9 ms·
Inflated rents, high interest and lack of supply create European housing crisis
- seydor 3y ago.. and it's EU wide due to the open market (housing among others). Yet we care more for plastic straws
- api 3y agoThe housing crisis is only a crisis if you're not a property owner, and in most cases property owners de facto control governments if for no other reason than the fact that they tend to be older and vote more. This is true in the US and probably in the EU too.
- mostlylurks 3y agoMuch of the EU has the added problem of there simply being more old people than young people, making this issue and some others, like the pension issue, much more hopeless than they would be in countries with healthy[0] population pyramids. [0]: "Healthy" being a shorthand for "compatible with our[1] current economic system". [1]: Basically the entire world.
- HPsquared 3y agoCould call it the "population pyramid scheme"
- HPsquared 3y agoBasically every government policy over the last 20+ years is in the direction of increasing house prices and rents. The good news is that if every policy is currently at "increase prices", any change will result in a decrease. Surely we must be approaching the peak now, what other things could they possibly do to restrict supply / increase demand? (I guess the climate goals leave a lot of freedom to continue tweaking)
- seydor 3y agoMaybe if renting is shown to be bad for the environment or sth
- zo1 3y agoSomething something, you will own nothing, right?
- gs17 3y agoI'd expect it to be worse for the environment than owning. My apartment has an electric heat system older than myself instead of a modern, efficient heat pump because I rent (to be fair, I'm not sure how the math works out on keeping the inefficient but working current HVAC system over replacing it, environmentally, but if it breaks, the cheapest possible thing that fits will replace it). I can't improve the insulation because I rent. I could never have something like solar panels because I rent. These investments would save energy, but utilities are my responsibility so my landlords haven't been interested. The most I can do as a renter is replace lightbulbs with LEDs. Plus, every time we're forced to move we end up making a lot of trash and burn a lot of fuel moving things.
- baal80spam 3y agoThe ruling class will do nothing to decrease real estate prices because it has skin in the game - they do NOT want them to decrease.
- bondarchuk 3y agoHigh interest? I seem to remember previously low interest was also blamed for the housing crisis..
- madsbuch 3y agoVolatility in interest rates always affect those with large loans the most (positive or negative).
- hash07e 3y agoThe inflation on rent is not due the recent "increase" in new population? expanding this: Not complaining but it is unfair to increase your population not organically, forbidding new constructions and expecting this "just works". What happens is both sides are squeezed in inflation and have lower quality of life and the govt. reaps higher taxes. Then same govt says you are evil for pointing out this? Edit: People are pointing out the asylum or refugee. That is not what I am talking about. Talking about cities having an influx. Like Austin or others cities where a large flux of people migrates. Please don't remove population movement from the equation only because it may affect some narrative
- ido 3y agoIf you wish to complain about migrants you can say so explicitly, as the dog whistle is entirely transparent anyway.
- HPsquared 3y agoCan't deny it is a factor. Not a single mention in the article though, of course. It's all discussion of the resulting effects, and the supply side. Demand side has multiple parts: - National population growth (migration, as fertility rate below replacement) - Money supply inflation (government spending, mortgage borrowing, years of artificially low interest rates) allowing people to bid up prices - Urbanization (office jobs and universities); people within the country move to the big cities - Social atomization (more housing needed per person) (EDIT: Ageing population too: children tend not to have their own place)
- Nitrolo 3y agoDepending in the demographics, a fertility rate below replacement level can still lead to a rising population even when excluding migrants, as the people who would be "replaced" by the new births might live for many more decades. I.e., we'd probably still have a housing crisis in Europe even if not a single foreigner came in.
- hash07e 3y ago
- codetrotter 3y ago> Soaring costs across the EU are pricing out renters, deterring prospective buyers and preventing new homes from being built. As Europe’s housing crisis grows, so do homelessness rates across the bloc. What are the solutions to Europe’s housing crisis? I literally do not understand why after all these years humanity has not yet worked out a system where every person would own a small house each, and instead we have this system that makes it super difficult for so many people to ever become homeowners.
- pydry 3y agoThat's communism. We've been programmed to be allergic to the word communism.
- Plasmoid 3y agoAre you sure it isn't the long history of failures of communist countries that has caused people to be soured on this idea?
- pydry 3y agoThat's certainly what people who charge rent and own media outlets say. Who am I to disagree with their megaphones?
- Plasmoid 3y agoDude. Are you actually stating that the multiple genocides that have been committed in communist countries were fabricated? Downplaying the killing fields or the Holodomor as invented by the media or landlords is incredibly offensive.
