11 ms·
CFPB kicks off rulemaking to remove medical bills from credit reports
- drak0n1c 3y agoHopefully they have a plan for a better mechanism to discourage frivolous ambulance calls and ER visits. Those resources are overloaded by casual abuse resulting in higher costs and wait times for those who truly need emergency care. Without an alternate disincentive that problem will only get worse with this change.
- shadowgovt 3y agoThis is yet another problem that could, hypothetically, be addressed by centralizing / single-payering the system. With one administrator having access to all that data, it would be straightforward to see where ERs and ambulances are being over-used for non-emergencies and address that in the community with both more funding for preventative care and intervention / education initiatives to get people using preventative care.
- jkingsman 3y agoI think having cost be the anti-abuse disincentive is the worst of all worlds -- cost is clearly not an effective deterrent of abuse given our current state of overutilization. It IS a deterrent in the case of avoidance, or arguably worse, a punishment in the case of attendance, for those who DO need it. I'm a volunteer EMT and my org runs free clinics staffed by doctors+nurses at major events to handle emergencies. It's truly free -- we don't bill anyone, insurance included -- but I've had people in dire medical distress avoid coming with me because they're afraid of the bill. Hell, I've had people in the midst of full blown psychosis and their single lucid thought is to yell "DON'T TAKE ME I CAN'T AFFORD AN AMBULANCE BILL" and my heart breaks. The American healthcare system is continuously setting and raising the high water mark for how deeply in failure the system is, but bankrupting people is not the holistic solution we need, in my opinion.
- init2null 3y agoPeople make "frivolous" visits because they are legally required to stabilize patients. This is what passes for a social safety net in the US, and we have failed in developing anything better for those not covered by Medicaid. People often make frivolous ambulance calls if they have trouble getting to the hospital or PCP. There are often reasons, and we would have a more reliable, more humane system if we focused on cheaper care over penalizing the poor. Providing only guaranteed emergency care is absurdly expensive.
- wilg 3y agoIIRC this gap exists in states (guess which!) that opted out of Medicaid expansion. So a solution is available if states take it.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoThis is a nationwide problem, it's not restricted to states that opted out of expansion. Federal Law requires that ERs treat anyone who comes in, regardless of ability to pay. Until the poor are able to access other resources like urgent care clinics, this is going to continue to be a problem.
- wilg 3y agoWell the poor have access to Medicaid, and if they make more than the Medicaid maximum, subsidized ACA plans. In neither of those cases should you have to go to the ER for non-emergency care. I believe the biggest problem is the coverage gap I mentioned, where 10 states for political reasons have not opted into the higher Medicaid maximums which creates a gap between Medicaid and ACA. This is dumb as hell. I am having trouble figuring out where exactly the other coverage gaps are or how big they are. I'm sure there are some. I would definitely support a switch to single payer to smooth out this mess.
- init2null 3y agoTo be fair, someone making $25,000 a year will have almost as much trouble paying out of pocket for an MRI as someone making $15,000. But the former won't qualify for Medicaid and the heavily-discounted health insurance won't do much to help with their first $10,000 of medical debt. Good but worthless advice to the majority living without any savings: don't get sick and don't get injured. Can anyone blame them if they avoid expensive testing? Medicaid is a great bandage, but the US needs a better system.
- sp0rk 3y ago> Hopefully they have a plan for a better mechanism to discourage frivolous ambulance calls and ER visits. Those resources are overloaded by casual abuse resulting in higher costs and wait times for those who truly need emergency care. Do you have any statistics regarding this? I'm sure there are some people that use the services unnecessarily, but is it really enough that it's a significant issue?
- indymike 3y ago> Without an alternate disincentive that problem will only get worse with this change. The ER is the only place that people can get care when they are uninsured and not wealthy. Your family doc will say no. Immediate care will say no. But the ER can't say no. People in this situation are mostly upper lower class and lower middle class who have lost their jobs or fell into an administrative crack. If you are poor, you will qualify for something to cover the cost. It's terrifying and is probably one of the best arguments for reform there is.
