7 ms·
IBM promised to back off facial recognition, then signed a $70M contract for it
- nijave 3y agoProbably by backing off they meant they just re-orged and fired a few people in that department
- nicechianti 3y ago[dead]
- supermatt 3y ago“IBM firmly opposes and will not condone uses of any technology, including facial recognition technology offered by other vendors…” They didn’t feel the need to “include” themselves in their definition of “any”
- willcipriano 3y agoIBM's solutions are so ancient they are no longer considered technology.
- wredue 3y agoIBM severed most of their ancient technology off in to Kyndryl. They’re pretty much all cloud at this point.
- Kwpolska 3y agoDid they sell off mainframes too?
- tw04 3y agoThey will never sell off mainframe. That's the one thing they can reliably tweak to hit their numbers and/or push other software that people don't want as a "bundle".
- berniedurfee 3y agoWhat cloud?
- MaxikCZ 3y agoI dont know. My close relative works as infrastructure engineer at major automotive company, and about every 2 years they are buying new computation clusters (think tens to low hundreds thousands of cores, along with network and storage infra). Every time a public tender is held, and every time there are several companies promising to achieve required results with whatever hardware. Last decade I know of three different firms being selected, where they guaranteed to succeed on speed requirements (some even saying its tested inhouse), only to admit failure after year of trying, taking all their hardware back with no pay. IBM at higher price was selected as backup, and every time was the only firm actually able to deliver on their promises and meet the benchmark requirements. I often see IBM getting a lot of flak here for whatever reasons, just sharing some counterweight.
- tw04 3y agoIt seems EXTREMELY unlikely that Cray would be unable to meet performance requirements and promises. They've consistently done so for decades in all manner of government and private institutions.
- MaxikCZ 3y agoCray was never selected. Either they didn't submit an offer, or their price was too high.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoI've sat in on plenty of B2B sales pitches, and am fairly certain that no salesman ever believes that you will actually run those tests. And if even if you did, that you would actually throw away a full year of integration work to go with the backup plan. Plus, having seen/heard a lot about how salesman are employed - all too often their commission/compensation is locked in when the contract is signed. They get their money regardless of what happens a year or two down the road, and are thus incentivized to "misrepresent" performance and capabilities.
- 3y ago
- unnah 3y agoMaybe they caught on with all the youngsters who call software and AI stuff "tech" instead of technology, and make a clear distinction between the two.
- _zoltan_ 3y agoQuantum computers, cutting edge crypto, cutting edge physical reseach just to name a few? I think we are pretty much at the forefront of a lot of things. disclaimer: I work at IBM Research but this is my own opinion.
- Melting_Harps 3y ago> cutting edge crypto BWAHAHAHA! Nothing about that program had any redeeming quality, the fact that everything was based on solidity was enough to confirm this: I knew IBM would be split into 2 companies when the upper brass refused to wise up to the obvious scams like ETH and eventually with Stellar. So much is put behind short term gains selling Z mainframes and empty promises of Watson for everything that nothing gets left over for anything actually innovative. Tell me, for all the anti BTC propaganda in the training and talking points, it must really have humbled a few people and hopefully got enough people fired to see that the SEC and even Blackrock ended up on our side and not yours. Instead all IBM has is a place amongst all the other s** coins no one uses with nearly no utility/volume or value to speak of [0]: whereas BTC keeps breaking hashrate ATH. You guys really dropped the ball on this one, and to be honest the fact that it's a bunch of dinosaurs running that place made it apparent it was never going to live up to it's promise: I just wished the rank and file had taken more effort to make this happen, some of us did try, as so many corps IBM services were willing to pilot-test this tech. I hate being this crass, I really do, but seriously you guys really screwed this one up. 0: https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/stellar/ https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/stellar/
- wnc3141 3y agoWhat is IBM's competitive position? I always assumed they were in the assurance business. I.e. they have well tested systems with close support. Anyone with more insight?
- MichaelZuo 3y agoThey're one of the few, if not only, technology vendor that is willing to sell something with a written 6 nine's reliability guarantee (e.g. 99.9999% uptime and conformance with advertised specifications/features), or your money back. No companies in SV, or Microsoft/Amazon, offer a single product that has that kind of guarantee, that I know of.
- tempodox 3y agoIf a pittance of $70M makes IBM go back on their word, they must really be on their last legs.
- pc86 3y agoI'll do it for 10¢ on the dollar.
- taskforcegemini 3y agoyou probably don't have an IBM to feed
- MrQuincle 3y agoIf this article is concerned about ethics at IBM https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust might be an interesting read for people who haven't yet.
- EGreg 3y agoDon’t trust Corporations in the capitalist system. Happens every day. OpenAI saying they will keep your private data safe from being used for training? I am wondering what the story will be in 5 years hehe
- jmclnx 3y agoFunny, some people in the Arab world are fighting required Hijab use. In the US and Europe, with this happening, I could see many people outside wearing Hijabs that cover your full face in the future.
- n1b0m 3y agoIf you’re referring to Iran then they’re Persian not Arab.
- _lvbh 3y agoThe Arab world refers to the Islamic countries in the Middle East I believe. Not any specific country
- n1b0m 3y agoIran is in the Middle East and and is also where the most recent and high profile protests against the forced wearing of the hijab have taken place. I’m pretty sure most Iranians wouldn’t take too kindly to being called Arab unless they are from the minority Iranian Arabs.
- ptdn 3y agoIran is not considered part of the Arabic world and is a completely different branch of Islam.
- rqtwteye 3y agoWhen will people learn that companies will almost always sell stuff as long as it’s legal and profitable. They have no morals. If we declined into a dictatorship they would sell equipment for total surveillance and oppression. If we don’t make it illegal to pollute they will pollute if they think it makes money.
