14 ms·
She paid husband's hospital bill. A year after his death, they wanted more money
- kwanbix 3y agoI really can not understand how fucked up us health care is.
- sydbarrett74 3y agoTo the hospital systems and insurance companies, the confusion is a feature, not a bug. They assume most patients and their families will just knuckle under and pay what they're told they owe. Since the health care sector is one of the largest political donors, elected officials have little incentive to fix anything, so they nibble at the edges and call it reform.
- junofan 3y agoIt’s not donations. It’s the fact that the largest employer in nearly every congressional district is a healthcare system. Heard this from a guy who worked on the ACA.
- Workaccount2 3y agoI never really thought about it, but you could effectively use sick people to import money into your desolate community. In the same way that tourists bring tourists dollars, sick people bring government dollars.
- b112 3y agoThere are some poorer countries, which do specialize in excellent health care for economic reasons.
- selimthegrim 3y agoCuba?
- visarga 3y ago.., Turkey, India
- junofan 3y agoThey’re price makers in a local area. They don’t need to import sick people.
- mdorazio 3y agoEven beyond employment, healthcare represents a ridiculous 18% of the US GDP these days.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThat number is ridiculous but it's also the broken window fallacy. If people spent less on healthcare inefficiency they'd have more money and spend it on something else. So it's not like you actually have to preserve the wasteful bureaucracy as though you're gaining something from it -- the jobs would just move to whatever industry supplies the things people would buy if they weren't forced to waste their money on this. The real problem is the employment, because then you have not just the industry but its unions lobbying to preserve the inefficiency.
- peteradio 3y agoI struggle how we can include that into GDP. It should be a number we are attempting to reduce not grow because its a massive tax on the citizens.
- junofan 3y agoIt’s a shadow tax that goes to decent-yet-useless $60–90k jobs to buy political influence. There’s no countervailing influence.
- sydbarrett74 3y agoI'm reminded of the Terry Gilliam film Brazil.
- sydbarrett74 3y agoYep, the United States spends an outsized portion on it, but has some of the worst outcomes of any developed country.
- sydbarrett74 3y agoGood point. Although I still think donations play a decent part.
- grecy 3y ago> largest political donors You pay politicians, and you get the outcomes you want. Every other country in the world calls it bribery.
- hulitu 3y ago> Every other country in the world calls it bribery. This is, unfortunately, not true for the majority of "democratic" countries. They call it "lobby". They avoid to call it "conflict of interest".
- TRiG_Ireland 3y agoIn principle, there's nothing wrong with lobbying. Legislators cannot be specialists on everything that needs to be done. Bat conservation charities lobby the government on issues related to bat conservation. Deaf associations lobby the government on issues related to education of Deaf students and Deaf accessibility. Lobbying from commercial interests is infinitely more suspect, of course, but still sometimes reasonable. The trick is to have very strong laws about openness: lobbyists should be registered, and minutes of meetings should be published. Ireland's Regulation of Lobbying Act (2015) [1] is something of a gold standard, which some other countries are considering using as a model [2]. [1]: https://www.lobbying.ie/help-resources/information-for-lobbyists/quick-guide-to-the-act/ https://www.lobbying.ie/help-resources/information-for-lobby... [2]: https://www.politico.eu/article/ireland-lobbying-clampdown-model-for-europe/ https://www.politico.eu/article/ireland-lobbying-clampdown-m...
- pmyteh 3y agoThere's also a need to stop lobbying being used as a cover for bribery: either openly or as a quiet quid-pro-quo. Your firm's argument for the importance of a regulatory change may be useful, but the associated $10k "donation" is just corruption. I've been reading vol. 3 of Robert Caro's biography of LBJ and the amount of illegal money routed from various Texas oil tycoons via Johnson in support of various causes is astonishing.
- adamredwoods 3y agoAnother technique is to pass the burden of proof onto the consumer. The hospital creates a new charge, and it is up to the patient to prove it should have been covered by insurance. For example, showing something like meeting your yearly out-of-pocket is a difficult task. Sometimes it's up to the consumer to connect the two departments, insurance and the hospital billing, on the phone at the same time. Seems simple but the wait time between the two parties is high, and either one of them will drop off mysteriously. If the bill is in dispute for too long, you will be sent to collections, and have your credit score degrade.
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoC.f. Executive Function Theft https://hedgehoglibrarian.com/2023/08/14/executive-function-theft/ https://hedgehoglibrarian.com/2023/08/14/executive-function-...
