15 ms·
ISPs complain that listing every fee is too hard, urge FCC to scrap new rule
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Terr_ 3y ago> ISPs object to a portion of the FCC order that says, "providers must list all recurring monthly fees" including "all charges that providers impose at their discretion, i.e., charges not mandated by a government." The five trade groups complain that this would require ISPs "to display the pass-through of fees imposed by federal, state, or local government agencies on the consumer broadband label." OK, so their problem is solely with pass-through 1:1 fees from local governments, and the ISPs totally agree that there's no problem showing their own fees that aren't one-to-one pass-through amounts, right?... Riiiight? > Comcast said the non-mandatory fees also include pass-through of state and local government fees. Sounds like they're choosing to mix fees [are / aren't] their fault together, and then whining that it's "unfair" to make them list any of them.
- phendrenad2 3y agoNo, because this article is only focusing on one objection here. You'll have to do some googling.
- nonethewiser 3y agoThey should want to show pass through fees. I had no idea there were any.
- whaleofatw2022 3y ago"Local government fees" are often fees the provider pays for a certain level of exclusivity... They don't want you to see the recurring bribes to the local politicians...
- danuker 3y agoAh! Listing it is too hard, but charging it isn't.
- Volundr 3y agoI'd bet internally their accounting is indeed reporting on these separate fees with great accuracy.
- mkl95 3y agoTo be fair, having a solid finance department and a shoddy-everything-else is a pretty common pattern.
- eli 3y agoSounds like they need to update their systems. But don't worry, they can just add a Fee Reporting Recovery Fee to recoup the cost from customers.
- sterwill 3y agoGoogle Fiber gets this right. They say my Internet package will cost $70 and every month the total I get charged is $70.
- Cerium 3y agoATT and Sonic fiber too. Both listed a price and charged it (90 and 50 respectfully).
- bsimpson 3y agoAlso MonkeyBrains in SF: they charge $105 every 3 months.
- delvinj 3y agoSame with US Internet in Minneapolis. I couldn't be more pleased with the service, coming off of 15 years with Comcast.
- jvanderbot 3y agoWhat kind of speed do you get? is this municipal wifi?
- remexre 3y agoI'm a happy customer until the end of the month (moving out of their service area, sadly); I had symmetric gigabit. No IPv6, though.
- jvanderbot 3y agoI live in the area, and loved Centurylink for this reason (symmetric gigabit, extremely low latency), but am stuck with Xfinity.
- tzs 3y agoThat's how Comcast works here in western Washington. If you have non-internet service from them (such as TV, phone, or home security) there are plenty of fees on your bill which makes it more than the advertised price of your package, but if you just have internet the bill matches the advertised price.
- mkl95 3y agoIn my country, everything seems to be too hard for ISPs. Imho governments should impose some SLAs and force them to disclose their hidden fees. I honestly believe ISPs and their leaders are not just evil but stupid enough that they cannot improve on their own.
- spicybright 3y agoNot stupid. They just know they don't have to improve on their own because it costs money with no returns.
- NickC25 3y agoIf they can charge for the fee, they should be by law mandated to tell me what it's for, and where it's going. Sick of these TelCos getting billions in subsidies, not spending it on infrastructure as promised (somehow they are allowed to act as a for-profit corporation!?), lobbying to get more taxpayer money, and then whining when we find out that half the fees on the bills they send out are just to pad profits. Greedy bastards, the lot of them. Time to cut the crap and just regulate them as utilities.
- germinalphrase 3y agoRemoving laws that enforce non-competition by municipalities would be a fine start.
- NickC25 3y agoBanning them from lobbying would also be a welcome change. How can a utility with a monopoly on services be allowed to buy favorable laws in government?
- mulmen 3y agoYou can't ban lobbying in a representative democracy.
- spicebox 3y agoYes you can, even if you don’t want to restrict lobbying on free speech ground you can place donation caps and increase transparency requirements which would both limit the power of corporate lobbying
- TylerE 3y agoThey'll just add another layer of rat finkery on top, making the whole mess EVEN LESS transparent. PACs were limited lobbying. That wasn't good enough...so we got super PACs with virtually no oversight what-so-ever.
