14 ms·
The feds asked TikTok for lots of domestic spying features
- karaterobot 3y ago> Many of the concessions the government asked of TikTok look eerily similar to the surveillance tactics critics have accused Chinese officials of abusing. I support a domestic ban on TikTok, and this is embarrassing. You're not supposed to be worse than the country you say is spying on your citizens. This undermines any moral authority they could claim, and makes their argument look like: "we want to ban you because we can't stand anyone doing a better job spying on Americans than us".
- giraffe_lady 3y agoWhat about the last 80 years makes you think the US has any sort of moral authority.
- SoftTalker 3y agoYou are 100% correct, but I'm not surprised in the least to hear about this.
- echelon 3y agoThey are not in fact 100% correct. CFIUS doesn't have authority over or interest in ordinary US citizens. They are 100% concerned with foreign intrusion of national security. That's their singular mandate. This is an auditing operation to determine the extent to which TikTok is a national security threat.
- scarmig 3y agoCFIUS closely works with US intelligence agencies. That in itself isn't damning. But it also bears pointing out that the NSA also doesn't have authority over or interest in ordinary US citizens and is ostensibly 100% concerned with foreign intrusion of national security. Actual activities can and do go much further than intelligence agencies' public mandate.
- Kalium 3y agoI would be surprised and upset if CFIUS did not work closely with intelligence agencies. CFIUS is an agency charged with risk mitigation from foreign actors. Doing that effectively requires good information and risk assessments. If CFIUS did not work closely with intelligence agencies, they would either be incapable of performing their function or running their own intelligence agency.
- rrdharan 3y agoThe article has an inflammatory headline, obviously, because that’s how the internet works. If you read the article though the actual content does not suggest they were asking for anything other than the ability to ensure TikTok/Byte Dance weren’t doing anything nefarious… and anyway it fell apart when it became obvious how hopeless that was because of how shady they (Byte Dance) are.
- pessimizer 3y ago> does not suggest they were asking for anything other than the ability to ensure TikTok/Byte Dance weren’t doing anything nefarious The Chinese do not think that they are doing anything nefarious either.
- empath-nirvana 3y ago> The Chinese do not think that they are doing anything nefarious either. "Nefarious" is very dependent on context. The CIA spying on China is what the CIA is _supposed_ to be doing -- it's not nefarious in the US context, but surely, to the Chinese, it's "nefarious activity" and the CIA is aware of that. Surely the Chinese know that they're up to no good from the US point of view, even if it's ethically fine from their point of view.
- neon_electro 3y ago> Forbes reports that the draft agreement, dated Summer 2022, would have given the US government agencies like the Department of Justice and Department of Defense far more access to TikTok’s operations than that of any other social media company. The agreement would let agencies examine TikTok’s US facilities, records, and servers with minimal prior notice and veto the hiring of any executive involved with leading TikTok US data security organization. It would also let US agencies block changes to the app’s terms of service in the US and order the company to subject itself to various audits, all on TikTok’s dime, per Forbes. In extreme cases, the agreement would allow government organizations to demand TikTok temporarily shut off functioning in the US. Can you share evidence that US regulators are holding US-based social media companies to all of these same requirements?
- tlb 3y agoDuring a hot war, it’s reasonable to be more concerned about enemy surveillance than domestic surveillance. In either case, you lose some privacy. But enemy surveillance can cause you to lose the war, or at least for more people to die before winning. We aren’t at war with China, but the possibility is taken seriously by the US foreign policy establishment, which knows more about the situation that you or I do. The most reliable way to avoid war is to be impossible to beat. So preempting the ability of potential enemies to collect data about our citizens reduces the chance of war.
- che_shirecat 3y agoWhat did the US foreign policy establishment know about Afghanistan and Iraq than you or I do? Last I heard from reliable sources, Iraq had WMD's and were a clear and present danger? Why not just preempt China's nuclear capability too by nuking them?
- bee_rider 3y agoI think you are just making a rhetorical flourish, but we should be clear that Iraq didn’t have WMDs, wasn’t an urgent danger, and any sources that said they did should not be treated as reliable.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> any sources that said they did should not be treated as reliable. American GEOINT, MASINT, SIGINT and TECHINT are likely the best in the world. American HUMINT, OSINT and--somewhat paradoxically--FININT are atrocious. Unfortunately, we frequently ascribe confidence intervals to our clandestine services based on experience with e.g. the NRO.
