6 ms·
It’s time for Americans to embrace small cars
- lockhouse 3y agoDoes anyone make a small car that safely seats 6 people with adequate storage space for doing a week worth of grocery shopping or luggage for a weekend trip?
- caycep 3y agonot a small car, but time to bring back the wagon!!!!
- santafen 3y agoI'm 100% here for station wagons!
- codevark 3y ago[dead]
- ecshafer 3y agoStation wagons used to fit that requirement.
- JohnFen 3y agoMaybe not, but most people don't have those requirements, and people who don't should drive a smaller car.
- tibbydudeza 3y agoI drive a 2017 VW Polo - just did my month-end shopping for a family of 3 today and in the rear I had 3 water cooler bottles to be refilled. It is indeed possible - just shop or pack more efficiently :).
- barbazoo 3y agoWhen I hear "VW Polo" I immediately think of this one: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c4/Volkswagen_Polo_Harlekin_in_Germany.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c4/Volkswag... Now they look so grown up, pretty much like a Golf.
- tibbydudeza 3y agoThe original Polo was made by their Spanish arm called SEAT - VW then took the model line further to slot in below the Golf when that became bigger and more expensive. The new Polo (2018-) is now the size the Golf 5/6 was circa 2009 and thus is priced accordingly. Their solution for our car market is to still produce the 2017 model and rebrand it as the Polo Vivo.
- barbazoo 3y agoThe average family size is 3.13 in the US btw so most families could probably make due with a smaller car that doesn't fit 6. https://www.statista.com/statistics/183657/average-size-of-a-family-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/183657/average-size-of-a... Doing a grocery shop with the entire family of 6 sounds stressful btw :)
- zip1234 3y agoMost cars also have racks on top for when additional storage is needed for a weekend trip. A subaru with car top carrier is a fairly common sight.
- helaoban 3y agoDo large families only exist in the U.S? Why is this not an issue for people in any other country? The explosion in vehicle size over the last 10 years in U.S is off-the-scale absurd, while per-capita fatal crashes have only gone UP over the same period[1]. 1. https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/yearly-snapshot https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/yearl... EDIT: You wouldn't believe how many GMC Yukons I see in my wealthy SF suburb that are used to shuffle 8 year-olds from school to soccer practice. For the uninitiated: https://www.carsized.com/en/cars/compare/ford-focus-2013-5-door-hatchback-rs-vs-gmc-yukon-2020-suv-lwb/ https://www.carsized.com/en/cars/compare/ford-focus-2013-5-d...
- lockhouse 3y agoI fail to see a reason to buy a car that would be suboptimal for my personal situation.
- helaoban 3y ago"I fail to see a reason to eat a serving that would be sub-optimal for my personal situation", said the 600-pound man before digging into a meal of 50 flapjacks and a Big Gulp.
- noelwelsh 3y agoHave you ever noticed there are other people where you live? And that they have different personal situations?
- lockhouse 3y agoSo if they don’t need a larger car they shouldn’t have them? Small cars are available, even in the US, but most people aren’t interested in buying them. There are lots of reasons for that. Unless you plan to get draconian about it, people would need a reason to favor small cars.
- noelwelsh 3y ago
- tekla 3y agoAmerica is the only place I've ever heard of where the ability to haul a week of groceries at a time is a requirement. I wonder how 6 billion other people manage to eat.
- lockhouse 3y agoIn many parts of rural America it’s not feasible to buy groceries and other supplies a day at a time. The stores are too far away to drive to that frequently. Plus it would defeat the purpose of a smaller car as more energy would be required overall.
- ericmay 3y agoI think that’s a good point, and one we should acknowledge as we stop designing our cities, roads, and transportation systems to cater only to this small number of rural people.
- FuriouslyAdrift 3y ago20% of the US is rural and that number has been increasing the last few years. That's about 70 million people.