- amluto 3y ago> Without an alternate disincentive The problem isn’t (IMO) an insufficient disincentive — it’s lack of a credible alternative. I have perfectly fine insurance, and getting an appointment for a merely slightly urgent issue is a pain in the rear. If I’m traveling, it’s almost impossible. COVID made this all worse. Last year, I saw a resort clinic (well staffed by assorted medical professionals) turning away anyone with any symptoms of illness and sending them straight to the ER (10 miles or so away through the snow) because they “might have COVID”.
- foobiekr 3y agoUrgent care facilities ought to be offloading ERs in most cases. Something as trivial as needing some stitches is an ER visit instead. I think this kind of ends up trivializing ER. That and drug seeking...
- brewdad 3y agoI've had to use urgent care a half dozen times over the past 20 years. In all but one case, they sent me to the ER because they didn't want to be responsible for my care outcomes. None of them were really "emergencies". I'm lucky if there is an actual MD on premises at my in-network urgent care.
- Auracle 3y agoOur local urgent care closes at 7:30pm on weekdays and 4pm on weekends. That doesn’t help.
- foobiekr 3y agoIt helps for half the day.
- _jal 3y agoThe hilarious thing is that the emergency room mandate has long been used as an excuse for opposing universal coverage. People used to say thing like "nobody in America is dying because they can't go to the hospital," as if that was bar. Now it apparently serves an excuse for claiming ER should cost more. Truly a universal policy, I guess.
- corinroyal 3y agoImagine thinking a visit to the ER was "frivolous". As if significant numbers of people would subject themselves to an ER for fun. Imagine looking at a situation in which significant numbers of people have no other access to care but ERs and think, "Those freeloaders!" What sort of twisted mirror-world ethics are these? How does one get to the point where they could type this, read it over, and hit send? You'd think the shame alone would be lethal.
- jorblumesea 3y ago[flagged]
- Uvix 3y agoWe pay for it one way or another. I'd rather pay for actual usage instead of getting taxed for stuff I might or might not have used.
- ericmay 3y agoIn the US you get it from both ends. You pay for insurance, they decline your claims, you have co-pays, minimums, etc. and then you pay more than you otherwise might because the hospitals have to cover those who need care but don’t have insurance. That’s why your aspirin is $300. You’re paying for lots of other people. And then you also pay taxes for Medicare and Medicaid programs, the VA, and other various, duplicative programs. I don’t have a strong opinion on either system on its own philosophical merits, but what I see today is that the health insurance industry is a jobs program with extra cost added in for profits and I’m just not really sure what the point of it is. If we are willing to let people die on the streets and refuse care, let’s get the government out and just go all-private. If we aren’t willing to do that we should drop the jobs programs and waste (insurance) and just go with tax-based healthcare and eliminate redundant programs (Medicare, Medicaid, etc.) and also the subsidization of insurance companies. Getting people the care they need to is almost certainly going to lead to a healthier and happier population that’s more productive as well, which is another economic benefit.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gnulinux 3y agoAbsolutely not true and this is simply American propaganda. The truth is American insurance industry is an extremely inefficient middleware that makes everything more expensive and worse than other developed countries. [1] [1] "US spends most on health care but has worst health outcomes among high-income countries, new report finds " https://www.cnn.com/2023/01/31/health/us-health-care-spending-global-perspective/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2023/01/31/health/us-health-care-spendin... Not to mention it's complete lunacy to think taxes are low in the US. I live in US but also pay taxes in a different country (that I'm a citizen of) that has healthcare and all the Federal tax I pay to US is significantly more (the other country is a fraction of fraction of US taxes). Not to mention, US taxes are extraordinarily, out-of-this-world level complicated if you have foreign assets so you pay thousands of $$$ to a CPA as well.
- dylan604 3y agoI hope this truly has the effect that it is meant to have. But being the pessimistic type towards US healthcare and insurance and credit agencies, I really expect this to go nowhere, or become so watered down that it is essentially meaningless.
- iuhfdsakljhfads 3y agoDoes this mean I don't have to pay any medical bills unless they sue me? Awesome, that's one less thing!
- CPLX 3y agoI mean by the logic you're using you don't have to pay ANY bill or abide by ANY contract unless someone goes to court to make you.
- p1mrx 3y agoUnder this system, what would be the reason to pay your medical bills?