- yonaguska 3y agoThey might be the best in the world- but it doesn't matter because they don't answer to citizens. I trust that they have good information- I don't trust that good information gets to us, our politicians, etc.
- echelon 3y agoThe government is auditing TikTok, not using TikTok to spy on US citizens. The US is trying to determine to what extent TikTok is a domestic security threat. CFIUS is an organ of the US government designed to prevent foreign intrusion that risks national security. That's the entity involved here. They don't touch ordinary US citizens. This is not domestic spying. It's investigating the capabilities of a foreign power on US soil.
- wkat4242 3y agoOf course Snowden showed us that agencies regularly exceed their mandates. Why would that not be possible here?
- 1MachineElf 3y agoAll I can tell you is I've worked for a company that had to comply with CFIUS agreement, and honestly, there are no surveillance capabilities whatsoever. They have oversight capabilities and can audit the parts of the business that are covered by the security rules. Ironically, these rules we had to comply with were called the National Security Agreement (NSA) but that entirely coincidental. It was not anywhere near as exciting as people commenting here are speculating.
- PurpleRamen 3y agoThe text indicates that they are trying to spy on the company, not the users. And this is a logical attempt if you don't trust the companies masters. Isn't china basically doing the same with every company, just in other ways?
- hedora 3y ago> The agreement would let agencies examine TikTok’s US facilities, records, and servers with minimal prior notice and veto the hiring of any executive involved with leading TikTok US data security organization. Granting access to TikTok servers to multiple US agencies is 100% about letting the US spy on users (just as they have the right to under US law, such as the US CLOUD Act, and also via the well-documented and illegal warrantless surveillance programs we all know about). Blocking executive hires is clearly so they can prevent whistleblowers from working in the organization, and is exactly what the US did when it was using Crypto AG to spy on its allies: https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/world/national-security/cia-crypto-encryption-machines-espionage/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/world/national-... Anyway, I'm against a ban of TikTok for the same reason that laws that target specific companies or individuals are unconstitutional. Instead, we should ban the things TikTok does that we think should be illegal, and then apply the law equally to US and foreign social media companies.
- ballenf 3y agoThe hiring veto grants essentially the power to install a covert agent. "We veto all your choices. But what about this guy... Relocating from Langley, VA wouldn't be hard for him."
- afiori 3y ago> Instead, we should ban the things TikTok does that we think should be illegal, and then apply the law equally to US and foreign social media companies. This is how the previous "Ban Tiktok" bill basically made VPNs illegal.
- dataflow 3y ago> laws that target specific companies or individuals are unconstitutional Do you have a link for this? If you're referring to bills of attainder, my understanding wasn't that they're as broad as just "targeting".
- sangnoir 3y ago> Instead, we should ban the things TikTok does that we think should be illegal, and then apply the law equally to US and foreign social media companies This would would destroy billions of dollars in profits, take down most of the ad-tech industry, which is why I suspect it will never happen. It's much easier to target individual companies like TikTok, or Cambridge Analytica while leaving the gravy train going. For the record, I fully agree with you on what the remedy ought to be - just cynical about viability.
- pixelatedindex 3y ago> I support a domestic ban on TikTok I don’t use any social media, so apologies if this is a dumb question. What is TikTok doing that other ones like YouTube, Instagram, Facebook isn’t? The only difference I am seeing is that the parent company is China. Misinformation is omnipresent across all those channels too. So on what basis should we ban them?
- karaterobot 3y agoNo, you're correct: it being China is the main reason. And it's a sufficient reason for banning it in my mind: cyber warfare is real warfare. It is understood that the government is spying on users of social media (one of several reasons I don't use any either). It's embarrassing for them to admit it, and it undermines any other arguments they could try to make about it, though. If you are claiming a moral high ground, you can't just openly admit you're as bad as the other guy.
