9 ms·
NASA clears the air: No evidence that UFOs are aliens
- amadazia 3y agoI wonder how much of our skyline is due to (gay) archtitects being pissed off.
- cammikebrown 3y agoNot extraterrestrial, but how about… Extradimensional? Seems easier to live in a higher dimension than to break the speed of light anyway.
- paulrouget 3y agoExtra dimensions are just scifi stuff. Physics would break appart if there were any "big enough" dimensions. Gravity & electromagnetism would not behave the way they behave (inverse square laws).
- isityouyesitsme 3y agoIt is also possible that everything humans understand is simply a vignette into a much larger reality, and all of those things would fall apart because they aren't true, they're merely the laws we've discovered with the limited information we have available to us.
- maxbond 3y agoMaybe. Is that a good explanation for some grainy footage? Is it a better explanation than, "the drone technology most of us are familiar with is a vignette of a much larger space of technological possibility; without the need to accommodate human frailty, strange and wonderful configurations of aircraft are possible, so much so that they may baffle even experienced airman? And like any strange and wonderful technology in this world, it's first used to spy, and in a decade will be used to serve ads."
- isityouyesitsme 3y agoPlease cote the spot where I suggested anything that even remotely looks like I took a position. All I mean to say is that circular logic based on upholding one's views of reality do not bring any clarity to the situation. The same situation seems to happen countless times in the history of empirical science and mathematics. There are incontrovertible facts, until some new information controverts them.
- maxbond 3y agoThat's fine, but you asked a question and I responded to it. Whether you hold a position, that's not really my business, I believe you when you say you don't.
- maxbond 3y agoI'm seeing now that it was a proposition not a question (I read it as "Is it" rather than "It is"), my mistake there. But I would've responded in the same way regardless, so substitute this with, "you proposed something and I responded to it."
- paulrouget 3y agoThen a "dimension" would not be a dimension as defined by math and physics.
- isityouyesitsme 3y agoThrow-away comment: that's essentially the point.
- kevinmchugh 3y agoIs there any way to falsify this idea?
- isityouyesitsme 3y agoI don't think that there is. An obvious comparison is religious thought. Unlike most religious thought, you do actually learn when the consensus has been utterly wrong. What you don't know is when that will happen.
- anon1199022 3y agoor maybe it might takes as few hundred more years to understand them? Our understanding of things evolve very slowly compared to age of universe.
- paulrouget 3y agoDimensions have a strict definition. Under those strict definitions we can draw conclusions that are 100% true. Math tell us things that can't be invalidated in the future. If it turns out there is "something else", it would not be a dimension as defined by math and physics.
- oefrha 3y agoSpeaking as a former theoretical high energy physicist who has studied string theory and other BSM theories (including “extra dimensions”) quite extensively and black hole information theory to a reasonable extent, the higher dimensions talked about in any close-to-mainstream physics really has nothing to do with sci-fi “inter-dimensional travel”. It’s quite amusing to read the sentence “Seems easier to live in a higher dimension than to break the speed of light”. The latter is well established, very precise physics, the former is a very vague, so far fictional concept with little to do with our current understanding of physics (and actually very much goes against it), yet somehow one is “easier” than another. Of course we can’t rule anything out, including “extra dimensions” in some scifi-esque sense that’s not currently understood, but these two don’t belong in the same sentence. (Btw, I enjoy sci-fi about traveling between alternate universes.)
- tomohelix 3y agoThe way I understand the extra "dimension" here is like me viewing a bacteria on a cover slide. To the bacteria, that 2D flat plane is all that matters. Sure, technically it is 3D, but the 3rd dimension is compressed so much it is basically nonexistent and the bacteria can't really be bothered anyway. They can't even comprehend the concept of dimensions. But to me, I am fully in 3D. I am literally an extradimensional being to the bacteria. And I am so far above it (no pun intended) I am incomprehensible to anything that lives on that 2D slide. Even if I assume the bacteria has some really good teachers and can build stuff (they actually do, they make biofilms that are pretty complex "superstructures"), the kind of thing they can do in their limited plane of existence is nothing compared to what a human can. So while I don't believe anything that was released so far points conclusively to real aliens, I don't find the concept of extradimensional beings too far fetch.
