10 ms·
Google User Data Is Police's Top Shortcut for Solving Crimes
- chii 3y agojust like opening letters, or search warrants, as long as the data is accessed via a court order, which has audit and transparency attached, it should be OK. What's not allowed is indiscriminate vacuuming of data for analysis to see if "crimes" have been committed.
- pnpnp 3y agoI’m so torn on this. Your digital life is so much more than a letter. I feel like police need to be very specific with what they are allowed to access.
- monero-xmr 3y agoFast forward to the 45 second mark https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cnA6XwVQUHY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cnA6XwVQUHY
- psunavy03 3y agoHow is this different from the fact that they can toss your house with a court order, if necessary? Yes, search warrants generally limit themselves more than that, but a warrant is a warrant and the authorities can search anything they need to that's reasonably connected to what they have probable cause to suspect. How is your digital life any different from your physical life in that regard? Police and other LE already have to go to a judge and be "very specific" to be able to search anywhere you have a reasonable expectation of privacy.
- hypothesis 3y agoThis is different because they are physically limited in number of houses they can toss per day, plus said activity is quite more observable to targets.
- psunavy03 3y agoThe number of warrants that can be served has nothing to do with the price of beer. Either a judge has approved the warrant based on probable cause presented to him/her by the police, or they haven't. If the police could hypothetically toss every house in the country twice a day and once on Sundays, that has precisely nothing to do with anything. So long as the only houses they DO toss are ones where a judge has reviewed the evidence, and determined that there is probable cause that tossing the house will turn up fruits or instrumentalities of a crime. Capability to do a thing has nothing to do with approval to do a thing under the law or ethics. I'm fully capable of being a (very bad) male prostitute, but I refrain from doing that for many obvious moral and legal reasons.
- autoexec 3y ago> So long as the only houses they DO toss are ones where a judge has reviewed the evidence, and determined that there is probable cause that tossing the house will turn up fruits You have a lot more faith than I do. I'd bet it's a lot more like a rubber stamp with basically zero review, assuming they bother with warrants at all (https://petapixel.com/2022/07/27/googles-nest-will-provide-data-to-police-without-a-warrant/ https://petapixel.com/2022/07/27/googles-nest-will-provide-d... https://www.aclu.org/news/privacy-technology/new-records-detail-dhs-purchase-and-use-of-vast-quantities-of-cell-phone-location-data https://www.aclu.org/news/privacy-technology/new-records-det... https://www.latimes.com/business/technology/story/2021-03-24/federal-agencies-subpoena-google-personal-information https://www.latimes.com/business/technology/story/2021-03-24... https://experiencedcriminallawyers.com/what-private-information-will-google-give-cops-without-a-warrant https://experiencedcriminallawyers.com/what-private-informat...)
- watwut 3y ago> So long as the only houses they DO toss are ones where a judge has reviewed the evidence, I think that actual process is that judge agrees to anything cops ask for, not evidence review is going on.
- psunavy03 3y ago
- dredmorbius 3y agoThe number of houses that can be searched is limited. Actual police officers or detectives need to visit said house, spend time on-prem, collect, and analyze evidence. A single site can be accessed at a time. Digital media are searched automatically, by hardware and processes, with many potential targets searched simultaneously and at vanishingly small cost. Physical evidence and print media are far slower to access and assess than digital media are. Physical evidence and print media have vastly lower data density than digital media do. Both temporal and spatial data resolution is far lower for the former. At the same time, provenance, integrity, and chain-of-possession over physical evidence media are also generally easier to ensure and assess, and both are generally less susceptible to either fabrication or modification. (The point here isn't that physical media cannot be tampered with. It's that digital media can be tampered with absolutely no evidence of this on the media itself. Typically some external validation or integrity check is necessary. Digital media can be entirely fabricated, all the more so now with AI and generator technologies, or can be entirely destroyed without a trace.) Digital media can be stored at volumes and for durations which would be utterly impossible with physical evidence. A 1 TB storage device, which can fit on your pinkie nail, can hold the equivalent of ~200,000 books, roughly the size of a fairly substantial public library. The entire Library of Congress book collection, 140 million volumes, assuming 5 MB each, would fit in 700 TB of storage. With currently-available 20 TB drives, that's about 35 disks, which would fit within a few standard rack units (mostly depending on the size of disk you'd opted for). The total cost would be a few thousand dollars. Digital media, particularly in the form of SaaS providers and Cloud storage, is an absolute trove of information on hundreds of millions or billions of people.
- pharmakom 3y agoI would rather a stranger search my house than my digital accounts and files, honestly.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoWhen they "toss your house" you are generally on notice that a warrant has been obtained. When they get data from Google, does Google notify you. (NB. Correct me if I am wrong but in the case of Google, unless it's a search of Google's premises, it's not a warrant, it's a subpoena. Without being notified of a subpoena there's no opportunity for you to challenge it.)
- chii 3y agoI would imagine that if the warrant is like a no-knock warrant, then google doesn't have to notify you. But otherwise, they would need to.
