8 ms·
The left talks about this all of the time, as do the middle and right. Pretending otherwise makes me question whether the author is actually trying to help or s
by acdha 3y ago
The left talks about this all of the time, as do the middle and right. Pretending otherwise makes me question whether the author is actually trying to help or simply sell his book.
- hosh 3y agoI'm curious, can you give examples? I hear this issue pretty loudly from the right, but not really much from the left. I know ordinary people talk about this issue, but it isn't the same as people in positions of power or influence.
- crazygringo 3y agoBasically all of the liberal publications treat it as a major topic every so often. A hugely shared article from 2 months ago in WaPo: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/07/10/christine-emba-masculinity-new-model/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/07/10/christine... Also in the Atlantic last year: https://www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/archive/2022/10/21-reader-views-on-the-masculinity-crisis/671703/ https://www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/archive/2022/10/21-r... This is just off the top of my head, but it's easy to do a Google search.
- junofan 3y agoOpinion pieces are cool, but have you seen any politicians in positions of power advance debate? What’s the Biden administration’s agenda for men?
- happytoexplain 3y agoFirst, a president's administration is not "the left" or "the right". In fact, it's frequently just "the lesser of two evils", as we so often hear from the voters, depending on the particular policy topic. Second, an administration not having "an agenda" for an issue as intractable/abstract as mental health is not a sign that they don't genuinely care. That said, I certainly agree that the president - in fact, all presidents, left or right - have paid no more than lip service to men's societal struggles, image issues, mental health, etc, but that is clearly not the driving thesis in this thread.
- crazygringo 3y agoYou might want to read the first WaPo piece I linked. It's precisely about how while liberals are recognizing the negative effects of the crisis of masculinity, they haven't been able to converge on solutions. And how that's a problem.
- UncleOxidant 3y agoHas the Overton window shifted to the right so much that The Atlantic is now considered liberal? It always seemed pretty centrist.
- WatchDog 3y agoThis media bias chart[0] seems to put them squarely in the left. Disclaimer, I'm not very familiar with either The Atlantic, nor who runs allsides.com and whatever biases they may have. https://www.allsides.com/media-bias/media-bias-chart https://www.allsides.com/media-bias/media-bias-chart
- vehemenz 3y agoIt's been a liberal publication for a long time. I think you might have it backwards though. If the Overton window shifts right, then The Atlantic would be considered more liberal, wouldn't it? If anything, some of the other journalistic institutions jumped the shark a bit from 2015-2020, which might make The Atlantic look more centrist than it really is, though it remains fundamentally liberal.
- anon776 3y agoOnly took a few min to find these. But regardless, it is very loud on the right because they feel its a problem or a source of a problem. Where the left looks at it as just a sign of the times or a progression or even a phase. Things were pretty non-masculine back in the late 70s and early 80s but nobody seems to care about that. I hate using the catch all of blaming social media but it does play a part in the attention to "issues". I could post a bunch of links but here are two relevant ones: https://www.cnn.com/style/article/masculinity-for-the-modern-world/index.html https://www.cnn.com/style/article/masculinity-for-the-modern... https://www.msnbc.com/opinion/msnbc-opinion/boys-arent-growing-conservative-just-not-politics-rcna98222 https://www.msnbc.com/opinion/msnbc-opinion/boys-arent-growi... Also the article tries to pin male graduation rates to masculinity but makes no mention of 300% tuition and crippling debt. I hate these types of articles that try take one issue and make it the scapegoat for all these complex problems. This over simplification of lifes complexities and how much things suck really need to stop.
- deaddodo 3y agoThey're referencing the common "toxic masculinity" talking points. I, personally, have always seen that more as displacing/blaming versus addressing legitimate issues. A common example would be the topic of male suicide, which is usually addressed as either "well, women try to kill themselves more often and that's totally not an indicator of attention seeking behavior versus genuine depression and fatigue with life" or "toxic masculinity and the patriarchy creates all of the problems for men". Both of which ignore pangender expectations and influences on the average (versus in-power) male experience. There's no doubt that the American left (and other Western nations' equivalents) diminishes male issues or treats them as unimportant due to the perspective that men created and control all of those issues. Useful for political influence, but useless for discourse or problem solving.
- hosh 3y agoI have a book on toxic masculinity on my shelf, and it is written as a deep exploration of psychology, archetypes, etc. The usual rhetoric I hear about toxic masculinity is very far away from the contents of that book. It is really easy to use that phrase in an aggressive way. Though, interestingly enough, Pixar’s Buzz Lightyear movie was written by someone who has thoroughly studied this. By that token, so can the contrast between Iron Man and Captain America in the MCU. Ironically enough, some of the very problems brought up by the right can be understood in an insightful way with this lens.
