7 ms·
Americans Saved $1.1T Less Than Previously Thought from 2017-2022
- lars512 3y agohttps://archive.ph/VlrjN https://archive.ph/VlrjN
- jihadjihad 3y ago> The reduction stems from an accounting adjustment that lowered personal income from mutual funds and real estate investment trusts. There is a good methodological discussion on the merits of this change, published back in May by the BEA [0]. > "At the same time, the inclusion of capital gains dividends, which flow to households, biases upward the estimates of personal income and saving from current production for the household sector. > Under the new treatment, BEA will remove income from capital gains from dividends paid by REITs (and, for consistency, from dividends paid by other corporate real estate businesses). This change will generally result in downward revisions to REIT dividends paid and offsetting upward revisions to undistributed profits of REITs, and thus business saving. This change will lead to similar downward revisions to dividends received by shareholders (households), to personal income, and to personal saving." 0: https://apps.bea.gov/scb/issues/2023/05-may/0523-ric-reit.htm https://apps.bea.gov/scb/issues/2023/05-may/0523-ric-reit.ht...
- idoh 3y agoHow is it justified to not include investment income channeled into savings as not part of overall savings rate? Money is fungible after all.
- Ericson2314 3y ago> The reduction stems from an accounting adjustment that lowered personal income from mutual funds and real estate investment trusts. This is adjusting the inflows not the outflows of rich people (and thus low marginal propensity to spend) people. So while every revision teaches us more things, this doesn't isn't really hitting "where the action is". Remember that in macroeconomics, saving is the break, and spending is the gas.
- jackmott42 3y agoI don't understand the last sentence, can you expound on what you mean?
- Guvante 3y agoBy most metrics used to measure economic success the economy as a whole is most "healthy" (aka productive) with little if any saving going on. Obviously that isn't true on smaller scales, living paycheck to paycheck isn't considered a good thing. It just means it is nuanced to discuss these problems from a Macroeconomic perspective. On the one hand saving a little is good for individuals on the other spending is better for the "economy".
- anonporridge 3y agoI think they mean that traditional economic wisdom is that high savings slows economic growth while high spending accelerates it. So, from the perspective of economic growth, we want people to spend as much as possible, not save. Beyond the money itself that is spent that spurs growth, you also can add on the fact that people with minimal savings are forced to work to survive. People with lots of savings are more inclined to lounge around and be unproductive. Of course, one could also argue that people with minimal savings are less creative, because they're in constant survival mode and grinding out the style of work they've always done.
- erikerikson 3y ago> we want people to spend as much as possible, That feels like a perversion of the credit industry. We can clarify that we want people to have as much excess income as possible, spending a fair percentage of it. If they're spending more than a sustainable amount, they are incurring excess and efficiencies and/or deficit spending which will have a suppressive effect on spending over the long term.
- yndoendo 3y agoSpending $5 on coffee is an economic transaction that lets that business use money to pay their employees, service their infrastructure, or re-invest in a new brewer; business to business transactions. Holding that $5 prevents any business to business transactions and possibly causes the company to constrict employees economy mobility or requires laying people off. By making the 1% richer through reduced taxation is actually economically harmful in the long run and reduces economic mobility. Same as politicians supporting budget cuts.
- drunner 3y agoInteresting, how does `Americans stashed away an average 8.3%` compare to the often stated ~50% have no emergency fund/savings. Does that mean those saving money are on average saving %16 of their income? Makes sense from a general bell curve/inequity point of view but just looking for some thoughts.
- SoftTalker 3y agoThe usual advice is to save at least 10%. First, that goes into your emergency fund. Once that is adequate, start investing for longer term goals/retirement. This requires you to have the discipline to not spend your emergency fund on Christmas shopping. It's for emergencies.
- coldbrewed 3y agoWhile it's true that the financial discipline needed to protect an emergency fund isn't as prevalent as it should be, it's important to remember that an emergency fund only lasts if you don't experience an emergency. From 2017-2022 we had a pandemic that caused an enormous number of personal emergencies; between layoffs, inflation, disease, death, and all of the associated costs it's safe to say that a lot of people may have wiped out their emergency fund just trying to survive.
- nradov 3y agoIt would be more accurate to say that government mismanagement of and irrational overreaction to the pandemic caused most of the financial emergencies.
- bcrosby95 3y agoOur emergency fund is more of a "shit happens" fund. Shit happens every year. $2k to fix the car. $10k to fix the leaky roof. $4k in emergency dental work. And that was just this year.
- cableshaft 3y ago
- lawisimportant 3y agomore like they were lying with data, oops
- lp0_on_fire 3y agoThis backpedaling looks familiar. Who would have thought that a couple thousand dollars of "stimulus" monies, your dollar being worth 20% less than it was a few years ago, record credit card debt, record wealth inequality between the have's and have-nots, and a completely screwed up housing market would lead to Americans saving "less than previously thought"... Remember, the people making fiscal policy have been citing "savings accrued during covid" every chance they can. The same chattering donor class, bureaucrats, and politicians that insist the economy is doing better than ever. The same chattering donor class, bureaucrats, and politicians, who redefined the meaning of "recession" when it was inconvenient to their policy goals. The same chattering donor class, bureaucrats, and politicians, who were gleefully calling for people to lose their jobs if they didn't get the latest iteration of a vaccine with questionable and overstated results.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> Remember, the people making fiscal policy have been citing "savings accrued during covid" every chance they can. That sounds pretty suspicious, except that this correction goes back well before covid, and the spike in 2020 and 2021 is just as huge with the new data. > The same chattering donor class, bureaucrats, and politicians, who redefined the meaning of "recession" when it was inconvenient to their policy goals. Look, "two quarters of shrinking GDP" is a really easy rule to apply, but it's so dependent on timing and ignores everything around it. Specifically, we had a single quarter with 7% growth, then two quarters that combined to 2.6% shrink, then a single quarter with 2.7% growth. I think it's fair to say that was not a recession, and the weird result in 2020 with -28.0% immediately followed by +34.8% is important to mention but also not a recession, so 2008 was the last actual recession in the US. > The same chattering donor class, bureaucrats, and politicians, who were gleefully calling for people to lose their jobs if they didn't get the latest iteration of a vaccine with questionable and overstated results. What did you find questionable that was in addition to any overstatement of results? And nobody wanted job losses, they just wanted people to try to fight the spread. Eventually enough spite built up, mostly against the people acting bad on purpose, but between a "make them lose their job" button and a "make them try (retroactively)" button I bet basically everyone you describe would have smacked the latter.
- Eumenes 3y agoNo shit. Rampant inflation, coupled with poor consumer spending habits such as buying expensive cars, being "house poor", iPhones, eating/drinking out non-stop, etc - def adds up.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]