15 ms·
Visualizing American inflation across eight categories
- pton_xd 3y agoAccording to the article, $1 in housing in 1999 is equivalent to $1.86 today. That's... incredibly hard to believe. The Case Shiller is up over 300% for the same time period. And $1 in food is $1.84 today? I don't have an index to reference, but also hard to believe.
- kfarr 3y agoI think they are saying you’d need $1.86 of today’s money spent on housing to be equivalent to $1 spent on housing in 99?
- quirino 3y agoI think the parent commenter understands this part, they're just saying they think the values are actually much higher
- cstejerean 3y agoThat's the hard to believe part, it would imply housing costs on average are only up by 86%, but that doesn't seem to be anywhere near accurate in at least large parts of the country (all the ones I looked at least when we considered moving).
- ls612 3y agoNot everywhere has had the same housing problems SF and NYC have had.
- quickthrower2 3y agoThat there exists a cheap house in a rural area doesn’t help most people who need a job. For them inflation is higher.
- ls612 3y agoPlenty of non-NYC/SF major metro areas (>1mm people) with far lower housing inflation than those cities. No need to be rural.
- eloisant 3y agoThis is true, but the question is not whether it helps or not but if the 86% increase is the right number or not. Yes inflation was higher in big cities.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoFar more than SF and NYC have had housing prices more than double over the last 20 years. Hell, doubling over that timeframe would barely be over 3% inflation.
- paulpauper 3y agobut maybe this is true if you factor in cheaper mortgages, lower rates . financing options were worse in 1999 vs 2019. Homes were very cheap in 1970 but way harder to get a good mortgage, too. much more was paid upfront.
- quickthrower2 3y agothis is the boomer retort. something Kirsty Allsopp might say for example. But: would you rather buy say a car for $100k interest free or $10k at 10% interest?
- gtowey 3y agoAgreed. Everything is at least a solid 30% more expensive than just 2020. Food has gotten insanely expensive in that time. Anecdotally, I can remember a burger at a restaurant was about $6 in 1999. Now average seems to be 15 to 20. I would believe that everything is about 3x the price from 20 years ago. This chart seems to say the average is less than 2x which I don't agree with.
- smelendez 3y agoRestaurant and packaged food (e.g., cookies, frozen meals) prices up an average 30% since 2020 is what I usually think too, but I also think bargains have disappeared, which is probably harder to capture. It feels like far fewer restaurants have lunch specials than in 2020, for instance, and a lot of cheap restaurants have either raised prices to the norm or closed. Bars and casinos having discounted or free food to get you to drink has gone out the window (even where legal). And looking back 20 years, it feels like far fewer restaurants have small and simple orders available. For instance, you used to be able to go into a diner or other casual restaurant and get a hamburger or other sandwich with no fries or side. That’s harder to find now. So is cheap, unremarkable coffee and cheap breakfast items, like small pastries or two-egg plates. Similarly, it’s harder to find a small car, a house or apartment without central air, a 15 inch TV (though TVs have gotten cheaper), etc.
- paulpauper 3y agoyeah, people are being forced to buy features or addons, which adds to the cost. this is another way to pass on inflation to the consumer marketed as a 'good deal', when it isn't. instead of an economical small car, you have to buy a bigger car which gets worse mileage and full of unwanted stuff.
- jclardy 3y agoYeah - I distinctly remember back in 2006-2007 (My early college days) getting a 2 for $2 deal at McDonalds - 2 bacon, egg and cheese biscuits for $2. Now one biscuit (normally) is $3.89 and they run 2 for $5 specials, but seemingly way less often. Back in the day, the special was ran literally all the time, but even still the cost of the biscuit was under $2. And this is 7 years past 1999. The Big Mac Index shows the price of a big mac in 2000 at $2.24, and now at $5.58, so that would put $1 in 2000 at $2.49 in 2020 which feels a lot closer to the actual number...but still low because everything "around" the entree has also increased similarly, if not more.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoThe graph is referencing the Consumer Price Index. I think that the official inflation numbers given are low to the point of absurdity. Time to dust off criticisms of the CPI... Most likely, no doubt, there's some political deflation of the numbers.
- kleton 3y agoCPI allows substitutions. So where the basket in 1999 included beef, now it probably only includes chicken.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoDoes it allow substitutions for country of origin? What if it was primarily US-made goods, but now reflects lower-cost imports?
- pton_xd 3y agoAnd, according to the article "the CPI does not directly measure the prices of investments like stocks or the purchase price of homes." So they have a category called "Housing" which presumably does not include the price of a home. Very informative and helpful infographic.
- snapplebobapple 3y agoIts owners equivalent rent i believe, which makes sense academically but not practically. When you are using it to gauge whether your monetary policy is causing inflation you should be looking at asset prices at least as hard as consumable prices and you shiuld be extremely wary doing substitutions.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoIt counts the cost of rent. If you buy a house for far more than the value of rent, you are making a speculative investment. Rent is half my mortgage for an equivalent house. It wouldn't be realistic to call my mortgage the cost of shelter.
