10 ms·
Are cooking videos making us better cooks?
- robomartin 3y agoDidn't read the article. That said, on the general topic hinted at by the title: Yes, they do. I followed Gordon Ramsay's many videos for a couple of years. I went from being able to a repertoire of eggs, rice and barbecue to cooking as close to world-class meals as I can imagine. This, to the point that we stopped going to expensive restaurants because, in most cases, the food is inferior to what I am able to cook at home. When you come out of a restaurant with your family, having dropped the equivalent of a car payment for the meal and your kids tell you "Dad, what you cook is massively better than that", well, you know you learned something. I also helped me learn and understand about such things as sauces, spices, proper preparation and generally giving me a sense of the things I can experiment with, have fun cooking and have more variety at my fingertips than just three dishes. So, yeah, for me, absolutely. Of course, what you get out of it is a function of the time and effort you put into it.
- r0b1n 3y agoI'm a fan of the various Jacques Pépin videos on youtube because they give a lot of advice on technique. There is an hour long one I cannot find right now that basically has almost everything you'll ever need in a video. And I like (also on youtube) Italia Squisita, because they nicely show what variations you can do, showing italian classics and their michelin-star version of it side by side. Edit: found the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CshkecuFfMc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CshkecuFfMc
- chongli 3y agoJacques Pépin is an absolute treasure. Such a famous chef yet never a jerk to anyone. Another favourite of mine is J. Kenji Lopez-Alt [1], or Kenji as everyone calls him . Really nice and non-pretentious guy. Tons of great advice for beginners. His cookbook even goes into details like how to stock and organize your fridge! I think one of his most endearing qualities is that he doesn’t hide his mistakes. He leaves them in the video and talks about them and how to recover. Far too often we see TV shows about people making mistakes in the kitchen and getting reamed out by the celebrity chef or having a meltdown of their own. Mistakes are inevitable in the kitchen, especially when you’re just starting out. Feeling really bad about it is a pretty surefire way to lose interest in learning to cook. [1] https://youtube.com/@JKenjiLopezAlt?si=Ubk8CUrtb8jkL8h1 https://youtube.com/@JKenjiLopezAlt?si=Ubk8CUrtb8jkL8h1
- deprecative 3y agoKenji is great until you have misophonia and his mouth sounds get you and you have issues with how unclean everything he does is. But his videos are a goldmine for great skills, recipes, everything. It is very good if you have a little basic hygiene and food safety skills and do not pick up bad habits from him. The knife manufacturer he uses has been very, very good as well. I have a few of their knives and it's been wonderful.
- kevinmchugh 3y agoI can't think of anything unhygienic I've ever seen Kenji do - do you have an example?
- deprecative 3y agoDoesn't (always) wash his hands after handling raw meat. Uses a sponge to wipe up raw chicken fluids and smears it all over the counter and stove.
- amrocha 3y agoThe guy is a professional chef that has run multiple restaurants and teaches people how to cook. Your standards for cleanliness might be unnecessarily higher, but don't you think it's a bit disingenuous to call his cooking "unclean"?
- deprecative 3y agoDude straight up uses a sponge to clean up the fluids from raw chicken and wipes down his stove with it. He rinses with water and uses utensils after handling raw meat. Why are you taking my observations personally? It doesn't make sense.
- amrocha 3y agoSure, he's made mistakes, that doesn't make his cooking "unclean". Unless people are getting sick from it (and they're not), his cooking is fine. And I'm not taking it personally btw, I just think it's silly to claim you know more about kitchen hygiene than a literal professional.
- pcardoso 3y agoChef Jean Pierre is another gem of a cook. https://www.youtube.com/@ChefJeanPierre https://www.youtube.com/@ChefJeanPierre
- 9991 3y ago> Didn't read the article. From the Hacker News Guidelines: > Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Next time you don't read an article, please keep it to yourself.
