12 ms·
Modern genetic data suggests pre-humans were a group of only 1,280 individuals
- mannyv 3y agoA long time ago there was a Sci-Fi story about the first humans crash-landing in Africa and fighting for survival among the hominids. I think the number of people on that ship was about 2k.
- 7thaccount 3y agoIs that one of the subsequent Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy books (satirical scifi)? Like we're all descendants of lawyers and other undesirables (iirc a civilization put all the lawyers on a ship to go to the sun, but it went off course and landed on earth?)
- pndy 3y agoBattlestar Galactica?
- nawgz 3y agoIt's a big claim. To estimate "1280 individuals" is... very precise.
- spiderice 3y agoYeah.. how can they possibly be so precise in that number? Anyone know?
- sho_hn 3y agoThey aren't, it's an estimate (with error bars).
- psychphysic 3y agoThe estimate is the estimate (1280 with SEM of 131). It's be foolish of them to mask it intentionally. Once independent estimates are made then you might synthesize an reasonable estimate. Both the editor summary I'm science and the headline here don't place much emphasis on the precise number.
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoThe actual linked article isn't the paper, and doesn't even name the paper as far I can tell, it's just given as "Hu, W. et al. Science 381, 979–984 (2023)." in a footnote. This is the actual paper, which (presumably, I cannot access) is specifically about how they made the estimate: Genomic inference of a severe human bottleneck during the Early to Middle Pleistocene transition: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abq7487 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abq7487
- br1 3y agoIt is a somewhat 'round' number, the width of 720p resolution.
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoThis is the number supported by DNA evidence. There will be a margin of error. The bigger issue, for me, is that I'm not sure how they can rule out the possibility that there were lots of other people around at that time whose lineages gradually died out. Modern genetic lineages may trace back to 1280 people (+/- the margin of error), but it seems pretty dubious to assume that those were the only people living at that time. It seems highly likely to me that there were infertile people, people who died young, people whose only living children were infertile or died young, etc. (I did not read the original paper, so maybe they accounted for this, or maybe they that specify that this was a genetic bottle neck for modern humans, but not necessarily the actual size of the population.)
- sidfthec 3y ago> I did not read the original paper, so maybe they accounted for this Then why say it's an issue?
- fooker 3y agoThey haven't.
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoI'm not saying it's an issue with the research. It's very likely the researchers thought of this. It IS an issue with the article linked here, since it does not explain the research and causes readers to walk away believing there were only 1280 people.
- svnt 3y agoThere is a minimum in the fossil record at that time. There may be other explanations for it, but one very reasonable one is that there just weren't very many skeletons to potentially fossilize.
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoCertainly. However, I am still highly doubtful that there were only 1280 people alive at that time. I'm not sure that this is what the article is claiming; however, it is written in a way that makes it very easy to come away with that message (as evidenced in this comment section). What are the chances that every person alive today, for example, will still have living descendants in 400,000 years? If people 400,000 years in the future do a genetic study on themselves to determine how many of their ancestors were alive in the year 2023, what percentage of the 2023 population will they be able to account for? My guess is a fair bit lower than 100%.
- vic-traill 3y agoIt's obviously the result of Roll Call: SMITH Here! JOHNSON Here! WILLIAMS Here! BROWN Here! JONES Here! GARCIA Here! MILLER Here! DAVIS Here! RODRIGUEZ Here! MARTINEZ Here! HERNANDEZ Here! LOPEZ Here! GONZALEZ Here! WILSON Here! ANDERSON Here! THOMAS Here! TAYLOR Here! MOORE Here! JACKSON Here! MARTIN Here! LEE Here! PEREZ Here! THOMPSON Here! WHITE Here! HARRIS Here! SANCHEZ Here! CLARK Here! RAMIREZ Here! LEWIS Here! ROBINSON Here! WALKER Here! YOUNG Here! ALLEN Here! KING Here! WRIGHT Here! SCOTT Here! TORRES Here! NGUYEN Here! HILL Here! FLORES Here! GREEN Here! ADAMS Here! NELSON Here! BAKER Here! HALL Here! [ ... ] ROSADO [ ... Crickets ... ]
- latchkey 3y agoI upvoted you on the amount of work you put into that comment. Even threw in a nguyen there too.
- vic-traill 3y agoI was shooting for 1280 surnames, but the comment length limit fixed that. Which I am grateful for in general :-) Anyway, I surmised I would give away just about all my karma on the comment, but, hell, I just couldn't resist!
- latchkey 3y agoIt is always worth risking a few karma points for a well crafted comment.
- hulitu 3y agoThey have very good meters those days. /s The fact that there is no comma (as in 1280,3333) is puzzling.
