8 ms·
Morocco earthquake kills more than 1,000
- p5a0u9l 3y agoI have a stellar contract SDE from Morocco. Aside from the humanitarian tragedy of this earthquake, my eyes have been opened to the challenges young professionals with Visas face in the US. They tend to be ripe for exploitation by hiring firms and contract agencies.
- hirako2000 3y ago[flagged]
- andybak 3y agoSo prior to colonialism, there was peaceful free movement of populations?
- tpm 3y agoNot always of whole populations (though often that too) but individuals travelled much more freely.
- laverya 3y agoAt least part of the reason that individuals traveled freely is that only rich individuals traveled. Paupers from London didn't get on ships to the new world - not without selling themselves into indentured servitude. When the economic barriers to migration fell to the point that subsistence farmers could travel between continents, we were always going to see either an equalization of living standards or the rise of political barriers.
- bobthepanda 3y agoYes. Even before the adoption of visas, the traveling experience for a first class passenger on a ship was very different from third class getting routed via Ellis Island in the US.
- dijit 3y agoNot in the majority of Europe, especially places like England or Poland which had strict restrictions on what serfs could do for hundreds of years. Part of the reason for Britains diverse regional dialects is due to this.
- rendaw 3y agoThat was within the country though, right? Not between countries? And this article [1] says enforcement of serfdom was localized and costly and there was de facto serf mobility. [1] https://broadstreet.blog/2021/05/07/serfdom-the-state-and-the-problem-of-enforcement/ https://broadstreet.blog/2021/05/07/serfdom-the-state-and-th...
- csomar 3y agoI don't know about peaceful but you could move. There were no visas and in fact no passports. Though, trying to get inside a "city" (ie: citadel) might be tricky. I guess they used gifts before to convince the other party. That being said, if you settled somewhere in some large empty land, no one will complain.
- andybak 3y ago> That being said, if you settled somewhere in some large empty land, no one will complain. That's because any empty land would probably be entirely unsuitable for a settlement. Obviously we haven't specified a period in history but this all sounds suspiciously rose-tinted to me.
- csomar 3y agoPlenty of land was suitable for settlement (ie: Argentina). Mostly empty and competing empires were too far. Of course, after the discovery of the "new" world, the amount of empty land reduced significantly.
- asdswe 3y agoIf you remove borders, you also have to remove social safety nets and other things which make rich countries better to live in than poor ones.
- delecti 3y agoThere's no inherent truth of the universe that requires countries to have such disparate wealth that some are so much better to live in. I bet most people arguing for removing borders would also argue there should be much better global equality.
- slashdev 3y agoWhere did you get your education? Serious question. Borders have nothing to do with colonialism. There is no human right to move and settle where you please, especially in this day and age where that entitles you to many social services paid for by taxes. A nation that does not control its borders is no longer a nation. No country on earth behaves that way. Not now, nor in the past.
- Jcampuzano2 3y agoThere's no human right to do so simply because societies and governments have deemed it such. There's not really any decent reason it "shouldn't" be a right for well meaning people. To be clear, I do agree that going somewhere else may grant you benefits you wouldn't have had in where you originally are from and that's due to taxes and other systems in place. But plenty of well meaning people who are skilled and willing to contribute to other societies are not allowed to do so just because they were born somewhere less fortunate or with certain stigmas attached. Its a complex problem of course, free movement does let some bad apples in that can cause a lot of harm. But it can go too far in my opinion.
- nicbou 3y agoThe problem of free movement is not bad apples, but simply too many apples. Even legal immigration is challenging to accommodate as a large influx of new residents disrupts everything from housing to culture. I say this as an immigrant who helps immigrants immigtate, so I'm very much pro immigration.
- proudeu 3y agoNations and countries are made up things, you know that? They are not naturally human but a social constructs made up by those in power to have better grip on other people (their serfs) in the past. Usually countries started as kingdoms and the premise was clear.
- ithkuil 3y agoMany societies of the past were conglomerations of tribes where each group/tribe had their own hierarchy and the various groups interacted with various kinds of hierarchy or lack thereof. Think of ancient Gaul or North American native nations. Despite them being formally independent groups, a common culture united people against what they perceived foreign. Gauls resisted Roman invasion, and even managed some degree of cohesion under Vercingetorix because they felt the threat of the common enemy.
- throw_m239339 3y ago> VISAs are a left over abomination of colonialism. This is patently false. Borders and border control are as ancient as human societies themselves and were not invented by those you deem "colonialists", which for you I bet doesn't include the Arabs and Persians themselves colonizing Europe... Or the mongols...
- skyyler 3y agoIgnoring Arab colonisation of Europe is something most Europeans do. Why do so many nouns in Spanish start with a?
- leetcodesucks 3y ago[dead]
- gedy 3y ago> human rights to visit and settle in any nation. Well when Europeans move to other countries en masse (even without violence), it's called colonialism too.
