8 ms·
YouTube suspends Russell Brand from making money off the streaming site
- akolbe 3y agoThis seems a little ... premature? Do we now have trial by TV? Worth reading: A few thoughts on the Russell Brand furore, by Jonathan Cook: https://www.jonathan-cook.net/blog/2023-09-17/thoughts-russell-brand-furore/ https://www.jonathan-cook.net/blog/2023-09-17/thoughts-russe... ... The media companies now fuelling the public mood via trial by TV are the very same companies that delighted in Brand’s sex-addict persona. As the Dispatches’ archival footage and testimonies make clear, those media corporations willingly exploited his persona – even allegedly at the risk of putting members of their staff and audiences in danger – to increase corporate profits. No one should regard them as good-faith actors in this latest development. Pointing this out does not mean one is condoning rape or sexual assault. In recent years, Brand has often argued that he went on a long and difficult personal journey of redemption, and that he is ashamed of the way he behaved in the past. There is at least ostensible evidence to back up Brand’s claims. There is zero evidence that the Dispatches documentary represents any kind of act of contrition by the media corporations now publicly reviling Brand for his behaviour. They haven’t seen the error of their ways. They are simply cashing in on Brand again – this time by bringing down the very celeb they built up. It’s all money in the bank for them. Pointing this out does not mean one is condoning rape or sexual assault. ...
- kmlx 3y ago> Do we now have trial by TV? we've had this for years now.
- refulgentis 3y agoI don't understand the persistent need for people to foreground "The Media" as some actor in these situations. In both cases, They relayed information and They are not a monolith, and often, if not always, the screeds about They betray an extreme lack of rigor and play on emotions
- threeseed 3y agoThe media is not a single entity. It is an industry comprised of multiple companies each with their own agendas, viewpoints etc. The publications involved in investigating Brand are not the same ones that profited from his exploits. And even if they did profit in the past does not mean they relinquish any right to atone for their mistakes. Hollywood tried to change and improve after the Weinstein situation. And so should the UK industry as Brand isn't the only one accused. We are talking about multiple cases of rape and sexual assault some involving a 16 year old girl. We need to not lose sight of who the real victims are here.
- sacrosancty 3y ago[dead]
- jeegsy 3y agoI suppose these days, it is useless to point out that these are unconfirmed accusations. Oh well
- akolbe 3y agoIt is worth noting, for the benefit of US-based readers, that the legal age of consent in the UK is 16. Brand was 31 at the time, according to media reports.
- matt-attack 3y agoIndeed. Americans tend to believe that the entirely arbitrary value of 18 set forth by many, but not all, states for the age of consent is somehow also a fundamental ethical principle.
- threeseed 3y agoIt is worth noting, that the 16 year old girl has accused him of sexual assault. So age of consent is not relevant.
- dazilcher 3y agoThen neither is the age, so why bring it up?
- atoav 3y agoI agree that corporations shouldn't punish people for alleged deeds that are not proven in a court of law — that is, unless it affects them directly. Imagine a barkeeper throwing someone out for a misbehaviour that has been communicated to them. That misbehaviour hasn't been proven in a court of law, it might even be the case that the barkeeper read the situation wrongly and threw that person out despite their innocence. Yet they should have the right to decide that, otherwise they wouldn't be able to enfore any kind of house rules unless they have two sworn witnesses for anything that happens. Now the pressing question is whether youtube is in a comparable situation here. Russel Brand, whether he is innocent or not, could now — with all the spotlights pointed at him — use that situation to produce more outrage — outrage that would make him a shitton of money that would be coming from YouTube. Seen from that perspective that move from youtube might be more of a strategic preventive measure to avoid dragging their platform into it without having to censor the guy than any form of punishment (although it will be read as such). Btw. I am not defending that position, I still think it is problematic and I still think social media platforms that resemble some sort of public square should have higher free speech standards than they do, but pick one freedom for corporations or free speech for it's customers, you cannot have both.
- orwin 3y ago> imagine a barkeeper throwing someone out for a misbehaviour that has been communicated to them Its absolutely correct to do it. While she was working at a bar in the caraibeans, my sister spotted a guy slipping something in a drink. The person who did it and both his friends weren't convicted (the police is useless and very 'assertive' towards victims there, especially women), but barred from all bar and restaurant owned by her employer
- rTX5CMRXIfFG 3y agoPeople seem to be over-aware of their freedom of speech but severely under-aware of freedom of association. If anything, capitalism best explains this move. It’s better to get rid of a potential liability before the liability materializes.