- medvezhenok 3y agoI think that’s actually the big problem with the CPI - it treats a house purchase as a speculative investment, rather than a separate category of housing on equal footing with rent. I think the median housing payment (mortgage + interest) should be included in the CPI. As someone who is looking to start a family, renting vs owning is not simply a financial question, they are totally different goods which are not interchangeable
- armchairhacker 3y agoThese "price comparisons" really need to be divided into specific categories. $1 from 1999 would be worth a lot more for buying a house, since house prices have gone up insane. $1 from 1999 would be worth much less for technology: a modern-day phone would be essentially priceless, but if you only care about specs, it could be replicated in a supercomputer, albeit for >$100 million (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21977330 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21977330) Even within a category it depends: certain food items (junk food) seem to have gone up in price considerably more than others.
- fooker 3y ago>These "price comparisons" really need to be divided into specific categories. Not it doesn't. This is the primary difference between liquid and non-liquid assets.
- CapricornNoble 3y agoI saw a YT vid that referenced a research paper that used a particular basket of goods to define the quality of life for a peasant in the Roman Empire. I think the trick is to build your personal consumption basket for essential unchanging goods and use that for comparison. Certain things like the types of food I eat have been reasonably consistent over the past 20 years. So something like "how many calories & grams of protein could I buy in 2003 vs 2023", and then compare that my hypothetical wage growth over that timeframe. Or wow much is a quart of oil? I needed to do oil changes 20 years ago, and still do my own today, etc...
- nickjj 3y ago> $1 from 1999 would be worth much less for technology This is expected given technology is advancing but pricing hasn't changed much if you factor in relative costs to relative performance / outcomes. For example in 1999-2000 you could have gotten a really solid machine capable of playing Quake 3 (the latest and greatest FPS game of that time) getting a rock solid 125 fps on a CRT monitor capable of doing 120hz for around $650-700. Realistically a solid machine nowadays with a mid-grade GPU is likely going to run you $1,000 to $1,200 and that could easily be more if you wanted a higher end GPU. All in all you're talking about a little under double the price which is roughly what an inflation calculator says (1.85x) for the same relative outcome.
- 4death4 3y agoReal estate prices are only indirectly included in CPI via owner-equivalent rent. Really, CPI is a joke for measuring broad inflation. It measures a specific basket of goods. Treating that basket of goods as the true value of the dollar is absurd.
- userinanother 3y agoCPI is ok for specific categories but the basket weighting is absolutely trash. That being said somehow healthcare indexing got messed up and it was down significantly which is silly because healthcare never goes down
- em500 3y agoThis is the current basket weighting: https://www.bls.gov/cpi/tables/relative-importance/2022.htm https://www.bls.gov/cpi/tables/relative-importance/2022.htm Which should be changed, under the constraint that they must sum to 100?
- userinanother 3y agoMedical care should be weighted at 20-30% to reflect how much of a burden it’s become. Childcare is severely underweighted as well. Housing is underweighted in rents and overweighted in owner equivalent rent. Those are just the obvious ones
- sokoloff 3y ago> Childcare is severely underweighted as well. Childcare is the average amount spent by all households, not only by the households which have childcare expenses. I spent essentially $0 on childcare now that my kids are old enough to stay home alone if my spouse and I go out. I expect to continue to spend $0 for the next 3-4 decades. > Housing is underweighted in rents and overweighted in owner equivalent rent. About 2/3 of Americans "own" their home. The owner-equivalent rent also happens to be about 2/3 the sum of (owner equivalent rent plus rent). That is not an accident, but rather is causally linked.
- paxys 3y agoUSA is a big country. Yes housing has gone up a lot more in NYC and SF, but those numbers are offset by random farm towns in North Dakota and Iowa.
- asynchronous 3y agoShow me anywhere, in the entire US, that has gone down in pricing for housing over the last three years.
- paxys 3y agoWho is saying anything about prices going down?
- serf 3y agothat doesn't seem that hard to find.[0] plenty of regions have fallen, it just isn't a consistent decline in most cases. [0]:https://smartasset.com/data-studies/where-home-prices-fell-2023 https://smartasset.com/data-studies/where-home-prices-fell-2...
- s1artibartfast 3y agoIt doesn't have to go down to support an 85% average increase. An equal number at 50% in the Midwest cancels 110% increase in sf.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoPretty much all of western US (and I expect 90% of the rest of the US) homes have declined in previous 18 months.
- dkasper 3y agoGuessing you’ve never looked at housing in random farm towns? They all mooned in 2021 too except the really crappy ones.
- paxys 3y agoHome values have gone up on paper due to real estate speculation, which CPI doesn't care about. It instead measures how much you would need to pay to rent an equivalent apartment year over year.