- moribvndvs 3y agoAbsolutely. I work in HIT for small to medium size practices. We all know how badly insurance is treating us as patients, but what’s not as well known is how much they squeeze medical providers (example [1]). Hospitals and networks have the weight to navigate insurance, but small independent offices don’t and are also getting absolutely fucked over. In addition to staffing issues, rising operational costs, excessive demand, slow turn around in receipts, rising complexity in software and regulatory compliance, a lot of local doctors are selling to networks and hospitals or just straight up closing doors. Large entities absorb all the same problems primarily by economies of scale which can result in poor individual care, increased out of pocket costs, amongst other things. [1] https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2023/08/15/1193754380/why-doctors-pay-millions-in-fees-that-could-be-spent-on-care https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2023/08/15/1193754...
- TedDoesntTalk 3y ago> local doctors are selling to networks and hospitals My primary care physician did this a couple of years ago. He still works at the practice and I still see him. When I asked him why he sold, he said he wants to do what he loves - practice medicine - not spend most of his time working with insurance companies. The worst part is all my records from years of visiting him did not transfer to the new system. It’s as if I’ve been seeing him for 2 years instead of 10 because no one can access my old test results and records. So much for continuity of care. Now I download all documents in their portal and save locally.
- TheNewsIsHere 3y agoYou’re not joking. There’s a major dental insurance carrier that finds it perfectly acceptable to “pay” dental offices with prepaid debit/credit cards. Think Greendot, Mastercard, or Visa prepaid cards. I’m fairly certain my dentistry firm is fighting back in ways I’m not comfortable sharing because I don’t know any facts and would just be speculating, but I do hope they’re sticking it to them.
- rwmj 3y agoI really don't understand why the US doesn't have a grown up healthcare system. Do you just not see how much better healthcare is in the rest of the developed world?
- vkou 3y agoThe healthcare system in the US is much better for a small group of people who make a lot of money from it, and they have bought the entirety of one, and much of another political party to ensure that it stays that way.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoThis is exactly it. Everyone asks why the American people put up with this, as if our congress actually gives a damn about the average American. Congressional votes are bought and paid for by corporations which benefit from the current, broken system.
- AmericanChopper 3y agoI’ve lived in quite a few different countries (including a couple that are frequently praised for their public healthcare systems), and the quality of the healthcare I’ve received in the US is far better than anything I’ve had anywhere else.
- causi 3y agoThe quality of care you did receive in those countries may have been lesser, but what could you have gotten if you paid as much there as you pay in the US?
- AmericanChopper 3y ago> but what could you have gotten if you paid as much there as you pay in the US? If you ignore the fact that I was already paying substantially more for it with higher taxes, the answer is still nothing. Countries with public healthcare don’t have expansive private healthcare systems, and nowhere in the world has a healthcare system that offers the level of service that the US system does. For example my sister was giving birth in New Zealand, and I wanted to just pay out of pocket for a private hospital for her. There are zero private hospitals in the country that offer this service, so her only option was to go to her local (and notoriously bad) hospital. She remained in the maternity ward for nearly a week, because while she was there that hospital had its 15th norovirus outbreak for the year.
- SomethingNew2 3y agoImo one part of the confusion and complexity is pricing. There is no standardized pricing. Many countries with government run healthcare systems solve this by not showing patients the prices and standardizing the price they pay to doctors etc. in the US you have the hospitals / health care providers, insurance companies, and patients all negotiating with each other. Some state governments tried to mandate a defined list of services and costs, but I don’t think it worked. Each provider categorizes things slightly differently. Also it seems the insurance companies and providers are fighting it out around what to pay, leaving the patient in the middle also trying to negotiate. It’s all very exhausting.
- visarga 3y ago> It’s all very exhausting. Mixing profit with healthcare is bound to lead to trouble. Patients got no choice but to accept the abuses of the system when they are sick. Like agreeing to things under duress.
- kingsloi 3y agoExactly the same happened to me & my family, and we've also appeared on NPR for a similar situation: > https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2022/09/22/1121612539/baby-high-medical-bills-nicu-heartbreak https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2022/09/22/1121612... My daughter died. Our story aired a year later. Another year later, so around 2 years after my daughter's death, I received a hospital bill for a little over $3,000, for her initial few weeks of ICU care. I never acknowledged it. I couldn't bring myself to call the hospital to setup a payment plan, say my daughters name in the same sentence as a dollar amount again. We haven't heard a peep since.
- _m8fo 3y agoThat’s terrible, sorry for your loss. Thanks for sharing.
- onemoresoop 3y agoSorry for your loss.
- goodbyesf 3y ago> We haven't heard a peep since. Good. But just to be safe, you should check your credit report from time to time to make sure they didn't send your account to collections.