- teh_klev 3y agoI think you got the wrong end of the stick with that guideline. It's intended for folks who accuse others of not having read the article, not for self admission that one didn't read the article. Also the article is behind a paywall and even with all my own usual tricks I can't get at it to read in any sensible way (even archive.is). In this case the article's topic is fairly obvious that you could legitimately comment here.
- morelisp 3y agoIt seems unfair if you can accuse yourself of not having read the article but not someone else.
- TheDong 3y ago> all my own usual tricks I can't get at it to read in any sensible way archive.org works fine for it for me. Does the following work for you? https://web.archive.org/web/20230904034416/https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/08/07/dining/cooking-videos-tiktok.html https://web.archive.org/web/20230904034416/https://www.nytim...
- teh_klev 3y agoHow odd, my first attempt with archive.org didn't work (I got a blank page). Seems to work now, thank you.
- robertlagrant 3y ago[flagged]
- 3y ago
- matwood 3y agoI've watched a lot of Gordon Ramsay videos and agree with you. His style is so efficient and not overly complicated, but he does everything perfect. Something else that he's led me to think about is to move more quickly. Making a great meal does not take very long once you have some base skills.
- quickthrower2 3y agoYou can beat a lot of restaurants as a shit cook simply because of economics. You are not under obligation to make a profit, so you don't need to cut the same corners. And the as you get to the high end stuff - that expensive stuff is really awful. Not hearty at all. It's like modern art, I am supposed to "get it" but I don't.
- jpmoral 3y agoI don't know about "better" but I do know that without the Internet I wouldn't have tried at all. Edit: after posting this I realised that video doesn't necessarily mean online but those don't have the same reach.
- twelve40 3y agoI agree... people like to complain how Google is overrun with recipe spam, but I actually tried a bunch of stuff from whatever Google pointed me to,liked it, and now do a bunch of cooking I wouldn't have done otherwise.
- aszantu 3y agoI got unlucky one day and watched a cooking video while intoxicated... it's so awful how they have to put some more of this and some of that and it wouldn#t be good without another spice... it's like sorcery... and the ppl doing it behave like that as well... horrible vibes, doesn't help that they all look sick and fat.
- theshrike79 3y agoMost cookbooks tend to be like the meme about drawing an owl [0]. Mostly because the people making the instructions make assumptions about Stuff One Should Just Know and skip those bits in the instructions. On video you can actually see the consistency of things as they are cooked and maybe even hear what the process sounds like (frying spices in oil has a distinct sound if the oil is at the correct temperature). You can also see the proper cutting technique, hopefully saving your fingers from pain later on. [0] https://www.danielzarick.com/uploads/2018-05-draw-the-owl.jpg https://www.danielzarick.com/uploads/2018-05-draw-the-owl.jp...
- rightbyte 3y agoYe but then it has to be a running video without cuts. But even then they might assume too much about my competence. I am trying to figure out how to use a specific tool to correct hinches with. And in each video I find the carpenter is like "then you bend in this direction" and stuff gets alligned. But I have no idea how they know which direction to pull on my door and they skip those steps while trying to explain.
- marginalia_nu 3y agoA lot what separates good and bad cooking is tacit understanding that can't be explained in words. You need to practice to detect the nuances in flavor. It's really basic and doesn't make good edutaninment content. I'd say 90% of being a competent chef is just down to knowing how to balance the basic flavor components; and to figure out how these things change during the cooking process. With practice and experimentation you can learn to infer what is lacking by taste and make anything go from bland to amazing. Spices and ingredients are much less important. They aren't unimportant, but they aren't what makes something decent into something great. You can make a head cabbage more delicious than most what you'll find in a cookbook if you get this right.
