8 ms·
The Ingenious Cardboard Bed
- lunaticlabs 3y agoI actually have a full queen size cardboard bed that looks similar to this, and they're amazing! I bought it as a temporary bed while I waited for my furniture to arrive during a cross-world move, and never gave it up. It's quite comfortable, and really easy to move, and includes under the bed drawers. I've been using it for 5 years now and its still holding up (with a matress, which these don't have, but still). My apartment is a different experience than the refugee camp for sure, but for all the people who are dispariging these vs. steel cots for their lack of durability, they're surprisingly tough. It'll easily survive a couple glass of water spilled on it without being destroyed, it won't handle a flood or a wet floor, but logistically a cardboard bed is amazing and works surprisingly well.
- jsndidneske 3y agoJust clean the floor and give them the mat you would put on the box. This is also a more robust and less wasteful method. They could instead make shelving and that would beore.usefull in a shelter
- ashout33 3y agoyeah I wonder why they don't do that. must have a reason?
- fisherjeff 3y agoWell bending all the way down to the floor is much more difficult for caregivers, for one thing.
- palmer_fox 3y agoPractical (bending down is harder), sanitary (the dirt is usually on the floor), safety (connecting any medical equipment is more dangerous, administering drugs is awkward and also more dangerous), etc. It's hard to impress some people with innovation.
- 0x6461188A 3y agoSometimes there are bugs on the ground.
- mainpassathome 3y agoit’s not very clear, but i think this is without a matress, like a camping cot it’s worth doing this because it raises the person up from the floor which if concrete drains heat quickly, or is less sanitary, and helps caregivers not bend down as much
- nulbyte 3y agoIt may seem less wasteful for someone who is rather limber, but it is not practical when some people have difficulty getting down onto or up off of the floor, particularly as we age.
- jtriangle 3y agoIf you're having that problem, look into DDPY yoga, they have a whole section on how to get up off the floor when you're not young and limber.
- waveBidder 3y agohaving slept on a mat on the floor for ~1 year until I dislocated my spouse's shoulder throwing a cockroach off the bed in a sleepy panic, I would strongly suggest against it.
- Aeolun 3y agoAre you trying to say this wouldn’t have happened in another bed? I’m not sure how being raised off the floor would change things.
- waveBidder 3y agoyes, they're way less likely to crawl up. only ever had it happen on the floor
- amelius 3y agoA floor can get relatively cold, and may act as a heat sink.
- Iulioh 3y agoThat is not a bed, that's just a flat and fucking uncomfortable surface Would you really want to stay on a surface with no barriers for you to block from falling down while sick? Turn around and you will be thankful for the medical staff already present
- bloopernova 3y agoIf you're a refugee you might be glad of a place to lie down that's not on the cold floor. Or dirty. Sure the comfort level is pretty low, but maybe futon style mats could be used?
- roughly 3y agoThey spent half the article describing what this is replacing and every picture of it in any realistic situation has mat on top of it.
- Iulioh 3y agoSorry but i see a very cost efficient waste of money
- dukeyukey 3y agoIf that's all the local industry can produce, it's better than nothing.
- Iulioh 3y agoHonestly i could even argue that in fact it is not better than nothing. A bad solution is a problem because it would lead to not providing a good solution.
- palmer_fox 3y agoThis is a puzzling display of confidence. Have you ever slept on the ground after a long hard day of dealing with a natural or a man-made disaster? Getting into ANY bed is the only thing you can think about (this plus eating, of course). Being able to distribute 10K beds on the day they are first needed is an incredible advantage over having to wait for several days for more comfortable beds (it's not even clear whether they are indeed more comfortable).
- 0x6461188A 3y agoWhere can I buy one?
- lardo 3y agoBuy? They’re free. https://store.usps.com/store/product/shipping-supplies/priority-mail-flat-rate-large-box-P_LARGE_FRB https://store.usps.com/store/product/shipping-supplies/prior...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 0x6461188A 3y agoI meant the bed for a normal sized human.
- skeltoac 3y agoWarning: keep floor dry.
- throw9away6 3y agoAnd perfect flat and level
- Scoundreller 3y agoI mean, you could shave off edges as required to match the floor. Just don't move it after.
- thr0waway001 3y agoCool! Although I sweat so much that I'd destroy that thing in one evening.
- gruez 3y agoA plastic sheet would solve that issue
- treme 3y agoYour sleep quality is likely suffering quite bad if you sweat that much regularly while asleep
- thr0waway001 3y agoThat it does. That it does. I live in a hot ass condo with no air conditioning and only a fan. So happy fall is here. In the summer I just ... bake.