- undersuit 3y agoThat definition of rural where the 20% comes from isn't countryside. https://www.hrsa.gov/rural-health/about-us/what-is-rural https://www.hrsa.gov/rural-health/about-us/what-is-rural "Micro area (urban core of 10,000-49,9999 people)" I apparently live in a rural area, Helena, MT. The state capital by the way. You can look up if you are the 20% Rural or 80% Urban here: https://data.hrsa.gov/tools/rural-health https://data.hrsa.gov/tools/rural-health I say all this because I walk to the grocery store and bike to work. In a rural area no less!
- ericmay 3y agoThanks, and also 70 million is still a much smaller number than 262 million which would be the remaining population (continuing to use broad number as the OP did) and so the point still stands based on that alone.
- noelwelsh 3y agoIt's incredible how everytime anything car / transportation related comes up on HN there is always an objection the boils down to "but that won't fit my niche use case!!1!"
- NeoTar 3y agoDoes anyone make any car which satisfies those requirements? I believe you may be looking for a mini-bus.
- nonameiguess 3y agoI don't know what counts as a "small" car here, but I drive a sport SUV because I don't need the storage or seating capacity of a full size, but I do at least need enough space to fit myself. I'm not huge, about 6'2.5" 180 lbs, but I have to find a sedan I can drive without hitting my head on the ceiling and feeling like my field of view is seriously impeded. If someone made something in-between, that doesn't need to be large overall but at least large enough in the space for the driver to acknowledge we're not all midgets, I'd gladly buy that. It's the same way with airline seating. Granting I'm a little bit of a special case because I'm missing two discs and have ten screws in my spine, but I find myself only flying first class not because I'm wealthy but because if I fly economy, I won't be able to stand up straight for three hours after the flight lands. If they sold something in-between, like say, economy seats as they existed 30 years ago, I'd gladly use that, too.
- santafen 3y agoHow often do people take a family of six grocery shopping? On vacation, sure, but that's an entirely different use model.
- lockhouse 3y agoWe do at least once a week, which why we own a minivan and not a small car.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ROTMetro 3y agoMy little hatch can do that for 5 people. And it's actually sporty and fun to drive unlike a truck.
- Mordisquitos 3y agoYes. Ford, for example: https://www.carsized.com/en/cars/compare/ford-galaxy-2015-minivan-vs-ford-f150-2017-4-door-pickup-supercrew-5.5-raptor/ https://www.carsized.com/en/cars/compare/ford-galaxy-2015-mi...
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThey don't sell those in North America. You used to be able to get a similar sized Mazda 5, but they recently stopped selling those too.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoRather than 6 people AND cargo, our requirement is 6 people OR 4 people + cargo. Kind of an annoying requirement. A tiny hatchback will do 5 people OR 2 people + cargo, so it's close but not quite. 5 people + cargo is also well served and seems to be the sweet spot but those vehicles don't have a way to accomodate 6. We have an old Mazda 5 micro-van that hits our requirements, but they no longer sell that in North America. So we either have to get something considerably larger or compromise.
- bradleyjg 3y agoWith six people plus a week’s worth of groceries for six, forget small cars—-there aren’t that many vehicles period. I’d think expanded length sport utility vehicles (e.g. Chevy Suburban) is going to be about it.
- Racing0461 3y agoSure, end the chicken tax that prevents things like the Toyota hilux from being imported.
- bad_alloc 3y agoA Hilux is 5.3m x 1.9m... how is that a small car?
- switch007 3y agoTrue but compared to eg an F150 the Hilux is 55cm shorter in length, 17cm narrower, and 10cm shorter in height. And about 900kg lighter.
- barbazoo 3y agoI don't get how blaming the government for one's individual car choice helps.
- ok123456 3y agoGovernments can pick winners and losers through the tax code and through tariffs. They made importing smaller trucks cost prohibitive in this case.
- flyingfences 3y agoIt's not an "individual choice" when the options are entirely unavailable due to regulatory discrimination.
- exolymph 3y agoThe government affects which vehicles are available for purchase.
- undersuit 3y agoI pretty sure you can buy any vehicle you want you just are going to have serious roadblocks getting it registered and legal in the US for driving on government roads.