- tayo42 3y agoYeah agree with this Reading "Salt, fat acid heat" demonstrates this really well. Maybe almost to well, it takes away some of the mystery I guess between cuisines. Everything is the same, just different aromatics/spices added That book changed how I approach cooking, I always wondered how people just make recipes, and now I can mostly do it
- glogla 3y agoI think especially the videos that show the process, like J. Kenji's, are pretty good (don't expect to be as fast as him when making things, though). But you still have to try it and practice, not just watch. The part of cooking I'm struggling with right now, and would love some guides and content on, is how to prepare a menu and plan groceries. It's a lot of work, but I'm sure there are ways to make it easier.
- leipert 3y agoDo you mean menu as in a weekly schedule or for a single function where you invite guests? Weekly menus have been easy for the family, if you plan in a few stews or rice/quinoa/bulgur/cuscus based dishes which are more forgiving with certain ratios of vegetables and stuff. So plan a few nice meals which need exact ratios, and with stuff you overbought/leftovers you can do these other dishes.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoWhen people ask me to teach them how to cook I definitely set expectations that we will be talking and shopping first. By the time you're in the kitchen with your knife out 2/3 of the work is already done.
- fuzztester 3y agoIt's equally or more the case that cooking more makes (for) better cooking videos ...
- myshpa 3y agoCooking makes us better cooks. Edit: I hear and I forget. I see and I remember. I do and I understand.
- BookhouseGames 3y agoAgreed. Practice at something makes us better at the thing.
- r0b1n 3y agoDisagreed. Practice is just one component in a cycle that makes us better: We watch something, think of something, read something. Then we try it out in practice. Then we observe or have someone else observe the practice and result. Then we take suggestions and improvements into account from that observation. Then we start over at one of the points above. If you only just repeat the "practice" step you'll get set in your ways, get used to doing the same mistakes all over, etc.
- myshpa 3y agoWhen it comes to cooking, it's hard to imagine someone getting progressively worse, especially when they are the ones tasting their creations. If it doesn't taste right, they'll naturally adjust and improve. The feedback loop is immediate and personal.
- r0b1n 3y ago"Better" is very one-dimensional, but cooking isn't. You can get worse at taste but better at health. Better at health and taste but worse at time consumption. Better at price but worse at hygiene. Many things are possible, but without an audience or at least your own critical acclaim, you cannot prioritize. And, of course, "there is no accounting for taste" meaning that some of the aforementioned dimensions are very subjective.
- light_hue_1 3y agoIt's easy to imagine people getting worse over time. I see it regularly. People don't do blind taste tests when they cook. They cook something and compare it to their previous memory. Then they slowly diverge and enter some crazy part of the space where no one should be cooking an ingredient that way. There's no notion of something tasting right on its own. You need to compare it against a better version of that dish. It's easy for two people to cook exactly the same dish, following the same recipe, both of them to think it came out great, and then when they taste each other's to discover that one is dramatically better.
- globular-toast 3y agoCan't seem to read the article. Some JS crap is freezing the page and can't scroll down (Firefox). I've learnt lots from both books and videos. Being a "good cook" requires a few things: * Skill in common techniques, * Knowledge of ingredients, * Good tools, * Repertoire. Videos are great for learning techniques. I've got books that do an admirable job of teaching how to knead or whisk etc., but nothing beats seeing someone do it. Some techniques are impossible to replicate without the right tools, though. You won't be able to replicate the chopping techniques you see with a cheap, blunt knife, for example. Videos often fail to mention this. Books are the best for knowledge about ingredients. Videos could do it, but I've never seen one and it's probably not good for TV or the Youtube algorithm. You just need to know a few key things about ingredients like how to buy them, how to prepare them (which bit to peel, which tools to use etc.), how ingredients interact with each other (for example, a video will show you cooking the onions before putting in acidic ingredients like tomatoes, but will it tell you why?) Harold McGee's On Food and Cooking is a must-have. Repertoire comes with time and I think you can get that from either books or videos. The best cooks don't really follow recipes after a while. A brief skim is often enough to assimilate a new recipe and it can then be carried out using existing knowledge and skills. For such a cook, a video can be a very inefficient way of learning a new recipe. I think of repertoire as like a giant Makefile in my head, I wrote about it in a bit of a silly article on my blog: https://georgek.github.io/blog/posts/cooking-with-make/ https://georgek.github.io/blog/posts/cooking-with-make/
- pjmorris 3y ago> Harold McGee's On Food and Cooking is a must-have. I love McGee, but we only tend to pull it out when we have a history or science question, not so much when we're cooking. A book we lean on heavily is 'The Flavor Profile Bible', Dornenberg and Page. The bulk of the book is an index of ingredients, listing ingredients/herbs/spices that pair well with each ingredient. We've profited from the videos mentioned here and we have our favorite cookbooks, but when we go to spice up the routine, this is the place we turn most often.
