9 ms·
Odd and unsafe baby car seats from the past
- aimor 3y agoWow this reminds me how much I miss all the legroom we used to have without a floor/center console. In modern cars I feel like I'm penned in a tiny personal pod. I'm hopeful electric cars lead to a return of leg room.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoPre 70s/80s cars were really total deathtraps, it's pretty amazing how far we've come. https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/motor-vehicle/historical-fatality-trends/deaths-and-rates/ https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/motor-vehicle/historical-fatalit...
- wedn3sday 3y agoAll modern cars are death traps.
- mech765 3y agoAren't bicycles more deadly per passenger mile?
- connicpu 3y agoIn terms of being killed by other vehicles on the road yes
- SoftTalker 3y agoWhich is why they don't belong on the road with cars.
- Robin_Message 3y agoI too agree with the banning of cars from areas where pedestrians and cyclists are likely to be, for example, all city centres and residential areas.
- eru 3y agoYou don't need to go quite so far. Dutch levels of separation are probably enough.
- connicpu 3y agoThe roads belonged to pedestrians, horses, and bicycles a long time before the car infestation took over
- parineum 3y agoI can't believe you're in favor of banning cars, horses and bicycles from the road.
- t0mas88 3y agoModern cars are very safe for the occupants compared to all previous iterations. It's the people by foot or bike you crash those cars into that are in a bad place.
- eru 3y agoThough different cars differ. SUVs are particularly bad for pedestrians and cyclists.
- kalleboo 3y agoIn the truck-loving US yes, but in Europe, pedestrian crash safety is also taken into account and has improved a lot. E.g. Volvo have hoods that pop up on impact to cushion the blow for pedestrians. Of course they're still less safe than not-cars, but in comparison to 50 years ago much has improved.
- t0mas88 3y agoThat hood popping system is also in BMWs, it may have become mandatory by now. Is it not included in US models?
- kalleboo 3y agoIt is but rather than normal cars, Americans prefer driving large pick-up trucks that are like being hit by a brick wall https://cdn.theatlantic.com/thumbor/AtTPZlAj9QVkg7ZtJ6q9Vk9cll4=/0x0:2048x1152/1310x736/media/img/posts/2021/12/FC3tgqEWQAoO6mv_1/original.jpg https://cdn.theatlantic.com/thumbor/AtTPZlAj9QVkg7ZtJ6q9Vk9c... https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/12/suvs-trucks-killing-pedestrians-cyclists/621102/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/12/suvs-truck...
- afavour 3y agoAll modern cars are deadly, just the deadliness is projected outwards. Don’t get me wrong, increased car safety is a good thing but people can drive like maniacs with a pretty good assurance they’re not going to be seriously injured even if they get in a crash. So they do. Which is bad news is you’re a pedestrian or a cyclist.
- bluGill 3y agoThey drove the same (or likely worse!) in 1960 when cars went just as fast as today, but they didn't have either the drivers training or the safety features of a modern car.
- genter 3y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C_r5UJrxcck https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C_r5UJrxcck
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wedn3sday 3y agoNot to be That Guy, but all car seats are unsafe since they're in cars. Im shocked on a daily basis how stupid and short sighted our car culture is, everyone has to behave perfectly all the time, and the consequences are death for you and random strangers. Any random stranger can sneeze at any time and kill your whole family.
- willio58 3y ago> Any random stranger can sneeze at any time and kill your whole family. So true. I live right near a stroad and a crosswalk on that stroad and about once a week I hear brakes being slammed on because people aren't paying attention and it's a high-traffic area for walkers (some of which are children) since the rest of the neighborhood is actually quite walkable. I've live in this place 1 year and now witnessed 4 accidents, luckily none of them killing anyone yet but it's just a matter of time. I've also been traveling a lot recently and experiencing cities (even American ones) that value good public transportation with metros (and even trains in the Northeast) and it's a breath of fresh air. Then I come back to where I live and the only way to describe it is I'm watching these huge machines, piloted by and only transporting 1 person in most cases, barreling around my local area just narrowly missing each other at high speeds. Every pilot is just assuming every other pilot had enough coffee that day, isn't massively distracted by any number of things, doesn't have road rage, isn't trying to show off their loud, polluting, and dangerous machine, etc. No wonder kids increasingly stay inside and get depressed. Previous generations literally built car and parking lot hellscapes and expect people to still enjoy life outside the home.
- eru 3y ago> Not to be That Guy, but all car seats are unsafe since they're in cars. Safety is a spectrum, not a binary.
- erulabs 3y agoKids are certainly less likely to be injured these days - but car seats for a dollar! Raising kids in the last 100 years makes normal consumer inflation look like a cute joke - modern car seats are easily 200x more expensive! It’s a horrible actuary table to make, especially as a parent, but the engineer in me does some napkin math: A) Number of children killed in car seat accidents B) number of children not born due to increased financial burden of any given child If B > A, we’re down net-children. Is “more kids” better than “safer kids”? Who’s to make a judgement like this? It’s a gruesome math - and not one that applies to the financially well off: if you can afford it, you’re not complaining about increasing your child's safety.