- helpfulContrib 3y agoHow about .. just terrestrial? In other words, we are not the most technologically advanced species on the planet. Merely bystanders to other, older, perhaps far more advanced civilizations that merely tolerate our presence on their planets surface. I mean, this tracks.
- tptacek 3y agoNow you're talking like David Grusch; if you just include the Vatican in your theory, you'll be on the same page as him.
- david-gpu 3y agoHas cammikebrown held a high position within the intelligence community? Has he been tasked as part of his official duties with finding any possible legacy reverse-engineering projects? Did he interview forty witnesses, including people who report being part of these programs currently? Did he collect evidence of wrongdoing and report it to the ICIG through the officially-sanctioned whistleblower process? Did the ICIG interview other witnesses and find his claims significant enough to forward them to Congress? Did cammikebrown eventually testify under oath in front of Congress, in both classified and non-classifief sessions? Well, if all that is true then I think we should pay a little attention to what cammikebrown is saying and demand that his claims are investigated, because either cammikebrown is full of shit and needs to end with his bones in jail, or he is not and there is some serious corruption that needs to be addressed within the DoD.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 3y agoVirtually none of this is true of Grusch.
- david-gpu 3y agoPlease be specific. I'm on mobile, but at least you can start here [0]. [0] https://thedebrief.org/intelligence-officials-say-u-s-has-retrieved-non-human-craft/ https://thedebrief.org/intelligence-officials-say-u-s-has-re...
- tptacek 3y agoYou should listen to Ezra Klein's interview with Leslie Kean, the author of that story. It's pretty comical.
- maxbond 3y agoDoes it seem easier? We have no indication that higher dimensions are a place you could "travel" to. This is the kind of ad-hoc hypothesis Occam cautioned against - multiplying entities unnecessarily. "UFOs are spycraft, hoaxes, and surprising atmospheric phenomena" is a perfectly serviceable alternative to the hypothesis "UFOs are alien spacecraft." Why are we introducing a new entity (extradimenional travel) which we have no other evidence for, when we don't need to?
- rqtwteye 3y ago"Higher dimensions" sounds kind of appealing but what does it really mean?
- Ziggy_Zaggy 3y agoThere R&D in this field is very early but yes there's already tons of literature on this topic to process/consider in the physics field(s).
- duozerk 3y agoNo there isn't (beyond occasional papers badly misinterpreted by mainstream press) There's tons of literature on this topic to process/consider in science fiction.
- Ziggy_Zaggy 3y agoThanks for pointing out this often-overlooked aspect of the conversation.
- AltruisticGapHN 3y agoLook into Donald Hoffmann. Space time is not fundamental.
- havnagiggle 3y agoI'd suggest calling it the big foot dimension.
- aergoibqer 3y ago[flagged]
- dennis_jeeves2 3y ago[flagged]
- david-gpu 3y agoWhat evidence do they have so far about these objects? NASA's head Bill Nelson said there are only a few high-resolution videos of these objects, but so far none of it has been released to my knowledge. The best way to stop conspiracies would be publicly releasing the radar and video data they do have of anomalous objects, whatever they might be. Anything else is patronizing and feeds distrust, deservedly or not.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Avshalom 3y agoThe best way to spot a conspiracy theory (in the pejorative sense) is that a lack of evidence and evidence against the theory are treated as affirmative.
