8 ms·
Make Your Car Electric for 5K in Less Than a Day
- audunw 3y agoVery interesting concept. Looks like the motor might be very lightweight so hopefully doesn’t add too much unsprung weight to the wheels. Wonder if it can be made to be durable under those conditions though.
- thelastgallon 3y agoCan this be done on a Nissan Leaf? Lots of old Leaf's with <100 mile range.
- proggy 3y agoI would imagine a battery replacement would be more cost effective than swapping to a brand new drive system. The $5k estimate appears to be completely hypothetical, presumably based on bill of materials alone.
- postalrat 3y agoDouble it once because $5k is optimistic then double it again for labor.
- nprateem 3y agoTo save you the maths, this comes out at around $18k
- speedgoose 3y agoI may miss a joke, because 5 * 2 * 2 = 20.
- quickthrower2 3y agoSo 18 give or take
- vGPU 3y agoYou can swap any Nissan leaf with a 40kWh battery pack with a CAN-bridge, and the programming software is now open source.
- CobaltFire 3y agoInteresting concept, with a few large caveats: Cost: I’d assume the cost is for a single motor; that would be a fairly unstable vehicle to drive with different left/right turning behavior. Wheel offset: Mounting the motor here will require a pretty massive increase in wheel offset or a pretty massive outward push of the wheel centerline, with each having its issues. Brake heat: If the stock brakes are used they will likely cook themselves and the motor. You are essentially requiring the electric motor to do all the braking, or else developing a hybrid braking system. Using hydraulic brakes on just one axle is a non-starter for safety reasons. Very clever idea, and maybe they can make it work. There are more than the reasons I listed as to why this hasn’t been pursued previously.
- moralestapia 3y ago>If the stock brakes are used they will likely cook themselves and the motor. ??? Why? Doesn't it take the same energy to stop a car disregarding what kind of force put it in motion?
- CobaltFire 3y agoNo; brakes function by turning the kinetic energy of the vehicle into heat via friction; using the motors for braking via regeneration produces some heat, but a fraction of the amount. For reference, it’s not uncommon to see temperatures of 1000F or higher after a single highway speed stop on the front rotors of most passenger vehicles. Having that amount of heat that close to the motor is something that needs to be designed around. The rear brakes will typically be 200-400F cooler depending on the weight bias, but that’s still not a trivial amount of heat.
- moralestapia 3y agoa) An ICE car is going 60 mph and brakes to a standstill. b) An electric car is going 60 mph and brakes to a standstill. How does one generate more heat than the other? Why would the brakes "cook themselves" in b when they don't in a? >For reference, it’s not uncommon to see temperatures of 1000F or higher after a single highway speed stop on the front rotors of most passenger vehicles. I'd like to see that reference. 1000F is F1 tier, lol.
- Scoundreller 3y agoStill wish someone would make a fairly straightforward retrofit that would “battery-ify” the electric loads on a vehicle. Would maybe handle 5-10% of a vehicle’s load, but should be the most straightforward to install. Some newer vehicles have a “belt-starter-generator” that’s just on the accessory belt, like the Fiat 500, and a tiny <1kwh battery, but dunno why it’s not expandable or why nobody makes something bolt-on for ICE vehicles that are common. Companies make a bolt-on supercharger kit for the Corolla, but nothing like this that could be useful in fleet/delivery/taxi applications. I guess gas is too cheap to plug in one’s vehicle for a 10% reduction in fuel consumption.
- iancmceachern 3y agoI get it. You power the accessories from the battery which was charged by the wall. Now you use 10% less gas. Smart.
- snypher 3y agoI don't think the electrical system load on the engine would amount to much gas saving, a 100 amp alternator may use only 4HP of your engine's power. Outside of the starter motor you don't use anything close to 100A for the accessories. Even an electric A/C is only a 5-10 horsepower saving.