- refurb 3y agohttps://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CSUSHPINSA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CSUSHPINSA Case-Shiller is up ~220%
- pcurve 3y agoIt’s doing one to one comparison of the comparable homes. Schiller looks at average home price without adjusting for newer homes being much larger and better furnished than the ones built 25 years ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- light_hue_1 3y agoOh, you're assuming that CPI is computed in a rational scientific way. And that "housing" means housing. Neither is true. Let's take a deep dive into how CPI housing is computed. You would think it could just be "track the price of every home sale in the US", or "track the price of every new rental". Ah, my naive friend, the US Bureau of Labor Statistics lives in the year 1900 as if data, electricity, compute, and statistics don't exist. Anyway, those numbers would be too scary and too objective. First, the real kicker, CPI housing doesn't measure the cost of a house! At all. Their rationale is that the a house is an investment. So it has no relationship to the Case-Shiller index at all. What do you measure if you don't measure the cost of housing? Well, you're left measuring rents, but that's not satisfying when a lot of people buy a home. So.. why don't we measure the imaginary rent that someone thinks that their house that they bought 30 years ago might be able to fetch. 3/4ths of the housing index is computed from a single quantity called the "Owners’ equivalent rent of residences". They ask people in a survey: “If someone were to rent your home today, how much do you think it would rent for monthly, unfurnished and without utilities?” Let that sink in for a moment. People who aren't renting their home. Who aren't real estate agents. Who have no idea what the cost to rent their home is. Who are homeowners and haven't rented a home in decades probably. "Bob, what do you think this would rent for?" "Ugh, $1400/month" Great! Let's base our entire understanding of the economy on the random answers of clueless people. But, remember, the Bureau of Labor Statistics needs to do everything like we're in the pre-electricity era cruising around on the latest model of horse. So they can't ask too many people. Only a few thousand people, and they keep asking the same people over and over again. Seriously, they ask the same few thousand people every 6 months what their rent is and what their imaginary rent is. They even admit this doesn't change much. And they admit this means all the data they get is garbage, it's too skewed by the particular properties of those few thousand people they randomly selected once. They could just ask 100,000 people or at least pick a different group of a few thousand every time? And then everything averages out eventually. Doing that with your horse and buggy is way too hard. Instead they adjust the junk responses they get for the type of housing, quality, etc. With a whole bunch of magic numbers that come from yet another survey of clueless people, the Department of Energy’s Residential Energy Consumption Survey, which was last run in 2020 (although I think housing CPI is computed with the 2015 run) and asked about 5000 households a bunch of questions + got some billing info from their utilities. They compute monthly CPI with an amazing formula that I think is the only use of a 6th degree square root I've ever seen in statistics (and I have CS/math degrees and do ML research; it's probably legit, but I'm not working backwards to figure out how they derived this). Oh, we're done yet! Housing also gets older all the time, we need to correct for this. That's a whole pdf. That I've never read. And I'm not sacrificing my sanity for HN. https://www.bls.gov/cpi/quality-adjustment/updating-housing-age-bias.pdf https://www.bls.gov/cpi/quality-adjustment/updating-housing-... But it has a model from January 1997 with 110 degrees of freedom. That's not confidence inspiring to say the least. Ok, so we ask clueless people to give us meaningless numbers that we then adjust based on complex largely meaningless formulas to compute an imaginary rent that doesn't exist instead of just looking at the actual cost of housing. How could this get worse? With the magic of "imputation"! A beautiful word from statistics that means "Oh, we didn't collect enough data and we have no idea what the actual number should be, so we're just going to make a number up and pretend like it's a data point we gathered based on some idea of what we think it ought to have been". Because the best data is the data you make up according to your gut. Feel free to read the horror show for yourself https://www.bls.gov/cpi/factsheets/owners-equivalent-rent-and-rent.htm https://www.bls.gov/cpi/factsheets/owners-equivalent-rent-an... No one with two neurons to rub together would ever adopt this methodology in the modern world. Of course none of these numbers match any of the reality that anyone experiences. Their documentation on how anything is computed reads like standup comedy.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoWe plan out meals and so we have dozens of recipes that we rotate through. Keeps things not quite boring while also keeping everything in the minds of everyone in the family so that when we ask what everyone wants for suppers this week they can think of something. Anyway, this is all to say that our grocery habits are fairly consistent. Our bill is up, in the past two years alone, between 30 and 40 percent. I haven't gone back to the old receipts to confirm exactly, but looking back at some old statements confirms that range. That's just two years. Not 24.
- creer 3y agoIt feels like "covid" and "supply chain issues" were a great excuse to wildly reshuffle prices, item availability, item quality and packaging quantity. ... And yet it doesn't seem visible in corporate profits. It's not very visible where that price difference is going. So I don't know yet. I'm open to useful data (which the current CPIs really are not.) By this I mean, corporate profits have increased but are still most often (never mind Apple) a small fraction of price in the retail world.
- HumblyTossed 3y ago> packaging quantity. Ha! Yeah, I've seen some 11oz(!!!) bags of coffee recently.