- xnx 3y agoI'm not qualified to say anything about the science, but every since reading about the theory described in "When the Sea Saved Humanity" (https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/when-the-sea-saved-humanity-2012-12-07/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/when-the-sea-save...), something about the idea of a small band of humans holed holding on to survival near the southern tip of Africa has captivated me.
- frozenport 3y agoI'd argue they didn't have too much humanity, or at least what differentiates us from Chimpanzees.
- chrisco255 3y agoMost certainly they did by then. About 1.8 million years ago is when the hand axe (handheld stone axes used as weapons and for cutting) was first developed, and fire control was developed by 1.5 million years ago by earlier hominids.
- c420 3y agoMastery of fire has entered the chat.
- psychphysic 3y agoThe article suggests control of fire is what lead to recovery of the population. So indeed quite a different time.
- ahauxuueei 3y agoBy that time we had mastered fire by probably a million years already.
- dontwearitout 3y agoThanks for sharing, that was a great read. I've always really been fascinated by the aquatic ape hypothesis (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aquatic_ape_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aquatic_ape_hypothesis), even if it's not widely accepted as fact.
- kibibu 3y ago[flagged]
- cubefox 3y agoMany were increasingly of the opinion that they'd all made a big mistake coming down from the trees in the first place, and some said that even the trees had been a bad move, and that no-one should ever have left the oceans.
- bradneuberg 3y agoOk Doomer!
- patall 3y agoYou are joking, but still: this was likely not the only group of humans in existance, just the one that became us.
- delta_p_delta_x 3y agoIn the beginning the Universe was created. This has made a lot of people very angry and been widely regarded as a bad move.
- lainga 3y agoThe romantic optimist in me will keep some hope out that that sort of thing was the Great Filter which felled so many of our unseen galactic neighbours.
- api 3y agoThe Great Filter is really just an arbitrary speculation since we don't know most of the parameters in the Drake equation with any certainty. It's also a fallacy to assume that a great filter, if it exists, must be a single discrete climactic test or have a single explanation. It could be that there exists on average a continuous low probability of an event or evolutionary path that rules out advanced intelligence in a given biosphere. Let's say that the yearly probability of such a terminal event or path is about 0.00000002%. Over 500 million years this would amount to a 99% chance of failing the great filter. If this is true it would mean that we're almost there, very likely to succeed, but also very likely pretty alone at least in our galaxy since there won't be that many advanced intelligences around. The difference though is that unlike the discrete great filter hypothesis there is no single apocalyptic event to fear. It's a small probability spread over aeons. This is just to show that we don't know the answer to the Fermi paradox at all. There's no testable or scientific answer at least. Only way to really know is to go out there and look around.
- borissk 3y agoThere may be 99% chance of failing the great filter in the 500M years before an industrial evolution and 99.99999999% chance of failing it in the 10K years past. Humankind invented nuclear weapons and had a lot of luck that they are hard to make and so far only 2 were used in anger. There's a good chance that with the progress of AI, nanotech, CRISPR very powerful weapons will become available to groups like ISIS - greatly decreasing humankind's chances of survival.
- api 3y agoWe just don’t know. At this point for all we know the birth of life is just unbelievably improbable and rare and that’s it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Aardwolf 3y agoIt's pretty crazy to think about this: if a generation would be 25 years on average, only 5 million individuals lived during those 100k years. But today, 100k years in the future sounds like a 100x longer time than what would already be unimaginable science fiction...
- kzrdude 3y agoThat perspective - is why we can say that we live in a very busy world right now. So much human life going on at the same time in this moment. A lot more than compared with 100k, 10k, 1k and 100 years ago.
- calimoro78 3y agoFair to say most of humankind’s time then has been spent staring at small digital screens.
- leafmeal 3y agoCrazy to think about! Minor correction: 5 million reproduced, presumably more lived but died young, etc. but you point still stands
- titzer 3y agoNo, it doesn't mean that. The bottleneck doesn't say anything about how many people were alive then, just how many contributed DNA surviving until present day. There could have been millions of individuals whose offspring eventually ended up as genetic dead ends and we'd never know, except for fossils.
- swader999 3y ago[flagged]
- svnt 3y agoThe idea of (at least one) population bottleneck in the evolutionary history of humans is fairly widely accepted. I haven't reviewed the paper or methods but generally their results fit the range of expectations of many in the field. This new paper is interesting in that they developed a new method in population genomics specifically to attempt to pin down all of: the time, the duration, and the size of the population. There are many earlier papers describing different methods for arriving at similar conclusions. The below paper used similar genetic signatures from bottleneck events such as the loss of rare alleles. Their methods were different. It explains one such process fairly well and is available to read: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2842629/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2842629/
- jokoon 3y agoWhich is why humans are very sensitive to interbreeding
- roncesvalles 3y agoBy sensitive to interbreeding do you mean that's the reason why humans can't have offspring with other apes? Curious to know how this is implied by a genomic bottleneck.
