8 ms·
State Governments Can’t Resist the Siren Song of Censorship
- mvncleaninst 3y agoFrom a local high school history textbook (commenting on the the first amendment): > Just how liberty should be limited is a matter of debate. For example, most of us support freedom of speech, especially when it applies to speech we agree with. But what about speech that we don’t agree with or that hurts others, such as hate speech? Should people be at liberty to say anything they please, no matter how hurtful it is to others? Or should liberty be limited at times to serve a greater good? If so, who should decide how, why, and under what circumstances liberty should be limited? Interestingly, there's a bunch of little asides like this. And most of them have this glaringly obvious lean to them, where they choose examples to comment on very conveniently. Personally I don't think niche political aspirations to "reinterpret" the first amendment have a place in a textbook for high schoolers
- paulmd 3y agoWell, blindly espousing the benefits and design goals of the current system's design is also a glaringly obvious lean, it's effectively an endorsement of the status quo, especially when you do it to literal children! it's actually quite problematic to go presenting civics as "wow, our system of checks and balances, how wonderful!" and ignore the part where overuse of checks and balances and requiring supermajority control of every single branch and chamber of government to do anything produces grinding deadlock and inability to respond to changing situations and an overall changing world. The benefit (prevent rash action and ensure control of a single branch/chamber/etc does not lead to negative outcomes) are effectively being presented while the downside is not, and people then go on to blindly chant these merits in their adult life and political life too. Things like the president being elected (rather than the leader of the party) also result in these "split government" outcomes that can also leave the government paralyzed, even if they increase the "expressiveness" of the political outcomes. Optimizing for a system where nobody is in the drivers seat has always struck me as a baffling design goal. Would you ever have a ship (or even a hospital operating room) with nobody in command? Perhaps it would be better to optimize for somebody being in the driver seat but then try to optimize the system so their actions are representative of the public's desires/needs, rather than simply optimizing for inaction and assuming inaction is usually best. We can always try again at the next election, but having 30-40% of the public able to drag the whole system to a halt is a bad design even if it springs from well-intentioned goals. Obviously not a third-grade civic lesson but for high-schoolers or AP civics/history courses? yeah, it probably should be discussed. But then, this also bumps into people who don't want citizens to receive training on critical thought in the first place, when that might lead to questioning authority (civic, religious, family, or otherwise). I think this is a situation where if the ideas are so fundamentally and obviously good, then they should be able to withstand a little bit of discussion and debate, no?
- mvncleaninst 3y ago> The benefit (prevent rash action and ensure control of a single branch/chamber/etc does not lead to negative outcomes) are effectively being presented while the downside is not, and people then go on to blindly chant these merits in their adult life and political life too. I feel like you're just ranting against a strawman here. I did public k-12 in a deep red state with teachers who were vocally conservative, and I remember them teaching the trade off (which is: checks and balances slow things down and make government more rigid, but can protect against abuse of power, especially from the executive). The thing is, most likely neither of us actually knows what's being taught in K-12 classrooms and we can only really speculate > but having 30-40% of the public able to drag the whole system to a halt is a bad design even if it springs from well-intentioned goals. It's only bad design if you don't agree with that 30-40%, else it's a lifesaver. Similar reasoning where you advocate for empowering the execute branch. In certain rare cases like FDR you could make the argument that it's beneficial and it wouldn't be far off, but FDR is the exception, not the rule
- gentleman11 3y agoIt’s the left and the right aggressively pushing for censorship these days. Both sides. It used to be a right wing stereotype but I think it’s more a left wing thing now. Maybe it’s just whoever is on the back foot are the ones who suddenly worry about their free speech while whoever is kn charge starts trying to silence everybody who disagrees with them
- viscountchocula 3y agoCan you give an example of a lefty state government aggressively pushing for censorship?
- HardlyCurious 3y agoWell, I can't think of any media articles talking about, specifically state level, censorship efforts from the left. But the Whitehouse was recently told by courts it couldn't communicate with social media companies about content moderation. Trying to claim that isn't censorship will require some mental gymnastics. But let's not forget the censorship around the hunter Biden laptop story and the censorship of lab leak theories for covid. Both completely legitimate topics, both completely blocked out during an election year. The right wasn't calling for or defending those actions, the left was.
- brightlancer 3y ago> Can you give an example of a lefty state government aggressively pushing for censorship? From the article: "For example, California presents its Age-Appropriate Design Code as a privacy regulation. Yet, the law imposes obligations on websites to deploy algorithms, designs, and features in a certain way or face fines. Of course, algorithms, features, and designs are the means by which websites develop, display, and disseminate speech."
- canadiantim 3y agoCanada, just look at Bill C-18. If that's not enough, they are about to try to pass an "anti-hate" bill as well targeting the internet, e.g. demanding taking down any content flagged as hate within 24 hours or massive penalties, so of course the default will be censorship to avoid penalties.