- lynx23 3y agoYou know, there is this old joke: Partner 1: "You'Re watching cooking videos all day, but still can't cook!" Partner 2: "Well, you're watching pron..."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mabbo 3y agoThe absolute pinnacle of cooking video chefs today has to be J. Kenji Lopez-Alt[0], in large part because of his use of first person view. He straps a go-pro to this head and you see what he sees while he cooks. There's no cuts or retakes (unless he's waiting for something to cook or gets interrupted by his kids). There's no swaps. And it's all real- he's cooking dinner for his family. And it doesn't always go perfectly. (See the excellent video titled "Doesn't matter, still pizza"). I'm a better cook for what I've learned watching him cook. [0] - https://m.youtube.com/@JKenjiLopezAlt https://m.youtube.com/@JKenjiLopezAlt
- annexrichmond 3y agoIt may have been Chef John who really popularized this first person angle
- veryfancy 3y agoChef John is a delight. Charming man, straightforward recipes.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoIs there just one Chef John? Last time I googled around, it wasn't clear to me.
- arthens 3y agoThis is the one that comes to mind https://youtube.com/@foodwishes https://youtube.com/@foodwishes
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kevinmchugh 3y agoI found his written work (which is how he built his following) _much_ more useful, but part of that's just about how I process information. Certainly it's valuable to be able to see how certain things are done, and it's hard for cooks to describe techniques sometimes.
- chpatrick 3y agoNot Another Cooking Show is another good no-BS cooking channel (although the thumbnails have been becoming more youtubey): https://www.youtube.com/@NOTANOTHERCOOKINGSHOW https://www.youtube.com/@NOTANOTHERCOOKINGSHOW
- wnolens 3y agoI'm a fan of this guy too. I have quite a few Italian recipes under my sleeve now.
- bkovacev 3y agoHere's a few more channels that I personally enjoy and recommend: - Ethan Chlebowski https://www.youtube.com/@EthanChlebowski https://www.youtube.com/@EthanChlebowski - Adam Ragusea https://www.youtube.com/@aragusea https://www.youtube.com/@aragusea I tried numerous recipes from both and learned quite a bit about the technique as well.
- throw0101a 3y agoJack Ovens is pretty decent (has a playlist of meal prep stuff): * https://www.youtube.com/@ChefJackOvens https://www.youtube.com/@ChefJackOvens
- DiabloD3 3y agohttps://www.youtube.com/@CharlieAndersonCooking https://www.youtube.com/@CharlieAndersonCooking is also a good one, and https://www.youtube.com/@FrenchGuyCooking https://www.youtube.com/@FrenchGuyCooking is highly entertaining and sometimes is educational.
