6 ms·
> People are comfortable on the streets, they enjoy the freedom This is the significant distinction between providing crappy shelter and providing a home. A lo
by vidarh 3y ago
> People are comfortable on the streets, they enjoy the freedom
This is the significant distinction between providing crappy shelter and providing a home. A lot of shelter spaces come with a lot of strings, and the first step to fixing the issues is to accept that you need to cut many or most of the strings - if a significant proportion of homeless prefer homelessness to the help you're offering, perhaps the "help" isn't all that helpful.
If you want to get people off the street, you need to provide a similar level of freedom in the housing you provide as what it replaces.
> (3) People are naturally generous/irresponsible with belongings and income that they will spontaneously share the windfall with everyone they know. So your shelter for one man will end up being a flophouse for a rotating cast of shady types
Is it worse having them in a house than on the streets? And how much of a problem is this going to be when everyone involved have their own shelter? It's only a windfall if you provide it to a few rather than everyone who needs housing.
- thechao 3y agoMy rabbi used to say that "charity with strings is just a bad job"; it's not charity if it's not given unconditionally.
- throw9away6 3y agoIf the person you provide charity to uses it to inflict harm on themselves and others is it really charitable?
- thechao 3y agoThey’re a person, not a puppet. I think you might be surprised at how little a budget is required for someone to harm themselves; some say it’s free!
- nonethewiser 3y ago1) should actually be “some people just want to be homeless.” Including people who could already return to a nice, clean home, but do not. So that remains unexplained.
- dsr_ 3y agoA solution doesn't have to be perfect in order to be much better than the status quo ante.
- nerdponx 3y agoHowever it should at least allow us to prioritize. Someone who just doesn't want to get off the street should be lower priority than someone who doesn't want to be there and for whatever reason can't make it work.
- nostrebored 3y agoThe environment of shelters without drugs is exactly why they’re so appealing for the type of person they’re successful for. Most of these shelters have shockingly high success rates and shockingly low occupancy. Other than age limitations, I can’t think of any other real restrictions. Are we just talking about allowing drug use in shelters here?
- watwut 3y agoThe actual restrictions of real world shelters - you must leave the place in the morning and can go back only in the evening. You can not lock your things, so you have to be constantly on guard. You cant come after certain hour, meaning making quite a lot of low paid jobs impossible to even get. Also, cramped unsanitary or otherwise unsafe conditions, frequently making a good place on street (tent or old building) actually better. That is from top of head, when I last time looked into it.
- throw9away6 3y agoWhy is that restriction in place though? Most rules have a reason clearly the before state was unworkable
- watwut 3y agoIt can be as simple as availability of workers. Or the space not being suitable for 24/7 occupation. Shelters are not exactly rich institutions. Likewise, the cramped and unsanitary conditions are frequently result of "well that is what we can afford" situation. But also, a bit off topic, many real world rules do not have good reasons. Plenty of rules are arbitrary, just because someone had power to make them.
- throw9away6 3y agoIndividual rules can be a result of one freak occurrence but if many different shelters systematically converge on a similar set of rules then there must be a reason.
- slily 3y ago> If you want to get people off the street, you need to provide a similar level of freedom in the housing you provide as what it replaces. Having a home at all significantly restricts freedom. Let alone all the maintenance it requires. If it's an apartment is it too restrictive to their freedom? Should they be exempt from lease terms (no pets/no smoking/no drugs etc.)? Should they have a free housekeeper on top? At which point is it acceptable to expect some level of responsibility from an adult receiving so much in entitlements? I'd argue that an excess of no-strings-attached programs makes homelessness more attractive than hard work to people who are on the edge.
- nemo44x 3y agoIt’s the problem with righteous stances. They don’t actually consider the consequences of their demands. As if it hadn’t been considered by many before and they are the first people to see the light. Not only will the homes become dilapidated they’ll become a drug den immediately. The interiors will be unkept and stripped of useful components to flip for drugs.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoWhen the homeless in Finland are given a home, it is state housing. Someone who is more knowledgeable than me can tell you whether there are units that permit pets, but I suspect homeless in Finland are much less likely to keep a pet than in the USA. With regard to smoking, this has become rare in Finnish housing both public and private. People know they shouldn't even smoke on their balconies any more but find somewhere outside the building. Tobacco has gradually been taxed higher and higher to the point where much of the population feels it is unaffordable, and the state already has its sights on a complete tobacco ban in the coming years.
