9 ms·
Top Russian rocket scientist dies from ‘mushroom poisoning’
- nicechianti 3y ago[dead]
- deely3 3y agoI am curious, does similar 'mushroom posioning' starts happening in last few years, or does similar incidents happened across last decades?
- krastanov 3y agoWild mushroom foraging is pretty common in Eastern Europe. Warnings about it in elementary school was why I was scared of eating mushrooms for a decade (admittedly a rather childish overreaction ;). Every few years I will hear about someone getting severely ill. Context: growing up in Bulgaria in the 90s and 00s.
- yread 3y agoin other words something like 30% of population goes foraging for mushrooms at least once a year and once a year someone dies. It's so rare that they write about it in the newspaper
- oneshtein 3y agoThis tradition predates Russian Empire.
- Muromec 3y agoObligatory https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21287736 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21287736
- dagw 3y agoPicking wild mushrooms is super common in Scandinavia. I had some mushrooms my wife picked for dinner yesterday. You read about maybe 1-2 deaths or serious illnesses a year in the newspaper, and it always makes national news. So yes it happens, but it's probably quite literally a 1-in-a-million event.
- 29athrowaway 3y agoThere is an AI generated book about mushroom foraging that gives fake, dangerous advice.
- pc86 3y agoDo you think that's relevant in this case?
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoDo they think dangerous advice on mushroom foraging is relevant to the topic of someone maybe having died from eating the wrong mushroom sourced from mushroom foraging? Do you think it's not relevant? It might not be that interesting, but you and I already made an off-the-cuff remark into way more of a thing than it deserved. Just downvote if you don't like the comment.
- Almondsetat 3y agoDo you think a recently made AI generated book only available in English and from western shops has made its way to a 77yo Russian executive who probably learnt to pick mushrooms 50 years ago?
- mcpackieh 3y agoThat's plainly not what pbhjpbhj said.
- belter 3y agoHe/she might be an AI...
- tgv 3y agoIt does sound at least related to me. As in: people with less experience and less precision that you might expect from a rocket scientist could be misled easily, with the same outcome.
- kdamica 3y agoDefinitely could be foul play, but I’ve also known a few older Russians who were very proud of their mushroom foraging skills.
- rebolek 3y agoAt 77 years, he certainly knew what he's picking up, it's not that hard to learn edible mushrooms, poisonous mushrooms and ignore the rest which may be edible but also not.
- appletrotter 3y ago> At 77 years, he certainly knew what he's picking up, Objection, conjecture!
- krastanov 3y agoThis is not remotely what the "common knowledge" about mushroom foraging is in Eastern Europe. There is a "funny" story in Bulgaria how the most famous mushroom foraging expert in Bulgaria a few decades ago died because he made a mistake when foraging. Plenty of edible mushrooms are just "twins" of poisonous mushrooms, using animal's knowledge to not eat them, without expending the metabolic cost to actually produce poison.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Plenty of edible mushrooms are just "twins" of poisonous mushrooms These are also living, evolving organisms. There will be mutants who knock back on a poisonous gene.
- oblak 3y agoYour counter example is one guy dying from poisoning, in a country that does a lot of shroom foraging (берем гъби у гората). The Russia rocket expert was likely killed.
- krastanov 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sonofhans 3y agoThe thing about the mafia — and the Russian government today is more mafia than anything — is that you can’t continue to make empty threats. Even if everyone in your protection racket is paying up, and no one is squealing or making waves, you still need to remind people _why_ they keep paying you. So it’s absolutely in Putin’s interests to keep assassinating his adversaries, and not to disclaim credit even if the deaths are not ordered by him. Random deaths reinforce Putin’s power just fine — it’s worse if you don’t know, if the threat of extrajudicial killing is random rather than predictable.
- jncfhnb 3y agoThis is a relatively new trend in recent times following a failed coup.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoputin assassinating people who displease him is not even remotely a new trend
- tristramb 3y ago"If you collect mushrooms for eating, you should always take 3 samples: one for the pot, one for the doctor and one for the coroner" Advice given on a fungus identification forum.
- FridayNightTV 3y ago[flagged]
- andsoitis 3y agoWhat is recommended reading for getting started with mushroom foraging? It seems like such an interesting activity.
- oldstrangers 3y agoEven then it's very advisable to go out into the wilderness with a trained professional.