- TuringNYC 3y agoMy favorite thing is when Telcos say they cannot tell you how much their plan will cost when you sign the contract, but magically, they are able to figure it out when you get your first bill.
- throitallaway 3y agoThis is why I like (for cell plans) prepaid carriers. Their prices are all-inclusive.
- Terr_ 3y agoYeah, I recently switched service and prepaid a full year. Not just fewer surprises, but often cheaper. I still live in a kind of dismayed disbelief at how much money the major cell-phone carriers want for plans they consider normal/budget. This seems to be because they include what is (to me) a crazy amount of cellular data, amounts I'll never use because I don't stream full-length movies on the bus or whatever. For context, a major local network's "essentials" plan costs $60/month for 50GB of "premium" mobile data and unlimited not-so-premium data. In contrast, a reseller's prepaid plan (on the same infrastructure) comes out to $15/month for 5GB (5G speeds) and a 4gb trickle (LTE) after that. Since I'm always near Wi-Fi and almost never exceed 2GB/month, it's a no-brainer.
- Shank 3y agoThe biggest issue with being on an MVNO is that your data priority is below all other customers. It’s not even that bad most of the time, but if you go to a congested area like a concert you’ll definitely feel the speed decrease.
- fuomag9 3y agoMeanwhile here in Italy rechargeable sims have 10 euros per month plans with unlimited data (which is actually ~1TB but it's not advertised since it's more of a fair use thing) or very high caps (150-200GB)
- nonethewiser 3y ago
- thomas-st 3y agoA while ago I was helping a friend pick a cell phone plan with T-Mobile USA. If you study their plans, the "Essentials" plan does not include "taxes and fees", but their "Magenta" plan does. When contacting T-Mobile, they could not tell me what the fees were even after providing the specific ZIP code. They said I would have to sign up for the plan first, and could then see the fees on the bill. Even when I told them that the choice of plan would depend on the amount of taxes and fees, they were not able to tell me and said that I could look at the current cell phone bill with the current carrier, and that the taxes and fees should be similar. It is crazy they can't tell you how much you'll be paying before signing up.
- Terr_ 3y ago> It is crazy they can't tell you how much you'll be paying before signing up. Even further along the dystopic spectrum: Imagine if it worked like health care insurance. Even monthly bills would be only guesses subject to arbitrary revision.
- gwright 3y agoMy favorite example in this space is college tuition/room/board. This seems to be the only example of a service in which you have to share all your financial details with the vendor and then they will tell you how much it is going to cost.
- actionablefiber 3y agoMany types of loans you can take out, where approval and interest are dependent on your credit history and assets, and also your tax burden to the government, are kind of like that too. Really anything where the amount charged varies with your ability to pay.
- gwright 3y agoOK, but room/board/tuition is not a loan. The college is determining a discount, not the ability to pay back a loan.
- xnx 3y agoI don't care about fees as much as I care about competitors (e.g. Google Fiber) getting easy access to poles.
- sys_64738 3y agoI don't see any fees on my Comcast bill for Internet only. Do these other fees come from cable TV?
- luma 3y agoSomehow it's _really_hard_ to list all the fees ahead of time, yet it's still _really_easy_ to list them all when it comes time to bill their millions of subscribers each and every month. The largest of these companies manage to compute this number more than a billion times a year. Any regulator who takes this line of reasoning seriously is immediately suspect.
- YeBanKo 3y agoWhile you are right, it’s not limited to telcos or isps, seems like in general consumer pricing must be required to be transparent.
- ryandrake 3y agoThere's nothing quite as American as not knowing what you're going to pay until the moment you have to pay it. It happens in retail, hotels, especially healthcare, car shopping, everything. We have this weird culture of just accepting terrible status-quo. This is one of the many nationwide problems that we have convinced ourselves there's no way to fix, despite many other countries in the world having fixed it a long time ago.
- CameronNemo 3y agoDon't forget restaurants that tack on "service fees" that often range from 1-18%.