- pmarreck 3y agoRight. For something so ho-hum, there's too many signs of suspicion-inducing secrecy showing, such as the fact that they didn't announce the guy's name who was going to lead it, then probably realized that that would just further any conspiracy theories around it (justifiably), then they DID announce his name... When I learned this yesterday I said aloud "FFS" because it's such a dumb human foible. If this was in fact a coverup, the only reason it's worked so long (despite humans being unable to keep secrets) is due to two things: 1) the implausibility of the premise 2) the ridicule of the claimants 3) the compartmentalization of the information, and possibly 4) the threat of unknown agents The thing is, the truth eventually always comes out. How do you think this is going to look, once it does?
- refulgentis 3y agoYou said "right" at the beginning then got reproachful at the end. In between there's a lot of material and references that won't be obvious to other people. So I'm confused. But I'm pretty sure they'll be just fine, as long as the reptilians continue suppressing the truth.* * my understanding of why people get drawn into these nothing-burgers is you see new info, you think somethings around the corner where all those skeptics are proven wrong. years pass, and people either acknowledge it was a nothing burger or escalate claims to explain away why there's all these aliens bouncing around, everyone would want to hear that, Congress is demanding anyone who claims such be given a wide bearth and credence and yet....still nothing.
- simion314 3y agoThis days there must be at least a few million more cameras then a few decades backa nd the alien or super natural images did not increased proportionally to the camera number as you would expect. I think the capitalistic "greed" caused all those old reports, it was so popular at that time so people produced the content that was in demand. i remember some TV show that was presented some old temple and claiming something like "only aliens would have had tools to cut this rocks at such perfect angles" - then when I had Internet access and check that temple I see it was made from sandstone (a very soft materials) and the freaking angles were not precise by a mile... so makes you wonder should there be consequences for this kind of intentional lying for cache ? (I mean in general and I understand that USA is super special).
- kibwen 3y ago> I think the capitalistic "greed" caused all those old reports, it was so popular at that time so people produced the content that was in demand. Rather than greed, I think it was just a meme. People got it in their minds that aliens in flying saucers were scooting around abducting cows, so they were psychologically primed to perpetuate the idea.
- wkat4242 3y agoWell how else are they supposed to make their hamburgers? They don't have cows up there. Ps more seriously, I wonder where the whole flying saucer concept comes from. Was it the SR71 with its rounded shapes? Or does it predate that?
- krapp 3y ago>I wonder where the whole flying saucer concept comes from. Kenneth Arnold, an Air Force pilot in 1947 who reported seeing craft shaped like "saucers" or "pie plates" flying past Mount Ranier[0]. He never called them "flying saucers" specifically but after the press picked up the story, the term and the concept became popular. After that, flying saucers became a trope in sci-fi movies. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenneth_Arnold_UFO_sighting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenneth_Arnold_UFO_sighting
- mypastself 3y agoI miss this brand of kooky theories. It’s sad how the conspiracy space has been monopolized by partisan politics in the past decade. I’d welcome the return of Area 51 and Bigfoot theories into the “mainstream” conspiracy theory arena…
- jwells89 3y agoAs fun and “harmless” as those old conspiracy theories are, there’s a line of thought that it was exactly those that primed many to fall down the numerous politically-charged conspiracy rabbitholes that exist today, which sounds believable. Those who jumped straight to political conspiracy theories were likely always vulnerable to this sort of thinking, but a significant portion were likely people who weren’t predisposed but had their mental safeguards and sanity checks eroded by Area 51 and Bigfoot sorts of stuff.
- ryandrake 3y agoIf we're going to consider "propensity to believe in things without evidence" to be problematic, I have bad news for you: Religions involving supernatural beliefs have existed for millennia, placing most people on Earth in that bucket.
- sixstringtheory 3y agoYou’re not wrong but what’s your point? Those people often create terrible policy. So… we are supposed to let conspiracists slide too because there’s this other group that also has problematic beliefs?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wkat4242 3y agoOh did they manage to clear out all the evidence this time? Area 51 must be getting really full by now. /jk
- cookiengineer 3y ago> Area 51 Maybe you should read up on the radar tests of the A12 prorotype, SR71 and skunkworks in general. 'Murica has an education problem if they think that this [1] was a space ship more than 65 years later. [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/91/Lockheed_A12_radar_testing_at_Area51.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/91/Lockheed...