- matthewaveryusa 3y agoYour wages can still be garnished.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoMy understanding is that medical debt would still be collectible and could be sold to third party debt collectors. It just couldn't hurt your credit report.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoWhy should people pay their medical debt that only exists because Congress refuses to implement a functioning national healthcare delivery system? If Congress refuses to act, the executive branch can sidestep them providing temporary relief until Congressional reps turn over enough to pass material legislation to fix the system.
- nradov 3y agoWhy should people pay for food when Congress refuses to hand out free food for everyone?
- toomuchtodo 3y ago> when Congress refuses to hand out free food for everyone? Can you say that when USDA food security and nutrition assistance benefits are around $183B a year? Certainly, it isn't for everyone, but for those in need. Why would we not extend similar policy to healthcare in a more efficient manner? No one is arguing for free healthcare (although that phrase is used colloquially), but a more efficient payer and delivery system, versus all of the bloat between patients and providers as exists today (insurance companies, pharmacy benefit managers, etc). Sibling comment by willcipriano touches on this bloat. https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/ag-and-food-statistics-charting-the-essentials/food-security-and-nutrition-assistance/?topicId=d7627f77-6cee-4ab9-bbb9-8c74d4778941 https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/ag-and-food-statistic...
- user3939382 3y agoThe newest FICO models already exclude this debt, though this is a much more significant step since most lenders and loan types you care about use very old FICO models that do include it and are unlikely to be updated any time soon.
- nradov 3y agoDo you know why lenders still use very old FICO models? Is this just inertia, or are the new models more expensive, or do the old models predict default risk better for those loan types?
- FireBeyond 3y agoMore expensive, for one. That's why CreditKarma and other 'free score' services often use Vantage, rather than FICO.
- dmoy 3y agoI think up until last year it was federal policy for Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac to use fico 5, and the rest of the industry kinda follows. Now I think they can use a new model, but it's probably some inertia on changing.
- user3939382 3y agoJust a complete guess. Banks and related insurance are using historical data with prediction models to forecast risk. Once the FICO version changes all that data is apples to oranges and the forecasting is less accurate.
- InTheArena 3y agoThe big reason is that the different scores come out of the models. That may seem counter-intuitive, but models tend to be very tied to specific populations in specific ranges, and stability is often as valuable as predictability. Different model behavior - up or down - means that financial institutions have to retest their entire strategy to make sure that it doesn't screw up the segmentation and models that they have layered on top of various credit scores. This is not a trivial or short process - It's pretty common to see 6 month and 12 month champion/challenger tests. Even then, assuming that there is not a significant lift in predictability (unlikely as the FICO score is good at what it does) or addressability (do people who previously had a thin file now have enough data to make a decision) then you also end up looking and saying that it's not worth the changes to move to a newer score. Also, scores are incredibly regulated. Proving that the model you layer on top of the FICO score doesn't have a disparate impact (something standing in as a proxy to a protected bit of information such as ethnicity) is expensive. VantageScore doesn't really change this; it's a copycat of the FICO score that came about because the credit unions don't like having the score aspect out of their control and would rather people just pay them instead of an independent third party instead. The only thing that really would change the score in any way is additional data - but social media mining for scores is not acceptable outside of China (where their score predicts compliance with government not credit risk).
- adamsb6 3y agoWhat are going to be the second-order consequences of such a policy? Are providers going to run credit checks on you before they agree to take you on as a patient? Require that you sign a document that gives them the right to garnish your wages for non-payment? Require up-front payment for services? Increase prices to cover the revenue lost to people that realize how little consequence there is for non-payment?
- jfghi 3y agoBe less profitable by not price gouging?
- cyanydeez 3y agoIn America, hospitals cannot refuse emergency care. So, while price gouging and insurance gouging are a thing, the actual hospitals may be poorly compensated in many places. That's why rural areas are losing hospitals.
- jfghi 3y agoI agree entirely but just don’t think that credit reports solve or help anything in this domain.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> don’t think that credit reports solve or help anything in this domain They help hospitals collect. Not saying that makes it right. Just that it has a purpose beyond greed and gouging.
- jfghi 3y agoI’d have to see data in order to confirm this is true. Once a delinquency gets placed on a credit report paying the bill doesn’t help the person that owes. It also assumes that the people not paying are choosing to do so rather than not being able to. Given the debts are sold at a steep discount, I’d say it’s more efficient to have lower prices up front which could potentially be affordable for more of the customers.