- dredmorbius 3y agoThe effects of a no-notice warrant remain profoundly different for a physical location, in which it's obvious that a search has occurred, and a digital search, in which it is not.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoExample of warrant issued to Google for information https://ia804707.us.archive.org/10/items/gov.uscourts.cacd.869106/gov.uscourts.cacd.869106.1.0.pdf https://ia804707.us.archive.org/10/items/gov.uscourts.cacd.8...
- pnpnp 3y agoMy personal biggest fear is that I feel like my search history is full of curious things than can be misconstrued in court. I’ve always been fascinated by red-teaming things, and a very curious person in general. For example, I took some advanced chemistry classes and wanted to look up how hard it would be to synthesize RDX one day. I feel like that could be used against me in the wrong situation. My computer is full of things that only exist in my mind, and I feel like that’s too personal for something like a jury to handle.
- quest88 3y agoThe small amount I've seen, they are.
- cm2187 3y agoAnd to take a measure of the creepiness, you just have to remind yourself what would be the non digital equivalent of what google is doing. You would be followed all day long by a guy who would log in his notebook every move you do, everything you say, who you meet, what they tell you, he would follow you into your doctor's office or at the coffee machine where you are flirting with a colleague. Anyone would go crazy with being spied on like that, it's worse than what the Stasi could ever do. And of course that notebook would be a treasure trove way more sensitive than a letter you would have written.
- doctorpangloss 3y agoAre you concerned that it advantages Google to have a cozy relationship with authorities everywhere? Do you think being friends with police big and small everywhere is powerful? Can politicians even offer "Do your job" to the same extent? It twists things.
- ricardo81 3y agoReasonable take, where I'd perhaps feel I'd disagree is that 90% of the Western World uses Google for search, mobile OS or whatnot- is it reasonable to presume they all read the ToS(s) and understand the consequences, or do they really have a choice in the matter? e.g. search engine choices wrt Google being scrutinised on a possible monopoly position.
- qup 3y agohttps://archive.ph/p6jcc https://archive.ph/p6jcc
- bella_sm 3y agoThank you, kind stranger!
- qup 3y agoLifehack: use another search engine and at least avoid the search query lists
- ta8903 3y agoIf you use google (the search engine) without being signed in and without sharing your location data, I doubt they could tie down any relevant information to you.
- stevezsa8 3y agoDoesn't any web request need a source IP address? So I'm sure Google can infer who you are. Or atleast your household. Plus, even if you used a Trusted^TM VPN, if the authorities want to know who you are, chances are they can find out.
- orthoxerox 3y agoIf you disable every cookie, run anti-fingerprinting on your (desktop!) browser and route your requests through TOR, then probably yes.
- bagels 3y agoImportance of advertising revenue would dictate otherwise.
- deadalus 3y agoI use Bing for porn. For reverse image search, I use Yandex. And for researching psychedelics and conspiracy(censored) topics - I use Brave Search. I use Google only for vanilla search that shows I am a good citizen(navigation, online shopping, general research on movies and sports...etc). I don't want my search Identity to be fully profiled by Google. Police(and other bad actors like a hostile government) are more likely to access my data on Google than on other lesser know search engine.
- ThePowerOfFuet 3y agoWhy use Google at all, instead of something like DuckDuckGo?
- extr 3y agoI've let Google track my location history for over 10 years now. On top of being incredibly useful (and fun) to remember where I was and when, I always imagined it would come in handy as an alibi if I was ever accused of a crime.
- snvzz 3y agoIt'd get thrown out as an alibi. But it'd be used as evidence for a crime. That's how it works with data: Against you.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jjoonathan 3y agoThat sounds rigged.
- nxm 3y agoEvidence of this?
- ffpip 3y agohttps://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/google-tracked-his-bike-ride-past-burglarized-home-made-him-n1151761 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/google-tracked-his-bike...
- extr 3y agoWhy would it get thrown out?
- sambazi 3y agocircumstantial
- tzs 3y agoSo? Much of the evidence in most criminal trials is circumstantial. For example fingerprints and DNA are circumstantial evidence. Direct evidence is evidence that directly links a person to a crime, which for the most part means testimony of a person who claims to have personal knowledge of the crime. Evidence that requires making inferences to get from the evidence to the crime is circumstantial. A good non-criminal example of direct vs. circumstantial evidence would be if you were trying to prove that it snowed last night and you found someone who said that they woke up at 3 AM and looked out a window and saw it snowing. That would direct evidence because you have someone who claims to have personal knowledge that what you are trying to prove happened actually happened. If instead of a witness who actually saw the snowfall you had a person who testified that there was no snow on the ground when they went to bed but when they woke up in the morning there was snow that would be circumstantial evidence. From that testimony you do have direct evidence that there was snow on the ground in the morning, but you have to make inferences if you are trying to prove that snow fell during the night and so that evidence is circumstantial for proving that.