- Avshalom 3y agoI know that post goes into the ground but the mental image of them driving that around with that jeep for radar tests is delightful.
- cookiengineer 3y agoThat would be a nice idea for halloween :D
- wkat4242 3y agoI know, it was a joke hence the /jk :P
- speak_plainly 3y agoThe absence of evidence is not conclusive proof of non-existence; rather, it may highlight our limitations in comprehending or addressing the topic. Just because there's no evidence currently suggesting an extraterrestrial origin doesn't rule out the possibility. Testimonies and indications of concealed information suggest that any existing evidence might be hidden or suppressed. Such revelations should intensify scrutiny on NASA's handling of the matter. There are accounts, and possibly some tangible evidence, of encounters with non-human entities, with some testimonies claiming that these beings identified themselves as extraterrestrial. While numerous skyward sightings exist—some dubious or misidentified—there remains a portion that defies explanation. NASA's commitment to empirical research is commendable. However, in light of the allegations, it would be prudent for them to conduct an internal review to ensure there have been no cover-ups or destruction of evidence in the past.
- smolder 3y agoWhat interest does NASA have in cover-ups or destruction of evidence? I can't imagine any reason for them to be dishonest about not finding evidence of aliens which is based in reality as opposed to paranoid nonsense.
- svnt 3y agoGP is suggesting that NASA was not given all of the evidence, ensuring that they would reach the conclusion they did.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ryandrake 3y agoThe burden of proof is on something's existence, not on its non-existence. Non-existence is the default assumption, unless we're ready to by default assume mermaids, unicorns, and Bigfoot exists.
- 3y ago
- jl6 3y agoHere are 11 things more plausible than UAPs being aliens: 1) It was a reflection 2) It was an insect 3) It was a bird 4) It was a balloon 5) It was a meteor 6) It was a secret new kind of aircraft from a department the pilot didn't know about 7) It was a secret new kind of aircraft from a foreign country 8) The image/video was fake, for money 9) The image/video was fake, for lulz 10) The pilot was confused 11) The pilot was lying (one for each season of The X-Files)
- ttul 3y agoBut what about that black ooze?
- skywal_l 3y agoSomewhere between 4) and 5): it was a camera artefact.
- readyplayernull 3y agoThose 600x480px cameras are the best at capturing UFOs.
- holoduke 3y agoTry filming an airplane from the ground. Most cameras used by people can only do proper 1x zoom. Everything more becomes a blurry video.
- ithkuil 3y agoThe point is that no matter how better imaging technology gets, sightings have been always been at the edge of the resolution
- david-gpu 3y agoWhen the images are clear we dismiss them as fake. The root of the problem is one of trust. Ask yourself: which person or institution do you trust enough that you would accept an image from them as proof of the NHI hypothesis? Because I've been called a crackpot multiple times in this HN post and yet I don't trust any source enough to accept any image they could provide as proof of NHIs.
- jasfi 3y agoAliens are the kind of thing that: 1. Wouldn't suddenly appear recently. On the human timeline, I'd say if they were around, we'd be neighbors. 2. If they did suddenly appear, it would be as obvious as the earth is round.
- RandomLensman 3y agoEvery generation just needs to go through its UFO phase, it seems. And just like the last time, it'll end with nothing to show for as far as extraterrestrials are concerned.
- lisper 3y agoIt is important to distinguish between two kinds of conspiracy theories: 1. Conspiracies where there is evidence of a conspiracy (like sworn testimony from conspirators) 2. Conspiracies where there is no evidence of a conspiracy, i.e. the hypothesis is that it is a successful conspiracy. Type 2 conspiracy theories are are like invisible pink unicorns: by design they are unfalsifiable, and hence unscientific, and so can be dismissed on those grounds alone. Contrary to popular opinion, extraordinary claims do not require extraordinary evidence to merit serious consideration, they merely require some evidence that cannot be accounted for by more mundane explanations. Weird video artifacts don't qualify.