- mcphage 3y agoWhat, did YouTube put him in jail?
- refulgentis 3y ago1st amendment says, and has always said, I have a right to make twitter and YouTube make you read my posts. At least, I keep being told that's the case on the way to explaining why civilization is being destroyed
- snehk 3y ago> 1st amendment says, and has always said, I have a right to make twitter and YouTube make you read my posts. Weren't the same people who made this joke again and again when Trump was banned from Twitter the exact same people who then cried out loud when Musk took over and changed the rules?
- orwin 3y agoNo, I don't think so. I have no evidence they are the same. I'm part of the people that pointed out that 'free speech absolutist' banned accounts that never posted CP, and barely made fun of a burning car, for political reasons. Corporate does corporate things. If Twitter was nationalized, 'rules for me and not for you' would be outrageous. Right now? If anybody is surprised it's their own damn fault.
- refulgentis 3y agoNah. I think you're trying to reference the "assassination coordinates" nonsense followed by journalist bans that were rescinded. Please be fair to Elon, he's in the arena.
- ConcernedCoder 3y agoIMHO, it IS premature if you believe he has some inalienable right to be on Youtube, he hasn't been convicted of anything yet, these are only allegations. Yet, it's a company doing it, and they aren't bound by any "must-be-convicted-1st" rules, they can just block someone for any reason, they ( and other companies ) do it all the time, and in this case it's probably "better safe than sorry" type of risk management.
- dark-star 3y agoThis has nothing to do with "trial". It's YouTube's platform, and YouTube as a company can decide who they want to do business with and who not. You explicitly agree to their TOS and TOU when signing up, and if you violate them (as determined by YouTube themselves!) you're out. tl;dr: nothing to see here, move along...
- rurban 3y agoSure, nothing to see also with the Dresdner 1933 Exhibition "Entartete Kunst". https://archiv.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/artdok/5826/1/Zuschlag_Die_Dresdner_Ausstellung_Entartete_Kunst_2004.pdf https://archiv.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/artdok/5826/1/Zuschlag_D... Nothing to see there, move along /s
- sundaeofshock 3y agoWhat’s your point here? Who are the Nazis and who are the oppressed? Are you suggesting that Brand is somehow being oppressed?
- gettodachoppa 3y agoTaking away the livelihood of someone for unproven allegations is not oppression? Do you realize what Youtube is in the year 2023? It's how a lot of self-employed people make their living. Are you one of those "it's not censorship, just make your own media platform" techbros?
- threatofrain 3y agoPart of the reason why YT is valuable to content creators is because YT fosters good optics.
- hsod 3y agoSomeone successfully did that! Tons of people that got demonetized on Youtube are doing great on Rumble. Including Russell Brand, as a matter of fact. He also just got a strong statement of support from the owner of another large monetized video distribution platform (X fka Twitter). So he can always move his show there.
- saberience 3y agoI think this is a bad faith argument, conflating legal proceedings with life consequences for bad behavior. We have trials for criminal and civil cases in law courts. When your child gets sent home from school for swearing at the teacher, do you ask the school for a fair trial by jury? We have consequences in everyday life all the time which don't require trials, just our own opinions. If I meet someone who seems sleazy (judging from my own opinion based on life experience), I am not going to encourage my daughter to date that person. We don't need trials by jury in our life to make decisions and take actions which have consequences. The truth is, it is generally true in life that where there is smoke there is fire. And with Russell Brand there has been a LOT of smoke for a long time, certainly more than enough smoke to judge that you probably wouldn't trust him with your daughter. And when you have not one but many women, with evidence, along with many pieces of video and audio of Russell Brands previous outrageous behavior (e.g. calling a man to tell him publicly on the radio that he had sex with his granddaughter, telling notorious pedophile Jimmy Saville that he would send him over his female assistant...), then it becomes more and more likely that in this case we just have someone who at worse is a rapist and at best is a total creep and sex pest. I certainly agree, before putting someone in prison they should have a fair trial. But no one is putting Brand in prison, are they?
- akolbe 3y agoThe exchange with Jimmy Savile happened on a primetime BBC Radio 2 comedy show. There were no consequences for Brand at the time. You can hardly accuse the media of being consistent in their moral outrage. For the Andrew Sachs "joke" see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_Ross#The_Russell_Brand_Show_and_Andrew_Sachs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_Ross#The_Russell_Bran... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Russell_Brand_Show_prank_calls_row https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Russell_Brand_Show_prank_c...