- pixelatedindex 3y agoHow do you spy on users of social media? Are we talking surreptitiously getting access to cameras/microphone or just getting data on user behavior? The former is obviously a major issue, but the latter can be obtained by anyone because tracking for ads is so ubiquitous and China can just pay to get it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dleeftink 3y agoQuite a few ways, whether through device/session fingerprinting [1], in-app browser keystroke tracking [2], frequent third-party post requests [3], individiual app usage patterns [4], geo-tracking [5], dark-patterned user onboarding [6] and continual facial recognition [7]. A canary blog series kicked off by the company itself is worth keeping an eye on to see the 'myths' they want to debunk most scrupously (such as keytracking)[8]. [1]: https://www.nullpt.rs/reverse-engineering-tiktok-vm-1 https://www.nullpt.rs/reverse-engineering-tiktok-vm-1 [2]: https://krausefx.com/blog/announcing-inappbrowsercom-see-what-javascript-commands-get-executed-in-an-in-app-browser https://krausefx.com/blog/announcing-inappbrowsercom-see-wha... [3]: https://app.urlgeni.us/blog/new-research-across-200-ios-apps-hints-surveillance-marketing-may-still-be-going-strong https://app.urlgeni.us/blog/new-research-across-200-ios-apps... [4]: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/05/business/media/tiktok-algorithm.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/05/business/media/tiktok-alg... [5]: https://www.afr.com/technology/tiktok-admits-collecting-location-data-20230309-p5cqo8 https://www.afr.com/technology/tiktok-admits-collecting-loca... [6]: https://au.reset.tech/uploads/resettechaustralia_policymemo_tiktok_final_online.pdf https://au.reset.tech/uploads/resettechaustralia_policymemo_... [7]: https://www.npr.org/2021/02/25/971460327/tiktok-to-pay-92-million-to-settle-class-action-suit-over-theft-of-personal-data https://www.npr.org/2021/02/25/971460327/tiktok-to-pay-92-mi... [8]: https://newsroom.tiktok.com/en-us/tiktok-truths-a-new-series-on-our-privacy-and-data-security-practices https://newsroom.tiktok.com/en-us/tiktok-truths-a-new-series...
- thefbi 3y agoI'll just ask a simple question, if you are an American citizen which governments uniformed thugs have the ability to kidnap or kill you: the American or Chinese government? Which of these does not even need to send secret agents or beat your country in a war and has free legal permission to kidnap and kill you? If you computed the results of this problem, the next question I ask is whom are you at more risk from?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agohttps://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/two-arrested-operating-illegal-overseas-police-station-chinese-government https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/two-arrested-operating-illega... > Two Arrested for Operating Illegal Overseas Police Station of the Chinese Government
- thefbi 3y agoAnd how many do your governments officially stamped thugs arrest? You don't even need to look up any stats to guess its in the ballpark of thousands or perhaps even the million per year. Edit: example stats for 2016 sourced from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incarceration_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incarceration_in_the_United_St... In 2016, there were an estimated 1.2 million violent crimes committed in the United States.[88] Over the course of that year, U.S. law enforcement agencies made approximately 10.7 million arrests, excluding arrests for traffic violations.[88] In that year, approximately 2.3 million people were incarcerated in jail or prison.[89]
- hedora 3y agoAlso, which steals more of your stuff, on average? This Washington Post article's title offers a clue: "Cops took more stuff from people than burglars did last year." https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/11/23/cops-took-more-stuff-from-people-than-burglars-did-last-year/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/11/23/cops-... The article is from 2015, but nothing's been done to reverse the trend. I wonder what they've gotten the ratio up to in the last eight years.
- nouveaux 3y agoI am against the US spying on its citizens. With that said, the US's ban on Tiktok is not a moral one. It's purely a competitive one. Why would we want our competitors to obtain more information on us?
- cooper_ganglia 3y agoI'm more worried what a foreign government would do with the private information of every US citizen, as opposed to what a domestic company would do. I'm still worried in both cases, but one of these situations seems much worse to me.
- yonaguska 3y agoA foreign government can't execute a no-knock raid on my home, can't garnish my wages, can't throw me in jail from outside of my country...etc. I know you used the wording "domestic company", but we are talking about governments here.
- vineyardmike 3y agoChina has shown to have an international police force to enact their will overseas. They probably won’t harm you, but they’re inching closer. I would also be vaguely worried about them sharing data with other companies in China that slowly influence commerce in America. I support the ban from a competitive perspective. Until meta can spy on Chinese citizens, why should the Chinese spy on Americans? Also I support it from a privacy perspective. We can’t as easily ban American companies from spying on us, but we should use any power to limit other companies from starting business spying on Americans. Make it less profitable globally.
- sitkack 3y agoThe FBI is also global. https://www.fbi.gov/contact-us/international-offices https://www.fbi.gov/contact-us/international-offices
- 3y ago
- yieldcrv 3y agothe list of similarities masqueraded as differences is pretty large one example: arbitrary seizure of private property? turns out that isn't just the domain of pretend communists, its a tenet of our society too
- mmcwilliams 3y agoIt's arguable that the public outcry about the risks of spying and the threats of state or country-wide bans on the service are exactly the kind of tactics that would be used to leverage this sort of access by the US.