- Trellmor 3y agoI recommend on of those https://www.404media.co/ai-generated-mushroom-foraging-books-amazon/ https://www.404media.co/ai-generated-mushroom-foraging-books... /s
- everyone 3y agoThese guys seem to know their stuff. There is a discord also. https://www.shroomery.org/ https://www.shroomery.org/
- toast0 3y agoMushroom foraging is highly local. Chances are you have a nearby mushroom group which could recommend a book that's good for your area.
- krastanov 3y agoThe vast majority of literature on the subject that I have seen uses drawings, not pictures... Probably part of the reason why this hobby has the reputation of killing people (in my country, Bulgaria, during the 90s and 00s). Not really answering your question, but it reminded me of...
- littlestymaar 3y agoAs a contrepoint, when drawing you can emphasize on the specific features of the mushroom you're drawing whereas pictures are always being more ambiguous. And if the mushroom you're about to pick has unclear specific features, you should not pick it anyway!
- deleted 3y ago
- hn72774 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- renegade-otter 3y agoThis is not really suspicious. I regularly went foraging for shrooms in Ukraine with my gram gram, but I was not allowed to pick anything, of course. It requires expertise. In that part of the world, this is very common, and so are the cases of people poisoning themselves because they think they are good at it. If you can't relate - think of all the "gun people" who think they are experts on gun safety and then they end up shooting themselves by accident.
- qaq 3y agoThat's more a question of proximity of events. Falling out of a window is not really suspicious. Falling out of a window while being on a crytical path for money laundering investigation into money laundering of Putin's inner circle ...
- throwawaymaths 3y agoFalling out a window is pretty much suspicious unless you're trying to demonstrate how safe the window is (they are, but not that safe)
- ncann 3y agoObligatory story about Garry Hoy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Garry_Hoy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Garry_Hoy
- hunson_abadeer 3y agoIt is not common at all. You have maybe several people dying every year, which is in the "hit by lightning" territory. It's very well-publicized whenever it happens, which probably helps keep the numbers low. But this is a very unusual way to die.
- scotty79 3y agoIt's like few cases per season per million people eating wild shrooms.
- ManuelKiessling 3y agoIs Russia running out of windows or what?
- api 3y agoPrigozhin fell from the sky in a plane so at least that one was still a fall. This isn’t even trying. I’m just blown away by the gullible fools who see this dying totalitarian dystopia with statistics around birth and family life that are way worse than anything in the West as a beacon of resistance to decadence or something. Of course I guess this isn’t new with Russia. Back in the Cold War it was naive elements of the left and now it’s naive elements of the right. They seem to excel at marketing themselves to the deeply disaffected. But there’s nothing there but a Potemkin village. The Gulag Archipelago should be required reading.
- pavlov 3y agoOr if it’s not Russia proper, then the object of right-wing idolatry is Orbán’s “illiberal democracy” in Hungary which is essentially Diet Putin.
- mindslight 3y agoThe ironic thing is that even a broken clock is right twice a day. This is like scoring less than 25% on a multiple choice test.
- SomeoneFromCA 3y agoThere are left apologists for Russia too. Jeffrey Sachs, Chomsky (he is doing it again, defending tyrants).
- throwaway154 3y ago[flagged]
- dboreham 3y agoPeople legit do die from mushrooms though. We had an incident locally a few months ago involving a restaurant that served a kind of mushroom that needs to be cooked, but didn't cook them (allegedly).
- DonHopkins 3y ago[dead]
- ben_w 3y ago"Special Lithobreaking Operation"
- demetrius 3y agoThe dates don't add up. The scientist got into hospital with mushroom positioning at 11th of August. https://charter97.org/ru/news/2023/8/31/561949/ https://charter97.org/ru/news/2023/8/31/561949/ The crash happened on the 19th of August. https://meduza.io/news/2023/08/19/roskosmos-pri-perehode-stantsii-luna-25-na-predposadochnuyu-orbitu-proizoshla-neshtatnaya-situatsiya https://meduza.io/news/2023/08/19/roskosmos-pri-perehode-sta...
- ImPostingOnHN 3y ago[flagged]
- tapyourears 3y ago[flagged]
- blindriver 3y agoYevgeny Prigozhin faked his death in 2019 via plane crash in the Congo. So I think the jury is still out whether or not he's actually dead. But people in Putin's gaze "mysteriously" die or get poisoned by polonium or other nasty stuff.
- petre 3y agoHe's probably dead this time. He was a dead man walking after his little rebellion anyway. Also, most of Wagner leadership died on that crash, including Utkin. He'd have to fake everybody's death.