- pydry 3y agoDo you call the holocaust a capitalist genocide? What about when my ancestors were exterminated in the Irish potato famine and the free market was used to justify it? Are you downplaying every genocide that took place in a capitalist country? You denied a historic genocide that killed my ancestors. You think you're offended? Well, I'm not. How can I be offended? You're a basic product of your environment. Youre told that genocides that happen under communist systems are de facto communist genocides. Obvioualy. And genocides that happen under capitalist systems happen for, well, entirely different reasons. Obviously. Realistically though, when pol pot, Stalin and Hitler went on extermination binges to kill enemies (real or imagined) their reasons were much the same... the maintenance of their power. Sorry I mean giving people houses and not charging rent - the two most evil things you could ever do.
- tornato7 3y agoI have a number of friends who moved to Europe while working remotely for US tech companies. I'd be interested to know how common this really is, but it could be a contributor to inflated housing prices there as well.
- jjcon 3y agoMigration is still much higher to the USA from Europe than the other way around so at least wrt the USA migration is actually helping the problem.
- jlnho 3y agoWhat are some good companies to work for while living in the EU? I am a SWE with 10+ years of experience and I have a US and EU passport.
- gumballindie 3y ago> but it could be a contributor to inflated housing prices there as well. Unless they are moving in the millions it'll barely make a dent. There have been reports coming in from countries such as portugal stating that "nomads" are driving housing costs up, but those are the exception - if anything it helps the economy of that country.
- mancerayder 3y agoNot if it helps drive a short term rental market, where apartments are taken off for people who come for a few months.
- uoaei 3y agoThe economy isn't a person. Rising prices shuts many people out of accessing necessities.
- kredd 3y agoWe have this problem in Canada as well, and it’s a hot discussion topic among younger generation. But I’m having a hard time convincing myself government would ever intervene since majority of people actually own their homes. Why would that portion of demographic vote against their own asset? I’m assuming it’s somewhat the same problem in other countries as well. I’m a renter, and don’t have any plans to get into real estate market. That being said, I feel bad for people just getting out of college and looking for an apartment. If you’re not in a rent controlled unit, it’s a clown show everywhere.
- whatshisface 3y agoDemocracies have a fundamental problem with majority oppression of minorities, because it is in the interest of 51% to vote away the belongings of the 49% in any case where they can be sure of their continued membership of whatever circumscribes the majority they belong to. Without population growth or immigration, I think the majority of homeowners may be permanent. I am not sure how the countries with home-owning majorities are going to get out of this conflict but in any case it will be a contest between a highly motivated minority and the majority. I guess history shows they can be won by the minority but not without a lot of organization and unrest. (Contrast this with autocracies, often associated with minorities like the Iraqi Shiites oppressing majorities like Iraqi Sunnis under Saddam's regime.)
- harambae 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority Certain aspects of the us government were put together to help counteract this, but yeah I agree to some extent. Maybe at some point the majority will be renters. It’s interesting to compare housing to automobile prices, because recently both seem to be in a bit of a bubble (and I say this as someone working in the auto industry). Easier to import cars from overseas though if the US dollar stays strong.
- whatshisface 3y ago>Certain aspects of the us government were put together to help counteract this Yes, that's why I am able to say it with such confidence. :-) Although they were put in place to protect a specific minority (landowners with a high social standing in the colonies) and work by promoting the interests of those with well-established networks. Until now progressive reform has largely undone that over time, leading to more democracy.
- FpUser 3y ago>"What are the solutions to Europe’s housing crisis?" Force every fucking politician to share their house with victims. Maybe then they'll wake up and do something.
- alexambarch 3y agoHonest question: what do we even do? I'm not European but it seems like you can't talk about the "housing crisis" without having to specify whether you're talking about Europe, Canada, the US, etc. I see suggestions to build more housing through taller buildings, but without any incentive to do that from people who care, what policies will realistically get passed to change anything?
- idespisecensors 3y ago[flagged]
- bondarchuk 3y agoHere in the Netherlands we used to have social housing built by the government and then rented out at reasonable rates, from like 50's - 90's. Now after a decade+ of right-ish government the housing associations are forced to sell off these houses and don't build a lot of new ones. But if we vote for the same parties as those who supported this policy back then, I don't see why we couldn't do it again.
- niemandhier 3y agoThere is plenty of space in Europe, and plenty of housing in Europe. Parts of France are full of empty houses, in Italy whole villages are up for sale, and East Germany has lost large amounts of population. If governments could make living in areas where lots of living space is available attractive, we would not need new houses.
- uoaei 3y agoLots and buildings for sale in Spain and Portugal but they look like the repairs would cost more than the entire package as-is.
- ipsento606 3y ago> If governments could make living in areas where lots of living space is available attractive, we would not need new houses. Perhaps it's easier to make it legal to build more housing in desirable areas instead of convincing millions of people to live in small, deserted villages with no jobs
- danaris 3y agoWell, if lots of people move there, they won't be deserted anymore. And with so much remote work available today, why do you need there to be a job there waiting for you? Just bring your job with you.