- treme 3y agoSurely you can afford AC. Not getting quality sleep is akin to driving drunk for tech people imho.
- willprice89 3y agoI wonder how they do the 350kg load test. I can't imagine the corners of the flat piece will support very much weight at all.
- alsuren 3y agoI noticed that in the photos they're all sitting above the bit where the reinforcements are at the edge of the bed. I couldn't see any reinforcement in the middle, ~but there might be some on more detailed plans~ the videos on their site don't show any support either, but I am willing to believe that the load can be distributed by the pair of cardboard sheets. You would hope that the 350kg is from a point load in the middle of the bed. If anyone finds out, I would also be interested to know.
- AustinDev 3y agoIf you like this watch the 'Japanology' episode about cardboard. It's free on the NHK app on Apple TV. Thats where I first learned of this and all the other amazing carboard things they make in Japan.
- devit 3y agoSeems very uncomfortable and only useful if someone really can't afford the $100-300 for a normal camping air or self-inflating pad, which seems miles better than this. And if you are OK with uncomfortable then a simple closed-cell foam mat, while possibly a bit more expensive, seems far more reliable, durable and cleanable than this.
- 14 3y agoThe specially mentioned refugee camps who often come with no money or supplies and only the clothing on their back. Or disasters where people gather in haste with no access to supplies as infrastructure has been destroyed. The logistics of sending larger mats is also harder. These can be made with existing facilities in any large city and deployed almost immediately. Of course there are better options or even sleeping on the floor would work in a pinch.
- ShakataGaNai 3y agoYour options are sleeping on a concrete floor (if you're lucky) or more likely dirt... or this bed? This is an amazing option. Is it the bestest life of luxury? Hell no. But your home has been destroyed by a war or disaster and you're lucky to get a warm meal. Now you get a bed? Even if not an amazing bed? It's worlds better than the alternative.
- vGPU 3y agoI have a cheap folding metal cot that is likely a significantly better alternative for not much difference in price.
- coprogram 3y agoThese cardboard beds cost 16-17 euros to produce. There are 100 million displaced people in the world. Your cheap folding metal cot will never be so cheap as to even come close to being a competitor on economic terms.
- 3y ago
- 0x6461188A 3y agoAccording to the article the startup is called "Humanitaria". Where can I find more information about them? Is there a link? I would like to buy a couple of these beds for when relatives visit.
- ShakataGaNai 3y agoIt was linked at the VERY end of the article: https://www.humanitaria.es/ https://www.humanitaria.es/
- devit 3y agoBuy something comfortable instead, such as an Exped Megamat 15 LXW plus a memory foam topper and maybe a foldable cot.
- soperj 3y agoThis is a bug problem waiting to happen no? Couldn't imagine these lasting for any length of time. Silverfish city.
- ShakataGaNai 3y agoIs the purpose of your Amazon box to last forever? No. They said at the very start, the purpose is to be able to CHEAPLY and QUICKLY produce and deliver beds when disaster strikes. If you've months to prepare, then you can buy and ship decent beds from anywhere in the world via sea/train/truck. But if you absolutely positively need 10,000 beds tomorrow? This is the answer.
- 23B1 3y agoA couple criticisms of this, having been in more than a few rough parts of the world including refugee camps: 1. Cardboard will almost certainly soak up the liquids and smells of a place like a refugee camp, which are typically not in nice flat, dry warehouses. This is bad when you need to be able to clean/sterilize the beds. Structurally, once these are soaked I imagine they're unusable again. 2. Not sure about those corners; these beds become your home and your 'zone' and you spend a LOT of time there, often sitting upright; I wouldn't want to plop down on one of those. Also, most people don't lay perfectly flat – and they often have a child with them which could create an imbalance. 3. Storage. Crime in refugee camps is rampant; folks often use the cots with legs as 'storage' and drape blankets over their personal goods to conceal them – especially important if you have kids, traveling with your most valuable currency, critical paperwork, etc. 4. Fire hazard which is SUBSTANTIAL in these scenarios. I like the idea and I see where they might be helpful, but I could think of a handful of design changes that might make it a lot better. a) It's basically a 'flat pack' design and I'd imagine there's other materials out there that might be more stable/durable/lightweight. b) Probably we could spend some time thinking through the geometry, for example, adding 'feet' at the far corners might make it more stable on uneven ground.