- Scoundreller 3y agoDepends on the source you read, but maintaining cruise at highway speeds only takes low double digits in horsepower. Having more mainly comes in handy for ascents and acceleration, though electrical loads are a bit more constant. (Another gripe of mine is how big engine sizes are in North America, it's not like Europe has low speed limits and no mountains)
- iancmceachern 3y agoOn a 100 hp economy car that's 10%
- tengbretson 3y agoHeck, just leave the old ac compressor and heater in and run it off the idling ice motor intermittently. 1 gallon of gas would probably be enough to get you as far as a full battery charge would for a hot summer road trip.
- IronWolve 3y agoThe ford f150 was popular for conversion kits from multiple companies. One of the easiest platforms to convert, lots of room for batteries and engine swap. Google and you can find multiple companies offering a swap. Also ford going to offer a conversion kits with Mach-E crate motors, but appears the supply shortage and rising prices put a pause on it. https://electrek.co/2021/11/03/ford-is-selling-mach-e-crate-motors-to-promote-custom-ev-conversions-like-this-f-100-concept/ https://electrek.co/2021/11/03/ford-is-selling-mach-e-crate-...
- flyinghamster 3y agoGM is also offering an electric crate motor: https://www.chevrolet.com/performance-parts/ecrate https://www.chevrolet.com/performance-parts/ecrate I'm not sure how "available" it is in the real world, and I'd note that it is sold through authorized installation centers rather than direct-to-DIYer.
- Animats 3y agoThat's more practical than wheel motors. Also, with pickups, there's room under the bed for the battery. Ford has a new electric truck platform in development, the "T3". This is supposedly electric from the ground up, unlike the F-150 and Ford Transit, which are modified versions of gas vehicles.
- coryrc 3y agoWildly ignorant choice. No one's going to sell a big enough battery without at least modeling its effect on crashworthiness, which is expensive. No, you can't run the car without the engine running; you won't have oil flow in the transmission, power steering, or power brakes. The car will handle like shit with so much unsprung weight (which is why no commercial car has ever used them, just demos). And the price quoted is basically COGS! Nobody on this process must have ever been involved in DFM.
- kibibu 3y ago> No, you can't run the car without the engine running; you won't have oil flow in the transmission, power steering, or power brakes You might have missed some key points in the pitch. Slide 4 has e-hydraulics for steering and braking.
- coryrc 3y agoThey're just clip-art on a slide. It's not possible for a reasonable price. NRE costs per model would be high, making a farce of "Make your car electric for 5k". For the mechanic installing the device, you have to have an installation manual listing where every cable and hose needs to go and be secured. And you need to choose well, because if it rubs anywhere: recall and fix (is there enough money in $5k for recalls? No). You have to hack the ECM, /per model/, to allow you to drive without the engine actually running. It's preposterous.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoThat doesn't solve lack of lubrication to the transmission. Go read your owner's manual under the section regarding towing. There are almost always restrictions on maximum speed and distance with the drive wheels not lifted. As the other commenter pointed out, there's a lot of hand-waiving going on by the kid who won the contest; it's like the farside comic where there's a giant "magic happens" in the middle of a board full of mathematic scribbling. For example: running HVDC to the engine compartment (for the AC, power steering, and vacuum pump) from the spare tire well in a vehicle whose undercarriage isn't designed for it requires pretty substantial armoring. The other problem: in-wheel motors are not new (Mistubishi sunk a LOT of R&D into it), and they haven't taken off for a reason. They massively increase unsprung weight. Your average car wheel weighs maybe 30-40lb at most. He's probably doubling that. That means atrocious ride quality and traction issues, because the tire's going to be bouncing around like crazy due to the suspension not being designed to dampen that much weight. The motor is also subject to all the vibration normally soaked by the suspension and vehicle frame. Trying to get an electric motor to withstand that sort of vibration is not a trivial problem. This is just a bunch of hogwash from Dyson. The kid figured out that what they care about is a nice big fat PR grabber, and he gave them one.
- rkho 3y agoI'm still not sure where this $5k number came from. The description says: > REVR could cost as little as $5k without rebates and can be installed in under a day. What are the conditions in which it "could" cost this amount, and has it already been achieved?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- barrysteve 3y agoI love this concept, there's some older cars with an excellent driving experience and iconic shapes out there to electrify. They're not worth spending big bucks on, but an EV retrofit kit that is 'good enough' would be worth it. Extra points, if your middle class 'car enthusiast' type could do the majority of the retrofitting (or all of it) himself. The aftermarket car culture has been waning a bit and safe electronics could be a big lift.
