to use Amex's site to 'enable' a perk and then read the fine print to make sure I actually get the benefit it makes me angry at some invisible product manager that hates customers.
- bombcar 3y agoIt is really nice once you give up trying to min/max rewards. And some of the issues are kind of self inflicted - the "always monthly on the nose" isn't a feature I really need, and I would actually prefer to offset that by a few days, so if they offered that as a feature I'd take advantage of it.
- sdfghswe 3y agoSo why did you stop using it?
- gonehome 3y agoI still use it, I just started traveling way more so lounge access was nice. Then once I had the travel cards I started using them to see if I could optimize their perks.
- wombat-man 3y agoYeah, I just can't spend my time on that stuff. I got a card that just gives me 2% on everything and I'm calling it a day. no fee. Airport lounges sound cool, my friends sometimes get a deal on travel/hotel. But they also can't use points in some situations for weird reasons. Another uses a spreadsheet to optimize his poins. I just can't devote that kind of time to that stuff.
- mikpanko 3y agoHow exactly is Goldman Sachs losing $1-2B here compared to regular consumer banks, which don’t? The article mentions having to deal with all accounts having monthly close on the same day, but it can’t be the whole reason.
- 2Gkashmiri 3y agoi guess they have minions who manually have to sign off on each of the accounts every month because policy
- YeBanKo 3y agoTo me seems like this whining is a part of negotiating tactics by GS.
- bjord 3y agoSee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37901647 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37901647 "This is completely unsurprising. The way banks make money on consumer credit cards is primarily through interest and fees, which primarily take advantage of people who are not financially literate. They also take intentional dark UX choices to ensure that collecting on fees or interest is much more likely. Meanwhile, Apple Card had such high eligibility requirements (I got denied the first time I replied and I'm a HENRY tech worker with an 812 credit score) that the vast majority of the customers in the program are exactly the type of people who are high earning and responsible enough with money to pay the card off each month to avoid interest and fees. Apple made it a step further due to the integration into Wallet that allows you to easily track spending and ensure you can trigger payments in a way to avoid interest. As a consumer, I love Apple Card, because it makes it simple to get base cash back and ensure I never get charged interest. Clearly it's a bad deal for Goldman Sachs, but I don't have any tears to shed for them."
- elteto 3y agoCan’t really believe the $1-2B figure. I would guess this figure is inflated and the real problem is that GS is unhappy with something in the current arrangement and they are publicly signaling so to Apple.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoIf vampires are against it, it might be good?
- tristor 3y agoThis is completely unsurprising. The way banks make money on consumer credit cards is primarily through interest and fees, which primarily take advantage of people who are not financially literate. They also make intentional dark UX choices to ensure that collecting on fees or interest is much more likely. Meanwhile, Apple Card had such high eligibility requirements (I got denied the first time I applied and I'm a HENRY tech worker with an 812 credit score) that the vast majority of the customers in the program are exactly the type of people who are high earning and responsible enough with money to pay the card off each month to avoid interest and fees. Apple made it a step further due to the integration into Wallet that allows you to easily track spending and ensure you can trigger payments in a way to avoid interest. As a consumer, I love Apple Card, because it makes it simple to get base cash back and ensure I never get charged interest. Clearly it's a bad deal for Goldman Sachs, but I don't have any tears to shed for them.
- trevortheblack 3y agoApologies to ask off topic question, but what is HENRY? I've never heard of this before.
- denial 3y agoHigh earner, not rich yet.
- sulam 3y agoHigh Earner, Not Rich Yet Many of whom never become rich because they spend money as fast as they earn it.
- ASinclair 3y agoHigh Earner, Not Rich Yet. So high income but relatively low net worth.
- tristor 3y agoHENRY = High Earner, Not Rich Yet It is mostly older Millenials/Xennials with professional jobs. They earn more than 2x the national median income, but have a net worth that's less than 3x their income or $1M (whichever is larger).