- jlawson 3y agoIt's not just about financial costs, it's also the physical space limitations. Cars generally can only fit 3 carseats. Regardless of equipment costs, that makes it infeasible for parents to have a 4th child. They wouldn't be able to go anywhere. This by itself has prevented thousands of births. I've known people for whom this was a major factor in a decision to not have another child. They are always the most thoughtful, low time preference people whose kids would benefit society the most.
- cameldrv 3y agoThis was still a problem in the 80s after mandatory seatbelts came in and cars got narrower. Some people say that 3 across is too hard with a normal car but I’ve found that even with a small car you can get 3 in without much trouble if you just get narrower seats.
- tragomaskhalos 3y agoIn the early 70's we'd drive down to Cornwall on holiday with my cousins - 3 adults and 3 kids squashed into a bog standard saloon car. It seems completely inconceivable now.
- woobar 3y agoThe cars with more than 5 seats do exist. If cost is not an issue as you suggest, it is pretty feasible to have 4+ children. It is even easier if you are not aiming to have them born in a rapid succession. Older kids can ride upfront.
- gumby 3y agoMy parents were quite concerned about car safety and tell me that when they bought a new car after I was born they insisted that it be fitted with seat belts even though the salesman insisted that it was a waste of money (mid 1960s). Also my parents: they bought my sister and me chid car seats "so you could look out the windows". Basically a shallow plastic bowl with a cushion attached and a folding wire frame underneath to make it higher.
- adrianmonk 3y agoWas it a Cosco Go Seat? https://www.ebay.com/itm/195773905158 https://www.ebay.com/itm/195773905158 That's what I had as a kid. I don't recall a cushion, though. Also, the plastic developed a crack and would painfully pinch your skin if you were wearing shorts.
- gumby 3y agoWhy indeed it was! The photo you linked to shows the cushion I was talking about -- the darker green patch.
- fsckboy 3y agothat little seat with the steering wheel? I had one of those, and I still remember it from age ... 3? 4? I remember the day I realized that moving the steering wheel back and forth all the time is not the way you drive a car, as fun and obvious as it is that it should work that way. I noticed my mother was holding the wheel straight so I started imitating her. (looking back now I can see so much of my generalized autism: playing with matchbox cars, I spent most of my time setting them up for parallel parking, and then for diagonal parking between the stripes. I hated when my friends wanted any type of "fantasy" play, i just wanted to be realistic all the time.) I concur that the main point of those car seats was as a booster seat, to get the kid up high enough to see out the window so they could better occupy themselves and not squall, but perhaps my perspective is biased. Also, that woman driving the car in the white heels? looks pretty much exactly like my mother.
- greggsy 3y agoIt’s interesting that you use the way you played with matchbox cars as an example, as I’ve seen that exact scenario used by therapists to inform an autism spectrum diagnosis in children. Probably not a coincidence, since they’re a very, very common toy that’s accessible to every demographic in western societies.
- user3939382 3y agoDoes the playpen in the back of my mom’s WV Bus count?
- Mizoguchi 3y agoI used to stand on the front seat with my mom driving (she was a terrible driver btw). She also took us kids once on a road trip around the mountains at 12000 ft elevation, lots of snow and exposed roads. This among other negligences unrelated to driving. A true miracle we made it into adulthood.
- dugmartin 3y agoAh the 70s - I remember laying horizontal as a kid in the back window area of our Gran Torino looking up at the sky on long road trips. More fun though was standing in the back of a pickup truck holding on to anything I could on the roof while it hauled down a country road and we ducked to avoid low branches.
- bombcar 3y agoOne thing to realize about these photos - they're still a vast improvement over a child literally rolling around on the floor (where they could get entangled with the pedals or who knows what else).
- eweise 3y agoI don't think I wore a seatbelt until my teenage years. We mainly rode in the back of the stationwagon where there was enough room to play games. I also remember riding in truck beds was a normal thing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- justrealist 3y agoI'm not convinced that's true. In a crash, the bar is going to cause a lot of internal damage and whiplash (if it contains them at all)... I mean it might be true, but I really doubt it was tested formally.
- kuhsaft 3y agoI think OP means that it’s an improvement in crash prevention not crash safety.
- bombcar 3y agoExactly. You could go your entire life without being involved in a crash, but if a child is rolling around in the car, you will probably be involved in at least annoyance quite quickly.
- flir 3y agoIt's ok, babies fold. I'm sure I've read that somewhere.
- jwestbury 3y ago
- nonethewiser 3y agoNow we have dozens of car seats designed by engineers and thoroughly crash-tested to create car seats that get thrown away (or are supposed to be) after any impact event. Makes me feel like we are much richer than we used to be.
- isk517 3y agoIt's definitely a rip off. I'm working on a new type of child car seat that I believe will take the market by storm. Guaranteed to be reusable after every crash. My plan to achieve this is by design the seat so that the force of the impact is funneled directly into the child, protecting the car seat from any damage.
