9 ms·
If you make less than $55K, the Labor Department wants you to get overtime pay
- mullingitover 3y agoPegging to a specific dollar value means this erodes every year (much like minimum wage). This should be pegged to a multiple of minimum wage, or some multiple of median national salary.
- idiotsecant 3y agounfortunately both minimum wage and the median national salary also represent a shrinking slice of the pie, just at different rates. What we should have is a % of per capita GDP but that's kind of a radical idea that could never go anywhere.
- Beached 3y agowhy not a multiple of the poverty line. there is already a mechanism in place to have this updated annually and accounta for inflation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bobongo 3y agoIndex it to CPI and that'll be that.
- archo 3y agohttps://archive.is/3Qv59 https://archive.is/3Qv59
- guerrilla 3y agoI'm not going to look into this further today but this sounds a lot like treating the symptoms rather thsn the disease.
- paulddraper 3y ago> Please don't post shallow dismissals
- HumblyTossed 3y agoThis is basically updating an existing rule to bring it more in line with today's market.
- ortusdux 3y agoI would love for things like this to be pegged to some sort of metric, but once you do that the focus shifts to gaming that metric.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIt should have been brought up to $200k per year. Exempt employees are pretty much always used to get around sufficiently staffing, either with sufficient redundant number of employees or sufficiently paying for dependable employees. I assume anyone with a customer facing “manager” title is just the on call employee who trades their ability to earn overtime for less volatility in their pay (salary). This is especially prevalent in immigrant communities with chain migration where the more recent families that migrate are expected operate a convenience store/gas station/motel/laundromat/franchise restaurant/etc day and night 7 days per week in exchange for the minimum allowed exempt salary.
- teaearlgraycold 3y agoTell me you make 200k without telling me you make 200k Edit: I think HN misunderstood my comment. It was a joke, not an accusation.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago$200k was chosen so that the exempt employee might actually end up being a real manager with an ability to manage and have control of a budget and increase payrates if necessary. Could be higher for all I care. It should also apply to more than 8 hours per day like it does in California.
- skyyler 3y agoDo retail or foodservice managers make 200k?
- no_wizard 3y agoShame they don't raise that even higher. It seems like ~60K in the governments mind is still high, even though as a population, even people making >100K are reporting that they feel like they can't get ahead, let alone people who make less than that. I think its great that they're updating this, but they should of increased it by 2/3s at least
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> even people making >100K are reporting that they feel like they can't get ahead I know people making $5+ million who say the same. This is the human condition. Anecdotes of not getting ahead and personal strife are terrible inputs for economic policy. American GDP per capita is about $75k [1]. Median household income around $70k [2]. If you want natural figure to revolve around, those are good ones. [1] https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?locations=US https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?location... [2] https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2022/demo/p60-276.html https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2022/demo/p60-27...
- no_wizard 3y agoI agree with this and I should have clarified - The cost of living is rising fast enough that the majority of people making between 100K and 250K are feeling like they can't get ahead, with record low numbers of home ownership (not just single family homes either, but condos etc) among this group of traditionally "automatic" home buyers, as well as record lows of asset accumulation. The dollar just isn't going as far as it used to, and there is no signs of that letting up any time soon, even with rising interest rates, you see no knock off effects on things like grocery prices or home prices, even though corporations are making record profits currently.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> record low numbers of home ownership…among this group of traditionally "automatic" home buyers Source? I see evidence of this in supply-restricted cities. But not in the country broadly. > dollar just isn't going as far as it used to Real wages are near historical highs and at par with the pre-Covid economy.
- usaar333 3y agoAre there any good studies on OT law trade-offs? Since at steady state the result is capping employee hours at 40, this type of law seems good for workers that want to maintain such a cap and bad for those that want to earn more.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThere is nothing stopping people from obtaining other sources of income if their one employer is unwilling to pay them 1.5x their regular payrate.
- usaar333 3y agoYes there is. In practice, many jobs have considerable fixed overheads to both employer and employee to you can't be hired for say under 10 hours a week. For instance, when I had a nanny, absent OT laws, optimal hours for both parties were 45/week. OT laws shifted my preference to 40. There is no 5 hour a week job my nanny could get given fixed overhead.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThat is a good example, and 40 is an arbitrary line to draw. However, absent universal basic income, I do not see an easier way for the government to establish a minimum quality of life at work, at least in terms of hours worked.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoSmoking hot take but: lower the line to 30. 80 hours a week is an absurd amount of your week taken up working and it is nearly impossible to fit in a M-F schedule of 16 hours between 2 employers. two 30 hour jobs come down to 12 hour work days. Which sucks immensely but is manageable. Especially between a day and night shift. Then again, asking for 30 hours is also like asking for a 33% pay raise. But there are very slow movements towards 4 day/32 hour work weeks, so maybe this will be a thing in due time.