- janalsncm 3y agoI don’t know enough about history to say how connected colonialism and visas are, but it feels deeply unfair that citizens of some countries have many visa free countries (USA, Japan, Singapore have some of the best passports) while citizens in other countries have to deal with a ton of paperwork and uncertainty.
- lemper 3y ago[flagged]
- mcpackieh 3y agoMy understanding is that earthquake resistant buildings should be able to withstand up to 7 with negligible to slight damage. Hopefully governments take building codes more seriously. https://www.usgs.gov/media/images/earthquake-intensity-scale https://www.usgs.gov/media/images/earthquake-intensity-scale
- hutzlibu 3y agoMorocco is quite poor in rural areas. You have to be able to fund a solid building and regulations help little with that. Otherwise you just create lots of corruption.
- Retric 3y agoCorrupt is a big deal, but not insurmountable. Convincing people that traditional methods aren’t earthquake resistant is one way to sidestep the issue. It’s not particularly expensive to build somewhat earthquake resistant structures. Quite a lot of it comes down to building techniques rather than significant effort or expensive materials. Multi story stone building generally do extremely poorly, but there’s a few cheap methods to significantly improve things such as timber bracing. The goal isn’t to make the building survive unscathed but to minimize casualties.
- hutzlibu 3y ago"Convincing people that traditional methods aren’t earthquake resistant is one way to sidestep the issue." Actually, the really old traditional buildings in morroco are quite earthquake resistant, because they are still standing and it was not the first earthquake there. It's the cheaply build new houses, that are the problem and yes, now is the time to give awareness that you should not build too cheaply and what one can do even with limited ressources. But I fear that the main response will be literal death penalty for some building company owners (morroco is a quite absolutistic monarchy) and otherwise not much change.
- propercoil 3y ago[flagged]
- DoreenMichele 3y agoOh? Name? Links? (Ideally in English.)
- propercoil 3y agohttps://twitter.com/hogrbe https://twitter.com/hogrbe
- throw_m239339 3y agoIs this documented scientifically that planet positions can affect earth seismic activity? Like the moon affects sea tides?
- DoreenMichele 3y agoOne of his tweets: Yes, there is much resistance within the scientific community regarding the influence of the planets and the Moon. But there's no extended research that 'disproves' it. It's merely an assumption. In fact, a scientific paper in Nature suggests otherwise. https://twitter.com/hogrbe/status/1622641784869322754 https://twitter.com/hogrbe/status/1622641784869322754
- hk__2 3y ago"there is much resistance within the scientific community" is the usual euphemism used by pseudo-scientists to justify their claim. There’s absolutely no evidence that you can predict earthquakes by looking at the positions of the planets, and this "researcher" is known for his very vague "predictions" that sometimes appear to be true, sometimes not. It’s the scientific equivalent of a broken clock.
- 3y ago
- whimsicalism 3y agoHaving been to some rural regions of the Atlas mountains not so long ago, many of the buildings are built onto precipices and do not look ready to withstand an earthquake.
- saiya-jin 3y agoYes, they dont get earhtquakes often, so nothing is prepared. Worst are multistory buildings not up to any quake-resistant standards. Did mt Toubkal hike (highest Atlas mountain) few years ago, pretty places, very sad to read all this.
- dmje 3y agoSame. Loved Toubkal, loved the people, loved Marrakech. So sad to see this.
- vkdelta 3y agoDeepest condolences to one of nicest people on earth. I had to been to Morocco on a vacation and the warmth and welcomeness was highlight of the trip. On top of that, people of Morocco love kids and accommodate a lot.
- leetcodesucks 3y ago[dead]
- turbo_fart 3y ago[flagged]
- lnsru 3y agoIt’s very politically incorrect. But yeah, things work differently in some countries if one does not bring in a bag with money or guns.
- decremental 3y ago[dead]
- esel2k 3y agoWide statements with just general negative content, totally politically incorrect. I have travelled there and yes if you spend time in the tourist places you face scammers often. The contrary is true when far away from stops - so I encourage all to discover in my opinion the best north africa country. And a small hint: staying in a resort is probably the last way to really understand a country and culture.
- jiofj 3y agoHeh, I live in Spain, a country that receives a LOT of immigration from there, and I couldn't help but think "what kind of moroccans has this guy seen?"
- kranke155 3y agoThe ones in Marrakesh tourist areas (can be like this). I wouldn’t use the words he used. More like harassment.
- freecodyx 3y agoI felt it, it was terrible experience, it was so strong that it was felt across wide regions. Luckily the epicenter was a bit far from major cities. At first i did not realize why my chair was shaking as i was using headphones, then for at least 10sec i couldn’t even stand. We spent the night outside
- npsomaratna 3y agoI remember the first earthquake I experienced. Same feeling: everything around me started shaking; for several seconds, I couldn't figure out what was happening; and then it suddenly hit me: it's an earthquake. (I'm from a country where earthquakes do not occur. For some reason, I always thought that earthquakes were accompanied by, well, movie-style earthquake sounds. It was kinda eye-opening to realize that earthquakes are silent...)