- anonporridge 3y agoThere was never a public outcry. There was an elite outcry.
- msgilligan 3y agoThey can't do that to our pledges. Only we can do that to our pledges.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nonethewiser 3y agoMake no mistake - western governments are envious of the spying tools that China has. Our freedoms are in spite of central government and thanks to an independent judiciary and wise founders. Some like Trudeau have even explicitly expressed admiration for the flexibility of the Chinese dictatorship. FBI, CIA, etc. would never decline to use the types of tools that China has.
- bilbo0s 3y agoFBI, CIA, etc. would never decline to use the types of tools that China has. That's just the kind of overheated hyperbole derailing so many of our civic discussions nowadays. FBI and CIA have far more effective tools at their disposal. They'd nearly always decline to use the journeyman tools China has in its cyber arsenal.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Mavvie 3y agoThe actual quote: > There's a level of admiration I actually have for China. Their basic dictatorship is actually allowing them to turn their economy around on a dime. I don't think that's wrong? Although it is certainly in bad taste for a prime minister.
- nonethewiser 3y agoOf course that’s bad. You cant justify dictatorships with good intentions.
- Micrococonut 3y agoWhat about with good outcomes?
- FreshStart 3y ago
- imiric 3y agoA ban on TikTok is not about the US government caring about their citizens. It's about a political enemy having access to data the US government also wants access to. If it was about preserving privacy or any moral argument, they would also ban domestic social media. They have no reason to do this since they already have access to domestic data. A second reason might be to mitigate foreign influence and propaganda, but this is also rampant on domestic social media, and they apparently have no desire to prevent this either. This seems ludicrous to me, as these tools are the primary weapons of information warfare.
- miguelazo 3y agoIt's actually mostly about US tech companies (especially social media) being inferior in the market at this point. Most of the security concerns are actually just hyped up because Byte Dance ate their lunches.
- edgyquant 3y agoNo it isn’t and this is a Chinese talking point. All social media is a privacy nightmare, this one is a privacy nightmare controlled by a geopolitical adversary. This is common sense and no one can seriously pretend to not understand the difference.
- miguelazo 3y agoAh yes, must be a “Chinese talking point”. No sensible American could have come to that conclusion on their own. Thank you for illuminating us with your Serious analysis.
- toasted-subs 3y agoI can point out that as far as the result to our economy and health social media has been a dounle edged sword. I think people don't understand why you'd use and how to make it effective.
- afiori 3y agoBig brother does not like competition
- akira2501 3y ago> This undermines any moral authority The PATRIOT act does this by just existing and continually being extended. Room 641a. Julian Assange's case. Mortal authority left the building in the early 2000s.
- opo 3y agoThe PATRIOT act itself expired in March of 2020.
- Tommstein 3y agoTIL. Unfortunate timing for what would have otherwise been front-page headline news, if not for the entire world as we otherwise knew it coming to a sudden crashing end.
- akira2501 3y agoIt really didn't, though. Parts of it have already been reauthorized through different acts that are still in effect. Point is, we didn't have a referendum, we didn't bolster our laws to prevent such a thing from happening again, and zero investigations of abuses of power have credibly been done in it's wake. "Letting it expire" is not some accomplishment other than kicking the can further down the road.
- orangepurple 3y ago> You're not supposed to be worse than the country you say is spying on your citizens The state ran media calling actually peaceful american flag waving re-opening protestors terrorists and murderers for spreading COVID, then literally a matter of days later called the costliest riots in U.S history mostly peaceful protests that were incapable of spreading COVID. This was probably the sign that it was all over and we had entered the biological terrorism era.
- godelski 3y ago[dead]
- OJFord 3y agoI'm not American, but I'd sooner assume it's just different parts of government not talking to each other than such an organised concerted effort.
- HenryBemis 3y agoYou can freely assume that (also not American). I think they are toying with their citizens. It is better to think that the gov is incompetent than outright malicious (which is definitely the case). Gor some reason they NEVER drop the ball into giving more freedoms but they ALWAYS drop the ball on taking some away.
- vGPU 3y agoAs usual, US government accusations against other countries turned out to involve a hefty dose of projection and “if I can’t have it then nobody can”.