- chrisfinazzo 3y agoHere I was thinking I was the only one with insane insurance stories... The closest experience I can think of to this was when I was a sophomore in college in 2006. In short order, I had a seizure, was taken to a local Trauma ICU, and hours later flown to a Level 1 facility in another part of the state. The hospital where I stayed billed us without issue, but the Trauma center decided it was the right thing to do when it sent the unadjusted bill to me at my college address. Oh, and the medical transport people who flew me around the state of NJ? Nothing. Just super. I also could talk about how earlier this year I spent 23 days in the ICU for an infection related to the same condition, and how an event from April-May still isn't settled as far as insurance goes, but I'm stressed enough at this point. Score 1 for PTSD! It occurs to me that I've surely met the deductible and OOP limit for the year, so that might explain why we've been so slow to see things get resolved. To top off this cavalcade of awfulness, the person who hired me into my current job lost her fight with pancreatic cancer last week. 2023 sucks.
- LanceH 3y agoEvery interaction I have involves checking out, standing before a sign that says, "all fees must be paid at time of service." I pay then, then months later get more bills to be paid well after the time of service.
- consz 3y agoAs far as I can tell, this is the correct way to handle this? I haven’t paid attention to any medical bills sent in the mail since I started working 15 years ago (I generally pay what they ask at the point of service), and I’ve never noticed any consequences (no denial of service anywhere, has never shown up in any way on my credit report, etc) — as far as my experience has shown, any bills sent after the fact are completely optional to pay.
- tomrod 3y agoIf you are in the US, you are probably often paying for the wrong services as billing errors are quite common.
- consz 3y agoMaybe? I don’t really care, that sounds like an error for the hospital to fix or get right the first time. Ignoring it seems to have no repercussions.
- tomrod 3y agoMy experience has been that bills can often be 5X the actual services. It can matter if you have any sort of real interaction. For minor common stuff you're right it is immaterial -- like a doc visit with a copay. But get a frenectomy? Mole removal? Vein ablation? Ortho surgery? I highly, highly recommend reviewing the procedure codes for anyone who recognizes they are their best, and often only, advocate.
- consz 3y ago
- javajosh 3y agoI'd like to see a new regulatory regime that allows individual health care providers like doctors, nurses, etc to start their own practices that are cash only. The sense I get is that small strappy businesses like that can't start because of the regulatory regime that's too expensive to comply with. But yeah in the end all of this machinery that gets between the patient and the provider and affects that relationship negatively needs to be done away with.
- meepmorp 3y ago> I'd like to see a new regulatory regime that allows individual health care providers like doctors, nurses, etc to start their own practices that are cash only. We already have that. Medical practices aren't required to take health insurance and can charge cash for services.
- Volundr 3y agoSpecifically, Googling "Direct Primary Care" in your area will probably find you what you are looking for. Specialists who work this way also exist, but are rarer (and significantly more expensive)
- prirun 3y ago> I'd like to see a new regulatory regime that allows individual health care providers like doctors, nurses, etc to start their own practices that are cash only. This is a non-starter because older people with Medicare coverage - the people who get sick more often - would have to pay their Medicare premium, supplement premium, and the cash price. In principle, I agree with you, sort of. Going to an immediate care center in my town for example costs $100 if you pay cash, but if you have insurance, they bill $300 and the insurance pays $100-150 (the rest gets written off). My suspicion, but I don't know this for sure, is that when a hospital bills say $1000 and the insurance pays $300, the hospital gets to take the $700 difference as a loss, ie, it lowers their taxes. So in this case instead of having to pay income taxes on $300, the hospital gets a tax deduction for $400. Anyone know if that is the case?
- INTPenis 3y agoWhat baffles me are these people who constantly show up to defend the US health care system, when there is clearly a plethora of real end user testimony showing how detrimental it is to the health of most United States citizens. Maybe HN isn't the best site to discuss this on, I'm guessing most of you work for some large tech sector business that offers good insurance. But most of the world is not made up of tech workers.
- grecy 3y agoI think it's very common for Americans with decent insurance to not want universal healthcare, and be afraid they'll pay waaaaay more in tax. They think the system is fine as it is, because they've never put it to the test. Then they have some catastrophic incident (car crash, cancer, heart attack, etc. etc.) and they're bankrupt in a few years and become very, very strong proponents of universal healthcare. I think it's exceptionally hard for people to understand the system until it personally impacts their life in a very big way. I'm not sure what to do about it. Maybe as a start every health insurance provider should be forced to provide facts about customers with the same insurance who had catastrophic events and how that worked out for them over 3-5 years.