- j16sdiz 3y agoI found the train of thought of "unfalsible == unscientific == can be dismissed" worrying. There are so much knowledge unfalsible yet we relied on. This overestimate our ability to reason, or gathering evidence.
- lisper 3y ago> so much knowledge unfalsible yet we relied on Like what?
- wefarrell 3y agoIt’s impossible to falsify patient reports of pain, yet the medical field takes them quite seriously.
- Fatnino 3y agoThe medical field will often ignore out of hand any reports of pain as drug seeking and do nothing about it. I have first hand experience with this.
- lisper 3y agoThat's not true. For example, if someone suddenly stops acting like they are in pain when they think they are not being observed that's a pretty good indication that they are faking it.
- afraidofthemoon 3y agoPatterns tell stories.
- retrocryptid 3y ago"Lack of evidence is not evidence of lack."
- perardi 3y agoI’m a big fan of this Substack post. The UFO craze was created by government nepotism and incompetent journalism https://www.theintrinsicperspective.com/p/the-ufo-craze-was-created-by-government https://www.theintrinsicperspective.com/p/the-ufo-craze-was-... > To sum up the story as far as I understand its convoluted depths: diehard paranormal believers scored 22 million in Defense spending via what looks like nepotism from Harry Reid by submitting a grant to do bland general “aerospace research” and being the “sole bidder” for the contract. They then reportedly used that grant, according to Lacatski himself, the head of the program, to study a myriad of paranormal phenomenon at Skinwalker Ranch including—you may have guessed it by now—dino-beavers. Viola! That’s how there was a “government-funded program to study UFOs.”
- motohagiography 3y agoCharitably, in government terms that's not a lot of money, and given congress gets a new set of bumpkins and rubes every four years, having current rigorous data and evidence relating to the beliefs they might be bringing into the job seems like a wise use of funds. The UAP thing is also mostly a lever for narrative control, where whenever the news gets a little too close for comfort, you can release some alien files and knock something out of the news cycle. $22-million gets you a whole bunch of dry powder for less than the cost of a crisis management firm on a political campaign. People will believe anything, and while you can rarely convince them otherwise, you absolutely can become the source for confirmations, and they'll follow whatever confirms their beliefs. Who cares what they actually believe so long as they're dependent on facts you control to believe it. That's just the game.
- aatd86 3y agoAbsence of evidence is not evidence of absence ;p
- maxbond 3y agoAbsence of evidence is most is definitely evidence of absence, even if it isn't absolute proof. Or rather, failing to find evidence that a hypothesis would predict to exist is evidence that the hypothesis is incorrect. You can't absolutely prove a negative, but every time you fail to substantiate evidence for the positive counter claim, your certainty of the negative claim should asymptotically approach 1. And eventually you should be satisfied with the body of evidence and move on to ask different questions. For that matter, I suppose you can't absolutely prove a positive either, for the reasons Descartes described; you can't prove the nonexistence of an omnipresent demon who adjusts your sensory information at just the right time and in just the right ways to make you believe something other than the truth. Still we hazard coming to conclusions and change our minds when the time comes.
- aatd86 3y agoYou can prove a negative. People always make that mistake but that's not true that you can't prove a negative. In any case, I was being tongue-in-cheek hence the smiley. My statement is still true. That we have no evidence of the existence of aliens doesn't mean they don't exist. We just don't have proofs. I don't know why people are getting so worked up by my little comment. :)
- maxbond 3y ago> You can prove a negative. I'd be interested to hear more. > In any case, I was being tongue-in-cheek hence the smiley. > I don't know why people are getting so worked up by my little comment. :) I'm certainly not getting worked up. You said something and I responded to it, because I thought the topic was interesting and worth responding to. If you're suggesting the egg is on my face for taking you seriously, well okay, but I think that's being disrespectful to yourself.