- senkora 3y agoI also like Brian Lagerstrom, who has a similar style to them: https://youtube.com/@BrianLagerstrom?feature=shared https://youtube.com/@BrianLagerstrom?feature=shared
- arthens 3y agoGreat recommendations. I also enjoy https://youtube.com/@ProHomeCooks https://youtube.com/@ProHomeCooks
- danjoredd 3y agoTownsends is my favorite, as well as Tasting History - Townsends https://www.youtube.com/@townsends https://www.youtube.com/@townsends - Tasting History https://www.youtube.com/@TastingHistory https://www.youtube.com/@TastingHistory
- matsemann 3y agoWhat I often miss is "the basics". After reading a recipe or following a video, I perhaps know how to make exactly that dish. But that's like a bootcamp programmer learning a single framework. I want to learn the concepts, how to apply them, how and when to break the rules, how to modify it and experiment with what I got. When I follow a recipe, and the result isn't pristine, how do I fix it? Should I add more salt? Should I get better at picking my tomatoes? I don't want to follow a cooking video to make the same recipe. What I want is to learn these things. I tried MasterClass, but felt it was just more of the same. Well produced, but in the end still recipe-follow-along. Which I enjoy watching, but in the same way watching Veritasium or Numberphile it is mostly entertainment, and doesn't make me a mathematician.
- Inityx 3y agoI'm a big fan of Helen Rennie on YouTube, since she spends a lot of time talking about those types of things https://youtube.com/@helenrennie https://youtube.com/@helenrennie
- maxnoe 3y agoGive "Salt Fat Acid Heat" a try (the book, not the netflix show)
- p1necone 3y agoThe Netflix show suuuuuucks, They completely disregarded the whole point of the book in favor of just doing a bog standard "make a pretty dish and eat it with some people" show. They barely went into any of the actually useful stuff the book talks about (it's in the name!).
- bityard 3y agoSee if there are any legit culinary classes in your area. If you don't want to take a class, you could maybe get by reading the textbooks they use. It at least go to the library and check out their culinary selection. A couple decades ago, there was a tv show called Good Eats by Alton Brown. If you can find the reruns, it has a lot of information for newbies, but it will take a long time to watch it all. I'm not an amazing chef but I do okay when I put my mind to it. Like anything else, it takes some up front effort to learn the basics and experience to learn the rest.
- 11235813213455 3y agoThere are very few things I cook, only rice and lentils, all the rest of my food I eat it crude (mostly vegetable, or even eggs, for fish I leave it in lemon juice, typically sardines, lemon also work for leek or onions to make them less strong. So cooking mostly happens in my guts now, and for vegetable digestion is incredibly better when outside, under the sun. Cooking destroy vitamins and many things
- apienx 3y agoGlad you found what suits your microbiome. Note that our species probably wouldn’t have developed big brains without “cooking”.
- 11235813213455 3y agoSure, but as our intelligence now decreases https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37307064 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37307064, we can try to find other ways to subsist
- jankoprowski 3y agoI recommend wonderful book "Cooking for geeks" [0] One of many things I learn from this book is physical and chemical processes ruling the cooking :) [0] - https://www.amazon.com/Cooking-Geeks-Science-Great-Cooks/dp/1491928050/ https://www.amazon.com/Cooking-Geeks-Science-Great-Cooks/dp/...
- psukhedelos 3y agoIs there any cooking content that takes into account cleaning up after? In my limited viewing experience the focus often seems to be prep and the cooking, ignoring the reality of the inevitable clean up. Is there anyone focusing on recipes and how to cook that minimises / reuses cookware and through to a reset clean kitchen? When I cook I enjoy getting into a flow where I’m ordering the prep or modifying the recipe so I’m able to reduce dirtying extra dishes and aim to have minimal clean up afterwards. Ideally the clean up of the cooking is essentially done by the time food is being served. I’m half serious and half amused at the idea of a cooking competition style show where participants must plate up, serve and then scrub.
- Groxx 3y agoThere are a fair number of "one pan" (pot/bowl/etc) recipes out there for this specific purpose, definitely try that search term :) though I haven't seen much of anything that includes cleanup explicitly. Only rare exceptions. And yeah, number of dishes matters to me too, much of the time. Most of the stuff I make can be done with one, rarely two, and that's about where I draw the line.