- hilbert42 3y agoAm I missing something here? Wouldn't most reasonably smart criminals leave their smartphones switched on at home before they go on a job? 'Switched on' at home would be an alibi if later questioned. Alternatively, at least switching to airplane mode or switching the phone off (but that could indicate intent). It seems to me then that only the stupid would get caught this way. That raises the question of how much longer will this method be effective when even the stupid get wind of the fact that their phones will betray them. From the unsolved crimes mentioned it seems the smart have caught on already. I wonder if there are any stats on whether crooks are actively aware of the dangers of carrying a phone. If so, then is there any trend downward in solving crimes as the knowledge of the fact spreads?
- watwut 3y agoMost often when people engage in small crime, they are not engaging in smart behavior overall. Having phone with them is just one of multiple stupid decisions that were done that week. They are used to have smartphones with them all the time, so they do not think about them at all. Another pretty common way of catching you is that you brag to friends or family about the crime and one of them tells the cops.
- hilbert42 3y agoAccepted, that's the stupid class. And no doubt such detection would be very useful in solving serious but unintended crime such as a hit-and-run accident.
- stevezsa8 3y agoI've seen a few stories of murders where the "smart" criminal turned their phone off during the exact window the crime took place. That and being seen at the scene of the crime was used as evidence. So the intent part is definitely a thing if they simply turn off their phone.
- fx1994 3y agoWell, you can check in current Ukraine vs. Russia war how both sides lost soldiers for using mobile phones. People tend to forget they carry device that might hurt them in the end.
- seydor 3y agoThis is very inefficient. There was never a stronger case for defunding the police. Google can arrest individuals with at least 79% better efficiency. Just needs a catchy name, something like GJail
- ehecatl42 3y ago>GJail Just Gail… the G is "soft" like giff.
- ibejoeb 3y agoNot to re-table a long settled debate, but I always knew that the one true pronunciation is gif, and everyone else who pronounce it gif is just weird.
- gadders 3y agoGive it 5 years though and they'd end of life the product and execute all the prisoners.
- Kim_Bruning 3y ago"Give me ten sentences spoken by the most innocent of men, and I will find something in them with which to hang him." -- Voltaire. All sorts of companies (not just Google) manage to store rather more than ten sentences these days. This is why data privacy should be considered so important. Sooner or later all sorts of people (including the government) discover this <treasure trove>, and some of them will use it to hang you. If you think it's not possible for ordinary citizens to care about data-privacy, maybe visit Germany. The number of times even pretty regular people asked me to do or not do something in the name of "datenschutz" was pretty large!
- nicolaslegland 3y ago"Qu'on me donne six lignes écrites de la main du plus honnête homme, j'y trouverai de quoi le faire pendre" — https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Cardinal_Richelieu#Disputed https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Cardinal_Richelieu#Disputed
- zombot 3y agoRichelieu was exactly the kind of man to have said something like this.
- Kim_Bruning 3y agoI double-checked and thought I had indeed made a mistake in attribution here. However, while Richelieu is the most commonly cited as the source of the quote, the source is actually somewhat disputed, and has been attributed to various people (who may or may not have been (mis)quoting Richelieu themselves), including -apparently- Voltaire. So I get off on a technicality :-/ . Going forward, I do promise to be more careful with attribution of quotes in future.
- Garvi 3y agoThe fact that social media demonstrated(faked by censorship) apathy after the Snowden revelations did the most damage to personal freedom as a single incident in history. Now everyone that respects privacy feels like they're alone. And all the broken people have a target to bash, to feel better about themselves. I'm talking about the folks using "I don't need privacy, because I have nothing to hide (this means I'm better than you)" to avoid facing their personal problems. The main problem of the situation we're finding ourselves in is this: How can you dispute information obtained this way? Reporting this: https://www.militarytimes.com/off-duty/military-culture/2021/11/08/investigative-journalist-seeks-to-uncover-the-truth-behind-fatal-2017-niger-ambush-in-documentary/ https://www.militarytimes.com/off-duty/military-culture/2021... ..is what gets you arrested for child porn possession. This man was snatched from his home without a warrant. The last remaining journalists, still working in this environment, took note. Make no mistake. The original story from Rolling stone magazine has been removed. Of course the people that followed the story closely, looked the other way in fear of being accused of supporting pedophilia. There was no outrage.
- lnxg33k1 3y ago[flagged]
- hfuyf65 3y agoAnger is a valid emotion, but it does not advance the conversation or gain you adherents to your cause. Here, it will almost certainly do the opposite. Just to give you an idea, you could have easily undermined the argument that reaction to Snowden's revelation was a societal shrug.
- lnxg33k1 3y agoNo mine was not anger, was a display of contempt (english is not my first language, i translated “disprezzo”) towards that part of society that advocates for principles only when it shrinks what they think its their rights, but when it affects in negative ways people that they don’t consider people then turn the other ways
- beej71 3y agoI know we can't know, but is having location history off enough? I still share my location with a few friends and family. I guess I have to trust that it's enough, since I already can't trust that Google isn't using some other channel to continuously monitor and record my location.
- reportgunner 3y agoI believe the only way is to not have the phone on you. There are many ways to track you other than GPS. Your phone might be collecting data even while it's in airplane mode and broadcast it once airplane mode is off.