- codevark 3y ago[dead]
- vinyl7 3y agoCars are huge because MPG regulations get easier as cars get larger. I'd say repeal/rework the MPG regulations, but that's a California law so the rest of the country doesn't get a say.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoIn that case, the federal government could pass a law saying that states are not permitted to regulate the MPG on vehicles in any way.
- JohnFen 3y agoAs I understand it (and I could be wrong), states can make regulations about MPG that are more restrictive than the feds, but not less. If my understanding is correct, then it makes little sense to prevent states from doing so as the feds could address this issue regardless.
- jdminhbg 3y agoThe rest of the country could get a say, if Congress wants to exercise its interstate commerce powers. Here is an effort to do the same on California's agricultural regulations: https://www.asas.org/taking-stock/blog-post/taking-stock/2023/06/29/interpretive-summary-the-eats-act-is-introduced https://www.asas.org/taking-stock/blog-post/taking-stock/202...
- Tempest1981 3y agoAnd because US gas prices are tolerable
- phendrenad2 3y agoDoes the RAV4 count as a "small car"? What about a Toyota Corolla? Because those are the two best-selling cars outside of the desert states (source: https://www.edmunds.com/most-popular-cars/ https://www.edmunds.com/most-popular-cars/ ).
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Does the RAV4 count as a "small car"? Its a small SUV, but not a small car.
- saltcured 3y agoIt still blows my mind that a RAV4 is considered a "compact SUV". To me it is quite large. It is just that what is considered a "large SUV" is what I think of as "schoolbus size"...
- switch007 3y agoI think "small" is either compact or smaller. Corolla is a compact - I'd consider it "small" especially in the US market In the UK, Compact is considered slightly more towards 'family' sized, and we have a lot more subcompacts and minis,
- tetromino_ 3y ago> Does the RAV4 count as a "small car"? The 1990s RAV4 was small. The current one is almost 18 inches longer and 6.5 inches wider.
- notnmeyer 3y agopretty much impossible as long as huge vehicles are sold. it sucks to drive a tiny car surrounded by much larger suvs and trucks. it feels like you’re driving a go-cart and is hard to be seen.
- AequitasOmnibus 3y agoForget small cars, Americans should embrace (and demand more) public transit. Switching everyone to small cars is putting a bandaid on a gaping open wound.
- NeoTar 3y ago"A developed country is not a place where the poor have cars. It's where the rich use public transportation." -- Gustavo Petro
- Dig1t 3y agoI have no desire to do such a thing. Being harassed by mentally ill people on the subway is not something I want to subject myself and my family to. If you've ever tried riding a bus or the train in LA or San Francisco, you'll know what I'm talking about. It can be a scary experience.
- switch007 3y agoIf you've ever taken a bus or train in ... most places in Europe...you'll know it's not a law that public transport = dangerous and full of meth heads. Public transport _can_ be good if you have a society that treats its poor well and highly respects and desires clean and good public transport and is willing to fund it.
- AequitasOmnibus 3y agoI lived in LA for almost a decade (leaving in 2020) and, despite hearing these horror stories, never once had that experience. And I rode the light rail at least 3-4 days/week. Instead what I saw was a largely unused public transit system that passed by hundreds of thousands of cars sitting in traffic on the 10 and 101. During that same time period I used to commute to SF for work 1 week per month and used BART and public transit almost exclusively. Also never had that experience. In both, I definitely SAW homeless people, some of whom were likely mentally ill, but seeing them and being harassed by them are totally different things. The latter is mainly fiction. By contrast, I’ve been harassed (at gunpoint) by middle-class “sane” drivers in a bout of road rage.
- 3y ago
- corbet 3y agoDunno why they had to go on about the "obsession with range" - range is not a function of smallness; indeed, smallness helps in that regard. We have a Chevy Bolt in the Colorado front range area...it's nominal 238-mile range (increased a bit after the battery recall) is good enough for almost everything, but I certainly wouldn't want it to be less than that. As-is, that range makes it risky to use that car to visit family in Wyoming. I don't think we are wrong to pay attention to range.
- MengerSponge 3y agoI just wish the Bolt supported faster charging!