- bafe 3y agoI doubt the government can do much for this (unless you want to return to the old East German tradition of planned production): these places offers very limited jobs and lower incomes. It would need a very large investment to make these places attractive enough for business to move there
- rilindo 3y agoThis feels like the same argument that is given here in the US[0], which mean that in general, most of the housing is not likely to be usable anyway. [0] https://youtu.be/3xZXdXxYBGU?si=QfLA4Ui1v4NVpxd_ https://youtu.be/3xZXdXxYBGU?si=QfLA4Ui1v4NVpxd_
- gumballindie 3y ago> As Europe’s housing crisis grows, so do homelessness rates In western europe. Having said that, raising interest rates means prices will go down but still be expensive for the average joe. Large "investors" on the other hand are making a killing. If you have cash buy now. As soon as the interest rate madness ends prices will skyrocket and you'll make a killing.
- betaby 3y ago> In western europe. I would say housing crisis real in Poland too. It's very expensive relatively to income there.
- gumballindie 3y agoPoland seems to have a home ownership rate of 86%. They are fine.
- spaniard89277 3y agoA hand in your left pocket to pay their pension. A hand in your right pocket to pay your rent. You'll get public debt to pay, poverty and the climate crisis to deal with. The social contract is broken. No wonder violence is on the rise. Guess this generations didn't really do the math, it seems they think they'll be dead soon.
- expertentipp 3y agoWhat EU fixed with free movement of services and workers, they reverted with the housing market. "We think 40k is a fair salary for this role. Ermmm what's that, housing?! no we don't have a problem with it. Why don't you just live somewhere?".
- expertentipp 3y agoOur politicians are heavily invested in real estate and they additionally leverage their influence to invest even more. Real estate is like heroine.
- idespisecensors 3y ago[flagged]
- idespisecensors 3y ago[flagged]
- TacticalCoder 3y agoOfficial EU number: in 2021 18% more migrants found their way to the EU compared to 2020. 2.3 million. That's 350 000 more migrants year-to-year from 2020 to 2021. (the official EU site do not give the numbers for 2022 / 2023 yet). Repeat that for three years and it's the basically this part from TFA: > Nearly 900,000 people sleep rough or stay in homeless accommodation every night in the EU Maybe, just maybe, that the EU should stop trying to absorb ever more people year after year because, obviously, there's an ongoing housing crisis and that there's simply no room at the moment to house all these people? P.S: if I can add something to my already depressing comment... A huge number of the houses and apartments in the EU are way too big and way too old and people don't even have enough money to fix these so that they'd consume less energy. When the prices of natural gaz and electricity skyrocketed I had people around me with yearly bills raise of 4 000 EUR, 5 000 EUR and even one 7 000 EUR year-on-year. These are insane amounts for middle-class europeans. So the issue is not just "not enough housing" in the EU. It's also "way too old and way too energy-hungry housing which cannot be fixed anytime soon".
- tjrgergw 3y agoOR maybe build more houses?
- idespisecensors 3y ago[flagged]
- 7e 3y agoEurope has been building houses for thousands of years. How do you think we got so many people? It didn’t solve the problem. It only encourages population growth. Building more roads doesn’t reduce traffic, and building more housing doesn’t reduce the demand for housing. It does hurt the planet and remove a lot of green space, though. Look at India and China.
- mikebenfield 3y ago> building more housing doesn’t reduce the demand for housing This is so obviously contrary to experience and common sense I'd characterize it as delusional.
- kazinator 3y agoI suppose it wouldn't be PC to mention immigration.
- ilikeitdark 3y agoHere in Barcelona, like many other cities, on top of this, many locals or long term outsiders, with Spanish salaries, are being priced out to lots of new professionals from outside Spain ,with much bigger paychecks. It's almost impossible to rent in the city for many locals.
- pcthrowaway 3y ago> Across the 27 EU member states, more than a quarter of Europeans between 15 and 29 years old reported living in overcrowded conditions in 2022 For those curious about what "overcrowding rate" means here, I assume it's this definition from Eurostat: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Glossary:Overcrowding_rate https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php... It's not entirely clear to me if this is intended to be the sum of the criteria, but even if it is, I suspect people taking a survey are not going to be able to parse that correctly. Also not defined: Whether bathrooms are considered "rooms" for this purpose. Assuming bathrooms are not considered separate rooms, it seems the only way to be overcrowded is if you have people sleeping in common areas, or more than 1 to a bedroom if not a couple (2 to a bedroom is fine for couples, 12-17 year olds of the same gender, or children under 12). I live in a city where the housing situation is quite dire and I still don't anyone between ages 18-29 living in such conditions. Lots of people do live in very tight spaces though (less than 75 square feet to a bedroom, with very little common area space) which to me seems like it should be considered overcrowded, but the definition given would consider this fine, whereas two unpartnered adults sharing a 600 square foot studio with a divider would be considered overcrowded
- betaby 3y agoEU, CA and USA are in denial of the fact of the rapid population growth.