- tibbydudeza 3y agoStrange indeed - sure it is just all coincidence.
- dannylandau 3y agoAs an active mushroom hunter (born in Russia), can confirm that this is extremely unlikely and uncommon. People who have done this since birth know how distinguish between mushrooms, and usually stick to the variety that they love the best. In Russia, the mushroom of choice is the "White Mushroom" (or Porcini, King Bolete) or Rejik (Milky cap) and Chanterreles, and a few others, and that's it, with the top 2 being the most sought after. I've been doing this for over 35 years, and always go after the same mushrooms, and have never been poisoned. So, very unlikely someone much older would make a mistake, sounds like foul play.
- tester756 3y agoOn the other hand - routine kills
- chinathrow 3y agoOn the other hand - Putin kills too.
- 404mm 3y ago> How did the he die? > From mushroom poisoning > But… there’s a bullet hole in his head.. > He refused to eat the mushrooms (Joke from 1980’s, Eastern Europe)
- hackyhacky 3y agoSounds more like lead poisoning.
- nier 3y agoPoor chap was meant to die of mushroom poisoning. His refusal to actually consume and the bullet hole are insignificant details in Eastern Europe.
- sschueller 3y agoThis article[1] from 20 years a ago paints a different picture. > Russians Dying--Literally--for Favorite Fungi > Like most Russians, Sergei Kayava and his family considered themselves mushroom experts--but the assumption proved fatal. > On July 8, he and his family eagerly dished up helpings of buttery fried forest mushrooms prepared by his mother-in-law. > “She is very good at cooking mushrooms. She boiled them and then fried them and then served them with boiled potatoes. It was delicious,” Kayava recalled Saturday. > But the dish killed Kayava’s wife, Marina, 40, and her father. Collecting mushrooms earlier that day, Kayava’s in-laws mistook the deadly blednaya poganka, or pale toadstool, for the innocuous and tasty syroyezhki mushroom. ... > The mushroom season has just begun and lasts until late September, but already at least 95 people have died in Russia and Ukraine, a casualty figure much higher than normal for this time of year. So although this seem unlikely that the top Russian rocket scientist died from mushroom poisoning it isn't out of the question or that ridiculous. [1] https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2000-jul-16-mn-53777-story.html https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2000-jul-16-mn-53777...
- Simon_O_Rourke 3y agoAt least he didn't fall out of a 10th floor window at the mushroom picking place, or accidentally cut off his head with pruning shears. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suspicious_deaths_of_Russian_businesspeople_(2022%E2%80%932023) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suspicious_deaths_of_Russian...
- wand3r 3y agoTop 2 comments from people who live in the region. This is extremely unlikely This is not really suspisvious
- caiquelira 3y agoWe need an independent fact checker
- iavael 3y agoIt's unlikely enough for such cases to get in the news. But these type of news are quite regular, so mushroom poisonings are not rare that much to be suspicious. In this case what's outstanding is the person, not circumstances.
- mordechai9000 3y agoI hope he wasn't eating gyromitra esculenta, the false morel. It contains a volatile toxic substance that metabolizes into monomethylhydrazine, a rocket propellent. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK470580 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK470580
- dylan604 3y agoWith the obvious reduction in budgets of the Russian space program, maybe he was doing it on purpose
- selimthegrim 3y agoDoes it grow two stories high like in the Smurfs so he could have fallen off the top too?
- hashtag-til 3y agoAll mushroom are edible. Some, only once.
- ChildOfChaos 3y agoI love the internet. The first two comments for me: 1) "As an active mushroom hunter, this is extremely unlikely and uncommon, this sounds like foul play. 2) I regularly go foraging in this region, this is extremely common and nothing suspicious.
- stevezsa8 3y agoYeah, after a few years of Reddit, I started calling this kind of thing "internet advice"... ok for a discussion, but often contradictory or wrong (if I happen to know the topic in depth). For example, people give advice to grown men and women about how to proceed with their divorce or financial planning. Lots of up votes to lend credibility.... but if you dig into their history, the advice giver is 14 years old according to their other posts on other subreddits. No disrespect to the people here. Just saying...