- HenryBemis 3y agoIsn't most of "surprising new vulnerabilities" NOBUS? (NObody BUt US) I didn't believe for a second that the MS Exchange vulnerability was not known & abused since forever. Now the Chinese have created what Zynga, Facebook, Pinterest, and the rest of the silicon valley failed to succeed. Get everyone meth-ed on an app. 150m Americans is nearly half the population. If you leave out the under 4 and the over 70, that's the majority of active population, having a homing beacon in their pocket reporting to China. This puts Room 641A to shame..
- vGPU 3y agoI’ve long had a suspicion that these vulnerabilities get discovered when china/russia/etc find them and start exploiting them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- toasted-subs 3y agoFeels like old mean people trying to get blackmail onto the next generation. A hard no from me. But it doesn't seem to make a difference what I say.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- fidotron 3y agoCan only think the feds regret not banning it long before anyone had heard of it. Suspect any new pretenders will not be so lucky. Edit to add: “and veto the hiring of any executive involved with leading TikTok US data security organization” - this is dangerously close to saying the quiet bit out loud.
- JimtheCoder 3y ago"Can only think the feds regret not banning it long before anyone had heard of it" But if no one has heard of it, then no one would be using it. Why would you ban something that no one is using...
- fidotron 3y agoBecause we follow a Rules Based Order and our Rules apply fairly to all market participants.
- JimtheCoder 3y agoAnd the rule that Tik Tok is clearly breaking is what? Being Chinese?
- fidotron 3y agoNot being owned by us. I wish this was merely a facetious response as opposed to the literal version of what the rule actually is.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Not being owned by us. We’d be fine if Bytedance were European, Australian, Japanese or even Indian. This is a problem with Russia and China, belligerent autocracies with whom our chances of near-term military confrontation is elevated.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago
- resuresu 3y ago[flagged]
- jwestbury 3y agoRecruiters mostly pitch me on "working for TikTok," because that's where the name recognition is. No doubt this is even more true for people reading Gizmodo.
- PreachSoup 3y agoThe title should be changed to the Feds asked a company in China to spy on American citizens
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoThe title should be changed to "Feds ask company to prove they are not lying again about CCP ties."
- Alex3917 3y agoSo basically this is another Joe Nacchio situation?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y ago> Examine TikTok’s U.S. facilities, records, equipment and servers with minimal or no notice, > Block changes to the app’s U.S. terms of service, moderation policies and privacy policy, > Veto the hiring of any executive involved in leading TikTok’s U.S. Data Security org, > Order TikTok and ByteDance to pay for and subject themselves to various audits, assessments and other reports on the security of TikTok’s U.S. functions, and, > In some circumstances, require ByteDance to temporarily stop TikTok from functioning in the United States. Knowing that TikTok keeps lying about CCP ties and data security this seems like a way to keep them honest? This doesn't list any domestic spying features.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoThe “agreement would let agencies examine TikTok’s US facilities, records, and servers.” That’s broad enough to warrant abuse of search privileges.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoHow else does one prove that TikTok is true to their word about data safety and separating their data from China? What makes you think that the ability to examine their facilities sidesteps the need for courts and warrants? I'm not buying the alarmist angle here.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> What makes you think that the ability to examine their facilities sidesteps the need for courts and warrants? Nothing sidesteps the legal need. But I’m seeing no evidence that these agreements contemplate any oversight. If the agent doing the examining decides to simultaneously look up an American’s TikTok account, nothing would stop them. (I agree the tone of this discussion is alarmist.)
- mrguyorama 3y ago>If the agent doing the examining decides to simultaneously look up an American’s TikTok account, nothing would stop them. And this is a concern because? They already have everything tiktok could give them. They shouldn't, but they do.
- electrondood 3y agoTikTok is brain cancer.
- accrual 3y agoTikTok has had nothing but positive effects for me. I mostly subscribe to intellectual content, positivity, and things that I feel improve my mental health. TikTok is what you make of it.
- infamouscow 3y agoSame. The TikTok algorithm did more to fix my mental health post-lockdown than multiple therapists or any other social media. Rather than being tuned for maximal negativity it seems ByteDance tuned the algorithm for maximal positivity.
- deprecative 3y agoThe algorithm is tuned for maximal engagement. It doesn't care if it's good or bad. It cares that you feed it all of your data and all of your friends and family's data. Yum yum.