- ryandrake 3y agoAnother person in a different thread[1] mentioned his city where businesses are tacking "living wage surcharges" onto their bills! So now the customer is paying your payroll? I'm convinced this is the inevitable end-state of American business: Advertise $0 for all products, and then opaquely "pass through" everything as fees when the customer goes to check out. 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37141091 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37141091
- em-bee 3y agoactually, i don't care that much about a list of all the fees. they just need to include them in the listed price. in some countries it's even required by law to do it that way.
- supertrope 3y agoIf only I could pay “up to” $65 per month. I downgraded from a gigabit plan because it was performing at 600-750 Mbps and only when using the ISP’s own speed test. The upload wasn’t any faster than the 500/50 plan. On real world tests like downloading Linux ISOs or downloading a 100GB game off Steam or Epic it was only 200-350 Mbps. What’s the point of a speed tier that only works on-net?
- jmyeet 3y agoComcast, Spectrum, AT&T, etc should not exist. They are rent-seekers. The people in the US who have the best Internet access are those where the service is provided by municipal broadband (eg [1]). You will never fix these big national ISPs because they exist solely to maximize shareholder profit while providing the least service possible at the highest price they can get away with while lobbying to change laws to benefit them and lock in their monopolies (eg to make municipal broadband illegal). As an aside, these national ISPs exemplify capitalism. Municipal broadband, by definition, follows socialistic principles (where the municipality and, by extension, its residents own the means of production). [1]: https://epb.com/fi-speed-internet/ https://epb.com/fi-speed-internet/
- mistrial9 3y agogreat bravado but not even close to happening.. here in California apparently there are only two companies that actually supply internet backbone to residential customers - perhaps those are AT&T and Comcast? Every other residential Internet service provider in California are resellers of those services. Why is this? there is what is said and then what is done .. as others have mentioned, no company securing those regulated monopoly positions would ever voluntarily give that up. It is very likely that those providers also play-well with whatever domestic surveillance is on tap since Clinton. Adding the word "socialistic" is simply corking the bottle, it would easily be mocked in public media while the backrooms play out.
- RajT88 3y agoIf anyone needed evidence of this, they could look up how some ISP's (Like AT&T) chose to react to the TVPA act: https://www.techspot.com/news/93754-isps-continue-charge-unfair-rental-fees-potentially-breaking.html https://www.techspot.com/news/93754-isps-continue-charge-unf... AT&T made it compulsory to use their gateways by installing certs for Auth on their hardware and just saying they do not offer for sale the same hardware and third party hardware could not (would not?) Be issued those certs. I tried my luck buying a gateway off ebay and trying to get out of the rental fee. Their position was that this was "theft" as they did not sell these devices. Granted, I had to file an FCC complaint to even get that response. The exec I spoke with basically threatened me with legal action if I did not drop it. Shady. They deserve to be replaced by muni or Federal internet indeed.
- exabrial 3y agoOk I'll be the odd person out and say this is actually sort of reasonable. I only know this because I've worked on large batch billing systems before. (Yes on a mainframe too. Gen-Z check your iWatch for a pulse). In the US, nearly any given city, un-incorporated area, county, region, state, can assess a tax for services. These things are like fleas. They're hard to track down and full compliance is nearly impossible, and the if-ands-butts when they apply and when they come-go is an added challenge, especially if they apply like to persons visiting the area. I'm guessing whats happening is most counties are like "our population is X" and you can estimate the tax billed owed on that, and that's good enough for government work. Customizing a billing system to individualize and print the $0.04 is an enormous expense for literally no benefit to the consumer. Again, just a guess. Now ISPs, many of them being entrenched monopolies, obviously hide behind their finances to rip consumers off. I'm not advocating for that. The real problem is a lot of these municipalities _invited_ the Comcasts of the world in at steep discounts, and now are crying that there is no competition (Because nobody else can compete profitably). That is another issue, but I don't think printing an extra $0.04 on your bill is going to make a lick of difference.