- trane_project 3y agoI think they meant incest. If we already did our share of it in the distant past, then fun with your cousin leads to a baby with a pig's tail. Or at least it did for the Buendía family: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_Hundred_Years_of_Solitude https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_Hundred_Years_of_Solitude
- daliusd 3y agoThat’s not the case everywhere IMHO. E.g. marrying cousins is kind of norm in some countries
- 3y ago
- titzer 3y agoHeadline is misleading. The existence of a population bottleneck of approximately 1200 individuals does not imply that humans almost went extinct. It doesn't say anything about the size of the population before or after that bottleneck. In fact, it doesn't even say anything about the size of the population at that time. It just means that those 1200 individuals are the only ones that have contributed genes to the gene pool that survives today. There could have been other human populations that did not pass on their genetic material to modern humans, but were the same species as those who did. In fact, there could have been a lot of them. There were many different hominid species alive at that time, and humans were in competition with them. We have no idea of their relative number. It could have been millions for all we know. Absent any other evidence, a population bottleneck (derived through studies of live human DNA) suggests nothing about the population at the time, or over time. Survivor bias.
- daveguy 3y agoYes. The number of breeding pairs present at one time could have coincided with a large population of human-like creatures that went extinct. The key point in your phrasing is: "There were many different hominid species alive at that time, and humans were in competition with them." If humpback whales eventually become extinct and blue whales eventually dominate global ecosystems we aren't going to say that means blue whales didn't experience a near extinction because "hey! plenty of whale-critters". A minimal number of breeding pairs is the definition of near-extinction. To imply otherwise is misleading. Homo-sapiens is not the same as Homo-neanderthalensis.
- borissk 3y agoThis bottleneck occurred before the split between "us" and neanderthals - so if this small population didn't survive there wouldn't be not only modern humans, but neanderthals as well.
- daveguy 3y agoAhh, yes. Good point. Neanderthals wasn't a good example. The ones that didn't survive from that point would have been called something else.
- gumby 3y agoAnd, according to the article, it's not just lucky that we survived that, but that very bottleneck could have itself produced H. Hiedelbergensis, and thus H. Sapiens Sapiens. Which also implies that while one remote group could have shrunk to a colony of about 1,300 hominids and leading to us, elsewhere other species of humans could have survived just fine for longer, later dying out due to other exogenous pressure, perhaps from our closer ancestors. I have read that the world's cheetah are so genetically similar that they appear to have suffered two population bottlenecks, the recent one being only 10-12Ky ago in which the population might have shrunk as low as 30-40 cheetahs.
- titzer 3y ago> might have shrunk as low as 30-40 cheetahs Or, at one point a mutation, or a group of mutations, gave rise to a small number of super-cheetahs that interbred, and those cheetahs completely out-competed all other cheetahs.
- gumby 3y agoOr, more likely, at one point a mutation, or a group of mutations, gave rise to a small number of super-cheetahs that interbred, and those cheetahs completely out-competed all other cheetahs until the remaining standard cheetahs, that had been enslaved rebelled under the cheetah Spartacus, overwhelming and eradicating the super-cheetahs using the super-cheetah's own aircraft and other weapons, though even in victory leaving only a small number of normal ones to continue the species. Ockham's razor says my scenario is more likely.
- titzer 3y agolol, have an upvote.
- dboreham 3y agoI am Cheetahcus!
- sidewndr46 3y agoThe Third Feline Servile war was a very dangerous time indeed
- dtx1 3y agoRemember that Black Monolith in 2001: A Space Odyssey? 1280 Individuals is in the realm of what some alien mission could do in terms of genetically a bunch of apes to become smarter
- wslh 3y agoOfftopic: I switched to the scifi/fantasy genre and wonder why the number is not 1024 or 2310 (2 x 3 x 5 x 7 x 11) or other number based on series such as Fibonacci. The closest from Wolfram Alpha is: 1280 has a representation as a sum of 2 squares: 1280 = 16^2 + 32^2
- dang 3y agoRelated: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2023/aug/31/population-collapse-almost-wiped-out-human-ancestors-say-scientists https://www.theguardian.com/science/2023/aug/31/population-c... (via https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37343844 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37343844, but we merged that thread hither)
- Sparkyte 3y agoHuman evolution science keeps expanding for the longest time it was thought Africa was the origin. It is seeming more like a global phenomenon as time passes. I have said this a lot. Don't look at Earth from today's lens, look at it from the 900k years ago lens. What animals were around, what sort of animals we hunted and sought after. How communities were formed and how we were able to safely breed. The answer is less complicated, we had a lot of closely genetic relatives all over the planet which we reproduced with creating a various diverse human race. And we is as in past caveman like ancestors. I am not refuting the earliest ancestors found in Africa, I am just pointing out it is easier to find ancestral sites from an undeveloped part of the world. Source: https://phys.org/news/2023-08-ancient-ape-trkiye-story-human.html https://phys.org/news/2023-08-ancient-ape-trkiye-story-human... Even China has dug fossils of ancient humans, but we have yet to really put that to study. However again Africa is the perfect place to find the ancient human origins because it has had less human development in terms of civilization than the rest of the world.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- semiquaver 3y agoMostly telephone sanitizers, I suspect.