- DrThunder 3y agoIt's positive in the same way eating a bunch of sugary donuts gives you a temporary short lasting dopamine boost. It's easily digestible with zero nutritional value. Rapid videos in succession short video formats that inject you with a quick dopamine hit are in fact NOT good for your mental health. This is why you see people continuously swipe for hours a day There are plenty of studies showing this. You're just rewiring your brain in a way that it'll want easily obtained dopamine with zero work. This leads to a rebound effect where you'll become bored quickly and depressed without it (similar to a recovering addict) It's not really "what you make of it".
- accrual 3y agoThat might be your experience but it's not mine. A have a lot of really excellent thoughtful content in my feed. I take notes and often save images (long press > save image) for future reference. If it had no value, I wouldn't be sitting here feeling like I've benefited from all the new perspectives I've received. The format doesn't dictate the content nor what one can get from it.
- brudgers 3y agoTo me, banning Tiktok smells like burning books. YMMV.
- redwall_hp 3y agoOr moral panics over Jazz, Rock, Dungeons & Dragons, whatever. People went from not knowing it existed to throwing fits after they found out that it's popular with socially progressive Gen Z-ers, and that a handful of teenagers screwed with a Donnie Dumbass rally via KPop spam. The emperor has no clothes until the US has an equivalent to the GDPR that legally enforces privacy practices for all companies, and all NSA surveillance is abolished. I'm all for preventing mass surveillance, actually doing it. But this is just a farce, and a culture war facet at that. It's just a vocal minority that's mad about people consuming media other than the conservative crack pipe.
- Capricorn2481 3y agoThere's plenty of conservative content on TikTok so I wouldn't paint it as some progressive paradise. That platform is mostly misinformation, and is playing a huge role in radicalizing people on the right
- deprecative 3y agoNobody is trying to ban short form video content. Y'all need to get better at your talking points.
- empath-nirvana 3y agoThe US would not be banning TikTok if it was run by a US company. It's not about the content.
- neilv 3y agoThe bulletpoints from the original Forbes reporting ("https://www.forbes.com/sites/emilybaker-white/2023/08/21/draft-tiktok-cfius-agreement/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/emilybaker-white/2023/08/21/dra...") look not like domestic spying, but more like close oversight of a party who isn't trusted but can't be shut down. With possible exception of this one: > * Examine TikTok’s U.S. facilities, records, equipment and servers with minimal or no notice, Such as if it includes arbitrary access to user data, or opportunity to modify the systems rather than only examine. Forbes included this interesting other bit, separate from its bulletpoint list, and I didn't see Gizmodo mention it: > It would also force TikTok U.S. to exclude ByteDance leaders from certain security-related decision making, and instead rely on an executive security committee that would operate in secrecy from ByteDance. BTW, why is Forbes calling this a "free speech platform"? Is that now accepted terminology, or is there some spin they're promoting? > Were it to be finalized, the agreement would provide the government near unfettered access to internal TikTok information and unprecedented control over essential functions that it does not have over any other major free speech platform. Is the explanation really as simple as: > Forbes (/fɔːrbz/) is an American business magazine founded in 1917 and owned by the Hong Kong-based investment group Integrated Whale Media Investments since 2014.[3][4] I'm inclined to think that the best defense against hypothetical threats from an app like this is a smart, critical-thinking, principled citizenry. But since Rupert Murdoch, and the culture that followed, have decimated that capability, maybe we need more help from government.
- nullifidian 3y agoWhat's the real threat of TikTok to the US? It should have nothing to do with spying since there isn't anything important that's submitted to the app(Who uses TikTok DMs?). If the app has a backdoor functionality or purposely made vulnerabilities and the feds are concerned by it, then it's a question to Google and their store's security/review policies/practices, and could be negated entirely by a mandate for TikTok to store all non-video traffic sent to the US users with a US based third party, in an unencrypted form. But it would be going overboard since in actuality it would be insane to for Chinese intelligence services to use TikTok to send exploits -- it could be easily detected and would be the casus belli for shattering the company, which is an 8 billion dollar business in the US. What the US establishment actually doesn't like is that TikTok wields a capability to influence the American public by amplifying certain topics and deranking others, also with their content policy. It's a capability that the US companies enjoy all across the world with few authoritarian exceptions, and even the EU doesn't get to review Facebook or Google's algorithms (there is an effort to force them to explain their algos (Digital Services Act), but as far as I know it's not even close to the intrusive search-like audits and vetos mentioned in this article), and smaller less influential countries/political entities can't even dream of forcing the FAANG to comply with their demands. So it's tremendously hypocritical for the US to rile up paranoia about "personal data" and "national security" especially considering the Snowden revelations. (Draconian)rules are for thee but not for me. Also the US companies' algorithms are probably protected by the first amendment, so I'm not even sure that this crack down on TikTok is even legal.