- chrisBob 3y agoI love the idea of cars vs trucks, and tried to spend my money accordingly recently. My newest vehicle is a Hyundai IONIQ 6 which is a 4 door sedan, and is certainly better in a vehicle-pedestrian or vehicle-bike accident than most other vehicles on the road. The problem is that, as a nice electric car, it is heavy. At 4500 lbs it is probably within a few pounds of our Honda Ridgeline (pickup truck). I could not figure out how to get around the weight problem and still get an AWD vehicle.
- soco 3y agoBut why is weight a topic at all? Are you taxed by weight? At bridge crossings or ferries? I assume you don't carry it yourself...
- dylan604 3y agostop thinking about weight like that. think of weight as mass in physics sense like F=ma. the higher the mass, the more force/energy at play in terms of collisions. the more mass, the higher the energy to +/- the acceleration parts of those equations.
- nayuki 3y agoMore weight directly translates into more energy (gasoline or electricity) to move the car.
- Brian_K_White 3y agoWeight carries many penalties. If anything it should cost more but doesn't. More weight costs more energy overhead to move whatever your actual payload is, so although electric motors may be more efficient than gas, it's still true that with batteries you have to accelerate and decelerate a lot more mass in addition to the payload (merely yourself many times). That is overhead. Regenerative braking and collecting energy on the downhill make enough difference that they are worth doing, but still don't come close to erasing what it cost to get going or go up the hill. Weight increases road wear. A lot. Weight is harder to stop or steer in an emergency. EVs are highly computerized and so they have excellent traction control which hides this problem in normal conditions, especially when comparing any EV to any older car with only basic or even no traction control. But put two vehicles with the same traction control including the fine conrol afforded by the electric motors, in the same situation, but one merely weighs more, and the heavier one will do worse. And "emergency situation" is really all day every day driving multiplied by millions. Weight increases tire wear. So much so that now tire rubber in the environment is a thing. Weight increases the wear on all mechanical parts, most apparent in brakes and engine, but in an EV those are both so much better than an ICE that the effect of weight is masked, but it's still there and actually applies to almost all parts of the vehicle. You don't see it individually but it's there worsening the overall stats on repairs and lifespans. It's like the energy overhead. It's just there making everything work harder, and that costs more of essentially every resource, not just energy but wear & tear, manufacturing, engineering, materials, and performance. "performance" doesn't mean boy racer stuff, I just mean performance of it's job. If a bearing needs to support more weight, it either needs to be made bigger, or made better, or made out of better stuff, or fail sooner, or a bit of all of those. It's a systemwide overhead like with the energy. "Mere" weight is not free, even though it's on wheels.
- theamk 3y ago> I'd like more people to buy smaller vehicles, but I'd also like more people to take public transport instead of driving It seems that easy car rental could be the solution to both: use public transport / small car for day to day needs, rent a bigger car when you need to go with friends/extended family somewhere. And yet it is only getting worse: in the recent years, it seems that Zipcar has very few cars available and a long queue; and no car rental agency in my area offers 6 or 7 seat cars. I wonder if this is a business decision because of lack of customers or some sort of government regulations thing?
- botanical 3y agoHow deadly American trucks are to children is something I recently learnt: American cars have dangerous front blind zones that it took 13 kids in a line for an SUV driver to spot them: https://youtu.be/NDH3FDfVQl0 https://youtu.be/NDH3FDfVQl0) Also: https://kmph.com/resources/media/08519543-f29c-43be-8ea2-c4f313a5a287-jumbo21x9_kids.PNG?1545288120151 https://kmph.com/resources/media/08519543-f29c-43be-8ea2-c4f...
- hgsgm 3y agoWhy don't the trucks have sensors?
- dragonwriter 3y agoOften, now, they do. But older trucks and SUVs are on the road still.