- 29athrowaway 3y agoICE vehicles produce a large amount of emissions... but the ones that do no not use roads are the ones that generate most of the pollution, not the ones on the roads. Off the roads there is less regulation and that is where 90% of the pollution happens.
- winrid 3y agoThat's complete BS. Off-road stuff can't possibly contribute to 90% of pollution even if everyone had a V8 off-road buggy and used it every weekend. It is waaaaaaaay less than 1%.
- quickthrower2 3y agoDoes off road include farm machines, lawn mowers, etc.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoA single 2-stroke leaf blower generates more pollution than several hundred SUVs. Now imagine the impact of a single 2-cycle outboard or motorcycle. https://www.google.com/search?q=2-cycle+engine++pollution https://www.google.com/search?q=2-cycle+engine++pollution
- winrid 3y agoAlmost nobody uses two strokes off-road. Like it's not even relevant to the discussion at all. Two strokes are almost completely gone in the western world save leaf blowers. Outboards have been largely 4 stroke for decades. Motorcycles - a very very small number of performance oriented bikes are two stroke, at least in the west. Motorcross people still use them but that's such a small number. In other places they are being phased out too.
- 29athrowaway 3y agoThink agriculture, mining, forestry, construction, lawn equipment, etc.
- onetokeoverthe 3y ago[dead]
- lnsru 3y agoI am always skeptic when I read about work on a car and “less than a day”. Trailer hitch install with cabling took exactly 4 hours. Dash cam install took 3 hours. Both on rather small bmw 3 series car. Doing cabling properly is always pita. Be it a house or a car. There was a newspaper article wringing, that battery replacement alone for Kia ev6 takes whole day.
- hexo 3y agoAnd never be able to certify it for road again. Thanks
- aivisol 3y agoThat was exactly what I was thinking. How do certify _any_ electric conversion in a country with mandatory annual or biannual technical inspection (i. e. most of EU)? I remember reading somewhere that costs in Germany and/or Scandinavia are so high that whole endeavour is not worth it.
- spacecadet 3y agoUnsprung... deadly.
- ChatGTP 3y agoA little off topic, but due to economics of scale, will the price of cars start to plummet once nearly everything is electrified ? $5k seems cheap, even for a retrofit, I can imagine building a new car should be even cheaper than this. Of course there is the body of the car, interior and suspension, but the whole package together should become cheap as motors and batteries become ubiquitous ?
- nradov 3y agoBatteries won't be cheap any time soon. It's totally possible to build a $5K car today. But it wouldn't meet safety or emissions requirements in most developed countries.
- ChatGTP 3y agoBecause Lithium is expensive?
- to11mtm 3y agoI mean, you're looking at up to 151$/kWH wholesale for the batteries. I'm assuming that doesn't include the cost of containers, wiring between them, logic or extra bits for the pack (e.x. IIRC Ford packs auto discharge in the cold to prevent freezing), or the cost of assembly.
- GoToRO 3y agoI could turn my car into a 4x4! Very nice concept, I hope he gets it into production.
- jimt1234 3y agoRich Rebuilds talks a lot about the true cost of EV conversions. Here's one good video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=og1dEaDXbwg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=og1dEaDXbwg
- dzhiurgis 3y agoWhy would you put 5k into a 3k shitbox? I get it for preserving older cars for movies, etc. But a corolla? Thats like replacing screen on iphone 6 and hoping it’s worth something.
- coin 3y agoThe car might be "electric" but the electricity comes from the gas powered engine. It's still a gas car - gas goes in and motion comes out.
- michaelhoney 3y agoSome unusually cranky replies in the comments. What is it about this project that gets commenters so lathered up? For context: > The James Dyson Award supports budding design engineers at the start of their careers. If you’re a current student or recent graduate with an idea that solves a problem, we want to hear about it. We’ll be equally impressed by rough-and-ready prototypes as we will by mass market-ready samples.