- commandlinefan 3y agoFor the most part, we get censorship because the majority wants censorship. (Or, at least, thinks they want censorship because they haven't thought all the way through what that actually is going to mean). The only reason we have anything resembling free speech in the United States is because the courts are stuck with the relatively unpopular first amendment - they're going to continue to ignore it as best they can and with a few trivial exceptions, not get much resistence.
- mrkeen 3y agoThe hard problem is defining censorship. 1a is applied pretty damn broadly in general - think Citizens United. But even if you take a more narrow definition of it (ask your government to change its ways), does that mean you can stand outside your Congressman's house at 1am with a megaphone? Would it be censorship to stop that?
- bluescrn 3y ago> Does that mean you can stand outside your Congressman's house at 1am with a megaphone? These days, that seems to depend entirely upon which cause you're protesting. If you're campaigning about the climate or against racism, you'll probably get away with it. But for many other causes, you'll probably be dragged away in handcuffs.
- rootusrootus 3y agoCops are by and large right-wing, not left. Historically, progressives have gotten the sharp end of the bayonet more often.
- bluescrn 3y agoPolice follow orders. For example, it's pretty obvious that in London they've been ordered by the powers that be to be very lenient to Just Stop Oil when they block roads over and over and over again. Meanwhile, also in the UK, a lone anti-abortion campaigner has been arrested on more than one occasion for silent prayer outside an abortion clinic. Under normal circumstances, it seems reasonable to limit protest in locations where patients visiting the clinic could be directly harassed, but at the same time, other protesters are permitted to repeatedly cause traffic chaos all over London, and are disrupting major events with no indication of any particularly harsh consequences.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoThis is a human problem, most people want to control what others think. It’s built into us for survival reasons.
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoI would be interested to see your thoughts from the perspective of a minority, especially one used as a scapegoat.
- uLogMicheal 3y ago> I would be interested to see your thoughts from the perspective of a minority, especially one used as a scapegoat. It is terrible what people say, do, have said, and have done to minority groups, but this sort of logic is a slippery slope to abuse. This means incentivized actors can intentionally identify with a group to pursue thought control over others. There should be a line in the sand when it comes to invading minds and forcing thought. Treatment of minorities has gotten better over the trajectory of time through natural behavioral changes and intelligence growth. Why now more than ever do we need such progressive controls? We live in a time where even the wolves do not necessarily have to be real to tell a story and now those stories can be used to force patterns of thought through censorship.
- gradExMachina 3y ago> A slippery slope fallacy (SSF), in logic, critical thinking, political rhetoric, and caselaw, is a fallacious argument in which a party asserts that a relatively small first step leads to a chain of related events culminating in some significant (usually negative) effect.[1] The core of the slippery slope argument is that a specific decision under debate is likely to result in unintended consequences. The strength of such an argument depends on whether the small step really is likely to lead to the effect. This is quantified in terms of what is known as the warrant (in this case, a demonstration of the process that leads to the significant effect). This type of argument is sometimes used as a form of fearmongering in which the probable consequences of a given action are exaggerated in an attempt to scare the audience. With all due respect, innocent people are dying because certain individuals incite violence against them. It's easy to express you support free speech when you are not on the receiving end and don't need to deal with insane people who think you are the devil-manifest. Would you be okay if your friends or family died in a shooting from an individual who consumed a particular class of content? Reality is that nothing is done in a vacuum, every action matters, every discussion matters, everything we utter matters.
- ryandrake 3y agoIn the US, minds are slowly changing on free speech. 40% of Millennials are OK with limiting speech offensive to minorities[1] and the trend by age cohort is very clear. We may disagree but we old people are aging out, and the newer generations are less likely to be free speech absolutists. Another poll[2] shows 61 percent of Americans agree that free speech should be restricted, and 51 percent believe that the First Amendment, ratified in 1791, should be rewritten to reflect the new cultural norms of today. 1: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2015/11/20/40-of-millennials-ok-with-limiting-speech-offensive-to-minorities/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2015/11/20/40-of-mil... 2: http://campaignforfreespeech.org/new-poll-free-speech-under-attack-majority-of-millennials-agree-jail-time-is-appropriate-for-certain-speech/ http://campaignforfreespeech.org/new-poll-free-speech-under-...
- rnk 3y agoI think your vision of free speech in the past is off, compared to my born in the 60s memory. There didn't used to be racist hate speech on the news or widely disseminated widely like there is today on reddit in certain groups. If there ever was a crowd saying things to say keep black kids out of their local school yelling, the news would probably minimize it. Hate speech wasn't common. It was happening of course, but not ever-present, but today it is very easy to see it. Today's conservatives in my mind just say it out loud, and the typical news media isn't squelching it, and social media is broadcasting it to get more interaction. Today that hate speech is widely disseminated. That's why today's youths are more open to blocking it - because it's much more ubiquitous.