- ChildOfChaos 3y agoYeah absolutely! It's crazy and I think one of the reasons why I really need to cut down my internet and reddit usage down somewhat. For a topic like this, that I know nothing about, I am mildly curious and don't want to research it in-depth to get an answer as this would be a wildly bad use of my time, so i rely on others that seem more knowledgeable, but the problem is, who do you believe and what can you trust when you do this? To really know, you have to verify, but to do so on a mild interest topic, is not worth it, therefore how much of this general consumption is ultimately of any use or has much of a point. Worse, I wonder in which topics my view is now warped, as I read some comment somewhere that I accepted as truth at the time and I now believe it although cannot remember the source. One of the troubles with Reddit, is that upvotes give a post apparent credibility but are voted on by everyone and most of the people there aren't experts or know what they are talking about, so the reality is whatever sounds the best, sounds 'nicer' or more politically correct gets the upvote. The truth, which might not fit that mould, will get much more mixed results.
- patapong 3y agoSame here... I also realize that over time I learn to predict what the top comment will be on certain topics. For example, in the AITA subreddit, I will always form my own opinion that is then "tested" by reading the most popular responses in the thread. The problem is, just because redditors think that a response is correct does not mean that it is. But at some point, especially on topics you know less about, you may start to confuse this prediction with your own opinion. Scary stuff!
- MerelyMortal 3y agoPerhaps not every death is intentional, but with many intentional deaths, unintentional ones will sometimes be grouped in, and the intentional deaths must affect moral which will affect the number of quality people willing to step up into roles, allowing for lower quality people stepping up causing lower quality outcomes until everything is a shell of its former self. Killing people for bad results seems to be a losing proposition.
- pizza 3y agoSome mushrooms contain trace amounts of agaritine, a hydrazine-like toxin. Twisted sense of humor?
- qaq 3y agoI wonder if Putin ever watched The Dictator
- voxpopuli123 3y ago[flagged]
- p1mrx 3y ago> Professor Vitaly Melnikov, 77, had headed the Department of Rocket and Space Systems at RSC Energia Was that department responsible for the Luna-25 lander/impactor? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energia_(corporation)#Deep_Space_exploration_spacecraft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energia_(corporation)#Deep_Spa... doesn't say explicitly.
- SergeAx 3y agoHighly unlikely. Luna 25 was build by Lavochkin Bureau.
- vogre 3y agoAs an active mushroom hunter (living in Russia), can confirm that it is likely. Mushroom gathering is extremely popular here, so experienced mushroom hunters are looking for second and third tier mushrooms, which are not that edible and have nasty mimics. So there is a moment when you confuse a champignon to a death cap, or Kuehneromyces mutabilis(summer stump mushroom) to Galerína margináta(deadly as the death mushroom), or parasol mushroom to fly agaric. Especially if you have bad eyes. Source: mushrooms in my stomach that I gathered and ate today.
- FridayNightTV 3y ago[flagged]
- vogre 3y agoI am just Russian who live in Russia and have some local context here. You are free to call me a troll, but I think you are just devaluing opinions that you don't like. At least I can speak about local mushroom eating traditions and dangers from first hands - I do it from childhood.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chemodax 3y agoThis is definitely propaganda comment: eating mushrooms in Russia is never considered as risky.
- sorokod 3y agoThe commettee is still out on emperor Claudius so this make take a while to sort out.
- LordGronk 3y agoJust looking at the list below, there’s no way that anyone could get me to enter a building with two or more stories if I were an important Russian.
- Kretinsky 3y agoRead the article, he has been sick for two weeks before dying. This looks a lot like regular shroom poisoning, he wasn't too young either, and I guess that, at >70 years old in Russia, you start to be more vulnerable. I guess that political murder could be an easy explanation, in which case it's really, really subtle, which - huh - isn't really what the FSB is known for ?
- smsm42 3y agoPoisoning people is exactly what FSB is known for.
- BeFlatXIII 3y agoWas it a polonium mushroom?
- dang 3y agoUrl changed from https://ptv-news.com.pk/top-russian-rocket-scientist-dies-from-mushroom-poisoning/ https://ptv-news.com.pk/top-russian-rocket-scientist-dies-fr..., which seems to be shameless blogspam so we've banned the site. Thanks to the user who figured this out!
- BrandoElFollito 3y agoThe comments threads for this post are insane. People, stop posting stuff that make me laugh because I am sitting at the ER with my son and people are looking at me funny. I could obviously skip the comments and read about the next JS framework but where wild be the pleasure in life then.
- fennecfoxy 3y agoAnyone that believes that this isn't suspicious hasn't really been paying much attention.