- kibwen 3y agoThat doesn't change the fact that they somehow manage to figure out the fees at billing time. If they need my street address in order to determine the eventual fees, that's fine. But for them to say that it just can't be done is to piss on me and tell me that it's raining.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoCapitalism is predicated upon consumers being able to make a rational purchasing decision. If true costs are hidden, there is no way for someone to assess the product before them. Maybe the fees are an irrelevant $.04 today, but that could turn into a hidden $6.99 tomorrow
- eli 3y agoThe rule at issue is about "discretionary" fees -- not ones imposed by a government. What's happening in many cases is states or localities are requiring the telco to comply with some law (e.g. to have functional 911) and the telcos get away with misleading customers into thinking their cost of doing business is your government tax.
- phendrenad2 3y agoThis is just how regulation in the US works. Agencies propose rules and affected companies and individuals voice any concerns when the rule is opened up for public comment. If they didn't voice concerns, we'd have a pretty terrible world where rules are handed down by fiat blindly.
- doctorpangloss 3y agoWe'll stop getting junk fees when (1) people stop checking out carts with higher prices than advertised or (2) total prices are required by law, like in Australia.
- mh8h 3y agoAs someone who has dealt with crazy tax codes and different regulatory fees in telecoms I can tell you that the systems that calculate those bills are very old and clunky. They are built to handle billing in batches, and are not suitable to provide accurate amounts to be shown on the consumer facing website on demand. Of course they can build something that is suitable. But they are a combination of [lazy, greedy, corrupt, under-resourced].
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoThat sounds like a technical debt to me.
- chris_wot 3y agoIf they are charging a fee, it means they are doing something. Better tell us what that is.
- _8j50 3y agoHear me out: Privatize all ISPs and run them USPS style (gov owned, non-gov board operated). Not just email but the internet is more vital than USPS, there is a reason it was never made fully private. New ISPs should still be allowed like fedex and ups are with usps. You pay thus bill but you also pay them again with your tax money with the hefty rural service subsidies they basically rob from the government. Municipal internet is thinking too small, federal internet is more like it. Last mile should be 100% gov owned with CPE/NID/inside-wiring installed by the gov or competing ISPs but owned by the consumer. The fed gov should just buy out their majority share stock and do a hostile takeover and buy the rest of the shares once price tanks when people here it will be operated at a loss. No more outsourced support,etc... because fedgov can't do that. And my favorite benefit: they can't sell your info to third parties and then have the gov buy it from them once they are operated by the fed. This type of stuff seems crazy but it can happen!
- martinald 3y agoThis is basically the exact model Australia did with their NBN which was a disaster. The idea was to nationalise the last mile networks and unify them into one wholesale ISP that retail providers could use. It also intended to upgrade the network rapidly to FTTH. Problem was just as it was getting started there was a change of govt and the FTTH element was significantly reduced in scope to save costs. So now you are left with the govt owning all the last mile infrastructure with basically no competition and an extremely slow plan to upgrade it. I believe FTTH upgrades are increasing in pace now, but it's hard for me to find stats on actual FTTH rollout there (they combine it with gigabit HFC which isn't the same imo). This is really the downfall of many people who think the state should nationalise telecoms. Yes it may work well with a government that's really commited to it. But you also run the risk of an election with someone that doesnt consider it a priority suddenly you are in a real mess.
- _8j50 3y agoWas their telecom government operated? Why would the government decide budget if they don't operate the company but merely own it like a shareholder would? To your point and my USPS analogy, the head of USPS trump appointed is still at the same job because Biden can't just fire him. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Postmaster_General https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Postmaster_Gener... This model has worked well despite the volatile nature of US election and one party railing against the USPS being wasteful and should be privatized.