- mistrial9 3y agoit is appropriate here to question these numbers carefully -- and, this fits very well to lived experience over 25 years in a place with very high rate of change.. one might say an epicenter of these changes.. the SF Bay Area in California.. from what I read, Los Angeles metro is very similar... Seattle also.. these places I know well and these numbers are real from the ground view.
- wuliwong 3y agoI wanted to comment with a similar sentiment, particularly about housing. I think the Case Shiller index is a solid reference. My own anecdotal experienced had me buying a house and selling it 2.5 years later (in 2022) for 72% more than what I paid for it.
- burritofanatic 3y agoAgreed. I remember in 2000 that I used to be able to buy the cheapest full meal with sides at a fast casual for under $4. Now maybe it under $12!
- rossdavidh 3y agoNot that this explains all of the discrepancy between official statistics and what we see in reality, but the average size home has gone up over time, so if you're looking at price per square foot instead of price per home it would account for some of that. The increase in average home size is especially striking given that the average family size is declining.
- francisofascii 3y agoI think many areas saw a significant fall in prices in the 2009 crash, but some hot areas didn't. Those hot areas are probably 3 times as high compared to 1999, but the areas that were more normal might be closer to 1.86. Sample of one. The house I once lived in sold for $193K in 1999, I sold it for $300K in 2007 (before the housing crash), it's Zillow estimate fell to $230K in 2010. Today the Zillow estimate is $454K. So that is 2.3 the cost.
- darth_avocado 3y agoHousing prices have 2X in just last 5 years, and in some markets more. Food is definitely way more expensive. Raw foods like Beef, eggs, flour, sugar etc. all has gone up 60-80% in the last two years. So I definitely believe you when you say it is hard to believe.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 3y ago> According to the article, $1 in housing in 1999 is equivalent to $1.86 today. That's... incredibly hard to believe. The Case Shiller is up over 300% for the same time period. Case-Shiller is index of homes-as-an-asset buy prices, the housing component of CPI is housing-as-a-consumed-service rent prices. 1999 was pretty near historical lows for the buy:rent price ratio, today is just off the all-time high, so, yes, now:1999 for buying a home as an asset is very different than now:1999 for consuming housing as a service.
- jjav 3y ago> And $1 in food is $1.84 today? I don't have an index to reference, but also hard to believe. Up until 1999/2000, a Burger King Whopper was $1. Today ~$8
- fsckboy 3y agobut there's no mention of what incomes did over the same period? the recent inflation was caused by cheap money policies (probably around covid) which flooded the market with spending, driving up prices. also, isn't inflation always calculated on a 12 month scale? each month they publish how much prices have increased from 12 months before. This means that if there is a lot of inflation for a few months, each succeeding month after that will show high inflation till that bulge in the snake works it's way through. The numbers are a valid comparison to a year earlier, but misleading if you think "omg we've had month over month of high annual inflation numbers!"
- s1artibartfast 3y agoLooks like the median income went from 34k to 40k [1]. However, median income is very misleading because it does not include goverment transfer payments, which are substantial in that income range. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEPAINUSA672N https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEPAINUSA672N
- WalterBright 3y agoNote the correspondence with federal deficits. Inflation is how we pay for deficits.
- up_o 3y agoSounds like you're leaning on the arm of that chair a bit heavily. Care to elaborate?
- gottorf 3y agoSeems self-evident to me that increasing the supply of dollars does not automatically increase the supply of goods and services that people actually consume.
- up_o 3y agoSetting aside your "self-evident" implication that goods and services across the board rise and fall with fluctuations in money supply... Is running a federal deficit and an increase in the money supply the same thing? Because my contention was with what Walter right actually said.
- WalterBright 3y ago> Is running a federal deficit and an increase in the money supply the same thing? No. The money supply will naturally increase as the value of goods and services in the economy grows. (This creation is done by the banks loaning money against collateral, it's a rather complex subject.) If the money supply increases faster than that, we have inflation. The way it increases faster than that is via the fiat money printing press. Here's another way to look at it. The US had a net zero inflation from 1800-1914. Everything the current government blames as a cause of inflation happened all over that time period, but no net inflation. From 1914 on, we've had endemic inflation. Any explanation of inflation has to account for that. The creation of the Fed accounts for it. It was given the power to arbitrarily create money, and so they did, to fund the deficits. Every other country saw the magic of this, and switched to fiat money and inflation.
- thallium205 3y agoThe value of the USD still erodes even amidst the many technology advances since then.
- jmclnx 3y agoNot only that, but I believe the USD is tied to Energy, not Gold. When I was young you could by a lot with just 25 cents. Plus I know people used less energy back then. But the Oil Embargos hit the US twice in the 70s, during that period inflation spiked and only settled down when the price of Oil stabilized. USD had adjusted to the new prices. Then in the last 20 years, a few times we had some relativity minor shocks due to OPEC decreasing production among other things. Thus inflation. People like to point to other things, but to me, our economy is directly tied to the price if energy. And maybe that is why trying to get off of fossil fuels seems almost impossible. And not counting the price of Energy in our inflation numbers skews our real issues.