- syntaxing 3y agoSame for helmets. It less so it’s purposely designed so people will keep buying them but more so that something has to absorb the impact so the kid doesn’t. Mechanical deformation turns out to be the most effective and safest but deformation is also a one way street hence why you need to change it after an impact. That being said, how often are you getting into accidents?!
- blincoln 3y agoImagine how much more expensive a car seat designed to be fully reusable after a collision would be, then consider how often most people are involved in serious collisions. I'm in my 40s, and I've been a passenger in one collision that required a tow truck, something like 20 years ago. Most people I've talked to have similar experiences in terms of frequency of serious collisions. It's less expensive overall to do it this way.
- ajford 3y agoYeah, that's because they're designed to absorb the damage into internal stress and deformation to dissipate the force of the crash. That force and momentum has to go somewhere and it's better to absorb it into the car seat and consider it a consumable than to transmit that force into the child it's meant to protect. The same thing applies for helmets. A motorcycle helmet is a consumable item and should be discarded after a crash as the internal foam structure will be deformed and could fail to properly absorb the impact forces in a subsequent crash.
- maxwell 3y agoI glanced at motor vehicle fatality rates in the U.S. previously and didn't see a clear impact of seat belt laws myself, instead the major drops seem to line up with economic recessions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35833165 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35833165
- derbOac 3y agoThis is getting tangential but it's striking to me how fatality rates went up during the pandemic. You can see the dips during previous recessions and energy crises like you're saying, and I'd expect something similar during the pandemic, but it went the other way.
- brewdad 3y agoPeople were bored sitting at home. Getting out in your car and driving stupidly fast on empty roads was one way to alleviate that boredom. My 25mph road regularly became a drag strip.
- dr_orpheus 3y agoSeems likely, I had to keep going to work in person during COVID and my commute to work became very fast, and not just because of the empty roads. I also wonder if there was an uptick in fatality as people started returning to work and those used to speeding down an empty road were suddenly confronted with traffic. Also reminds me of some statistics I saw back in drivers ed class. I don't remember the exact stats, but in winter months there were significantly more crashes due to inclement weather/poor visibility as one might expect. But there were more fatal crashes in summer because people drive faster when they have clear conditions and line of sight.
- lostlogin 3y ago> fatality rates went up during the pandemic. They went down during lockdown in some places. I think the severity of lockdown is likely related, and New Zealand’s was more severe than most. https://www.1news.co.nz/2020/12/31/sad-and-disappointing-2020-road-toll-still-high-despite-lockdown-lulls/ https://www.1news.co.nz/2020/12/31/sad-and-disappointing-202...
- kn0where 3y agoI can’t tell if this article is AI generated or just sloppily written. The organization is really weird. There are just two (very specific) subheadings in the piece: “Bunny Bear Booster Seat (1933)” and “In the 1970s Car Hammocks for Babies Were a Thing (1970s)”, but these sections discuss multiple different car seat designs besides the title ones, making me think these “sections” were LLM-generated. None of the photos are specific to the sections of the article they appear in—it’s as if the author just did a google image search for “old car seat” and sprinkled them throughout the article with no particular chronological or contextual significance.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dfxm12 3y agoIt reads like an AI generated article. There also doesn't appear to be a by line. The site has a contact form, but no one is named in the contact us or about us page. To me, this points more to AI generated than sloppily written.
- Terr_ 3y agoIt is kinda weird: It'd be one thing if it was simply an unordered list of photos, but the text seems like it was randomly interspersed too.
- Aardwolf 3y agoI didn't read it, just enjoyed scrolling through the photos. It's at least awesome that such a collection of photos exists of a topic that would otherwise certainly be entirely forgotten. Do you think archeologists might still be able to find this series of photos in, say, 500 years?
- moribvndvs 3y agoI mean, I just google image searched “historical car baby seat” and all those photos showed up, almost in the same order as the article. To answer your question, if Google is still around, yes.
- h2odragon 3y ago70s kids rode in the back of the pickup truck. They'd yell at us not to jump around too much back there. Car seat laws are fun, they often talk about size and (hopefully, usually) age: Some small people have a legal grey area where they should legally be in a car seat as they learn to drive.
- deckard1 3y ago1980s kids too. I remember after tee-ball my entire team would hop into the back of the coach's pickup and ride to get ice cream.
- resolutebat 3y agoIn Singapore even today, all passengers in a car must wear seatbelts, unless they're crammed into the back of a pickup truck. https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/opinion/article/3131590/singapores-migrant-workers-deserve-better-be-ferried-livestock https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/opinion/article/3131590/singa...
- hydrok9 3y agoWe did this in the 2000s as well
- AlgorithmicTime 3y agoMeanwhile my son is almost 3 and already approaching a size where he legally only needs a booster seat.
- ChoHag 3y agoI can't lie, I like the look of that one that hangs them out the side window. Can we get them for planes?
- jvm___ 3y agoI've sat backwards in the trunk of a Ford Taurus station wagon. A few years later there was one at a demolition derby - after the first hit there wasn't much car left behind the rear wheels... Eep!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]