- dan-robertson 3y agoI think this story is not very interesting. In particular: - Some new regulations were proposed. The regulator asks for comments. The industry says they don’t like the regulations. That is the general story here and so I think it is mostly not interesting. - The headline thing does sound hard. If you can’t see why it might be hard to figure out from your software and policies (built up through decades of mergers) exactly what all the fees are, I think you basically have a lack of imagination. Plenty of online stores even struggle to show you how much sales tax you’ll be charged. It is right for industry to state that this is hard but that it is hard needn’t mean that the regulations shouldn’t apply. Sometimes new rules are harder to implement than regulators expected and their deadlines get pushed back, but I think that’s basically still normal. I don’t think there is anything interesting here - Some other comments made were that consumers would find the list of fees confusing. That does sound confusing. (It would be even worse if they had to read out such a schedule over the phone) I personally think it wouldn’t be a particularly good outcome of the regulations for consumers to see some long list of potential extra fees below the sticker price – they don’t know the true price before and they don’t know the true price afterwards. I was not entirely convinced by the argument that this is like sales tax. I didn’t look at the alternative proposals, but plausibly some could be better. For example you could require a maximum price inclusive of fees and taxes be conspicuously advertised and require that fees may not total above this advertised maximum. It seems to me that the right rule would require companies to publish some number representing their cost where decreasing that number (a) gets them more business on the margin and (b) leads to less surprise bills to customers. The max-bill number could be decreased by knowing better what fees would be charged or by actually reducing the cost of services and I think both of those are things the regulator wants
- JoeAltmaier 3y ago[flagged]
- tptacek 3y agoI'm with the ISPs on this, at least partway. Some of the fees ISPs charge aren't really fees at all, but rather pass-through taxes, set by ordinance and mandated into ISP bills through local franchise agreements. These aren't ISP fees at all; the ISPs don't control them, don't benefit from them, and presumably would rather they not exist at all. Annoyingly, the point of sale for Internet connections isn't necessarily the municipality where installation happens, meaning that to give a complete record of these fees, ISPs need infrastructure to look them up by address. It's not the world's hardest IT problem, but it's a cost imposed on them by external actors, and those costs all get passed to consumers.
- smolder 3y agoNormally when a business has costs, they recoup them by charging an amount for their services that can pay their costs and leave them some margin. ISP around the US advertise one price and then tack on these... apparently special costs as separate line items. There's no good reason they should be allow to exclude them from the advertised price. Somewhat related: Comcast recently called to try to trick me into moving from month to month to a 2 year contract with a $200+ cancellation fee for a piddly amount of savings monthly. If I wasn't reading the details I'd have fallen for it. They also still haven't replaced the faulty coax line at my current location that they said they would get to "soon", (before the pandemic,) after half a dozen phone calls and several tech visits. Their level of service is abysmally poor in any area without competition. They make a ton of money. It's an inexcusably bad situation. I feel very limited in where I can buy property because of the widespread local monopolies held by shit companies like Comcast.
- tptacek 3y agoThey're not "... apparently special costs". They're taxes that local governments are charging their residents, using Comcast as a bill collector.
- smolder 3y ago> They're not "... apparently special costs". Yes, they are. > They're taxes that local governments are charging their residents, using Comcast as a bill collector. Uh huh. But that's effectively the same as just charging the ISP per subscriber, the difference is all perception and inconvenience to the subscriber. Why don't we get line items for the property tax that businesses pay on every bill?
- lightlyused 3y agoThe old AT&T behaviors still haunt us to this day.
- laurencerowe 3y agoThe US desperately needs to institute the EU rule that all advertised prices are inclusive of all taxes and fees. It’s not just sales tax (which admittedly varies by city) but you also see absurd things like ‘SF health mandate’ on a receipt at a restaurant. What are they going to break out next, rent?
- breadwinner 3y agoIn Seattle when they increased minimum wage to $15, this airport parking company called MasterPark started adding a "living wage surcharge" to their bill [1]. Employee wages are a "surcharge" that's added on to the bill!! I don't think anything can top this. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/kellyphillipserb/2014/06/12/seattle-biz-tacks-living-wage-surcharge-onto-receipts-in-response-to-15hour-minimum-wage/?sh=11ed1154acf9 https://www.forbes.com/sites/kellyphillipserb/2014/06/12/sea...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- expertentipp 3y agoSorry but you have some idealistic view of some EU regulations. In every country where ISPs form a oligopoly, predatory practices and billing ensue.
- himinlomax 3y agoIn France we have one operator (SFR Red) that's known for being shit and messing with billing and having predatory practices, but the other three major operators are generally fine and you typically pay exactly what was advertised.