- halfmatthalfcat 3y agoHow does that square with the US largely energy independent now? With Shale, the US is far less reliant on foreign oil (ala energy).
- jmclnx 3y agoUS is an energy exporter now.
- saltminer 3y agoOil was a big driver of inflation in the 70s, but another factor which tends to be overlooked is population growth: while the US population had been rather stagnant during WW2, the post-WW2 baby boom led to the 70s being filled with the now-adult Baby Boomers entering the workforce and demanding housing, transportation, etc. which really didn't help things. If there was no WW2 (or if there was no baby boom because people kept having kids like normal throughout WW2), inflation would have been much less pronounced during the 70s. https://russellinvestments.com/us/blog/inflation-pales-to-1970s https://russellinvestments.com/us/blog/inflation-pales-to-19... https://www.epbmacroresearch.com/blog/initial-conditions-for-inflation-1940s-1970s-2020s https://www.epbmacroresearch.com/blog/initial-conditions-for...
- gregorvand 3y agoLike some other commenters, what is actually being represented here is hard to understand. Which is usually what nice visualizations are supposed to clear up over [CPI documentation].
- justinzollars 3y agoThese are probably real numbers, but the government lies deliberately to keep inflation adjusted payments down. Costs such as social security are fixed to inflation. A site I follow is called ShadowStats that uses the old government accounting measures to calculate inflation, and its interesting to see the difference. https://www.shadowstats.com/ https://www.shadowstats.com/
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoThis doesn't seem right. 24.6% unemployment. Unless I'm living in a bubble, that's not anywhere near the correct number. https://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/unemployment-charts https://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/unemployment-char...
- gottorf 3y ago> long-term discouraged workers, who were defined out of official existence in 1994 The labor force participation rate, defined as the percentage of people 16 years of age or older who are working or seeking work (minus "institutional", aka military) currently sits around 63%. The US population is roughly 17% over 65. Those three numbers roughly add up to 100%.
- mminer237 3y agoRoughly 20% of the us is under 16, which makes your 17% go up to like 21%. Also that's still ignoring full-time students in treating housewives as unemployed.
- gottorf 3y ago> the government lies deliberately to keep inflation adjusted payments down "Hedonic quality adjustment" is the preferred term. ;-)
- avidiax 3y agoYes, because I enjoy an economy 4 door twice as much now that they cost twice what they used to. Now I have Bluetooth, a rear view camera, increased fuel economy and improved crash protection. Today, if I get t-boned by a lifted F-350, I'll die in a hospital instead of on the road, and you can't put a price on that.
- GerryB 3y agoTechnology is a dramatic counterexample. 1999's ASCI Red 1-2 teraflop supercomputer cost $46,000,000 1999 dollars. A 2 teraflop 2022 iPhone 14 costs $800. Even if you nitpick the computation comparison, there's still a 5 order of magnitude reduction in cost.
- lovvtide 3y agoTech is the exception that proves the rule, rather, advancing so fast that the concomitant price deflation outpaced inflation seen in other sectors. There's an interesting chart that shows how inflation has been distributed very unequally in the economy over the last 20 years. Things like healthcare and housing where the supply is legally/artificially constrained (thus preventing natural price deflation) have seen the biggest increases. https://www.investors.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/CPIChart2018.png https://www.investors.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/CPIChar...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nojvek 3y agoThis is only until Dec 2017. The world is a lot different after Covid. Car prices have definitely shot up quite a bit.
- almost_usual 3y agoThings that are hard to produce or rare typically keep pace with inflation. Tech becomes easier to produce over time due to improvements so it does not keep pace with inflation and typically deflates.
- paxys 3y agoAre they trying to say that costs of education have only gone up 14% since 1999?
- samspenc 3y agoThis was the part that was most surprising to me as well. Most other reports seem to indicate that education is among the fastest rising costs compared to inflation, similar to healthcare. I'm surprised to see that number so low in this report.
- mactrey 3y agoVarious other sources give much higher numbers, like up 179% from 1999 to 2020 [1] or up 110% from 1998 - 2018 [2]. So I'm not sure what's going on with the article. It could be that they're deflating by wage increases, or showing the change relative to overall inflation, or something like that. [1] https://educationdata.org/average-cost-of-college-by-year https://educationdata.org/average-cost-of-college-by-year [2] https://www.cnbc.com/2017/11/29/how-much-college-tuition-has-increased-from-1988-to-2018.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/11/29/how-much-college-tuition-has... Edit: I would have assumed the OP article was based on this series: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUUR0000SAE1 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUUR0000SAE1
- RagnarD 3y agoVery understated, so probably driven from government deliberate statistical/interpretational manipulations. Also: inflation is NOT fundamentally about price changes. Inflation is purely the result of arbitrary expansion of government fiat money supply. A simple example drives this home. One could say that a $1,000 computer of say 10 years ago was much less powerful than a $900 computer of today, and be right. One could say that inflation hasn't affected computers, and they would be wrong. Without the expansion of fiat money, that $900 computer would be, say, $500 or less. The final price is not how inflation can or should be measured.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- whoomp12342 3y agoanother good example is cars. in 2000, you got heat, ac, and maybe a casset player. Now look at all the gizmos and gadgets on them
- doubled112 3y agoI would rather most of the gizmos and gadgets go away, and I can't be alone. Laws and manufacturers have decided for me though. No fighting it now.