- vkou 3y ago> What's the real threat of TikTok to the US? It's the same threat that Hollywood and Jazz music had to the USSR and the same threat that Facebook and Reddit has to the CCP.
- nullifidian 3y agoTheoretically the first amendment forbids to go after this kind of "threat" then, since it would be like forbidding a citizen to read a foreign book.
- 3y ago
- bastardoperator 3y agoWhat are the feds going to do with all these cat meme videos?
- computing 3y agoBan it for reciprocal reasons. Either China allows FB, Google, Instagram, X, etc to operate there. Or we ban TikTok here. Countries already have unfair competition protections, this would fall under that.
- calvinmorrison 3y agoThe CIA and, by extension, the US government as a whole have never altered the outcome of elections anywhere for regime change, and have never instigated color revolutions for regime change.
- Transpire7487 3y agoOf course, spying on Americans is only bad when the scary CCP does it.
- tgv 3y agoThis arguments keeps popping up, but yes, it's not good when another country does it. You've got no say in it, and it can only be used for nefarious purposes. You've got no idea what your own government is using that info for, but you can be sure that the CCP is not going to prevent terrorism in your country. You also can't vote Xi out of office, can you? You can however vote the politicians that are responsible for domestic spying out of office, or try to press them into being transparent and implementing proper legislation through various means. Don't pretend the two are equal. The only thing equal between them is that you don't like either.
- Transpire7487 3y agoThe US intelligence community is responsible for more terrorism within America than any it may have prevented. You can't get rid of them through voting, the next president will just install another stooge and the cycle will continue. The FBI spied on Trump's campaign, he "cleaned house", Christopher Wray is just as bad as James Comey. It can't be fixed. Merrick Garland is just as bad as Bill Barr. It needs to be abolished.
- Ms-J 3y agoIt's a sick fact for both points. Also remember that Barr was first working for Central Intelligence and then became the US Attorney General. If that wasn't so sick I could at least laugh.
- tgv 3y agoSo your argument is: FBI bad, so the Chinese government should be allowed to spy. Ok then.
- Transpire7487 3y ago
- steno132 3y agoI'm not seeing any "spying" here. What the government is requesting is a audit capability, similar to what the FDA has for domestic food manufacturers. The FDA can inspect food plants, and if in the public interest, shut them down temporarily. Let me ask this, without this power how do you propose the government hold TikTok accountable for anything?
- advisedwang 3y agoThe agreement would give feds ability to "Examine TikTok’s U.S. facilities, records, equipment and servers", which no doubt includes user data. So it's not like being able to audit a food manufacturer. It would be like also having the ability to find out which consumer ate every bite of of the food, their reactions, what meals it was part of, where they ate it, who they shared their food with etc.
- kiawe_fire 3y agoSlowly but surely, I’m beginning to learn that whenever a US government agency has a problem with something, the problem isn’t that they are genuinely concerned about the thing they say they are, the problem is they aren’t the ones benefiting from it.
- air7 3y agoDo we know what/how TikTok is "spying"? I mean it is just an app running on a mobile device just like any other app. What data does it collect that the feds would like to get their hands on? Perhaps the ban should be on the ability of any app to collect this data in the first place?
- sitkack 3y agoLocation, FoaF graph, kinds of things people engage with. It isn't just for direct spying but getting access to cliques. If you know your targets cook likes special kind of porn, you now have leverage to get an APT installed on machine close to the target. People's defenses are down when the lower brain is motivated.
- psychphysic 3y agoWowza, it's clear Feds weren't interested in preventing spying so much as to start themselves.
- kornhole 3y agoThis is worse than the threats to Facebook and Twitter to revoke section 230. NATO and other Natsec employees penetrated TikTok long ago as reported by Alan Macleod. https://www.mintpressnews.com/?s=tiktok https://www.mintpressnews.com/?s=tiktok
- adultSwim 3y agoThe US situation with TikTok seems much closer to kneecapping the competition, like we did with Huawei, than protection.