- clan 3y agoWe all have our own journey. But one of the biggest improvements in enjoying to cook was to learn not to clean up after. It was a revelation to me and the big enabler which moved cooking from a chore to something I appreciate. Do not clean up after - clean during! Maybe annoying at first but it quickly turn into a habit There is plenty of time (as a home cook!) during prep to clean the knives, bowls boards etc. What will seem like a huge mountain if left to linger will be a breeze when you learn to keep your station clean. And you never see this very simple fact of life in most videos. I really used to optimize how few bowls etc. I would use as I hated the dishes afterwards. But quickly cleaning a bowl after use only take seconds and I no longer dread reaching for another if it ease my process. This usually only leaves a pan and maybe a pot to clean when done eating. Not too bad even though I do them by hand as I am particular with what goes into the dishwasher That. And doing mis en place rather than running head first into it. Absolute key lessons for me. Sparks joy ;-) EDIT: And if you stack things in the sink we cannot be friends. Sorry. Stack them elsewhere and keep them low.
- mustafa_pasi 3y agoI love watching cooking videos. It's my number one go to, when I want to turn off my brain completely. But I never try to replicate recipes. I just pick up ideas. I never ever cook from a recipe, either. Cooking is very much like programming. You have a goal (what you feel like eating that day), a framework (what you have laying around and your cooking skills) and you just execute something that approximates your goal. And just like programming you have to learn by doing. Sometimes it is worth following recipes when you want to cook something new from a foreign cuisine, but I rarely do that. I cook almost exclusively European food, so I know instinctively how to combine the ingredients together to get the taste profile I am yearning for, and I also know how to cook each of the separate ingredients individually. I really don't "get" people who seem to lack this cooking instinct. In my family there is nobody who doesn't know how to cook. My father rarely cooked when my mother was in good health, but once she fell ill, he picked it up at the ripe old age of 70, and is now able to cook pretty much everything. Baked savoury goods are his favourite. If you don't know how to cook, you probably need to cancel your food delivery subscriptions and just force yourself to cook your own food. You'll pick it up amazingly quickly. I messed up quite a few times, but I don't remember ever having to throw food away. You always get something edible if you are creative enough. A couple of weeks ago I had one of my worst disasters. I was attempting a Georgian savoury pie and my dough was a bit too highly hydrated and my filling a bit too warm due to my impatience, and I tried using a new technique for forming the pie instead of the usual one of sandwiching the filling between two pre-rolled layers of dough. The bottom of the pie tore apart and I was left with a mix of filling and raw dough. It seemed like a write-off, but I quickly added a bit more flour and mixed it all thoroughly together and baked it as a bread instead, and it turned out a bit dry but delicious. Anyway, there is definitely value in cooking videos.
- selimthegrim 3y agoUsually, I will take a couple different recipes for the same dish and mix-and-match things I like from them to arrive at an approximation of the same result.
- singingwolfboy 3y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20230904111038/https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/08/07/dining/cooking-videos-tiktok.html https://web.archive.org/web/20230904111038/https://www.nytim...
- sigzero 3y agoIt's making me a better cook.
- foorio 3y ago[dead]
- wnolens 3y ago[flagged]
- prpl 3y agoI think some Jacques Pepin videos, especially old ones, helped me to the next level, more than anything else. I have a 70s print of La Methods and, while I was fairly advanced before getting it, it is pretty thorough on methods for cooking. The thing I love about his later stuff especially is that it is practically freestyle. Ming Tsai has a bit of that too.
- misterflibble 3y agoHe is masterful, and I regularly use some of his simple dinners for my weekly rotation recipes. Like Anthony Bourdain said "if Jacques Pepin shows you how to roast a chicken, that's how you roast a chicken!"
- el_benhameen 3y agoI love his philosophy and style, particularly in his various PBS series. He teaches you not just to cook different dishes, but how to gracefully cook several at once in a reasonable weeknight dinner timeframe. The way he’s relaxed about quantities and substitutions and focuses on making things the way he likes them versus how they’re “supposed to be made” completely changed my approach to the kitchen and gave me a fundamental ease with cooking. And I love the “waste not, want not” philosophy!