- o11c 3y agoIME none of those modern gizmos and gadgets are actually useful. But "intermittent windshield wipers" should not be an optional feature, Toyota!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- andruby 3y agoSome of the gizmos were useful in my opinion: Central locking, power windows, navigation (before our phones did it), power steering. Lots of engine efficiencies reduced fuel usage.
- talkingtab 3y agoI work at a convenience store. We have a penny jar. Except about four months ago people starting leaving dimes, nickels and quarters. It was not a gradual change, people hardly ever left more than pennies. And it is not just one or two people. My take is that nothing less than a dollar bill is worth much anymore. Part of this is could be the issue of cash vs card, but my uneven sample says that ratio is not really changing. And what can you buy for $0.25? Nothing. $0.50? Nothing. Not a cheap drink, not a cup of coffee. For a dollar? Still nothing.
- throwaway44444d 3y agoReally, that's a real shame if it is. I havent been back the US since late 2014. I remember walking around Manhattan near Times Square I think, just exploring and seen so many signs for $1 slice of Pizza, I think it tad more with some sales tax thing applied when I had one, another breakfast time I got bagel with cream cheese from one of the vans I think near one of the big banks near wall street I think $1.50-$2.00. I was staying in a top-end hotel courtesy of a company I was interviewing with but unsure of expense policy I just got the food around and about myself and found it extremely cheap if you were a little careful. How much has this changed? My memory of facts could be a little off, but I always had US down for cheap plates of mountains of food, and takeaways that were next to nothing price wise.
- eloisant 3y agoIt didn't really got more expensive because salaries have increased as well. Maybe for a tourist coming from a country that hasn't seen that much inflation (Japan?)
- jraby3 3y agoThere are still plenty of $1 slices in NYC. Same with $1 coffee and inexpensive bagels.
- snake42 3y agoThis is not true in my experience. Every pizza spot is at least up to $1.50 a slice. I have only lived here 2 years, but I never see a $1 coffee. https://www.today.com/food/news/nycs-2-bros-dollar-pizza-slices-rcna77180 https://citylimits.org/2022/07/28/how-much-does-a-bagel-cost-in-your-nyc-neighborhood/
- blindriver 3y agoThese graphs are just lies based on lies based on lies. Food prices have basically doubled in a couple of years. Prices for McDonald's have gone from about $5 for a breakfast meal combo to almost $9. I can't go out for dinner in the Bay Area for 2 adults and 2 kids for less than $100. In 9 years up to 2021, my house price almost tripled. That is inflation that no one talks about. My new house price that I bought in 2021 is down 15%. This is deflation that no one talks about... yet. The government skews numbers because they allow consumers to "trade down" to lower quality, cheaper products so that inflation doesn't look like it's going up. This doesn't capture the fact that the product is much, much lower quality. If you compare a real Big Mac to today's Big Mac, it's a pale comparison. Same goes for just about everything else. What use to be "regular" is now considered premium, and that inflation doesn't get captured over the decades.
- mmaurizi 3y agoInflation numbers are nationwide, but bay-area housing prices are not. And high housing raises the costs of all labor-intensive services (like your McDonalds), since employees need somewhere to live.
- jraby3 3y agoI don’t think the government intentionally skews numbers. The phone in your pocket, your laptop, your car have all gone up in quality/safety/speed but that also isn’t counted.
- elil17 3y agoThat is counted. As is shrinkflation, decreases in quality, etc.
- jncfhnb 3y agoYou live in outlier land and are confused when it doesn’t match the norm.
- elil17 3y ago> "Bay Area" The Bay Area is not America. In Philadelphia, for example, entrees at a nice restaurant downtown are about $15, while I fed three adults at a bar in the suburbs for $40. The government isn't lying to you with CPI, you just live in an outlier city.
- 29athrowaway 3y agoHopefully $1 bills remain a thing. Making it rain with $5s is too expensive.
- Eric_WVGG 3y agoI find it fascinating that thirty years ago, the sort of "default" unit of paper currency was a $20 bill — like, ATMs never output tens or fifties, it was always twenties, so you'd probably have a few andrew jacksons in your pocket — but today that's still the go-to. Walk into any convenience store and try to pay with a fifty dollar bill, you're lucky if they even take bills that large, they won't want to make change, they'll pull out a highlighter to make sure it's real. But it's only worth about twenty bucks to anyone who was around for Nirvana.