- quacked 3y agoI believe people should take care to add "men and women at" before talking about companies. Companies and corporations are abstractions. There are real people taking these actions. - "Men and women at IBM promised to back off facial recognition, then signed a $70M contract for it" - "Men and women would sell equipment for total surveillance and oppression" etc. The reason I think this is important is that there's actually a very small number of people relative to the general population that are capable of producing this technology. It's easy to be angry at the suits, or at the broad abstraction "IBM" for enabling this, but the fact of the matter is that there are spineless cowards out there getting up every morning to go and build facial recognition software. They deserve the ire of thinking people. No matter what the era is, there will be sociopaths running large organizations looking to control everyone, but these days there's a huge coterie of nerds getting paid handsomely to help.
- Retric 3y agoI think you’re vastly underestimating how many people can figure it out with a little research and on the job training. The basic government consulting model is to take fresh collage grads and have them muddle through. And while yes it’s a horrific waste of taxpayer money, it also works surprisingly often.
- toyg 3y ago> spineless cowards It's hard to be brave when you have to support a family, pay for a mortgage, pay for the kids' college, etc. I remember feeling queasy, almost 20 years ago, when I got hired for a very good salary to do helpdesk, and realized the customers I had to support included some Bad Actors: big mining, big arm manufacturing, even big spying... but I could finally afford to buy a small house, marry my partner, and start a family. So I sucked it up, and without that experience I wouldn't be where I am now.
- adolph 3y agoIt is foolish to think that an assertion without an incentivizing contract is anything other than marketing. What, is a public corporation going to turn down 70M because of something a leader said when it was popular? They have legal fiduciary obligations against not making money, not against changing directions. Even at the granularity of individual humans, what people want to do is largely orthogonal to what they do. In James Clear's book Atomic Habits one of the more hard-core ways of pre-committing to a course of action is to write a contract with an "accountability partner." Below is a sample: https://s3.amazonaws.com/jamesclear/Atomic+Habits/Habit+Contract.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/jamesclear/Atomic+Habits/Habit+Cont...
- say_it_as_it_is 3y ago"IBM CEO Arvind Krishna announced a hiring pause in May, but that’s not all. Later that month, the CEO also stated the company plans to replace nearly 8,000 jobs with AI. Krishna noted that back-office functions, specifically in the human resources (HR) sector, will be the first to face these changes. In recent weeks, the company has opened up dozens of positions for AI-based roles to help develop and maintain these systems." The mask has fallen.
- darkerside 3y agoWell in their defense, when they said that they didn't know they could make $70M on it
- NikkiA 3y agoWould expect no better from the company that unabashedly profited from the holocaust and south africa's apartheid.
- MagaMuffin 3y ago[dead]
- seydor 3y agoI think it s impossible to hold off the oncoming onslaught of Big State powered by AI , but i think we are doing a very bad job of telling the public to prepare for it, starting with AI powered online manipulation
- kingkawn 3y agoThe thing that AI has already made possible is a total police state. Communication analysis can now feasibly be carried out on all text/spoken dialogue transmitted within a given domain, whereas in the past it was limited by the number of human agents available for this work.
- JohnFen 3y agoI'd like to prepare for it. How?
- seydor 3y agoYou 're probably in tech so you already know. But the public isn't even aware how easy it is to e.g. copy someone's voice with AI. The mainstream news are uninterested
- gumballindie 3y ago> But the public isn't even aware how easy it is to e.g. copy someone's voice with AI. I always demo it where people are open to it, I show them how it can used to steal their banking data (that has been the case already for many years), explain how everything they do is tracked (to those a little bit savy i show them the "hidden" tracking pixels here and there), I demo how people can talk about certain topics or search on site A and then similar content is shown on site B, and so on. Spread the word, demo, explain, educate. The mainstream is interested but they don't know how it works. They imagine cabals of people in secret dark chambers when in fact it was product managers in daily standups planning and delivering all this and an all too open to corruption politicians happy to keep the maases obedient and numb.
- 3y ago
- paxys 3y agoWho the hell is signing a large contract with IBM and expecting them to deliver working tech? > IBM signed a $69.8 million (£54.7 million) contract with the British government Ah, just good old fashioned grift. Nothing to be concerned about. The money is being spent on executive bonuses and government official kickbacks, not developing facial recognition.
- goodbyesf 3y ago> Who the hell is signing a large contract with IBM and expecting them to deliver working tech? Considering they have tens of billions in revenue every year, a lot of people. But what's IBM's niche? I remember they promoted watson a few years back and nothing seems to have come out of that. IBM is such an iconic name in tech but I don't remember them doing anything noteworthy for a long time. At this point IBM is just famous for being famous.
- mistrial9 3y agowatsonx.ai where have you been !
- thrashh 3y agoAfaik a ton of companies use Watson. IBM doesn’t market services… they market solutions. You contract with them and they figure out how they build something for you. And it may include Watson.
- _delirium 3y agoYeah, though it's not really what people think of from the Bob Dylan ads. Watson started as a specific piece of technology (an attempt to turn the Jeopardy-winning system into a general AI engine) and later morphed into just a catch-all brand for everything IBM offers in AI and ML.
- hanniabu 3y agoHow is that a grift? They'll get like 3 meetings with that contract!
- datadrivenangel 3y agoClassic IBM. Principles are cheap unless you pay for them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoActually this is a good thing. Knowing IBM’s consultancy track record, this will serve as a money and time honeytrap for any government interested in this while not actually delivering any useable tech.
- pizzaknife 3y agoas an eternal optimist, i hope this is how it shakes out