- jlawson 3y agoIt's remarkable how you've managed to completely invert the reality. Please link where racist hate speech is "widely disseminated" on reddit. (Reddit has been strictly controlled speech according to San Francisco values for a decade). Or please show, anywhere in America, a "crowd saying things to say keep black kids out of their local school yelling".
- MSFT_Edging 3y ago
- ck2 3y agoNot just first amendment, people always forget the fourteenth amendment. Many state laws are massive fourteenth amendment violations, the problem is the supreme court gets the final say on that interpretation and you can predict how each and every one of those will go down for the next decade or two.
- yieldcrv 3y ago> Many state laws are massive fourteenth amendment violations Because the application of the 14th amendment is newer and less familiar. The 14th Amendment's passage is the first time the Constitution and Bill of Rights applied to the states at all. The Federal Government was really this smaller separate thing back then, before a few key events where it essentually subjugated all states. The rationale of extending the 14th amendment to all states was clarified decades later, and in fact is still being clarified in different contexts. So yes, there are still outstanding 14th amendment violations. You suggest the Supreme Court is a problem. Outside of 1 or 2 medical procedures it actually isn't that divided on most things if you go and look. Majority opinions are mostly bipartisan, or the whole court agrees. But you can use this less obvious understanding to your advantage over the next decade or two.
- seanw444 3y agoAlmost every single 2A-related ruling is party lines though. Seriously. Almost every single one.
- goodbyesf 3y agoThe past 10 years. Media: We demand online censorship. Media: State governments can't resist the siren song of censorship. Unbelievable. Also, it's amazing how the article left out the most egregious example of state censorship - anti-bds laws. A few dozen states make it illegal to boycott a foreign country. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-BDS_laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-BDS_laws Can you imagine if china or russia was able to get nearly 30+ states to make it illegal to boycott china or russia? Also, a super-majority of americans are against anti-bds laws and yet most states have them. Makes a mockery of democracy and representative government.
- vouaobrasil 3y agoThere is a reason why censorship is coming back these days, and its primary cause is technological. Of course, the proponents of censorship are people, but basically, the entire sum of technology behaves as an organism that optimizes for efficiency in its own growth. Dissenting ideas are impeding the growth of technology now. Moreover, we can roughly gauge how dangerous dissenting ideas are by how strong the push for censorship is. For example, there is already another post in this thread about the left pushing for censorship for speech if it is goes against their radical identity politic philosophy. But why is that? It is because their philosophy is idea for getting as many as people as possible building technology. Of course, that is not the proximal motivation of most leftists, but the technological system is giving them a voice because it helps technology progress. (Note, I am not right-leaning, nor do I intent to advocate one political point over the other. I never vote for conservatives, as I hate their anti-environmentalist philosophy. The right and left have one goal in common though, and that is to push technology forward. Thus both will be in favour of policies that push technology forward, but in different ways.)
- seanw444 3y agoI find it funny how people have to clarify "I'm not right-learning btw" to lend more credence to their claims, and to not be attacked. Shows where we're at.
- rootusrootus 3y ago> Shows where we're at Nah, it just shows where that person's mind is at. HN, in particular, has plenty of strong opinions from both sides of the metaphorical aisle. Particularly in this discussion.
- vouaobrasil 3y agoI only said it because I have been accused here in the past of being right-leaning and I'm sick of it.
- uLogMicheal 3y ago> Dissenting ideas are impeding the growth of technology now. This is extremely naive. Much of modern science and industry is built from dissent, people seeing that things are different or should be done different. Is your comment to say we have moved past a need for dissent? Remember, Galileo dissented and was censored.
- PartiallyTyped 3y agometa: There's a lot of irony when HN users complain about censorship in one of the most censored spaces of the internet.
- seanw444 3y agoWhile you're right, I'd say a good dictator is better than a good "council". Dang (and whoever helps him, if anyone) does a good job of keeping meaningful debate alive here, and shunning useless commentary and unwarranted hate. But yeah, it is censorship.
- uLogMicheal 3y agoEver wonder why a post is stuck at the bottom of the front page or falls off so quickly? There are stealth censorship controls built into the platform to adjust or remove discussions they do not want here, often times, discussions about censorship. Bias is present in moderation most places you go.
- uLogMicheal 3y agoWhere can genuine discussion be had in the digital age?
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoWe are having genuine discussion, it's just that certain people are trigger happy with flagging anything that goes against a certain narrative. I have had multiple instances where my account was flagged because I expressed a contrarian view, and I couldn't actually participate because I was rate-limited. No censorship also does not mean "genuine", 4chan is an example of this; virtually everything sans CSAM is "allowed", but genuine discussions are not happening because of trolls. Ultimately, you will most likely not have a genuine discussion online, and irl you need a particular group of people who are capable of entertaining differing opinions. In the span it took me to write this comment, GP received -3 and two other comments -4 total, proving the point. I tried to respond to sibling chain, and to none's surprise, I have been rate-limited again and I am effectively banned from discussing anything in this thread :).