- switch007 3y ago10 kids is a price the SUV drivers are willing to pay ! Imagine if the car manufacturers being forced to display that pic on their brochures or as as a decal on the side of the SUV in the showroom
- foobarian 3y ago> Compared to the herculean task of building supply chains to sustain a broad domestic EV market, tackling this problem from the demand side almost seems easy. Proving that EVs can road trip may have been an important psychological hurdle for the technology to tackle, but it remains more psychological than real: the average American motorist drives about 40 miles per day and 95 percent of our car trips are 30 miles or shorter. I keep shaking my head at how people keep downplaying the range problem and explaining it away with average-based arguments. It's not psychological, and if people wanted the small cars the market would show it. This just reads like moralizing.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoHow would you explain it better? I've done 4 1900 mile road trips in an EV, and have found that a 250 mile range would be sufficient. We stopped for bathroom breaks, food, sleep, etc. more often and longer than was necessary to charge the car.
- foobarian 3y agoAnecdotally, in my wider circle of people I interact with either online or at work/family/neighbors etc. and talked about this with at least half would not be served by the current charging infrastructure and charging UX, including myself. This is maybe a small sample size but I am very skeptical that this ratio would be much smaller at large. This is why when people come in saying that "250 miles is fine" and "we were going to be in the bathroom and restaurant for an hour anyway" it comes off as moralizing. It would be much more honest to just acknowledge the above and then state that for the good of the planet the more wasteful of us should adapt and maybe not demand dense 5-minute refuels, be more mindful planning roadtrips, work on supporting charging infra rollout, etc.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoI've had those conversations. But when you dig further into those reasons the justifications often don't hold up. They'll say "I can't get an EV because I need to be able to drive from X to Y". So I punch that route into abetterrouteplanner, and >50% of the time the route is quite feasible on a 250 mile EV. If you've tried that and it doesn't work for you, fine. But many haven't.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jpm_sd 3y agoI have three kids, and sometimes drive the carpool for swimming or hockey. So we have one minivan and one Nissan Leaf. The small car is the day-to-day car and the minivan is the expedition/carpool car. Works great for us. I have no idea why everyone else buys SUVs.
- Brendinooo 3y agoWhile I'm inclined to agree, the incentives have just never been right. Take something like the Honda Fit - its price point meant that you could spend something like a thousand more and get a Civic. In order to go with the Fit, you either needed that small margin to matter a lot, or you just really had to want a cheaper car. Economies of scale don't work here because of the chicken-and-egg problem, and possibly because size simply isn't as big of a driver of cost as labor and mandatory features. And you never really pay a non-monetary price for having a larger vehicle. We have a minivan and I never hit height maxes, never feel like it's too big to drive anywhere (except for Manhattan, haha). Cheap interest and long terms probably shrunk the cost difference quite a bit too. Safety of the passengers will be a battle you have to fight, particularly for people who spend significant time on the interstate.
- hgsgm 3y agoCivic burns more gas and is a little harder to manipulate into small spaces.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoThe civic was only a little more thirsty than the fit when it was here in the US. It also has significantly higher performance (~7s 0-60 vs 9s for the fit). Acceleration doesn't matter much in the city but being able to safely complete a pass on a two lane road is a major concern for a lot of america. Overall, for a few thousand more, the civic is just simply a nicer car. If you went with the fit, you made significant sacrifices for those 'magic seats'
- Brendinooo 3y agoBeen awhile since I was fresh on the numbers, but a quick search says in 2020 the Fit got 33/40 MPG and the Civic got 32/42? Definitely not enough to move the needle for most prospective buyers. Maybe it's different in Europe, dunno if it's a supply or demand thing but the US market notoriously does not offer the weaker, more fuel efficient motors. I just looked it up the other day; the Camry offers motors under 170HP for some markets but nothing under 200 in the US.
- ok123456 3y agoMake regular sedans exempt from CAFE, and make SUVs and non-work trucks follow them. Add absolute limits to fix the loopholes that were introduced EPA guidelines under Obama that resulted in vehicles getting larger and larger. There's no reason to make every little passenger sedan engine turbocharged, with GDI fuel injection, with cylinder deactivation, and with auto-stop just so they can sell more behemoths.
- aapl88889 3y agoLarger cars are due to fuel economy regulations. You can thank your government for this.