- wenc 3y agoI have a copy of the combined La Méthode and La Technique. Although I don't have any special affinity for French cooking, Jacques Pepin got me into cooking because he showed me that method and technique was universal. His knife skills were fun to watch. The person who got me into knife skills was Martin Yan who had a show called "Yan Can Cook" (not to be confused with Wok with Yan by Stephen Yan from Canada).
- Finnucane 3y agoYears ago I worked in the library at the French Culinary Institute and I had all of the demo videos on a shelf behind my desk, including the ones Chef Jacques made. And his demos often focused on very basic techniques like knife skills, but it was stuff you’d be doing every day, and he made it clear why getting good at them mattered.
- aprentic 3y agoThat's kind of like asking any variety of, "Can X videos make us better at X?" Absolutely, but the more relevant question is if a particular cooking video or series, out of the vast set of "cooking videos" will make a particular viewer a better cook. Probably not. I'd suggest a few questions to determine if that's true. What is the specificity of the video? Some "cooking" videos only pretend to be about teaching cooking but they're actually about something entirely different. I love watching old episodes of Iron Chef but I don't expect to learn anything practical. Some cooking shows are about a particular aspect of cooking; a video on cooking with Spam won't make me a better cook because I don't cook with Spam. A video on how to make cakes look attractive with fondant won't make me a better cook because I like food made of food ingredients rather than construction materials. Does the author know their subject matter? Many videos tell you stuff that's just plain wrong, or even dangerous (don't make popcorn on a soda-can stove with methanol or it could blow up in your face). Are they level-appropriate? When I left for college, my mom gave me a copy of "How to boil an egg". I got a lot of benefit out of that book but something similar would be useless today. By the same token, years later, we got a lot of great information of of Rose Levy Beranbaum's "The Bread Bible", but it wouldn't have helped me at all as a freshman with a communal kitchen and minimal cooking ability. There's also the question of what the viewer is going to do with it. You can watch videos all day long without getting any better at cooking. If you want to get better at cooking you primarily need to cook. Some videos may aid that effort but even the best ones will only help to the extent that you're willing to implement what they teach and practice it.
- airwejtilawj 3y agoOf course. The vast majority of "cooking" videos are intended for entertainment, not instruction. I can honestly say that the majority of what I know today about cooking I learned from Youtube, but the most popular videos on Youtube are the most shallow ones, the ones that do three second cuts between unrelated images and spend most of their time showing people's faces instead of the purported subject matter. For most cooking videos, 95% of viewers will never even consider actually doing any cooking based on what they watched. But in spite of that, Youtube is an incredible learning resource for the minority of users who actually want to use it to learn. Maybe that's the best we can hope for.
- airwejtilawj 3y ago[flagged]
- mongol 3y agoI like the Chain Baker. He has a quite scientific approach, for example he bakes the same bread with salt before yeast, yeast before salt, and two other variations, to explore the difference it makes. In the next video he tries something else in four variations. Over time you learn what matters and not.
- an_aparallel 3y agothe right kind...of cooking videos make us better cooks...100% just like the right kind of recipe books. There are tonnes of both kinds. I learnt to cook legitimate indian cuisine watching www.vahchef.com videos. I learnt to cook legitimate korean food by reading www.maangchi.com recipes. And i learnt bonafide Persian cooking from "Food of Life". I think books, websites and videos all make for better cooks...so long as the recipe writer is aware of their assumed knowledge and can consisely deliver the tricks of the trade within a recipe that holds the cooks attention, be it on the page or in the video. The written recipes from Vahchef were actual legit trash - with missing ingredients and steps. But his videos...un believable!
- neonate 3y agohttps://archive.ph/ljBsv https://archive.ph/ljBsv
- dbg31415 3y agoI TiVo’d and watched “Everyday Italian” most nights in college but I never seemed to learn how to cook anything from the show. Still… time well spent. Ha!