- paxys 3y agoGoldman played the tech startup game to launch its consumer banking division and is now finding out what happens when there aren't any VCs or retail investors to pass the bag to. They poured billions into user acquisition and signing sweetheart deals with companies like Apple without caring about how they will eventually make a profit. But surely they will make up for it in volume right? Would have been so much easier if they bought a smaller fully-operational bank and rebranded it.
- datavirtue 3y agoOk, that would take care of the bank. You still need to build the servicing company, which is the part they seemed to have fucked up.
- kaycebasques 3y agoIf Apple took on more of this business themselves then equity markets would probably see it as a bad sign, yes? I recall that conglomerates have a bit of a bad rap. Also, if GS is struggling with this business then it would probably be even more difficult for a computer company, yes?
- prewett 3y agoBanking isn't exactly Apple's core competency. I would regard it as diworsification, for sure.
- Scubabear68 3y agoThis article is interesting because it is claiming Goldman is hating on its consumer businesses, but meanwhile its Marcus division seems to be doing well. I use it for both savings and loans and it is very convenient, and they are pretty aggressive in marketing it. Is it really all consumer facing activity, or just the Apple portion?
- jeffbee 3y agoWhat are some visible indications that Marcus is doing any better?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Scubabear68 3y agohttps://www.reuters.com/breakingviews/goldmans-marcus-is-lesson-self-made-failure-2023-02-02/ https://www.reuters.com/breakingviews/goldmans-marcus-is-les... Apparently Marcus has been a failure too. I had no idea.
- fdye 3y agoHonestly, I feel like this is another bi-product of 0% interest rates for so long. Bankers have essentially stopped caring at all about deposit amounts. Many banks still offer 0.x% interest even with most T-bills paying 5%+. It is an odd position from something that should be easy business, receive billions in deposits, invest in 6 month T-bills, carve off 0.5-1% of the profit amount for yourself, profit? I'm convinced this is less about them actually losing money and more about them having sour grapes about not making 100x or something. Like the credit card is losing money when it is immensely popular and charges like 18% interest, HOW?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoLots of banks have offered very competitive interest rates for a long time now. https://www.doctorofcredit.com/high-interest-savings-to-get/ https://www.doctorofcredit.com/high-interest-savings-to-get/ Bigger banks are simply betting that people will not go through the trouble of moving their money.
- Sohcahtoa82 3y ago> Bigger banks are simply betting that people will not go through the trouble of moving their money. This applies even at smaller banks that don't make savings account their primary product. Like, my credit union offers 0.1 - 0.9% savings accounts depending on your balance. With a $250,000 balance, you qualify for some Premier savings account with 4.8%. I said screw it. I created an account somewhere else that gives over 5%. Yeah, it means my money might take a couple days for me to get if it I absolutely need it, but I can't imagine a scenario where that would be a problem that my credit card can't take care of.
- tootie 3y agoFrom what I've read GS's entire consumer division has been a giant money pit. They accumulated an impressive about of loans in a very short time, but haven't turned a profit after sinking hundreds of millions into development and acquisitions.
- jglashdkfgh 3y agoI had an Apple Card for two months. It was the worst card I've ever used. It was rejected for ~5% of all transactions, randomly, online and in person, always with error codes no one could diagnose or correct. All I could do was call Goldman Sachs, who would tell me to try swiping it again, huh, that should have worked, we don't see any record of a transaction ever being attempted, and after half an hour with them they would tell me to call Apple and after an hour on the phone with Apple they would tell me it was Goldman Sachs' fault. I had more rejected transactions with my Apple Card than with every other debit/credit card I've ever had in the previous twenty years combined. Total crap, and completely incompetent, irresponsible "support". I cancelled it and went back to my bank cards.
- moomoo11 3y agoApple Card is great. These days I just carry two cards. Amazon prime card for obvious reason. For everything else (irl stuff) I use my Apple Card. I don’t travel - I prefer airbnb - I don’t eat out that much. So I just don’t need points anymore for anything else.