- saberience 3y agoSo are you saying that if someone commits a crime and gets away with it at the time, there should be no consequences if the crime is later revealed or reviewed? That somehow, time makes this all better? There were no consequences for Jimmy Saville too. Why? Because he was a powerful, wealthy man and it's hard for people to go against rich celebrities. Can you imagine being a young woman with no wealth or fame trying to go against Brand at the height of his celebrity? Or being a lowly Production Assistant at the BBC or Channel 4, wanting to complain but knowing nothing will happen or you may lose your job. That there were no consequences back then doesn't mean there shouldn't have been, we have no idea what happened behind the scenes. It's been historically hard for women to speak up against powerful usually rich men.
- Karellen 3y agoAlso worth noting - a broadcaster like Channel 4 is not a monolith that produces all of the programmes that it airs. A lot of the programmes, like those in the Big Brother franchise, are produced by independent production companies and then shopped to multiple distributors like Channel 4, or Channel 5, or ITV2 (where the most recent series have aired) for broadcast. Also, I would argue that media companies that do journalism should not shy away from having those journalists investigate other departments of those companies. And while those journalists ought to give those depts the right to respond to any accusations, they shouldn't necessarily wait until those depts have completed in-depth investigations of their own and concocted a full CYA strategy, before breaking the story. (Pointing this out does not mean one is condoning the actions of media corporations)
- jemmyw 3y agoChannel 4 was founded on the idea of being a public broadcaster that only used third party production companies for it's content. It's written into it's charter.
- mirzap 3y agoI really hate this modern trial by social media. There's a reason we have a legal system, courts, and process. If he's found guilty by the court, then hang him by his balls and cancel everything, I don't care. But don't nuke anyone before the court says "guilty."
- rebolek 3y agoWell, within today's legal system, social media are responsible what's posted on their site.
- akolbe 3y agoIt's not about the content though in this case (God knows there is worse crap on YouTube), but about the person who uploaded it.
- iinnPP 3y agoThe ads I get in Youtube are full of obvious lies, AI generated garbage, clear copyright violations, and worse. What makes matters worse is that comments get disabled aa does sharing. I can't even link to the problem. If I report the ad, it is there again tomorrow. It's almost as if that counts as interaction worthy of trying the ad again. I personally don't like RB. I find the whole act to be off-putting. Though that is most often a sign of others liking the content. I don't think letting the "reason" go unchallenged is responsible given the above.
- notahacker 3y agoHe's not getting a massive boost to his views this week because of the content though, but because he's an alleged sex offender. Of all the people demonetised by YouTube, already rich man can't profit from allegations of sex offences unless he can find brands willing to pay him directly has to be one of the least sympathetic.
- NolF 3y agoWhat's the case law that social meedia sites are responsible for the content on their site? Youtube just recently won the ISIS recruitment case as a counter example [0]. [0] https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/21-1333_6j7a.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/21-1333_6j7a.pdf
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- threeseed 3y agoThere seems to be a lot of misinformation floating around. Brand has been the subject of a joint investigation by The Times, The Sunday Times and Channel 4 where the claims are backed by a significant amount of evidence vetted by their lawyers. These aren't reckless publications. These claims have subsequently led to at least some of the involved parties submitting police reports alleging sexual assault. And from reports by the newspapers the expectation is that more parties are coming forward. This is not trial by TV, social media etc. These are serious claims being taken very seriously because of the strength of the evidence presented to date. As such, Youtube is absolutely correct here to err on the side of caution.
- bt4u 3y ago[dead]
- 0xDEF 3y agoLet's be honest. Do you think Russell Brand would have been cancelled this hard if he was a boring centrist instead of spending the past 18 months talking about Ukrainian "bio-Nazi labs"? Neurodivergent people are being persecuted for wrongthink.
- threeseed 3y agoHe is alleged to have raped and sexually assaulted a number of girls. One as young as 16. He is alleged to have passed along a girl to a known pedophile. I actually don't care who the person is. If that is true then they should be in jail. End of story.
- drewcoo 3y ago> . . . girls. One as young as 16. 16 is the age of consent in the UK. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_of_consent_reform_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_of_consent_reform_in_the_U...