- EdwardCoffin 3y agoI learned to cook in the '90s and '00s, so before cooking videos. I was mostly self-taught, from cookbooks and magazines. I absolutely would have benefited from some of the basic techniques type videos available now: the kinds that show what simmering looks and sounds like compared to what boiling looks like. The kind that shows how to soften onions until they're glassy, and how to sauté garlic without burning it. My main mistakes back then were simply using too high a heat (though on rare occasion not high enough, like when pan-searing fish), cooking too long, and not using enough oil. All of these things could have been corrected with basic technique videos. On a somewhat related note, a long time ago I learned how to make gnocchi from an elderly Italian woman. Her teaching technique was immersive: she simply made a batch of it with me standing at her side. There's an art to how quickly you knead the flour into the potatoes: if you don't knead it in rapidly enough you work it too much and it gets tough. You also don't want to overshoot and knead too much flour in. She would work a certain amount in, then have me poke the dough to feel it, and she'd comment on the consistency and where in the process we were; things like "this is what it feels like when you're almost there" and "now it is ready". These things were remarkably hard to put into words, it was a much more immediate thing, like she could detect and point out to me how different it felt from thirty seconds ago. These were things like resilience, just how resistant the dough was to being poked and how quickly it popped back. I can't see how this kind of thing could be conveyed in text or a video, or any way other than in person.
- tracerbulletx 3y agoI think that the internet is making everyone (on average), better at everything and we just don't really notice because we get used to it. I've seen higher standards for almost every hobby, chore, sport, and daily activity because everyone is comparing themselves to the global experts in whatever it is that they do and have access to being taught by them.
- daft_pink 3y agoIt's making me actually cook, which by default ia making me a better cook, because I don't cook. I watch Ethan Chlebowski on youtube. However, the comments thread here is full of so many ideas that I'm going to check them out when I get a chance. Thanks everyone for commenting!
- SoftTalker 3y agoTo learn to cook, cook. Maybe take a basic culinary class at the local community college to learn how to chop and dice and slice and other basics. But just cook. You get better by doing.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoFor a very different take on cooking videos, I recommend "Cooking Terms" [0] by RiffTrax. [0] https://www.rifftrax.com/cooking-terms https://www.rifftrax.com/cooking-terms
- bicepjai 3y agoChef John Food Wishes has made me a better cook. I’m not a chef but I have learned a lot from his videos. The great learning process in his videos is that he wants us to play with choices that cater to our needs. Definitely #1 rank in my listing
- poulsbohemian 3y agoHere's another take: with the way blogospam and search engine fodder has ruined recipe sites, cooking videos are one of the best ways to actually capture new food ideas and recipes. It's also the best way I know to learn a new cuisine. I was a proficient cook before tuning in to videos, but the videos have enabled me to expand the options of what I can put on my family's table.
- Dowwie 3y agoI can create delicious Korean recipes because of Maangchi. I can also create the perfect crispy breakfast potatoes because of J. Kenji Lopez Alt. Cooking videos gave me the confidence to try to replicate what is made. I never feel the same from cookbooks.
- smudgy 3y agoDunno but it's definitely making me more creative - I've branched from american, brazilian, italian, french and japanese to adding chinese, korean, vietnamese, scottish, english and canadian.
- danjoredd 3y agoIt depends entirely on the cooking video. Cooking tiktoks? They are a waste of everybody's time. Nobody is going to make a recipe from TikTok. Videos like Townsends? Yeah, I make food from them all the time!
- c_o_n_v_e_x 3y agoThe Thomas Keller masterclass was very good imo, the series focused on techniques and principles rather than recipes.
- tekchip 3y agoI scrolled a ways and was surprised to not run across any shoutouts for Brian Langerstrom. Really clear, really concise, recipes and presentation that are so so good. https://youtube.com/@BrianLagerstrom https://youtube.com/@BrianLagerstrom