- defrost 3y agoThe soaking and required dry floor critique is a significant factor. The "wouldn't want to plop down on one of those" point might be imagined, the article asserts that: In Humanitaria's cardboard bed design, the cardboard bed can support up to 350 kilograms of weight, well above the 150 kilograms supported by the usual camping beds used by NGOs. which certainly bears looking into - cardboard with internal corrugated layers is stronger than many think. As for Storage - these are literally flip top (unfloored) "boxes" - lifting the top reveals a walled interior, easily as 'safe' | 'secure' as a stuff on a bed with a blanket over the top.
- h2odragon 3y agoImagine how much more durable it would be if they waxed the cardboard. Prolly make it non-recyclable tho. Makes me suspect the point of the effort is not the people using the product. The sales literature here is certainly aimed at the people who want to purchase lack of concern for details like utility, along with their humanitarian donations. Edit: makes me wonder what the cardboard "shipper coffins" cost. it appears the funeral industry keeps the prices high but it seems like any box company should be able to slap these together, with custom printing, at competitive prices.
- jtriangle 3y agoTodays coffins are sponsored by RAGE SHADOW LEGENDS ...lord take me now
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- semiquaver 3y agoThe article seems to be making misleading claims to make a questionable design sound more beneficial in numeric terms than it actually is. The first words you see in the article are: > The current cost of buying 1,000 camp beds for a refugee camp is $110,000 to $220,000, it takes two weeks to produce them, another two weeks to ship them (by land or sea) and 24 hours to set them up. By comparison, 1,000 Humanitaria beds cost $17,000, can be produced in hours on existing, readily-available packaging machinery in every major city in the world, delivered folded flat by plane next day and can be set up in 20 minutes. 24 hours vs 20 minutes makes me think they are not comparing apples to apples. Either they are comparing the time it takes to set up 1000 beds with that of a single one or they are claiming the total setup time for these beds from flat pack to usable is 1.2s. And 1000 camp beds in 24 hours is only 1.4 minutes per bed. Elsewhere in the article they say that “A single person can set up 70 beds in an hour”, which is 51 seconds, not so far off from the camp bed figure. Also, why on earth would we be manufacturing new beds for each new occupant in every case? Tube and canvas camp beds are durable and reusable. Just because these beds necessarily can only be used when brand new and must be discarded after doesn’t mean you get to assume the same negative qualities for the thing you are comparing against. The $100-200 claimed wholesale price for camp cots is also an order of magnitude off reality, as a few seconds browsing alibaba can confirm. This is the worst kind of credulous “behold the power of design!” puff piece, complete with an insulting comment questioning the intelligence of the people at humanitarian agencies that this work is supposed to benefit: > In fact, the beds used by NGOs all over the world are still camping beds with an average price between €100 and €200 (US$110 to $220) EACH, and because no-one had ever looked at it logically before, they take between five and 20 minutes each to assemble and are not suitable for transport in large quantities. Humanitarian work should be praised, but not if it’s counterproductive self-congratulation.
- yesbut 3y agoIts a virtue signalling advertisement for a cardboard bed subscription service to these NGOs. Just give people durable beds. The cardboard beds would be broken after the first use. Just more garbage. Not very eco. Like you said, tube and canvas beds are durable and can be reused. What those cardboard bed makers are after is a subscription service.
- oftenwrong 3y agoI am surprised that cardboard (corrugated fibreboard) furniture is not more common. It is an impressively durable and strong material despite its low cost. We could all have the option of cheap, lightweight, easy-to-move, utilitarian, eco-friendly furniture. There are only a few companies, like https://www.chairigami.com/ https://www.chairigami.com/ , that produce such furniture.
- quickthrower2 3y agoWater/dampness might be an issue?
- jfim 3y agoIKEA has some pieces, such as the lack table (https://www.ikea.com/us/en/p/lack-side-table-white-30449908/ https://www.ikea.com/us/en/p/lack-side-table-white-30449908/).
- expertentipp 3y agoThis bloody table... it's everywhere and it chips and disintegrates under slightest stress. One expects to be able to sit on a table at least. Be careful what you wish for when asking for a "furnished apartment".
- roflyear 3y agoYah this table is awful. But it is $14 I guess. Lol.
- mutex_man 3y agoI just checked their website and their prices are insane. $250 for a cardboard bookcase? I can get significantly nicer stuff for less than that at a bunch of other places.
- GlassOwAter 3y agoLol they say their 3 ply cardboard is the important part. I might have to make my own furniture. https://www.packagewarehouse.com/boxes/cardboard-boxes/corrugated-cardboard/triplewall-corrugated-cardboard-sheets/ https://www.packagewarehouse.com/boxes/cardboard-boxes/corru...