- mh- 3y agoDepends on the type of earthquake, the composition of the ground near you, etc. Where I live now, weak earthquakes can sometimes almost only be heard, along with a brief shake you'd easily mistake for someone slamming a door.
- elliotec 3y agoEarthquakes are not silent. I'm not sure where you experienced yours but earthquakes are deafeningly loud. Movie-style earthquake sounds don't even do it justice.
- npsomaratna 3y agoI was in an apartment building in Santiago, Chile—in fact, pretty much all of the earthquakes I experienced were in Santiago. Never heard any (out of the normal) sounds. Is that because the buildings were built to handle earthquakes?
- notnmeyer 3y agonot universally true.
- formvoltron 3y agoI spend a lot of time in Morocco. I always wondered what an earthquake might do because they quite often build with simple cinderblock. The government actually sort of encourages it because official land ownership is not the norm and sometimes the government will raze buildings that were built without proper permits. Of course people couldn't really afford earthquake proof houses anyways. Sad situation all around. Was planning to go this winter, but I don't want to be a tourist in the midst of calamity.
- zmgsabst 3y agoJust putting out there that it might still be a good time to go: I can’t speak to Morocco, but a number of SE Asian places derive significant incomes from tourism — and losing that after natural disasters compounds the problem. There’s a possibility that visiting Morocco is bringing needed money into their community (as long as you’re not going to areas short on supplies). You need money to rebuild. And tourism is ~7% of Morocco’s GDP (as of a few years ago). https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/e3197856-en/index.html?itemId=/content/component/e3197856-en https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/e3197856-en/index.html?i...
- whimsicalism 3y ago> Was planning to go this winter, but I don't want to be a tourist in the midst of calamity. I'm very conflicted on this one, it seems like this is the intuition I (along with a lot of people) want to reach for but is that actually the most helpful thing?
- timinou 3y agoNo, life goes on and it's not a calamity. It's pretty bad, but we'll have another crisis if tourism goes down because of the bad publicity of the earthquake. For many Moroccans, welcoming tourists is their livelihoods. The best thing you can do to support them is to keep your plans in place.
- prmoustache 3y agoIn 1960 an earthquake in Agadir claimed almost half of the city's population. That gives you an idea about how badly prepared they were. City has been rebuild (except from the hill were you can see the memorial words at night) supposedly under earthquake sagety norms but that isn't the case of the rest of the country.
- tibbydudeza 3y agoEarthquakes in Africa is rather unusual - we get some but it is more due to underground mining activity than tectonics. Looking it seems this were the Eurasian plate meets the African plate ???.
- ivan_gammel 3y agoAre you sure? Africa is a big continent. There's a lot of seismic activity going on in the eastern part of it, there are volcanoes etc.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoI think the Atlas range is still growing. That means plates coming together. I lived in Morocco (and have visited Marrakesh), but that was in the late 1960s. I also lived in East Africa, where they still have some active vulcanism, but I think things are subsiding. Morocco had a bad earthquake in Agadir, in 1960. A huge number of folks died. I think it was mostly poor people, who live in rather slapdash shanty towns.
- 8bitsrule 3y agoLooks very sad. According to the USGS search engine on that part of N. Africa, there've been no other quakes >= mag 6 in the region (nor for at least halfway down the AF coast) in 200 years. (The closest was in Portugal; Agadir was a 5.8.)(There were hundreds in the eastern Mediterranean.) So it's been centuries. That can't have helped; many of those structures have been around -a long- time.
- Nessitro 3y agoI was playing with my cat that night when she started acting weird. Shortly after, I started hearing cracking noise inside the walls. That's when it hit me. Went to my roommate's room and woke him up and got out. It wasn't as strong as I thought but strong enough to get everyone out to the main street. As we sat down waiting for potential aftershocks I heard someone saying people died way down south. I googled "earthquake morocco" and first estimations showed a town that not that far from taroudant region where grandma lives(mountainous rural area). I tried calling but to no avail as the cell network was congested. We went home after an hour and a half passing out from the exhaustion. Woke up the next morning and called her, she was okay but it was strong enough to render the whole village(douar) petrified and make the decision to sleep outside... I got into social media afterwards and was shocked to hear that 320 people died in Al houz region... it's more than 2300 people as of writing this. May they rest in peace and give the victims families patience to get through these difficult times. This is a map of almost all of the villages(dawawir) that were most impacted by the earthquake: https://goo.gl/maps/xdfG5YnHC6Z2vEci6 https://goo.gl/maps/xdfG5YnHC6Z2vEci6 (thanks to whoever made it) If you'd like to donate, please do via official channels; Bank Al-Maghrib, our central bank, made a special fund for the management of the effects of the earthquake: https://www.bkam.ma/en/News/2023/Make-your-donations-to-the-special-fund https://www.bkam.ma/en/News/2023/Make-your-donations-to-the-...