- badlucklottery 3y agoOff the top of my head, the left talks a lot about gun suicides (and how to improve the situation). Why this is relevant to the discussion: The gun suicide rate is up for teens: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2023/07/27/guns-suicides-all-time-high-2022/70476645007/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2023/07/27/guns-s... Men are far more likely commit suicide by gun: https://preventfirearmsuicide.efsgv.org/about-firearm-suicide/statistics/ https://preventfirearmsuicide.efsgv.org/about-firearm-suicid... Unfortunately, the news tends to focus hard on the "mass shooting" angle instead of the suicide rate when discussing safe storage and red flag laws.
- wGEric 3y agoThe left talks about stagnate wages, rising costs of college, and healthcare all the time. They talk about it as issues for everyone and not just men. Raising minimum wage helps everyone including men. Making college cheaper and easier to access helps everyone including men. Free healthcare helps everyone including men.
- NickC25 3y agoThey do, but they also vote in politicians who don't really do much to help those issues beyond giving them lip service. Multiple Democratic presidents have not done anything substantial to address some of the issues you mentioned. Not saying that the GOP is better, they are objectively far worse. But the Democrats have squandered every chance to really help this country in meaningful drastic ways. Shit, Biden was THE biggest friend to Corporate America while he was in the senate, and that didn't stop while he was VP, nor as President. You think someone who was completely bought and paid for by the healthcare lobby was going to allow Obama to deploy a government-backed healthcare option, instead of the mess we got with the ACA?
- ZeroGravitas 3y ago> You think someone who was completely bought and paid for by the healthcare lobby was going to allow Obama to deploy a government-backed healthcare option, instead of the mess we got with the ACA? Are you talking about Biden, or every single Republican here?
- NickC25 3y agoBoth, actually. I'm well aware that the GOP sucks, but the corporate wing of the Democratic party has put their foot down and voted with the GOP for way too long...especially on issues that are popular across the country even among different political demographics. Drug reform, immigration, education, healthcare, gun control, etc... Corporations donate lavishly to both parties because it's just too easy and cheap to do so, plus the promise of having whatever party is in power completely subservient to your interests is quite appealing if you're a CEO. I'd love a president who actively goes out of their way to fuck Wall Street, Big Pharma, Big Healthcare, Bio Oil, etc... but the last politician to attempt to do that on the national level was Bernie, and he got shafted.
- happytoexplain 3y ago>it isn't the same as people in positions of power This is the crux of 90% of fallacious criticisms of political parties. A lot of people in power are immoral and don't care about certain issues for identity-politics reasons, but as well there are reasonable people in power who can only give so much attention to so many topics at any given time, and some issues naturally become more associated with one party than another. In a perfect world that would be fine and everybody would understand that just because the news articles and speeches concerning a particular party don't divvy their focus on particular issues in the same manner as one personally would given one's own specific politics, that doesn't mean "the left" or "the right" "don't care" about X issue or are "silent on" issue X. That phrasing is usually an oversimplification used as an excuse to bash a party disliked by the writer/speaker for other reasons. The two specifics reasons this pattern is fallacious is: A. It implies that the people in power generally don't care about the issue, which may only appear true if you do not have a holistic sample of their opinions and policies, which is not something the media facilitates. B. It implies that the voter base of those people must generally agree with them on the particular issue.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mellosouls 3y agoThe overwhelming way the left talks about it is in terms of "toxic" masculinity or through the perspective of feminism. The latter is a valid perspective, but dominates the discourse which is hardly a balanced approach.
- inemesitaffia 3y ago[dead]
- gopherthon 3y ago[flagged]
- hdjjhhvvhga 3y agoBut it's not a binary choice. You can point out the right is irrational about the situation of women and at the same time agree with them on certain points regarding the situation of boys and men.
- nrdxp 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y agoPlease don't use HN for ideological battle. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- dang 3y agoPlease don't use HN for ideological battle. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- zzzeek 3y ago[flagged]
- wing-_-nuts 3y ago>The left talks about this all of the time They absolutely do NOT. The right has Jordan Peterson and a raft of people discussing men's issues. The left has NO equivalent. The silence is deafening. If you dare to bring up men's issues in education, parental rights, etc, you get lumped in with the MRA wackadoodles. The left is especially harsh in silencing dissent, and frankly every time it happens, you're pushing people further into the arms of the right wing. Edit: exhibit A. This is the fastest I've had an innocuous comment go negative on hackernews. Tow the party line or be silenced I guess...
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoAgreed. The left is all about addressing minorities and feminism. While I support that, they do not talk about men's issues, about men for men.
- cultofmetatron 3y ago> The left is all about addressing minorities and feminism. they are all about addressing feminists and female minorities. I can tell you from my own experience, the vast majority of the left don't give a shit about minority men either.
- tomtheelder 3y agoThis just doesn’t line up with my experience whatsoever. For my friends on the left it’s a common topic, and I see it discussed in left leaning publications all the time. I wonder when I see these characterizations of the left if they are coming from social media. I’m not on any social media aside from this site I guess, so I’m not sure if that’s what’s going on. The folks on the left that I interact with in real life are definitely a very big tent group.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoWhat you're seeing is the support amongst your bros. That's great. That doesn't equate to discussion on 'the left'. You don't see it being discussed much in books, podcasts, blog posts, documentaries etc, except on the right.