- consz 3y agoI’ll repost my comment from a recent thread, but this article is a surprise to me, I thought this had already been the case for years? Reposted comment — As far as I can tell, this is the correct way to handle this? I haven’t paid attention to any medical bills sent in the mail since I started working 15 years ago (I generally pay what they ask at the point of service), and I’ve never noticed any consequences (no denial of service anywhere, has never shown up in any way on my credit report, etc) — as far as my experience has shown, any bills sent after the fact are completely optional to pay.
- rqtwteye 3y agoMy ex had collectors calling her several times a day for months while she was disputing a bill. It probably depends on whether the hospital writes the bill off or sells it to collectors.
- wizerdrobe 3y agoI feel for your ex, I have three (3) in office visits covered by my insurance that are overdue as of August. I’ve had to go back and forth on the phone in a Kafka-hell to get my insurance to cover a covered visit because of some opaque clerical error (and I write medical insurance review software and I’m still confused as to who is to blame…). Insurance issued a payment last month finally, but the doctor has yet to recognize it so I still get reminders on being “late” for a bill I don’t ultimately owe. I cannot imagine how infuriated I would be if I were being punished on my credit for someone else’s clerical error.
- rqtwteye 3y ago"I’ve had to go back and forth on the phone in a Kafka-hell to get my insurance to cover a covered visit because of some opaque clerical error" the same happened to my ex. Something had gone wrong between hospital and insurance and both refused to fix it. Which left her in between trying to figure this out while trying to recover. It's really infuriating that they can treat people that way. Once you experience this together with billing for things that never happened and insurance refusing things they have to cover, you can only conclude that insurances and hospitals are basically fraudsters that for some reason are allowed to get away with it.
- hnrodey 3y agoI think it should be acceptable that unpaid medical debt appears on the credit report. The medical debt should be removed once the debt is paid. The above is for medical debt only and how I would prefer the system to work. There are other good comments about possible second and third order effects from such changes to debt reporting.
- Madmallard 3y agoGreat time for disabled people to die because they won’t be able to get care. Disabled people can’t pay for psychotic medical bills as it is and this will just result in medical providers denying care without upfront pay.
- mehlmao 3y agoI've never had a doctor run a credit report on me before, have you?
- Madmallard 3y agoorganizations will start doing it to protect profits probably
- kevmo 3y ago[flagged]
- loco5niner 3y agogrift?
- jowea 3y agoGraft is a word too. > graft (countable and uncountable, plural grafts) > (uncountable) Corruption in official life. > (uncountable) Illicit profit by corrupt means, especially in public life.
- loco5niner 3y agoInteresting. That is a completely different (and legitimate) use of the word graft than I'm used to.
- dantheman 3y agoHow about just enforce fraud laws and mandate up front billing/estimates. Like we do everywhere else?
- dang 3y agoPlease don't start predictable flamewars on HN, no matter which nation or which sort of healthcare system you favor. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- kevmo 3y agoDo not think I was doing that, but will (continue to) keep community rules in mind. Thank you for modding!
- seatac76 3y agoTangential but kudos to Rohit Chopra, he has done a stellar job at CFPB, between the credit reporting changes and the elimination of bank fees alone he has had quite the impact. Just a few years it looked more likely that the CFPB would be dissolved.
- capital_guy 3y agoI agree that Chopra is excellent at his job. Unfortunately, It's still in danger of being dissolved. The Supreme Court is hearing a case in October challenging the legality of the agency's funding mechanism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumer_Financial_Protection_Bureau_v._Community_Financial_Services_Association_of_America%2C_Limited https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumer_Financial_Protection_...
- voldacar 3y ago>Its structure included a director that could not be fired by the President except for cause, and the ability to request funding from the Federal Reserve rather than the United States Congress I mean, that does sound pretty insane
- gmerc 3y agoDoes it in the light of how the US government actually works?
- leereeves 3y agoTrying to prevent some future elected government from changing course? I can see the appeal, but yeah, it sounds like a bad precedent.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- MarkMarine 3y ago
- clircle 3y agoGet ready for more debt.