- metadat 3y ago> In Humanitaria's cardboard bed design, the cardboard bed can support up to 350 kilograms of weight, well above the 150 kilograms supported by the usual camping beds used by NGOs. That's enough for.. menage a trois where each participant weighs 257 lbs. Impressive if true. Wasn't there something about the cardboard beds at the Olympics not holding up and collapsing from a regular pounding by 2 people? Most Olympians don't weigh even 200 lbs.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- j1mmie 3y agoAnd once you eat it, they can stuff you in the very coffin-shaped bed/box you lay on, and bury you in an eco-friendly grave.
- maphew 3y agoTry reading the article without an adblocker. It's basically one long ad for packing machines and extras. "Build cool thing with cardboard" is to get people in the door.
- jeffrallen 3y agoThere are a well known list of priorities in a humanitarian relief situation. Beds are not on it.
- uoaei 3y agoDo you have a source for this list? I suspect it's not as well known as you hope.
- jeffrallen 3y agoHere is an example of MSF's priority list: https://evaluation.msf.org/sites/default/files/2021-12/The%20Priorities%20Check-Lists%2C%20Indicators%2C%20Standards.pdf https://evaluation.msf.org/sites/default/files/2021-12/The%2...
- lwhi 3y agoWouldn't a camp bad have mattress? Isn't a camp bed going to have a longer life span?
- sandworm101 3y ago"The cost of 1,000 beds for a refugee camp ranges from €100,000 to €200,000 (US$110 to $220) a bed" What? Has nobody involved with this article ever seen a military camp? A military cot is setup in seconds, can be shipped basically instantly, will not disintegrate in contact with water, and has served millions of soldiers well for decades. Amazon can deliver one to my house for less than 100$. If you need beds for people, dont obsesse over labels. It doesnt matter whether it is sold as a bed or as a cot. What matters is having a safe place to put it.
- uoaei 3y agoIn the choice between sponsoring the costs of $100*1000 beds plus chartering planes and logistics personnel to bring them from wherever they may be warehoused, or calling up packaging manufacturers and truckers close to the disaster site to churn out and ship pallets of beds in hours, it's a no-brainer. Have you ever worked in logistics? Products don't magically materialize when you click "Order now" on a website. They either have to be stored somewhere (somehow always inconvenient vs where you want them to be) or manufactured to order. The reason the military is so good at this is because they learned in WWII that winning wars is largely a matter of logistics and attrition. Their movements are planned weeks or months in advance and they're constantly shipping things around to accommodate those plans. (Ironically this made them vulnerable to guerrilla warfare and its emphasis on stochastic sabotage tactics, which is why they lost in Vietnam and the Middle East, but that's besides the point.) Commercial logistics systems don't have this kind of central planning because of the fetishism around market forces so you are at the whim of whoever has the stuff you want (or the means of production) when you want it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- uoaei 3y agoAre commenters here intentionally ignoring the point or just not bothering to read the article closely enough to get it? The first 24-48 hours of disaster relief invariably sees a need for a field hospital and temporary accommodations to be set up. Other NGOs will be flying in with more semi-permanent solutions (days, weeks, months) while the first responders are setting up. This product is for the first responders. If you can address a 1000-bed need immediately (injuries being expected to be distributed as a power law with few major injuries and many minor ones), then only need 100 beds after the several days these cardboard beds are likely to last, that buys the logistics people with the semi-permanent solutions enough time to come in and set something up more amenable even if those amenities take a bit longer to pack, ship, unpack, and install. Water could be an issue, except plastic sheets pack even better than cardboard and are fully waterproof. Bugs could be an issue, except by the time these beds have become infested better amenities will have already arrived. And cardboard can be cut up and reused for quite a few things. Based on the attitudes of these commenters I'd wager they can't imagine the human ingenuity that becomes available in such dire situations.
- sandworm101 3y agoRefugee camps mean sanitation problems. Hygiene is always an issue. These cardboard beds as absorbant, impossible to clean, and full of void spaces. And as paper they are likely even edible by something unpleasant. They will quickly become literal nests for everything but humans. For a refugee camp you want hard surfaces that can be sprayed with bleech and no uncleanable crevices or voids. In most any refugee situaion, these things will become roach and rat motels within days.
- Ekaros 3y agoThey talk about production being in every major city. But would those be available in a crisis? At that moment? And on other hand a few thousand of the more expensive priced ones don't seem that big of investment on global scale. Just store them near major cities with airports... Same thing...
- Jemm 3y agoUnsupported edges right where people will sit.