- supertrope 3y agoIf you have a good job and don’t have any chronic medical conditions and have never been hospitalized and no one you care about has experienced those things the US medical-industrial complex is fine. Healthy Americans want the payroll deductions for health insurance employee contribution, Medicare, Social Security, income tax to be as small as possible. When we get sick or injured we want no wait highest quality maximum intervention medical care and low co-pays.
- nitwit005 3y agoThere's a lot of willful denial of reality when it comes to health care, but even when that doesn't happen, a lot of discussions just end up being people explaining how things work to others. The Veterans Health Administration is a huge sprawling thing. A lot of people aren't aware it exists.
- vkou 3y ago
- oneepic 3y agoThere are two extremes I'm familiar with: - sticker shock from the bill - like, holy fuck, I was supposed to have insurance. Why is my provider taking back its coverage a year later? (May be called a "takeback" as customer support told me over the phone) - Called customer support about the bill, and they were mostly supportive and believed what I said about being covered at the time. This was a relief to speak to nice people, but at the same time why make me fight an uphill battle? Why force so much confusion and fear on the patient at once?
- fallinghawks 3y agoKaiser keeps sending me bills for a pair of non-emergency visits that happened 6 months ago. They're small amounts, but it's crazy that it seems to take months for Kaiser's insurance to decide how much they're going to pay for various labs.
- ok123456 3y agoThe mistake was paying anything. If you paid anything on it, it then becomes collectable.
- siliconc0w 3y agoImagine if they passed a common sense requirement that is you want any payment it needs to be a single bill, day of service, plain language. I was thinking we should use the proposition system here in CA to get this through- who wouldn't vote for it.
- frumper 3y agoThat sounds like the unintended consequence is you'd be billed the day of service the full cost and you can submit the claim to your insurance for reimbursement.
- bsenftner 3y agoThe US "healthcare system" is a criminal organization. And the US government is in on that con. The USA is such a farce, it's impossible to grasp the totality of it all.
- maerF0x0 3y agoWe simply need a sort of statute of limitations for B2C transactions. - Your employer can incorrectly pay you for a long time and then demand the money back. - A hospital bill can come (afaik) anytime in the future - You can dispute charges, the provider can fail to provide customer service, but your credit score is negatively affected. Etc. We need bills that focus on favoring the "little guy" in the fight so that wealth, dominance, and power are mitigated in justice. EDIT: actually the bit about employer overpay being for "Decades" and demand back was not entirely true, depends on the state, ranges from weeks to 15 years according to my googling.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agohttps://www.forbes.com/advisor/debt-relief/debt-relief-statute-of-limitations-debt-collection-by-state/ https://www.forbes.com/advisor/debt-relief/debt-relief-statu...
- supertrope 3y agoA lot of health plans consider any bill presented more than a year from the date of service forfeited. Medical billing is notoriously slow, opaque, and fragmented. On the insurance side they tend to be super slow in payment running 120 days behind forcing the hospital to de facto provide vendor credit to insurance companies that are way better capitalized than they are.
- sampo 3y agoWhat happens if people move to a new address, or to a new country? The hospital mails the bills to the old address but nobody will know?
- spicyusername 3y agoIt'll probably go to collections and their credit score will tank for no reason.
- sampo 3y agoThe credit score of the dead person, or the spouse?
- deprecative 3y agoSpouse under the assumption they either accept ownership of the debt or they already were the owner of the debt.
- sameg14 3y agoThe American healthcare system is so broken, this exact thing has happened to everyone I know including myself
- drewg123 3y agoThe worst experience I've had is one where I interacted with a provider, I paid my co-pay, they billed my insurance, my insurance paid the remainder, and it seemed to be done. Roughly a year later, the insurance company audited the bill, determined that the provider coded something wrong, and (somehow) took back their money. So the provider turned around and billed me 18 months later. I called the provider, who had no clue what had happened. The insurance company finally told me that they reversed the charges, and told me I was not responsible for the bill, and the provider had to generate a correct bill. That was the last I heard of it, and I'm still expecting a several thousand dollar bill to show up in the mail..
- bob_theslob646 3y agoWow! That is quite a ride. You know there's a problem when an organization has to hire a billing coder in order to decipher what to bill patients. The whole thing just seems sad
- black_13 3y ago[dead]
- reducesuffering 3y agoMaybe ask why UnitedHealth is a $455B company with 400k employees which provides no actual medical care themselves.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoMy dental insurance tried to make me pay the full cost of my invisalign treatment twice. I've ignored the second bill. Delta Dental can eat shit and see how they like their own insurance plans. They also dragged their feet paying the part they said they would cover. They split it into two equal payments and said I would get half now and half in the next calendar year as long as I had continuous coverage during that time. Checked EOBs/statements/etc for any hint that they could do this, it was the first time I'd heard about it.