- yladiz 3y agoEven if the prices aren't great depending on the provider, at least in EU countries the price you see is what you pay. My internet bill is not €30 + hidden fees + taxes + executive coffee fund, it's just €30. You may be charged additionally in specific circumstances like ending a contract early without cause, but in the general case you aren't charged on top of what you see, so I don't know what you mean by "in every country [...] predatory practices and billing ensue" because it's not necessarily the case.
- YeBanKo 3y agoThis is not an ISP problem, this is a consumer problem. A simple all industry regulation can fix it. Requiring all advertised prices to always include all taxes, surcharges and mandatory fees. All ambiguity to be interpreted in consumer’s favor. All the cancellation and signups fees, or other additional requirements to get the advertised price must be spelled out in the same font, size or speech speed right next to the price. This is it. It was a little comical when Biden said he is going to fight ticket fees and then this came: https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2023/06/15/president-biden-recognizes-actions-by-private-sector-ticketing-and-travel-companies-to-eliminate-hidden-junk-fees-and-provide-millions-of-customers-with-transparent-pricing/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases... Like they asked not to scam US consumer and they kindly agreed. Heck, if only CA, TX and some other medium to large state passed something like this, it would probably push the industries over.
- TylerE 3y agoThat they're complaining means the rules don't go far enough. If the rules went far enough they'd be changing behavior.
- wiseleo 3y agoIf you can bill for it, you can disclose it.
- anticensor 3y agoNot always the case. For example, Turkish electricity providers are forbidden by law to disclose the amount of lost power recovery fee.
- muppetman 3y agoWorking at an ISP I've never understood all these fees/random charges, and this "fear my ISP is watching what I'm doing" Then I realise it's a US thing. In NZ we don't log/care what DNS sites you hit. You're better off to use our DNS because it's faster/closer to you than 1.1.1.1/8.8.8.8. We don't charge any fees, short of the $90 a month for unlimited Gigabit Ethernet speeds fibre. I feel so bad for you all. As a tech behemoth you bring amazing technology to the lives of everyone on the planet (well, within reason). But it seems your personal lives have to suffer as a result, it's so screwed up. I hope all and any stupid additional "fees" are shot down. The "Service costs you $X a month" should be all you see, it's up the ISP to account for all their outgoings before setting that price. Edit: To be clear, the ISP I work for. I don't think any of the others do either, but I obviously can't vouch for what they do/don't do. I know the Mobile Carriers here aggregate and sell locations data from the cell towers.
- RajT88 3y agoProfit is the almighty motivator in the US. For reasons I cannot fathom, most outages in US ISP's are due to their DNS servers going down. The reason ISP's log all your traffic is so they can sell that data to data brokers. The sale of a data set is not a one-time thing. You can sell it over and over again. Different brokers or end customers or even government agencies (yes the government is buying that data, reported here even) or you can sell time slices of that data or demographic slices of that data. I could not tell you how profitable that data sales is. It is a closely guarded secret. This could mean it is very high or very low, either sparking much outrage. But for sure, ISP's in the US are spying on their users for profit. Why the US and not (say) NZ? Lots of money, and lots of people. I would trust an ISP in Vanuatu not to spy on me.
- zer8k 3y ago> and this "fear my ISP is watching what I'm doing" Then I realise it's a US thing I'm not sure about it being a US thing. But I don't personally have a privacy fear with my ISP because I can't really do anything about it. At some point a clear request has to hit the edge of my ISP and at that point, no matter what I do, they will know what I'm doing. It's better to mitigate the deep packet inspection part of it rather than worry about DNS requests leaking (that's what coffee shops are for). The real problem I have with it is I pay $280/mo. for a "gigabit" line from Cox. It has a data cap. On top of having a data cap if I don't use my own DNS Cox will inject ads and other data into my requests. There are several blog posts on this happening and I am not on my computer with screenshots. It suffices to say that they, and other ISPs in the US (at least), regularly poison requests with advertisements, warnings, alerts, and other non-sense. During COVID, despite paying for a top tier plan, my connection was throttled to 10 Mbps 5/7 days a week because so many people were watching Netflix. It doesn't even matter if you pay more they'll QoS your ass into the ground at a whim. Billions of dollars and they can't even spend the time to install better hardware. The combination of last-mile control and a resulting veritable monopoly on internet in most localities means ISPs can more or less do what they want. Sucks. I try not to blame the employees but they, too, are complicit in this nonsense. ISPs are a legitimate cancer.