- 3y ago
- bparsons 3y agoWhy is there an income ceiling on overtime in the US?
- rtkwe 3y agoYou've got it backwards. It's not a ceiling on nonexempt jobs it's a floor for overtime exempt jobs. You're required to pay X in salary in order to categorize someone as a salaried employee as well as the other requirement on the type of work being performed.
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoIt's more a floor on being exempt from overtime. Basically, the thought process is that salaried employees have a different relationship with the employer than others, in that they're more paid to get a job done, rather than for the amount of time worked. These employees also tend to have enough leverage against their employer to come to a fair employment contract. On the other hand, jobs on the lower end of the spectrum have much less leverage, and are being paid for their time. We, as a society, have a vested interest in companies not working their employees to death, so we discourage companies from overworking their employees, by making them pay extra to employ them more than a full-time job. The question then becomes: How do we differentiate these two classes of job? If you don't set a firm boundary, employers will pretend even the poor stiff working the nightshift at the gas station Quikmart is in the former category. The main rule for overtime exemption is "are you a professional or in management, or not?", with the 55k floor existing to make sure companies don't get too creative with job title labeling. The real ceiling on federally-mandated overtime is $107,432, at which point you're making enough that the government trusts you to negotiate advantageous employment terms yourself.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Why is there an income ceiling on overtime in the US? There isn’t. There is a pay (and other conditions) floor on employers being exempt from the general federal requirement to pay overtime at a specified rate. (State law may impose similar requirements even where federal exemptions apply, and even where both federal and state exemptions apply, employers may offer terms that involve overtime pay.)
- makomk 3y ago"President Barack Obama attempted to raise the cut-off in 2016, aiming for $47,476, but that was ultimately blocked by a federal judge over states' concerns that the new threshold would increase their costs." That's not why Obama's attempt to raise the cut-off was blocked. The federal law governing this exempts anyone employed in a "bona fide executive, administrative or professsional capacity" and only gives the administrative branch the power to set rules like minimum pay if they're aimed at ensuring exempt employees do actually fall into those categories. The main stated benefit of raising the cut-off, according to the official documents from the Obama administration explaining it, was that it would force employers to pay overtime to people who genuinely were conducting this kind of exempt work. Actually forcing employers to pay overtime to people who weren't carrying out exempt work was described as a more minor secondary benefit. That was a plain and straightforward violation of the letter of the law. Most of the US press just avoided talking about this part of the court rulings at all, presumably for partisan reasons.
- arpyzo 3y agoWhy should there be a ceiling on this at all? Just because someone makes more money does not mean it should be acceptable to abuse their time in the workplace. Most people earn high incomes, not because they signed up to meet arbitrary demands, but because they invested in education and training, and/or agreed to take on a high level of responsibility.
- H8crilA 3y agoThis concept of "eligibility for overtime" is so far beyond reason that it looks shocking even for the ultra low American standards. Having a law that literally forbids worker compensation would be a reason to remove government almost anywhere in the world. It's like something from a Monty Python sketch, produced in the building next to the Silly Walks department. The only people "not eligible for overtime" are those that cannot work overtime due to medical (or other similar) reasons.
- gizmo686 3y agoThere is no law that prevents employers from offering overtime pay to people with a salary over the limit.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Having a law that literally forbids worker compensation The law doesn’t forbid overtime for people making over the listed amount, it means that employers aren’t federally mandated to pay overtime (and certain other things) for employees making above a certain base-pay threshold. Not only is it allowed to pay overtime to people making over the federal threshold, there are states where it is mandatory – just as with minimum wage, there are states that have exemption pay thresholds (and other exemption requirements) that make many federally-exempt jobs not exempt under state law, such that overtime pay is still required.
- aidenn0 3y agoThe ceiling makes sense because a high salary is a reasonable proxy for individual bargaining power. I'm sure I could convince my manager to let me work strictly 9-5 in exchange for halving my salary (which would still put me over the 55k mark).
- thelastknowngod 3y agoI wonder how that would be calculated. My salary is comfortably into the six figures but my taxable income is below the $55k threshold.
- egberts1 3y agoEven under best Social Security, this falls below $55K/yr. Nominal retirement from Uncle Sam is more like $19,200/year. So, is Dept of Labor going to crush us seniors economy-wise by pulling the rear?
- soligern 3y agoOvertime pay should be normal for everyone that works more than the 8 hours. Being on call is a travesty. Just have shifts like every other industry does.