- engineer_22 3y agoIf the shelter becomes unsanitary it becomes a source of disease.
- bumby 3y ago>if a significant proportion of homeless prefer homelessness to the help you're offering, perhaps the "help" isn't all that helpful. If you want to get people off the street, you need to provide a similar level of freedom in the housing you provide as what it replaces. Can you elaborate on the the specific rules you’re referring to? That might help guide the discussion. Because at face value, there seems to be an issue where there isn’t an acknowledgment that with freedom comes responsibility. That responsibility looks an awful lot like rules that many people in these situations struggle to manage. It seems hard to argue for one without necessitating the other but maybe some specific examples could clarify your point.
- duped 3y agoA big one is drug/alcohol use. One of the understandings behind "housing first" policies is that when you treat chronic homelessness as a public health problem, you need to attack the big symptoms first (being unhoused) before you can see the outcomes you want (being a productive member of society). Housing isn't a reward, it's a basic human need. And it's the baseline for treating people - because you cannot treat people if you cannot find them.
- bumby 3y agoDon’t you think it makes sense to attack the root problem (addiction) as well as the “big symptoms”? Wouldn’t that look like a rule to be in a treatment program or be otherwise clean? I can get on board with housing being a basic human need that society helps supply. But that’s subtly different than the OP’s claim of housing with virtually the same freedom from rules. I’m not sure “unfettered housing” is a human right.
- toddmorey 3y agoWell don’t frame it as a right, think in terms of desired outcome. If a user relapses, does removing their housing help in recovery?
- 3y ago
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThose strings are for the safety and even comfort of other people who use the shelter. Let’s put it this way, one reason often used by unhoused why they avoid shelters is because they don’t feel safe around the other people in the shelters, especially the addicts. So you have strings, because even addicts don’t want to be in a shelter with other addicts. Yes, it excludes, but not having the strings also excludes. You cut most of those strings, you lose even more people who are willing to use those shelters. This is why tiny homes are touted as solutions (you get private space that isn’t shared), but even in that case they try to form stable communities by again, applying strings (having a neighbor burn down their house in the middle of the night affects other residents of the community).
- throw9away6 3y agoIf you don’t have strings attached you end up with tiny brothels, tiny drug dens and tiny Arms depots. So you still have to have rules and enforcement.
- vidarh 3y agoIf you leave people on the streets, do you imagine none of these things happen?
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoA lot of activities are hard to do in a tent. And it’s not really binary, yes they will happen, no they won’t happen as much. Recently a few people were murdered at a squatted property near where I live that the police left alone for far too long. Things just get out of hand too quickly at a property taken over by addicts (regardless of their housing status), and yes, that still happens in tents on the street, just to a lesser degree (although we did have a fight for drug turf recently at one encampment that involved IEDs, so maybe that’s changing?).
- marniewebb 3y agoI’m currently involved in a project to develop a tech intervention to support outreach workers in providing emergency shelter to unhoused individuals[1]. Part of the goal is to get data on why people don’t accept available shelter and how to address those blockers by creating more shelter spaces that meet more people’s needs. We know we will see the ability to keep companion animals, safe storage for personal items, and the ability to stay with family members as reasons people don’t take shelter. It’s easy to empathize with that. If I were a woman on the street with my mid-sized dog (companionship and protection) with all the possessions I had left (after months at least of hard decisions about what I couldn’t take) and a 13-year-old son (we are likely to get separated in shelter placement) I would be resistant to most of the options available to me. And that doesn’t even begin to address what led me to the streets in the first place (job loss, family support system loss, domestic violence, health expenses). This is my opinion, but based on some observational experience, the only people for whom living on the streets is “easier” are those who are young, healthy, and have a family support system to return to. This recent article in the Guardian provides a good overview: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/aug/17/san-diego-arrest-unhoused-homeless-crisis https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/aug/17/san-diego-ar... [1] https://insider.govtech.com/california/news/san-diego-county-oks-300k-housing-app-for-homeless https://insider.govtech.com/california/news/san-diego-county...
- Dma54rhs 3y agoThe social housing in Finland Congress with strings as well, anti social behavior is not tolerated.
- vidarh 3y agoWhich will be an issue in convincing those who wants to engage in those behaviors to take up the offers. So what? You address what you can, and start by treating them as you would others. We're not talking about letting them get away with more, but about not treating them as second class people with restrictions no non-homeless people would put up with.