- michaelmrose 3y agoI've worked for an ISP. The only fees that are arguably reasonable are taxes imposed on the company so you can say we offer $n across many markets + local/state/federal taxes as applicable. These taxes are a tiny minority of such fees which exist solely to open with we offer service for a small n which is a crappy undesirable level of service whereas actually charging as much as 2n for small levels of n. Instead of disclosing them just make all extra fees for consumer facing service illegal and force a singular ala carte cost where the total cost is the sum of entries like buying cans of beans at the grocery store. It's a known field that needs no creativity in its pricing model.
- javajosh 3y agoVariable pricing is a HUGE industry in the US (and elsewhere). It's true for fees like this, and it's even more true for variable rate mortgages. Whoever owns your mortgage can add arbitrary fees to your mortgage at any time, and whats more, is they not only don't have to tell you but the companies that manage the mortgage data consider the code and data proprietary. I personally believe there is a huge, recurring fraud going on that eclipses what e.g. Wells Fargo has been doing to its customers.
- kitanata 3y ago[flagged]
- zzo38computer 3y agoThe ISP (or any other business) should be required by law to list precisely the amount and conditions for all fees that the customer must pay, recurring and non-recurring. Any potential customer must have the opportunity to get this information from them (and doing so should not require an internet connection, since otherwise it is a conflict of interest if the fee is for the internet connection). Even fees that are mandated by the government should be required to be listed, although the ISP need not say that they are mandated by the government (if they have the same conditions as other fees they charge, the amount can simply be combined with it). If a customer wants to know about the government mandates, they should request such information from the government or from public libraries (and again, internet connection should not be required, since it would be a conflict of interest if the fees are related to internet access). If they charge a fee which is not listed, then the customer should not be required to pay that fee. The ISP might (at most) cancel the service (although it is unsure if it should be permitted, due to net neutrality), but they cannot sue you or debt collection etc, if it is their own fault.
- jiveturkey 3y agowell, guess there is going to be a new fee listing fee added on
- ta988 3y agoThere is really a problem in the US, here in a big city a lot of stores, restaurants and service companies just keep adding fees so it become impossible to get the real price of stuff. And some restaurants not only add fees but the servers preclick on 20% tip for counter service. This is really getting out of hand.
- WesolyKubeczek 3y agoFees too hard to list? Then don’t have that many to begin with! Are you a big company doing serious business, or some puling child?
- piyush_soni 3y agoWhen I moved back to India from the US, I was pleasantly surprised how cheap and fast the internet here is (which should have been the characteristic of a developed nation like USA). I currently have a 300 Mbps home broadband, TV, Unlimited calling cellphone with 1.5 GB mobile data everyday, and an unlimited calling landline phone all in one plan in less than 21 USD a month.
- trollied 3y agoI used to work on big telco billing systems. All possible charges, discounts etc are configured in the billing system (otherwise you wouldn't be able to bill for them!). Doesn't take a genius to work out how easy it would be to list them... As a European looking over the pond, lobbying and this sort of crap have gone too far in the States. I don't know why you all put up with it.
- sharts 3y agoIf it's so hard to list them, surely it is much harder to collect them?
- theragra 3y agoThis is so weird to read. My local small ISP in EU has only one fee: monthly. That's it.
- FounderBurr 3y agoI’m sure they have zero difficulty enumerating fees and what’s passed through when the irs asks.
- nottorp 3y agoI still don't understand how it can be legal to charge more than the price written in the contract... Feeling like... if i ever moved to the US... i'd have to declare bankruptcy in a month because I'll spend triple what I think I'm spending due to the "fees".
- spacecadet 3y agoWe should all just stop paying and hijack the infrastructure.
- theonlybutlet 3y agoWell if it's too burdensome, simplify your charges. Snake oil salesman complains it's too difficult to sell snake oil.
- r00fus 3y agoThis is obviously a lie, the provide the fee in the invoice to the customer and probably have to identify the fees for taxation purposes with tax authorities at tax time.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]