- zo1 3y agoObviously there is a big disconnect between what we think and what you do from your comment. It's fair to ask why and examine it so we can get common ground here. Like seriously, we can't be living in different realities so there must be more to it.
- ZeroGravitas 3y ago[flagged]
- TulliusCicero 3y agoThere's enormously more focus within the left on the struggles of women and girls. Which makes a certain amount of sense, but boys and men certainly have their own serious problems.
- cultofmetatron 3y agoas someone who has largely progressive values, I hesitate to call myself liberal anymore because of a lot of the downright embarrasing shit comming from the left these days. > The left talks about this all of the time, every time I've seen leftists talk about this. its always in the form of gaslighting men into blaming themselves for their failures. as if the k-12 educational system isn't currently stacked against them.
- gopherthon 3y ago[dead]
- quantified 3y agoStacked against them more than girls? Explain please.
- danjoredd 3y agoDid you read the article you are commenting on? He mentions that schools don't service men very well and that most dropouts are men
- quantified 3y ago> But overall, young men hit the labor market or college or whatever less well-prepared as a result of the education system. No facts about it, just some random assertion. Schools aren't going to change the way males relate to playing games, sports, and farting around in general compared with actually studying. What other part of the article did I miss? Oh, this: > the education system isn’t doing very well by lots of our boys and men now. We have a ten percentage point drop in the share of male teachers, incredible underinvestment in apprenticeships and vocational forms of learning, and all kinds of changes in school environments that mean that we’re not serving them very well. What changes in environments? Vocational means simply that boys don't do desks and paper well- is that true? Do male teachers make that much difference? The thrust here is that the economy has left men behind. Maybe that's true, which is more important.
- mortureb 3y agoThe left doesn’t talk about shit when it comes to this. It’s always some feminist bullshit approach that just doesn’t work for men.
- gaganyaan 3y agoThat just doesn't match my reality. Maybe I run in the wrong circles, but I've never heard any leftists I know discuss societal issues with sympathy towards men in general. There's sympathy for individuals facing their problems, but nothing like the article. What discourse I've seen that focuses on men's issues from the left tends to not really get it. If they just tsk tsk harder at Jordan Peterson and criticize toxic masculinity harder, surely the incels will realize the error of their ways. Meanwhile, other groups are offering a sense of purpose in life that doesn't require feeling ashamed of yourself. Even if that purpose is not a good one, don't be surprised that people sign up for it. It's hard to think that even centrists are interested in fixing the problem when there's headlines like this: > Biden criticizes ‘white man’s culture’ as he talks violence against women https://www.cnn.com/2019/03/27/politics/joe-biden-white-mans-culture/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/03/27/politics/joe-biden-white-mans... That's just a random example. The article adds a bit more color, but not much. Do you think rhetoric like that will draw in any white men that don't have a shame kink? I don't, and a few weak hand-wringing articles here and there don't make up for it.
- sershe 3y agoThe litmus test is whether the issues are being treated like an (apocryphal?) Medieval witch test, where you are a witch regardless of the outcome. For example, the fact that males disproportionately commit suicide is blamed on toxic masculinity - lack of vulnerability, cultural self esteem issues or whatever. Ok, fair enough; now the counterfactual is, what if females disproportionately committed suicide? It's pretty clear that it would be diagnosed on the left as related to toxic masculinity too (like e.g. women being less assertive asking for raises is). The left talks about these issues like that, all the time, indeed - that makes it easier to dismiss the issues or to blame them on the "victim". It appears that the author thinks some other approach is needed.
- acdha 3y agoDo you have any real examples? As written, it sounds like you’re criticizing non-specific hypothetical leftists for doing something hypocritical which doesn’t seem likely to lead anywhere productive without identifying who you’re talking about or providing examples of real things they said.
- sershe 3y agoI provided a real example of an issue where men do worse being diagnosed on the left as a problem with men. I don't think I need to provide examples of issues where women do worse and it's diagnosed on the left as a problem with men. I argue that's the whole of the left discourse.. any new issues would be handled similarly regardless of the outcomes to be discussed. Can you provide any issues as counter-examples?
- acdha 3y agoYou mentioned an issue (suicide) but simply asserted how it would be treated. You didn’t mention a single real person taking a position on the issue, establish that they were broadly representative of a group, or even establish which group you’re talking about (i.e. are you using “left” in the Fox News sense, general mainstream American sense, or European sense? Those are very different.)
- dang 3y agoPlease don't take HN threads into generic ideological battle. I'm sure that wasn't your intention and also that the title is provocative in that direction, but when the topic is inflammatory, it takes a conscious effort not to feed flamewar. We ended up with a bad one here and your comment was the root of it. "Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive." "Eschew flamebait. Avoid generic tangents." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- acdha 3y agoFeel free to delete the thread. The only reason I left a comment was because people often complain about stories being flagged without explanation and I didn’t think an intentionally provocative article would lead to a positive discussion.