- MuffinFlavored 3y ago> but today that's still the go-to. I agree with you however I think this shows how poorly people understand inflation. Inflation from 1993 -> 2023 is 113% Slipping a waiter an extra $20 has 113% less meaning in 2023 than it did in 1993. You should be slipping a $40 lol
- Eric_WVGG 3y agoFor sure. Every bartender in my ’hood loves me because I'm the only person who tips more than a buck for a beer.
- FrustratedMonky 3y ago? Man, I still use a buck. Didn't realize how much that had changed. Guess used to be if a beer was 2, and you tip a buck, it is 50% Now a Beer is 6, and you tip a buck, it is ~16%. But really, 50% was way too much to begin with, it was just convenient accounting when hammered.
- cooper_ganglia 3y agoA $40 tip is wild unless you’re talking about taking the entire family out to a nice restaurant, lol. I remember 20 years ago, the general rule was to tip at least 10%, then at some point it changed to 20%. I abide by that. If it was great service, I tip 20%, if it wasn’t very good, I tip 10%.
- 3y ago
- quickthrower2 3y agoThat medical sparkline is so straight I could use it to level concrete. Is this driven by some % annual increase policy?
- sgerenser 3y agoLikely related to Medicare policies and reimbursement rates, upon which many other insurers base their rates (e.g. reimburse up to 200% of the Medicare allowed rate).
- no_wizard 3y agoWould the gold standard have prevented or slowed any of this inflation runway? I’m not one of those libertarian types who believes the fed is a giant conspiracy, however there is something to be said for mechanisms that cap the ability to print money
- anfilt 3y agoOne thing people forget is loans with modern banking can effectively increases money supply as well.
- ralph84 3y agoThe CPI is calculated by the US government. They have every incentive to understate inflation and zero incentive for it to be accurate. The US government is the biggest debtor in the world. Inflation is good for debtors. The US government is controlled by monied interests. Inflation, as a wealth transfer from poor to rich, is good for monied interests. Academic economists as always exist to provide air cover for the regime.
- recursivedoubts 3y agoMost apparel has gotten ridiculously worse than it was in 1999, adjusted for cost. I have a J. Crew shirt from 1999 I can still wear, which cost $49 in 1999. Equivalent shirt today will be $98, the buttons and stitching will be horrible comparatively and it will die a faded death after a couple of years. The new shirt, however, will photograph really well online.
- mikewarot 3y agoInflation isn't a scalar, which is the main point of the article. The problem is that capturing all prices at all times in all locations is effectively impossible, so it's generally oversimplified out of necessity. On the other hand, the value of a Dollar... The Morgan Silver Dollar from 1901 that I keep with me as a reminder, is worth about $17.50 in melt value.[1] The folks my age and younger generally don't appreciate the value of hard money.[2] It's almost always bought about 4 gallons of gasoline, or a meal for one. Say what you will about the inefficiency of a commodity backed currency, it won't shrink to zero value over time. [1] https://www.coinflation.com/coins/1878-1921-Silver-Morgan-Dollar-Value.html https://www.coinflation.com/coins/1878-1921-Silver-Morgan-Do... [2] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/h/hardmoney.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/h/hardmoney.asp
- taway_6PplYu5 3y agoYou know, the Spanish once found a whole country made out of silver, they called it Argentina (argent == silver). And they brought a lot of this silver back to mainland Spain. While the value of silver coin did not shrink to zero during that time, it did shrink quite a bit, all across Europe. Historians like to write about 150 years of massive inflation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_revolution
- mikewarot 3y agoFrom that article Prices rose on average roughly sixfold over 150 years. This level of inflation amounts to 1.2% per year compounded Prices have risen far quicker than that since the Nixon shock. Perhaps the reason we haven't gotten upset is that most people don't remember the value of hard currency?
- honksillet 3y agoThese are official numbers which are a gross underreporting of actual inflation.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoSomeone always says that, but the calculations are available. And there have been very detailed reviews of the 'its all fake' side, that have shown the published rates really aren't that far off from what the detractors say is happening if you use the various 'alternate methods'.
- elil17 3y agoPerhaps where you live. They are meant to reflect averages.
- flagrant_taco 3y agoThe Consumer Price Index is a scam at this point, as far as I can tell. They regularly modify the list of items in the cart, meaning the data isn't reliable over time. They also include caveats where they can modify the Scritsmier price differences. For example, they attention to adjust the new price to account for what they consider to be added value. Say a product is 15% more expensive one year after a new model is released. When calculated the CPI, they can decide that the new model added 10% more value or benefit to the user, meaning the price only rose by 5%. I wish I could find the study now, but around 2013 someone compared the CPI listed price increase of magazines to the actual change in the price listed on the cover over something like 20 years. The true value change was around 130% but the CPI had adjusted for value 30%. Most people seem to be feeling this now when they notice that process have risen much higher than the claimed 4 or 5%.