- zwieback 3y agoSure, politics plays into it but if you live anywhere in the US outside of inner city a large car is very practical and people want what they want. Also, Americans are willing to spend a lot of their disposable income on cars. Until we pass restrictive laws to force people to buy smaller cars they will not. Even high gas prices had a limited effect on consumer behavior. The sad part for people like me who would like a nice smaller car, perhaps an EV, is the very limited selection.
- mmcgaha 3y agoWhy We Can't Have Small Trucks Anymore - Blame the EPA https://youtu.be/azI3nqrHEXM https://youtu.be/azI3nqrHEXM
- undersuit 3y agoNo. I'm going to blame the manufacturers. We can have small trucks, American manufacturers refuse to release them. It's not like they can't do anything about the highly profitable situation they lobbied themself into.
- flashgordon 3y agoI am really not a car person (just need to get from a to b). But as I see large families (3+ kids may be?) minivans and SUVs start to look pretty appealing. Is there a way to address them while not fetishizing size alone? Now large families may not be the norm but Id worry about laws/tariffs penalizing them, no? For example, to address the front blind spot issue would mandating extra radars and front cameras (and the ensuing cost) be ok? Yes it is still penalizing large families but they may at least be getting a safety feature?
- StockHuman 3y agoThankfully minivans and station wagons do not suffer the same enormous blind spot problem the modern American truck is presently facing. That, and the standard five-seat arrangement can accommodate both parents and three kids, which is already a rare degree of occupancy. If you’re committed to 7+ seater vehicles after birthing a platoon I think the financial penalties of that decision were already understood at child number 4.
- undersuit 3y agoMinivans aren't a problem. Part of the "mini" of the van comes from the manufacture. A van is built off a "truck platform", a minivan is built off a "car platform".
- paulrpotts 3y agoFather of eight kids here. I wouldn't really speak of SUVs and minivans in the same breath. SUVs really aren't very suitable for transporting a bunch of kids. They generally don't have extra side doors so kids will have to climb over seats. And despite being so huge, they often hold a shockingly small amount of cargo, unless you add a cumbersome cargo container to the roof rack. We had a Tahoe with a painfully small third row seat and could not even bring a whole load of groceries home in the space remaining in back. It was not possible to use it for camping unless we brought a second car (a Honda Element) to actually hold the stuff. Older minivans like the (now radically redesigned) Dodge Grand Caravan were far better and had far better visibility. I have really not kept up with current minivans - a lot of the models which would hold more passengers have disappeared - but I do think they are designed with better safety features, not to mention better mileage. It's easy to say "just get a Sprinter," but they are shockingly expensive even on the used market.
- turtlebits 3y agoIMO, the problem is price. The price difference for a small car is almost not worth the tradeoff, utility-wise. We need small city cars that cost < $10k.
- xnx 3y agoSounds good, but I'm not interested in unilateral disarmament against monster sized vehicles and drivers being ever more distracted.
- simonblack 3y agoThat won't happen until Americans can get past the 'Bigger is Better' mindset. In most of the world, small nippy sporty cars are more desirable than lumbering 'Yank Tanks'. That's the difference between https://carsales.pxcrush.net/carsales//cars/private/at3q087e4n6p1963palbsj68t.jpg?pxc_method=limitfill&pxc_bgtype=self&pxc_size=720,360 https://carsales.pxcrush.net/carsales//cars/private/at3q087e... and this https://www.speednik.com/files/2023/04/that-was-then-this-is-now-the-pontiac-gto-2023-04-12_10-38-10_365891-1440x888.jpeg https://www.speednik.com/files/2023/04/that-was-then-this-is...
- friend_and_foe 3y agoAn article about this topic that doesn't address the fact that emissions standards on small cars are prohibitively high, which is why they just make them bigger, is not worth reading.
- joker_minmax 3y agoBeyond time. The parking spaces are not designed for your freaking Hummvee. Everyone wants me to get rid of my small 2007 sedan but the same make and model car today is much larger. I can park anywhere and I will give this up when the car absolutely dies for good.