- akolbe 3y agoHang on a minute. He is accused of having had an "emotionally abusive and controlling relationshp" with a 16-year-old when he was 31. That is not the same as rape. The age of consent in the UK is 16, and 16-year-olds are legally sexually active all the time in the UK. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-66831593 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-66831593 Brand has also not been accused of passing along a girl to a known pedophile. He is accused of having joked about sending his assistant to Jimmy Savile, on a BBC Radio 2 comedy show in 2007. (The BBC did not fire him for that.) https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2023/sep/17/russell-brand-in-plain-sight-review-so-many-red-flags-ignored-for-so-long https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2023/sep/17/russell...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hunters_laptop 3y agoamerican: china commie, no free speech, dictactorship, blabla.. also american: ...
- 0xDEF 3y agoBut this is Britain. The UK has never had the same range of speech as the US or France.
- defrost 3y agoThis is Youtube - a transnational subsidiary of the US Alphabet group.
- timeon 3y agoI'm not advocating for what these private companies are doing but do you really think that it is comparable?
- hunters_laptop 3y agoactually more bad, because he is from a land that screaming about 'freedom and democracy'
- throwawayyy9237 3y agoFree speech is not the same as being entitled to a spotlight on YouTube. He is free to use whatever other means he wants to spread his ideas. It's not like he's being shipped off to a forced labour camp.
- hunters_laptop 3y agohe got suspends so basically russell now under forced labour camp
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- RamblingCTO 3y agoWhen reading something like this I'm always reminded of the many cases where it turned out to be absolutely groundless. See Rammstein. You might not like their lifestyle, but let's leave law enforcement to ... law enforcement and judges. You do so much damage with wrong convictions because it feels right. Let's wait and see, then condemn.
- tamimio 3y agoI remember in Boston explosion how one social media site (I think it was Reddit?) they went full detective mode and ended up accusing innocent people with their pictures all over the internet.
- deepsummer 3y agoI don't get it. Even if all allegations are true.. that would mean he committed crimes over 10 years ago. Aren't ex-convicts allowed to monetize a YouTube channel that's completely unrelated to the allegations? Why does YouTube need to penalize him? Is there a YouTube policy that explains this?
- throwawayyy9237 3y agoWell, I have no idea why they make their decisions, but purely from an argument point of view, if we take the concept of prison as a "debt to society", ex-convicts paid theirs, if guilty, Brand hasn't.
- tamimio 3y agoExactly! I just questioned the same point in another comment, even if he found guilty, why he can’t make money off the platform? Especially for a public figure.
- NoblePublius 3y agoConvicted of no crime. The fix is in.
- jacknews 3y agoIt seems the treatment of Assange has defined the playbook for dealing with critics of 'the system', the status-quo, whatever you want to call it.
- LightHugger 3y agoThis is just youtube using a convenient excuse to steal money from him. They aren't going to stop playing ads on it, they just get to keep all of it. The perverse incentive is absurd.
- tamimio 3y agoI don’t know this person or this incident, but it seems nowadays if you want to end someone’s career and/or public image, you just need to invite some women they have been with and call it sexual assault. That goes without saying, is there a court order to stop monetizing his channel? He seems to be a public figure, so his main income is .. being public. What did he actually say to have him cancelled, or whom did he annoy?
- Simulacra 3y agoI don't know if there was ever a time in the world, where an accusation did not automatically mean guilt. However, it seems in modern times, because of the ease at which information can be disseminated, that you are guilty by accusation first. I don't really know anything about this guy, and YouTube is a private company like Twitter, they can do whatever they want now, but something just seems inherently unfair to punish based on accusation alone. Even if its multiple people. Prove it, then punish, is the only way to at least strive for a fair system.
- goodbyesf 3y ago[flagged]
- err4nt 3y agoI don't know this incident, but the person is a famous actor who has kind of turned into a political commentator and spiritual coach (if that makes sense). The cynic in me says that (just like Joe Rogan) because he's a very popular, widely listened to, _independent_ media production, traditional media wants them gone and would do almost anything in their influence to discredit or remove these people. I'd encourage you to look at the viewership numbers for people like Joe Rogan, Russel Brand, and their peers in independent media, and then look at viewership numbers for CNN, etc and 'traditional'-style media companies and you can see why they may have targets on their backs. Because they're such big targets, it really makes me scrutinize and extra skeptical about things brought against them, not because I believe they haven't done crimes or are good people, but because there's so much incentive by so many others to simply knock them out of the game by any means.