- wly_cdgr 3y agoFor such a small population to survive for ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND YEARS is mind-boggling
- euroderf 3y agoThe article says: "Of greater surprise is the estimated length of time that this small group survived. If this is correct, then one imagines that it would require a stable environment with sufficient resources and few stresses to the system." Maybe they were kept in a nature preserve run by friendly aliens, until the climate got sorted out ?
- airocker 3y agoSounds like the number of employees at OpenAI in 3 years.
- aa1234556 3y ago[dead]
- fiforpg 3y agoA rather bizarre number, 2^8*5. Only two prime factors, but also not a pure power of 2.
- bombela 3y ago2^10+2^8==1280
- krick 3y agoHow do you actually get a number like that? What are the computations, simplified? Is it a coincidence that 1280 = 2⁷ * 10? (I mean, it makes me wonder if it isn't basically a result of using some sort of a decision tree splitting some set by 2 or something, and 10 is perhaps just some hard-coded into the model assumption — which it most probably isn't, of course, I'm just wondering: what is that number?)
- Shrezzing 3y ago>Is it a coincidence that 1280 = 2⁷ * 10? 1280 is the nearest threshold we can estimate to, for the reason you've describe. In the OP's title it suggests "exactly 1280", while the original published piece in Science[1] uses the phrase "around 1280". [1]https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abq7487 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abq7487
- kgeist 3y agoDoes it suggest all languages stem from a single proto-language after all? Or complex language emerged later than 900,000 years ago.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoInspiration for a Science Fiction story of aliens preparing a seed population from some unimpressive apes on a backwater planet.
- Shorel 3y agoUnrelated but fun: There's a Colombian rock group called "1280 almas". 1280 souls.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- T-A 3y agoThe paper places the bottleneck "between around 930,000 and 813,000 years ago" and has it lasting "for about 117,000 years" [1]. This overlaps with the bottleneck found back in 2017 (also by genetic analysis) in early Neanderthal and Denisovan populations [2][3]: Approximately 750,000 years ago, according to Rogers, the forerunners of Neanderthals and Denisovans left the ancestors of modern humans behind in Africa to make their way across Eurasia’s expansive territory. Once on their own, something nearly wiped them out entirely; the genetic data shows the population passed through a severe bottleneck, never observed in previous studies. [1] https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abq7487 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abq7487 [2] https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.1706426114 https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.1706426114 [3] https://www.quantamagazine.org/genetics-spills-secrets-from-neanderthals-lost-history-20170918/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/genetics-spills-secrets-from-... Edit: typos, the bane of my existence.
- red_trumpet 3y agoShould be "back in 2017" ;)
- T-A 3y agoThanks, beat me to it.
- nonameking2026 3y agoMaybe there was a great flood
- dredmorbius 3y agoNY Times coverage: <https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/31/science/human-survival-bottleneck.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/31/science/human-survival-bo...> (From a subsequent HN submission.)
- riialist 3y agoAccording to current consensus, the Finnish population has gone through several bottlenecks. There might have been just two surviving paternal lineages from the bottle neck 4000 years ago. And after that, there were plenty of times when only a 1/3 or less survived the famines related to wars and plunders. So, interestingly, Finnish DNA is an isolate but highly diverse within itself. See e.g https://www.nature.com/articles/ejhg2016205 https://www.nature.com/articles/ejhg2016205
- berniedurfee 3y agoI wonder if it was 1280 in one community or split across several disparate and possibly warring groups. I suppose competition from other hominid species might have pushed one community to band together for survival. I just can’t imagine one community of any size surviving for very long without carving up territory and battling for scarce resources or hoarding to create artificial resource scarcity. We’re such a fractured and combative species. If we were down to 1280 today I think we’d still figure out how to fight each other.