- bitshiftfaced 3y agoIf they didn't do those things, then wouldn't we just get a flagrant_taco from an alternate dimension who would instead argue about how CPI doesn't account for changes in consumer preference over time or how a cell phone in 2023 is different from one in 2003?
- HumblyTossed 3y agoThere should be two parts to the list. A constant long term index and a shorter term more variable one.
- sokoloff 3y agoWould the long term index have a horse-drawn carriage, a butter churn, a typewriter, a 50# block of ice for the icebox, and a rotary dial phone in it? At some point, even the long-term index can't be constant.
- flagrant_taco 3y agoIf they listed both that would make sense, that's commonplace when listing net vs gross revenue, nominal vs real GDP, etc
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- roenxi 3y ago> The Consumer Price Index (CPI) is like a yardstick that helps us understand how much the cost of everyday things, like groceries or rent, has gone up or down over time. It is a sign of the madness of monetary policy that raw changes in price are an unsuitable for measuring whether the value of something has gone up or down. Cutting a bit off the yardstick each year doesn't help. They just make it harder to figure out what is happening in the economy.
- RhodesianHunter 3y agoA cell phone from 2 decades ago is an entirely different product from a cell phone today. That needs to be accounted for.
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoSo what? Imagine you need 200 of bricks to fix a wall. You may say that modern brick is 50% better, more insulating whatever. And now your inlation number is 10% instesd of 60% But I still need the same number of bricks to fill in the hole on the wall. And I have to pay 60% more for it, not 10%. So when it comes to cost of living and surviving in the world, this argument is pure fantasy.
- cma 3y agoAre the vast majority of insulated bricks used in repair for unheated spaces and walls, or in new construction?
- kshacker 3y agoIf the brick is more insulating, it should require less insulation and less heating / cooling costs, thereby reducing your expenses, no?
- trey-jones 3y agoDepends on many factors: Can you achieve the same level of insulation for less, by using traditional insulating materials and techniques instead of insulating bricks? Does the law mandate that your bricks have a certain R-Value? How much heating and cooling is required in the climate where the building is located? As usual there is no simple answer. Bricks are OK as an analogy, but very poor as an example: as far as I'm aware modern bricks are no more insulating than old bricks, and neither are any good at the job. If there is a modern and insulating brick, then I don't think it's really caught on very much yet.
- badcppdev 3y agoIt's very pretty but having a stacked graph is really inappropriate. We don't spend equal amounts on those categories and stacking the graphs obscured the relative changes. There is no analysis worth anything in the text. It's just showcasing a pretty graph
- rwmj 3y agoIt also assumes that in 2000 you spent exactly the same amount on each of these categories, which is very weird. It would be much more interesting to know the relative amount of need for each category.
- rossdavidh 3y agoWhether the proportion among them is correct is a valid point, but since the extra cost of the different categories is cumulative to the household budget, there is an argument for stacking them. It would make more sense if it were proportional to household spending between categories, but I suppose then some of the categories would be too thin to see the increase.
- badcppdev 3y agoExactly my point. If a category becomes 3x more expensive but it only takes up 1% of my expenditure then a stacked graph without proportions is very misleading.
- lasermike026 3y agoPeople should stop driving. Education and medical care should be free. That's a start.
- jncfhnb 3y agoThe top level visualization is deeply misleading. By stacking all the categories with an initial equal weight at $1 you are visually showing your own personal weighting of goods for total CPI.
- coding123 3y agoUnfortunately my personal inflation is about 100%. Lays chips which used to be 2.50 are consistently 5.00 at my grocery store. Shrug not sure why.
- tantalor 3y agoI'm confused how this visualization is meant to work. I would expect I can compare today to an arbitrary time in the past. But the visualization actually shows 2000 vs an arbitrary time in the future. How is that a useful comparison? What is special about 2000? I don't care about the buying power of a dollar from 2000 in 2015. I do care about the buying power of a dollar from 2015 in 2023.
- datadrivenangel 3y agoUse of index years are common in inflation. Adding an index year option could be cool though.
- culi 3y agoSo what's the deal with apparel? How come it's actually decreased?
- ipnon 3y agoClothing manufacture is really only bottlenecked by labor. It’s one of the areas where if someone puts up the capital, and the factory is located in a city with low-cost labor, a profit will be turned. It’s a great example of what economists call “comparative advantage.” You can see clearly that the categories with the most inflation are those that can’t be traded: housing, education, medical care are all dependent on American regulatory cartels.
- culi 3y agoSure, but alternatively you could just as easily say, "you can see clearly that all the categories that are regulated are those with nearly vertical demand curves: housing, education, medical care are all easy to exploit by corporate cartels without regulation"
- ipnon 3y agoMy friend, you are clearly the more skilled economist between us.
- black_13 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- phendrenad2 3y agoTo really measure inflation, you need to find some good or service that hasn't changed in quality in decades. iPhones keep getting better. Houses keep getting better (mosty). What's left? Tax preparation? Polo shirts? Airline flights?